Differential effects of moving versus stationary territorial intruders on territory defence in a songbird

1.  In territorial contests, not only acoustic or other signals, but also the movements of a territorial intruder are likely to influence the response of a resident.
2.  We tested this movement hypothesis by simulating moving vs. stationary intruders into the territories of winter wrens Troglodytes troglodytes , using the same non-interactive song playbacks in both treatments.
3.  Male winter wrens showed a different long-term singing reaction in response to a moving than to a stationary intruder.
4.  One day after experiencing an intruder that was switching between three locations, residents started to sing earlier before sunrise, and they sang more and longer songs at dawn than before the intrusion.
5.  Residents receiving the same playback from one location only reacted by starting to sing later relative to sunrise, and by singing fewer and shorter songs than before the intrusion.
6.  We could not discriminate between the treatments when examining the short-term singing reactions during and immediately after the playbacks. However, our results clearly demonstrate an effect of the spatial behaviour of territorial intruders on the long-term territory defence of residents at dawn, about 24 h after an intrusion.
7.  We argue that spatial behaviour of territorial intruders should be an integral part of the study of animal territory defence behaviour. Investigating long-term changes in territory defence at dawn is a sensitive tool for discriminating between different types of intruders.     

Effects of resource distribution on activity and territory defence in house mice, Mus domesticus

How much an animal invests in defending a territory depends, in part, on the quality, quantity and distribution of resources, but do animals target their investment in defence within the territory according to the location of different resources? We examined whether wild-caught male and female house mice increased aggression towards intruders of the same or opposite sex when in areas containing their food/water or nest site. Pairs of resident mice were established in enclosures consisting of two areas. In split enclosures, food and water were in one area and a nest site in the other, while in clumped enclosures all resources were in one area with no resources in the other. Residents of both sexes were quicker to attack intruders, and were more aggressive, in areas containing resources than in an area containing no resources. There was no difference in aggression between areas containing food/water, a nest site or both. The effect of resources on territorial defence was due largely to changes in aggression against intruders of the opposite sex. Residents, especially males, attacked intruders of their own sex more than those of the opposite sex. This bias was much stronger when no resources were present, owing to low aggression against opposite-sex intruders in the absence of resources. There were no differences in intruder aggression, and the relative size of the intruder (heavier or lighter than the resident) had no effect on resident aggression. Residents also spent less time out of their nest in clumped enclosures owing to low activity in the nonresource area.     

Territory Area as a Determinant of Mating Systems

Territoriality is an integral part of breeding behavior in manyanimals. Because the reproductive success of territorial malesis often limited by access to females, breeding males shouldbehave as "area maximizers" when the basis of female choiceis either the abundance of resources within the territory orterritory area per se. Being reproductively more limited byenergy, territorial females should be "energy maximizers." Aseries of simple analytical models of territory area for suchforagers is developed to explore how changes in local food productionand/or local competitor density affect both the probabilityof a territorial male securing more than one mate (polygyny)and the probability of his and his mates' reproductive successincreasing. Two cases are modeled (only males territorial vs.both sexes territorial), each for various sets of assumptionsregarding interactions between food production, feeding efficiency,and competitor density. Concurrent responses in territory area,territory food reserves, net energy gain, and time budgetingprovide testable sets of predictions for each scenario. Whereonly males are territorial (Case I), changes in food productioncan have different (indeed, opposite) effects upon an individualmale's probability of becoming polygynous, depending upon whetherthe basis of female choice is the abundance of food within theterritory or another factor positively correlated with territoryarea. Increases in competitor density usually decrease the probabilityof polygyny regardless of the basis of female choice. Whereboth sexes are territorial and territories overlap intersexually(Case II), the mating system becomes a function of the numberof female territories within each male's territory, which varieswith the ratio of male to female territory areas. In this case,the probability of polygyny occurring will increase if foodproduction for both sexes increases without concurrent increasesin competitor density, and will decrease if competitor densityfor both sexes increases without concurrent increases in feedingefficiency. Few data are presently available to test eitherthese general predictions or numerous sets of secondary predictionstabulated in the text. Available evidence is largely consistentwith the models, but mostly circumstantial. This is becausethe predictions of these and other models of territory areaare strongly assumption dependent, and few published studieshave investigated these assumptions. These analyses demonstratethat to accurately assess the mechanisms by which environmentalfactors affect territory area, and thus mating systems, testsof the underlying assumptions of models are essential.     

