Reversibility of strand invasion promoted by recA protein and its inhibition by Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA-binding protein or phage T4 gene 32 protein

When recA protein promotes homologous pairing and strand exchange involving circular single strands and linear duplex DNA, the protein first polymerizes on the single-stranded DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament which then binds naked duplex DNA to form nucleoprotein networks, the existence of which is independent of homology, but requires the continued presence of recA protein (Tsang, S. S., Chow, S. A., and Radding, C. M. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 3226-3232). Further experiments revealed that within a few minutes after the beginning of homologous pairing and strand exchange, these networks began to be replaced by a distinct set of networks with inverse properties: their formation depended upon homology, but they survived removal of recA protein by a variety of treatments. Formation of this second kind of network required that homology be present specifically at the end of the linear duplex molecule from which strand exchange begins. Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA-binding protein or phage T4 gene 32 protein largely suppressed the formation of this second population of networks by inactivating the newly formed heteroduplex DNA, which, however, could be reactivated when recA protein was dissociated by incubation at 0 degrees C. We interpret these observations as evidence of reinitiation of strand invasion when recA protein acts in the absence of auxiliary helix-destabilizing proteins. These observations indicate that the nature of the nucleoprotein products of strand exchange determines whether pairing and strand exchange are reversible or not, and they further suggest a new explanation for the way in which E. coli single-stranded DNA-binding protein and gene 32 protein accelerate the apparent forward rate of strand exchange promoted by recA protein, namely by suppressing initiation of the reverse reaction.     

recA protein promoted DNA strand exchange

recA protein and circular single-stranded DNA form a stable complex in the presence of single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB), in which one recA protein monomer is bound per two nucleotides of DNA. These complexes are kinetically significant intermediates in the exchange of strands between the single-stranded DNA and an homologous linear duplex. After completion of strand exchange, the recA protein remains tightly associated with the circular duplex product of the reaction and the SSB is bound to the displaced linear single strand. Upon addition of ADP, the recA protein-duplex DNA complex dissociates. RecA protein also interacts with single-stranded DNA in the absence of SSB; however, the amount of recA protein bound is substantially reduced. These findings provide direct physical evidence for the participation of SSB in the formation of the recA protein-single-stranded DNA complexes inferred earlier from kinetic analysis. Moreover, they confirm the ability of recA protein to equilibrate between bound and free forms in the absence of SSB.     

Kinetics of DNA renaturation catalyzed by the RecA protein of Escherichia coli

The recA enzyme of Escherichia coli catalyzes renaturation of DNA coupled to hydrolysis of ATP. The rate of enzymatic renaturation is linearly dependent on recA protein concentration and shows saturation kinetics with respect to DNA concentration. The kinetic analysis of the reaction indicates that the Km for DNA is 65 microM while the kcat is approximately 48 pmol of duplex formed (pmol of recA)-1 (20 min)-1. RecA protein catalyzed renaturation has been characterized with respect to salt sensitivity, Mg2+ ion and pH optima, requirements for nucleoside triphosphates, and inhibition by nonhydrolyzable nucleoside triphosphates and analogues. These results are consistent with a Michaelis-Menten mechanism for DNA renaturation catalyzed by recA protein. A model is described in which oligomers of recA protein bind rapidly to single-stranded DNA, and in the presence of ATP, these nucleoprotein intermediates aggregate to bring complementary sequences into close proximity for homologous pairing. As with other DNA pairing reactions catalyzed by recA protein, ongoing DNA hydrolysis is required for renaturation. However, unlike the strand assimilation or transfer reaction, renaturation is inhibited by E. coli helix-destabilizing protein.     

Networks of DNA and RecA protein are intermediates in homologous pairing

Partial coating of single-stranded DNA by recA protein causes its aggregation, but conditions that promote complete coating inhibit independent aggregation of single strands and, instead, cause the mutually dependent conjunction of single- and double-stranded DNA in complexes that sediment at more than 10 000 S. This coaggregation is independent of homology but otherwise shares key properties of homologous pairing of single strands with duplex DNA: both processes require ATP, MgCl2, and stoichiometric amounts of recA protein; both are very sensitive to inhibition by salt and ADP. Coaggregates are closed domains that are intermediates in homologous pairing: they form faster than joint molecules, they include virtually all of the DNA in the reaction mixture, and they yield joint molecules nearly an order of magnitude faster than they exchange DNA molecules with the surrounding solution. The independent aggregation of single-stranded DNA differs in all respects except the requirement for Mg2+, and its properties correlate instead with those associated with the renaturation of complementary single strands by recA protein.     

