Immune and inflammatory responses in sudden infant death syndrome

Infancy is a time of unparalleled infection exposure. Coming from the privilege of the uterus, the newborn infant must make appropriate immune responses following infection that eliminates the infection but protects the host. There is evidence that in sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) subjects there is a background of recent 'trivial' infection and immunological/inflammatory reactivity. This immunological/inflammatory reactivity is seen in enhanced pulmonary immunoglobulins and T-cell activation. It may be that in certain SIDS cases a trivial infection triggers an exaggerated inflammatory response, inducing cytokine cascades and eventual demise of the infant.     

Respiratory viruses and sudden infant death.

Viruses were shown to be present in the respiratory tract in 200 of 763 cases of the sudden infant death syndrome studied in the nine years 1974-82. Epidemiological and pathological evidence suggested that the distribution of viruses in the sudden infant death syndrome differs between infants aged 3 months or less and those aged over 3 months: the incidence of detection of virus was 14% in the younger group compared with 39% in the older group. The distribution of the viruses in these two groups was compared with that in 1341 live infants with respiratory virus infections. Adenovirus, influenza virus, parainfluenza virus, and rhinovirus had similar distribution among the victims of the sudden infant death syndrome and live controls. The incidence of detection of respiratory syncytial virus was increased in the older infants dying of the sudden infant death syndrome (90% of the cases detected) compared with the older group of live infants (53%). Antibody studies, detection of virus, and epidemiological data suggest that respiratory syncytial virus may be a precipitating factor of sudden death in older infants.     

Role of respiratory viruses in childhood mortality.

Respiratory viruses have been identified at necropsy in the lungs of 13 out of 24 children who died with observed acute respiratory illness. The histological appearances of the lungs supported the association between virus and death in each of these 13 children and suggested an unidentified virus aetiology in a further five cases. Histological appearances compatible with bacterial infection were found in the lungs of only two of the 24 children. Similar virus and histological findings have been reported in about one-third of victims of the sudden infant death syndrome (cot deaths), indicating a rapid unobserved respiratory virus infection as the most likely mode of death in this group. Evidence that respiratory viruses may be involved in a larger proportion of sudden unexpected deaths, perhaps as antigens in a hypersensitivity reaction, is discussed. Respiratory viruses seem the major identifiable agents contributing to the maintenance of the postneonatal mortality rate since acute respiratory illness and the sudden infant death syndrome together account for about two-thirds of deaths at this age.     

Preliminary investigation of lethally toxic sera of sudden infant death syndrome victims and neutralisation by commercially available immunoglobulins and adult sera

The aim of the study was to test the hypotheses (i) that sudden infant death syndrome sera are toxic to 11-day old chick embryos and (ii) that such a toxicity can be counteracted by immunoglobulin or adult sera. Serum samples from 11 SIDS victims and five controls were tested for lethal toxicity in the chick embryo bioassay. Five serum samples were used to challenge chick embryos injected with the following: sudden infant death syndrome serum plus Hank's balanced salt solution; Hank's balanced salt solution alone; sudden infant death syndrome serum plus 3% w/v commercial immunoglobulin; sudden infant death syndrome serum plus 6% w/v immunoglobulin; sudden infant death syndrome serum plus pooled sera of 40 healthy adults. Results obtained revealed that Hank's balanced salt solution, the pooled adult serum and the commercial immunoglobulin were all non-lethal, in the chick embryo test system. By contrast. 10 sudden infant death syndrome victims yielded sera containing lethal levels of toxin(s) compared to 2/5 controls which was statistically significant (P < 0.05, Fischer's exact test). In the tests of sudden infant death syndrome serum plus immunoglobulin or pooled adult serum, the lethality of sudden infant death syndrome serum was abolished in all cases. The reduction in toxicity of individual sudden infant death syndrome serum plus immunoglobulin or pooled adult serum was often statistically significant (P<0.05-P<0.00005, Fischer's exact test). We conclude that lethal levels of toxin are present in sudden infant death syndrome sera and that they can be neutralised by normal immune serum. These results indicate that passive immunisation is a potential treatment to protect babies considered at risk from sudden infant death syndrome.     

