Optimization of iTRAQ labelling coupled to OFFGEL fractionation as a proteomic workflow to the analysis of microsomal proteins of Medicago truncatula roots

Background

Shotgun proteomics represents an attractive technical framework for the study of membrane proteins that are generally difficult to resolve using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The use of iTRAQ, a set of amine-specific isobaric tags, is currently the labelling method of choice allowing multiplexing of up to eight samples and the relative quantification of multiple peptides for each protein. Recently the hyphenation of different separation techniques with mass spectrometry was used in the analysis of iTRAQ labelled samples. OFFGEL electrophoresis has proved its effectiveness in isoelectric point-based peptide and protein separation in solution. Here we describe the first application of iTRAQ-OFFGEL-LC-MS/MS on microsomal proteins from plant material. The investigation of the iTRAQ labelling effect on peptide electrofocusing in OFFGEL fractionator was carried out on Medicago truncatula membrane protein digests.

Results

In-filter protein digestion, with easy recovery of a peptide fraction compatible with iTRAQ labelling, was successfully used in this study. The focusing quality in OFFGEL electrophoresis was maintained for iTRAQ labelled peptides with a higher than expected number of identified peptides in basic OFFGEL-fractions. We furthermore observed, by comparing the isoelectric point (pI) fractionation of unlabelled versus labelled samples, a non-negligible pI shifts mainly to higher values.

Conclusions

The present work describes a feasible and novel protocol for in-solution protein digestion in which the filter unit permits protein retention and buffer removal. The data demonstrates an impact of iTRAQ labelling on peptide electrofocusing behaviour in OFFGEL fractionation compared to their native counterpart by the induction of a substantial, generally basic pI shift. Explanations for the occasionally observed acidic shifts are likewise presented.     

Efficient fractionation and improved protein identification by peptide OFFGEL electrophoresis

The sample fractionation steps conducted prior to mass detection are critically important for the comprehensive analysis of complex protein mixtures. This paper illustrates the effectiveness of OFFGEL electrophoresis with the Agilent 3100 OFFGEL Fractionator for the fractionation of peptides. An Escherichia coli tryptic digest was separated in 24 fractions, and peptides were identified by reversed-phase liquid chromatography on a microfluidic device with mass spectrometric detection. About 90% of the identified individual peptides were found in only one or two fractions. The distribution of the calculated isoelectric points for the peptides identified in each fraction was especially narrow in the acidic pH range. Standard deviations approached the size of the pH segment covered by the respective fraction. The experimental peptide isoelectric point measured by OFFGEL electrophoresis was used as an additional filter for validation of peptide identifications.     

Peptides OFFGEL electrophoresis: a suitable pre-analytical step for complex eukaryotic samples fractionation compatible with quantitative iTRAQ labeling

Background  

The proteomes of mammalian biological fluids, cells and tissues are complex and composed of proteins with a wide dynamic range. The effective way to overcome the complexity of these proteomes is to combine several fractionation steps. OFFGEL fractionation, recently developed by Agilent Technologies, provides the ability to pre-fractionate peptides into discrete liquid fractions and demonstrated high efficiency and repeatability necessary for the analysis of such complex proteomes.     

Use of DNA ladders for reproducible protein fractionation by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) for quantitative proteomics

In proteomics, one-dimensional (1D) sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) is widely used for protein fractionation prior to mass spectrometric analysis to enhance the dynamic range of analysis and to improve the identification of low-abundance proteins. Such protein prefractionation works well for quantitation strategies if the proteins are labeled prior to separation. However, because of the poor reproducibility of cutting gel slices, especially when small amounts of samples are analyzed, its application in label-free and peptide-labeling quantitative proteomics methods has been greatly limited. To overcome this limitation, we developed a new strategy in which a DNA ladder is mixed with the protein sample before PAGE separation. After PAGE separation, the DNA ladder is stained to allow for easy, precise, and reproducible gel cutting. To this end, a novel visible DNA-staining method was developed. This staining method is fast, sensitive, and compatible with mass spectrometry. To evaluate the reproducibility of DNA-ladder-assisted gel cutting for quantitative protein fractionation, we used stable isotope labeling with amino acids in cell culture (SILAC). Our results show that the quantitative error associated with fractionation can be minimized using the DNA-assisted fractionation and multiple replicates of gel cutting. In conclusion, 1D PAGE fractionation in combination with DNA ladders can be used for label-free comparative proteomics without compromising quantitation.     