Patterns of nuclease protection during strand exchange. recA protein forms heteroduplex DNA by binding to strands of the same polarity

recA protein, in the presence of ATP, polymerizes on single-stranded DNA (plus strand) to form a presynaptic nucleoprotein filament that pairs with linear duplex DNA and actively displaces the plus strand from the recipient molecule in a polarized fashion to form a new heteroduplex molecule. The interaction between recA protein and DNA during strand exchange was studied by labeling different strands and probing the intermediate with pancreatic deoxyribonuclease I (DNase I) or restriction endonuclease. The incoming single strand was resistant to DNase I in the original nucleoprotein filament and remained resistant even after extensive strand exchange had occurred. Both strands of the parental duplex molecule were sensitive to DNase I in the absence of joint molecule formation; but as strand exchange progressed following homologous pairing, increasing stretches of the parental plus strand became resistant, whereas the complementary parental minus strand remained sensitive to DNase I throughout the reaction. Except for a region of 50-100 base pairs at the end of the newly formed heteroduplex DNA where strand exchange was initiated, the rest of the heteroduplex region was resistant to cleavage by restriction endonucleases. The data suggest that recA protein promotes strand exchange by binding both the incoming and outgoing strands of the same polarity, whereas the complementary strand, which must switch pairing partners, is unhindered by direct contact with the protein.     

Separation of the presynaptic and synaptic phases of homologous pairing promoted by recA protein

Homologous pairing of single strands with duplex DNA promoted by recA protein occurred without a lag only when the protein was preincubated with ATP and single-stranded DNA. The rate-limiting presynaptic interaction of recA protein and single strands showed a high temperature coefficient: it proceeded 30 times more slowly at 30 degrees C than at 37 degrees C, whereas synapsis showed a normal temperature coefficient. Thus, the presynaptic phase could be separated experimentally from the rest of the reaction by preincubation of single strands with recA protein and ATP at 37 degrees C, followed by a shift to 30 degrees C before double-stranded DNA was added. The presynaptic phase was an order of magnitude more sensitive to inhibition by ADP than was subsequent strand exchange. Presynaptic complexes that were formed at 37 degrees C decayed only slowly at 30 degrees C, but Escherichia coli single strand binding protein caused complexes to form rapidly at 30 degrees C which indicates that single strand binding protein accelerated the rate of formation of complexes. Preincubation synchronized the initial pairing reaction, and further revealed the rapid formation of nascent heteroduplex DNA 250-300 base pairs in length.     

Kinetic modeling of the recA protein promoted renaturation of complementary DNA strands

Quantitative agarose gel assays reveal that the recA protein promoted renaturation of complementary DNA strands (phi X DNA) proceeds in two stages. The first stage results in the formation of unit-length duplex DNA as well as a distribution of other products ("initial products"). In the second stage, the initial products are converted to complex multipaired DNA structures ("network DNA"). In the presence of ATP, the initial products are formed within 2 min and are then rapidly converted to network DNA. In the absence of ATP, the initial products are formed nearly as fast as with ATP present, but they are converted to network DNA at a much lower rate. The time-dependent formation of initial products and network DNA from complementary single strands for both the ATP-stimulated and ATP-independent reactions can be modeled by using a simple two-step sequential kinetic scheme. This model indicates that the primary effect of ATP in the recA protein promoted renaturation reaction is not on the initial pairing step (which leads to the formation of initial products) but rather is to increase the rate at which subsequent pairing events can occur.     

An unpaired 3' terminus stimulates recA protein-promoted DNA strand exchange

In the presence of 100 mM NaCl, the efficient exchange of strands between a circular single strand and an homologous DNA duplex promoted by the recA and single-stranded DNA binding proteins of Escherichia coli requires an unpaired 3' terminus. Of the duplex DNAs tested, only those with 4 unpaired bases at the 3' termini are effective. Without added NaCl, strand exchange proceeds efficiently with all duplex DNA termini examined including a nicked circular duplex. Thus, at approximately physiological salt concentrations, factors in addition to the recA and single-stranded DNA binding proteins are needed to promote efficient strand exchange. One such factor may be a DNA helicase(s).     

