Differential diagnosis of oncocytic lesions of the breast and thyroid utilizing a semiquantitative approach.

OBJECTIVE: To assess whether a light microscopic, semiquantitative approach could reliably distinguish between benign nonneoplastic, benign neoplastic and malignant oncocytic lesions of the breast and thyroid. STUDY DESIGN: Alcohol-fixed, Papanicolaou-stained fine needle aspiration smears of histologically proven goiter and chronic thyroiditis (18 cases), Hürthle cell adenomas (7 cases), Hürthle cell carcinomas (6 cases), fibrocystic disease (17 cases), papillomas and papillomatosis (7 cases) and apocrine carcinomas (6 cases) were rated by three independent observers using the following 10 cytologic criteria: cellularity, nuclear-cytoplasmic ratio, multinucleation, nuclear size, nuclear shape, anisonucleosis, multinucleolation, nucleolar-nuclear ratio, nucleolar size and nucleolar shape. Each of these 10 cytologic criteria was rated using a 1-3 scale. The scores for all 10 features were summed to give a total score for each case. The total scores were statistically analyzed to determine the validity and reproducibility of the summed criteria. RESULTS: The summed criteria of the total scores were reproducible between the three observers, with standard deviations ranging from 1.36 to 2.88 for thyroid and 1.72 to 2.00 for breast oncocytic lesions. The ability of the total scores to differentiate benign from malignant oncocytic lesions of the breast and thyroid was confirmed by a positive predictive value for malignancy of 67% for thyroid and 72% for breast and a negative predictive value for malignancy of 100% for nonneoplastic oncocytic lesions and > 90% for benign oncocytic neoplasms in both. The Kruskal-Wallis test revealed that the total scores were able to distinguish three diagnostic categories of nonneoplastic, benign neoplastic and malignant oncocytic breast and thyroid lesions, with P < .005. CONCLUSION: Without the expenditures of additional time, costs or materials, this semiquantitative approach compared favorably with contemporary morphometric studies involving the differential diagnosis of oncocytic cell pathology in fine needle aspiration cytology.     

Ki-67 and AgNOR proliferative markers as diagnostic adjuncts to fine needle aspiration cytology of thyroid follicular lesions

OBJECTIVE: To differentiate hyperplastic nodules (HPN), follicular adenoma (FA) and follicular carcinoma (FCA) of the thyroid by cytomorphologic features combined with argyrophilic nucleolar organizer regions (AgNORs) and Ki-67 proliferative markers on fine needle aspiration cytology. STUDY DESIGN: Cytomorphologic patterns, along with two proliferation markers, Ki-67 and AgNORs, in fine needle aspirates of 123 histologically confirmed cases of thyroid follicular lesions, including 39 hyperplastic nodules, 70 follicular adenomas and 14 cases of follicular carcinomas, were recorded. RESULTS: Mean AgNOR (mAgNOR) counts and Ki-67 labelling index (LI) were consistently higher in FCA in comparison to FA and HPN irrespective of the cytologic patterns in fine needle aspiration smears. Between benign and malignant lesions, an overlap of 1.83% at the cutoff point of 4.0 was observed in cases of mAgNORs, whereas it was 11.09% at a cutoff of 5.0 in cases of Ki-67 LI. CONCLUSION: mAgNOR counting in fine needle aspiration smears is more sensitive, simple and cost effective as compared to Ki-67 LI for differentiating between benign and malignant thyroid follicular neoplasms.     

The gray zone in breast fine needle aspiration cytology. How to report on it?

OBJECTIVE: To study the "gray zone" in breast fine needle aspiration cytology in which an unequivocal diagnosis cannot be reached with fine needle aspiration cytology findings. STUDY DESIGN: This study compared cytology and histopathology of 72 breast lesions in which an initial cytologic diagnosis of atypia was given. RESULTS: There were 36 benign (50%) and 36 malignant (50%) histologic biopsy cases in the cytologic atypia group. Anisonucleosis, chromatin and nuclear membrane irregularity, and presence of myoepithelial cells were significantly different in benign and malignant cases. CONCLUSION: The gray zone in breast fine needle aspiration cytology is a broad spectrum that changes from proliferative fibrocystic disease to sclerosing adenosis to malignancy. Diagnosing gray zone pathology as atypical in fine needle aspiration cytology causes no delay in treatment as excisional biopsy is recommended for all equivocal cases.     

