Isethionic acid and floridoside isolated from the red alga, Grateloupia turuturu, inhibit settlement of Balanus amphitrite cyprid larvae

Isethionic acid (2-hydroxyethane sulfonic acid) and floridoside (2-O-alpha-D-galactopyranosylglycerol) were extracted from the red alga, Grateloupia turuturu, and tested for anti-settlement activity against cyprid larvae of the tropical barnacle, Balanus amphitrite and for their toxicity to nauplius larvae. Isethionic acid was active for anti-settlement but had the disadvantage of being toxic to nauplius larvae. Floridoside was a potent inhibitor of cyprid settlement at non-toxic concentrations to nauplii (0.01 mg ml(-1)).     

Reversible anti-settlement activity against Amphibalanus (=Balanus) amphitrite,Bugula neritina,and Hydroides elegans by a nontoxic pharmaceutical compound,mizolastine

Mizolastine, an antihistamine pharmaceutical, was found to significantly inhibit larval settlement of the barnacle Amphibalanus (=Balanus) amphitrite, the bryozoan Bugula neritina, and the polychaete Hydroides elegans with EC₅₀ values of 4.2, 11.2, and 4.1 µg ml^?1, respectively. No toxicity against the larvae of these three species was observed at the concentration range tested during incubations with mizolastine. To determine whether the anti-settlement activity of mizolastine is reversible, recovery bioassays using these three species were conducted. More than 70% of the larvae that had been exposed for 4 h to mizolastine at concentrations four-fold greater than their respective EC₅₀ values completed normal metamorphosis. The results of the recovery bioassay provide evidence that the anti-settlement effect of mizolastine is reversible in addition to being nontoxic. The anti-settlement activities of several intermediates of the synthesis process of mizolastine were also examined. One of the intermediates, 2-chloro-1-(4-fluorobenzyl)-1H-benzo[d]imidazole, inhibited larval settlement and metamorphosis with low toxicity. These results may improve the understanding of the key functional group responsible for the anti-settlement activity of mizolastine.     

Inhibitory effect of phenolic compounds and marine bacteria on larval settlement of the barnacle Balanus amphitrite amphitrite darwin

This study examined the inhibitory effect of 3 phenolic compounds and 12 strains of marine bacteria on the larval settlement of Balanus amphitrite amphitrite. The phenolic compounds used were phlorotannins, phloroglucinol and tannic acid. Phlorotannins are polymers of phloroglucinol (1,3,5‐trihydroxybenzene) known only from brown algae. Tannic acid, which exists in terrestrial plants, is composed of oligomers of phloroglucinol attached to a sugar molecule. The bacterial strains used were isolated from a natural biofilm. The following were investigated: 1) the toxicity of the phenolic compounds to B. a. amphirite in three different larval stages, viz. nauplius II, nauplius V and cyprid; 2) the potency of the compounds as inhibitors of larval settlement and the possible mechanism involved in settlement inhibition; and 3) the effects of the bacteria on larval settlement. The level of toxicity of the phenolic compounds varied widely for the larvae. Phlorotannins were most toxic, having LC₅₀ values ranging from 9.47 to 40.35 μg ml^‐1; phloroglucinol was least toxic, having LC₅₀ values of 235.12 to 368.28 μg ml^‐1. In general, nauplii were more sensitive to the toxicity of the phenolic compounds than cyprids. The greater sensitivity of nauplii may be due to their active feeding behavior, which exposes the interior of their bodies to the compounds by active intake. Phloroglucinol was the most potent settlement inhibitor, having an EC₅₀ value of 0.02 μg ml^‐1. Phlorotannins and tannic acid had EC₅₀ values of 1.90 μg ml^‐1 and 14.05 μg ml^‐1, respectively. Phloroglucinol appeared to inhibit larval settlement through a relatively non‐toxic mechanism as its LC₅₀ value was four orders of magnitude higher than its EC₅₀ value. The high potency of phloroglucinol indicates that a simple constituent of a complex natural compound can be more effective than the natural compound itself. Larval settlement bioassays with monospecies bacterial films indicated that some of the bacterial species were inhibitory to larval settlement while the others showed no effect. None of the bacterial strains in this study induced larval settlement.     

