A salt-induced kinetic intermediate is on a new parallel pathway of lysozyme folding.

Lysozyme folds through two competing pathways. A fast pathway leads directly from a collapsed state to the native protein, whereas folding on a slow pathway proceeds through a partially folded intermediate (I(1)). At NaCl concentrations above 100 mM, a second transient intermediate (I(2)) is induced as judged by the appearance of an additional apparent rate constant in the refolding kinetics. Monitoring the time course of native molecules and of both intermediates shows that the NaCl-induced state (I(2)) is located on neither of the two folding pathways observed at low-salt concentrations. These results suggest that I(2) is a metastable high-energy intermediate at low-ionic strength and is located on a third folding pathway. The folding landscape of lysozyme seems to be complex with several high-energy intermediates located on parallel folding routes. However, the experiments show no evidence for partially folded states on the fast direct pathway.     

A pathway for conformational diversity in proteins mediated by intramolecular chaperones.

Conformational diversity within unique amino acid sequences is observed in diseases like scrapie and Alzheimer's disease. The molecular basis of such diversity is unknown. Similar phenomena occur in subtilisin, a serine protease homologous with eukaryotic pro-hormone convertases. The subtilisin propeptide functions as an intramolecular chaperone (IMC) that imparts steric information during folding but is not required for enzymatic activity. Point mutations within IMCs alter folding, resulting in structural conformers that specifically interact with their cognate IMCs in a process termed "protein memory." Here, we show a mechanism that mediates conformational diversity in subtilisin. During maturation, while the IMC is autocleaved and subsequently degraded by the active site of subtilisin, enzymatic properties of this site differ significantly before and after cleavage. Although subtilisin folded by Ile-48 --> Thr IMC (IMCI-48T) acquires an "altered" enzymatically active conformation (SubI-48T) significantly different from wild-type subtilisin (SubWT), both precursors undergo autocleavage at similar rates. IMC cleavage initiates conformational changes during which the IMC continues its chaperoning function subsequent to its cleavage from subtilisin. Structural imprinting resulting in conformational diversity originates during this reorganization stage and is a late folding event catalyzed by autocleavage of the IMC.     

Folding pathway mediated by an intramolecular chaperone. The inhibitory and chaperone functions of the subtilisin propeptide are not obligatorily linked

The subtilisin propeptide functions as an intramolecular chaperone (IMC) that facilitates correct folding of the catalytic domain while acting like a competitive inhibitor of proteolytic activity. Upon completion of folding, subtilisin initiates IMC degradation to complete precursor maturation. Existing data suggest that the chaperone and inhibitory functions of the subtilisin IMC domain are interdependent during folding. Based on x-ray structure of the IMC-subtilisin complex, we introduce a point mutation (E112A) to disrupt three hydrogen bonds that stabilize the interface between the protease and its IMC domain. This mutation within subtilisin does not alter the folding kinetics but dramatically slows down autoprocessing of the IMC domain. Inhibition of E112A-subtilisin activity by the IMC added in trans is 35-fold weaker than wild-type subtilisin. Although the IMC domain displays substantial loss of inhibitory function, its ability to chaperone E112A-subtilisin folding remains intact. Our results show that (i) the chaperone activity of the IMC domain is not obligatorily linked with its ability to bind with and inhibit active subtilisin; (ii) degradation and not autoprocessing of the IMC domain is the rate-limiting step in precursor maturation; and (iii) the Glu(112) residue within the IMC-subtilisin interface is not crucial for initiating folding but is important in maintaining the IMC structure capable of binding subtilisin.     

Functional analysis of propeptide as an intramolecular chaperone for in vivo folding of subtilisin nattokinase

Here, we show that during in vivo folding of the precursor, the propeptide of subtilisin nattokinase functions as an intramolecular chaperone (IMC) that organises the in vivo folding of the subtilisin domain. Two residues belonging to β-strands formed by conserved regions of the IMC are crucial for the folding of the subtilisin domain through direct interactions. An identical protease can fold into different conformations in vivo due to the action of a mutated IMC, resulting in different kinetic parameters. Some interfacial changes involving conserved regions, even those induced by the subtilisin domain, blocked subtilisin folding and altered its conformation. Insight into the interaction between the subtilisin and IMC domains is provided by a three-dimensional structural model.     

