Regulation of cellular immune response against autologous human melanoma. II. Mechanism of induction and specificity of suppression

The cytotoxic immune response in the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) against an autologous malignant melanoma cell line, PJ-M, was found to be down-regulated in in vitro co-culture (IVC) selectively by unfractionated resident lymph node lymphocytes (derived from a lymph node infiltrated with the PJ-M melanoma cells) and T4+ as well as T8+ fractions of the resident lymph node-derived lymphocytes. In this study, the mechanism involved in, and the specificities of, cytotoxic immune response in this autologous system were examined at population and clonal levels. Resident lymph node lymphocytes were isolated from both involved and uninvolved lymph nodes from the same patient. Resident lymphocytes from both sources regulated the generation of cytotoxic immune response when both types of resident lymph node lymphocytes were further sensitized against the PJ-M cells in IVC and were expanded in interleukin 2 (IL 2). An IL 2-dependent homogeneous lymphocyte line (I-10:1) bearing the phenotype of a helper T cell (T4+) and a T4+ clone (I-10.3) of the I-10:1 line, established by limiting dilution culture, also down-regulated the generation of cytotoxic immune effector cells in the PBL in IVC against the PJ-M targets. The IL 2-dependent T4+ inducer line I-10:1 generated a functionally differentiated T8+ suppressor population(s) that, in turn, could abrogate cytotoxic response in fresh PBL in IVC against PJ-M cells. The inducer line I-10:1 and its subclone I-10.3 suppressed the generation of cytotoxic effector cells in the PBL in IVC selectively against the autologous PJ-M cells. Generation of cytotoxic allo-response in IVC was unaffected by the inducer lines. These results provide further evidence for the involvement of the regulatory network in cytotoxic immune response in an autologous human tumor system, and suggest a potential explanation for cytotoxic unresponsiveness against autologous melanoma cells.     

IL-4-transduced tumor cell vaccine induces immunoregulatory type 2 CD8 T lymphocytes that cure lung metastases upon adoptive transfer.

Vaccinations with tumor cells engineered to produce IL-4 prolonged survival and cured 30% of mice bearing pulmonary metastases, an effect abrogated by in vivo depletion of T cells. Vaccination induced type 2 T cell polarization in both CD4 and CD8 T lymphocyte subsets. We focused on the antitumor activity exerted by type 2 CD8+ T cells (Tc2) activated by IL-4 tumor cell vaccination. Tc2 lymphocytes lacked in vitro tumor cytotoxicity, but released IL-4 upon stimulation with tumor cells, as shown by limiting dilution analysis of the frequencies of tumor-specific pCTL and of CD8 cells producing the cytokine. In vivo fresh purified CD8+ T lymphocytes from IL-4-vaccinated mice eliminated 80-100% of lung metastases when transferred into tumor-bearing mice. CD8+ lymphocytes from IL-4-vaccinated IFN-gamma knockout (KO), but not from IL-4 KO, mice cured lung metastases, thus indicating that IL-4 produced by Tc2 cells was instrumental for tumor rejection. The antitumor effect of adoptively transferred Tc2 lymphocytes needed host CD8 T cells and AsGM1 leukocyte populations, and partially granulocytes. These data indicate that Tc2 CD8+ T cells exert immunoregulatory functions and induce tumor rejection through the cooperation of bystander lymphoid effector cells. Tumor eradication is thus not restricted to a type 1 response, but can also be mediated by a type 2 biased T cell response.     

Regulation of contact sensitivity reaction: contrasuppressor T cells and contrasuppressor factor downregulate efferent T suppressor cells.

Contact sensitivity (CS) reaction mediated by CD 4+8- Th 1 cells is under the control of several antigen-specific regulatory lymphocytes. Reaction is downregulated at the induction stage by T afferent suppressor T cells (Ts-aff) that prevent immunization and at the effector stage by efferent T suppressor cells (Ts-eff) that made immune Th 1 cells inoperative. Both suppressor cells are CD 4-8+ Th 1 effector cells and are protected against the suppressive action of Ts-eff cells by CD 4+8- contrasuppressor T cells (Tcs). As has been already shown there are also regulatory interactions between regulatory cells themselves and Ts-aff cells in addition to their effect on precursors of Th 1 cells, also preventing the induction of Ts-eff cells. The present experiments extend these findings and demonstrate that Ts-eff cells are also under negative control of Tcs lymphocytes. Likewise, antigen-specific factor produced by contrasuppressor T-T cell hybridoma, used in lieu of Tcs cells, impedes the activation of Ts-eff cells. In both cases regulation is aimed at the precursors of Ts-eff cells. Our experiments demonstrate that the outcome of immunization is dependent not only on the balance between immune cells and regulatory cells, but also on interactions between regulatory cells themselves.     