Proteomic analysis of larvae during development, attachment, and metamorphosis in the fouling barnacle, Balanus amphitrite

The barnacle, Balanus amphitrite, is one of the primary model organisms for rocky-shore ecology studies and biofouling research. This barnacle species has a complex life cycle during which the swimming nauplius molts six times and transforms into a cyprid stage. Cyprids must attach to a surface to metamorphose into a juvenile barnacle. To clarify the overall profile of protein expression during larval development and metamorphosis, 2-DE was used to compare the proteome of the nauplius, the swimming cyprid, the attached cyprid, and the metamorphosed cyprid. The proteome of the swimming cyprid was distinctly different from that of other life stages and had about 400 spots. The proteomes of the attached and metamorphosed cyprids were similar with respect to major proteins but had significantly lower numbers of spots compared to that of swimming larval stages. Obviously, synthesis of most proteins from swimming cyprids was switched off after attachment and metamorphosis. Our advanced MS analysis (MALDI-TOF/TOF MS/MS) allowed us to identify the proteins that were differentially and abundantly expressed in the swimming cyprid. These proteins included signal transduction proteins (adenylate cyclase and calmodulin) and juvenile hormone binding proteins. In summary, for the first time, we have analyzed the global protein expression pattern of fouling marine invertebrate larvae during metamorphosis. Our study provides new insights into the mechanisms of barnacle larval metamorphosis and also provides a foundation for exploring novel targets for antifouling treatments.     

Barnacle Settlement on Hydrogels

Settlement of cultured Balanus amphitrite cyprid larvae was tested on different non-solid hydrogel surfaces. Gels consisting of alginate (highly anionic), chitosan (highly cationic), polyvinyl alcohol substituted with light-sensitive stilbazolium groups (PVA-SbQ; very low cationic) and agarose (neutral) were applied in cell culture multi-well plates. Polystyrene served as a solid surface reference. Preliminary experiments were performed to determine whether any substances leaching out of the gels could inhibit barnacle settlement. Whilst leachate from the gels revealed no toxicity towards Artemia salina nauplius larvae, PVA-SbQ in solution at and above a concentration of 0.4 ppm inhibited B. amphitrite cyprid settlement. Gels were therefore washed to avoid such effects during further testing, and toxicity and settlement tests with B. amphitrite nauplii and cyprids, respectively, applied to verify that washing was effective. Settlement was tested directly on the different test materials, followed by a quality test of non-settled larvae. All gels inhibited barnacle settlement compared to the polystyrene controls. Gels consisting of 2.5% PVA-SbQ or 0.5% agarose showed promising antifouling properties. Although some settlement occurred on 2.5% PVA-SbQ gels, metamorphosis was clearly inhibited. Only 10% of the larvae had settled on 0.5% agarose gels after 8 d. Less than 40% settlement occurred on alginate gels, as well as on 2% chitosan gels. Quality testing showed that the majority of remaining non-settled larvae in all gel experiments were able to settle when offered a suitable solid substratum.     

Combined effect of cyprid age and lipid content on larval attachment and metamorphosis of Balanus amphitrite darwin

Various algal diets of different lipid content and composition were used to rear batches of naupliar larvae of Balanus amphitrite. The cyprids in these larval batches differed in lipid content and were used to investigate the combined effect of cyprid lipid content and cyprid age on attachment and metamorphosis. For this purpose, cyprids were aged for 0,3 and 6 d at 8°C prior to utilization in laboratory attachment assays. The percentage attachment of cyprids with similar lipid content differed significantly among the three age categories. A strong and a weak positive relationship between cyprid lipid content and attachment were monitored in young and old cyprids, respectively. A significant interaction (two‐way ANOVA) between cyprid age and lipid content was observed, indicating that these factors jointly affect larval attachment and metamorphosis in B. amphitrite from the beginning of the cyprid stage.     