ATP-independent renaturation of complementary DNA strands by the mutant recA1 protein from Escherichia coli

In an effort to clarify the requirement for ATP in the recA protein-promoted renaturation of complementary DNA strands, we have analyzed the mutant recA1 protein which lacks single-stranded DNA-dependent ATPase activity at pH 7.5. Like the wild type, the recA1 protein binds to single-stranded DNA with a stoichiometry of one monomer per approximately four nucleotides. However, unlike the wild type, the mutant protein is dissociated from single-stranded DNA in the presence of ATP or ADP. The ATP analogue adenosine 5'-O-3' (thiotriphosphate) appears to stabilize the binding of recA1 protein to single-stranded DNA but does not elicit the stoichiometry of 1 monomer/8 nucleotides or the formation of highly condensed protein-DNA networks that are characteristic of the wild type recA protein in the presence of this analogue. The recA1 protein does not catalyze DNA renaturation in the presence of ATP, consistent with the dissociation of recA1 protein from single-stranded DNA under these conditions. However, it does promote a pattern of Mg2+-dependent renaturation identical to that found for wild type recA protein.     

ADP-mediated dissociation of stable complexes of recA protein and single-stranded DNA

The complete exchange of strands between circular single-stranded and full length linear duplex DNAs promoted by the recA protein of Escherichia coli is dependent upon the hydrolysis of ATP and is strongly stimulated by the single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB). In the presence of SSB, stable complexes of recA protein and single-stranded DNA are formed as an early step in the reaction. These complexes dissociate when the ADP/ATP ratio approaches a value of 0.6-1.5, depending upon reaction conditions. Thus, ATP hydrolysis never proceeds to completion but stops when 40-60% of the input ATP has undergone hydrolysis. recA protein can participate in a second round of strand exchange upon regeneration of the ATP. While 100-200 mol of ATP are hydrolyzed/mol of heteroduplex base pair formed under standard reaction conditions in the presence of SSB, this value is reduced to 16 at levels of ADP lower than that required to dissociate the complexes. ATP hydrolysis appears to be completely irreversible since efforts to detect exchange reactions using 18O probes have been unsuccessful.     

Production of triple-stranded recombination intermediates by RecA protein, in vitro

During the directional strand exchange that is promoted by RecA protein between linear duplex DNA and circular single-stranded DNA, a triple-stranded DNA intermediate was formed and persisted even after the completion of strand transfer followed by deproteinization. In the deproteinized three-stranded DNA complexes, the sequestered linear third strand resisted digestion by E coli exonuclease I. In relation to polarity of strand exchange which defines the proximal and distal ends of the duplex DNA, when homology was restricted to the distal region of duplex substrate, the joints formed efficiently and were stable even upon complete deproteinization. Enzymatic probing of deproteinized distal joints with nuclease P1 revealed that the joints consist of long three-stranded structures that at neutral pH lack significant single-stranded character in any of the three strands. Instead of circular single-stranded DNA, when a linear single strand is recombined with partially homologous duplex DNA, in the presence of SSB, the formation of homologous joints by RecA protein, is significantly more efficient at distal end than at the proximal. Taken together, these observations suggest that with any single-stranded DNA (circular or linear), RecA protein efficiently promotes the formation of distal joints, from which, however, authentic strand exchange may not occur. Moreover, these joints might represent an intermediate which is trapped into a stable triple stranded state.     

Escherichia coli recA protein protects single-stranded DNA or gapped duplex DNA from degradation by RecBC DNase

RecA- mutants of Escherichia coli extensively degrade their DNA following UV irradiation. Most of this degradation is due to the recBC DNase, which suggests that the recA gene is involved in the control of recBC DNase in vivo. We have shown that purified recA protein inhibits the endonuclease and exonuclease activities of recBC DNase on single-stranded DNA. The extent of inhibition is dependent on the relative concentration of recA protein, recBC DNase, and the DNA substrate; inhibition is greatest when the concentrations of DNA and recBC DNase are low and the concentrations of recA protein is high. At fixed concentrations of recA protein and recBC DNase, inhibition is eliminated at high concentrations of DNA. In the presence of adenosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate), an ATP analog which stabilizes the binding of recA protein to both single- and double-stranded DNA, recA protein is a more potent inhibitor of the nuclease activities on single-stranded DNA and is a weak inhibitor of the exonuclease activity on double-stranded DNA. Inhibition of the latter is enhanced by oligodeoxynucleotides, which stimulate the binding of recA protein to double-stranded DNA. In the presence of adenosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate), recA protein also inhibits the action of exonuclease I on single-stranded DNA and of lambda exonuclease on double-stranded DNA. These observations are most consistent with the idea that recA protein protects DNA from recBC DNase by binding to DNA. RecA protein also blocks the endonucleolytic cleavage of gapped circular DNA by recBC DNase. Since both recA protein and recBC DNase have the ability under certain conditions to unwind duplex DNA and to displace strands, we looked for evidence that their combined action would enlarge gaps but found no extensive enlargement. D-loops, a putative intermediate in genetic recombination, are effectively protected against the action of recBC DNase by the E. coli single strand binding protein and by recA protein in the presence of adenosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate).     