Long-term control of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection is mediated by dynamic immune responses

The primary goal of this study was to determine how chronic exposure to Ag influences the functionality of Mycobacterium tuberculosis-specific T cell responses. The frequency of IFN-gamma-producing effector CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells dynamically changed during persistent M. tuberculosis infection. CD8(+) T cells used differential effector functions during acute and chronic phases of the immune response, where CD8(+) T cells produced negligible amounts of IFN-gamma early in infection, but switched to cytokine production during the chronic stage of infection. Using limiting dilution analysis, CD8(+) T cells isolated during the initial phase of infection demonstrated lytic potential, but this waned in the chronic stage. The apparent loss of cytotoxic activity was not associated with the lack of perforin. Ag dose could potentially govern the functional program of CD8(+) T cells. Collectively, these results depict a host immune response mounted against M. tuberculosis of a significantly more dynamic nature than previously recognized.     

Regulatory T cells phenotype in different clinical forms of Chagas' disease

CD25(High) CD4+ regulatory T cells (Treg cells) have been described as key players in immune regulation, preventing infection-induced immune pathology and limiting collateral tissue damage caused by vigorous anti-parasite immune response. In this review, we summarize data obtained by the investigation of Treg cells in different clinical forms of Chagas' disease. Ex vivo immunophenotyping of whole blood, as well as after stimulation with Trypanosoma cruzi antigens, demonstrated that individuals in the indeterminate (IND) clinical form of the disease have a higher frequency of Treg cells, suggesting that an expansion of those cells could be beneficial, possibly by limiting strong cytotoxic activity and tissue damage. Additional analysis demonstrated an activated status of Treg cells based on low expression of CD62L and high expression of CD40L, CD69, and CD54 by cells from all chagasic patients after T. cruzi antigenic stimulation. Moreover, there was an increase in the frequency of the population of Foxp3+ CD25(High)CD4+ cells that was also IL-10+ in the IND group, whereas in the cardiac (CARD) group, there was an increase in the percentage of Foxp3+ CD25(High) CD4+ cells that expressed CTLA-4. These data suggest that IL-10 produced by Treg cells is effective in controlling disease development in IND patients. However, in CARD patients, the same regulatory mechanism, mediated by IL-10 and CTLA-4 expression is unlikely to be sufficient to control the progression of the disease. These data suggest that Treg cells may play an important role in controlling the immune response in Chagas' disease and the balance between regulatory and effector T cells may be important for the progression and development of the disease. Additional detailed analysis of the mechanisms on how these cells are activated and exert their function will certainly give insights for the rational design of procedure to achieve the appropriate balance between protection and pathology during parasite infections.     

Development and homeostasis of T cell memory in rhesus macaque.

The rhesus macaque (RM) is a critical animal model for studies of viral pathogenesis and immunity, yet fundamental aspects of their cellular immune response remain poorly defined. One such deficiency is the lack of validated phenotypic signatures for their naive and memory T cell subsets, and the resultant unavailability of accurate information on their memory T cell development, homeostasis, and function. In this study, we report a phenotypic paradigm allowing definitive characterization of these subsets and their comprehensive functional analysis. Naive T cells are optimally delineated by their homogeneous CD95(low)CD28(high)beta(7) integrin(int) (CD4+) or CD95(low)CD28(int)CD11a(low) (CD8+) phenotypes. This subset 1) was present in blood and secondary lymph tissues, but not effector sites; 2) vastly predominated in the fetal/neonatal immune system, but rapidly diminished with postnatal age; 3) lacked IFN-gamma production capability, and specific responses to RM CMV; and 4) demonstrated low in vivo proliferative activity. CD4+ and CD8+ memory subsets were CD95(high), but otherwise phenotypically heterogeneous and included all IFN-gamma production, RM CMV-specific responses, effector site T cells, and demonstrated high in vivo proliferative activity ( approximately 10 times the naive subset). These analyses also revealed the RM "effector memory" subset within the overall memory population. This population, best defined by lack of CD28 expression, contained the majority of RM CMV-specific cells, was highly enriched in extralymphoid effector sites, and comprised an increasing proportion of total memory cells with age. The effector memory subset demonstrated similar in vivo proliferative activity and survival as CD28+ "central memory" T cells, consistent with independent homeostatic regulation.     