Modeling the isoelectric focusing of peptides in an OFFGEL multicompartment cell

In proteomic analysis of complex samples at the peptide level (termed shotgun proteomics), an effective prefractionation is crucial to decrease the complexity of the peptide mixture for further analysis. In this perspective, the high-resolving power of the IEF fractionation step is a determining parameter, in order to obtain well-defined fractions and correct information on peptide isoelectric points, to provide an additional filter for protein identification. Here, we explore the resolving power of OFFGEL IEF as a prefractionation tool to separate peptides. By modeling the peak width evolution versus the peptide charge gradient at pI, we demonstrate that for the three proteomes considered in silico (Deinococcus radiodurans, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Homo sapiens), 90% of the peptides should be correctly focused and recovered in two wells at most. This result strongly suggests OFFGEL to be used as a powerful fractionation tool in shotgun proteomics. The influence of the height and shape of the compartments is also investigated, to give the optimal cell dimensions for an enhanced peptide recovery and fast focusing time.     

Label-free quantification and shotgun analysis of complex proteomes by one-dimensional SDS-PAGE/NanoLC-MS: evaluation for the large scale analysis of inflammatory human endothelial cells

To perform differential studies of complex protein mixtures, strategies for reproducible and accurate quantification are needed. Here, we evaluated a quantitative proteomic workflow based on nanoLC-MS/MS analysis on an LTQ-Orbitrap-VELOS mass spectrometer and label-free quantification using the MFPaQ software. In such label-free quantitative studies, a compromise has to be found between two requirements: repeatability of sample processing and MS measurements, allowing an accurate quantification, and high proteomic coverage of the sample, allowing quantification of minor species. The latter is generally achieved through sample fractionation, which may induce experimental bias during the label-free comparison of samples processed, and analyzed independently. In this work, we wanted to evaluate the performances of MS intensity-based label-free quantification when a complex protein sample is fractionated by one-dimensional SDS-PAGE. We first tested the efficiency of the analysis without protein fractionation and could achieve quite good quantitative repeatability in single-run analysis (median coefficient of variation of 5%, 99% proteins with coefficient of variation <48%). We show that sample fractionation by one-dimensional SDS-PAGE is associated with a moderate decrease of quantitative measurement repeatability while largely improving the depth of proteomic coverage. We then applied the method for a large scale proteomic study of the human endothelial cell response to inflammatory cytokines, such as TNFα, interferon γ, and IL1β, which allowed us to finely decipher at the proteomic level the biological pathways involved in endothelial cell response to proinflammatory cytokines.     

Two‐step OFFGEL approach for effective peptide separation compatible with iTRAQ labeling

Shotgun proteomic analyses are increasingly becoming methods of choice for complex samples. The development of effective methods for fractionating peptides to reduce the complexity of the sample before mass analysis is a key point in this strategy. The OFFGEL technology has recently become a tool of choice in proteomic analysis at peptide level. This OFFGEL electrophoresis (OGE) approach allows the in‐solution separation of peptides from various biological sources by isoelectric focusing in highly resolved 24 fractions. It was also demonstrated that OGE technology is a filtering tool for pI‐based validation of peptide identification. As peptide OGE is compatible with iTRAQ labeling, OGE is finding valuable applications in quantitative proteomics as well. The aim of this study is to explain a new 2D‐OGE approach that improves the proteomic coverage of complex mixtures such as colorectal cell line lysates, and which is compatible with iTRAQ labeling.     

