Hypothetical model for monitoring microbial growth by using capacitance measurements--a minireview.

Microbiological impedance devices are used routinely by food and manufacturing industries, and public health agencies to measure microbial growth and metabolism. In this paper a hypothetical model explaining the effects of microbial growth and metabolism on capacitance at electrode-medium interfaces, that can be supported by fundamental theories and principles of electrochemistry, is presented. This model provides a framework to interpret changes in capacitance during microbial growth and metabolism and can be used to generate and test hypotheses on factors (i.e., temperature, microbial cell density, microbial growth and medium conductivity) contributing to increases or decreases in capacitance.     

Electrochemical changes in media due to microbial

Microbial metabolism affected the electrical impedance parameters of a two terminal-measuring cell-containing growth media. The relationship between microbial growth and relative changes in both The capacitive and resistive parts of impedance was examined. Both components of impedance were shown to be indicative of bacterial growth. In low conductivity media the change in the conductance of the media (G_sol) clearly correlated to bacterial growth. In more conductive media the relative changes in G_sol were smaller, and in these media measurements of the changes of polarization capacitance (C_pol) were useful for monitoring bacterial growth.Yeast growth in two media resulted in large changes in C_pol (20–100%) while the changes in G_sol were very small (1–4%). This result indicated that, for some combinations of microorganisms and media, measuring C_pol might be preferable over G_sol for the detection of microbial growth.Microbial metabolism resulted in a change of 2–2.5 units in pH. This pH change resulted in a 40% change in C_pol but less than a 14% change in G_sol.     

Causes of conductance change in yeast cultures.

The conductance change due to growth of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Y112, Zygosaccharomyces bailii M and Rhodotorula rubra NCYC 63 in culture media containing glucose, tartrate pH buffer and ammonium ions as sole nitrogen source was compared with that in a medium containing L-asparagine as sole nitrogen source. Decreases in conductance were observed in glucose-ammonium cultures of all three yeasts while little change occurred in cultures with L-asparagine as sole nitrogen source. This supports the hypothesis that the metabolic activity primarily responsible for conductance change in yeast cultures is the uptake of charged ammonium ions as nitrogen source and the reaction of protons with pH buffer compounds. Rhodotorula rubra cultures with L-asparagine as sole carbon source caused large increases in conductance with growth. Chemical analyses of culture filtrates showed that this increase in conductance was due to use of L-asparagine as carbon source and the excretion of nitrogen surplus to biosynthetic needs as ammonium. In addition, the production of aspartate, acetate and bicarbonate contributed to the increase in conductance.     

Causes of conductance change in yeast cultures

The conductance change due to growth of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Y112, Zygosaccharomyces bailii M and Rhodotorula rabra NCYC 63 in culture media containing glucose, tartrate pH buffer and ammonium ions as sole nitrogen source was compared with that in a medium containing L-asparagine as sole nitrogen source. Decreases in conductance were observed in glucose-ammonium cultures of all three yeasts while little change occurred in cultures with L-asparagine as sole nitrogen source. This supports the hypothesis that the metabolic activity primarily responsible for conductance change in yeast cultures is the uptake of charged ammonium ions as nitrogen source and the reaction of protons with pH buffer compounds.
Rhodotorula rubra cultures with L-asparagine as sole carbon source caused large increases in conductance with growth. Chemical analyses of culture filtrates showed that this increase in conductance was due to use of L-asparagine as carbon source and the excretion of nitrogen surplus to biosynthetic needs as ammonium. In addition, the production of aspartate, acetate and bicarbonate contributed to the increase in conductance.     

