Ihh signaling is directly required for the osteoblast lineage in the endochondral skeleton

Indian hedgehog (Ihh) is indispensable for development of the osteoblast lineage in the endochondral skeleton. In order to determine whether Ihh is directly required for osteoblast differentiation, we have genetically manipulated smoothened (Smo), which encodes a transmembrane protein that is essential for transducing all Hedgehog (Hh) signals. Removal of Smo from perichondrial cells by the Cre-LoxP approach prevents formation of a normal bone collar and also abolishes development of the primary spongiosa. Analysis of chimeric embryos composed of wild-type and Smo(n/n) cells indicates that Smo(n/n) cells fail to contribute to osteoblasts in either the bone collar or the primary spongiosa but generate ectopic chondrocytes. In order to assess whether Ihh is sufficient to induce bone formation in vivo, we have analyzed the bone collar in the long bones of embryos in which Ihh was artificially expressed in all chondrocytes by the UAS-GAL4 bigenic system. Although ectopic Ihh does not induce overt ossification along the entire cartilage anlage, it promotes progression of the bone collar toward the epiphysis, suggesting a synergistic effect between ectopic Ihh and endogenous factors such as the bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). In keeping with this model, Hh signaling is further found to be required in BMP-induced osteogenesis in cultures of a limb-bud cell line. Taken together, these results demonstrate that Ihh signaling is directly required for the osteoblast lineage in the developing long bones and that Ihh functions in conjunction with other factors such as BMPs to induce osteoblast differentiation. We suggest that Ihh acts in vivo on a potential progenitor cell to promote osteoblast and prevent chondrocyte differentiation.     

肥大软骨细胞特异性表达Cre重组酶转基因小鼠的建立

肥大软骨细胞是软骨细胞的终末分化形式,在软骨内成骨过程中发挥十分关键的作用。为了研究肥大软骨细胞在骨骼发育过程中的功能,我们构建了在8.2 kb小鼠X型胶原基因（Col10a1）启动子控制下表达Cre重组酶的转基因小鼠品系（Col10a1-8.2-Cre）。采用显微注射法将11.5 kb的转基因片段引入小鼠基因组,共注射受精卵328枚,获得子代鼠51只,经PCR基因型鉴定有3只在基因组上整合有Cre重组酶基因。PCR检测发现Col10a1-8.2-Cre转基因在含有肥大软骨细胞的组织中表达。为了检测Cre重组酶表达的强度和组织特异性,转基因小鼠与ROSA26报告小鼠交配。子代ROSA26;Col10a1-8.2-Cre双转基因小鼠LacZ染色检测的结果显示,Cre重组酶在所有的肥大软骨细胞中表达。原位杂交的结果验证Col10a1-8.2-Cre转基因表达在肥大区的上端。以上结果表明,我们建立的肥大软骨细胞特异性表达Cre重组酶的转基因小鼠品系可以作为一种遗传学工具,介导目的基因在肥大软骨细胞中的敲除。     

Transgenic mice that express Cre recombinase in hypertrophic chondrocytes

In order to investigate the physiological control of hypertrophic chondrocytes which present the terminally differentiated form of chondrocytes, we generated a mouse line expressing the Cre recombinase under the control of the mouse type X collagen (Col10a1) promoter. In situ hybridization analysis demonstrated the expression of Col10a1-Cre transgene in hypertrophic chondrocytes of femur at postnatal day 2 (P2). In order to test the excision activity of the Cre recombinase, the Col10a1-Cre transgenic line was crossed with the mouse strain carrying the Smad4 conditional alleles (Smad4co/co) and the reporter line ROSA26. Multiple tissue PCR of Col10a1-Cre;Smad4co/+ mice revealed the restricted Cre activity in tissues containing hypertrophic chondrocytes. LacZ staining revealed that the Cre activity was observed in the cartilage primordia of ribs at E14.5 and only detected in the lower hypertrophic region of ribs at P1. These data suggest that the Col10a1-Cre mouse line described here could be used to achieve conditional gene targeting in hypertrophic chondrocytes.     

