Relationship of tightly bound ADP and ATP to control and catalysis by chloroplast ATP synthase

Whether the tightly bound ADP that can cause a pronounced inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by the chloroplast ATP synthase and F1 ATPase (CF1) is bound at catalytic sites or at noncatalytic regulatory sites or both has been uncertain. We have used photolabeling by 2-azido-ATP and 2-azido-ADP to ascertain the location, with Mg2+ activation, of tightly bound ADP (a) that inhibits the hydrolysis of ATP by chloroplast ATP synthase, (b) that can result in an inhibited form of CF1 that slowly regains activity during ATP hydrolysis, and (c) that arises when low concentrations of ADP markedly inhibit the hydrolysis of GTP by CF1. The data show that in all instances the inhibition is associated with ADP binding without inorganic phosphate (Pi) at catalytic sites. After photophosphorylation of ADP or 2-azido-ADP with [32P]Pi, similar amounts of the corresponding triphosphates are present on washed thylakoid membranes. Trials with appropriately labeled substrates show that a small portion of the tightly bound 2-azido-ATP gives rise to covalent labeling with an ATP moiety at noncatalytic sites but that most of the bound 2-azido-ATP gives rise to covalent labeling by an ADP moiety at a catalytic site. We also report the occurrence of a 1-2-min delay in the onset of the Mg2+-induced inhibition after addition of CF1 to solutions containing Mg2+ and ATP, and that this delay is not associated with the filling of noncatalytic sites. A rapid burst of Pi formation is followed by a much lower, constant steady-state rate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Medium ADP and not ADP already tightly bound to phylakoid membranes forms the initial ATP in chloroplast phosphorylation.

Measurements are reported on the source of the ADP and γ-phosphoryl moieties of the initial ATP formed when chloroplast thylakoid membranes are energized by an acid-base transition. Millisecond mixing and quenching experiments demonstrate that most or all of the initial ATP, formed in amounts considerably less than the amount of CF₁-ATPase present, arises from medium ADP and medium P_i. With no or low amounts of added medium ADP, the tightly-bound ADP present in thylakoid membranes is released to the medium on energization, then subsequently forms ATP. These results rule out the possible conversion of the ADP tightly-bound to CF₁-ATPase to tightly-bound ATP as a step in the main pathway of chloroplast phosphorylation. Less complete experiments indicate a similar behavior of tightly-bound ADP of submitochondrial particles.     

Function of tightly bound nucleotides on membrane-bound chloroplast coupling factor

The kinetic behavior of tightly bound nucleotides on chloroplast coupling factor from spinach was determined under phosphorylating and nonphosphorylating conditions. Chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1) was labeled with tightly bound radioactive ADP and/or ATP at two specific sites and reconstituted with thylakoid membranes depleted of CF1 by treatment with NaBr. The initial incorporation and dissociation of ADP from one of the sites requires light but occurs at the same rate under phosphorylating and non-phosphorylating conditions. The initial rate is considerably slower than the rate of ATP synthesis, but nucleotide exchange is very rapid during steady-state ATP synthesis. A direct correspondence between this nucleotide binding site and a site on soluble CF1 that hydrolyzes ATP was demonstrated. A second site binds MgATP very tightly; the MgATP does not dissociate during ATP synthesis nor does its presence alter the rate of ATP synthesis. This is analogous to the behavior found for soluble CF1 during ATP hydrolysis. These results demonstrate that the tight-binding nucleotide sites on soluble CF1 and membrane-bound coupling factor are essentially identical in terms of binding properties and kinetic behavior during ATP hydrolysis and synthesis.     

On the mechanism of sulfite activation of chloroplast thylakoid ATPase and the relation of ADP tightly bound at a catalytic site to the binding change mechanism

Washed chloroplast thylakoid membranes upon exposure to [3H]ADP retain a tightly bound [3H]ADP on a catalytic site of the ATP synthase. The presence of sufficient endogenous or added Mg2+ results in an enzyme with essentially no ATPase activity. Sulfite activates the ATPase, and many molecules of ATP per synthase can be hydrolyzed before most of the bound [3H]ADP is released, a result interpreted as indicating that the ADP is not bound at a site participating in catalysis by the sulfite-activated enzyme [Larson, E. M., Umbach, A., & Jagendorf, A. T. (1989) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 973, 75-85]. We present evidence that this is not the case. The Mg2(+)- and ADP-inhibited enzyme when exposed to MgATP and 20-100 mM sulfite shows a lag of about 1 min at 22 degrees C and of about 15 s at 37 degrees C before reaching the same steady-state rate as attained with light-activated ATPase that has not been inhibited by Mg2+ and ADP. The lag is not eliminated if the enzyme is exposed to sulfite prior to MgATP addition, indicating that ATPase turnover is necessary for the activation. The release of most of the bound [3H]ADP parallels the onset of ATPase activity, although some [3H]ADP is not released even with prolonged catalytic turnover and may be on poorly active or inactive enzyme or at noncatalytic sites. The results are consistent with most of the tightly bound [3H]ADP being at a catalytic site and being replaced as this Mg2(+)- and ADP-inhibited site regains equivalent participation with other catalytic sites on the activated enzyme.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Activation of ATPase of spinach coupling factor 1. Release of tightly bound ADP from the soluble enzyme