The number of nucleoli in benign and malignant thyroid lesions: a useful diagnostic sign in cytological preparations

The slides of fine needle aspiration cytology specimens from 99 cases of cold thyroid nodules with known histology were reviewed and the number of nucleoli per nucleus counted and correlated with the different histopathological groups. Significant differences were observed between benign and malignant thyroid lesions in the number of nucleoli in the cytological material. Lower values were present in nodular goitres and follicular adenomas compared to carcinomas. In benign lesions the majority of nuclei contained one nucleolus and nuclei with two, three or more nucleoli were less frequent than in follicular, papillary, medullary and anaplastic carcinomas. Only one case of follicular adenoma had cells containing three or more nucleoli compared to more than half the cases of follicular carcinoma.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of ovarian lesions

OBJECTIVE: To assess the diagnostic value of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in ovarian lesions. STUDY DESIGN: Sixty-two fine needle aspirations of varied ovarian masses were performed between January 2000 and February 2003. Aspiration material was obtained from fresh tissues at the time of frozen section before dissection of the specimens. The slides were evaluated by a pathologist who was blinded to the gross findings and histopathologic diagnosis. RESULTS: A total of 62.9% of cases were assessed as malignant and 30.6% as benign. Two false positive and 2 false negative cases occurred. In our series the overall sensitivity and specificity were 95.1% and 90.4%, respectively. Seven benign and 15 malignant lesions could be subclassified specifically. CONCLUSION: We studied excised specimens, but since ovarian masses are reachable by laparoscopically and ultrasonographically guided aspiration, FNAC can be used for diagnoses of these lesions. If a multidisciplinary approach can be carried out in patients with ovarian lesions, cytopathologic interpretation can provide optimum benefits.     

Thyroid neoplasms. Can we do any better with quantitative cytology?

The differential diagnosis of thyroid neoplasms by routine cytology presents major difficulties. We therefore looked for measurable nuclear parameters that could be generated from Feulgen-stained smears obtained by fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB). These parameters would then be used to differentiate between benign and malignant lesions. Seventy-six patients whose cold thyroid nodule was surgically excised after FNAB and examined by a pathologist were used in this study: 56 benign, 18 malignant and 2 atypical adenomas. A set of 3,662 cells from the 33 benign cases was compared with the set of 1,712 cells from the 11 malignant nodules. Discrimination between the two populations was based on four nuclear features ranked according to their discriminating power. The first ranked was a textural parameter, followed by a densitometric and finally two other textural parameters. The rate of nuclei that could be regarded as benign was computed for each case using the ranked parameters. The average rate for the 33 benign cases was 85% (50.2 = 100%, set at the 95% confidence interval). In a prospective study of the 32 remaining patients, sensitivity and specificity were, respectively, 92% and 88%, which were higher than those obtained by conventional cytology.     

Computed tomography-guided fine needle aspiration of peripheral lung opacities. An initial diagnostic procedure?

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the results of computed tomography (CT)-guided fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology following negative fiberoptic bronchoscopy and sputum cytology. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective study of 64 patients who underwent CT-guided needle aspiration of lung opacities over one year. Following a review of the CT studies, patients were selected according to image characteristics of a primary neoplasm and pleural effusion in cases with pleural lesions. The lesions were classified into three categories--intrapulmonary and peripheral pulmonary, pleuropulmonary and pleural--and were localized and aspirated under CT using a fine needle (22-23 gauge) for obtaining cellular material. Lesions diagnosed as benign on FNA cytology were followed by serial CT scans for a period of two years at six-month intervals. RESULTS: Thirty-nine of 64 (61%) lesions were diagnosed as malignant on FNA cytology and 25 of 64 (39%) as benign. There was one false negative case. There were no serious complications from the procedure. CONCLUSION: FNA under CT guidance may be applied as the initial procedure in the diagnosis of peripheral malignant pulmonary lesions, rendering a high diagnostic yield.     