Detection of viable Salmonella typhimurium by impedance measurement of electrode capacitance and medium resistance

Three-electrode electrochemical impedance technique was investigated for detection of Salmonella typhimurium by monitoring the growth of bacteria in selenite cystine (SC) broth supplemented with trimethylamine oxide hydrochloride (TMAO.HCl) and mannitol (M). The change in the system impedance during the growth of bacteria was studied using frequency spectral scanning. It was found that the impedance at low frequencies (<10 kHz) mainly came from the double-charged layer capacitance, reflecting the changes at the electrode interface and the adsorption on the electrode surface. While at high frequencies (>10 kHz), the system impedance mainly depended on the medium resistance. The adsorption of bacteria on the electrode surface was detected by measuring low frequency impedance, and verified with Faradic impedance spectroscopy. Enumeration of S. typhimurium using a low frequency (1 Hz) capacitance measurement and a high frequency (1 MHz) resistance measurement were compared. The detection times were determined for quantitative analysis based on the growth curves of bacteria referring to either the medium resistance or electrode capacitance. The regression equations for the detection times (t(d), h) and the initial cell number (N, cells.ml(-1)) were t(d)=-1.24logN+13.4 with R(2)=0.98 and t(d)=-1.40logN+14.46 with R(2)=0.97 for the medium resistance and electrode capacitance methods, respectively.     

Detection of viable Salmonella using microelectrode-based capacitance measurement coupled with immunomagnetic separation

In this study, we demonstrated the use of a general medium--brain heart infusion (BHI) broth that is not specifically formulated for impedance measurement, to achieve detectable impedance signals by using an interdigitated microelectrode (IME) with capacitance measurement at low frequencies. Anti-Salmonella antibody coated immunomagnetic beads were used to separate S. typhimurium from samples to provide the selectivity to this method. From analysis based on the equivalent circuit of the IME system, we found that the impedance change in BHI broth resulting from the growth of Salmonella was indeed the change in the double layer capacitance and could be monitored at 10 Hz using the IME. The results indicated that medium modification to improve impedance signal is not necessary with this IME system. However, effective immunological separation for the target organism is required for the selectivity when non-selective media are used. This finding provides a more flexible option of medium in impedance methods, which may provide opportunities to test those species of bacteria that have no suitable conductance growth medium. The detection time, t(d), was obtained from the impedance growth curve (impedance against bacterial growth time) at 10 Hz at the point where the impedance started to change. A linear relationship between the detection time and the logarithmic value of the initial cell number (N) was found in the Salmonella cell number ranging from 10(1) to 10(6) cfu/ml. The regression equation was t(d) = -1.22Log N + 8.90, with R2 = 0.95. The detection times for the initial cell number of 10(1) CFU/ml and 10(6) CFU/ml are 8 h and 1.5 h, respectively. This method is more sensitive than impedance methods using conventional electrodes.     

The competition transport of sodium ions and protons in the cytoplasmic access channel of the Na+,K+-ATPase

The changes in capacitance and conductance of lipid bilayer membranes have been studied with adsorbed membrane fragments containing Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase. These changes have been initiated by fast release of protons from a bound form (“caged H⁺”) induced by an UV flash. The changes of the capacitance in the presence of Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase were affected by the frequency of the applied voltage, pH and the concentration of sodium ions. Addition of sodium ions altered the changes of capacitance caused by a pH jump in the medium due to caged H⁺ photolysis, and the magnitude and sign of this effect depended on the initial pH. These results are explained by competitive binding of sodium ions and protons to the ion-binding sites of the Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase at its cytoplasmic side. The pH at which the sign of the sodium ion effect changed allows the evaluation of the pK of the proton binding site, which is about 7.6.     

Rapid detection of Bacillus stearothermophilus using impedance-splitting

An impedance splitting method was used to detect Bacillus stearothermophilus in suspension and attached to stainless steel surfaces. The effects of bacterial metabolism on the impedance of the culture medium and the ionic layers of the measuring electrodes were recorded using the BacTrac 4000 microorganism growth analyser. Impedance changes were measured at 55 degrees C. Seven of the eight media produced changes in the electrode impedance (E-value) and all media produced negligible changes in the impedance of the culture medium (M-value). Good correlations were obtained between cell numbers and the E-value measured over 18 h (r > 0.9) for the two strains of B. stearothermophilus tested in trypticase soy broth. The E-value correlations were used to estimate the numbers of both vegetative and spore forms of B. stearothermophilus as either planktonic or adhered cells. For the detection of B. stearothermophilus using impedance, only methods where the E-value impedance is recorded, can be used.     