Expression of Cre recombinase in chondrocytes causes abnormal craniofacial and skeletal development

The cranial base synchondroses are growth centers that drive cranial and upper facial growth. The intersphenoid synchondrosis (ISS) and the spheno-occipital synchondrosis (SOS) are two major synchondroses located in the middle of the cranial base and are maintained at early developmental stages to sustain cranial base elongation. In this study, we report unexpected premature ossification of ISS and SOS when Cre recombinase is activated in a chondrocyte-specific manner. We used a Cre transgenic line expressing Aggrecan enhancer-driven, Tetracycline-inducible Cre (ATC), of which expression is controlled by a Col2a1 promoter. Neonatal doxycycline injection or doxycycline diet fed to breeders was used to activate Cre recombinase. The premature ossification of ISS and/or SOS led to a reduction in cranial base length and subsequently a dome-shaped skull. Furthermore, the mice carrying either heterozygous or homozygous conditional deletion of Tsc1 or Fip200 using ATC mice developed similar craniofacial abnormalities, indicating that Cre activity itself but not conditional deletion of Tsc1 or Fip200 gene, is the major contributor of this phenotype. In contrast, the Col2a1-Cre mice carrying Cre expression in both perichondrium and chondrocytes and the mice carrying the conditional deletion of Tsc1 or Fip200 using Col2a1-Cre did not manifest the same skull abnormalities. In addition to the defective craniofacial bone development, our data also showed that the Cre activation in chondrocytes significantly compromised bone acquisition in femur. Our data calls for the consideration of the potential in vivo adverse effects caused by Cre expression in chondrocytes and reinforcement of the importance of including Cre-containing controls to facilitate accurate phenotype interpretation in transgenic research.

     

Indian hedgehog in the late-phase differentiation in mouse chondrogenic EC cells, ATDC5: upregulation of type X collagen and osteoprotegerin ligand mRNAs

Endochondral bone formation includes a cascade of cellular events such as proliferation, maturation, hypertrophic conversion and calcification of chondrocytes and the cartilage replacement by bone. During these processes, hypertrophic conversion and calcification of chondrocytes (the late-phase differentiation) is a crucial process of chondrogenic differentiation. Indian hedgehog (Ihh), a secreted protein expressed in early hypertrophic chondrocytes, is thought to be involved in regulation of hypertrophic conversion via a feedback loop through the perichondrium. In the present study, we showed by Northern analysis and in situ hybridization that Smoothened (Smo), a key component in hedgehog signal transduction, was expressed in chondrocytes in both adult mice and mouse embryos at 16 days post-coitum in vivo, suggesting that Ihh directly acts on chondrocytes. We previously reported that Ihh, Patched and Smo were all expressed in differentiated ATDC5 cells. Exogenously administered mouse recombinant N-terminal protein of Ihh (mrIhh-N) upregulated the gene expression of type X collagen, a phenotypic marker of hypertrophic chondrocytes, as well as osteoprotegerin ligand (OPGL), a potent stimulator of osteoclastogenesis and osteoclast activity, while it did not modulate the expression of Ihh itself, bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-4, BMP-6, transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta1 and TGF-beta2 in differentiated ATDC5 cells. Moreover, when added to the osteoclast cultures, mrIhh-N markedly stimulated the formation of resorption pits on dentine slices. Our data support the hypothesis that Ihh stimulated the late-phase chondrogenic differentiation in differentiated ATDC5 cells and upregulated the gene expression of OPGL in these cells.     

Critical roles of the TGF-β type I receptor ALK5 in perichondrial formation and function, cartilage integrity, and osteoblast differentiation during growth plate development

TGF-β has been implicated in the proliferation and differentiation of chondrocytes and osteoblasts. However, the in vivo function of TGF-β in skeletal development is unclear. In this study, we investigated the role of TGF-β signaling in growth plate development by creating mice with a conditional knockout of the TGF-β type I receptor ALK5 (ALK5^CKO) in skeletal progenitor cells using Dermo1-Cre mice. ALK5^CKO mice had short and wide long bones, reduced bone collars, and trabecular bones. In ALK5^CKO growth plates, chondrocytes proliferated and differentiated, but ectopic cartilaginous tissues protruded into the perichondrium. In normal growth plates, ALK5 protein was strongly expressed in perichondrial progenitor cells for osteoblasts, and in a thin chondrocyte layer located adjacent to the perichondrium in the peripheral cartilage. ALK5^CKO growth plates had an abnormally thin perichondrial cell layer and reduced proliferation and differentiation of osteoblasts. These defects in the perichondrium likely caused the short bones and ectopic cartilaginous protrusions. Using tamoxifen-inducible Cre-ER™-mediated ALK5-deficient primary calvarial cell cultures, we found that TGF-β signaling promoted osteoprogenitor proliferation, early differentiation, and commitment to the osteoblastic lineage through the selective MAPKs and Smad2/3 pathways. These results demonstrate the important roles of TGF-β signaling in perichondrium formation and differentiation, as well as in growth plate integrity during skeletal development.     