Value of repeated fine needle aspiration cytology in patients with nodular goiter

OBJECTIVE: To assess the value of reaspiration cytology in benign nodular thyroid disease. DESIGN: We prospectively studied 400 patients (365 women, 35 men) aged 46 years (18-89) with nodular thyroid disease and initial benign fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). Reaspiration of the same nodule was performed in a median follow-up time of 14 months (6-18). RESULTS: Repeat FNAC was benign in 346 patients (86.5%), insufficient for diagnosis in 42 (10.5%), suspicious in 16 (2.5%) and malignant in 2 (0.5%). All diagnostic changes to suspicious malignant cytology took place in patients with solitary nodules. Surgery confirmed thyroid cancer in the 2 patients with malignant cytology, in 5 of 10 patients with suspicious cytology and in none of 39 patients with benign cytology who underwent surgery for other reasons. Clinical changes (size increase or local symptoms) were not related to changes in cytologic diagnosis after a second aspiration, nor with the results of the biopsy. CONCLUSION: Repeat aspiration cytology of thyroid nodules may correct initial false negative results because of cytologic misdiagnosis, occurring in 1.75% of patients, whereas clinical changes did not contribute to diagnosis change. Repeat aspiration cytology is recommended in all patients with nodular goiter.     

Evaluation of accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology in BI‐RADS3 category breast lesions: cytohistological correlation in 337 cases

C. Engohan‐Aloghe, N. Hottat, J. Cosaert, R. Boutemy, I. Fayt and J.‐C. Noël
Evaluation of accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology in BI‐RADS3 category breast lesions: cytohistological correlation in 337 cases Objective: To evaluate the accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in BI‐RADS3 breast lesions. Methods: Between January 2004 and December 2007, 337 cases from BI‐RADS3 lesions underwent FNAC. Three to six needle passes were made on each patient. In 67 cases (20%) a histological biopsy was performed. Cytological and histological interpretations were performed by the same pathologist. Results: The histological diagnosis showed that 88% (59/67) of BI‐RADS3 breast lesions were benign. Only 6% (4/67) were malignant, consisting of ductal carcinoma in situ and infiltrating ductal carcinoma. Conclusion: BI‐RADS3 lesions remain disruptive in their management. However, the correlation between cytology and histology showed that most of these lesions were benign and that finally FNAC remains a useful and accurate test in the management of these lesions.     

Evaluating the diagnostic significance of nuclear grooves in thyroid fine needle aspirates with a semiquantitative approach

OBJECTIVE: To clarify the diagnostic significance of nuclear grooves in thyroid fine needle aspirates, to search for other associated nuclear features and to identify possible diagnostic pitfalls. STUDY DESIGN: In total, 67 fine needle aspiration cases were retrospectively reviewed for selected nuclear features, including grooves, intranuclear cytoplasmic invaginations, enlargement, pleomorphism and status of nucleoli. A semiquantitative method was used to estimate the percentage of nuclear grooves in 5 high-power fields with the most frequent nuclear grooves. RESULTS: Unequivocal intranuclear cytoplasmic invaginations were a specific diagnostic feature of papillary carcinoma. In the absence of intranuclear cytoplasmic invaginations, the presence of > or = 20% nuclear grooves was virtually diagnostic of thyroid neoplasms, predominantly papillary carcinoma. Less than 10% of nuclear grooves virtually eliminated the possibility of papillary carcinoma. However, 10-19% of nuclear grooves may be seen in papillary carcinoma and benign lesions; therefore, such cases fell into the diagnostic category of "atypical cytology" or "indeterminate" cytology. Nuclear enlargement with elongation was a readily identifiable feature usually associated with nuclear grooves. Significant pleomorphism was more commonly seen in papillary carcinoma than in benign lesions. CONCLUSION: A semiquantitative method is helpful when nuclear grooves are encountered in thyroid cytology in the absence of other diagnostic features. It can significantly improve the diagnostic specificity of nuclear grooves for papillary carcinoma.     

