Antigen-specific T cell-mediated suppression. II. In vitro induction by I-J-coded L-glutamic acid50-L-tyrosine50 (GT)-specific T cell suppressor factor (GT-T8F) of suppressor T cells (T82) bearing distinct I-J determinants.

The induction of new suppressor T cells (Ts2) by suppressive extracts (TsF) from L-glutamic acid50L-tyrosine50 (GT) nonresponder mice was examined. Incubation of normal spleen cells with allogeneic GT-TsF for 2 days in vitro led to the generation of Ts2 cells able to suppress subsequent responses to the immunogen GT-methylated bovine serum albumin (GT-MBSA) in vivo. This induction occurred efficiently when TsF donor and target cells differed at all of H-2, including the I-J subregion. B10.BR (H-2k) GT-TsF, adsorbed on, then acid eluted from GT-Sepharose and anti-I-Jk [B10.A (3R) anti-B10.A (5R)]-Sepharose in a sequential fashion could induce BALB/c (H-2d) spleen cells to become Ts2 only if nanogram quantities of GT were added to the purified GT-TsF. This indicates a requirement for a molecule or molecular complex possessing both I-J determinants and antigen (GT)-binding specificity, together with GT itself, for Ts2 induction. The induced Ts2 are I-J+, since their function can be eliminated by treatment with anti-I-Jk plus C. These I-J determinants are coded for by the precursor of the Ts2 and do not represent passively adsorbed, I-J coded TsF, since anti-Ijk antiserum [(3R X DBA/2)F1 anti-5R] which cannot recognize the BALB/c (I-Jd) TsF used for induction still eliminates the activity of induced A/J (I-Jk) Ts2. These data provide further evidence for and information about the minimum of two T cells involved in antigen-specific suppressor T cell systems.     

Monoclonal antibodies specific for single chain or two chain GAT-specific suppressor factors: production and analysis of in vitro modulating properties

Fusion of spleen cells from rats hyperimmunized with T cell hybridoma derived GAT-specific TsF1 or TsF2 suppressor T cell factors has resulted in the generation of hybridomas secreting monoclonal antibodies reactive with the appropriate GAT-TsF used for immunization, and in several cases, reactive with other GAT-TsF1 and TsF2. The monoclonal anti-TsF1 antibodies are capable of modulating in vitro GAT-specific PFC response in a GAT-specific manner; some suppress responses to GAT directly, whereas others reverse GAT-TsF1-mediated suppression of responses. The monoclonal anti-TsF2 antibodies all reverse suppression but are reactive with combinatorial determinants, I-J+ chains or antigen-binding chains of the GAT-TsF2. The data are discussed in terms of the nature of the determinants recognized by these antibodies as well as the potential uses of these reagents for studying the suppressor T cell pathway and potential relationships between Ts1, Ts2, and T helper cells.     

Murine interstitial nephritis. VII. Suppression of renal injury after treatment with soluble suppressor factor TsF1

We prepared soluble suppressor T cell factor (TsF1) from donor spleens harvested from mice primed with tubular antigen-derivatized lymphocytes to analyze both its functional interactions with a larger suppressor T cell network and its influence on the nephritogenic effector T cell response producing interstitial nephritis to a parenchymal antigen. Our findings indicate that TsF1 is antigen-specific, genetically restricted by I-J in its direct mediation of suppression, and capable of inhibiting the development of interstitial lesions. TsF1 also provides an inducing signal for the activation of effector Ts-2 suppressors following presentation by accessory cells. The induction of a Ts-2 effect, however, requires that the factor-presenting cell and the recipient of such cells share homology at I-J, and that the TsF1, the precursor Ts-2 cells, and the recipient of the Ts-2 effect share the same Igh-V allotype. Finally, the results of this current report clearly demonstrate a possible therapeutic role for soluble suppressor factors in the management of interstitial renal disease.     

