Genomic instability in neoplasia

Recent studies have demonstrated novel alterations of microsatellite DNA in tumor tissue. The alterations, termed microsatellite instability or replication error phenotype, have now been observed in tumors from patients with hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC), the Muir-Torre syndrome (MTS) and in an increasing number of sporadic tumors. These observations, along with the use of genetic linkage analysis, have led to the identification of at least four genetic susceptibility loci for HNPCC, hMSH2, hMLH1, hPMS1 and hPMS2, each of which are involved in DNA mismatch repair. For those tumors demonstrating microsatellite instability, several different phenotypes may exist, the significance of which is currently unknown. Defective DNA mismatch repair may have important implications for the mechanism of tumorigenesis and the clinical behavior of tumors.     

Is the mismatch repair deficient type of Muir-Torre syndrome confined to mutations in the hMSH2 gene?

The Muir-Torre syndrome (MTS) is a rare autosomal-dominant condition characterized by the occurrence of sebaceous skin lesions and internal tumours in a patient. It has been demonstrated that at least a subgroup of MTS exhibits clinical and molecular genetic features of hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer, including microsatellite instability in skin and visceral tumours, because of mutations in DNA mismatch repair genes. We have identified germline mutations in the hMSH2 gene in two unrelated MTS patients ascertained because of their skin tumours. Our results, together with published MTS cases, support the hypothesis that MTS with its characteristic skin lesions is confined to mutations in the hMSH2 gene. Received: 22 July 1996 / Revised: 12 August 1996     

Muir-Torre phenotype has a frequency of DNA mismatch-repair-gene mutations similar to that in hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer families defined by the Amsterdam criteria.

Muir-Torre syndrome (MTS) is an autosomal dominant disease defined by the coincidence of at least one sebaceous skin tumor and one internal malignancy. About half of MTS patients are affected by colorectal cancer. In a subgroup of MTS patients the disease has an underlying DNA mismatch-repair (MMR) defect and thus is allelic to hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC). The purpose of this study was to examine to what extent germ-line mutations in DNA MMR genes are the underlying cause of the MTS phenotype. We ascertained 16 MTS patients with sebaceous skin tumors and colorectal cancer, and we examined their skin and visceral tumors for microsatellite instability. All the patients exhibited high genomic instability in at least one tumor. The search for germ-line mutations in the hMSH2 and hMLH1 genes in 13 of the MTS patients revealed truncating mutations in 9 (69%): eight mutations in the hMSH2 gene and one in the hMLH1 gene. This is the first systematic search for germ-line mutations in patients ascertained on the basis of sebaceous skin tumors. Our results indicate that (1) MTS patients exhibit significantly more mutations in the hMSH2 gene than in the hMLH1 gene; and (2) the subpopulation of MTS patients who are also affected by colorectal cancer, irrespective of family history and age at onset of tumors, may have a likelihood for an underlying DNA MMR defect similar to that for patients with a family history fulfilling the strict clinical criteria for HNPCC.     

Missense mutations in hMLH1 associated with colorectal cancer

One of the most prevalent hereditary syndromes associated with colorectal cancer is hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC). The inherited gene defects in HNPCC have been shown to reside in DNA mismatch repair genes, mostly hMSH2 or hMLH1. Most HNPCC patients are heterozygous with regard to the relevant mismatch repair gene; they have one normal and one mutated allele, and mismatch repair in normal somatic cells is functional. Cancer predisposition in HNPCC is believed to be associated with the loss of the wild-type allele in somatic cells, resulting in defective DNA mismatch repair. This gives rise to DNA microsatellite instability (MSI), an increased somatic mutation rate, and eventually, to the accumulation of mutations in genes involved in colorectal carcinogenesis. In support of this theory, colorectal tumors in HNPCC patients and in mice deficient for hMSH2 or hMLH1 show MSI. Here, we describe two missense mutations in hMLH1 exon 16 associated with colorectal cancer. Interestingly, the tumors do not show MSI. This raises some potentially important issues. First, even microsatellite-negative colorectal tumors can be associated with germline mutations and these will be missed if an MSI test is used to select patients for mutation screening. Second, the lack of MSI in these cases suggests that the mechanism involved in carcinogenesis could be different from that generally hypothesized.     