Respiratory and heart rate patterns in infants destined to be victims of sudden infant death syndrome: average rates and their variability measured over 24 hours.

From a prospective study in which 24 hour recordings of the electrocardiogram and respiratory activity (abdominal wall movement) were made on a population of full term infants, 22 recordings were obtained from 16 infants who later were victims of the sudden infant death syndrome. The average heart rate, average heart rate variability, average breath to breath interval, and average breath to breath interval variability over the whole of each recording for the 22 recordings were compared with those from a control group of 324 infants selected at random from the rest of the population. No significance was found in the number of recordings from those infants who suffered the sudden infant death syndrome which lay outside the 5th-95th percentile range of the control group for the four variables studied. In a group comparison no difference was found between the sudden infant death syndrome group and the controls either in terms of the respiratory variables studied or in terms of the average heart rate variability. The results did, however, suggest that there may be a group difference in terms of the average instantaneous heart rate.     

Sudden infant death syndrome and Canadian Aboriginals: bacteria and infections

Aboriginal populations in Canada, America and Australia have higher incidences of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) than non-Aboriginal groups. Canadian Aboriginal populations (known also as first nation, native or Indian) experience infant morbidity/mortality rates 3-7 times that of non-Aboriginals, with upper track respiratory infection and SIDS recorded as the leading causes. The aim of this investigation was to examine the home environment of Aboriginal infants, particularly during winter months when respiratory tract infections and SIDS are more common. Environmental bacteria, fungi and air particulates were examined in the residences of Aboriginal infants during visits to individual homes on an Aboriginal reserve. The physical histories of SIDS victims were gathered from medical files. Air and surfaces were sampled by agar strips which were processed by a commercial laboratory. The levels of fungi, bacteria and air particulate rates recorded in the reserve homes of Aboriginal infants registered levels considered to be detrimental to the health of the inhabitants. Such extreme levels could contribute to the high incidence of respiratory disease and SIDS experienced by Canadian Aboriginal infants.     

Exposure to cigarette smoke, a major risk factor for sudden infant death syndrome: effects of cigarette smoke on inflammatory responses to viral infection and bacterial toxins

Exposure to cigarette smoke is a major risk factor for sudden infant death syndrome and also for respiratory infections in children. It has been suggested that toxigenic bacteria colonizing the respiratory tract might play a role in some cases of sudden infant death syndrome and nicotine has been demonstrated to enhance the lethality of bacterial toxins in a model system. Pyrogenic toxins of Staphylococcus aureus have been identified in tissues of infants who died of sudden infant death syndrome. It has been suggested that some of these deaths were due to induction of inflammatory mediators by infectious agents during a period when infants are less able to control these responses. The aim of this study was to assess the effects of a water-soluble cigarette smoke extract on the production of tumor necrosis factor alpha and nitric oxide from human monocytes in response to staphylococcal toxic shock syndrome toxin 1 or infection of the monocytes with respiratory syncytial virus. Cell culture supernatants were examined by a bioassay using mouse fibroblasts (L-929 cell line) for tumor necrosis factor alpha activity and by a spectrophotometric method for nitrite. Compared with monocytes incubated with medium only, monocytes incubated with any of the factors or their combinations tested in the study released higher levels of tumor necrosis factor alpha and lower levels of nitric oxide. Incubation with cigarette smoke extract increased tumor necrosis factor alpha from respiratory syncytial virus-infected cells while it decreased tumor necrosis factor alpha from cells incubated with toxic shock syndrome toxin. Incubation with cigarette smoke extract decreased the nitric oxide production from respiratory syncytial virus-infected cells while it increased the nitric oxide production from cells incubated with toxic shock syndrome toxin. Monocytes from a minority of individuals demonstrated extreme tumor necrosis factor alpha responses and/or very high or very low nitric oxide. The proportion of samples in which extreme responses with a very high tumor necrosis factor alpha and very low nitric oxide were detected was increased in the presence of the three agents to 20% compared with 0% observed with toxic shock syndrome toxin 1 or 4% observed with cigarette smoke extract or respiratory syncytial virus.     

Ethnic differences in mortality from sudden infant death syndrome in New Zealand.