Defence, intrusion and the evolutionary stability of territoriality

Territorial behaviour can only be adaptive if its costs are outweighed by its benefits. Territorial individuals incur costs by defending their territories against intruders. Usually these intruders are assumed to be non-territorial floaters attempting to take over the whole territory or neighbours trying to extend the borders of their own territory. We instead investigate how costs and benefits of territorial behaviour are affected by neighbours which invade to steal resources on a territory.We show analytically that in the absence of defence intrusion into neighbouring territories always pays and that even if territories are defended intrusion levels can still be high. Using a more detailed simulation model we find that territory defence usually disappears from the population even if owners have a strong advantage over intruders in terms of fighting costs or foraging efficiency. Defence and thus territoriality can only be evolutionarily stable if fighting costs for the intruder relative to the productivity of the territory are very high or if crossing the borders between territories carries additional costs.Our results show that stealing of resources by neighbours can have a considerable effect on the evolutionary stability of territory defence and thus territoriality itself. A more mechanistic model of territorial behaviour is needed to incorporate these kinds of mechanisms into a general theory on the evolution of territoriality.     

Determinants of territory size of the dusky gregory

To test the effect of food abundance and intruder pressure as determinants of territory size, the dusky gregory Stegastes nigricans were used as subjects on a coral reef in southern Taiwan during November to December 2000. Adults were used as intruders to provoke aggressiveness in a conspecific territory owner. The owner's maximum distance of attack (MDA) was used to delineate the territory size. While the owner of a territory appeared to defend a single boundary against different conspecifics, size variations among territories were evident. The effect of an intruder's identity on territory‐size regulation was not clear because for each territory examined, the MDA was found to be neither linked to the body size of the intruder nor to the amount of algae in the intruder's territory. Moreover, no significant differences were found between the MDAs that the owner maintained against neighbours and non‐neighbours even though, when conspecifics intruded in pairs, the probability was significantly higher for the first attack to be launched on a neighbour than on a non‐neighbour. Also when a neighbour and a non‐neighbour appeared simultaneously near the territory, the bite rate against the neighbour was also significantly higher. An inverse relationship between the amount of algae in the defended territory and the MDA of the owner indicates that food abundance might account for variations among territories. By contrast, territory size was not linked to the body size of the owner.     

An energy-based model of optimal feeding-territory size

An energy-based model of feeding territoriality is described. The model predicts an optimal territory size where the territory holder's net energy intake is maximized, on a daily or seasonal time scale. Simulated effects on optimal territory size of animal size, food availability, and competitor density are in general agreement with observed relationships in a wide variety of animals. When salmonid data are used to estimate the model parameter values, predicted territory sizes are similar to those actually observed. When emigration is allowed, the model predicts that territoriality, through individual selection alone, can regulate population size, but that this regulation breaks down when initial densities exceed some threshold value. Sensitivity analysis shows optimal territory size to be most affected by those parameters influencing food intake and energy expenditure. Some alternative criteria for optimization are also discussed. An animal maximizing net foraging efficiency has a smaller territory than one maximizing net energy, but the effects of animal size, food availability, and competitor density on territory size are the same in either case.     

The relative importance of prey availability and intruder pressure in feeding territory size regulation by harriers,Circus cyaneus