Modelling the effectiveness of a natural antimicrobial on Salmonella enteritidis as a function of concentration, temperature and pH, using conductance measurements

The growth of Salmonella enteritidis in a brain heart infusion medium was monitored using the traditional viable count method and by conductance measurements using a Rabit impedance instrument. Growth curves (log₁₀ cfu ml⁻¹ vs time) at three different concentrations of oleuropein (0, 0·2 and 0·8%), pH values in the range of 5–8 and incubation temperatures from 22 to 42 °C were modelled using the Gompertz equation. A good correlation between the maximum growth rate from the viable count method and the maximum slope of the conductance curve from the impedance instrument was established. Based on this correlation, the maximum specific growth rate of Salm. enteritidis was modelled as a function of the oleuropein concentration, initial pH values and the incubation temperature with a quadratic equation, using a new, larger dataset of growth measurements by conductance. The developed model was validated by statistical comparison of predicted growth rates with growth rates determined by the viable count method, within the limits of the antimicrobial, pH and temperature domain.     

Membrane capacitance and conductance changes parallel mucin secretion in the human airway epithelium

Measurement of the magnitude and kinetics of exocytosis from intact epithelia has historically been difficult. Using well-differentiated cultures of human bronchial epithelial cells, we describe the use of transepithelial impedance analysis to enable the real-time quantification of mucin secretagogue-induced changes in membrane capacitance (surface area) and conductance. ATPgammaS, UTP, ionomycin, and PMA induced robust increases in total cellular capacitance that were demonstrated to be dominated by a specific increase in apical membrane surface area. The UTP-induced increase in capacitance occurred in parallel with goblet cell emptying and the secretion of mucin and was associated with decreases in apical and basolateral membrane resistances. The magnitude and kinetics of the capacitance increases were dependent on the agonist and the sidedness of the stimulation. The peak increase in capacitance induced by UTP was approximately 30 mucin granule fusions per goblet cell. Secretagogue-induced decreases in apical membrane resistance were independent of exocytosis, although each of the secretagogues induced profound reductions in basolateral membrane resistance. Transepithelial impedance analysis offers the potential to study morphological and conductance changes in cultured human bronchial epithelial cells.     

An investigation of indirect conductimetry for detection of some food-borne bacteria

Indirect conductimetry using a rapid automated bacterial impedance technique was investigated. Strains of Staphylococcus aureus, Listeria monocytogenes, Enterococcus faecalis, Bacillus subtilis, Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Aeromonas hydrophila and Salmonella spp. grown in Whitley Impedance broth all elicited indirect conductimetric changes. These indirect conductance responses were improved by the addition of 2 g/l glucose to the medium and resulted in maximum changes of 2340-4300 microS with associated maximum rates of change of 520-1210 microS/h. Furthermore, the indirect conductimetric assay detected growth of staphylococci, listeria and salmonella in media containing high concentrations of salts used as selective agents in culture media for the isolation of these organisms.     

Functional characterization of PorB class II porin from Neisseria meningitidis using a tethered bilayer lipid membrane

PorB class II from Neisseria meningitidis is a pore-forming, outer-membrane protein that can translocate to the host-cell membrane during Neisserial infections. This report describes development of tethered bilayer lipid membrane (tBLM) system to measure PorB conductance properties. The tBLM was fabricated by depositing a self-assembled monolayer of 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphothioethanol (DPPTE) tethering lipid on a gold electrode and then using 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) liposomes to deposit the upper tBLM leaflet. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and cyclic voltammetry (CV) were used to monitor tBLM formation and subsequent PorB incorporation. The highly insulating tBLM exhibited a membrane resistance and capacitance of 2.5MOmegacm(2) and 0.7 microF/cm(2), respectively. PorB was incorporated into the tBLM in an active conformation, as evidenced by its mediation of ion passage and the decrease in membrane impedance. After PorB incorporation, the membrane resistance decreased to 0.6MOmegacm(2). As expected, the PorB channel was found to be non-selective, allowing the transport of both cations and anions. Cyclic voltammetry indicated that ferricyanide ions can also pass through the pores. The PorB-containing biomimetic interface developed in this study could potentially be used to screen for compounds that modulate PorB activity.     