Genetic recombination: recA protein promotes homologous pairing between duplex DNA molecules without strand unwinding.

The recA protein of Escherichia coli promotes pairing in vitro between covalent circular duplex DNA and homologous circular duplex DNA containing a single stranded region. We have used a filter binding assay to investigate the frequency of homologous pairing between gapped and intact duplex DNA when unwinding of the free 3' and 5' ends of the gapped molecules was blocked. In order to obtain DNA without free ends, the gapped DNA was treated with trimethylpsoralen and 360 nm light so as to introduce about 6 crosslinks per DNA molecule and the double stranded regions on either side of the gaps were then digested up to the first crosslinks with exonuclease III and lambda exonuclease. This treatment did not diminish the frequency of homologous pairing, an observation which is difficult to reconcile with models for recombination requiring strand unwinding before pairing.     

Kinetics of homologous pairing promoted by RecA protein: effects of ends and internal sites in DNA

When recA protein was preincubated with single-stranded DNA in the presence of an ATP-regenerating system prior to the addition of homologous duplex DNA, a slow presynaptic step was eliminated, and the subsequent homologous pairing was revealed as a reaction whose rate exceeds by 1 or 2 orders of magnitude the calculated rate of spontaneous renaturation in 0.15 M NaCl at Tm -25 degrees C. The pairing reaction displayed saturation kinetics with respect to both single-stranded and double-stranded DNA, indicating the existence of a rate-limiting enzyme-substrate complex. The signal observed in the assay of the pairing reaction was due to pairing at free homologous ends of the duplex DNA, as well as pairing in the middle of the duplex molecule, away from a free end. The apparent rate of pairing of circular single strands with linear duplex DNA was equal to the sum of the rates of pairing at sites located at either end of the duplex DNA or at interior sites, but the apparent rates attributable to ends were greater, and nicks also stimulated the apparent rate.     

On RecA protein-mediated homologous alignment of two DNA molecules. Three strands versus four strands

The recA protein from Escherichia coli can homologously align two duplex DNA molecules; however, this interaction is much less efficient than the alignment of a single strand and a duplex. Three strand paranemic joints are readily detected. In contrast, duplex-duplex pairing is detected only when the incoming (second) duplex is negatively supercoiled, and even here the pairing is inefficient. The recA protein-promoted four strand exchange reaction is initiated in a three strand region, with efficiency increasing with the length of potential three strand pairing available for initiation. This indicates that a paranemic joint involving three DNA strands may be an important intermediate in all recA protein-mediated DNA strand exchange reactions and that the presence of three strands rather than four is a fundamental structural parameter of paranemic joints.     

Identification and characterization of the Escherichia coli RecT protein, a protein encoded by the recE region that promotes renaturation of homologous single-stranded DNA.

Recombination of plasmid DNAs and recombination of bacteriophage lambda red mutants in recB recC sbcA Escherichia coli mutants, in which the recE region is expressed, do not require recA. The recE gene is known to encode exonuclease VIII (exoVIII), which is an ATP-independent exonuclease involved in the RecE pathway of recombination. A 33,000-molecular-weight (MW) protein was observed to be coexpressed with both exoVIII and a truncated version of exoVIII, pRac3 exo, when they were overproduced under the control of strong promoters. We have purified this 33,000-MW protein (p33) and demonstrated by protein sequence analysis that it is encoded by the same coding sequence that encodes the C-terminal 33,000-MW portion of exoVIII. p33 is expressed independently of exoVIII but is probably translated from the same mRNA. p33 was found to bind to single-stranded DNA and also to promote the renaturation of complementary single-stranded DNA. It appears that p33 is functionally analogous to the bacteriophage lambda beta protein, which may explain why RecE pathway recombination does not require recA.     