Summary The relative importance of prey availability and intruder pressure in the regulation of harrier (Circus cyaneus) territory size was investigated over two years using analytical methods chosen to permit comparison with Myers et al. (1979) study of sanderlings (Calidris alba). Relationships between territory area and two variables, prey type (mice; large, medium, and small birds) and intruder type (conspecific neighbors, conspecific floaters, and heterospecific floaters), and the consistency of these relationships between years, also were examined. Individual harrier territory areas were highly variable, ranging from 7.8 to 1249 ha in 1984/1985, and 3.9 to 71.3 ha in 1985/1986. Of the prey variables, only mouse availability was significantly inversely correlated with territory area in both years, and slopes resulting from correlations between the logarithms of these two variables did not differ significantly from — 1, the expected result if harriers were adjusting mouse availabilities. The abundance of mice in conjunction with their greater ease of capture relative to birds made them functionally more available, and hence harriers' primary prey. This may explain why mice, rather than birds, were apparently the defended resource. Of the intruder variables, neighbor variables were most strongly inversely cortelatd with territory area. Partial correlation analyses to determine the relative importance of intruder pressure and prey availability in regulating territory size revealed that in 1984/1985, mouse availability and intruder pressure were relatively independent and each explained some variation in territory area, whereas in 1985/1986, mouse availability, rather than intruder pressure, significantly explained all variation in territory area. Possible explanations for why territory sizes of harriers appear to be regulated more closely by food density, whereas territory sizes of sanderlings appear to be regulated more closely by intruder pressure, are based upon differences in 1) neighbor effects, 2) environmental ronmental variability, and 3) accuracy of resource assessment by intruders. The variation in intruder rates and prey availabilities observed between years suggests the need to conduct studies over several years in order to assess accurately the relative importance of these variables in territory-size regulation.     

Depth-related differences in territory size and defense in the herbivorous cichlid,neolamprologus moorii, in lake tanganyika

Neolamprologus moorii, a small herbivorous cichlid of Lake Tanganyika, defends its territory against food competitors. Territory size and territorial defense were compared between two sites at different depths. In the shallow site, more fishes intruded into the territories than in the deep site, owing to the higher density fish population in the former. The territory holders in the shallow site attacked intruders more often, although the ratio of attacks to number of intruders was similar to that of the deep site. The territories in the deep site were larger and contained a greater amount of algae than the shallow site. The larger territory size in the deep site may have resulted from the lower cost of territory defense due to the lower competitor density and from the need to maintain a greater amount of food resources to compensate for lower algal productivity.     

Feeding Territoriality in Aquatic Insects: Cost-Benefit Models and Experimental Tests

Two points are evident from a review of the literature describingfeeding territoriality in aquatic insects. First, feeding territorialityis much more common in this group than was previously recognized.Second, most of the examples involve species that have smallforaging areas and harvest rapidly renewing resources, suchas filterable particles and attached microalgae. To interpretthese patterns, I discuss how the net benefits of territorialdefense vary as a function of several components of food availability. I present the results of recent laboratory and field experimentstesting cost-benefit models that predict patterns of territorysize and defense frequency. Feeding-territory size in grazingcaddisfly larvae increases with the resident's body size andis inversely related to food abundance, which agrees with thepredictions of several models of optimal territory size. Twokinds of stream insects that rely on food items delivered bywater currents (i.e., surface-feeding water striders and filter-feedinglarval black flies) respond to increases in food abundance byreducing their allocation of time to territorial defense.Inblack flies, complex interactions between competitor densityand food abundance also influence the amount of time spent defendinga territory. I consider several connections between territorial behaviorand interspecific competition. The distribution and abundanceof both territorial species and their competitors may dependin part upon how the costs and benefits of feeding territorialityvary along resource abundance gradients. The tendency of someterritorial grazers to settle preferentially near conspecificsmay occur because animals living in groups exclude interspecificcompetitors more efficiently than isolated individuals, whichsuggests some simple tests of optimal group size models. I conclude by summarizing the strengths and weaknesses of thesestudy systems, both as a source of new and broader theoriesof feeding territoriality, and as a testing ground for thosetheories. An important strength of these consumer-resource systemsis the ability to conduct realistic experimental studies examiningthe causes and consequences of territoriality. One importantweakness is the lack of information on the time-energy budgetsof these insects. The acquisition of such information deservesa high priority, since it will permit more rigorous tests ofcost-benefit models that evaluate the adaptive significanceof territorial behavior.     

Male and female cooperatively breeding fish provide support for the "Challenge Hypothesis"

The idea that territorial aggression is regulated by androgensand that aggression itself can modulate androgen levels is wellestablished in males. In many species, females also displayaggressive behavior, yet little work has been conducted on theeffects of female aggression on hormone levels. In this study,we compared the effects of a simulated territory intrusion (amethod for testing the Challenge Hypothesis) on males and femalesof the fish, Neolamprologus pulcher. This cichlid fish fromLake Tanganyika is a particularly useful species to examinesex differences in the behavioral mediation of hormones as breedingpairs remain in a territory year round and both sexes defendthis territory against conspecific and heterospecific intruders.In our study, both sexes indeed aggressively defended theirterritory against a simulated territory intruder. In responseto intruders, both males and females displayed elevated levelsof circulating 11-ketotestosterone, but only females exhibitedincreases in testosterone. Neither aggressing male nor femalefish showed changes in estradiol levels compared to control(nonaggressing) fish. Residents were more aggressive than theintruders and won most of the interactions. However, residents(or winners) did not show higher hormone levels than intruders(or losers). We suggest that aggression commonly modulates androgenlevels in both male and female teleost fish.     