OBJECTIVES--To examine the factors which might explain the higher mortality from sudden infant death syndrome in Maori infants (7.4/1000 live births in 1986 compared with 3.6 in non-Maori children). DESIGN--A large nationwide case control study. SETTING--New Zealand. 485 infants who died of sudden infant death syndrome were compared with 1800 control infants. There were 229 Maori and 240 non-Maori cases of sudden infant death syndrome (16 cases unassigned) and 353 Maori and 1410 non-Maori controls (37 unassigned). RESULTS--Maori infants had 3.81 times the risk (95% confidence interval 3.06 to 4.76) of sudden infant death syndrome compared with non-Maori infants. The risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome within groups were remarkably similar. When Maori and non-Maori controls were compared the prevalence of many of the known risk factors was higher in Maori infants. In particular, mothers were socioeconomically disadvantaged, younger, and more likely to smoke and their infants were of lower birth weight and more likely to share a bed with another person. Multivariate analysis controlling for potential confounders found that simply being Maori increased the risk of sudden infant death syndrome by only 1.37 (95% CI = 0.95 to 2.01), not statistically significantly different from 1. Population attributable risk was calculated for prone sleeping position, maternal smoking, not breast feeding, and infants sharing a bed with another person. In total these four risk factors accounted for 89% of deaths from sudden infant death syndrome in Maori infants and 79% in non-Maori infants. CONCLUSION--The high rate of sudden infant death syndrome among Maori infants is based largely on the high prevalence in the Maori population of the major risk factors. Other risk factors, not related to ethnicity, probably explain remaining differences between Maori and non-Maori children.     

Inflammatory responses in sudden infant death syndrome – past and present views

Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) is sudden unexpected death in infancy for which there is no explanation based on commonly accepted diagnostic criteria; however, half of the victims have had slight signs of infection prior to death. Such slight infection with fever is an important risk factor in combination with a prone sleeping position, especially in infants between 2 and 4 months of age. The purpose of this review is to summarise findings that support the theory that a significant part of cot deaths may be due to an overreaction to otherwise harmless infections. Such factors are mucosal immune stimulation, cytokines in the cerebrospinal fluid and hypoxanthine levels in vitreous humour. The review aims at explaining why we believe that a slight infection combined with a prone position, a warm environment and a vulnerable age period may trigger a vicious circle leading to death.     

Thermal environment and sudden infant death syndrome: case-control study.

OBJECTIVE--To compare the thermal environment of infants who died of the sudden infant death syndrome with that of age matched control infants. DESIGN--Case-control study. Infants who died were matched with two controls, one for age and one for age and birth weight. Thermal measurements were conducted at the death scene for cases and at the scene of last sleep for control infants, who were visited unexpectedly within four weeks of the index infant''s death on a day of similar climatic conditions. A follow up questionnaire was administered to parents of cases and controls. SETTING--The geographical area served by the professional Tasmanian state ambulance service, which includes 94% of the Tasmanian population. SUBJECTS--41 infants died of the sudden infant death syndrome at home; thermal observations at death scene were available for 28 (68%), parental questionnaire data were available for 40 (96%). 38 controls matched for age and 41 matched for age and birth weight. RESULTS--Cases had more excess thermal insulation for their given room temperature (2.3 togs) than matched controls (0.6 togs) (p = 0.009). For every excess thermal insulation unit (tog) the relative risk of the sudden infant death syndrome was 1.26 (95% confidence interval 1.05 to 1.52). The average thermal bedding value calculated from parental recall was similar to that observed by attendant ambulance officers (mean difference = 0.4 tog, p = 0.39). Cases were more likely to have been found prone (odds ratio 4.58; 1.48 to 14.11). Prone sleeping position was not a confounder or effect modifier of the relation between excess thermal insulation and the syndrome. CONCLUSIONS--Overheating and the prone sleeping position are independently associated with an increased risk of the sudden infant death syndrome. Further work on infant thermal balance and sudden infant death is required and guidelines for appropriate infant thermal care need to be developed.     