In vitro generation of suppressor T cells. Induction of CD3+, IgH-restricted suppressor cells

Previous studies of the immune response of C57BL/6 mice to the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP) hapten determined that challenge with antigenic forms of hapten induces both immunity and suppression. The anti-NP plaque-forming cell response can be down regulated by an Ag-induced cascade consisting of three suppressor T cell subsets. These three populations, termed Ts1, Ts2, and Ts3 have been characterized to have inducer, transducer and effector functions, respectively. Although the functions of each of these subsets have been examined in vivo, the cellular requirements for in vitro Ts induction have only been investigated for the Ts3 population. The present study characterizes the cellular events that lead to the induction of the Ts2, suppressor transducer population. Culture of naive C57BL/6 spleen cells with Ts1-derived suppressor factor in the absence of exogenous Ag leads to the generation of Ts2 cells that mediate Ag-specific suppression of NP plaque-forming cell responses. Phenotypic analyses demonstrate that a CD3+, CD4-, CD5+, CD8+, and I-J+ precursor population is stimulated by TsF1 to become mature Ts2 cells that express CD3, CD8, and I-J but not CD5. Although previous studies have reported an essential role for B cells in the induction of other Ts populations, depletion of B cells from Ts2 induction cultures had no effect on Ts2 generation. Despite the absence of B cells in these cultures, the mature Ts2 cells were functionally IgH restricted. Studies with IgH congenic B.C-8 mice suggest that this restriction specificity was imposed by the idiotype-related determinants expressed on the TsF1, not the T cell genotype.     

Nonspecific inhibitor of DNA synthesis elaborated by T acceptor cells. I. Specific hapten- and I-J-driven liberation of an inhibitor of cell proliferation by Lyt-1-2+ cyclophosphamide-sensitive T acceptor cells armed with a product of Lyt-1+2+-specific suppressor cells

Lyt-1+2+ hapten-specific T suppressor cells (Ts) from mice injected and then painted with picryl or oxazolone derivatives produce hapten-specific T suppressor factors (TsF) in vitro. Stimulation by painting with contact sensitizer (which need not be specific) gives rise to Lyt-1-2+, I-J+, cyclophosphamide-sensitive T acceptor cells (Tacc). When the Tacc population is armed with TsF and then is exposed to specific antigen in the context of I-J-controlled determinants (antigen-presenting, haptenized spleen cells and Ts sharing the same I-J subregion), a nonspecific inhibitor of DNA synthesis (nsINH) appears in the supernatant. This inhibitor suppresses the primary DNA synthetic response to concanavalin A, lipopolysaccharide, and alloantigens in both syngeneic and allogeneic lymphocytes. The nsINH is only effective when added to lymphocyte cultures less than 8 hr after the stimulation with concanavalin A. The nsINH, however, affects neither primary nor secondary cytotoxicity in vitro. These data suggest the mouse immune system is capable of selective regulation of the response to specific antigen by the production of nonspecific soluble suppressor factor(s).     

Analysis of hapten-specific T suppressor factors: genetic restriction of TsF1 activity analyzed with synthetic hybrid suppressor molecules

We have analyzed the first-order suppressor factor secreted by an azobenzenearsonate (ABA)-specific T suppressor cell (Ts) hybridoma. Treatment of the factor with 5 mM dithiothreitol (DTT) yields two fragments with distinct phenotypes and functional capabilities. One fragment is bound by a monoclonal anti-I-J antibody, the other is not. Further, although neither molecular fragment by itself is sufficient to suppress an ABA response, a mixture of the two reconstitutes the suppressive activity. The I-J- portion of the first-order suppressor factor (TsF1) presumably guides the antigen specificity; activity of the ABA-specific Ts I-J- TsF1 factor can be reconstituted with an I-J+ subunit of a TsF molecule of either sheep red blood cell (SRBC) or ABA specificity. The genetic restriction for Igh-linked determinants of the ABA/SRBC hybrid TsF molecules is influenced by the I-J+ portion, regardless of the original antigen specificity of that molecule. The data support a two-subunit TsF model. Polyclonal ABA-specific TsF1 molecules appear to resemble the monoclonal factor in structure.     