Experimental analysis of territory size in a population of the fire ant Solenopsis invicta

Alternative models of territoriality are based on contrastingassumptions about the behavioral processes determining territorysize. In a series of controlled field experiments on the fireant Solenopsis invicta, I tested whether territory size is affectedby the availability of food, as predicted by most economic models,and whether territory size is affected by fighting ability,as predicted by models of competition among neighbors. Abundantfood was offered for 30–35 days to selected colonies eitherimmediately next to the nest (experiment 1) or at peripheralsites near the territory boundary (experiment 2). These foodsupplements had no detectable effect on territory size. Furthermore,food placed near the periphery of the territory did not significantlyalter local boundary positions. During both experiments, largecolonies lost more territory than did small colonies, reflectingtemporary declines in worker number due to the seasonal productionof reproductives. Such losses by large colonies during the summermonths create opportunities for newly founded colonies to expandterritories. In a third experiment, colonies from which workerswere removed lost significantly more territory than did unmanipulatedcontrols. These results show that territory areas in S. invictaare strongly affected by the relative fighting ability of neighboringcolonies but provide no evidence that colonies adjust territoryarea in response to short-term changes in the availability offood.     

Some effects of energy costs on foraging strategies

We consider the effect of including energy costs on the optimal strategy for animals exploiting a depleting food resource. In the context of central place foraging this leads to the problem of what load size should be brought back to the central place. Two strategies are discussed: (i) maximize gross rate of energy delivery and (ii) maximize net rate of energy delivery. The optimal load size (or optimal patch time) for net maximizers is not always larger than for gross maximizers, as has been claimed. Instead, the difference in optimal load size has the same sign as the difference between metabolic rates of travelling and foraging. We point out that the influence of costs has not always been correctly incorporated in experimental tests of the theory.     

Landmark Territoriality in the Neotropical Paper Wasps Polistes canadensis (L.) and P. carnifex (F.) (Hymenoptera: Vespidae)

Male Polistes canadensis and P. carnifex aggregate along crests of prominent ridges in Santa Rosa National Park, Costa Rica. At these sites males of both species defend territories (trees and shrubs) by chasing conspecific rivals. Territories do not contain nests or resources that are collected by females. Chasing by territorial males reduces the amount of time spent by intruders in a territory. I describe and contrast male territorial behavior of both species. Some male P. canadensis are territorial while others in the same area exhibit patrolling behavior, flying from one occupied territory to another. Males of P. carnifex exhibit territoriality only. Patrolling in P. canadensis is an outcome of relatively high male density along the ridge, rendering territories in short supply, as shown by the observation that experimentally vacated territories are seized rapidly by formerly patrolling males. Due to a high intraspecific intrusion rate, territorial male P. canadensis spend less time perching and more time flying and chasing intruders from their territories than do male P. carnifex. Males of these two species also differ in the placement of their territories along the ridgeline; P. canadensis occupy territories in saddles while P. carnifex occupy those at peaktops. I show that this divergent spatial pattern is not maintained by competitive exclusion of either species by the other, and I discuss alternative explanations for their separate spatial distributions. Comparative data suggest that males are territorial because females restrict matings to within territories, and I discuss alternative hypotheses to explain this bias in female behavior.     

Territorial behaviour in an Australian nectar-feeding bird

The red wattlebird, a large Australian honey eater, defends feeding territories from other nectar-feeding birds. One such territory decreased in size and experienced fewer intruders as the density of flowers increased. Daily energy production from the nectar in the territory closely approximated the energy requirements of the territory holder. The bird was probably minimizing energetic costs rather than maximizing energy intake.     