Mycobacterial lipopeptides elicit CD4+ CTLs in Mycobacterium tuberculosis-infected humans

In searching for immunogenic molecules with the potential to induce protective immune responses against tuberculosis, we developed an ex vivo model to study frequency, phenotype, and effector functions of human T lymphocytes recognizing hydrophobic Ags of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M.Tb). To obtain unbiased results, we characterized T lymphocytes responding to a crude cell wall extract (chloroform methanol extract of M.Tb (M.Tb-CME)) containing a broad spectrum of mycobacterial glycolipids and lipopeptides. A significant proportion of T lymphocytes recognized M.Tb-CME (290 IFN-gamma+ T cells/10(5) PBMCs) and developed to effector memory cells as determined by the expression of CD45RO and the chemokine receptors CXCR3 and CCR5. Expanded lymphocytes fulfilled all criteria required for an efficient immune response against tuberculosis: 1) release of macrophage-activating Th1 cytokines and chemokines required for the spatial organization of local immune responses, 2) cytolytic activity against Ag-pulsed macrophages, and 3) recognition of infected macrophages and killing of the intracellular bacteria. Phenotypically, M.Tb-CME-expanded cells were CD4+ and MHC class II restricted, challenging current concepts that cytotoxic and antimicrobial effector cells are restricted to the CD8+ T cell subset. Pretreatment of M.Tb-CME with protease or chemical delipidation abrogated the biological activity, suggesting that responses were directed toward mycobacterial lipopeptides. These findings suggest that lipidated peptides are presented by M.Tb-infected macrophages and elicit CD4+ cytolytic and antimicrobial T lymphocytes. Our data support an emerging concept to include hydrophobic microbial Ags in vaccines against tuberculosis.     

Modeling regulation mechanisms in the immune system

We develop a mathematical framework for modeling regulatory mechanisms in the immune system. The model describes dynamics of key components of the immune network within two compartments: lymph node and tissue. We demonstrate using numerical simulations that our system can eliminate virus-infected cells, which are characterized by a tendency to increase without control (in absence of an immune response), while tolerating normal cells, which are characterized by a tendency to approach a stable equilibrium population. We experiment with different combinations of T cell reactivities that lead to effective systems and conclude that slightly self-reactive T cells can exist within the immune system and are controlled by regulatory cells. We observe that CD8+ T cell dynamics has two phases. In the first phase, CD8+ cells remain sequestered within the lymph node during a period of proliferation. In the second phase, the CD8+ population emigrates to the tissue and destroys its target population. We also conclude that a self-tolerant system must have a mechanism of central tolerance to ensure that self-reactive T cells are not too self-reactive. Furthermore, the effectiveness of a system depends on a balance between the reactivities of the effector and regulatory T cell populations, where the effectors are slightly more reactive than the regulatory cells.     

Sufficiency of the CD8+ T cell lineage to mount an effective tumoricidal response to syngeneic tumor-bearing novel class I MHC antigens

The origins of "help" in rejection of syngeneic tumors by the CD8 T cell lineage was examined with a model tumor inappropriately expressing novel class I MHC and subject to cytolytic T cell (CTL)-mediated rejection. The requirement for CD4+ Th cells to induce CD8+ CTL effectors in vivo was investigated by using C3H mice selectively depleted of either CD4+ or CD8+ T cells. Rejection of the tumor was vigorous and indistinguishable from normal mice after depletion of CD4+ T cells in vivo. In contrast, in CD8+ T cell-depleted mice tumors grew progressively, confirming that T cells of the CD8+ lineage are required for a tumoricidal immune response, and cells of this lineage are sufficient for a primary response. Taken together, these results demonstrate that, in the absence of CD4+ T cells in vivo, unprimed cells of the CD8+ lineage are fully competent to mount an effective CTL immune response to syngeneic cells expressing novel class I Ag, consistent with the concept that only T cells with class I recognition specificity may be required to satisfy the need for both help and effector functions in the response.     