Immunological evidence for a bacterial toxin aetiology in sudden infant death syndrome

Toxin-specific antibodies to clostridial, enterobacterial and staphylococcal toxins implicated in sudden infant death syndrome were studied in sera from sudden infant death syndrome infants and a comparison group of infants (babies with phenylketonuria). The results indicated a higher proportion of sera from sudden infant death syndrome infants contained IgA that bound to clostridial and enterobacterial toxins but a higher proportion of sera from the phenylketonuria comparison group contained IgA that bound staphylococcal toxins. The higher proportion of serum samples with IgG and IgM in the healthy comparison babies serum probably indicated immunity in this group of babies to these toxins. The effect of gender and age had a minimal effect on the incidence of these antibodies. The presence of toxin-specific antibodies in sudden infant death syndrome and the of comparison infants suggests that all infants are exposed to these toxins and most babies successfully overcome the toxic challenge. Some infants with predisposing risk factors (temperature change, smoking, infection, immune development, sleeping position, etc.) that could affect the baby's immune competency could succumb to these and possibly other toxins. This immunological evidence further strengthens the view that bacterial toxins are a significant cause of sudden infant death syndrome.     

Bottle feeding and the sudden infant death syndrome.

OBJECTIVE--To determine whether the risk of the sudden infant death syndrome is increased in bottle fed babies. DESIGN--Population based case-control study matching for age and time. SUBJECTS--All babies aged 1 week to 1 year dying of sudden infant death syndrome during November 1987 to April 1989 or February 1990 to June 1991 and two live controls. SETTING--Avon and north Somerset. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Breast or bottle feeding, sleeping position, maternal smoking, parental employment, and length of gestation. RESULTS--Compared with being fully breast fed, the crude odds ratio for sudden infant death in fully bottle fed babies was 3.1 and for mixed breast and bottle fed babies 1.5. These odds ratios fell to 1.8 (95% confidence interval 0.7 to 4.8) and 1.2 (0.5 to 2.7) respectively after maternal smoking, parental employment, preterm gestation, and sleeping position had been adjusted for. Sleeping position partly masked the effect of being bottle fed on sudden infant death as breast fed babies were more likely to have slept prone than bottle fed babies. CONCLUSIONS--Bottle feeding is not a significant independent risk factor for the sudden infant death syndrome. Patterns of maternal smoking, preterm gestation, and parental employment status account for most of the apparent association with bottle feeding.     

Muscimol dialysis in the rostral ventral medulla reduced the CO(2) response in awake and sleeping piglets.

Some victims of sudden infant death syndrome have arcuate nucleus abnormalities. The arcuate nucleus may be homologous with ventral medullary structures in the cat known to be involved in the control of breathing and the response to systemic hypercapnia. We refer to putative arcuate homologues in the piglet collectively as the rostral ventral medulla (RVM). We inhibited the RVM in awake and sleeping, chronically instrumented piglets by microdialysis of the GABA(A) receptor agonist muscimol. Muscimol dialysis (10 and 40 mM) had no effect on eupnea but caused a significant reduction in the response to hypercapnia during both wakefulness (34.8 +/- 8.7 and 30.7 +/- 10.1%, respectively) and sleep (36.7 +/- 6.7 and 49.5 +/- 8.9%, respectively). The effect of muscimol on the CO(2) response was entirely via a reduction in tidal volume and appeared to be greater during non-rapid-eye-movement sleep. We conclude that the piglet RVM contains neurons of importance in the response to systemic CO(2) during both wakefulness and non-rapid-eye-movement sleep. We hypothesize that dysfunction of homologous regions in the human infant could lead to impaired ability to respond to hypercapnia, particularly during sleep, which could potentially be involved in the pathogenesis of sudden infant death syndrome.     

Can the fall in Avon's sudden infant death rate be explained by changes in sleeping position?