Comparative Analysis of Label-Free and 8-Plex iTRAQ Approach for Quantitative Tissue Proteomic Analysis

High resolution proteomics approaches have been successfully utilized for the comprehensive characterization of the cell proteome. However, in the case of quantitative proteomics an open question still remains, which quantification strategy is best suited for identification of biologically relevant changes, especially in clinical specimens. In this study, a thorough comparison of a label-free approach (intensity-based) and 8-plex iTRAQ was conducted as applied to the analysis of tumor tissue samples from non-muscle invasive and muscle-invasive bladder cancer. For the latter, two acquisition strategies were tested including analysis of unfractionated and fractioned iTRAQ-labeled peptides. To reduce variability, aliquots of the same protein extract were used as starting material, whereas to obtain representative results per method further sample processing and MS analysis were conducted according to routinely applied protocols. Considering only multiple-peptide identifications, LC-MS/MS analysis resulted in the identification of 910, 1092 and 332 proteins by label-free, fractionated and unfractionated iTRAQ, respectively. The label-free strategy provided higher protein sequence coverage compared to both iTRAQ experiments. Even though pre-fraction of the iTRAQ labeled peptides allowed for a higher number of identifications, this was not accompanied by a respective increase in the number of differentially expressed changes detected. Validity of the proteomics output related to protein identification and differential expression was determined by comparison to existing data in the field (Protein Atlas and published data on the disease). All methods predicted changes which to a large extent agreed with published data, with label-free providing a higher number of significant changes than iTRAQ. Conclusively, both label-free and iTRAQ (when combined to peptide fractionation) provide high proteome coverage and apparently valid predictions in terms of differential expression, nevertheless label-free provides higher sequence coverage and ultimately detects a higher number of differentially expressed proteins. The risk for receiving false associations still exists, particularly when analyzing highly heterogeneous biological samples, raising the need for the analysis of higher sample numbers and/or application of adjustment for multiple testing.     

The structure and amount of actin in IMR-90 fibroblasts.

Double-labelling and peptide isolation have been used to examine the homology between the actin of IMR-90 human embryo fibroblasts and muscle actin. After separation of mixtures of [14C]carboxymethylated muscle actin and [3H]carboxymethylated proteins of IMR-90 cells of electrophoresis on sodium dodecyl sulphate-containing polyacrylamide gels, peptides were generated from the material co-migrating with actin by digestion with chymotrypsin. Peptides homologous with peptides accounting for Cys-217, Cys-256, Cys-284 and Cys-373 of muscle actin are present in this material, but no peptide homologous with a Cys-10-containing peptide was detected. From the amount of actin-derived peptides present, the actin content of IMR-90 fibroblasts was calculated to be 4.2% of the total protein of these cells.     

Sub-proteomic fractionation,iTRAQ, and OFFGEL-LC–MS/MS approaches to cardiac proteomics

Using an in solution based approach with a sub-proteomic fraction enriched in cardiac sarcomeric proteins; we identified protein abundance in ischemic and non-ischemic regions of rat hearts stressed by acute myocardial ischemia by ligating the left-anterior descending coronary artery in vivo for 1 h without reperfusion. Sub-cellular fractionation permitted more in depth analysis of the proteome by reducing the sample complexity. A series of differential centrifugations produced nuclear, mitochondrial, cytoplasmic, microsomal, and sarcomeric enriched fractions of ischemic and non-ischemic tissues. The sarcomeric enriched fractions were labeled with isobaric tags for relative quantitation (iTRAQ), and then fractionated with an Agilent 3100 OFFGEL fractionator. The OFFGEL fractions were run on a Dionex U-3000 nano LC coupled to a ThermoFinnigan LTQ running in PQD (pulsed Q dissociation) mode. The peptides were analyzed using two search engines MASCOT (MatrixScience), and MassMatrix with false discovery rate of < 5%. Compared to no fractionation prior to LC–MS/MS, fractionation with OFFGEL improved the identification of proteins approximately four-fold. We found that approximately 22 unique proteins in the sarcomeric enriched fraction had changed at least 20%. Our workflow provides an approach for discovery of unique biomarkers or changes in the protein profile of tissue in disorders of the heart.     