CD8+ CD28- T regulatory lymphocytes inhibiting T cell proliferative and cytotoxic functions infiltrate human cancers

Tumor growth is allowed by its ability to escape immune system surveillance. An important role in determining tumor evasion from immune control might be played by tumor-infiltrating regulatory lymphocytes. This study was aimed at characterizing phenotype and function of CD8+ CD28- T regulatory cells infiltrating human cancer. Lymphocytes infiltrating primitive tumor lesion and/or satellite lymph node from a series of 42 human cancers were phenotypically studied and functionally analyzed by suppressor assays. The unprecedented observation was made that CD8+ CD28- T regulatory lymphocytes are almost constantly present and functional in human tumors, being able to inhibit both T cell proliferation and cytotoxicity. CD4+ CD25+ T regulatory lymphocytes associate with CD8+ CD28- T regulatory cells so that the immunosuppressive activity of tumor-infiltrating regulatory T cell subsets, altogether considered, may become predominant. The infiltration of regulatory T cells seems tumor related, being present in metastatic but not in metastasis-free satellite lymph nodes; it likely depends on both in situ generation (via cytokine production) and recruitment from the periphery (via chemokine secretion). Collectively, these results have pathogenic relevance and implication for immunotherapy of cancer.     

Lymphocyte clones from old subjects: growing rate and functional activity

Old subjects exhibit a decline in circulating T cells and an impaired proliferative response to mitogens, plus a relative increase in cells with NK phenotype not associated with a concomitant increase in their cytolitic activity.In the present study a limiting dilution assay was used to evaluate the phenotype, the functional activity and the proliferative capacity of clones obtained from peripheral blood lymphocytes of old and young subjects. CD5+ CD8+ clones from old people showed a significant impairment in their proliferative capacity and a decreased lytic activity against K562 and P815-IgG cell lines.     

Mycobacterium tuberculosis-reactive CD8+ T lymphocytes: the relative contribution of classical versus nonclassical HLA restriction

Previous studies in mice and humans models have suggested an important role for CD8+ T cells in host defense to Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb). In humans, CD8+ Mtb-reactive T cells have been described that are HLA-A2-, B52-, as well as CD1-restricted. Recently, we have described Mtb-specific CD8+ T cells that are neither HLA-A-, B-, or C- nor group 1 CD1-restricted. At present, little is known about the relative contribution of each of these restriction specificities to the overall CD8+ response to Mtb. An IFN-gamma enzyme-linked immunospot assay was used to determine the frequency of Mtb-reactive CD8+ T cells directly from PBMC. The effector cell frequency among five healthy purified protein derivative-positive subjects was 1/7,600 +/- 4,300 compared with 1/16,000 +/- 7,000 in six purified protein derivative-negative controls. To determine the frequencies of classically, CD1-, and nonclassically restricted cells, a limiting dilution analysis was performed. In one purified protein derivative-positive subject, 192 clones were generated using Mtb-infected dendritic cells (DC). Clones were assessed for reactivity against control autologous DC, Mtb-infected autologous DC, and HLA-mismatched CD1+ targets (DC), as well as HLA-mismatched CD1- targets (macrophages). Of the 96 Mtb-reactive CD8+ T cell clones, four (4%) were classically restricted and 92 (96%) were nonclassically restricted. CD1-restricted cells were not detected. Of the classically restricted cells, two were HLA-B44 restricted and one was HLA-B14 restricted. These results suggest that while classically restricted CD8+ lymphocytes can be detected, they comprise a relatively small component of the overall CD8+ T cell response to Mtb. Further definition of the nonclassical response may aid development of an effective vaccine against tuberculosis.     

Immobilized anti-CD3-induced T cell growth: comparison of the frequency of responding cells within various T cell subsets.

