Ligand exchange between proteins. Exchange of biotin and biotin derivatives between avidin and streptavidin

We have studied the structural elements that affect ligand exchange between the two high affinity biotin-binding proteins, egg white avidin and its bacterial analogue, streptavidin. For this purpose, we have developed a simple assay based on the antipodal behavior of the two proteins toward hydrolysis of biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester (BNP). The assay provided the experimental basis for these studies. It was found that biotin migrates unidirectionally from streptavidin to avidin. Conversely, the biotin derivative, BNP, is transferred in the opposite direction, from avidin to streptavidin. A previous crystallographic study (Huberman, T., Eisenberg-Domovich, Y., Gitlin, G., Kulik, T., Bayer, E. A., Wilchek, M., and Livnah, O. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 32031-32039) provided insight into a plausible explanation for these results. These data revealed that the non-hydrolyzable BNP analogue, biotinyl p-nitroanilide, was almost completely sheltered in streptavidin as opposed to avidin in which the disordered conformation of a critical loop resulted in the loss of several hydrogen bonds and concomitant exposure of the analogue to the solvent. In order to determine the minimal modification of the biotin molecule required to cause the disordered loop conformation, the structures of avidin and streptavidin were determined with norbiotin, homobiotin, and a common long-chain biotin derivative, biotinyl epsilon-aminocaproic acid. Six new crystal structures of the avidin and streptavidin complexes with the latter biotin analogues and derivatives were thus elucidated. It was found that extending the biotin side chain by a single CH(2) group (i.e. homobiotin) is sufficient to result in this remarkable conformational change in the loop of avidin. These results bear significant biotechnological importance, suggesting that complexes containing biotinylated probes with streptavidin would be more stable than those with avidin. These findings should be heeded when developing new drugs based on lead compounds because it is difficult to predict the structural and conformational consequences on the resultant protein-ligand interactions.     

A spectrophotometric assay for nanogram quantities of biotin and avidin

Parameters and conditions of an enzyme based assay for biotin and avidin are presented. Biotinylated glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase when complexed with avidin becomes inactivated. Thus it was possible to construct a competitive assay system for biotin. The assay is sensitive between 100-500 ng/ml and could detect as little as 10 ng in 0.1 ml with a between run error of 2.4%. It requires a 60 min incubation at 21 degrees C and 5 min to assay. The avidin assay, based on the degree of inactivation of biotinylated-glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase in relation to the concentration of avidin, could detect as little as 0.25 ng in 0.1 ml or 2.5 ng/ml with an assay time of 10 min with a between run error of 3.9%. Both assays are rapid with significant improvements over other non-isotopic methods in sensitivity and comparable to radioisotopic methods in sensitivity with the added advantage of ease of method.     

Conformational flexibility of avidin: the influence of biotin binding

Ligand binding to proteins is a key process in cell biochemistry. The interaction usually induces modifications in the unfolding thermodynamic parameters of the macromolecule due to the coupling of unfolding and binding equilibria. In addition, these modifications can be attended by changes in protein structure and/or conformational flexibility induced by ligand binding. In this work, we have explored the effect of biotin binding on conformation and dynamic properties of avidin by using infrared spectroscopy including kinetics of hydrogen/deuterium exchange. Our results, along with previously thermodynamic published data, indicate a clear correlation between thermostability and protein compactness. In addition, our results also help to interpret the thermodynamic binding parameters of the exceptionally stable biotin:AVD complex.     

Thermodynamics of the binding of biotin and some analogues by avidin

1. The reaction between avidin and biotin was found to be exothermic, ΔH being −20·3kcal./mole of biotin bound. The corresponding value of ΔH for streptavidin was −23kcal./mole. 2. The heat evolved was independent of the pH (between 5 and 9), of the buffer (borate or ammonia) and of the fractional saturation of the avidin with biotin. 3. The entropy change for the reaction was zero, and it is suggested that the entropy increase to be expected from hydrophobic interactions was counterbalanced by a decrease in entropy accompanying the formation of buried hydrogen bonds. 4. Modification of the potential hydrogen-bonding sites of the imidazolidone ring led to a decreased heat output and a positive entropy of reaction.     