Response of larval barnacle proteome to CO(2)-driven seawater acidification

The majority of benthic marine invertebrates have a complex life cycle, during which the pelagic larvae select a suitable substrate, attach to it, and then metamorphose into benthic adults. Anthropogenic ocean acidification (OA) is postulated to affect larval metamorphic success through an altered protein expression pattern (proteome structure) and post-translational modifications. To test this hypothesis, larvae of an economically and ecologically important barnacle species Balanus amphitrite, were cultured from nauplius to the cyprid stage in the present (control) and in the projected elevated concentrations of CO₂ for the year 2100 (the OA treatment). Cyprid response to OA was analyzed at the total proteome level as well as two protein post-translational modification (phosphorylation and glycosylation) levels using a 2-DE based proteomic approach. The cyprid proteome showed OA-driven changes. Proteins that were differentially up or down regulated by OA come from three major groups, namely those related to energy-metabolism, respiration, and molecular chaperones, illustrating a potential strategy that the barnacle larvae may employ to tolerate OA stress. The differentially expressed proteins were tentatively identified as OA-responsive, effectively creating unique protein expression signatures for OA scenario of 2100. This study showed the promise of using a sentinel and non-model species to examine the impact of OA at the proteome level.     

Substratum/bacterial interactions and larval attachment: Films and exopolysaccharides of Halomonas marina (ATCC 25374) and their effect on barnacle cyprid larvae,Balanus amphitrite Darwin

Laboratory experiments were conducted to study the interaction between adhesion of the bacterium Halomonas marina to substrata of different wettabilities, the combination of which has been demonstrated to influence the attachment response of cyprid larvae of the barnacle Balanus amphitrite. Cyprid attachment in the presence of bacterial films was shown to be inhibited when films were on polystyrene but not on tissue‐culture polystyrene or glass. Using an enzyme‐linked lectin assay, bacteria on polystyrene showed an increase in binding of the lectin concanavalin A compared to bacteria on tissue‐culture treated polystyrene, indicating a difference in surface polymers associated with H. marina when attached to different substrata. Although bacterial growth supernatants when adsorbed to polystyrene were inhibitory to barnacle attachment, exopolysaccharides, to which the lectins may be binding, were not inhibitory. The data indicate that adhesion of films of bacteria to polystyrene alters the exopolymer production by H. marina and it is suggested that this change may be involved in the inhibition of cyprid attachment. However, the inhibition of cyprid larvae does not appear to be associated with the exopolysaccharides of the bacterium.     

Visualization of putative ion-transporting epithelia in Amphibalanus amphitrite using correlative microscopy: Potential function in osmoregulation and biomineralization

Thoracican barnacles are a unique suborder of crustaceans typified by their calcified exterior, which provides protection to the sessile juvenile and adult. Biomineralization is mediated by a mantle epithelium that appears to be involved in calcium uptake and the secretion of calcium laden matrix. Larval and adult intertidal Balanomorph barnacles tolerate a wide range of salinities and it is hypothesized that active ion transport is the primary mechanism for osmoregulation. We observed adult Amphibalanus amphitrite producing an electrolyte-rich secretion emanating from the junction of the basis and parietal plates. Further study of this region using silver staining microscopic techniques, verified by scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive spectroscopy, revealed a chloride ion rich mantle epithelium. A distinctive pattern of silver chloride stained epithelia was revealed in all A. amphitrite life stages. These epithelia were observed to contain mitochondria rich cells in nauplius and cyprid larvae (as shown by DASPMI staining visualized with confocal laser scanning microscopy) and therefore exhibit potential for active ion transport. Rhod-5 N (a low affinity cellular Ca²⁺ indicator) labeling was also observed in all barnacle life stages, in tissues shown to be chloride positive. We suspect that the observed chloride ion rich epithelia facilitate ionic regulation via active transport, and biomineralization via cellular Ca²⁺ uptake, storage and mobilization.     