Several seemingly unrelated procedures used to elicit the latent ATPase activity of soluble spinach coupling factor 1 can be correlated to the release of tightly-bound ADP from the uncoupled enzyme. This ADP release is further enhanced by the presence of medium nucleotides, especially substrate ATP, and may or may not involve release from the catalytic site itself. Similarly, the light/dithiothreitol activation of membrane-bound CF1 ATPase is reported to be accompanied by energy-dependent ADP dissociation. Further indication that ADP release is involved in the ATPase activation mechanism is the observation that a pyruvate kinase phosphoenolpyruvate trap for ADP released during light/dithiothreitol treatment greatly retards the decay of membrane-bound ATPase activity that occurs in the dark, presumably by preventing reassociation of ADP. The time course of CF1 reactivation by light, after light/dithiothreitol activation followed by dark decay, allows a distinction to be made between the apparently rate-limiting dithiol modification and the more rapid dissociation of tightly bound ADP.     

Studies of substructure and tightly bound nucleotide in bacterial membrane ATPase

Highly purified preparations of Streptococcus faecalis ATPase contain a similar but inactive protein detected by prolonged polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The inactive protein appears to arise by proteolytic cleavage of the major subunits in the enzyme. By use of a new technique, subunit analysis in SDS gels was performed on the enzyme band and the inactive protein band excised from a polyacrylamide gel after electrophoresis. The results indicated that the ATPase has the composition α₃β₃γ in which α = 60,000, β = 55,000, and γ = 37,000 daltons. The inactive protein appears to have the composition (f)₆ in which f = 49,000 daltons. There is also evidence that the enzyme band contains some slightly modified forms of the ATPase, such as α₃β₂ (f)γ. The inactive protein lacks the capacity for tight nucleotide binding. Our experiments show that the tight ATPase-nucleotide complex formed in S. faecalis cells (the endogenous complex) behaves differently from the tight complex formed in vitro (the exogenous complex). We prepared a doubly labeled complex containing endogenous ³²P-labeled ADP and ATP and exogenous ³H-labeled ADP. We observed that the addition of free nucelotide to the doubly labeled ATPase displaced the exogenous bound ligand from the enzyme but not the endogenous bound nucleotide. We suggest that the displaceable and nondisplaceable forms of the tight ATPase-nucleotide complex correspond to two different conformational states of the enzyme.     

Properties of ATP tightly bound to catalytic sites of chloroplast ATP synthase

Under steady state photophosphorylating conditions, each ATP synthase complex from spinach thylakoids contains, at a catalytic site, about one tightly bound ATP molecule that is rapidly labeled from medium 32Pi. The level of this bound [32P]ATP is markedly reduced upon de-energization of the spinach thylakoids. The reduction is biphasic, a rapid phase in which the [32P] ATP/synthase complex drops about 2-fold within 10 s, followed by a slow phase, kobs = 0.01/min. A decrease in the concentration of medium 32Pi to well below its apparent Km for photophosphorylation is required to decrease the amount of tightly bound ATP/synthase found just after de-energization and before the rapid phase of bound ATP disappearance. The [32P]ATP that remains bound after the rapid phase appears to be mostly at a catalytic site as demonstrated by a continued exchange of the oxygens of the bound ATP with water oxygens. This bound [32P]ATP does not exchange with medium Pi and is not removed by the presence of unlabeled ATP. The levels of tightly bound ADP and ATP arising from medium ADP were measured by a novel method based on use of [beta-32P]ADP. After photophosphorylation and within minutes after the rapid phase of bound ATP loss, the measured ratio of bound ADP to ATP was about 1.4 and the sum of bound ADP plus ATP was about 1/synthase. This ratio is smaller than that found about 1 h after de-energization. Hence, while ATP bound at catalytic sites disappears, bound ADP appears. The results suggest that during and after de-energization the bound ATP disappears from the catalytic site by hydrolysis to bound ADP and Pi with subsequent preferential release of Pi. These and related observations can be accommodated by the binding change mechanism for ATP synthase with participation of alternating catalytic sites and are consistent with a deactivated state arising from occupancy of one catalytic site on the synthase complex by an inhibitory ADP without presence of Pi.     