Extremely high thermal stability of streptavidin and avidin upon biotin binding

The effect of biotin binding on the thermal stability of streptavidin (STV) and avidin (AVD) was evaluated using differential scanning calorimetry. Biotin binding increases the midpoint of temperature Tm of thermally induced denaturation of STV and AVD in phosphate buffer from 75 and 83 degrees C to 112 and 117 degrees C at full biotin saturation, respectively. This thermostability is the highest reported for proteins coming from either mesophilic or thermophilic organisms. In both proteins, biotin also increases the calorimetric enthalpy and the cooperativity of the unfolding. Thermal stability of STV was also evaluated in the presence of high concentrations of urea or guanidinium hydrochloride (GuHCl). In 6 M GuHCl, STV remains as a tetramer and the Tm of the STV-biotin complex is centered at 108 degrees C, a few degrees below the value obtained in phosphate buffer. On the contrary, STV under fully saturating condition remains mainly in its dimeric form in 8 M urea and the thermogram shows two endotherms. The main endotherm at a lower temperature has been ascribed to the dimeric liganded state with a Tm of 87 degrees C, and the higher temperature endotherm to the tetrameric liganded form with a Tm of 106 degrees C. As the thermostability of unliganded protein in the presence of urea is unchanged upon binding we related the extremely high thermal stability of this protein to both an increase in structural ordering and compactness with the preservation of the tetramer integrity.     

A sensitive enzyme assay for biotin, avidin, and streptavidin

Reciprocal enzyme assays are described for the vitamin biotin and for the biotin-binding proteins avidin and streptavidin. The assays are based on the following steps: (a) biotinylated bovine serum albumin is adsorbed onto microtiter plates; (b) streptavidin (or avidin) is bound to the biotin-coated plates; (c) biotinylated enzyme (in this case alkaline phosphatase) is then interacted with the free biotin-binding sites on the immobilized protein. For biotin assay, competition between the free vitamin and the biotinylated enzyme is carried out between steps (b) and (c). The method takes advantage of the four biotin-binding sites which characterize both avidin and streptavidin. The method is extremely versatile and accurate over a concentration range exceeding three orders of magnitude. The lower limits of detection are approximately 2 pg/ml (0.2 pg/sample) for biotin and less than 100 ng/ml (10 ng/sample) for either avidin or streptavidin.     

Ion selective electrode estimation of avidin and biotin using a lysozyme label

A method for the homogeneous estimation of the biotin binding protein, avidin, by use of an enzyme label is described. As in homogeneous enzyme immunoassay, where no separation step is employed, the activity of a biotin-lysozyme conjugate is inhibited by the binding of avidin, instead of an immunoagent. Biotin concentration can also be related to conjugate activity after sequential saturation of a known amount of avidin by the biotin sample and the biotin-lysozyme conjugate. Conjugate activity is followed potentiometrically by the release of trimethylphenylammonium ion from loaded Micrococcus lysodeikticus cells or turbidimetrically using a M. lysodeikticus cell suspension.     

Tissue distribution of avidin and streptavidin injected to mice. Effect of avidin carbohydrate, streptavidin truncation and exogenous biotin

Radioionated avidin and streptavidin were characterized for their biodistribution and tissue association in Balb/c mice, in comparison to their interaction with cells in vitro. Binding of avidin to spleen and bone-marrow cells in vitro was up to 20-fold higher than that of streptavidin, but when tested in vivo avidin clearance from blood and tissues was considerably faster than that of streptavidin. Levels of avidin at 24 h after an intravenous injection were below 1% (of the injected dose/mass tissue) in most organs. Non-glycosylated avidin was similar in its biodistribution to native avidin. Native streptavidin exhibited higher and prolonged tissue association with 5-10% levels in lung, liver, spleen, kidney and blood, whereas its truncated form showed low tissue levels (1-3%) but a remarkably high affinity to the kidney (80%). Exogenous biotin did not affect streptavidin distribution in vivo but caused a 2-7-fold increase in the retention of avidin (but not non-glycodylated avidin) in some of the organs.     

