Towards an understanding of the molecular basis of effective RNAi against a global insect pest,the whitefly Bemisia tabaci

In planta RNAi against essential insect genes offers a promising route to control insect crop pests, but is constrained for many insect groups, notably phloem sap-feeding hemipterans, by poor RNAi efficacy. This study conducted on the phloem-feeding whitefly Bemisia tabaci reared on tomato plants investigated the causes of low RNAi efficacy and routes to ameliorate the problem. Experiments using tomato transgenic lines containing ds-GFP (green fluorescent protein) revealed that full-length dsRNA is phloem-mobile, ingested by the insects, and degraded in the insect. We identified B. tabaci homologs of nuclease genes (dsRNases) in other insects that degrade dsRNA, and demonstrated that degradation of ds-GFP in B. tabaci is suppressed by administration of dsRNA against these genes. dsRNA against the nuclease genes was co-administered with dsRNA against two insect genes, an aquaporin AQP1 and sucrase SUC1, that are predicted to protect B. tabaci against osmotic collapse. When dsRNA constructs for AQP1, SUC1, dsRNase1 and dsRNase2 were stacked, insect mortality was significantly elevated to 50% over 6 days on artificial diets. This effect was accompanied by significant reduction in gene expression of the target genes in surviving diet-fed insects. This study offers proof-of-principle that the efficacy of RNAi against insect pests can be enhanced by using dsRNA to suppress the activity of RNAi-suppressing nuclease genes, especially where multiple genes with related physiological function but different molecular function are targeted.     

High mortality caused by high dose of dsRNA in the green rice leafhopper Nephotettix cincticeps (Hemiptera: Cicadellidae)

RNA interference (RNAi) is a useful tool for gene functional studies in non-model insects and pest insects. Establishment of experimental conditions for RNAi, which differ from insect to insect, is important for evaluating the effect of dsRNA injection of relevant genes. When injecting dsRNA into the green rice leafhopper Nephotettix cincticeps (Uhler), high mortality was observed. Therefore, the adverse effects of injection of dsRNA on leafhopper development were examined to assess the suitable conditions for RNAi in this species. Injection manipulation by using a glass capillary did not affect leafhopper survival but delayed the molt of the corresponding instar. High mortality was observed when large amounts of dsRNA were administered. This adverse effect of dsRNA was examined in 2 genes, exogenous EGFP gene and endogenous peptidoglycan recognition protein gene (NcPGRP12). Injection of a high dose (60 ng/insect) caused high mortality in all stages tested: 4th instar, 5th instar, and female adult. A relatively low dose (6 ng/insect) did not cause high mortality, retaining a high potential for gene silencing. Since RNAi is highly effective in this species, the deleterious effect of large amounts of dsRNA could be avoided by administering a low dsRNA dose.     

Exploring systemic RNA interference in insects: a genome-wide survey for RNAi genes in Tribolium

Background

RNA interference (RNAi) is a highly conserved cellular mechanism. In some organisms, such as Caenorhabditis elegans, the RNAi response can be transmitted systemically. Some insects also exhibit a systemic RNAi response. However, Drosophila, the leading insect model organism, does not show a robust systemic RNAi response, necessitating another model system to study the molecular mechanism of systemic RNAi in insects.

Results

We used Tribolium, which exhibits robust systemic RNAi, as an alternative model system. We have identified the core RNAi genes, as well as genes potentially involved in systemic RNAi, from the Tribolium genome. Both phylogenetic and functional analyses suggest that Tribolium has a somewhat larger inventory of core component genes than Drosophila, perhaps allowing a more sensitive response to double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). We also identified three Tribolium homologs of C. elegans sid-1, which encodes a possible dsRNA channel. However, detailed sequence analysis has revealed that these Tribolium homologs share more identity with another C. elegans gene, tag-130. We analyzed tag-130 mutants, and found that this gene does not have a function in systemic RNAi in C. elegans. Likewise, the Tribolium sid-like genes do not seem to be required for systemic RNAi. These results suggest that insect sid-1-like genes have a different function than dsRNA uptake. Moreover, Tribolium lacks homologs of several genes important for RNAi in C. elegans.

Conclusion

Although both Tribolium and C. elegans show a robust systemic RNAi response, our genome-wide survey reveals significant differences between the RNAi mechanisms of these organisms. Thus, insects may use an alternative mechanism for the systemic RNAi response. Understanding this process would assist with rendering other insects amenable to systemic RNAi, and may influence pest control approaches.     