Identification and characterization of the Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 proteome

Via combined separation approaches, a total of 1399 proteins were identified, representing 47% of the Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 theoretical proteome. This includes 1323 proteins from the soluble fraction, 44 from the insoluble fraction and 32 from the extra-cellular or secreted fraction. We used conventional 2-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) for the soluble fraction, and shotgun proteomics for all three cell fractions (soluble, insoluble, and secreted). Two gel-based fractionation methods were explored for shotgun proteomics, namely: (i) protein separation utilizing 1-dimensional gel electrophoresis (1-DE) followed by peptide fractionation by iso-electric focusing (IEF), and (ii) protein and peptide fractionation both employing IEF. Results indicate that a 1D-IEF fractionation workflow with three replicate mass spectrometric analyses gave the best overall result for soluble protein identification. A greater than 50% increment in protein identification was achieved with three injections using LC-ESI-MS/MS. Protein and peptide fractionation efficiency; together with the filtration criteria are also discussed.     

Purification of plant complex protein extracts in non-denaturing conditions by in-solution isoelectric focusing

An alternative approach for plant complex protein extracts pre-purification by in-solution isoelectric focusing in non-denaturing conditions is presented. The separation of biologically active proteins, in narrow ranges of isoelectric point (pI) was obtained by a modified OFFGEL electrophoresis. Two different water-soluble protein extracts from Phragmites leaves were fractionated into 24 fractions within a 3–10 pI range at 10 °C in the absence of denaturing/reducing agents. One-dimensional electrophoretic analysis revealed different protein distribution patterns and the effective fractionation of both protein extracts. Peroxidase activity of each fraction confirmed that proteins remained active and pre-purification occurred. Biological triplicates assured the needed reproducibility.     

Proteomics based on peptide fractionation by SDS-free PAGE

Here we demonstrate the usefulness of peptide fractionation by SDS-free polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and its applicability to proteomics studies. In the absence of SDS, the driving force for the electrophoretic migration toward the anode is supplied by negatively charged acidic amino acid residues and other residues as phosphate, sulfate and sialic acid, while the resulting mobility depends on both the charge and the molecular mass of the peptides. A straightforward method was achieved for SDS-PAGE of proteins, enzyme digestion, peptide transfer and fractionation by SDS-free PAGE, which was named dual-fractionation polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (DF-PAGE). This method increases the number of identified proteins 2.5-fold with respect to the proteins identified after direct analysis, and more than 80% of assigned peptides were found in unique SDS-free gel slices. A vast majority of identified peptides (93%) have p I values below 7.0, and 7% have p I values between 7.0 and 7.35. Peptide digests that were derived from complex protein mixtures were in consequence simplified as peptides that are positively charged are not recovered in the present conditions. The analysis of a membrane protein extract from Neisseria meningitidis by this approach allowed the identification of 97 proteins, including low-abundance components.     

A proteomic approach for investigation of photosynthetic apparatus in plants

The proteome of the photosynthetic apparatus of barley (Hordeum vulgare), obtained by analysis of thylakoids without any previous fractionation, was mapped by native electrophoresis followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) as the second dimension two-dimensional-blue native (2-D/BN)/SDS-PAGE). This protocol provided an excellent alternative to the 2-D-isoelectric focusing/sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis for 2-D separation of the most hydrophobic thylakoid proteins. Monocots and dicots showed significant differences in the first dimension while in the second dimension patterns appeared similar. Identification of each spot was performed by internal peptide primary sequence determination using both nano-electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry and, to a lesser extent, peptide mass fingerprinting matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight using MALDI-TOF. This is due in particular to the fact that a limited number of peptides was obtained after trypsin digestion of these highly hydrophobic proteins. A larger number of peptides from hydrophilic intermembrane domains of transmembrane proteins were detected. Despite this, about 70% of the expected proteins were identified, including proteins with grand average of hydropathicity scores higher than 0.5. It is therefore reasonable to assert that protein hydrophobicity is not the limiting factor. Small proteins were not well identified with trypsin digestion. Instead some of these could be identified using acid hydrolysis. The method presented here does not require prefractionation of different thylakoid complexes and consequently gives confidence in comparing the proteome of the photosynthetic apparatus before and after treatment. It thus allows us to understand the molecular mechanisms underlying physiological adaptations of higher plants and to perform screening of photosynthetic mutants.     