Importance of FNAC in the detection of tumours within multinodular goitre of the thyroid

The primary challenge in the management of a multinodular thyroid gland is to rule out malignancy. The present study was undertaken to assess the value of preoperative ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in diagnosing tumours of the thyroid gland. Of the 80 patients operated for multinodular lesions, malignant tumours were found in 29 and benign tumours in 36 patients (81%) and non-tumorous lesions in 15 (19%) patients. Compared with the histopathological postoperative diagnosis, the overall sensitivity of FNAC was 85% and specificity 88%. Current morphological diagnosis of the nodules in multinodular goitre requires thorough preoperative examination, including ultrasound-guided FNAC in order to establish the appropriate management.     

Posters. P17 Accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology in diagnosis of thyroid swellings

Introduction Fine needle aspiration cytology is regarded as the gold standard investigation in diagnosis of thyroid swellings. Published data suggest an overall accuracy rate of 75% 1 in the detection of thyroid malignancy. The aim of this study was to determine the accuracy of FNA cytology in detection of thyroid malignancy in our surgical unit. Methods Between 1989–2002, 144 patients who underwent thyroid resection by single consultant surgeon and who had pre‐operative FNA were enrolled in this retrospective study. The pre‐operative FNA results were compared with definitive histological diagnosis following thyroid resection. Fine needle aspiration cytology was performed using aspirate and non‐aspirate techniques on each thyroid swelling. The cytological sample was assessed by a single cytopathologist and was classified as inadequate, non‐neoplastic, neoplastic, suspicious or indeterminate. The histology was classified as non‐neoplastic (benign) and neoplastic (malignant). Results Fine needle aspiration cytology analysis revealed 94 (13.88%) non‐neoplastic, six (65.27%) neoplastic and 20 (4.16%) suspicious aspirates. Twenty (13.88%) samples were inadequate and four (2.77%) samples were indeterminate. Histological analysis showed 118 (81.94%) benign, 26 (18.05%) malignant specimens. Fine needle aspiration cytology had a sensitivity, specificity and accuracy rate of 52.6%, 86.6% and 79.1%, respectively for diagnosing thyroid malignancy. Conclusion The results are comparable with the current published data and demonstrate that FNA cytology in our hands is accurate investigation for pre‐operative diagnosis for the detection of thyroid malignancy.     

Papillary breast lesions diagnosed on cytology. Profile of 65 cases

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the cytologic features of nipple discharge and fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic smears from breast lesions reported as showing papillary features and to correlate them with histopathologic features. STUDY DESIGN: The study group consisted of FNA smears and/or nipple discharge smears from 65 breast lesions diagnosed on cytology as duct papilloma, papillary lesion, fibrocystic condition, fibroadenoma, papillary neoplasm or papillary carcinoma. Cytomorphologic features assessed included cellularity, cell pattern (clusters, papillary, 3-dimensionality, etc.) and cell characteristics (monomorphism, pleomorphism, apocrine change, plasmacytoid features). Histological material was available for review and cytohistologic correlation in all cases. RESULTS: Forty-six specimens were FNA smears, and 16 were nipple discharge smears; in 3 cases FNA and nipple discharge cytologic smears were available for review. Cytologic study could predict the presence of a papillary pattern in all neoplasms with pure or focal papillary differentiation. There was an overlap in cytomorphologic features between papillary and nonpapillary benign lesions as well as between benign and malignant papillary neoplasms. Frank blood in the aspirate, cell dissociation and atypia, however, were more frequent in the last. CONCLUSION: Overlap of cytologic features in nonneoplastic and neoplastic benign papillary lesions and between benign and malignant papillary neoplasms necessitates histologic evaluation in all cases diagnosed as papillary on cytology. Since 49.2% of lesions showing papillary features on cytology prove to be malignant, all cases reported as papillary on cytology should be excised urgently for histologic assessment.     