Systemic gene knockdown in Camponotus floridanus workers by feeding of dsRNA

RNA interference (RNAi) technology enables to study specific gene functions also in social insects, which are otherwise difficult to access for genetic manipulations. The recent sequencing of the genomes from seven ant species made these members of the Formicidae available for knockdown studies. However, for this purpose the RNAi technology first needs to be adapted for application in ants. Studies on other insects show that the effectiveness of RNAi is quite species-specific and can depend on several experimental parameters such as the investigated stage of the insect, the target gene and/or the dsRNA delivery method. RNAi in ants through feeding of dsRNA is a preferable approach, since knockdown can be achieved in individuals without interfering with the animal’s physiology in contrast to injection of dsRNA. Here, we present a protocol for gene knockdown in Formicidae by feeding of dsRNA to worker animals. The expression of a peptidoglycan recognition protein gene, PGRP-LB, was efficiently knocked down in the body of Camponotus floridanus worker ants. Moreover, we describe a relatively cheap method to extract dsRNA from bacteria in order to obtain large quantities needed for feeding experiments.     

Enhancement of Larval RNAi Efficiency by Over-expressing Argonaute2 in Bombyx mori

RNA interference has been described as a powerful genetic tool for gene functional analysis and a promising approach for pest management. However, RNAi efficiency varies significantly among insect species due to distinct RNAi machineries. Lepidopteran insects include a large number of pests as well as model insects, such as the silkworm, Bombyx mori. However, only limited success of in vivo RNAi has been reported in lepidoptera, particularly during the larval stages when the worms feed the most and do the most harm to the host plant. Enhancing the efficiency of larval RNAi in lepidoptera is urgently needed to develop RNAi-based pest management strategies. In the present study, we investigate the function of the conserved RNAi core factor, Argonaute2 (Ago2), in mediating B. mori RNAi efficiency. We demonstrate that introducing BmAgo2 dsRNA inhibits the RNAi response in both BmN cells and embryos. Furthermore, we establish several transgenic silkworm lines to assess the roles of BmAgo2 in larval RNAi. Over-expressing BmAgo2 significantly facilitated both dsRNA-mediated larval RNAi when targeting DsRed using dsRNA injection and shRNA-mediated larval RNAi when targeting BmBlos2 using transgenic shRNA expression. Our results show that BmAgo2 is involved in RNAi in B. mori and provides a promising approach for improving larval RNAi efficiency in B. mori and in lepidopteran insects in general.     

昆虫RNAi通路及其核心元件的研究综述

RNAi作为分子生物学的一种重要技术,在昆虫基因功能和功能基因组研究中得到广泛应用,同时,有关昆虫RNAi的机制也受到了大家的关注。近年来的研究结果表明,昆虫RNAi的通路与其他动物相同,根据引起基因沉默的RNA分子的类型,可以分为siRNA、miRNA和piRNA 3种不同的通路。昆虫RNAi通路中的核心元件包括了:(1)行使切割作用的RNaseⅢ家族成员Drosha和Dicer;(2)用来降解目的 mRNA的Argonaute蛋白;(3)dsRNA结合蛋白Pasha、R2D2和Loquacious。了解昆虫RNAi的通路及其核心元件,有助于我们更好地理解昆虫RNAi的分子机制和改进实现RNAi的方法,对促进昆虫RNAi技术的研究及其在害虫防控中的应用具有指导意义。     

Functions of duplicated genes encoding CCAP receptors in the red flour beetle, Tribolium castaneum

Crustacean cardioactive peptide (CCAP) is a nonapeptide originally isolated from the shore crab, Carcinus maenas, based on its cardioacceleratory activity. This peptide is highly conserved in insects and other arthropods. In insects CCAP also has an essential role in ecdysis behavior. We previously identified two homologous genes, ccapr-1 and ccapr-2, encoding putative CCAP receptors in the red flour beetle, Tribolium castaneum. In contrast, some insects, including Drosophila melanogaster, carry only one gene encoding a CCAP receptor. Phylogenetic analysis of putative CCAP receptor orthologs reveals a number of independent gene duplications in several insect lineages. In this study, we confirmed that CCAP activates both putative T. castaneum receptors in a heterologous expression system. RNA interference (RNAi) of ccapr-1 and ccapr-2 revealed that ccapr-2 is essential for eclosion behavior in T. castaneum, while RNAi for ccapr-1 did not result in any abnormal phenotype. In vivo cardioacceleratory activity of exogenously applied CCAP was abolished by RNAi of ccapr-2, but not by that of ccapr-1. Thus, only ccapr-2 mediates the cardioacceleratory function, ccapr-1 having apparently lost both functions for eclosion behavior and for cardioacceleration since the recent gene duplication event.     

