Variable proton-pumping stoichiometry in structural variants of cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase is a multisubunit membrane-bound enzyme, which catalyzes oxidation of four molecules of cytochrome c²⁺ and reduction of molecular oxygen to water. The electrons are taken from one side of the membrane while the protons are taken from the other side. This topographical arrangement results in a charge separation that is equivalent to moving one positive charge across the membrane for each electron transferred to O₂. In this reaction part of the free energy available from O₂ reduction is conserved in the form of an electrochemical proton gradient. In addition, part of the free energy is used to pump on average one proton across the membrane per electron transferred to O₂. Our understanding of the molecular design of the machinery that couples O₂ reduction to proton pumping in oxidases has greatly benefited from studies of so called “uncoupled” structural variants of the oxidases. In these uncoupled oxidases the catalytic O₂-reduction reaction may display the same rates as in the wild-type CytcO, yet the electron/proton transfer to O₂ is not linked to proton pumping. One striking feature of all uncoupled variants studied to date is that the (apparent) pK_a of a Glu residue, located deeply within a proton pathway, is either increased or decreased (from 9.4 in the wild-type oxidase). The altered pK_a presumably reflects changes in the local structural environment of the residue and because the Glu residue is found near the catalytic site as well as near a putative exit pathway for pumped protons these changes are presumably important for controlling the rates and trajectories of the proton transfer. In this paper we summarize data obtained from studies of uncoupled structural oxidase variants and present a hypothesis that in quantitative terms offers a link between structural changes, modulation of the apparent pK_a and uncoupling of proton pumping from O₂ reduction.     

The cytochrome c binding site on cytochrome c oxidase.

Cytochrome $\text{c}$ was chemically coupled to cytochrome $\text{c}$ oxidase using the reagent 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide (EDC) which couples amine groups to carboxyl residues. The products of this reaction were analyzed on 2.5–27% polyacrylamide gradient gels electrophoretically. Since cytochrome $\text{c}$ binds to cytochrome oxidase electrostatically in an attraction between certain of its lysine residues and carboxyl residues on the oxidase surface, EDC is an especially appropriate reagent probe for binding-subunit studies. Coupling of polylysine to cytochrome oxidase using EDC was also performed, and the products of this reaction indicate that polylysine, an inhibitor of the cytochrome $\text{c}$ reaction with oxidase, binds to the same oxidase subunit as does cytochrome $\text{c}$, subunit IV in the gel system used.     

The site and mechanism of dioxygen reduction in bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase

The site and mechanism of dioxygen reduction in cytochrome c oxidase from bovine heart muscle have been investigated. The rate of cytochrome c2+ oxidation by O2 is shown to be affected by several factors: 1) pH, with optima at 5.65 and 6.0, 2) temperature between 0 and 29 degrees C, with E alpha = 13 kcal mol-1, 3) D2O exchange, with a reduction in rate of 50% or more at the pH optima, and 4) the addition of ethylene glycol or glycerol, which significantly lowers the rate. The extremely narrow (delta vCO approximately 4 cm-1) infrared stretch bands at approximately 1964 and approximately 1959 cm-1 for liganded CO are only slightly affected by factors 1-4 or by changes in the oxidation state of metals other than the heme alpha 3 iron. These results indicate a stable, unusually immobile O2 reduction site well-isolated from the external medium, a characteristic expected to be important for oxidase function. Precise stereochemical positioning of hydrogen donors adjacent to O2 liganded to heme alpha 3 iron can be expected in order to achieve the optimization of the time/distance relationships required for enzyme catalysis. These findings support a novel mechanism of O2 reduction via a hydroperoxide intermediate within a reaction pocket that experiences little change in conformation during the hydrogen and electron transfer steps.     

Evidence for dimer structure of proton-pumping cytochrome c oxidase, an analysis by radiation inactivation.

Cytochrome c oxidases, purified from bovine heart and the thermophilic bacterium PS3, were irradiated with a high-energy electron beam. The proton transport activities of both preparations and their electron transfer activities decreased as single exponential functions of the radiation dosage. Applying the target theory with alkaline phosphatase as an internal standard, the following functional molecular weights were obtained for cytochrome c oxidation and H+ pumping: 63-73 kd and 160-220 kd, respectively, for the bovine enzyme, and 80-100 kd and 190-230 kd for the PS3 enzyme. The results suggest that a dimer structure is necessary for H+ pumping, while a core part of monomer (presumably the largest two subunits, i.e. subunits I and II) is sufficient for cytochrome c oxidation.     

