Achieving specificity in selected and wild-type N peptide-RNA complexes: the importance of discrimination against noncognate RNA targets

The boxB RNA pentaloops from the P22 and lambda phages each adopt a GNRA tetraloop fold upon binding their cognate arginine-rich N peptides. The third loop base in P22 boxB (3-out) and the fourth in lambda boxB (4-out) are excluded to accommodate this structure. Previously, we selected a pool of lambda N sequences with random amino acids at loop contacting positions 13-22 for binding to either of these two GNRA-folded pentaloops or a canonical GNRA tetraloop and isolated a class of peptides with a new conserved arginine (R15). Here, we characterize the binding of lambda N and these R15 peptides using fluorescent titrations with 2-aminopurine labeled versions of the three GNRA-folded loops and circular dichroism spectrometry. All peptides preferentially bind the lambda boxB RNA loop. lambda N and R15 peptide specificity against the P22 loop arises from the cost of rearranging its loop into the 4-out GNRA structure. Modeling indicates that the interaction of R8 with an additional loop phosphate in the 4-out GNRA pentaloop selectively stabilizes this complex relative to the tetraloop. R15 peptides gain additional discrimination against the tetraloop because their arginine also preferentially interacts with the 4-out GNRA pentaloop phosphate backbone, whereas K14 and W18 of lambda N contribute equal affinity when binding the tetraloop. Nonspecific electrostatic interactions by basic residues near the C-termini of these peptides create significantly steeper salt dependencies in association constants for noncognate loops, aiding discrimination at high salt concentrations. Our results emphasize the importance of considering specificity against noncognate as well as nonspecific targets in the combinatorial and rational design of biopolymers capable of macromolecular recognition.     

Structural mimicry in the phage phi21 N peptide-boxB RNA complex

We determined the solution structure of a 22-amino-acid peptide from the amino-terminal domain of the bacteriophage phi21 N protein in complex with its cognate 24-mer boxB RNA hairpin using heteronuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The N peptide binds as an alpha-helix and interacts predominately with the major groove side of the 5' half of the boxB RNA stem-loop. This binding interface is defined by surface complementarity of polar and nonpolar interactions, and little sequence-specific recognition. The phi21 boxB loop (CUAACC) has hydrogen bond and backbone torsions typical of the "U-turn" motif, as well as base stacking of the last 4 nt, and a hydrogen bonded C:C pair closing the loop. The exposed face of the phi21 boxB loop, in complex with the N peptide, is strikingly similar to the GNRA tetraloop-like folds of the related lambda and P22 bacteriophage N peptide-boxB RNA complexes. The N peptide-boxB complexes of the various phage, while individually distinct, provide similar structural features for interactions with the Escherichia coli host factors to enable antitermination.     

Binding of the Bacteriophage P22 N-Peptide to the boxB RNA Motif Studied by Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Protein-RNA interactions are important for many cellular processes. The Nut-utilization site (N)-protein of bacteriophages contains an N-terminal arginine-rich motif that undergoes a folding transition upon binding to the boxB RNA hairpin loop target structure. Molecular dynamics simulations were used to investigate the dynamics of the P22 N-peptide-boxB complex and to elucidate the energetic contributions to binding. In addition, the free-energy changes of RNA and peptide conformational adaptation to the bound forms, as well as the role of strongly bound water molecules at the peptide-RNA interface, were studied. The influence of peptide amino acid substitutions and the salt dependence of interaction were investigated and showed good agreement with available experimental results. Several tightly bound water molecules were found at the RNA-binding interface in both the presence and absence of N-peptide. Explicit consideration of the waters resulted in shifts of calculated contributions during the energetic analysis, but overall similar binding energy contributions were found. Of interest, it was found that the electrostatic field of the RNA has a favorable influence on the coil-to-α-helix transition of the N-peptide already outside of the peptide-binding site. This result may have important implications for understanding peptide-RNA complex formation, which often involves coupled folding and association processes. It indicates that electrostatic interactions near RNA molecules can lead to a shift in the equilibrium toward the bound form of an interacting partner before it enters the binding pocket.     

Site-specific variations in RNA folding thermodynamics visualized by 2-aminopurine fluorescence

The fluorescent base analogue 2-aminopurine (2-AP) is commonly used to study specific conformational and protein binding events involving nucleic acids. Here, combinations of steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy of 2-AP were employed to monitor conformational transitions within a model hairpin RNA from diverse structural perspectives. RNA substrates adopting stable, unambiguous secondary structures were labeled with 2-AP at an unpaired base, within the loop, or inside the base-paired stem. Steady-state fluorescence was monitored as the RNA hairpins made the transitions between folded and unfolded conformations using thermal denaturation, urea titration, and cation-mediated folding. Unstructured control RNA substrates permitted the effects of higher-order RNA structures on 2-AP fluorescence to be distinguished from stimulus-dependent changes in intrinsic 2-AP photophysics and/or interactions with adjacent residues. Thermodynamic parameters describing local conformational changes were thus resolved from multiple perspectives within the model RNA hairpin. These data provided energetic bases for construction of folding mechanisms, which varied among different folding-unfolding stimuli. Time-resolved fluorescence studies further revealed that 2-AP exhibits characteristic signatures of component fluorescence lifetimes and respective fractional contributions in different RNA structural contexts. Together, these studies demonstrate localized conformational events contributing to RNA folding and unfolding that could not be observed by approaches monitoring only global structural transitions.     