Microsatellite instability.

Unlike aneuploidy, considered to be the cardinal feature of malignant tumors ever since the chromosomal analysis of neoplastic cells became technically feasible, a second pathway toward malignancy has emerged over the past decade that is not characterized by gross aneuploidy but, instead, by inactivation of the DNA mismatch repair system, leading to a hypermutable state in which simple repetitive DNA sequences are unstable during DNA replication. Although mutations of many of these microsatellite sequences are presumably innocuous, because they do not occur in the coding or regulatory regions of genes, other such sequences are critically located in the coding regions of genes involved in the regulation of cell growth. First discovered in the rather uncommon hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer syndrome, where there is an inactivating germline mutation in one of the DNA mismatch repair genes and most of the tumors show microsatellite instability, the latter phenomenon has since been implicated in about 15% of sporadic colorectal cancers, as well as in cancers at several other sites, such as the endometrium. Tumors showing microsatellite instability are generally near-diploid, are at a low stage of development, have a favorable prognosis, and, in the colon, are commonly located on the right side. In recent years, epigenetic phenomena, including hypermethylation and loss of imprinting, have come to be recognized as having a significant bearing on the development of these tumors.     

Automated fluorescent detection of microsatellite instability

Microsatellites are highly polymorphic repetitive DNA segments dispersed throughout the genome and have been widely used for genetic linkage analysis and allele loss. Instability of microsatellites sequences has been linked to deficiencies in DNA mismatch repair, and is observed in a number of different tumor types. Analysis of microsatellite instability is thought to be a useful clinical tool for cancer diagnosis. Fluorescent detection of microsatellite instability using an automated DNA sequencer holds several distinct advantages over traditional radioactive analysis and electrophoresis, allowing simultaneous analysis of a number of different markers for a large number of samples, high resolution, sensitivity, and clear interpretation of data. In this article we present an established protocol, which has been used successfully to detect microsatellite instability in DNA samples from human tumors and circulating tumor DNA in serum/plasma.     

Genetic instability in human mismatch repair deficient cancers

Cancers showing microsatellite instability (MSI-H) are frequent tumors characterized by inactivating alterations of mismatch repair (MMR) genes that lead to an incapacity to recognize and repair errors that occur during DNA replication. These cancers can be inherited as in the human non-polyposis colorectal cancer syndrome, or can occur sporadically in 10-15% of colorectal, gastric and endometrial cancers. MSI-H tumors have different clinicopathological features compared to cancers without this phenotype, termed MSS, and the repertoire of genetic events involved in tumoral progression of both phenotypes is thought to be different. In MSI-H tumors, most of the genetic changes occur at both non-coding and coding microsatellites that are particularly prone to errors during replication due to their repetitive sequence. This mechanism appears to be the main "genetic pathway" by which functional changes with putative oncogenic effects are accumulated in these tumors.     

Reduced frequency of extracolonic cancers in hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer families with monoallelic hMLH1 expression.

Hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) is an autosomal dominant disease caused by mutations in one of at least four different DNA mismatch repair genes, hMLH1, hMSH2, hPMS1, and hPMS2. Phenotypically, HNPCC is characterized by the early onset of colorectal cancers and various extracolonic cancers. Depending on the presence or absence of extracolonic tumors, HNPCG-has been divided into two syndromes (Lynch syndrome I and Lynch syndrome II), but, so far, no correlation to distinct genotypes has been demonstrated. In this study, we present a frequent hMLH1 intron 14 founder mutation that is associated with a highly reduced frequency of extracolonic tumors. The mutation disrupts the splice donor site and silences the mutated allele. Tumors exhibited microsatellite instability, and loss of the wild-type hMLH1 allele was prevalent. We propose that the mutation results in a milder phenotype, because the mutated hMLH1 protein is prevented from exerting a dominant negative effect on the concerted action of the mismatch repair system.     

Cloning and expression of the Xenopus and mouse Msh2 DNA mismatch repair genes.