Folding intermediates of the prion protein stabilized by hydrostatic pressure and low temperature

Prion diseases are associated with conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein, PrPC, into a misfolded form, PrPSc. We have investigated the equilibrium unfolding of the structured domain of recombinant murine prion protein, comprising residues 121-231 (mPrP-(121-231)). The equilibrium unfolding of mPrP-(121-231) by urea monitored by intrinsic fluorescence and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopies indicated a two-state transition, without detectable folding intermediates. The fluorescent probe 4,4'-dianilino-1,1'-binaphthyl-5,5-disulfonic acid (bis-ANS) binds to native mPrP-(121-231), indicating exposure of hydrophobic domains on the protein surface. Increasing concentrations of urea (up to 4 M) caused the release of bound bis-ANS, whereas changes in intrinsic fluorescence and CD of mPrP took place only above 4 M urea. This indicates the existence of a partially unfolded conformation of mPrP, characterized by loss of bis-ANS binding and preservation of the overall structure of the protein, stabilized at low concentrations of urea. Hydrostatic pressure and low temperatures were also used to stabilize partially folded intermediates that are not detectable in the presence of chemical denaturants. Compression of mPrP to 3.5 kbar at 25 degrees C and pH 7 caused a slight decrease in intrinsic fluorescence emission and an 8-fold increase in bis-ANS fluorescence. Lowering the temperature to -9 degrees C under pressure reversed the decrease in intrinsic fluorescence and caused a marked (approximately 40-fold) increase in bis-ANS fluorescence. The increase in bis-ANS fluorescence at low temperatures was similar to that observed for mPrP at 1 atm at pH 4. These results suggest that pressure-assisted cold denaturation of mPrP stabilizes a partially folded intermediate that is qualitatively similar to the state obtained at acidic pH. Compression of mPrP in the presence of a subdenaturing concentration of urea stabilized another partially folded intermediate, and cold denaturation under these conditions led to complete unfolding of the protein. Possible implications of the existence of such partially folded intermediates in the folding of the prion protein and in the conversion to the PrPSc conformer are discussed.     

Folding pathway mediated by an intramolecular chaperone: the structural and functional characterization of the aqualysin I propeptide

Aqualysin I, a thermostable homologue of subtilisin, requires its propeptide (ProA) to function as an intramolecular chaperone (IMC). To decipher the mechanisms through which propeptides can initiate protein folding, we characterized ProA in terms of its sequence, structure and function. Our results show that, in contrast to ProS (propeptide of subtilisin), ProA can fold spontaneously, reversibly and cooperatively into a stable monomeric alpha-beta conformation, even when isolated from its cognate protease-domain. ProA displays an indiscernible amount of tertiary structure with a considerable solvent-accessible hydrophobic surface, but is not a classical molten-globule folding intermediate. Moreover, despite showing only 21 % sequence identity with ProS, ProA can not only inhibit enzymatic activity with a magnitude tenfold greater than ProS, but can also chaperone subtilisin folding, albeit with a lower efficiency. The structure of ProA complexed with subtilisin is different from that of isolated ProA. Hence, additional interactions seem necessary to induce ProA into a compact structure. Our results also suggest that: (a) propeptides that are potent inhibitors are not necessarily better IMCs; (b) propeptides within the subtilase family appear polymorphic and; (c) the intrinsic instability within propeptides may be necessary for rapid activation of the cognate protein.     

The folding pathway of barnase: the rate-limiting transition state and a hidden intermediate under native conditions