even-skipped is not a pair-rule gene but has segmental and gap-like functions in Oncopeltus fasciatus, an intermediate germband insect

The pair-rule gene even-skipped is required for the initiation of metameric pattern in Drosophila. But Drosophila segmentation is evolutionarily derived and is not representative of most insects. Therefore, in order to shed light on the evolution of insect segmentation, homologs of the pair-rule gene even-skipped have been studied in several insect taxa. However, most of these studies have reported the expression eve but not its function. We report the isolation, expression and function of the homolog of Drosophila even-skipped from the intermediate germband insect Oncopeltus fasciatus. We find that in Oncopeltus, even-skipped striped expression initiates in a segmental and not pair-rule pattern. Weak RNAi suppression of Oncopeltus even-skipped shows no apparent pair-rule like phenotype, while stronger RNAi suppression shows deletion of nearly the entire body. These results suggest that in Oncopeltus, even-skipped is not acting as a pair-rule gene. In almost all insects, prior to its striped expression, even-skipped is expressed in a conserved broad gap-like domain but its function has been largely ignored. We find that this early broad domain is required for activation of the gap genes hunchback and Krüppel. Given the large RNAi deletion phenotype and its regulation of hunchback and Krüppel, even-skipped seems to act as an über-gap gene in Oncopeltus, indicating that it may have both upstream and downstream roles in segmentation.     

Sensitivity to RNA interference-mediated gene silencing in intact and ligated larvae of the armyworm, Mythimna separata (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

RNA interference (RNAi) is a common tool for analysis of gene function in both model and non-model insects, but it is becoming evident that RNAi efficiency varies considerably from species to species. We examined RNAi efficiency in larvae of the armyworm Mythimna separata (Walker) using multiple genes and tissues. First, we showed that five different target genes exhibited distinct tissue distribution patterns by quantitative determination of mRNA in total hemocytes, foregut, midgut, hindgut, Malpighian tubules and fat body: neuroglian mRNA was most abundant in fat body; inhibitor of apoptosis proteins mRNA was found to be ubiquitous; aquaporin 4 mRNA was most enriched in hindgut; cueball and prophenoloxidase 2 were mainly expressed in hemocytes. Second, we assessed sensitivity to gene silencing by double-strand RNA injection of these five genes in the six different tissues. We found that these genes generally showed refractoriness to double-strand RNA-mediated gene knockdown irrespective of the tissue tested. Finally, we demonstrated that appreciable gene knockdown was achieved at least in the adhering hemocyte fraction when larval isolated abdomen was prepared by ligation and subjected to dsRNA injection. Our study thus added detailed information on the refractoriness of larval tissues of a lepidopteran insect to gene silencing through RNAi and provided a new potential approach to improve RNAi efficiency.     

The advent of RNA interference in Entomology

RNA interference (RNAi) is a cellular process by which an mRNA is targeted for degradation by a small interfering RNA that contains a strand complementary to a fragment of the target mRNA, resulting in sequence specific inhibition of gene expression. The discovery of RNAi enabled the use of loss‐of‐function analyses in many non‐model insects other than Drosophila to elucidate the roles of specific genes. The RNAi approach has been widely used on insects in several fields, including embryogenesis, pattern formation, reproduction, biosynthesis and behavior. The increasing availability of insect genomes has made the RNAi technique an indispensable technique for characterizing gene functions in insects. Here we review the current status of RNAi‐based experiments in insects and the applications of RNAi for species‐specific insecticides, focusing on non‐drosophilid insects. We also identify future applications for RNAi‐based studies in Entomology.     

Lipids help double-stranded RNA in endosomal escape and improve RNA interference in the fall armyworm,Spodoptera frugiperda

RNA interference (RNAi) is a valuable method for understanding the gene function and holds great potential for insect pest management. While RNAi is efficient and systemic in coleopteran insects, RNAi is inefficient in lepidopteran insects. In this study, we explored the possibility of improving RNAi in the fall armyworm (FAW), Spodoptera frugiperda cells by formulating dsRNA with Cellfectin II (CFII) transfection reagent. The CFII formulated dsRNA was protected from degradation by endonucleases present in Sf9 cells conditioned medium, hemolymph and midgut lumen contents collected from the FAW larvae. Lipid formulated dsRNA also showed reduced accumulation in the endosomes of Sf9 cells and FAW tissues. Exposing Sf9 cells and tissues to CFII formulated dsRNA caused a significant knockdown of endogenous genes. CFII formulated dsIAP fed to FAW larvae induced knockdown of iap gene, growth retardation and mortality. Processing of dsRNA into siRNA was detected in Sf9 cells and Spodoptera frugiperda larvae treated with CFII conjugated ³²P-UTP labeled dsGFP. Overall, the present study concluded that delivering dsRNA formulated with CFII transfection reagent helps dsRNA escapes from the endosomal accumulation and improved RNAi efficiency in the FAW cells and tissues.     