Intrinsic uncoupling in proton-pumping cytochrome c oxidase: pH dependence of cytochrome c oxidation in coupled and uncoupled phospholipid vesicles

The pH dependence of the transient aerobic kinetics of cytochromes c and a has been investigated with cytochrome oxidase reconstituted in phospholipid vesicles in the absence and presence of an uncoupler and an ionophore. The cytochrome a reduction level immediately after the burst phase was 60-80% and was not significantly changed by the addition of uncoupler and/or ionophore. The coupled rate of ferro-cytochrome c oxidation increases linearly with decreasing pH in the range 8.4-5.4. The increase in rate on uncoupling becomes less with decreasing pH and low cytochrome c concentration, being almost zero at pH 5.4. The coupled rate is increased by a lowering of the outside pH when the inside pH is constant. Varying the inside pH with a constant outside pH of 7.4 has little effect on the rate. It is suggested that the electrochemical potential has two separate effects on the coupled rate: the pH gradient mainly slows down the intramolecular electron transfer, but the membrane potential also lowers the second-order rate constant for the reaction with cytochrome c. The results are interpreted in terms of a model in which protonation of an acid-base group with a pKa of 6.4 from the inside increases the catalytic constant. Protonation from the outside, on the other hand, leads to an intrinsic uncoupling, because the protonated enzyme in the output state can return to the input state. This has no adverse physiological effect, since it becomes significant only at pH values well below 7.     

Structural changes at the surface of cytochrome c oxidase alter the proton-pumping stoichiometry

Data from earlier studies showed that minor structural changes at the surface of cytochrome c oxidase, in one of the proton-input pathways (the D pathway), result in dramatically decreased activity and a lower proton-pumping stoichiometry. To further investigate how changes around the D pathway orifice influence functionality of the enzyme, here we modified the nearby C-terminal loop of subunit I of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c oxidase. Removal of 16 residues from this flexible surface loop resulted in a decrease in the proton-pumping stoichiometry to <50% of that of the wild-type enzyme. Replacement of the protonatable residue Glu552, part of the same loop, by an Ala, resulted in a similar decrease in the proton-pumping stoichiometry without loss of the O₂-reduction activity or changes in the proton-uptake kinetics. The data show that minor structural changes at the orifice of the D pathway, at a distance of ~40 Å from the proton gate of cytochrome c oxidase, may alter the proton-pumping stoichiometry of the enzyme.     

X-ray structure and the reaction mechanism of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase

X-ray structure of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase in the fully oxidized state shows a peroxide bridging between Fe2+ and Cu2+ in the O2 reduction site. The bond distances for Fe-O and Cu-O are 2.52 and 2.16 A, respectively. The structure is consistent with antiferromagnetic coupling between the two metals, which has long been known and to recent redox titration results [J. Biol. Chem. 274 (1999) 33403]. The trigonal planer coordination of Cu1+ in the O2 reduction site is consistent with the very weak interaction between Cu1+ and O2 bound at Fe2+ revealed by time-resolved resonance Raman investigations. One of the three histidine imidazoles coordinated to the Cu ion in the O2 reduction site fixes a tyrosine phenol group near the O2 reduction site with the direct covalent link between the two groups. The structure suggests that the phenol group is the site for donating protons to the bound O2. Redox-coupled conformational change in an extramembrane loop indicates that an aspartate (Asp51) in the loop apart from the O2 reduction site is the site for proton pumping.     

The structure of the cytochrome a3-CuB site of mammalian cytochrome c oxidase as probed by MCD and EPR spectroscopy

The nature of the complexes formed between cytochrome c oxidase and the three inhibitory ligands N3-, CN-, and S2- have been investigated by a combination of MCD and EPR spectroscopy. CN- forms a linear bridge between the Fe III a3 and CuB II, suggesting that the distance between these centers in the oxidized enzyme is between 5 and 5.25 A. This distance is too short to permit N3- to form a linear bridge and the evidence suggests this to be bent. In contrast S2- or SH- is unable to form any bridge and it seems likely that two SH- ions are bound by the bimetallic site, one to Fe III a3 and the other to CuB I. The significance of the a3-CuB distance in terms of oxygen binding and reduction is discussed.     