The nature of the rate-limiting transition state at zero denaturant (TS(1)) and whether there are hidden intermediates are the two major unsolved problems in defining the folding pathway of barnase. In earlier studies, it was shown that TS(1) has small phi values throughout the structure of the protein, suggesting that the transition state has either a defined partially folded secondary structure with all side chains significantly exposed or numerous different partially unfolded structures with similar stability. To distinguish the two possibilities, we studied the effect of Gly mutations on the folding rate of barnase to investigate the secondary structure formation in the transition state. Two mutations in the same region of a beta-strand decreased the folding rate by 20- and 50-fold, respectively, suggesting that the secondary structures in this region are dominantly formed in the rate-limiting transition state. We also performed native-state hydrogen exchange experiments on barnase at pD 5.0 and 25 degrees C and identified a partially unfolded state. The structure of the intermediate was investigated using protein engineering and NMR. The results suggest that the intermediate has an omega loop unfolded. This intermediate is more folded than the rate-limiting transition state previously characterized at high denaturant concentrations (TS(2)). Therefore, it exists after TS(2) in folding. Consistent with this conclusion, the intermediate folds with the same rate and denaturant dependence as the wild-type protein, but unfolds faster with less dependence on the denaturant concentration. These and other results in the literature suggest that barnase folds through partially unfolded intermediates that exist after the rate-limiting step. Such folding behavior is similar to those of cytochrome c and Rd-apocyt b(562). Together, we suggest that other small apparently two-state proteins may also fold through hidden intermediates.     

Mechanism of the kinetically-controlled folding reaction of subtilisin

Like many secreted proteases, subtilisin is kinetically stable in the mature form but unable to fold without assistance from its prodomain. The existence of high kinetic barriers to folding challenges many widely accepted ideas, namely, the thermodynamic determination of native structure and the sufficiency of thermodynamic stability to determine a pathway. The purpose of this article is to elucidate the physical nature of the kinetic barriers to subtilisin folding and to show how the prodomain overcomes these barriers. To address these questions, we have studied the bimolecular folding reaction of the subtilisin prodomain and a series of subtilisin mutants, which were designed to explore the steps in the folding reaction. Our analysis shows that inordinately slow folding of the mature form of subtilisin results from the accrued effects of two slow and sequential processes: (1) the formation of an unstable and topologically challenged intermediate and (2) the proline-limited isomerization of the intermediate to the native state. The low stability of nascent folding intermediates results in part from subtilisin's high dependence on metal binding for stability. Native subtilisin is thermodynamically unstable in the absence of bound metals. Because the two metal binding sites are formed late in folding, however, they contribute little to the stability of folding intermediates. The formation of productive folding intermediates is further hindered by the topological challenge of forming a left-handed crossover connection between beta-strands S2 and S3. This connection is critical to propagate the folding reaction. In the presence of the prodomain, folding proceeds through one major intermediate, which is stabilized by prodomain binding, independent of metal concentration and proline isomerization state. The prodomain also catalyzes the late proline isomerizations needed to form metal site B. Rate-limiting proline isomerization is common in protein folding, but its effect in slowing subtilisin folding is amplified because of the instability of the intermediate and an apparent need for simultaneous isomerization of multiple prolines in order to create metal site B. Thus, the kinetically controlled folding reaction of subtilisin, although unusual, is explained by the accrued effects of events found in other proteins.     

Engineering antibody fitness and function using membrane-anchored display of correctly folded proteins

A hallmark of the bacterial twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway is its ability to export folded proteins. Here, we discovered that overexpressed Tat substrate proteins form two distinct, long-lived translocation intermediates that are readily detected by immunolabeling methods. Formation of the early translocation intermediate Ti-1, which exposes the N- and C-termini to the cytoplasm, did not require an intact Tat translocase, a functional Tat signal peptide, or a correctly folded substrate. In contrast, formation of the later translocation intermediate, Ti-2, which exhibits a bitopic topology with the N-terminus in the cytoplasm and C-terminus in the periplasm, was much more particular, requiring an intact translocase, a functional signal peptide, and a correctly folded substrate protein. The ability to directly detect Ti-2 intermediates was subsequently exploited for a new protein engineering technology called MAD-TRAP (membrane-anchored display for Tat-based recognition of associating proteins). Through the use of just two rounds of mutagenesis and screening with MAD-TRAP, the intracellular folding and antigen-binding activity of a human single-chain antibody fragment were simultaneously improved. This approach has several advantages for library screening, including the unique involvement of the Tat folding quality control mechanism that ensures only native-like proteins are displayed, thus eliminating poorly folded sequences from the screening process.     