Expression of cytokeratin 19 and protein p63 in fine needle aspiration biopsy of papillary thyroid carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the immunocytochemical distribution of CK19 and p63 on archival cytologic smears of 27 papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTCs), 22 benign thyroid lesions and 5 malignant non-PTC lesions. STUDY DESIGN: Archival cytologic smears of 27 papillary carcinomas, 22 benign thyroid lesions and 5 malignant nonpapillary carcinomas were processed for immunocytochemical detection of CK19 and p63, and results were compared. RESULTS: CK19 showed strong cytoplasmic staining in 22/27 fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNABs) of PTCs, in 5 benign lesions and in 4 malignant lesions of the control group. p63 Positivity was present in FNABs of 20/27 PTC and in 1 FNAB of nodular hyperplasia. Eighteen FNABs of PTC (66.6%) showed both strong CK19 staining and p63-positive cells, whereas none of the control cases showed coexpression of CK19 and p63. CONCLUSION: Coexistence of strong CK19 positivity and p63-positive cells can enhance the cytologic diagnosis of PTC.     

Proteomic identification of new biomarkers and application in thyroid cytology

OBJECTIVE: To validate proteins identified by proteomics as potentially usable markers in thyroid pathology. STUDY DESIGN: Frozen sections of thyroid tumors were manually micro-dissected and proteins extracted. Two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis and subsequent liquid chromatography/mass spectroscopy were performed, and differentially expressed proteins were identified. Validation of candidates for tumor markers (galectin-1, galectin-3, S100C and voltage-dependent anion channel 1 [VDAC1]) was done by immunohistochemistry in 21 cell blocks from fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNAB) and corresponding histology specimens (13 cases). RESULTS: Galectin-3 was negative in benign lesions and positive in FNAB from papillary carcinoma (5 of 5), follicular variant of papillary carcinoma (1 of 4) and follicular carcinoma (1 of 2). S100C was positive in some benign lesions: hyperplasia (2 of 4), goiter (1 of 3) and follicular adenoma (1 of 3), with predominantly nuclear pattern of staining. S100C was positive in malignant lesions, showing cytoplasmic location. Galectin-1 was negative in benign lesions and positive in follicular carcinoma (1 of 2), papillary carcinoma (2 of 5) and follicular variant of papillary carcinoma (1 of 4). VDAC1 was detected in benign and malignant lesions, showing a strong positivity in follicular carcinomas. CONCLUSION: Immunohistochemical validation of potential markers is a crucial step before clinical application in diagnosis. Galectin-3, galectin-1 and S100C can be used to help in discriminating benign and malignant thyroid lesions.     

Diagnostic pitfalls in fine needle aspiration cytology of atypical apocrine metaplasia in a breast lesion. A case report

BACKGROUND: Apocrine metaplastic cells are frequently encountered in fine needle aspirates of breast lesions. Atypical apocrine metaplastic cells with signet ring features can also occur, and their presence may present a diagnostic dilemma in the differentiation of benign versus malignant lesions. CASE: A fine needle aspirate of a 2.5 x 1.0-cm, subareolar mass in a 47-year-old female showed atypical cells with signet ring morphology. Also present were clusters of cells that were enlarged and showed nuclear atypia, prominent nucleoli and cytoplasmic granules. Papillary cohesive clusters of ductal cells were also identified. The fine needle aspiration diagnosis was mucinous carcinoma. The nodule was excised, and the histologic diagnosis was sclerosing ductal papilloma with atypical apocrine metaplasia. CONCLUSION: Atypical apocrine cells can be misinterpreted as mucinous carcinoma or usual duct adenocarcinoma on fine needle aspiration cytology. We present clues that may help in rendering the correct interpretation.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of invasive cribriform carcinoma of the breast with osteoclastlike giant cells: a case report