Rapid verification of candidate serological biomarkers using gel-based, label-free multiple reaction monitoring

Stable isotope dilution-multiple reaction monitoring-mass spectrometry (SID-MRM-MS) has emerged as a promising platform for verification of serological candidate biomarkers. However, cost and time needed to synthesize and evaluate stable isotope peptides, optimize spike-in assays, and generate standard curves quickly becomes unattractive when testing many candidate biomarkers. In this study, we demonstrate that label-free multiplexed MRM-MS coupled with major protein depletion and 1D gel separation is a time-efficient, cost-effective initial biomarker verification strategy requiring less than 100 μL of serum. Furthermore, SDS gel fractionation can resolve different molecular weight forms of targeted proteins with potential diagnostic value. Because fractionation is at the protein level, consistency of peptide quantitation profiles across fractions permits rapid detection of quantitation problems for specific peptides from a given protein. Despite the lack of internal standards, the entire workflow can be highly reproducible, and long-term reproducibility of relative protein abundance can be obtained using different mass spectrometers and LC methods with external reference standards. Quantitation down to ~200 pg/mL could be achieved using this workflow. Hence, the label-free GeLC-MRM workflow enables rapid, sensitive, and economical initial screening of large numbers of candidate biomarkers prior to setting up SID-MRM assays or immunoassays for the most promising candidate biomarkers.     

Comparison of protein and peptide prefractionation methods for the shotgun proteomic analysis of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803

Proteome analysis by gel-free "shotgun" proteomics relies on the simplification of a peptide mixture before it is analyzed in a mass spectrometer. While separation on a reverse-phase (RP) liquid chromatographic column is widely employed, a variety of other methods have been used to fractionate both proteins and peptides before this step. We compared six different protein and peptide fractionation workflows, using Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, a useful model cyanobacterium for potential exploitation to improve its production of hydrogen and other secondary metabolites. Pre-digestion protein separation was performed by strip-based isoelectric focusing, one-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, or weak anion exchange chromatography, while pre-RP peptide separation was accomplished by isoelectric focusing (IEF) or strong cation exchange chromatography. Peptides were identified using electrospray ionization quadrupole time of flight-tandem mass spectrometry. Mass spectrometry (MS) and tandem mass spectra were analyzed using ProID software employing both a single organism database and the entire NCBI non-redundant database, and a total of 776 proteins were identified using a stringent set of selection criteria. Method comparisons were made on the basis of the results obtained (number and types of proteins identified), as well as ease of use and other practical aspects. IEF-IEF protein and peptide fractionation prior to RP gave the best overall performance.     

The importance of peptide detectability for protein identification, quantification, and experiment design in MS/MS proteomics

Peptide detectability is defined as the probability that a peptide is identified in an LC-MS/MS experiment and has been useful in providing solutions to protein inference and label-free quantification. Previously, predictors for peptide detectability trained on standard or complex samples were proposed. Although the models trained on complex samples may benefit from the large training data sets, it is unclear to what extent they are affected by the unequal abundances of identified proteins. To address this challenge and improve detectability prediction, we present a new algorithm for the iterative learning of peptide detectability from complex mixtures. We provide evidence that the new method approximates detectability with useful accuracy and, based on its design, can be used to interpret the outcome of other learning strategies. We studied the properties of peptides from the bacterium Deinococcus radiodurans and found that at standard quantities, its tryptic peptides can be roughly classified as either detectable or undetectable, with a relatively small fraction having medium detectability. We extend the concept of detectability from peptides to proteins and apply the model to predict the behavior of a replicate LC-MS/MS experiment from a single analysis. Finally, our study summarizes a theoretical framework for peptide/protein identification and label-free quantification.     