Acid-Induced Formation of Molten Globule States in the Wild Type <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis> 5-Enolpyruvylshikimate 3-Phosphate Synthase and its Three Mutated Forms: G96A,A183T and G96A/A183T

Recent advances in protein chemistry have led to progress in the understanding of protein folding and properties of possible intermediates during the folding of proteins. The molten globule (MG) state, a major intermediate of protein folding, has a denatured state with native-like secondary structure. In the present work, the acid-induced unfolding of wild type Escherichia coli 5-enolpyruvylshikimate 3-phosphate synthase (EPSPS) and its three different variants (G96A, A183T and G96A/A183T) were studied by far- and near-UV circular dichroism (CD), intrinsic fluorescent emission spectroscopy and 1-anilino naphthalene-8-sulfonate (ANS) binding. At pH < 3.0, these EPSPS variants acquire partially folded state, which show the characteristics of the MG state, e.g., a drastic reduction of defined tertiary structure and almost no change in the secondary structure. ANS binding experiments show that hydrophobic surface of these variants is exposed to a greater extent in comparison to the native form, at acidic pH. Wild type, G96A, A183T and G96A/A183T acquire MG states at pH 2.0, 1.5, 3.0 and 3.0, respectively, which show that pH stability of MG state of G96A has increased in comparison to wild type; and pH stability of MG states of two other mutants is lower than that of the wild type. The results suggest that there is a direct relationship between stability of protein and pH stability of its folding intermediates.     

The folding of alpha-1-proteinase inhibitor: kinetic vs equilibrium control

Previous folding studies of alpha-1-proteinase inhibitor (alpha1-PI), which regulates the activity of the serine protease human neutrophil elastase, show an intermediate state at approximately 1.5 M guanidine-HCl (Gu). For the normal form of alpha1-PI, we demonstrate the reversible formation of the same stable distribution of monomeric and polymeric intermediates after approximately 1 h in 1.5 M Gu at approximately 23 degrees C from fully folded or fully unfolded alpha1-PI at similar final total concentrations and show that the stable distribution of monomeric and polymeric intermediates conforms with the law of mass action. We attribute these observations to an apparent equilibrium among intermediates. Our CD data are compatible with the intermediates having slightly relaxed structures relative to that of fully folded alpha1-PI and, thus, with the polymeric intermediates having a loop-sheet structure. Furthermore, we observe that the rates of folding (fast and slow terms) from the intermediate state are the same as those from the fully unfolded state, thereby supporting the contention that this intermediate state is on the folding pathway. We attribute the tendency of the Z mutant protein to polymerize/aggregate to an increased rate of the monomeric intermediate to form the apparent equilibrium distribution of intermediate species relative to its rate of folding to give intact alpha1-PI.     

Folding pathway for partially folded rabbit muscle creatine kinase.

Rabbit muscle creatine kinase (CK) was modified by 5,5'-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) accompanied by 3 M guanidine hydrochloride denaturation to produce a partially folded state with modified thiol groups. The partially folded CK was in a monomeric state detected by size exclusion chromatography, native-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, circular dichroism, and intrinsic fluorescence studies. After dithiothreitol (DTT) treatment, about 70% CK activity was regained with a two-phase kinetic course. Rate constants calculated for regaining of activity and refolding were compared with those for CK modified with various treatments to show that refolding and recovery of activity were synchronized. To further characterize the partially folded CK state and its folding pathway, the molecular chaperone GroEL was used to evaluate whether it can bind with partly folded CK during refolding, and 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonate was used to detect the hydrophobic surface of the monomeric state of CK. The monomeric state of CK did not bind with GroEL, although it had a larger area of hydrophobic surface relative to the native state. These results may provide different evidence for the structural requirement of GroEL recognition to the substrate protein compared with previously reported results that GroEL bound with substrate proteins mainly through hydrophobic surface. The present study provides data for a monomeric intermediate trapped by the modification of the SH groups during the refolding of CK. Schemes are given for explaining both the partial folding CK pathway and the refolding pathway.     