Age-related changes within a suppressor T cell circuit

The effects of aging on cellular and molecular components of the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl-specific suppressor T (Ts) cell circuit were analyzed in vitro using inducer (Ts1), transducer (Ts2), and effector (Ts3) cells and activating factors (TsF1 and TsF2) derived from young or old mice. The activation of Ts2 cells by TsF1 and of Ts3 cells by TsF2 was found age-restricted, suggesting a loss of Ts2 and Ts3 cell subsets in old mice. However, the activation of Ts3 cells by small amounts of TsF2 is more efficient when both are derived from old rather than from young mice while the same level of maximum suppression is attained. Higher affinity of the interactions involved in Ts cell activation may compensate for loss of Ts cell subsets in old mice. No age restriction was found for antigen presentation to Ts1 cells and for the interaction between Ts3 cells and target B cells. Thus, the effects of aging on immunosuppression result from changes within the Ts cell circuit.     

Mechanism controlling the genetic restrictions of an NP-specific suppressor factor that inhibits B cell responses

The mechanism of B cell suppression by a T cell hybridoma-derived monoclonal effector suppressor factor (TsF3) was studied in the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP) system. The NP-specific effector suppressor cells that produce TsF3 are Lyt-1-, 2+, I-J+, NP-binding T cells and are induced by immunization with NP conjugates. Monoclonal TsF3 inhibits both T cell activity as measured by suppression of contact sensitivity responses and B cell function as measured by suppression of antibody production to both T-independent and T-dependent antigens. The present studies were designed to specifically investigate the mechanisms and genetic restrictions that govern the interactions between TsF3 and its target cells in the plaque-forming cell (PFC) response. The results show that the target of TsF3 is a splenic adherent cell. Suppression will occur only if the restriction specificity of the TsF3 matches the H-2 genotype of the adherent population. Once this TsF3-adherent cell interaction has occurred, suppression of NP-specific B cells can occur across an H-2 barrier. The data also demonstrate that Igh-linked gene products do not appear to play a part in the TsF3-mediated suppression of in vitro PFC responses, which contrasts with the requirements for regulation of T cell-mediated contact sensitivity responses.     

Interaction of idiotype-specific T suppressor factor with the hapten-specific third-order T suppressor subset results in antigen-nonspecific suppression

The interaction between the third-order T suppressor (Ts3) cell and the idiotype (Id)-specific second-order Ts factor (TsF2) was studied in the phenyltrimethylamino (TMA) hapten system. The experimental system which we used allowed the independent analysis of induction and activation requirements of Ts3. The procedure consisted of inducing the Ts3 in vivo and activating the enriched T-cell populations containing Ts3 in vitro with TsF2. The suppressive potential was then tested in mice previously primed for delayed-type hypersensitivity responses which were also treated with cyclophosphamide to deplete Ts3 and other drug-sensitive Ts cell types. Using this experimental system, it was found that the Id-specific TsF2 was required for the in vitro activation of Ts3. Furthermore, the TsF2 activated only the homologous and not heterologous antigen-primed Ts3-containing T cells and moreover, the target of TsF2 was found to be the Ts cells bearing hapten-specific receptors. Once the TMA hapten-specific Ts3 was activated with TsF2, the ensuing suppression was antigen nonspecific. The data demonstrate that the Ts3 represents a final effector Ts cell type in the TMA system.     

A monoclonal antibody raised to tumor-specific T cell-derived suppressor factors also recognizes T suppressor inducer factors of the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl hapten suppressor network

A monoclonal antibody (mAb), B16G, was raised from BALB/c mice immunized with affinity-purified T suppressor factors (TsF) specific for the murine mastocytoma P815. This mAb was found to bind to polyclonal TsF isolated from the spleens of tumor-bearing animals, and to the TsF released from a P815-specific T cell hybridoma. In this study, B16G was tested for its reactivity with TsF produced in the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl hapten system. The factors from three types of suppressor T cell hybridomas, each representing the immortalized analogues of the inducer T suppressor cell (Ts1), transducer suppressor cell (Ts2), and effector suppressor cell (Ts3) network populations, were tested. B16G was found to be reactive with two sources of TsF1 as assayed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and delayed-type hypersensitivity bioassay. By contrast, TsF2 and TsF3 were nonreactive with B16G. These results indicate that B16G recognizes class-specific suppressor factor determinants, and that the transducer/effector factors of the network are apparently serologically distinct. Because the B16G mAb fails to recognize 4-hydroxy-3-nitro-phenyl acetyl-specific TsF3 that share idiotype-related determinants with TsF1 yet binds to TsF1 molecules that have interacted with antigen, the binding is apparently independent of the site of antigen recognition. Additionally, the results show that the tumor-specific TsF1 raised in one suppressor system share serologic determinants with anti-hapten TsF1 raised in another.     