Energy budget for the larval development ofElminius modestus (Crustacea: Cirripedia)

Biomass (CHN), respiration rate and food uptake were estimated for the larval development ofElminius modestus at three temperatures (12, 18, 24°C). Mean values of dry weight, elemental composition and energy equivalents increased exponentially with the development from nauplius II to VI. Dry weight, elemental composition and energy content exhibited the highest values at 18°C. Respiration rates increased with the larval stages expressed by a power function, but increased logarithmically with the dry weight of the larvae. The cypris larvae showed a reduced respiration rate compared with nauplius VI. The ingestion rate was measured at a concentration of 100 cells ofSkeletonema costatum μl⁻¹. At 12 and 18°C ingestion rates increased exponentially and at 24°C by a logarithmic function. The fittings were used to estimate the energy budget ofE. modestus during larval development. The energy content of the larvae increased during the development from nauplius II to VI by a factor of 21 at 12°C, 25 at 24°C and 31 at 18°C. The estimated energy content of the freshly metamorphosed barnacle is 100 mJ (12°C), 130 mJ (24°C) and 150 mJ (18°C). The assimilation- (A/I) and gross growth efficiencies (K₁) increased strongly during the development from nauplius II to VI (A/I: 6–14% in nauplius II to 50–90% in nauplius VI; K₁: 4% in nauplius II to 75% in nauplius VI). The net growth efficiency (K₂) showed a relatively constant level ranging between 57 and 83%.     

Larval development of the pedunculate barnacles Octolasmis angulata Aurivillius 1894 and Octolasmis cor Aurivillius 1892 (Cirripedia: Thoracica: Poecilasmatidae) from the gills of the mud crab,Scylla tranquebarica Fabricius, 1798

Detailed studies of larval development of Octolasmis angulata and Octolasmis cor are pivotal in understanding the larval morphological evolution as well as enhancing the functional ecology. Six planktotrophic naupliar stages and one non-feeding cyprid stage are documented in details for the first time for the two species of Octolasmis. Morphologically, the larvae of O. angulata and O. cor are similar in body size, setation patterns on the naupliar appendages, labrum, dorsal setae-pores, frontal horns, cyprid carapace, fronto-lateral gland pores, and lattice organs. Numbers of peculiarities were observed on the gnathobases of the antennae and mandible throughout the naupliar life-cycle. The setation pattern on the naupliar appendages are classified based on the segmentation on the naupliar appendages. The nauplius VI of both species undergoes a conspicuous change before metamorphosis into cyprid stage. The cyprid structures begin to form and modify beneath the naupliar body towards the end of stage VI. This study emphasises the importance of the pedunculate barnacle larval developmental studies not only to comprehend the larval morphological evolution but also to fill in the gaps in understanding the modification of the naupliar structures to adapt into the cyprid life-style.     

Variation in toxicity of copper pyrithione among populations and families of the barnacle,Balanus amphitrite

Inter- and intra-population variation in the toxicity of the antifouling biocide copper pyrithione (CuPT) was examined for nauplius larvae of the barnacle Balanus amphitrite. Nauplii were collected from brooding adults from four sites within the Newport River estuary (NC), chosen based on an initial estimation of recent and historical human activities that affect local contamination levels. Each site was characterized for the presence of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and for the frequency of gastropod imposex, an indicator of contamination by organotins. Sensitivity of nauplii to CuPT varied significantly across the sites/populations, with LC₅₀ values ranging from 4.0 μg l^?1 to 6.1 μg l^?1. Larvae from the most contaminated site were the most sensitive to CuPT. Intrapopulation variation in toxicity was investigated by exposing nauplius larvae from 15 maternal families to a fixed concentration of CuPT (6.1 μg l^?1). Variation in larval mortality among the families was significant, ranging from 15.1% to 98.9%.     