Peptide analysis by rapid, orthogonal technologies with high separation selectivities and sensitivities.

This article examines the current status of peptide analysis by orthogonal micro-/nano-separation strategies, with emphasis on the complementary use of high performance capillary liquid chromatography (micro-HPLC), capillary zonal electrophoresis (HPCZE), open tubular capillary electrochromatography (ot -CEC) and packed capillary electrochromatography (p -CEC). The ability to interface these techniques with mass spectroscopic (MS) procedures has enabled substantial progress to be made in the analysis of very small quantities of peptides, as well as proteins and other bio-macromolecules. As a consequence, the staged application of these high resolution techniques as part of the standardisation of biological products via robust, sensitive protocols is rapidly becoming a reality. Recent conceptual and theoretical advances have also allowed improved levels of prediction and optimisation of these procedures. Since significant differences in selectivity can be achieved with micro-HPLC, HPCZE and HPCEC respectively, collectively these sophisticated techniques provide unprecedented opportunities for the rapid, orthogonal and sensitive separation of complex mixtures of peptides and proteins. Several advantages of using these technologies in tandem are highlighted.     

Proteomic analysis of plasma membrane vesicles isolated from the rat renal cortex

Polarized epithelial cells are responsible for the vectorial transport of solutes and have a key role in maintaining body fluid and electrolyte homeostasis. Such cells contain structurally and functionally distinct plasma membrane domains. Brush border and basolateral membranes of renal and intestinal epithelial cells can be separated using a number of different separation techniques, which allow their different transport functions and receptor expressions to be studied. In this communication, we report a proteomic analysis of these two membrane segments, apical and basolateral, obtained from the rat renal cortex isolated by two different methods: differential centrifugation and free-flow electrophoresis. The study was aimed at assessing the nature of the major proteins isolated by these two separation techniques. Two analytical strategies were used: separation by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) at the protein level or by cation-exchange high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) after proteolysis (i.e., at the peptide level). Proteolytic peptides derived from the proteins present in gel pieces or from HPLC fractions after proteolysis were sequenced by on-line liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Several hundred proteins were identified in each membrane section. In addition to proteins known to be located at the apical and basolateral membranes, several novel proteins were also identified. In particular, a number of proteins with putative roles in signal transduction were identified in both membranes. To our knowledge, this is the first reported study to try and characterize the membrane proteome of polarized epithelial cells and to provide a data set of the most abundant proteins present in renal proximal tubule cell membranes.     

Comparison of the 95,000 molecular weight protein from Limulus sperm with muscle alpha-actinin.

The 95,000 molecular weight protein (95K protein) of the false discharges of Limulus sperm, purified by means of preparative gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate, was compared with a 95K protein from Limulus muscle and chicken gizzard alpha-actinin. The results were as follows. 1) One-dimensional peptide mapping using four different proteases showed differences among these proteins. 2) Two-dimensional peptide mapping using trypsin showed that about 30% of the peptides in the digest of the sperm 95K protein were similar to those of chicken gizzard alpha-actinin and about 50% of the peptides were similar to those of the Limulus muscle 95K protein. 3) The sperm 95K protein contained relatively large amounts of Gly, Pro, and Ser and relatively small amounts of Glu and Leu compared to the muscle proteins. 4) Antibodies against the sperm 95K protein did not cross-react with the Limulus muscle 95K protein or chicken gizzard alpha-actinin. These results suggest that the 95K protein of sperm is different from alpha-actinin in primary structure.