A study of the interaction of avidin with 2-anilinonaphthalene-6-sulfonic acid as a probe of the biotin binding site

The environment of the biotin binding site on avidin was investigated by determining the fluorescence enhancement of a series of fluorescent probes that are anilinonaphthalene sulfonic acid derivatives. Of the compounds tested, 2-anilinonaphthalene-6-sulfonic acid (2,6-ANS) exhibited the greatest enhancement under the conditions used (which would reflect both molar fluorescence enhancement and binding affinity) and exhibited more than 95% reversal upon addition of biotin. Thus, 2,6-ANS was chosen for more detailed characterization of the interaction with avidin. Only a single class of binding sites for 2,6-ANS was identified; the mean value for the Kd was 203 +/- 16 microM (X +/- 1 S.D.), and the molar ratio of 2,6-ANS binding sites to biotin binding sites was approx. 1. These results provide evidence that the biotin binding site and the 2,6-ANS binding site are at least partially overlapping, but the possibility that the probe binding site is altered by a conformational change induced by biotin binding cannot be excluded. At excitation = 328 nm and emission = 408 nm, the molar fluorescence of the bound probe was 6.8 +/- 1.0 microM-1 and that of the free probe was 0.061 +/- 0.008 microM-1 giving an enhancement ratio (molar fluorescence of bound probe/molar fluorescence of free probe) of 111 +/- 22. Upon binding, the wavelength of maximum fluorescence decreases. These findings also provide evidence that the fluorescence enhancement associated with the interaction of 2,6-ANS and avidin reflects the environment of the biotin binding site. The Kosower's Z factor, an empirical index of apolarity, was 82.1 for the 2,6-ANS binding site on avidin. This value reflects a degree of apolarity that is similar to apolar environments observed for substrate binding sites on several enzymes; although not the dominant factor, this environment may contribute to the strong binding of biotin.     

Colorimetric competitive inhibition method for the quantification of avidin, streptavidin and biotin.

A colorimetric competitive inhibition assay for avidin, streptavidin and biotin was developed. The method for avidin or streptavidin was based on the competitive binding between avidin or streptavidin and a streptavidin-enzyme conjugate for biotinylated dextrin immobilized on the surface of a microtitre plate. For biotin quantitation the competition is between free biotin and the immobilized biotin for the streptavidin-enzyme conjugate. The limits of detection which was determined as the concentration of competitor required to give 90% of maximal absorbency (100% inhibition) was approximately 20 ng/100 microl per assay for avidin and streptavidin and 0.4 pg/100 microl per assay for biotin. The methods are simple, rapid, highly sensitive and adaptable to high throughput analysis.     

The effect of N-bromosuccinimide on the sub-unit structure of avidin and its complexes with biotin

1. Each molecule of biotin bound to avidin protected four tryptophan residues from oxidation by N-bromosuccinimide, regardless of the occupancy of neighbouring binding sites in the four-sub-unit avidin molecule. 2. The oxidation products from avidin molecules in which some of the sites were occupied were separated on columns of Sephadex G-100. In the absence of biotin, oxidized avidin broke down into sub-units, which partly aggregated. When some of the sites were occupied by biotin, the only detectable products were completely oxidized avidin (sub-units and large aggregates) and unoxidized avidin-biotin complex (tetramer). Since the biotin-containing sub-units were randomly distributed before oxidation took place, they must have dissociated from the molecules containing oxidized sub-units and then reassociated to form the tetrameric avidin-biotin complex. 3. This reassociation still occurred in 3.5m-guanidinium chloride, which prevents the reassociation of unoccupied sub-units. During their brief existence in this medium, the sub-units of avidin-biotin complex were protected from oxidation by N-bromo-succinimide to the same extent as was the tetrameric complex. 4. It is concluded that sub-units of avidin-biotin complex do not readily lose their biotin, even in 3.5m-guanidinium chloride, and that monomeric biotin-binding species are probably present in solutions of avidin sub-units at guanidinium chloride concentrations between 3.0m and 3.5m.     