Caloric content of larvae of the brine shrimpArtemia salina

Summary 1. Caloric contents ofArtemia salina nauplii and larvae have been determined by employing a combustion calorimetry. Freshly hatched nauplii contain on an average 5953 cal/g organic substance; the respective value for 7-day-old (2 mm long) larvae is 5854 cal/g.2. The effect of starvation on the caloric contents was investigated. After a 72 hour starvation period, nauplii contain 5430 cal/g organic substance, 2 mm long larvae 5115 cal/g.3. The ash contents (expressed as % of body dry weight) ofArtemia larvae increase as a function of the length of the starvation period.4. After determining the weight of the nauplii, the caloric content of a single nauplius was calculated after different periods of starvation. It ranges from 0.00924 cal per freshly hatched nauplius to 0.00459 cal per nauplius starved for 96 hours.

---

Kaloriengehalt von Larven des SalinenkrebsesArtemia salina

Kurzfassung Der Energiegehalt frisch geschlüpfter Nauplien (5953 cal/g organische Substanz) und 2 mm langer Larven (Metanauplius IV, 5854 cal/g organische Substanz) vonArtemia salina Leach wurde mit einem Parr 1412 Bombenkalorimeter ermittelt. Ferner wurde der Einfluß verschieden langer Hungerperioden auf den Kaloriengehalt dieser Tiere untersucht. Nach 72stündigem Hungern wurden für die Nauplien 5430 cal/g organische Substanz und für die 2 mm langen Larven 5115 cal/g organische Substanz ermittelt. Der Aschegehalt der Tiere stieg mit zunehmender Dauer der Hungerperiode. Anhand des Gewichts der geschlüpften und hungernden Nauplien wurde der Kaloriengehalt einzelner Tiere bestimmt: er reicht von 0,00924 cal pro Tier (gerade geschlüpfter Nauplius) bis 0,00459 cal pro Tier (Nauplius, 96 Stunden ohne Futter).

---

---

Dedicated to Professor Dr.Friedrich Krüger on his 65^th birthday, August 18, 1967.     

Larval development and post-settlement metamorphosis of the barnacle Balanus albicostatus Pilsbry and the serpulid polychaete Pomatoleios kraussii Baird: Impact of a commonly used antifouling biocide,Irgarol 1051

Abstract

The impact of a commonly-used antifouling algicide, Irgarol 1051, on the larval development and post-settlement metamorphosis of the barnacle, Balanus albicostatus Pilsbry (Crustacea: Cirripedia), and the larval metamorphosis of a serpulid polycheate, Pomatoleios kraussii Baird, was evaluated. In the case of B. albicostatus, larval mortality increased with an increase in the concentration of Irgarol 1051, and there was a shift in the larval stage targeted from advanced instars to early instars. Nauplii that survived to the cyprid instar stage when reared in the presence of Irgarol 1051 showed prolonged instar and total naupliar duration when compared to the controls. The post-settlement metamorphosis of cyprids significantly varied with Irgarol concentration and also with biofilm age. One and 2-d-old untreated biofilms showed higher metamorphosis when compared to 5-d-old biofilms. However, when the biofilms that promoted cyprid metamorphosis were treated with Irgarol 1051 at low concentrations, metamorphosis rates decreased. Cyprids were prevented from metamorphosing completely by biofilms treated at the highest concentration of Irgarol 1051. Inhibition of metamorphosis was also observed in the case of competent polychaete larvae when exposed to Irgarol 1051 compared to those exposed to metamorphosis inducers such as 3-iso-butyl-1-methylxanthine (IBMX) and natural biofilms. Identification of the pathway(s) that caused the promotory biofilms to become toxic when exposed to Irgarol 1051 is discussed.     