Development of mice with osteoblast-specific connexin43 gene deletion

Genetic deficiency of Cx43 in vivo causes skeletal developmental defects, osteoblast dysfunction and perinatal lethality. To determine the role of Cx43 in the adult skeleton, we developed two models of osteoblast-specific Cx43 gene deletion using Cre mediated replacement of a "floxed" Cx43 allele with a LacZ reporter gene. Cre recombinase expression in osteoblasts was driven by either the osteocalcin OG2 promoter or the 2.3 kb fragment of the Colalpha1(I) promoter. Homozygous Cx43(fl/fl) mice, in which the Cx43 coding region is flanked by two loxP sites, were crossed with Cre expressing mice in a heterozygous Cx43-null background [Cx43(+/-); Colalpha1(I)-Cre or Cx43(+/-); OG2-Cre]. Cx43 gene ablation was demonstrated in tissues by selective X-gal staining of cells lining the endosteal surface, and in cultured osteoblastic cells from calvaria using different approaches. Although no LacZ expression was observed in proliferating calvaria cells, before osteoblast differentiation begins, post-proliferative cells isolated from conditional knockout mice [Cx43(fl/-); Colalpha1(I)-Cre or Cx43(fl/-); OG2-Cre] developed strong LacZ expression as they differentiated, in parallel to a progressive disappearance of Cx43 mRNA and protein abundance relative to controls. Selective Cre mediated Cx43 gene inactivation in bone forming cells will be useful to determine the role of Cx43 in adult skeletal homeostasis and overcome the perinatal lethality of the conventional null model.     

Expression and activity of osteoblast-targeted Cre recombinase transgenes in murine skeletal tissues

The Cre/loxP recombination system can be used to circumvent many of the limitations of generalized gene ablation in mice. Here we present the development and characterization of transgenic mice in which Cre recombinase has been targeted to cells of the osteoblast lineage with 2.3 kb (Col 2.3-Cre) and 3.6 kb (Col 3.6-Cre) fragments of the rat Col1a1 promoter. Cre mRNA was detected in calvaria and long bone of adult Col 2.3-Cre and Col 3.6-Cre mice, as well as in tendon and skin of Col 3.6-Cre mice. To obtain a historical marking of the temporal and spatial pattern of Cre-mediated gene rearrangement, Col-Cre mice were bred with ROSA26 (R26R) mice in which Cre-mediated excision of a floxed cassette results in LacZ expression. In Col 2.3-Cre;R26R and Col 3.6-Cre;R26R progeny, calvarial and long bone osteoblasts showed intense beta-gal staining at embryonic day 18 and postnatal day 5. The spatial pattern of beta-gal staining was more restricted in bone and in bone marrow stromal cultures established from Col 2.3-Cre;R26R mice. Similar differences in the spatial patterns of expression were seen in transgenic bone carrying Col1a1-GFP visual reporters. Our data suggest that Col 2.3-Cre and Col 3.6-Cre transgenic mice may be useful for conditional gene targeting in vivo or for obtaining osteoblast populations for in vitro culture in which a gene of interest has been inactivated.     

Collagen1alpha1 promoter drives the expression of Cre recombinase in osteoblasts of transgenic mice

Osteoblasts participate in bone formation, bone mineralization, osteoclast differentiation and many pathological processes. To study the function of genes in osteoblasts using Cre-LoxP system, we generated a mouse line expressing the Cre recombinase under the control of the rat Collagen1alpha1 (Col1alpha1) promoter (Col1alpha1-Cre). Two founders were identified by genomic PCR from 16 offsprings, and the integration efficiency is 12.5%. In order to determine the tissue distribution and the activity of Cre recombinase in the transgenic mice, the Col1alpha1-Cre transgenic mice were bred with the ROSA26 reporter strain and a mouse strain that carries Smad4 conditional alleles (Smad4(Co/Co)). Multiple tissue PCR of Col1alpha1-Cre;Smad4(Co/+)mice revealed the restricted Cre activity in bone tissues containing osteoblasts and tendon. LacZ staining in the Col1alpha1-Cre;ROSA26 double transgenic mice revealed that the Cre recombinase began to express in the osteoblasts of calvaria at E14.5. Cre activity was observed in the osteoblasts and osteocytes of P10 double transgenic mice. All these data indicated that the Col1alpha1-Cre transgenic mice could serve as a valuable tool for osteoblast lineage analysis and conditional gene knockout in osteoblasts.     

