DNA condensation in bacteria: Interplay between macromolecular crowding and nucleoid proteins

The volume of a typical Eschericia coli nucleoid is roughly 10⁴ times smaller than the volume of a freely coiling linear DNA molecule with the same length as the E. coli genome. We review the main forces that have been suggested to contribute to this compaction factor: macromolecular crowding (that “pushes” the DNA together), DNA charge neutralization by various polycationic species (that “glues” the DNA together), and finally, DNA deformations due to DNA supercoiling and nucleoid proteins. The direct contributions of DNA supercoiling and nucleoid proteins to the total compaction factor are probably small. Instead, we argue that the formation of the bacterial nucleoid can be described as a consequence of the influence of macromolecular crowding on thick, supercoiled protein-DNA fibers, that have been partly charge neutralized by small multivalent cations.     

Interplay of DNA supercoiling and catenation during the segregation of sister duplexes

The discrete regulation of supercoiling, catenation and knotting by DNA topoisomerases is well documented both in vivo and in vitro, but the interplay between them is still poorly understood. Here we studied DNA catenanes of bacterial plasmids arising as a result of DNA replication in Escherichia coli cells whose topoisomerase IV activity was inhibited. We combined high-resolution two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis with numerical simulations in order to better understand the relationship between the negative supercoiling of DNA generated by DNA gyrase and the DNA interlinking resulting from replication of circular DNA molecules. We showed that in those replication intermediates formed in vivo, catenation and negative supercoiling compete with each other. In interlinked molecules with high catenation numbers negative supercoiling is greatly limited. However, when interlinking decreases, as required for the segregation of newly replicated sister duplexes, their negative supercoiling increases. This observation indicates that negative supercoiling plays an active role during progressive decatenation of newly replicated DNA molecules in vivo.     

Internal Dynamics of Supercoiled DNA Molecules

The intramolecular diffusive motion within supercoiled DNA molecules is of central importance for a wide array of gene regulation processes. It has recently been shown, using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, that plasmid DNA exhibits unexpected acceleration of its internal diffusive motion upon supercoiling to intermediate density. Here, we present an independent study that shows a similar acceleration for fully supercoiled plasmid DNA. We have developed a method that allows fluorescent labeling of a 200-bp region, as well as efficient supercoiling by Escherichia coli gyrase. Compared to plain circular or linear DNA, the submicrosecond motion within the supercoiled molecules appears faster by up to an order of magnitude. The mean-square displacement as a function of time reveals an additional intermediate regime with a lowered scaling exponent compared to that of circular DNA. Although this unexpected behavior is not fully understood, it could be explained by conformational constraints of the DNA strand within the supercoiled topology in combination with an increased apparent persistence length.     

DNA bending,compaction and negative supercoiling by the architectural protein Sso7d of Sulfolobus solfataricus

Members of the Sso7d/Sac7d family are small, abundant, non-specific DNA-binding proteins of the hyperthermophilic Archaea Sulfolobus. Crystal structures of these proteins in complex with oligonucleotides showed that they induce changes in the helical twist and marked DNA bending. On this basis they have been suggested to play a role in organising chromatin structures in these prokaryotes, which lack histones. We report functional in vitro assays to investigate the effects of the observed Sso7d-induced structural modifications on DNA geometry and topology. We show that binding of multiple Sso7d molecules to short DNA fragments induces significant curvature and reduces the stiffness of the complex. Sso7d induces negative supercoiling of DNA molecules of any topology (relaxed, positively or negatively supercoiled) and in physiological conditions of temperature and template topology. Binding of Sso7d induces compaction of positively supercoiled and relaxed DNA molecules, but not of negatively supercoiled ones. Finally, Sso7d inhibits the positive supercoiling activity of the thermophile-specific enzyme reverse gyrase. The proposed biological relevance of these observations is that these proteins might model the behaviour of DNA in constrained chromatin environments.     