Proton-pumping mechanism of cytochrome c oxidase: a kinetic master-equation approach

Cytochrome c oxidase is an efficient energy transducer that reduces oxygen to water and converts the released chemical energy into an electrochemical membrane potential. As a true proton pump, cytochrome c oxidase translocates protons across the membrane against this potential. Based on a wealth of experiments and calculations, an increasingly detailed picture of the reaction intermediates in the redox cycle has emerged. However, the fundamental mechanism of proton pumping coupled to redox chemistry remains largely unresolved. Here we examine and extend a kinetic master-equation approach to gain insight into redox-coupled proton pumping in cytochrome c oxidase. Basic principles of the cytochrome c oxidase proton pump emerge from an analysis of the simplest kinetic models that retain essential elements of the experimentally determined structure, energetics, and kinetics, and that satisfy fundamental physical principles. The master-equation models allow us to address the question of how pumping can be achieved in a system in which all reaction steps are reversible. Whereas proton pumping does not require the direct modulation of microscopic reaction barriers, such kinetic gating greatly increases the pumping efficiency. Further efficiency gains can be achieved by partially decoupling the proton uptake pathway from the active-site region. Such a mechanism is consistent with the proposed Glu valve, in which the side chain of a key glutamic acid shuttles between the D channel and the active-site region. We also show that the models predict only small proton leaks even in the absence of turnover. The design principles identified here for cytochrome c oxidase provide a blueprint for novel biology-inspired fuel cells, and the master-equation formulation should prove useful also for other molecular machines. .     

The effect of non-esterified fatty acids on the proton-pumping cytochrome c oxidase reconstituted into liposomes.

Bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase was reconstituted in phospholipid vesicles, and the effect of different non-esterified fatty acids (NEFA) was studied on its proton pump and on the proton permeability of the vesicles. Neither parameter appeared to be affected by concentrations of NEFA known to uncouple oxidative phosphorylation (10 microM). Also the permeability for K+ was not affected by them. The fatty acids caused an increase in the rate of electron transfer in the absence, but not in the presence, of uncoupler and/or valinomycin [diminution of the respiratory-control index (RCI)]. The RCI of 8.7-7.5 was decreased to about 4.5 in the presence of 0.27-10 microM-NEFA. Oleic acid was not effective at the above concentrations. Subunit III-depleted enzyme preparations gave vesicles with an RCI of about 5.5, which was decreased to 4.5 in the presence of NEFA. With both native and subunit III-depleted oxidase the RCI was never decreased to the value of 1 by NEFA, as happens with classical protonophores.     

Calcium-bound structure of bovine cytochrome c oxidase

The crystal structure of bovine cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) shows a sodium ion (Na⁺) bound to the surface of subunit I. Changes in the absorption spectrum of heme a caused by calcium ions (Ca²⁺) are detected as small red shifts, and inhibition of enzymatic activity under low turnover conditions is observed by addition of Ca²⁺ in a competitive manner with Na⁺. In this study, we determined the crystal structure of Ca²⁺-bound bovine CcO in the oxidized and reduced states at 1.7 Å resolution. Although Ca²⁺ and Na⁺ bound to the same site of oxidized and reduced CcO, they led to different coordination geometries. Replacement of Na⁺ with Ca²⁺ caused a small structural change in the loop segments near the heme a propionate and formyl groups, resulting in spectral changes in heme a. Redox-coupled structural changes observed in the Ca²⁺-bound form were the same as those previously observed in the Na⁺-bound form, suggesting that binding of Ca²⁺ does not severely affect enzymatic function, which depends on these structural changes. The relation between the Ca²⁺ binding and the inhibitory effect during slow turnover, as well as the possible role of bound Ca²⁺ are discussed.     

The mechanism by which oxygen and cytochrome c increase the rate of electron transfer from cytochrome a to cytochrome a3 of cytochrome c oxidase

When cytochrome c oxidase is isolated from mitochondria, the purified enzyme requires both cytochrome c and O2 to achieve its maximum rate of internal electron transfer from cytochrome a to cytochrome a3. When reductants other than cytochrome c are used, the rate of internal electron transfer is very slow. In this paper we offer an explanation for the slow reduction of cytochrome a3 when reductants other than cytochrome c are used and for the apparent allosteric effects of cytochrome c and O2. Our model is based on the conventional understanding of cytochrome oxidase mechanism (i.e. electron transfer from cytochrome a/CuA to cytochrome a3/CuB), but assumes a relatively rapid two-electron transfer between cytochrome a/CuA and cytochrome a3/CuB and a thermodynamic equilibrium in the "resting" enzyme (the enzyme as isolated) which favors reduced cytochrome a and oxidized cytochrome a3. Using the kinetic constants that are known for this reaction, we find that the activating effects of O2 and cytochrome c on the rate of electron transfer from cytochrome a to cytochrome a3 conform to the predictions of the model and so provide no evidence of any allosteric effects or control of cytochrome c oxidase by O2 or cytochrome c.     