Brood defence and parental roles in a biparental cichlid fishLamprologus toae in Lake Tanganyika

Brood defence of a cichlid fish,Lamprologus toae, was investigated in its natural habitat in Lake Tanganyika. Both parents guarding a brood attacked both conspecific and heterospecific intruder fishes at different locations. The heterospecific intruder fishes could be classified into three groups on the basis of the locations at which the attacks against each species took place. The distinction of groups by the parents seemed to be primarily based on food habits and feeding behaviour of the intruder fishes. The piscivorous species which were more dangerous for the brood were attacked by both parents at more distant locations from the brood. Parental defence of breeding territory changed with the development of the young. The frequency of attacks against each group decreased after the young reached the size too large for the fishes of the group to prey on. Division of labour in the territorial defence was recognized between male and female. The male parent mainly defended the peripheral region of the territory and the female parent defended the inner region. Significance of the selective attack against intruders and the division of labour between the two sexes in brood defence is discussed.     

Snowshoe hare optimal foraging and its implications for population dynamics

The results of an optimal foraging model using linear programming with constraints for feeding time, digestive capacity, sodium requirements, and energy requirements indicate that snowshoe hare (Lepus americanus) may forage as energy maximizers. The solution provides the quantities of major food classes (leaves, herbs, fungus, twigs) included in the diet. The species composition of each diet class also is determined using a simultaneous search model based upon the probability of encounter, the probability of sufficient item size, and the probability of sufficient quality. The results also indicate that hare life history parameters (weaning size, size at first reproduction, average adult size) and potential demographic changes in hare populations may be controlled by foraging considerations.     

The Effect of Variability on the Optimal Size of a Feeding Territory

Previous empirical and theoretical work has focused on how feedingterritory size is governed by average levels of food availabilityand intrusion pressure; the potentially important effects ofvariability have not yet been studied in detail. Here I incorporatevariation in food availability and intrusion pressure in somesimple optimality models of territory size. The results showthat the possible effects of variability are diverse, includingboth increase and decrease in territory size. And in some cases,variation in food availability produces qualitatively differenteffects than variation in intrusion pressure.     

Calling as an ownership convention on pied wagtail territories

Winter feeding territories were more profitable to owners than intruders. Even when intruders landed on a territory undetected they failed to achieve a profitable feeding rate because they fed in areas recently depleted by the owner. For intruders therefore, ownership was a sign of unprofitability. Intruder scalled ‘chis-ick’, apparently to find out if a territory was occupied. Owners replied ‘chee-wee’ and this was usually sufficient to cause the intruder to retreat. Only owners called ‘chee-wee’. Owners reacted more aggressively to tape-recorded broadcasts of the ‘chee-wee’ call played on their territory than to broadcasts of ‘chis-ick’.     

Behavioral, physiological, and endocrine responses of starlings to acute increases in density

One potential stressor to vertebrates both in the wild and in captivity is the presence of numerous individuals in a confined space. To examine the effects of increased conspecific density in birds, we simultaneously measured cardiac, behavioral, and endocrine responses of European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris) to acute crowding. A cage containing a resident bird was outfitted with a trap door that allowed for the introduction of intruder birds (one, three, or five birds) without human interference. The resident bird was implanted with a subcutaneous heart rate (HR) transmitter, behavior was videotaped through a two-way mirror, and blood samples were taken at the end of each treatment to determine plasma corticosterone (CORT) concentrations. Resident starlings significantly increased both general activity and aggressive behaviors while decreasing preening following the initiation of elevated conspecific density. Intruder starlings increased feeding, drinking, and aggressive pecking rates, but postintrusion feeding rates decreased as intruder number increased. Preening decreased in both residents and intruders following the intrusion. HR increased in the resident starlings at the time of intruder introduction, with an increase in the magnitude of this response directly correlating with increasing intruder number. The CORT response to increased density was dependent on social role (resident or intruder), since increasing density did not alter CORT levels in resident birds, but resulted in elevated CORT 30 min following the five-intruder introduction in the intruder birds. Together, these data suggest that increased conspecific density is a significant acute stressor in starlings which is capable of inducing aggression in both residents and intruders. Furthermore, it elicits different responses from different physiological and behavioral systems, and behavioral responses such as feeding and general activity may be density-dependent. The data specifically illustrate that cardiac and behavioral activation can be independent of CORT release, and the CORT response of starlings to increased conspecific density is dependent on social role and degree of the increase in density.