BACKGROUND: Nonneoplastic osteoclastlike giant cells are occasionally associated with carcinoma of the breast, pancreatobiliary and gastrointestinal systems. In the breast, this uncommon stromal response is seen mainly in invasive carcinoma with low grade cytology, among which invasive cribriform carcinoma is the classic example. Details of the fine needle aspiration cytology of this phenomenon, especially in thin-layer preparations, have been described rarely. CASE: The fine needle aspiration cytology of an invasive cribriform carcinoma of the breast occurred in a 66-year-old woman. Cytology showed cohesive sheets and three-dimensional cribriform clusters of bland-looking and mitotically inactive ductal cells in a blood-stained background. Scattered multinucleated, osteoclastlike giant cells, some containing hemosiderin granules, were also seen. Myoepithelial cells and naked nuclei were not obvious. The cellular composition was more discernible in liquid-based cytologic preparations. Histologic examination of the excisional biopsy showed an invasive cribriform carcinoma associated with many osteoclastlike giant cells in a hypervascular stroma. CONCLUSION: In view of the extremely low grade cytology of the malignant ductal cells, invasive cribriform carcinoma may closely mimic benign proliferative breast diseases on fine needle aspiration biopsy. Recognition of this special relationship with osteoclastlike giant cells, which are rarely present in certain subtypes of breast cancer but not benign lesions, can help to arrive at a correct cytologic diagnosis.     

Ag-NOR technique in fine needle aspiration cytology of salivary gland masses.

Because of their complexity, salivary gland lesions are often difficult to identify correctly with fine needle aspiration cytology. To see whether the Ag-NOR staining technique for nucleolar organizer regions would be useful in this respect, we studied a series of smears from benign and malignant salivary gland lesions. The smears, previously treated with Papanicolaou and May-Grünwald-Giemsa stain, were destained and restained with Ag-NOR silver. The correlation between the cytologic-histologic diagnosis and the number of Ag-NORs in benign (sialadenitis, pleomorphic adenoma, oncocytoma and Warthin's tumor) and malignant lesions (adenoid cystic carcinoma, adenocarcinoma, carcinoma ex pleomorphic adenoma and squamous carcinoma) was statistically significant (P = less than .05). The Ag-NOR technique appears useful in the diagnosis of salivary gland lesions. One great advantage is that previously stained slides can be reused for silver staining, thus providing an excellent guide to the diagnosis, especially in doubtful cases and when corresponding histologic specimens or extra unstained slides are unavailable.     

Usefulness of fine needle aspiration of the thyroid in an endemic goiter region

The accuracy of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of the thyroid was addressed in 142 nodular goiters from an endemic goiter region. The aspirations and their interpretation were based on the methodology of the Karolinska Hospital. For practical purposes, the follicular lesions were divided into type I (benign), type II (atypical benign) and type III (suspicious). Excluding the follicular lesions, the cytohistologic agreement for the whole series was 87%, with a correlation of 81.5% for carcinomas. The type I and type II follicular lesions were benign on histologic grounds; 39% of the carcinomas were detected in the type III follicular lesions. The 0.7% false-positive diagnoses increased to 15% when type III follicular lesions were included. No false negatives were recorded. These observations, together with the increase of surgically resected thyroid carcinomas after FNA was accepted as a diagnostic modality, indicate that FNA biopsy of the thyroid is an accurate diagnostic method and is useful in selecting patients for subsequent surgery in areas of endemic goiter.     

Improved breast cytology results with near patient FNA diagnosis

OBJECTIVE: To examine the impact of a cytopathologist using near patient fine needle aspiration diagnosis (NPFD) for breast diagnosis. STUDY DESIGN: The cytology results of all palpable solid breast lesions undergoing fine needle aspiration (FNA) during a two-year period were prospectively audited and categorized as definitely benign or malignant (definite), probably benign, indeterminate or suspicious (indefinite) or unsatisfactory. The final diagnosis (benign or malignant) was determined from a review of patients' charts and a survey of patients' family physicians. Aspirates were performed by surgical staffand reported either later (non-NPFD) or by NPFD. RESULTS: Of 720 FNAs, 230 were by NPFD and 490 by non-NPFD. NPFD was associated with a significantly greater proportion of definite reports (91.9% versus 82.4%). NPFD of discrete breast lumps was associated with higher specificity (89.1% versus 67.5%) and a lower unsatisfactory rate (9.4% versus 19.6%) than non-NPFD. NPFD did not improve the unsatisfactory rate of FNAs from diffuse breast thickenings. CONCLUSION: FNA by a dedicated specialist and immediate reporting should be an integral part of a breast diagnostic service.