Membrane composition and ion-permeability in extremophiles

Abstract: Protons and sodium ions are the only used coupling ions in energy transduction in Bacteria and Archaea. At their growth temperature, the permeability of the cytoplasmic membrane of thermophilic bacteria to protons is high as compared to sodium ions. In some thermophiles, therefore, sodium is the sole energy coupling ion. Comparison of the proton- and sodium permeability of the membranes of variety of bacterial and archaeal species that differ in their optimal growth temperature reveals that the permeation processes of protons and sodium ions must occur by different mechanisms. The proton permeability increases with the temperature, and has a comparable value for most species at their respective growth temperatures. The sodium permeability is lower than the proton permeability and increases also with the temperature, but is lipid independent. Therefore, it appears that for most bacteria the physical properties of the cytoplasmic membrane are optimised to ensure a low proton permeability at the respective growth temperature.     

The extremely low frequency electrical properties of plant stems

The electrical properties (variation of capacitance and conductance with frequency) of a plant stem can be conveniently measured in vivo by time domain dielectric spectroscopy. In this technique a voltage step is applied to a stem. The resulting polarization current is sampled by a microprocessor and Fourier-transformed to yield these properties. Spectra were obtained for seven electrode separations along a Poinsettia stem. The inverse capacitance and conductance were plotted vs separation for 50 frequencies from .35 to 350 Hz. Least-square fits yielded the effective dielectric constant and conductivity of the stem over this frequency range. In this way electrode effects were eliminated. A similar procedure was carried out for Coleus. A log-log plot of dielectric constant vs frequency shows a two-stage linear decrease for both plants. The conductivity is primarily DC. The dielectric loss decreases smoothly with frequency for Coleus. These results are compared to those for bone and the inorganic material hollandite. The dielectric properties seem best described by a cooperative, many-body approach.     

Involvement of protons in the ion transport cycle of Na<Superscript>+</Superscript>,K<Superscript>+</Superscript>-ATPase

The effect of pH on electrogenic sodium transport by the Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase has been studied. Experiments were carried out by admittance recording in a model system consisting of a bilayer lipid membrane with adsorbed membrane fragments containing purified Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase. Changes in the membrane admittance (capacitance and conductance increments in response to photo-induced release of ATP from caged ATP) were measured as function of AC voltage frequency, sodium ion concentration, and pH. In solutions containing 150 mM Na⁺, the frequency dependence of capacitance increments was not significantly dependent on pH in the range between 6 and 8. At a low NaCl concentration (3 mM), the capacitance increments at low frequencies decreased with the increasing pH. In the absence of NaCl, the frequency-dependent capacitance increment at low frequencies was similar to that measured in the presence of 3 mM NaCl. These results may be explained by involvement of protons in the Na⁺,K⁺-ATPase pump cycle, i.e., electroneutral exchange of sodium ions for protons under physiological conditions, electrogenic transport of sodium ions at high pH, and electrogenic transport of protons at low concentrations (and in the absence) of sodium ions.     

An electrical method for detecting Listeria spp

A number of selective media for Listeria have been tested for use with electrical methods for growth detection. A modification of an existing medium containing acriflavine, ceftazidime, nalidixic acid and aesculin gave good selectivity and signal response. The capacitance signal was more reliable than conductance and was characteristic of Listeria spp.     

Astrocyte swelling leads to membrane unfolding, not membrane insertion

The mechanisms mediating the release of chemical transmitters from astrocytes are the subject of intense research. Recent experiments have shown that hypotonic conditions stimulate the release of glutamate and ATP from astrocytes, but a mechanistic understanding of this process is not available. To determine whether hypotonicity activates the process of regulated exocytosis, we monitored membrane capacitance by the whole-cell patch-clamp technique whilst a hypotonic medium was applied to cultured astrocytes. If exocytosis is triggered under hypotonic conditions, as it is following increases in cytosolic calcium, a net increase in membrane surface area, monitored by measuring the whole-cell membrane capacitance, is expected. Simultaneous measurements of cell size and whole-cell membrane conductance and surface area demonstrated that hypotonic medium (210 mOsm for 200 s) resulted in an increase in membrane conductance and in the swelling of cultured astrocytes by an average of 40%, as monitored by cell cross-sectional area, but without any corresponding change in membrane surface area. As we have demonstrated that capacitance measurements have the sensitivity to detect increases in cell surface area as small as 0.5%, we conclude that cell swelling occurs via an exocytosis-independent mechanism, probably involving the unfolding of the plasma membrane.     