Involvement of the MAP kinase pathways in induction of GADD45 following UV radiation

Indian hedgehog (Ihh) is highly expressed in prehypertrophic chondrocytes in vivo and has been proposed to regulate the proliferation and maturation of chondrocytes and bone collar formation in the growth plate. In high-density cultures of rabbit growth-plate chondrocytes, Ihh mRNA was also expressed at the highest level in the prehypertrophic stage. To explore endogenous factors that regulate Ihh expression in chondrocytes, we examined the effects of various growth factors on Ihh mRNA expression in this system. Retinoic acid (RA) and bone morphogenetic protein-2 enhanced Ihh mRNA expression, whereas PTH/PTH-related peptide (PTHrP) markedly suppressed Ihh expression. RA at more than 10(-8) M induced the expression of Ihh and Patched 1 (Ptc1) within 3 h, before it increased the type X collagen mRNA level at 6-24 h. Cycloheximide blocked the up-regulation of Ihh by RA, indicating the requirement of de novo protein synthesis for this stimulation. These findings suggest that RA is involved in the up-regulation of Ihh during endochondral bone formation. In contrast to RA, PTH (1-84) at 10(-7) M abolished the mRNA expression of Ihh and Ptc1 within 2-4 h, before it suppressed the expression of type X collagen at 12-24 h. The inhibition of Ihh expression by PTH (1-84) did not require de novo protein synthesis. PTH (1-34), PTHrP (1-34), and (Bu)(2)cAMP also suppressed Ihh expression. On the other hand, Ihh has been reported to induce PTHrP synthesis in the perichondrium. Consequently, the direct inhibitory action of PTH/PTHrP on Ihh appears to be a negative feedback mechanism that prevents excess PTHrP accumulation in cartilage.     

Indian hedgehog coordinates endochondral bone growth and morphogenesis via parathyroid hormone related-protein-dependent and -independent pathways

Indian hedgehog (Ihh) and Parathyroid Hormone-related Protein (PTHrP) play a critical role in the morphogenesis of the vertebrate skeleton. Targeted deletion of Ihh results in short-limbed dwarfism, with decreased chondrocyte proliferation and extensive hypertrophy, features shared by mutants in PTHrP and its receptor. Activation of Ihh signaling upregulates PTHrP at the articular surface and prevents chondrocyte hypertrophy in wild-type but not PTHrP null explants, suggesting that Ihh acts through PTHrP. To investigate the relationship between these factors during development of the appendicular skeleton, mice were produced with various combinations of an Ihh null mutation (Ihh(-/-)), a PTHrP null mutation (PTHrP(-/-)), and a constitutively active PTHrP/Parathyroid hormone Receptor expressed under the control of the Collagen II promoter (PTHrPR*). PTHrPR* rescues PTHrP(-/-) embryos, demonstrating this construct can completely compensate for PTHrP signalling. At 18.5 dpc, limb skeletons of Ihh, PTHrP compound mutants were identical to Ihh single mutants suggesting Ihh is necessary for PTHrP function. Expression of PTHrPR* in chondrocytes of Ihh(-/-) mice prevented premature chondrocyte hypertrophy but did not rescue either the short-limbed dwarfism or decreased chondrocyte proliferation. These experiments demonstrate that the molecular mechanism that prevents chondrocyte hypertrophy is distinct from that which drives proliferation. Ihh positively regulates PTHrP, which is sufficient to prevent chondrocyte hypertrophy and maintain a normal domain of cells competent to undergo proliferation. In contrast, Ihh is necessary for normal chondrocyte proliferation in a pathway that can not be rescued by PTHrP signaling. This identifies Ihh as a coordinator of skeletal growth and morphogenesis, and refines the role of PTHrP in mediating a subset of Ihh's actions.     