Bacterial MutS protein and its yeast and human homologs MSH2 trigger the mismatch repair process by their initial binding to mispaired and unpaired bases in DNA. We describe the cloning and sequencing of genes from Xenopus laevis and Mus musculus encoding the homolog of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae MSH2 (the major DNA mismatch binding protein). Mutations in the human homolog of this gene have recently been implicated in microsatellite instability and DNA mismatch repair deficiency in tumour cells from patients with the most common hereditary predisposition to cancer (Lynch syndrome, or hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer, HNPCC), as well as in a significant percentage of sporadic tumours. Expression of the amphibian and murine Msh2 gene in different tissues appears to be ubiquitous. The Xenopus gene is highly expressed in eggs, a model system for the biochemistry of DNA mismatch repair. Expression of the murine gene is low in all tissues examined, and is relatively high in a rapidly dividing cell line. These data are suggestive of a role for MSH2 during DNA replication.     

Replication error repair,microsatellites, and cancer

Some common human tumors are characterized by inactivating alterations of mismatch repair (MMR) genes that lead to an inability to recognize and repair errors that occur during DNA replication. These alterations are either inherited in the so-called hereditary non polyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) syndrome or can occur sporadically in 10-15% of colorectal, gastric, or endometrial tumors. Because of their repetitive nature, microsatellite sequences are particularly prone to mutation in tumors with MMR deficiency. Thousands of microsatellite alterations accumulate in MMR deficient cancers and these are referred to as MSI-H tumors (high level of microsatellite instability). MSI-H tumors have different clinicopathological features compared to cancers without this phenotype, and the repertoire of genetic events involved in their tumoral progression is also thought to be different. Many of the genetic alterations observed in MSI-H tumors affect nucleotide repeat tracks contained within genes thought to have a putative oncogenic function. These alterations are believed to play an important role during MSI-H carcinogenesis, since they can be either inactivating or activating events that are selected for in a recessive or dominant manner. We provide here an overview of the genetic changes that occur in MSI-H tumors and that appear to constitute a new genetic mutator pathway leading a normal cell to become malignant.     

The instability within: problems in current analyses of microsatellite instability

Microsatellite instability is regarded as one of the phenotypes of defective DNA mismatch repair and, consequently, as a marker of high risk for cancer. Despite numerous studies, the reported rates for positive microsatellite instability differ widely in each human malignancy. These discrepancies may relate to problems in the methods used. To establish a methodology for an accurate microsatellite instability analysis, technical requirements for a precise assay and biological conditions required for positive microsatellite instability were discussed. First, to describe microsatellite changes in detail, a sensitive detection system with linear detection characteristics and electrophoresis with standardised migration and minimised migration errors are considered to be necessary. Therefore, systems using fluorescent labelling and laser scanning are recommended. For reproducible polymerase chain reactions, it is essential to control the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase activity in Taq polymerase. Second, as a biological condition for positive microsatellite instability, feasible selection and combination of microsatellite markers, mutations in specific DNA mismatch repair genes and existence of monoclonal populations enriched sufficiently in a sample are essential. Finally, one possible diagnostic criterion for positive microsatellite instability is proposed, that is the existence of one of the patterns shown in the panel (see Fig. 6) at one or more loci in a set of more than five microsatellite markers.     

Association between methylation in mismatch repair genes,V600E BRAF mutation and microsatellite instability in colorectal cancer patients

Colorectal cancer (CRC) corresponds to the third most prevalent type of cancer. Its origins can either be sporadic or inherited, being Lynch syndrome the most common form of hereditary CRC. The activation of BRAF oncogene, inactivation of mismatch repair genes by methylation of CpG islands, and microsatellite instability (MSI) have been reported to be involved in CRC development. The goal of the study was to characterize CRC tumors using clinical and molecular criteria through association and cluster analysis. Amsterdam II and Bethesda guidelines and molecular variables were analyzed in 77 patients from Brazil. The replication error (RER) status, based in microsatellite instability, showed association with metachronous tumor, MLH1 gene methylation and inverse association with left-sided and synchronous tumors. The PMS2 gene was considered the best predictor for differentiating levels of methylation and the mononucleotide were considered the best markers to evaluate RER status. The cluster 1 was characterized of individuals over 60 years of age, female, right-sided tumor, high microsatellite instability, and metachronous or synchronous tumors. The individuals in cluster 2 were younger than 45 years of age, male and showed left sided or rectum tumors, and microsatellite stability. Even though it was not observed a significant association, a higher number of individuals with family history of cancer and tumors without promoter methylation were found in cluster 2. The V600E mutation did not show association with clinical or molecular characteristics. Evaluation of MSI and methylation of MLH1 and PMS2 genes should be considered in order to assist with clinical diagnosis.     