The effect of disease-associated mutations on the folding pathway of human prion protein

Propagation of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies is believed to involve the conversion of cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a misfolded oligomeric form, PrP(Sc). An important step toward understanding the mechanism of this conversion is to elucidate the folding pathway(s) of the prion protein. We reported recently (Apetri, A. C., and Surewicz, W. K. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 44589-44592) that the folding of wild-type prion protein can best be described by a three-state sequential model involving a partially folded intermediate. Here we have performed kinetic stopped-flow studies for a number of recombinant prion protein variants carrying mutations associated with familial forms of prion disease. Analysis of kinetic data clearly demonstrates the presence of partially structured intermediates on the refolding pathway of each PrP variant studied. In each case, the partially folded state is at least one order of magnitude more populated than the fully unfolded state. The present study also reveals that, for the majority of PrP variants tested, mutations linked to familial prion diseases result in a pronounced increase in the thermodynamic stability, and thus the population, of the folding intermediate. These data strongly suggest that partially structured intermediates of PrP may play a crucial role in prion protein conversion, serving as direct precursors of the pathogenic PrP(Sc) isoform.     

Positive selection dictates the choice between kinetic and thermodynamic protein folding and stability in subtilases

Subtilisin E (SbtE) is a member of the ubiquitous superfamily of serine proteases called subtilases and serves as a model for understanding propeptide-mediated protein folding mechanisms. Unlike most proteins that adopt thermodynamically stable conformations, the native state of SbtE is trapped into a kinetically stable conformation. While kinetic stability offers distinct functional advantages to the native state, the constraints that dictate the selection between kinetic and thermodynamic folding and stability remain unknown. Using highly conserved subtilases, we demonstrate that adaptive evolution of sequence dictates selection of folding pathways. Intracellular and extracellular serine proteases (ISPs and ESPs, respectively) constitute two subfamilies within the family of subtilases that have highly conserved sequences, structures, and catalytic activities. Our studies on the folding pathways of subtilisin E (SbtE), an ESP, and its homologue intracellular serine protease 1 (ISP1), an ISP, show that although topology, contact order, and hydrophobicity that drive protein folding reactions are conserved, ISP1 and SbtE fold through significantly different pathways and kinetics. While SbtE absolutely requires the propeptide to fold into a kinetically trapped conformer, ISP1 folds to a thermodynamically stable state more than 1 million times faster and independent of a propeptide. Furthermore, kinetics establish that ISP1 and SbtE fold through different intermediate states. An evolutionary analysis of folding constraints in subtilases suggests that observed differences in folding pathways may be mediated through positive selection of specific residues that map mostly onto the protein surface. Together, our results demonstrate that closely related subtilases can fold through distinct pathways and mechanisms, and suggest that fine sequence details can dictate the choice between kinetic and thermodynamic folding and stability.     

The Folding Trajectory of RNase H Is Dominated by Its Topology and Not Local Stability: A Protein Engineering Study of Variants that Fold via Two-State and Three-State Mechanisms

Proteins can sample a variety of partially folded conformations during the transition between the unfolded and native states. Some proteins never significantly populate these high-energy states and fold by an apparently two-state process. However, many proteins populate detectable, partially folded forms during the folding process. The role of such intermediates is a matter of considerable debate. A single amino acid change can convert Escherichia coli ribonuclease H from a three-state folder that populates a kinetic intermediate to one that folds in an apparent two-state fashion. We have compared the folding trajectories of the three-state RNase H and the two-state RNase H, proteins with the same native-state topology but altered regional stability, using a protein engineering approach. Our data suggest that both versions of RNase H fold through a similar trajectory with similar high-energy conformations. Mutations in the core and the periphery of the protein affect similar aspects of folding for both variants, suggesting a common trajectory with folding of the core region followed by the folding of the periphery. Our results suggest that formation of specific partially folded conformations may be a general feature of protein folding that can promote, rather than hinder, efficient folding.     