Hapten-specific responses to the phenyltrimethylamino hapten. V. A single chain antigen-binding I-J+ first-order T suppressor factor requires antigen to induce anti-idiotypic second-order suppressor T cells

We have previously shown that a single i.p. injection of the monovalent antigen, L-tyrosine-p-azophenyltrimethylammonium in complete Freund's adjuvant induces a Ly-1+2-, idiotype-bearing, and antigen-binding first-order T suppressor (Ts1) population. We showed that soluble factors extracted from these cells could suppress delayed-type hypersensitivity responses if administered at the induction phase of the response. In this paper we additionally characterize the suppressor factor, TsF1, with respect to its biologic, serologic, and chemical properties. The studies show that the TsF1 is neither allotype nor H-2 restricted and can induce anti-idiotypic T suppressor cells (Ts2), but it requires the presence of antigen to do so. The factor binds antigen, bears I-J encoded determinants, is resistant to reduction and alkylation, and elutes as a single chain factor after adsorption onto monoclonal anti-I-J antibody-coupled Sepharose beads in the presence of dithiothreitol (DTT). This is in marked contrast to TsF2 (derived from Id-specific Ts2-containing spleen cells), which lost its suppressive activity after reduction and alkylation, and behaves as a two chain factor after adsorption and elution from anti-I-J-coupled beads in the presence of DTT. The TsF1 is discussed with respect to the properties of it and those of TsF1 from other similar idiotype-dominated antigen systems.     

A genetically restricted suppressor factor that requires interaction with two distinct targets

We have previously described a genetically restricted suppressor factor (TsF3) that suppresses the terminal phases of the contact sensitivity response. The activity of TsF3 is restricted by genes in the H-2 (I-J) and Igh complexes. This report analyzes the mechanisms responsible for these genetic restrictions. One cellular target of TsF3 is an I-J-bearing antigen-presenting cell population that is sensitive to low doses of cyclophosphamide. To elicit suppression I-J homology is required between this antigen-presenting cell population and the TsF3 donor. In contrast, the Igh-linked genetic restriction exists between TsF3 and an unprimed cell population present in the recipient. These findings suggest that under these experimental conditions TsF3 acts by bridging the APC with cells of the host. Finally, we demonstrated that nonspecific bystander or cognate suppression can be mediated by TsF3, provided specific antigen is present in the site of the ongoing T cell response.     

Insulin-specific suppressor T cell factors

Murine antibody responses to heterologous insulins are controlled by MHC-linked immune response genes. Although nonresponder mice fail to make antibody when injected with nonimmunogenic variants of insulin, we have recently shown that nonimmunogenic variants stimulate radioresistant, Lyt- 1+2- helper T cells that support secondary antibody responses. However, the helper activity can not be detected unless dominant, radiosensitive Lyt-1-2+, I-J+ suppressor T cells are removed. In this paper we report that extracts of primed Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells contain insulin-specific suppressor factors (TsF) that are capable of replacing the activity of suppressor T cells in vitro. The activity of these factors is restricted by MHC-linked genes that map to the I-J region, and immunoadsorption studies indicated that they bind antigen and bear I-J-encoded determinants. Insulin-specific TsF consists of at least two chains, one-bearing I-J and the other the antigen-binding site. Furthermore, mixing of isolated chains from different strains of mice indicates that the antigenic specificity is determined by the antigen-binding chain and the MHC restriction by the H-2 haplotype of the source of the non-antigen-binding, I-J+ chain. Moreover, mixtures containing antigen-binding chain from allogeneic cell donors and I-J+ chain from responder cell donors have activity in cultures containing responder lymphocytes. This suggests that preferential activation of suppressor T cells, rather than differential sensitivity to suppression, results in the nonresponder phenotype to insulin.     