Human T cells can be divided into subsets based on the expression of CD29, CD45RA, CD45RO, LFA-3, or CD11a. It has been suggested that the subset of CD4+ T cells that expresses high densities of CD29, CD11a, CD45RO, and LFA-3 contains "memory" T cells, whereas the subset of cells that expresses CD45RA contains "naive" T cells. In order to obtain a more complete picture of the functional capacities of human naive and memory CD4+ and CD8+ T cell subsets, highly purified T cells were activated with a uniform stimulus and responses were examined in bulk cultures and under limiting dilution conditions. T cell activation was achieved with an immobilized mAb to the CD3 molecular complex, 64.1. In bulk cultures, immobilized 64.1 stimulated a vigorous response. Moreover, the number of cells entering the cell cycle, the magnitude of the [3H]thymidine incorporation, and the growth of the cells over 6 days in culture by naive and memory CD4+ T cells was comparable. To delineate the frequency of responsive cells in each subset more precisely, cells were cultured with immobilized 64.1 at limiting dilution and the precursor frequency of responding cells was assessed by examining wells microscopically for visible growth. Immobilized 64.1 was able to induce some T cells from each subset to grow in the complete absence of AC, when exogenous IL2 was present. The number of responding CD4+ and CD8+ cells was comparable. The percentage of naive cells responding in each population was approximately three times greater than the frequency of memory cells. IL4 could also support the growth of immobilized 64.1-activated CD4+ T cells, but the frequency of responding cells was much lower than that supported by IL2. The vast majority of the IL-4 responsive CD4+ cells resided within the naive cell subset. The data indicate that the response of CD4+ and CD8+ naive and memory T cell subsets to immobilized anti-CD3 depends on the density of responding cells. Naive T cells have an enhanced capacity to grow when cultured in the absence of other T cells or accessory cells. This ability may facilitate their expansion during primary immune responses.     

The role of the T cell in autoimmune inflammation

T cells, in particular CD4+ T cells, have been implicated in mediating many aspects of autoimmune inflammation. However, current evidence suggests that the role played by CD4+ T cells in the development of rheumatoid inflammation exceeds that of activated proinflammatory T-helper (Th)1 effector cells that drive the chronic autoimmune response. Subsets of CD4+ T cells with regulatory capacity, such as CD25+ regulatory T (Treg) cells and Th2 cells, have been identified, and recent observations suggest that in rheumatoid arthritis the function of these regulatory T cells is severely impaired. Thus, in rheumatoid arthritis, defective regulatory mechanisms might allow the breakdown of peripheral tolerance, after which the detrimental Th1-driven immune response evolves and proceeds to chronic inflammation. Here, we review the functional abnormalities and the contribution of different T cell subsets to rheumatoid inflammation.     

Primary CD4+ T-cell responses provide both helper and cytotoxic functions during Epstein-Barr virus infection and transformation of fetal cord blood B cells

Most humans carry Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) in circulating memory B cells as a latent infection that is controlled by an immune response. When infected by EBV, B lymphocytes in fetal cord blood are readily transformed to lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL). It is frequently assumed that this high efficiency of transformation is due to the absence of a primary immune response. However, cord blood lymphocytes stimulated with autologous LCL yield CD4+ T cells that can completely inhibit the growth of LCL by a major histocompatibility complex-restricted cytotoxic mechanism mediated by granulysin and granzyme B. Because EBV-transformed B cells maintain the phenotype of antigen-activated B-cell blasts, they can potentially receive inhibitory or helper functions from CD4+ T cells. To assess these functions, the effect of EBV-specific CD4+ T cells on the efficiency of virus transformation of autologous B cells was assayed. Paradoxically, although the cytotoxic CD4+ T-cell lines reduced EBV B-cell transformation at a high effector/target ratio of 10:1, they caused a twofold increase in B-cell transformation at the lower effector/target ratio of 1:1. Th1-polarized CD4+ T cells were more effective at inhibiting B-cell transformation, but Th2-polarized cell lines had reduced cytotoxic activity, were unable to inhibit LCL growth, and caused a 10-fold increase in transformation efficiency. Tonsil lymphoid follicles lacked NK cells and CD8+ T cells but contained CD4+ T cells. We propose that CD4+ T cells provide helper or cytotoxic functions to EBV-transformed B cells and that the balance of these functions within tonsil compartments is critical in establishing asymptomatic primary EBV infection and maintaining a stable lifelong latent infection.     