Intrinsic flexibility of snRNA hairpin loops facilitates protein binding

Stem–loop II of U1 snRNA and Stem–loop IV of U2 snRNA typically have 10 or 11 nucleotides in their loops. The fluorescent nucleobase 2-aminopurine was used as a substitute for the adenines in each loop to probe the local and global structures and dynamics of these unusually long loops. Using steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence, we find that, while the bases in the loops are stacked, they are able to undergo significant local motion on the picosecond/nanosecond timescale. In addition, the loops have a global conformational change at low temperatures that occurs on the microsecond timescale, as determined using laser T-jump experiments. Nucleobase and loop motions are present at temperatures far below the melting temperature of the hairpin stem, which may facilitate the conformational change required for specific protein binding to these RNA loops.     

A novel stable RNA pentaloop that interacts specifically with a motif peptide of lambda-N protein

To achieve a novel specific peptide-nucleic acid binding model, we designed an in vitro selection procedure to decrease the energetic contribution of the electrostatic interaction in the total binding energy and to increase the contribution of hydrogen bonding and pi-pi stacking. After the selection of hairpin-loop RNAs that specifically bound to a model peptide of lambda N protein (N peptide), a new thermostable pentaloop RNA motif (N binding thermostable RNA hairpin: NTS RNA) was revealed. The obtained NTS RNA was able to bind to the N peptide with superior specificity to the boxB RNA, which is the naturally occurring partner of the lambda N protein.     

Inherent protein structural flexibility at the RNA-binding interface of L30e

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae ribosomal protein L30 autoregulates its own expression by binding to a purine-rich internal loop in its pre-mRNA and mRNA. NMR studies of L30 and its RNA complex showed that both the internal loop of the RNA as well as a region of the protein become substantially more ordered upon binding. A crystal structure of a maltose binding protein (MBP)-L30 fusion protein with two copies in the asymmetric unit has been determined. The flexible RNA-binding region in the L30 copies has two distinct conformations, one resembles the RNA bound form solved by NMR and the other is unique. Structure prediction algorithms also had difficulty accurately predicting this region, which is consistent with conformational flexibility seen in the NMR and X-ray crystallography studies. Inherent conformational flexibility may be a hallmark of regions involved in intermolecular interactions.     

Changes in the conformation and stability of 5 S RNA upon the binding of ribosomal proteins.

The binding of ribosomal proteins L25, L18, and L5 to 5 S RNA results in a conformational change and a destabilization of the 5 S RNA molecule. The changes observed in the near ultraviolet circular dichroism (CD) spectra and in the melting profiles indicate an increase in base stacking uith an accompanying increase in asymmetry of the bases and a decrease in the conformational stability of the 5 S RNA. These results are consistent with the interpretation that the binding of these proteins increases the stacking of specific single-stranded bases in 5 S RNA and aligns them in helical arrays, resulting in a conformation which facilitates base-pairing with nucleotide segment(s) of the ribosomal 23 S RNA or the transfer RNA (or both). The simple and precise difference CD method described here is potentially useful for studying subtle conformational changes of other nucleic acid-protein interactions.     

Mapping DNA conformations and interactions within the binding cleft of bacteriophage T4 single-stranded DNA binding protein (gp32) at single nucleotide resolution

In this study, we use single-stranded DNA (oligo-dT) lattices that have been position-specifically labeled with monomer or dimer 2-aminopurine (2-AP) probes to map the local interactions of the DNA bases with the nucleic acid binding cleft of gp32, the single-stranded binding (ssb) protein of bacteriophage T4. Three complementary spectroscopic approaches are used to characterize these local interactions of the probes with nearby nucleotide bases and amino acid residues at varying levels of effective protein binding cooperativity, as manipulated by changing lattice length. These include: (i) examining local quenching and enhancing effects on the fluorescence spectra of monomer 2-AP probes at each position within the cleft; (ii) using acrylamide as a dynamic-quenching additive to measure solvent access to monomer 2-AP probes at each ssDNA position; and (iii) employing circular dichroism spectra to characterize changes in exciton coupling within 2-AP dimer probes at specific ssDNA positions within the protein cleft. The results are interpreted in part by what we know about the topology of the binding cleft from crystallographic studies of the DNA binding domain of gp32 and provide additional insights into how gp32 can manipulate the ssDNA chain at various steps of DNA replication and other processes of genome expression.     

RNA aptamers for the MS2 bacteriophage coat protein and the wild-type RNA operator have similar solution behaviour

We have probed the effects of altering buffer conditions on the behaviour of two aptamer RNAs for the bacteriophage MS2 coat protein using site-specific substitution of 2′-deoxy-2-aminopurine nucleotides at key adenosine positions. These have been compared to the wild-type operator stem–loop oligonucleotide, which is the natural target for the coat protein. The fluorescence emission spectra show a position and oligonucleotide sequence dependence which appears to reflect local conformational changes. These are largely similar between the differing oligonucleotides and deviations can be explained by the individual features of each sequence. Recognition by coat protein is enhanced, unaffected or decreased depending on the site of substitution, consistent with the known protein–RNA contacts seen in crystal structures of the complexes. These data suggest that the detailed conformational dynamics of aptamers and wild-type RNA ligands for the same protein target are remarkably similar.