TGFbeta2 mediates the effects of hedgehog on hypertrophic differentiation and PTHrP expression

The development of endochondral bones requires the coordination of signals from several cell types within the cartilage rudiment. A signaling cascade involving Indian hedgehog (Ihh) and parathyroid hormone related peptide (PTHrP) has been described in which hypertrophic differentiation is limited by a signal secreted from chondrocytes as they become committed to hypertrophy. In this negative-feedback loop, Ihh inhibits hypertrophic differentiation by regulating the expression of Pthrp, which in turn acts directly on chondrocytes in the growth plate that express the PTH/PTHrP receptor. Previously, we have shown that PTHrP also acts downstream of transforming growth factor beta (TGFbeta) in a common signaling cascade to regulate hypertrophic differentiation in embryonic mouse metatarsal organ cultures. As members of the TGFbeta superfamily have been shown to mediate the effects of Hedgehog in several developmental systems, we proposed a model where TGFbeta acts downstream of Ihh and upstream of PTHrP in a cascade of signals that regulate hypertrophic differentiation in the growth plate. This report tests the hypothesis that TGFbeta signaling is required for the effects of Hedgehog on hypertrophic differentiation and expression of PTHRP: We show that Sonic hedgehog (Shh), a functional substitute for Ihh, stimulates expression of Tgfb2 and Tgfb3 mRNA in the perichondrium of embryonic mouse metatarsal bones grown in organ cultures and that TGFbeta signaling in the perichondrium is required for inhibition of differentiation and regulation of Pthrp expression by Shh. The effects of Shh are specifically dependent on TGFbeta2, as cultures from Tgfb3-null embryos respond to Shh but cultures from Tgfb2-null embryos do not. Taken together, these data suggest that TGFbeta2 acts as a signal relay between Ihh and PTHrP in the regulation of cartilage hypertrophic differentiation.     

Indian hedgehog signals independently of PTHrP to promote chondrocyte hypertrophy

Chondrocyte hypertrophy is an essential process required for endochondral bone formation. Proper regulation of chondrocyte hypertrophy is also required in postnatal cartilage homeostasis. Indian hedgehog (Ihh) and PTHrP signaling play crucial roles in regulating the onset of chondrocyte hypertrophy by forming a negative feedback loop, in which Ihh signaling regulates chondrocyte hypertrophy by controlling PTHrP expression. To understand whether there is a PTHrP-independent role of Ihh signaling in regulating chondrocyte hypertrophy, we have both activated and inactivated Ihh signaling in the absence of PTHrP during endochondral skeletal development. We found that upregulating Ihh signaling in the developing cartilage by treating PTHrP(-/-) limb explants with sonic hedgehog (Shh) protein in vitro, or overexpressing Ihh in the cartilage of PTHrP(-/-) embryos or inactivating patched 1 (Ptch1), a negative regulator of hedgehog (Hh) signaling, accelerated chondrocyte hypertrophy in the PTHrP(-/-) embryos. Conversely, when Hh signaling was blocked by cyclopamine or by removing Smoothened (Smo), a positive regulator of Hh signaling, chondrocyte hypertrophy was delayed in the PTHrP(-/-) embryo. Furthermore, we show that upregulated Hh signaling in the postnatal cartilage led to accelerated chondrocyte hypertrophy during secondary ossification, which in turn caused reduction of joint cartilage. Our results revealed a novel role of Ihh signaling in promoting chondrocyte hypertrophy independently of PTHrP, which is particularly important in postnatal cartilage development and homeostasis. In addition, we found that bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp) and Wnt/beta-catenin signaling in the cartilage may both mediate the effect of upregulated Ihh signaling in promoting chondrocyte hypertrophy.     

Parathyroid hormone-related peptide expression in the epiphyseal growth plate of the juvenile chicken: evidence for the origin of the parathyroid hormone-related peptide found in the epiphyseal growth plate