The enhancement of neural growth by amino-functionalization on carbon nanotubes as a neural electrode

This paper reports the success of amino-functionalization on multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) to promote neuronal cells growth on MWCNT electrode for extracellular recording, attributed to the formation of positive charge of NH(2) molecules on their surfaces. Besides, the surface of MWCNT electrode becomes hydrophilic after amino-functionalization (AF-MWCNTs) which can enhance electrical conductivity because of lower MWCNT/electrolyte interfacial impedance and higher interfacial capacitance. Durability tests show that electrical characteristics of the MWCNTs treated by 2 wt% 1,4-diaminobutane solution (2 wt%-AF-MWCNTs) can last for at least six months in air ambient. The neural recording of crayfish shows that 2 wt%-AF-MWCNTs can provide better capability on detecting action potentials of caudal photoreceptor (CPR) interneuron compared to suction glass pipette from the evidence of a higher S/N ratio (126 versus 23). The amino-functionalized MWCNT electrode is feasible for long-term recording application according to the results of biocompatibility tests. As the MWCNTs were directly synthesized on Si-based substrates by catalyst-assisted thermal chemical vapor deposition (CVD) at a low temperature (400 °C), these self-aligned MWCNT electrodes could be friendly implemented in integrated circuits fabrications.     

Heterotrophic plate counts of surface water samples by using impedance methods.

Membrane filtration, spread plating, and pour plating are conventional methods used to determine the heterotrophic plate counts of water samples. Impedance methods were investigated as an alternative to conventional methods, since sample dilution is not required and the bacterial count can be estimated within 24 h. Comparisons of impedance signals obtained with different water samples revealed that capacitance produced faster detection times than conductance. Moreover, the correlation between heterotrophic plate count and detection time was highest (r = 0.966) when capacitance was used. Linear and quadratic regressions of heterotrophic plate count and impedance detection time were affected by incubation temperatures. Regressions between heterotrophic plate counts based on conventional methods and detection times of water samples incubated at less than or equal to 25 degrees C had R2 values of 0.878 to 0.933. However, regressions using detection times of water samples incubated at greater than or equal to 30 degrees C had lower R2 values, even though water samples produced faster detection times. Comparisons between broth-based versions of R2A medium and plate count agar revealed that the latter correlated highly with heterotrophic plate count, provided that water samples were incubated at 25 degrees C and impedance measurements were conducted with the capacitance signal (r = 0.966). When the linear regression of this relationship was tested with 100 water samples, the correlation between predicted and actual log10 CFU milliliter-1 was 0.869. These results indicate that impedance methods provide a suitable alternative to conventional methods.     

Heterotrophic plate counts of surface water samples by using impedance methods.

Membrane filtration, spread plating, and pour plating are conventional methods used to determine the heterotrophic plate counts of water samples. Impedance methods were investigated as an alternative to conventional methods, since sample dilution is not required and the bacterial count can be estimated within 24 h. Comparisons of impedance signals obtained with different water samples revealed that capacitance produced faster detection times than conductance. Moreover, the correlation between heterotrophic plate count and detection time was highest (r = 0.966) when capacitance was used. Linear and quadratic regressions of heterotrophic plate count and impedance detection time were affected by incubation temperatures. Regressions between heterotrophic plate counts based on conventional methods and detection times of water samples incubated at less than or equal to 25 degrees C had R2 values of 0.878 to 0.933. However, regressions using detection times of water samples incubated at greater than or equal to 30 degrees C had lower R2 values, even though water samples produced faster detection times. Comparisons between broth-based versions of R2A medium and plate count agar revealed that the latter correlated highly with heterotrophic plate count, provided that water samples were incubated at 25 degrees C and impedance measurements were conducted with the capacitance signal (r = 0.966). When the linear regression of this relationship was tested with 100 water samples, the correlation between predicted and actual log10 CFU milliliter-1 was 0.869. These results indicate that impedance methods provide a suitable alternative to conventional methods.