DNA condensation by high-affinity interaction with avidin

Avidin, the basic biotin-binding glycoprotein from chicken egg white, is known to interact with DNA, whereas streptavidin, its neutral non-glycosylated bacterial analog, does not. In the present study we investigated the DNA-binding properties of avidin. Its affinity for DNA in the presence and absence of biotin was compared with that of other positively charged molecules, namely the protein lysozyme, the cationic polymers polylysine and polyarginine and an avidin derivative with higher isoelectric point (pI approximately 11) in which most of the lysine residues were converted to homoarginines. Gel-shift assays, transmission electron microscopy and dynamic light scattering experiments demonstrated an unexpectedly strong interaction between avidin and DNA. The most pronounced gel-shift retardation occurred with the avidin-biotin complex, followed by avidin alone and then guanidylated avidin. Furthermore, ultrastructural and light-scattering studies showed that avidin assembles on the DNA molecule in an organized manner. The assembly leads to the formation of nanoparticles that are about 50-100 nm in size (DNA approximately 5 kb) and have a rod-like or toroidal shape. In these particles the DNA is highly condensed and one avidin is bound to each 18 +/- 4 DNA base pairs. The complexes are very stable even at high dilution ([DNA] =10 pM) and are not disrupted in the presence of buffers or salt (up to 200 mM NaCl). The other positively charged molecules also condense DNA and form particles with a globular shape. However, in this case, these particles disassemble by dilution or in the presence of low salt concentration. The results indicate that the interaction of avidin with DNA may also occur under physiological conditions, further enhanced by the presence of biotin. This DNA-binding property of avidin may thus shed light on a potentially new physiological role for the protein in its natural environment.     

Recombinant NeutraLite avidin: a non-glycosylated, acidic mutant of chicken avidin that exhibits high affinity for biotin and low non-specific binding properties

A recombinant non-glycosylated and acidic form of avidin was designed and expressed in soluble form in baculovirus-infected insect cells. The mutations were based on the same principles that guided the design of the chemically and enzymatically modified avidin derivative, known as NeutraLite Avidin. In this novel recombinant avidin derivative, five out of the eight arginine residues were replaced with neutral amino acids, and two of the lysine residues were replaced by glutamic acid. In addition, the carbohydrate-bearing asparagine-17 residue was altered to an isoleucine, according to the known sequences of avidin-related genes. The resultant mutant protein, termed recombinant NeutraLite Avidin, exhibited superior properties compared to those of avidin, streptavidin and the conventional NeutraLite Avidin, prepared by chemo-enzymatic means. In this context, the recombinant mutant is a single molecular species, which possesses strong biotin-binding characteristics. Due to its acidic pI, it is relatively free from non-specific binding to DNA and cells. The recombinant NeutraLite Avidin retains seven lysines per subunit, which are available for further conjugation and derivatization.     

Electrochemical fabrication and evaluation of highly sensitive nanorod-modified electrodes for a biotin/avidin system

Bioaffinity sensors need to be rapid, specific, and highly sensitive. To realize these features, electrodes that can elicit high electrochemical performance are necessary. In this study, we developed nanorod array electrode and performed cyclic voltammetry (CV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) experiments to study the interfacial properties of the nanorod array electrode with Fe(CN)(6)(3-/4-) as the redox molecules. Results showed that both the CV and EIS measurements captured very well the resistive and capacitive changes due to the adsorption of functionalizing molecules and the coupling between avidin and biotin. The EIS measurements were more sensitive in discriminating small changes caused by the surface adsorption of various molecules. The use of avidin-functionalized gold nanorod modified electrodes had led to much increased detection sensitivity along with a detection-limit as low as 1 ng/mL of biotin.     