Antisettlement activity of synthetic analogues of polymeric 3-alkylpyridinium salts isolated from the sponge Reniera sarai

Based on the high, non-toxic and reversible antifouling activity of the polymeric 3-alkylpyridinium salts isolated from the sponge Reniera sarai, the anti-settlement activity and toxicity of a series of synthetic analogues has been studied. All the test compounds were less efficient than the natural polymers, suggesting that the high and reversible anti-macrofouling activity of the natural polymers could derive from their detergent-like properties. The values obtained for EC_50sett. of inhibition of cyprid settlement and EC_50imm. as naupliar toxicity for the synthetic compounds indicate that the presence of single or multiple charges in the structure is not relevant for the antifouling activity which, conversely, is favoured by increasing the length of the alkyl chain, or by the presence of uncharged pyridine units. The compound 1,8-di(3-pyridyl)octane was the most efficient (EC_50sett.= 0.44?μg?ml^–1), although with a higher toxicity on naupliar stage of B. amphitrite than the natural polymers.     

The screening of sponge extracts for antifouling activity using a bioassay with laboratory-reared cyprid larvae of the barnacle Balanus amphitrite

Antifouling coatings based on organotin compounds possess a world-wide threat to the environment and due to growing restrictions there is a need for environmentally safe antifouling systems. TNO is working on the development of novel antifouling systems based on secondary metabolites from sponges. Screening for natural antifoulants is conducted using a settlement assay with cyprid larvae of the barnacle Balanus amphitrite Darwin. Forty-four sponges (35 species) were collected from around the island of Curaçao in the Caribbean and settlement assays were performed with the ethyl-acetate extracts. Thirty-one extracts significantly inhibited cyprid settlement at 0.1 mg ml⁻¹, of which 22 significantly inhibited settlement at 0·01 mg ml⁻¹.     

Effects of temperature and salinity on the larvae of two species of rhizocephalan (Crustacea: Cirripedia)

Summary

Responses of larvae of two rhizocephalan species to changes in seawater temperature and salinity were studied under laboratory conditions. Peltogasterella gracilis parasitizes the hermit crab Pagurus pectinatus, which occurs at stable salinity and gradually changing temperature in summer. Sacculina polygenea is a parasite of the crab Hemigrapsus sanguineus, which lives in the intertidal zone in summer where salinity and temperature can fluctuate during the day. The development of both species is comprised of five naupliar stages and the cyprid stage, and it was considered successful if more than 50% of the nauplii attained the cyprid stage. P. gracilis nauplii successfully developed at 12–20°C and 30–34‰, but at 22°C successful development occurred in a narrower salinity range (32–34‰). All nauplii died both at 25°C and in 26‰. S. polygenea nauplii successfully reached the cyprid stage at higher temperatures (18–25°C) and a wider salinity range (18–34‰) than P. gracilis nauplii, but at 12°C and 16‰ larval development of S. polygenea was suppressed. Under favorable conditions, naupliar development lasted 3.5 days in P. gracilis and 2–3 days in S. polygenea. The cyprids of both rhizocephalan species demonstrated a greater resistance to temperature and salinity changes than nauplii. However, P. gracilis cyprids were active in a narrower salinity range (16–34‰), as compared to S. polygenea cyprids (8–34‰). Under favorable conditions the cyprids of both species survived for 6 to 10 days.     