OBJECTIVE--To examine the impact of changing practice with regard to infant sleeping position on mortality from the sudden infant death syndrome. DESIGN--A population based study of all infants dying suddenly and unexpectedly during February 1990 to July 1991, and two groups of controls; one comprising every 125th baby born to Avon residents and the other comprising pairs of infants matched to each index case for age, neighbourhood, and date of study. Information about sleeping position was collected at home visits soon after the index baby''s death or, for the population based controls, on several occasions in the first six months of life. The design was comparable to that of an earlier study of the same population. SETTING--County of Avon. SUBJECTS--35 infants who died suddenly and unexpectedly (32 of the sudden infant death syndrome), 70 matched controls, and 152 population based controls. RESULTS--The prevalence of prone sleeping in the matched controls was much lower than that found in an earlier study in Avon (28% (18/64) 1990-1 v 58% (76/131) 1987-9; p less than 0.001) and was comparable with the prevalence in population based controls (29%). This would be expected to lead to a reduction in the incidence of the sudden infant death syndrome to 2.0/1000 live births (95% confidence interval 1.8/1000 to 2.5/1000). The actual mortality fell from 3.5/1000 in 1987-9 to 1.7/1000. CONCLUSION--The fall in mortality can be almost entirely accounted for by the reduction in prone sleeping, suggesting a causal relation exists between them. Side and supine positions confer protection but the side position is unstable and the infant may roll prone. We therefore recommend supine as the safest sleeping position for babies.     

Disseminated tuberculoid lesions in infants following BCG vaccination.

The records of 830 consecutive autopsies at Children''s Hospital, Winnipeg revealed that 26 of the 36 infants (34 Canadian Indian, 1 Inuit and 1 Caucasian) given BCG vaccine shortly after birth had tuberculoid granulomas in various sites, including the vaccination site, regional lymph nodes, liver, spleen, lung, bone marrow and salivary gland. Mycobacterium bovis, BCG type, was identified in three of the four cases in which isolation was attempted. The principal causes of death had been sudden infant death syndrome and respiratory tract infections. None of the infants had histologic evidence of an immune deficiency. However, it is possible that in two cases the dissemination of BCG was enhanced by a temporary immunologic defect induced by malnutrition.     

Interaction between bedding and sleeping position in the sudden infant death syndrome: a population based case-control study.

OBJECTIVE--To determine the relation between sleeping position and quantity of bedding and the risk of sudden unexpected infant death. DESIGN--A study of all infants dying suddenly and unexpectedly and of two controls matched for age and date with each index case. The parents of control infants were interviewed within 72 hours of the index infant''s death. Information was collected on bedding, sleeping position, heating, and recent signs of illness for index and control infants. SETTING--A defined geographical area comprising most of the county of Avon and part of Somerset. SUBJECTS--72 Infants who had died suddenly and unexpectedly (of whom 67 had died from the sudden infant death syndrome) and 144 control infants. RESULTS--Compared with the control infants the infants who had died from the sudden infant death syndrome were more likely to have been sleeping prone (relative risk 8.8; 95% confidence interval 7.0 to 11.0; p less than 0.001), to have been more heavily wrapped (relative risk 1.14 per tog above 8 tog; 1.03 to 1.28; p less than 0.05), and to have had the heating on all night (relative risk 2.7; 1.4 to 5.2; p less than 0.01). These differences were less pronounced in the younger infants (less than 70 days) than the older ones. The risk of sudden unexpected death among infants older than 70 days, nursed prone, and with clothing and bedding of total thermal resistance greater than 10 tog was increased by factors of 15.1 (2.6 to 89.6) and 25.2 (3.7 to 169.0) respectively compared with the risk in infants of the same age nursed supine or on their side and under less than 6 tog of bedding. CONCLUSIONS--Overheating and the prone position are independently associated with an increased risk of sudden unexpected infant death, particularly in infants aged more than 70 days. Educating parents about appropriate thermal care and sleeping position of infants may help to reduce the incidence of the sudden infant death syndrome.     

Is there a link between cot death and child abuse?

Forty five babies delivered in Oxford obstetric units who subsequently died unexpectedly in infancy were compared with 134 controls matched for maternal age, social class, parity, and year of birth to see whether five factors identified in an earlier study as predictive of subsequent child abuse would also predict the sudden infant death syndrome. Epidemiological findings had suggested certain similarities between the two events. In contrast with babies who were abused, four of the five factors did not distinguish between babies who died suddenly and unexpectedly and their controls, but there was a slight increase in the proportion of mothers of babies who died suddenly and unexpectedly for whom nursing staff thought that support and advice on feeding the baby were needed. Factors predictive of child abuse did not predict sudden infant death in this study.     