Spectroelectrochemical study of the cytochrome a site in carbon monoxide inhibited cytochrome c oxidase

The reduction potential of the cytochrome a site in the carbon monoxide derivative of beef heart cytochrome c oxidase has been studied under a variety of conditions by thin-layer spectroelectrochemistry. The reduction potential exhibits no ionic strength dependence and only a 9 mV/pH unit dependence between pH 6.5 and 8.5. The weak pH dependence indicates that protonation of the protein is not stoichiometrically linked to oxidoreduction over the pH range examined. The temperature dependence of the reduction potential implies a relatively large standard entropy of reduction of cytochrome a. The measured thermodynamic parameters for reduction of cyctochrome a are (all relative to the normal hydrogen electrode) delta Go'(25 degrees C) = -6.37 kcal mol-1, delta Ho' = -21.5 kcal mol-1, and delta So' = -50.8 eu. When cytochrome c is bound to the oxidase, the reduction potential of cytochrome a and its temperature dependence are not measurably affected. Under all conditions studied, the cytochrome a site did not exhibit simple Nernstian n = 1 behavior. The titration behavior of the site is consistent with a moderately strong anticooperative interaction between cytochrome a and CuA [Wang, H., Blair, D. F., Ellis, W. R., Jr., Gray, H. B., & Chan, S. I. (1985) Biochemistry (following paper in this issue)].     

Reaction mechanism of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase

The 1.9 A resolution X-ray structure of the O2 reduction site of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase in the fully reduced state indicates trigonal planar coordination of CuB by three histidine residues. One of the three histidine residues has a covalent link to a tyrosine residue to ensure retention of the tyrosine at the O2 reduction site. These moieties facilitate a four electron reduction of O2, and prevent formation of active oxygen species. The combination of a redox-coupled conformational change of an aspartate residue (Asp51) located near the intermembrane surface of the enzyme molecule and the existence of a hydrogen bond network connecting Asp51 to the matrix surface suggest that the proton-pumping process is mediated at Asp51. Mutation analyses using a gene expression system of the Asp51-containing enzyme subunit yield results in support of the proposal that Asp51 plays a critical role in the proton pumping process.     

A cytochrome c oxidase proton pumping mechanism that excludes the O2 reduction site

A redox-coupled conformational change in Asp51 of subunit I and a hydrogen-bond network connecting Asp51 with the matrix surface have been deduced from X-ray structures of bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase. This has provided evidence that Asp51 may play a role in the proton pumping process. However, the lack of complete conservation of a residue analogous to Asp51, the inclusion of a peptide bond in the hydrogen-bonding network and the lack of apparent involvement of the O2 reduction site have been used as arguments against the involvement of Asp51 in the mechanism of proton pumping. This minireview re-examines these arguments.     

The subunit structure of the cytochrome c oxidase complex.

The subunit structure of the cytochrome c oxidase complex has been obtained for three preparations each isolated by a different detergent procedure. Six polypeptides were present in all samples with the following molecular weights: subunits I, 36000; II, 22500, III, 17100; IV, 12500; V, 9700; and VI, 5300. These subunits have been purified by gel filtration in sodium dodecyl sulfate or in 6 M guanidine hydrochloride and their amino acid compositions have been determined. Subunit I is hydrophobic in character with a polarity of 35.7%. Subunits II through VI are more hydrophilic with polarities of 45.5, 48.6, 47.8, 49.7, and 53.7%, respectively.     

A structural model for the adduct between cytochrome c and cytochrome c oxidase

An ensemble of structural models of the adduct between cytochrome c and cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans has been calculated based on the experimental data from site-directed mutagenesis and NMR experiments that have accumulated over the last years of research on this system. The residues from each protein that are at the protein–protein interface have been identified by the above experimental work, and this information has been converted in a series of restraints explicitly used in calculations. It is found that a single static structural model cannot satisfy all experimental data simultaneously. Therefore, it is proposed that the adduct exists as a dynamic ensemble of different orientations in equilibrium, and may be represented by a combination or average of the various limiting conformations calculated here. The equilibrium involves both conformations that are competent for electron transfer and conformations that are not. Long-range recognition of the partners is driven by non-specific electrostatic interactions, while at shorter distances hydrophobic contacts tune the reciprocal orientation. Electron transfer from cytochrome bc ₁ to cytochrome c oxidase is mediated through cytochrome c experiencing multiple encounters with both of its partners, only part of which are productive. The number of encounters, and thus the electron transfer rate, may be increased by the formation of a cytochrome bc ₁–cytochrome c oxidase supercomplex and/or (in human) by increasing the concentration of the two enzymes in the membrane space. Protein Data Bank Accession numbers The coordinates of the five best structural models for each of the four clusters have been deposited in the Protein Data Bank (PDB ID 1ZYY).