The specificity of lambda exonuclease. Interactions with single-stranded DNA.

The lambda exonuclease, an enzyme that has been implicated in genetic recombination, rapidly and processively degrades native DNA, starting at the 5' terminus. The enzyme will also degrade the 5'-terminated strand at a single-stranded branch. The experiments reported here reveal various interactions of the enzyme with single-stranded DNA. The rate of digestion is related inversely to the length of single strands. Chains of 100 nucleotides are digested at about 10% the rate of digestion of native DNA. Digestion of the single-stranded ends of lambda DNA does not appear to occur processively. The enzyme binds to circular as well as linear single strands and the affinity for single strands is also related inversely to the chain length. In an equimolar mixture of single- and double-stranded DNA the action of lambda exonuclease on the latteris about half-inhibited. At 20 degrees the initiation of digestion at the 5' terminus of duplex DNA is blocked sterically when such DNA has 3'-terminal single strands that are longer than 100 nucleotides. Information about these properties is important for the practical use of lambda exonuclease as well as for reflections on the role of the enzyme in genetic recombination.     

DNase protection by recA protein during strand exchange. Asymmetric protection of the Holliday structure

When recA protein pairs linear duplex DNA with a homologous duplex molecule that has a single-stranded tail, it produces a recombination intermediate called the Holliday structure and causes reciprocal or symmetric strand exchange, whereas the pairing of a linear duplex molecule with fully single-stranded DNA leads to an asymmetric exchange. To study the location of recA protein on DNA molecules undergoing symmetric exchange, we labeled individually each end of the four strands involved and looked for protection against DNase I or restriction endonucleases. As expected, because of its preferred binding to single-stranded DNA, recA protein protected the single-stranded tails of either substrates, or products. In addition however, strong protection extended into the newly formed heteroduplex DNA along the strand to which recA protein was initially bound. Experiments with uniformly labeled DNA showed a corresponding homology-dependent asymmetry in the protection of the tailed substrate versus its fully duplex partner. Restriction experiments showed that protection extended 50-75 base pairs beyond the point where strand exchange was blocked by a long region of heterology. When compared with earlier observations (Chow, S. A., Honigberg, S. M., Bainton, R. J., and Radding, C. M. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 6961-6971), the present experiments reveal a pattern of association of recA protein with DNA that suggests a common mechanism of asymmetric and symmetric strand exchange.     

Effects of various single-stranded-DNA-binding proteins on reactions promoted by RecA protein

To relate the roles of Escherichia coli SSB in recombination in vivo and in vitro, we have studied the mutant proteins SSB-1 and SSB-113, the variant SSBc produced by chymotryptic cleavage, the partially homologous variant F SSB (encoded by the E. coli sex factor), and the protein encoded by gene 32 of bacteriophage T4. All of these, with the exception of SSB-1, augmented both the initial rate of homologous pairing and strand exchange promoted by RecA protein. From these and related observations, we conclude that SSB stimulates the initial formation of joint molecules by nonspecifically promoting the binding of RecA protein to single-stranded DNA; that SSB plays no role in synapsis of the RecA nucleoprotein filament with duplex DNA; that stimulation of strand exchange by SSB is similarly nonspecific; and that all members of the class of proteins represented by SSB, F SSB, and gene 32 protein may play equivalent roles in making single-stranded DNA more accessible to RecA protein.     

Continuous association of Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding protein with stable complexes of recA protein and single-stranded DNA

The single-stranded DNA binding protein of Escherichia coli (SSB) stimulates recA protein promoted DNA strand exchange reactions by promoting and stabilizing the interaction between recA protein and single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). Utilizing the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of SSB, an ATP-dependent interaction has been detected between SSB and recA-ssDNA complexes. This interaction is continuous for periods exceeding 1 h under conditions that are optimal for DNA strand exchange. Our data suggest that this interaction does not involve significant displacement of recA protein in the complex by SSB when ATP is present. The properties of this interaction are consistent with the properties of SSB-stabilized recA-ssDNA complexes determined by other methods. The data are incompatible with models in which SSB is displaced after functioning transiently in the formation of recA-ssDNA complexes. A continuous association of SSB with recA-ssDNA complexes may therefore be an important feature of the mechanism by which SSB stimulates recA protein promoted reactions.