Combined p53/Bax mutation results in extremely poor prognosis in gastric carcinoma with low microsatellite instability

Gastric cancer is highly refractory to DNA-damaging therapies. We therefore studied both gene mutation and protein expression of p53 and Bax in a cohort of 116 patients with gastric cancer who underwent R0-resection with a curative intent. Bax mutation was independent from severe microsatellite instability (MSI), that is, global mismatch repair deficiency as determined by analysis of BAT-25/BAT-26 microsatellite markers. Thus, Bax-frameshift mutation is a feature of tumors with low MSI. In contrast and as expected, no p53 mutations were observed in the microsatellite instable tumors. p53 Mutation or p53 overexpression did not have an impact on disease prognosis. p53-Inactivation was, however, associated with an extremely poor prognosis in the subgroup of patients with Bax-mutated tumors. Thus, we show for the first time that the combined mutation of p53 and Bax, two key regulators of the mitochondrial apoptosis pathway, results in an extremely aggressive tumor biology and poor clinical prognosis.     

Two modes of microsatellite instability in human cancer: differential connection of defective DNA mismatch repair to dinucleotide repeat instability

Microsatellite instability (MSI) is associated with defective DNA mismatch repair in various human malignancies. Using a unique fluorescent technique, we have observed two distinct modes of dinucleotide microsatellite alterations in human colorectal cancer. Type A alterations are defined as length changes of ≤6 bp. Type B changes are more drastic and involve modifications of ≥8 bp. We show here that defective mismatch repair is necessary and sufficient for Type A changes. These changes were observed in cell lines and in tumours from mismatch repair gene-knockout mice. No Type B instability was seen in these cells or tumours. In a panel of human colorectal tumours, both Type A MSI and Type B instability were observed. Both types of MSI were associated with hMSH2 or hMLH1 mismatch repair gene alterations. Intriguingly, p53 mutations, which are generally regarded as uncommon in human tumours of the MSI⁺ phenotype, were frequently associated with Type A instability, whereas none was found in tumours with Type B instability, reflecting the prevailing viewpoint. Inspection of published data reveals that the microsatellite instability that has been observed in various malignancies, including those associated with Hereditary Non-Polyposis Colorectal Cancer (HNPCC), is predominantly Type B. Our findings indicate that Type B instability is not a simple reflection of a repair defect. We suggest that there are at least two qualitatively distinct modes of dinucleotide MSI in human colorectal cancer, and that different molecular mechanisms may underlie these modes of MSI. The relationship between MSI and defective mismatch repair may be more complex than hitherto suspected.     

Genomic instability and cancer

Tumorigenesis can be viewed as an imbalance between the mechanisms of cell-cycle control and mutation rates within the genes. Genomic instability is broadly classified into microsatellite instability (MIN) associated with mutator phenotype, and chromosome instability (CIN) recognized by gross chromosomal abnormalities. Three intracellular mechanisms are involved in DNA damage repair that leads to mutator phenotype. They include the nucleotide excision repair (NER), base excision repair (BER) and mismatch repair (MMR). The CIN pathway is typically associated with the accumulation of mutations in tumor suppressor genes and oncogenes. Defects in DNA MMR and CIN pathways are responsible for a variety of hereditary cancer predisposition syndromes including hereditary non-polyposis colorectal carcinoma (HNPCC), Bloom syndrome, ataxia-telangiectasia, and Fanconi anaemia. While there are many genetic contributors to CIN and MIN, there are also epigenetic factors that have emerged to be equally damaging to cell-cycle control. Hypermethylation of tumor suppressor and DNA MMR gene promoter regions, is an epigenetic mechanism of gene silencing that contributes to tumorigenesis. Telomere shortening has been shown to increase genetic instability and tumor formation in mice, underscoring the importance of telomere length and telomerase activity in maintaining genomic integrity. Mouse models have provided important insights for discovering critical pathways in the progression to cancer, as well as to elucidate cross talk among different pathways. This review examines various molecular mechanisms of genomic instability and their relevance to cancer.     