Evidence for sequential barriers and obligatory intermediates in apparent two-state protein folding

Many small proteins fold fast and without detectable intermediates. This is frequently taken as evidence against the importance of partially folded states, which often transiently accumulate during folding of larger proteins. To get insight into the properties of free energy barriers in protein folding we analyzed experimental data from 23 proteins that were reported to show non-linear activation free-energy relationships. These non-linearities are generally interpreted in terms of broad transition barrier regions with a large number of energetically similar states. Our results argue against the presence of a single broad barrier region. They rather indicate that the non-linearities are caused by sequential folding pathways with consecutive distinct barriers and a few obligatory high-energy intermediates. In contrast to a broad barrier model the sequential model gives a consistent picture of the folding barriers for different variants of the same protein and when folding of a single protein is analyzed under different solvent conditions. The sequential model is also able to explain changes from linear to non-linear free energy relationships and from apparent two-state folding to folding through populated intermediates upon single point mutations or changes in the experimental conditions. These results suggest that the apparent discrepancy between two-state and multi-state folding originates in the relative stability of the intermediates, which argues for the importance of partially folded states in protein folding.     

Cold rescue of the thermolabile tailspike intermediate at the junction between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation.

Off-pathway intermolecular interactions between partially folded polypeptide chains often compete with correct intramolecular interactions, resulting in self-association of folding intermediates into the inclusion body state. Intermediates for both productive folding and off-pathway aggregation of the parallel beta-coil tailspike trimer of phage P22 have been identified in vivo and in vitro using native gel electrophoresis in the cold. Aggregation of folding intermediates was suppressed when refolding was initiated and allowed to proceed for a short period at 0 degrees C prior to warming to 20 degrees C. Yields of refolded tailspike trimers exceeding 80% were obtained using this temperature-shift procedure, first described by Xie and Wetlaufer (1996, Protein Sci 5:517-523). We interpret this as due to stabilization of the thermolabile monomeric intermediate at the junction between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation. Partially folded monomers, a newly identified dimer, and the protrimer folding intermediates were populated in the cold. These species were electrophoretically distinguished from the multimeric intermediates populated on the aggregation pathway. The productive protrimer intermediate is disulfide bonded (Robinson AS, King J, 1997, Nat Struct Biol 4:450-455), while the multimeric aggregation intermediates are not disulfide bonded. The partially folded dimer appears to be a precursor to the disulfide-bonded protrimer. The results support a model in which the junctional partially folded monomeric intermediate acquires resistance to aggregation in the cold by folding further to a conformation that is activated for correct recognition and subunit assembly.     

Role of individual histidines in the pH-dependent global stability of human chloride intracellular channel 1

Chloride intracellular channel proteins exist in both a soluble cytosolic form and a membrane-bound form. The mechanism of conversion between the two forms is not properly understood, although one of the contributing factors is believed to be the variation in pH between the cytosol (~7.4) and the membrane (~5.5). We systematically mutated each of the three histidine residues in CLIC1 to an alanine at position 74 and a phenylalanine at positions 185 and 207. We examined the effect of the histidine-mediated pH dependence on the structure and global stability of CLIC1. None of the mutations were found to alter the global structure of the protein. However, the stability of H74A-CLIC1 and H185F-CLIC1, as calculated from the equilibrium unfolding data, is no longer dependent on pH because similar trends are observed at pH 7.0 and 5.5. The crystal structures show that the mutations result in changes in the local hydrogen bond coordination. Because the mutant total free energy change upon unfolding is not different from that of the wild type at pH 7.0, despite the presence of intermediates that are not seen in the wild type, we propose that it may be the stability of the intermediate state rather than the native state that is dependent on pH. On the basis of the lower stability of the intermediate in the H74A and H185F mutants compared to that of the wild type, we conclude that both His74 and His185 are involved in triggering the pH changes to the conformational stability of wild-type CLIC1 via their protonation, which stabilizes the intermediate state.     

Relationship between the native-state hydrogen exchange and folding pathways of a four-helix bundle protein

The hydrogen exchange behavior of a four-helix bundle protein in low concentrations of denaturant reveals some partially unfolded forms that are significantly more stable than the fully unfolded state. Kinetic folding of the protein, however, is apparently two-state in the absence of the accumulation of early folding intermediates. The partially unfolded forms are either as folded as or more folded than the rate-limiting transition state and appear to represent the major intermediates in a folding and unfolding reaction. These results are consistent with the suggestion that partially unfolded intermediates may form after the rate-limiting step for small proteins with apparent two-state folding kinetics.