Mechanisms of dsRNA uptake in insects and potential of RNAi for pest control: A review

RNA interference already proved its usefulness in functional genomic research on insects, but it also has considerable potential for the control of pest insects. For this purpose, the insect should be able to autonomously take up the dsRNA, for example through feeding and digestion in its midgut. In this review we bring together current knowledge on the uptake mechanisms of dsRNA in insects and the potential of RNAi to affect pest insects. At least two pathways for dsRNA uptake in insects are described: the transmembrane channel-mediated uptake mechanism based on Caenorhabditis elegans’ SID-1 protein and an ‘alternative’ endocytosis-mediated uptake mechanism. In the second part of the review dsRNA feeding experiments on insects are brought together for the first time, highlighting the achievement of implementing RNAi in insect control with the first successful experiments in transgenic plants and the diversity of successfully tested insect orders/species and target genes. We conclude with points of discussion and concerns regarding further research on dsRNA uptake mechanisms and the promising application possibilities for RNAi in insect control.     

RNAi技术在昆虫学中的研究进展及展望

在昆虫中,RNAi是一种对抗外源病毒的天然免疫方式,基于生物体中的这种内在机制而建立的RNAi技术已经被广泛用来研究多种昆虫基因的功能。近年的研究结果表明RNAi技术在抵御害虫和防治益虫疾病方面具有潜在的应用价值,有可能对农业有害生物的控制起到巨大的推动作用。本文综述了RNAi与昆虫免疫、及其在昆虫基因功能研究、害虫控制、益虫疾病控制和昆虫系统生物学方面的最新研究进展,并展望了RNAi在昆虫学研究中的发展趋势。     

昆虫的RNA干扰

RNA干扰(RNAi)是一种强有力的分子生物学技术, 在昆虫研究中得到了较多的应用。目前, RNAi技术主要应用于昆虫功能基因和功能基因组研究, 已在多个目的19种昆虫上实现了RNAi。在昆虫上实现RNAi的方法主要有注射、浸泡、喂食、转基因和病毒介导等方法, 这些方法各有特点, 其中喂食法因其简单而最有应用前景。昆虫RNAi的系统性较为复杂, 只有部分昆虫具有RNAi的系统性。昆虫中RNAi信号传导的基因可能是sid-1, 但昆虫RNAi的系统性机理还不是很清楚。转基因植物产生的dsRNA实现了对作物的保护, 证实了RNAi技术可用于害虫控制, 为害虫控制开辟了新领域。昆虫的RNAi研究处在起步阶段, 研究昆虫RNAi的机理, 特别是RNAi在昆虫体内的系统性扩散机理, 改进实现RNAi的方法, 提高RNAi技术在昆虫研究中的应用, 有利于昆虫基因功能鉴定和害虫控制, 促进昆虫学科的发展。     

Advanced technologies for genetically manipulating the silkworm Bombyx mori,a model Lepidopteran insect

Genetic technologies based on transposon-mediated transgenesis along with several recently developed genome-editing technologies have become the preferred methods of choice for genetically manipulating many organisms. The silkworm, Bombyx mori, is a Lepidopteran insect of great economic importance because of its use in silk production and because it is a valuable model insect that has greatly enhanced our understanding of the biology of insects, including many agricultural pests. In the past 10 years, great advances have been achieved in the development of genetic technologies in B. mori, including transposon-based technologies that rely on piggyBac-mediated transgenesis and genome-editing technologies that rely on protein- or RNA-guided modification of chromosomes. The successful development and application of these technologies has not only facilitated a better understanding of B. mori and its use as a silk production system, but also provided valuable experiences that have contributed to the development of similar technologies in non-model insects. This review summarizes the technologies currently available for use in B. mori, their application to the study of gene function and their use in genetically modifying B. mori for biotechnology applications. The challenges, solutions and future prospects associated with the development and application of genetic technologies in B. mori are also discussed.