A study on the exchange of tightly bound nucleotides on the membrane-associated chloroplast ATP synthase complex

Light-induced exchange of tightly bound ADP on the membrane-associated chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF₁) was concluded to be a two-step mechanism involving a loose enzyme-ADP complex (Strotmann, H., Bickel-Sandkötter, S. and Shoshan, V. (1979) FEBS Lett. 101, 316–320). Rapid binding of [¹⁴C]ADP to the coupling factor after deenergization of thylakoids which were illuminated in the presence of [¹⁴C]ADP was suggested to reflect the conversion of loosely bound to tightly bound ADP. Experimental data of the present paper support the assumption of an intermediate enzyme form with loosely bound ADP: (a) the amplitude of the rapid binding phase is independent on the concentration of uncoupler added in the light; (b) the amplitude is virtually unaffected by dilution of the medium [¹⁴]CADP concentration; (c) high concentrations of unlabeled ADP are required to reduce the rapid binding phase while binding of medium [¹⁴C]ADP is inhibited by unlabeled ADP in the micromolar range. These results exclude the possibility that the rapid initial formation of tightly bound [¹⁴C]ADP on deenergization might be caused by an energized nucleotide-free enzyme form which is able to pick up [¹⁴C]ADP from the medium at a higher rate than the deenergized nucleotide-free form. At saturating [¹⁴C]ADP concentrations in the light, the amount of the loose enzyme-ADP complex is about 35%, while 65% of the coupling factors contain a tightly bound ADP. Dissociation of the loose complex is slow in the absence of medium nucleotides but accelerated if ADP is present, suggesting that ADP binding to another site of the enzyme promotes release of the former ADP molecule. The significance of the loosely bound nucleotide in the catalytic mechanism is discussed.     

The possible role of tightly bound adenine nucleotides in oxidative and photosynthetic phosphorylation

The tightly bound nucleotides of the beef-heart mitochondrial ATPase are released during cold inactivation followed by ammonium sulfate precipitation. During incubation at 0°C the sedimentation coefficient (s_{20 W}) of the ATPase first declines from 12.1 S to 9 S. Prolonged incubation or precipitation with ammonium sulfate leads to dissociation of the 9 S component into subunits with s_{20 W} of 3.5 S. The 9 S component still bears bound nucleotides which exchange more extensively and rapidly with added nucleotides than those bound to the active 12.1 S component. The bound nucleotides are lost when the 9 S form dissociates into the smaller subunits. Thus, firm binding of nucleotides is a property of the quarternary structure of the enzyme. The exchangeability of the nucleotides bound to the ATPase of chloroplast membranes is greatly increased in membranes illuminated in the presence of pyocyanine. P_i can exchange into both the β and γ positions of the bound nucleotides when the membranes are energized in the presence of Mg²⁺. The exchange of the nucleotides and the incorporation of P_i are insensitive to the inhibitor Dio-9 but are inhibited by the uncoupler S₁₃.

1 Abbreviation: S₁₃, 5-chloro-3-t-butyl-2′-chloro-4′nitrosalicylanilide.

This inhibition by S₁₃ parallels that of the inhibition of photosynthetic phosphorylation. These findings are discussed with regard to our hypothesis that electron transfer causes release of preformed tightly bound ATP from the ATPase by inducing a conformational change.     

Modulation of the chloroplast ATPase by tight ADP binding. Effect of uncouplers and ATP

Inactivation of the membrane-bound ATPase by tight ADP binding was studied under nonenergized conditions. The energy state of the system was controlled either by omitting MgCl₂, preventing ATP hydrolysis, or by addition of an uncoupler which dissipates the . In the absence of Mg²⁺, ATP prevents the inactivation of the enzyme by ADP, in a competitive manner. This effect of ATP resembles that of GDP with Mg²⁺ present. In the presence of nigericin, Mg²⁺, and ATP, inactivation occurs after a 10–15-sec interval, during which the enzyme is able to hydrolyze ATP at a relatively rapid rate. The degree of inactivation is proportional to the level of bound ADP detected. This behavior is different from that of the coupled ATPase (no uncoupler added), where inactivation is attained only upon exhaustion of the ATP by its hydrolysis, despite the finding that ADP binds tightly to the active ATPase at all stages of the reaction. Higher levels of tightly bound ADP were detected in the presence of an uncoupler. We suggest that the interval during which the enzyme becomes inactive is that required for the enzyme to generate and bind ADP, and to change from the active to the inactive conformation. These results support the mechanism suggested previously for the modulation of the ATPase by tight nucleotide binding.     

The binding of a second divalent metal ion is necessary for the activation of ATP hydrolysis and its inhibition by tightly bound ADP in the ATPase from Halobacterium saccharovorum.