Assessment of microsatellite instability in head and neck cancer using consensus markers

Head and neck cancer is the sixth most common cancer in the world and one of the most lethal cancers. Microsatellite instability is an important characteristic of tumor cells and is observed both in presence and absence of mismatch repair gene mutations. The importance of microsatellite instability in head and neck cancer is not well established due to the lack of a consensus panel and selection of different markers, criteria and methodological variances. The main objective of this study was to investigate the performance of a consensus panel of microsatellite repeats by automated fragment analysis. Matched tumor and normal tissue samples from 99 patients were analyzed using five mononucleotide markers. Following PCR the amplified fragments were analyzed by capillary electrophoresis on an ABI 310 genetic analyzer. Microsatellite instability was observed in 26 patients. In 17 patients instability was detected at multiple loci. NR21 and BAT25 were the most frequently altered targets. These two mononucleotide markers could detect all samples displaying high-instability. In this study we describe a standardized fluorescent multiplex PCR combined with computerized analysis, which allows rapid and accurate analysis of a high number of samples and obviates the need to compare tumors with matching normal tissue.     

Drug treatment in the development of mismatch repair defective acute leukemia and myelodysplastic syndrome

DNA from therapy-related acute leukemia/myelodysplastic syndrome cases (tAL/MDS) from the GIMEMA [Gruppo Italiano Malattie Ematologiche Maligne dell'Adulto] Archive was examined for the microsatellite instability (MSI(+)) phenotype that is diagnostic for defective DNA mismatch repair. More than 60% (16/25) of tAL/MDS cases were MSI(+) in contrast to <4% (0/28) of de novo cases. hMLH1 gene silencing was rare and evidence of promoter methylation was found in less than one-third of the MSI(+) cases. Among the GIMEMA patients who had been treated for breast cancer there was an apparent trend towards early onset primary breast disease. This suggests that there might be common predisposing factors for breast cancer and tAL/MDS. There were also three examples of mutations in the MRE11 gene among the 25 tAL/MDS cases suggesting that defective recombinational DNA repair may promote the development of secondary malignancy. MSI(+) tAL/MDS was significantly associated with previous chemotherapy and the frequency of MSI(+) among radiotherapy patients was considerably lower. In view of the established relationship between drug resistance and mismatch repair defects, we suggest that selection for therapeutic drug resistance may contribute to the incidence of MSI(+) tAL/MDS.     

Mismatch Repair-Deficient Crypt Foci in Lynch Syndrome – Molecular Alterations and Association with Clinical Parameters

Lynch syndrome is caused by germline mutations of DNA mismatch repair (MMR) genes, most frequently MLH1 and MSH2. Recently, MMR-deficient crypt foci (MMR-DCF) have been identified as a novel lesion which occurs at high frequency in the intestinal mucosa from Lynch syndrome mutation carriers, but very rarely progress to cancer. To shed light on molecular alterations and clinical associations of MMR-DCF, we systematically searched the intestinal mucosa from Lynch syndrome patients for MMR-DCF by immunohistochemistry. The identified lesions were characterised for alterations in microsatellite-bearing genes with proven or suspected role in malignant transformation. We demonstrate that the prevalence of MMR-DCF (mean 0.84 MMR-DCF per 1 cm² mucosa in the colorectum of Lynch syndrome patients) was significantly associated with patients’ age, but not with patients’ gender. No MMR-DCF were detectable in the mucosa of patients with sporadic MSI-H colorectal cancer (n = 12). Microsatellite instability of at least one tested marker was detected in 89% of the MMR-DCF examined, indicating an immediate onset of microsatellite instability after MMR gene inactivation. Coding microsatellite mutations were most frequent in the genes HT001 (ASTE1) with 33%, followed by AIM2 (17%) and BAX (10%). Though MMR deficiency alone appears to be insufficient for malignant transformation, it leads to measurable microsatellite instability even in single MMR-deficient crypts. Our data indicate for the first time that the frequency of MMR-DCF increases with patients’ age. Similar patterns of coding microsatellite instability in MMR-DCF and MMR-deficient cancers suggest that certain combinations of coding microsatellite mutations, including mutations of the HT001, AIM2 and BAX gene, may contribute to the progression of MMR-deficient lesions into MMR-deficient cancers.