The common bacterial toxins hypothesis of sudden infant death syndrome

The background to the common bacterial toxin hypothesis of sudden infant death syndrome is presented. The idea is that some cases of sudden infant death syndrome are due to the lethal effects of nasopharyngeal bacterial toxins which can act synergistically to trigger the events leading to death. The concept is consistent with the age distribution of sudden infant death syndrome, the winter excess of cases and the role of prone sleeping and passive exposure to cigarette smoke. A number of laboratory-based investigations are described. There is an increased isolation of staphylococci and Gram-negative bacilli from sudden infant death syndrome infants compared with age- and season-matched healthy infants. Bacteria from sudden infant death syndrome infants interact synergistically to cause sudden death in gnotobiotic weanling rats. Bacterial toxins implicated in sudden infant death syndrome interact synergistically to cause death in chick embryos. Nicotine in very low doses potentiates the lethal effect of toxin combinations in chick embryos. Staphylococcal toxins and endotoxins have been demonstrated in sudden infant death syndrome tissues, antibodies to endotoxins are low in sudden infant death syndrome cases and the prone sleeping position leads to pooling of secretions in the upper airways, increasing the risk of bacterial growth and toxin production. If the hypothesis is correct, then there is the possibility of a further reduction in the incidence of sudden infant death syndrome based on immunisation against the toxins involved.     

Bed sharing,smoking, and alcohol in the sudden infant death syndrome. New Zealand Cot Death Study Group.

OBJECTIVES--To investigate why sharing the bed with an infant is a not consistent risk factor for the sudden infant death syndrome in ethnic subgroups in New Zealand and to see if the risk of sudden infant death associated with this practice is related to other factors, particularly maternal smoking and alcohol consumption. DESIGN--Nationwide case-control study. SETTING--Region of New Zealand with 78% of all births during 1987-90. SUBJECTS--Home interviews were completed with parents of 393 (81.0% of total) infants who died from the sudden infant death syndrome in the postneonatal age group, and 1592 (88.4% of total) controls who were a representative sample of all hospital births in the study region. RESULTS--Maternal smoking interacted with infant bed sharing on the risk of sudden infant death. Compared with infants not exposed to either risk factor, the relative risk for infants of mothers who smoked was 3.94 (95% confidence interval 2.47 to 6.27) for bed sharing in the last two weeks and 4.55 (2.63 to 7.88) for bed sharing in the last sleep, after other confounders were controlled for. The results for infants of non-smoking mothers were inconsistent with the relative risk being significantly increased for usual bed sharing in the last two weeks (1.73; 1.11 to 2.70) but not for bed sharing in the last sleep (0.98; 0.44 to 2.18). Neither maternal alcohol consumption nor the thermal resistance of the infant''s clothing and bedding interacted with bed sharing to increase the risk of sudden infant death, and alcohol was not a risk factor by itself. CONCLUSION--Infant bed sharing is associated with a significantly raised risk of the sudden infant death syndrome, particularly among infants of mothers who smoke. The interaction between maternal smoking and bed sharing suggests that a mechanism involving passive smoking, rather than the previously proposed mechanisms of overlaying and hyperthermia, increases the risk of sudden infant death from bed sharing.     

Post-Neonatal Sudden Unexplained Death in a California Community

To gain further insight into the problem of infant sudden death, a study was undertaken to investigate a complete series of cases of infant sudden unexplained death that occurred during a seven-year period in Sacramento County. Needed information was abstracted from autopsy records, Medical Examiner''s records and death certificates. The average death rate for the seven-year period was 1.7 for 1,000 live births. Average age at time of death was 2.8 months. There were no records of sudden death among infants over the age of eight months.Higher than average death rates were observed within many of the low socioeconomic areas of Sacramento County. Also, sudden unexplained deaths appeared to occur more frequently in the winter months than in the spring, summer or fall. In over half the cases the infants had a cold, the sniffles, or other respiratory tract congestion within two weeks of the date of death, which seems to support the oft-quoted contention concerning the possibility of nasal obstruction which could initiate the fatal apnea. An additional notable finding was the very frequent occurrence of petechial hemorrhage in the thymus, heart, and lung tissues.The unique age distribution of these deaths in combination with the high frequency of low socioeconomic groups and the frequency of minor respiratory ailment would suggest approaches that can be taken to identify infants at high risk and thus initiate effective community health programs for prevention.