A binding site for divalent metal ions on the ATPase from Halobacterium saccharovorum is proposed. This site is different from the catalytic site which binds ATP and a complexed divalent metal ion. Occupation of the second site greatly stimulates the rate of ATP hydrolysis and the affinity of the catalytic site for the metal ion-ATP complex. The time-dependent inhibition of the ATPase, which occurs during catalysis and which is known to be caused by the retention of ADP, is also dependent on the occupation of this metal ion binding site. The binding of the metal ion apparently induces extremely tight binding of ADP after the departure of Pi. Mg2+, Mn2+, Zn2+, Co2+, and Ca2+ were tested and showed both the activating and the inhibitory effects, although their binding constants for ATP and the second metal ion binding site were quite different. The characteristic shapes of the nonlinear ATP hydrolysis curves obtained with different metal ions, and different ratios of metal ion and ATP, could be explained with the established dissociation constants. On this basis, a model for the ATPase was developed with two catalytic cycles: one in which the second metal ion binding site is occupied, and another in which it is empty. These pathways are connected by metal ion-dependent equilibria.     

Purification of cytochrome b6 A tightly bound protein in chloroplast membranes

Purification of cytochrome b₆ was pursued to further develop rational technology for purification, proof of purity, and study of properties of membrane proteins. Cytochrome b₆ was purified—the first time from any source—from spinach chloroplast membranes; yield of pure cytochrome b₆ was 30% of that found in ethanol-extracted particles. The three-step procedure (pH 8) employed: (I) extraction in Triton X-100-4 M (optionally 2 M) urea, (II) chromatography in a Bio-Gel A-1.5m Column (Triton X-100-4 M urea). Without this step, subsequent electrophoresis failed. (III) Preparative disc gel electrophoresis.

Properties of cytochrome b₆: Cytochrome b₆ migrated in undenatured form as a single band in disc electrophoresis (pH 8, 7 or 8.9). None of the limited, accepted properties of the cytochrome in particles was altered by the purification procedure: Reduced b₆ has absorption maxima (22 °C) at 434, 536, and 563 nm; at −199 °C the a absorption region shows two peaks of equal intensity at 561 and 557 nm. Cytochrome b₆ is reduced by dithionite (not by ascorbate) and is autoxidizable. The prosthetic group of b₆ is protohaemin and is fully extractable by acid-acetone. No non-haem iron is present. The millimolar extinction coefficient of reduced b₆ (563–600nm) per mole of haem is 21. The protein equivalent weight is 40000 g per mole of haem. Cytochrome b₄ is an intrinsically aggregatable molecule. The reduced cytochrome does not react with CO except when Triton X-100 is present.     

The localization of tightly bound cardiolipin in cytochrome oxidase

One to two molecules of tightly bound cardiolipin are associated with resolved fractions of cytochrome oxidase containing subunits I to III or I to IV. Large scale isolation of subunits I to IV indicates the presence of approximately 0.5 molecule of cardiolipin per molecule of subunit I. Lipoprotein staining of sodium dodecyl sulfate/urea/acrylamide gels of cytochrome oxidase support the findings that subunit I is a lipoprotein. The resistance of this tightly bound cardiolipin to organic solvent extraction suggests a specific association of some tenacity with the protein.     

Removal of tightly bound ADP induces distinct structural changes of the two tryptophan-containing regions of the ncd motor domain

ncd is a molecular motor belonging to the kinesin superfamily. In solution, it is a homo-dimer of a 700 amino acid polypeptide. The C-terminus of each polypeptide forms a globular domain of about 40 kDa, the motor domain with ATPase activity. The ATPase site of the motor domain of kinesin family members, including ncd, binds ADP tightly, the release of which is facilitated by microtubules during the mechanochemical ATPase cycle. Previously, we studied the spectroscopic characteristics of the ncd motor domain, focusing on interactions of the transition-moment-dipoles between ADP and aromatic amino acid side chains using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. In the present study, we generated several ncd motor domain mutants. In each, a tryptophanyl or specific tyrosyl residue was mutated. We found that Trp370 and Tyr442, the latter of which stacks directly with the adenine moiety of bound ADP, caused the bound ADP to exhibit peculiar CD signals. In addition, fluorescence measurements revealed that Trp370, but not Trp473, was responsible for the emission intensity change depending on the presence or absence of bound ADP. This fluorescence result implies that the structural change induced at the ADP-binding site (on the release of the ADP) is transmitted to the region that includes Trp370, which is relatively close to the ADP-binding site but not in direct contact with the ADP-binding region. In contrast, Trp473 in the region that is in contact with the alpha-helical coiled coil stalk did not experience the structural changes caused on removal of ADP. The distinct behavior of these two tryptophanyl residues suggests that the ncd motor domain has a bifacial architecture made up of a relatively deformable side including the nucleotide binding site and a more rigid one.