Effect of thyroxine and chicken growth hormone on immune function in autoimmune thyroiditis (obese) strain chicks.

The effect of thyroxine (T4) and/or recombinant chicken growth hormone (rcGH) supplementation on immune function and on immune cell maturation was examined in Obese strain chickens. Day-old Obese strain chicks received the control treatments or were treated with either T4 (supplemented in the diet), T4-rcGH, or rcGH (by daily injection) in a full factorial design. At 4 weeks of age, the proliferative activity of peripheral blood T cells to either mitogenic or allogenic cell (mixed lymphocyte response) challenge was assessed. At the same time, peripheral blood lymphocytes and thymocytes were collected and prepared for flow cytometry analysis. Proliferative responses to both T cell mitogens and allogeneic splenocytes were significantly increased (P less than 0.05) by rcGH treatment, while the combined T4-rcGH treatment resulted in a significant increase in allogeneic and in concanavalin A responsiveness, but not in the response to phytohemagglutinin. All supplemented groups showed a significant decrease in the mean fluorescent intensity for CT-1a+ thymocytes, while thymocytes from birds receiving either T4 or rcGH alone had higher proportions of CD4+ and CD8+ cells. The monoclonal antibody staining of thymocytes from T4-rcGH-supplemented animals more closely resembled that of the unsupplemented controls. Among the peripheral blood lymphocytes, there were no changes in the numbers of CD4+, CD8+, or sIg+ cells as a result of treatment. The mean fluorescent intensity of sIg+ cells was significantly decreased, however, as a result of T4 supplementation when given either alone or in combination with rcGH. Finally, the mean fluorescent intensity ratios of CD4+ to CD8+ cells was significantly increased as a result of rcGH supplementation. These results strongly support a role for both the thyroid hormones and growth hormone in regulating and/or enhancing immune function, with changes in functional responses paralleled by concomitant changes in the T cell populations as expressed by shifts in T cell surface marker expression.     

B-Cell Control of Regulatory T Cells in Friend Virus Infection

B lymphocytes have well-established effector roles during viral infections, including production of antibodies and functioning as antigen-presenting cells for CD4 + and CD8 + T cells. B cells have also been shown to regulate immune responses and induce regulatory T cells (Tregs). In the Friend virus (FV) model, Tregs are known to inhibit effector CD8 + T-cell responses and contribute to virus persistence. Recent work has uncovered a role for B cells in the induction and activation of Tregs during FV infection. In addition to inducing Tregs, B cell antibody production and antigen-presenting cell activity is a target of Treg suppression. This review focuses on the dynamic interactions between B cells and Tregs during FV infection.     

In vitro suppression of CD8+ T cell function by Friend virus-induced regulatory T cells

Regulatory T cell (Treg)-mediated suppression of CD8+ T cells has been implicated in the establishment and maintenance of chronic viral infections, but little is known about the mechanism of suppression. In this study an in vitro assay was developed to investigate the suppression of CD8+ T cells by Friend retrovirus (FV)-induced Tregs. CD4+CD25+ T cells isolated from mice chronically infected with the FV suppressed the development of effector function in naive CD8+ T cells without affecting their ability to proliferate or up-regulate activation markers. In vitro restimulation was not required for suppression by FV-induced Tregs, correlating with their high activation state in vivo. Suppression was mediated by direct T cell-T cell interactions and occurred in the absence of APCs. Furthermore, suppression occurred irrespective of the TCR specificity of the CD8+ T cells. Most interestingly, FV-induced Tregs were able to suppress the function of CD8+ effector T cells that had been physiologically activated during acute FV infection. The ability to suppress the effector function of activated CTLs is likely a requisite role for Tregs in limiting immunopathology by CD8+ T cells during antiviral immune responses. Such activity may also have adverse consequences by allowing viruses to establish and maintain chronic infections if suppression of antiviral immune responses occurs before virus eradication.