Characterization of an antigen-specific suppressive factor derived from a cloned suppressor effector T cell line

A cloned effector-type suppressor T cell line, 3D10, which is known to suppress the antibody response against dinitrophenylated keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), produced a soluble KLH-specific factor (TsF) that can replace the function of parental T cell clones. High activity of TsF was released spontaneously into the culture supernatant when cultured in interleukin 2 (IL 2)-containing medium, requiring no antigenic stimulation. The culture supernatant of 3D10 was also capable of inhibiting the KLH-induced proliferative response of primed T cells in an antigen-specific manner. The direct target of TsF was found to be Lyt-1+2- T cells undergoing an early stage of antigen-specific proliferation. TsF was antigen binding but lacked any other serologic markers such as I-J and immunoglobulin heavy chain-linked allotypic determinants on T cells. No genetic restriction was found in its action on allogeneic T cells. The production of IL 2 in proliferative T cells by antigenic stimulation was not inhibited by TsF. These results indicate that the TsF described here is the legitimate mediator produced by the effector-type suppressor T cell that suppresses the antigen-specific responses of Lyt-1+2- T cells. The m.w. of TsF was approximately 75,000.     

Purification and analysis of an antigen-specific suppressor factor from a T cell hybridoma specific for phenyltrimethylamino hapten

The synthetic monovalent antigen L-tyrosine-p-azophenyltri-methylammonium (tyr (TMA)) induces in A/J mice, a cascade of regulatory T cells in the absence of any detectable effector function (e.g., CTL, delayed-type hypersensitivity, etc.). An important component of the activated T cells is a first order suppressor T cell or Ts1 that is Ly-1+2-, functions only at the afferent limb of the anti-TMA response, binds the TMA ligand and bears cross-reactive idiotypes associated with anti-TMA antibodies. This Ts1 produces a suppressor factor (TsF1) that binds the TMA ligand, bears the cross-reactive idiotypes and I-J determinants and functions to induce an idiotype-specific Ts2 population. To study the biochemistry of this TsF, use was made of T cell hybridomas that constitutively produce TMA-TsF1 (8A.1 and 8A.3). The TsF1 was purified from culture supernatant or cell extracts by (NH4)2SO4 precipitation, reverse phase HPLC and either affinity chromatography or by preparative IEF. The TsF1 has an isoelectric point of 6.5 and a m.w. of 26,000 or 62,000 as analyzed by SDS-PAGE or high performance molecular sieve chromatography. Its precipitation in 30 to 40% (NH4)2SO4; elution pattern from reverse phase high performance columns; its capacity to bind to a mAb specific for L-glutamic acid 60L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT)-TsF1 strongly suggest that this protein belongs to the same family of proteins as do the GAT-TsF1 described previously. Most noteworthy is that although these TsF1 proteins show remarkable similarities, they are absolutely specific in their biologic activity; TMA-TsF1 will not suppress the response to GAT-BA-TNP and GAT-TsF1 will not suppress the response to TMA-BA-TNP. Thus the TMA-TsF1 represents a second example of a unique group of Ag-specific proteins whose function is to induce or activate other suppressor T cells in the primary immune response to Ag.     

T suppressor factor activity is due to two separate molecules. The Lyt-1(-)2+I-J+ cells of mice primed with antigen make an antigen binding molecule which is only active when complemented by cofactor made by Lyt-1+2(-)I-J+ cells

Mice primed with picrylsulfonic acid (PSA) and then painted on the skin with picryl chloride produce antigen-specific T suppressor factor (TsF). In contrast unpainted primed mice fail to produce active TsF. This is not due to the absence of the antigen binding part of TsF but to the absence of a cofactor. This cofactor is (a) antigen nonspecific and occurs in potassium chloride extract of normal spleen cells. It also occurs in the 24 hr supernatant of normal cells modified by haptenisation with picryl or the unrelated NP antigen (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl), and in preparations of conventional TsF (PSA/PCl) from painted PSA-primed mice; (b) bears I-J determinants; and (c) is produced by Lyt-1+2(-)I-J+ cells. The antigen binding molecule occurs alone in the supernatant of PSA-primed mice. It lacks I-J determinants and has a molecular weight around 35,000 and 75,000. It is produced by Lyt-1(-)2+I-J+ cells and is only active when complemented by cofactor. However, the complementation is genetically restricted and the restriction maps to the I-J subregion of the MHC.     