When similar beginnings lead to different ends: Constraints and diversity in cirripede larval development

Summary

Cirripedes are fascinating models for studying both functional constraints and diversity in larval development. Adult cirripedes display an amazing variation in morphology from sessile suspension feeders that still retain many crustacean characters to parasites that have lost virtually all arthropod traits. In contrast, cirripede larval development follows a common scheme with pelagic larvae comprising a series of nauplii followed by a cyprid. Variations are mostly concerned with whether or not the nauplii are feeding and the degree of abbreviation of development, culminating in species where the larvae hatch as cyprids. The cypris larvae are very similar among the ingroups of the Cirripedia, but interesting variations occur in structures used for substrate location and attachment. The cyprid is specialized to both swim through the water and actively explore the substratum by walking on the antennules and using an array of sensory organs in search for a suitable site to attach. This unique morphology and behavior of the cyprid have enabled the Cirripedia to colonize widely different habitats ranging from hard rock to soft animal tissue. Yet, the cyprid can metamorphose into juveniles as different as a setose feeding barnacle and the vermiform stages of the parasitic forms. This emphasizes the importance of the cyprid as one of the key features for the evolutionary success of the Cirripedia.     

The effect of temperature on the growth,development and survival of Macropetasma africanus (Balss) (Penaeoidea:Penaeidae) larvae reared in the laboratory

Macropetasma africanus (Balss) has been successfully spawned and its larvae reared under controlled laboratory conditions. The relationship between egg number (E) and female total length (L) was E = 18.59 L^2.11. An experiment was designed to test the effect of temperature on larval development, survival and growth. Temperature effected larval development time, from 13–15 days at 25°C, to 25 days at 15°C (nauplius 1 to post-larva). Mortality was low for the naupliar stages at 25, 22 and 18°C, while at 15°C only 52% of the larvae reached nauplius 6. Mortality was highest from nauplius 6 to protozoea 1 (17, 21, and 18% at 25, 22, and 18°C, respectively), but decreased considerably for all temperatures once the mysis stage was reached. Overall survival rates from nauplius 1 to post-larva decreased with decreasing temperature (65, 54, 48, and 39% at 25, 22, 18, and 15°C respectively). Temperature also significantly affected larval growth. At 25°C mean total length was significantly (P < 0.05) larger than at 15°C (protozoea 2 to post-larva), while from protozoea 3 to post-larva total length differences were significantly different (P < 0.05) between 18 and 25°C. M. africanus has a major spawning peak in summer, suggesting that there may be a selective advantage to reproducing during the warmer months.     

Influence of tannic acid and Cry1Ac toxin of Bacillus thuringiensis on larval survival, growth, and development of Helicoverpa armigera

Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) causes huge economic losses in cotton production around the world. Tannin, one of the important secondary substances in cotton plants, can increase the δ‐endotoxin activity of Bacillus thuringiensis ssp. kurstaki. The mechanism of interaction between tannin and Bt toxin on H. armigera is unclear. We investigated the interaction between tannic acid and Cry1Ac toxin in H. armigera, and monitored survival, growth, and development during the larval period after treating the larvae with four concentrations of Cry1Ac toxin (0, 2, 8, and 14 μg^?1) alone or in combination with four concentrations of tannic acid (0, 0.5, 1, and 2 mg g^?1). Mortality of larvae treated with both tannic acid and Cry1Ac was higher than the mortality of larvae treated with tannic acid or Cry1Ac alone. Mortality was 47.5 and 51.5% in larvae treated with 14 μg g^?1 Cry1Ac alone or 2 mg g^?1 tannic acid alone, respectively. In contrast, larval mortality was 75% when treated with the mixture of 14 μg g^?1 Cry1Ac and 2 mg g^?1 tannic acid, suggesting that a mixture of the two enhanced the effectiveness of each one alone. The developmental time of larvae treated with the combination of tannic acid and Cry1Ac was significantly longer than when they were treated with Cry1Ac or tannic acid alone. Larval weight, pupal weight, and pupation rate were also significantly reduced in larvae treated with both toxins, compared with the larvae treated with either toxin alone. These results showed that the interactive effect of tannic acid and Cry1Ac on larval growth inhibition is additive, and that tannic acid improves Cry1Ac toxicity to insects. Tannic acid used in combination with B. thuringiensis might potentially reduce overall insecticide use, thus delaying development of insecticide resistance.