Specific binding of avidin to biotin containing lipid lamella surfaces studied with monolayers and liposomes

The interaction of avidin (from egg white) with phospholipid (monolayer and bilayer) model membranes containing biotin-conjugated phospholipids has been studied. In the first part, using surface sensitive techniques (ellipsometry and surface plasmon resonance) we demonstrated that the nonspecific adsorption of avidin to phospholipid lamella could be abolished by adding an amount of Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, or Ba²⁺ that led to an electrostatic interaction. The specific binding of avidin to lipid mixtures containing biotin-conjugated phospholipids was obviously composition dependent. The ratio 1:12 of a B-DPPE/DPPE mixture was found to be the optimum molar ratio. When we compared the results from the surface sensitive techniques with those from the electron micrographs of a two dimensional crystal of avidin (obtained in our laboratory), the optimum ratio was found to be determined by the effect of lateral steric hindrance. In the second part, we observed the pattern of the layers of fluorescently labeled phospholipid and adsorbed proteins with a home-made micro fluorescence film balance. The fluorescence images showed that avidin was preferentially bound to the receptors that were in the fluid domains. Further, with a sensitive fluoresence assay method, the effect of the phase behavior of liposomes on the specific binding of avidin was measured. This showed that avidin interacted with biotin-lipid more weakly in the gel state liposome than in the liquid state liposome. The major conclusion was that the binding of avidin to a membrane bound model receptor was significantly restricted by two factors: one was the lateral steric hindrance and the other was the fluidity of the model membrane.Abbreviations B-DPPE Biotinyl dipalmitoylphosphatidyl ethanolamine - B-DMPE Biotinyl dimyristoylphosphatidyl ethanolamine - BNHS d-biotin-N-hydroxysuccinimide ester - DMPA dimyristoylphosphatidyl acid - DMPC dimyristoylphosphatidyl choline - DMPS dimyristoylphosphatidyl serine - DOPC dioleoylphosphatidyl choline - DPPC dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline - DPPE dipalmitoylphosphatidyl ethanolamine - FITC fluorescein isothiocyanate - RDB-DOPE N(Lissamine rhodamine B sulfonyl) dioleoyl phosphatidylethanolamine - SPR surface plasmon resonance Correspondence to: S. F. Sui     

Improved DNA chip with poly(amidoamine) dendrimer peripherally modified with biotin and avidin

Important properties for a biosensor are the sensitive detection of target DNA at low concentration, the specific and accurate distinction of the target and other DNA having a similar sequence, and measurement capability over a wide range of target concentrations. To these ends, generation 3 polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimer was used to improve DNA chip properties. PAMAM dendrimer surface amine moieties were modified to biotin and immobilized on glass slides using biotin-avidin conjugation. The surface morphologies of the avidin-biotin-dendrimer complexes were observed using atomic force microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Detection sensitivity for fluorescence-labeled target DNA increased approximately 4-fold by the dendrimer coating. Dendrimer coating also markedly improved the dynamic range and detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms. Dendrimer complex morphology had little effect on the sensitivity.     

UV resonance Raman study of streptavidin binding of biotin and 2-iminobiotin: comparison with avidin

UV resonance Raman (UVRR) spectroscopy is used to study the binding of biotin and 2-iminobiotin by streptavidin, and the results are compared to those previously obtained from the avidin-biotin complex and new data from the avidin-2-iminobiotin complex. UVRR difference spectroscopy using 244-nm excitation reveals changes to the tyrosine (Tyr) and tryptophan (Trp) residues of both proteins upon complex formation. Avidin has four Trp and only one Tyr residue, while streptavidin has eight Trp and six Tyr residues. The spectral changes observed in streptavidin upon the addition of biotin are similar to those observed for avidin. However, the intensity enhancements observed for the streptavidin Trp Raman bands are less than those observed with avidin. The changes observed in the streptavidin Tyr bands are similar to those observed for avidin and are assigned exclusively to the binding site Tyr 43 residue. The Trp and Tyr band changes are due to the exclusion of water and addition of biotin, resulting in a more hydrophobic environment for the binding site residues. The addition of 2-iminobiotin results in spectral changes to both the streptavidin and avidin Trp bands that are very similar to those observed upon the addition of biotin in each protein. The changes to the Tyr bands are very different than those observed with the addition of biotin, and similar spectral changes are observed in both streptavidin and avidin. This is attributable to hydrogen bond changes to the binding site Tyr residue in each protein, and the similar Tyr difference features in both proteins supports the exclusive assignment of the streptavidin Tyr difference features to the binding site Tyr 43.