Hapten-specific T cell responses to 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl. XIII. Characterization of a third T cell population involved in suppression of in vitro PFC responses

The involvement of a third-order suppressor T cell population (Ts3) in the suppression of in vitro PFC responses was analyzed. It was shown that Ts2 effector-phase suppressor cells, induced by the i.v. injection of NP-coupled syngeneic spleen cells, require a third suppressor T cell population to effect NPb idiotype-specific suppression of an in vitro B cell response. This Ts3 population was shown to be present in NP-primed but not unprimed donors. The Ts3 population specifically binds NP and is Lyt-1-, Lyt-2+, I-J+ and bears NPb idiotypic determinants. The involvement of the Ts3 population in a suppressor pathway that requires recognition of idiotypic determinants is discussed.     

An in vitro system for the generation of suppressor cells and the requirement for B cells in their induction

An in vitro method for the generation of effector suppressor cells (Ts3) was developed. By utilizing this protocol, it was possible to investigate both the cellular and genetic requirements for suppressor cell induction. It was determined that populations containing Ts3 cells can be induced after a 4-day culture of spleen cells and antigen. These Ts3 cells are similar to Ts3 cells generated by in vivo immunization. Both populations are I-J+, bind NP hapten, bind NP hapten, bear receptors which share NPb idiotypic determinants with anti-NP antibodies, function during the effector phase of the immune response, and require activation with Ts2 cells. Generation of Ts3-containing populations required both nylon wool-nonadherent T cells and a nylon-adherent, B cell-enriched population from an Igh-identical donor. T cells cultured with antigen alone or with syngeneic macrophages and antigen did not develop suppressive activity. Lytic treatment of the nylon-adherent population with a B cell-specific monoclonal antibody (J11d) removed the ability to generate suppressor cells. These results imply that the induction of suppressor T cells requires B lymphocytes, and that this induction process is dependent on Igh-linked gene products.     

Induction of T cell responses in nonresponder mice by abolishing suppression with monoclonal antibodies recognizing A region-controlled, T cell-specific determinants

Mouse strains carrying the kappa allele at loci A beta, A alpha, E beta, and E alpha are nonresponders to lactate dehydrogenase B (LDHB) and to allotypic determinants of IgG2a myeloma proteins (for example, UPC10 used in this study). The nonresponsiveness to these antigens is caused by T suppressor (Ts) cells that prevent antigen-primed T helper (Th) cells from proliferating. We demonstrate here that monoclonal antibodies specific for an A region-controlled molecule selectively expressed on T cells (A-T) are capable of inducing anti-LDHB and anti-UPC10 responses of primed T cells from nonresponder strains. A monoclonal anti-J antibody that cross-reacts with the A-T molecule also induces responsiveness, whereas another J-specific antibody that lacks this cross-reactivity fails to do so. The mechanism of response induction is blocking of the interaction between the Ts cell or its factor (TsF) and the target of suppression, the antigen-specific Lyt-1+2- (Th) cell. The blocking occurs at the level of the Ts cell and the TsF. The data indicate that Ts cells and TsF carry a unique, A region-controlled molecule that is not only functionally analogous but also serologically similar to the J molecule.     

The immune response and the eye. I. The effects of monoclonal antibodies to T suppressor factors in anterior chamber-associated immune deviation (ACAID)

We report the effects of two monoclonal antibodies (mab) specific for murine T suppressor (Ts) factors (TsF) in anterior chamber (AC)-associated immune deviation (ACAID), as induced by AC inoculation of TNP-coupled syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-Spl). One mab (14-12) is specific for Ts effector factor and can block the induction of Ts cells in ACAID if given before or after AC injection of TNP-Spl. The other mab (14-30) is specific for Ts inducer factors and blocks suppression only after given after TNP-Spl. We also studied the surface phenotype of the Ts cells induced by AC injection of TNP-Spl. We show that at least two cells are required for the adoptive transfer of suppression in TNP-ACAID. One is Lyt-2+ and 14-12+, the other is I-J+. These Ts cells have the surface phenotype of Ts effector cells as seen in other systems. These results indicate that mab which bind TsF in other systems affect Ts cells in TNP-ACAID, and that the Ts cells induced in TNP-ACAID are only of the Ts effector type.