Parathyroid hormone-related peptide (PTHrP) has been shown to be essential for normal endochondral bone formation. Along with Indian hedgehog (Ihh), it forms a paracrine regulatory loop that governs the pace of chondrocyte differentiation. However, the source of PTHrP for this regulatory loop is not clear. While one hypothesis has suggested the periarticular perichondrium as the source of PTHrP for growth plate regulation, other data utilizing immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridization would indicate that growth plate chondrocytes themselves are the source of this peptide. The data described in this report supports the view that postnatal growth plate chondrocytes have the ability to synthesize this important regulatory peptide. Immunohistochemistry of tissue sections showed that PTHrP protein was evident throughout the chick epiphysis. PTHrP was seen in chondrocytes in the periarticular perichondrium, the perichondrium adjacent to the growth plate, the prehypertrophic zone of the growth plate, and the hypertrophic zone of the growth plate. However, cells in the proliferative zone, as well as some chondrocytes in the deeper layers of articular cartilage were predominantly negative for PTHrP. PTHrP was detected by Western blotting as a band of 16,400 Da in extracts from hypertrophic chondrocytes, but not from proliferative cells. RT-PCR detected PTHrP mRNA in both proliferative and hypertrophic growth plate chondrocytes, as well as in articular chondrocytes. PTH/PTHrP receptor mRNA was detected by Northern blotting in growth plate, but not articular chondrocytes. Thus, we conclude that most of the PTHrP present in the epiphyseal growth plate of the juvenile chick originates in the growth plate itself. Furthermore, the presence of large amounts of PTHrP protein in the hypertrophic zone supports the concept that PTHrP has other functions in addition to regulating chondrocyte differentiation.     

Smad4 is required for the normal organization of the cartilage growth plate

Smad4 is the central intracellular mediator of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) signals. To study the role of Smad4 in skeletal development, we introduced a conditional mutation of the gene in chondrocytes using Cre--loxP system. We showed that Smad4 was expressed strongly in prehypertrophic and hypertrophic chondrocytes. The abrogation of Smad4 in chondrocytes resulted in dwarfism with a severely disorganized growth plate characterized by expanded resting zone of chondrocytes, reduced chondrocyte proliferation, accelerated hypertrophic differentiation, increased apoptosis and ectopic bone collars in perichondrium. Meanwhile, Smad4 mutant mice exhibited decreased expression of molecules in Indian hedgehog/parathyroid hormone-related protein (Ihh/PTHrP) signaling. The cultured mutant metatarsal bones failed to response to TGF-beta1, while the hypertrophic differentiation was largely inhibited by Sonic hedgehog (Shh). This indicated that Ihh/PTHrP inhibited the hypertrophic differentiation of chondrocytes independent of the Smad4-mediated TGF-beta signals. All these data provided the first genetic evidence demonstrating that Smad4-mediated TGF-beta signals inhibit the chondrocyte hypertrophic differentiation, and are required for maintaining the normal organization of chondrocytes in the growth plate.     

BMP and Ihh/PTHrP signaling interact to coordinate chondrocyte proliferation and differentiation.

During endochondral ossification, two secreted signals, Indian hedgehog (Ihh) and parathyroid hormone-related protein (PTHrP), have been shown to form a negative feedback loop regulating the onset of hypertrophic differentiation of chondrocytes. Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs), another family of secreted factors regulating bone formation, have been implicated as potential interactors of the Ihh/PTHrP feedback loop. To analyze the relationship between the two signaling pathways, we used an organ culture system for limb explants of mouse and chick embryos. We manipulated chondrocyte differentiation by supplementing these cultures either with BMP2, PTHrP and Sonic hedgehog as activators or with Noggin and cyclopamine as inhibitors of the BMP and Ihh/PTHrP signaling systems. Overexpression of Ihh in the cartilage elements of transgenic mice results in an upregulation of PTHrP expression and a delayed onset of hypertrophic differentiation. Noggin treatment of limbs from these mice did not antagonize the effects of Ihh overexpression. Conversely, the promotion of chondrocyte maturation induced by cyclopamine, which blocks Ihh signaling, could not be rescued with BMP2. Thus BMP signaling does not act as a secondary signal of Ihh to induce PTHrP expression or to delay the onset of hypertrophic differentiation. Similar results were obtained using cultures of chick limbs. We further investigated the role of BMP signaling in regulating proliferation and hypertrophic differentiation of chondrocytes and identified three functions of BMP signaling in this process. First we found that maintaining a normal proliferation rate requires BMP and Ihh signaling acting in parallel. We further identified a role for BMP signaling in modulating the expression of IHH: Finally, the application of Noggin to mouse limb explants resulted in advanced differentiation of terminally hypertrophic cells, implicating BMP signaling in delaying the process of hypertrophic differentiation itself. This role of BMP signaling is independent of the Ihh/PTHrP pathway.