Chromosomal domains of supercoiling in Salmonella typhimurium

The chromosomes of enteric bacteria are divided into about 50 independently supercoiled domains. It is not known whether the net level of DNA supercoiling is similar in each domain, or whether the domains are differentially supercoiled. We have addressed this question genetically, using a supercoiling-sensitive promoter to probe the relative levels of supercoiling at defined points around the Salmonella typhimurium chromosome. We conclude that, within the limits of resolution of this approach, the level of supercoiling does not differ significantly between chromosomal domains, and that each domain responds in a similar fashion to factors that perturb supercoiling. These findings have implications for the organization of the bacterial genome.     

Supercoiled DNA and non-equilibrium formation of protein complexes: A quantitative model of the nucleoprotein ParBS partition complex

ParABS, the most widespread bacterial DNA segregation system, is composed of a centromeric sequence, parS, and two proteins, the ParA ATPase and the ParB DNA binding proteins. Hundreds of ParB proteins assemble dynamically to form nucleoprotein parS-anchored complexes that serve as substrates for ParA molecules to catalyze positioning and segregation events. The exact nature of this ParBS complex has remained elusive, what we address here by revisiting the Stochastic Binding model (SBM) introduced to explain the non-specific binding profile of ParB in the vicinity of parS. In the SBM, DNA loops stochastically bring loci inside a sharp cluster of ParB. However, previous SBM versions did not include the negative supercoiling of bacterial DNA, leading to use unphysically small DNA persistences to explain the ParB binding profiles. In addition, recent super-resolution microscopy experiments have revealed a ParB cluster that is significantly smaller than previous estimations and suggest that it results from a liquid-liquid like phase separation. Here, by simulating the folding of long (≥ 30 kb) supercoiled DNA molecules calibrated with realistic DNA parameters and by considering different possibilities for the physics of the ParB cluster assembly, we show that the SBM can quantitatively explain the ChIP-seq ParB binding profiles without any fitting parameter, aside from the supercoiling density of DNA, which, remarkably, is in accord with independent measurements. We also predict that ParB assembly results from a non-equilibrium, stationary balance between an influx of produced proteins and an outflux of excess proteins, i.e., ParB clusters behave like liquid-like protein condensates with unconventional “leaky” boundaries.     

Enhanced binding of an HU homologue under increased DNA supercoiling preserves chromosome organisation and sustains Streptomyces hyphal growth

Bacterial chromosome topology is controlled by topoisomerases and nucleoid-associated proteins (NAPs). While topoisomerases regulate DNA supercoiling, NAPs introduce bends or coat DNA upon its binding, affecting DNA loop formation. Streptomyces, hyphal, multigenomic bacteria known for producing numerous clinically important compounds, use the highly processive topoisomerase I (TopA) to remove excessive negative DNA supercoils. Elongated vegetative Streptomyces cells contain multiple copies of their linear chromosome, which remain relaxed and relatively evenly distributed. Here, we explored how TopA cooperates with HupA, an HU homologue that is the most abundant Streptomyces NAP. We verified that HupA has an increased affinity for supercoiled DNA in vivo and in vitro. Analysis of mutant strains demonstrated that HupA elimination is detrimental under high DNA supercoiling conditions. The absence of HupA, combined with decreased TopA levels, disrupted chromosome distribution in hyphal cells, eventually inhibiting hyphal growth. We concluded that increased HupA binding to DNA under elevated chromosome supercoiling conditions is critical for the preservation of chromosome organisation.     

Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I mutants: Increased supercoiling is corrected by mutations near gyrase genes

Bacterial chromosomes and plasmid (pBR322) DNA from topoisomerase I-defective Escherichia coli strains have been characterized with respect to superhelical density. The topoisomerase I defect results in increased negative superhelical density of both the bacterial chromosome and pBR322. Thus topoisomerase I is involved in determining the level of supercoiling in bacteria. Three of the topoisomerase I-defective strains we studied carry secondary mutations that decrease superhelical density; these additional mutations are closely linked to the gyrB locus in two of the strains and to the gyrA locus in the third strain.     

The form of the DNA substrate required for excisive recombination of bacteriophage lambda.

We have studied the excision reaction of bacteriophage lambda, both in vivo and in vitro, using as a substrate a λatt²(L × R) phage carrying both the right and left-hand prophage attachment sites. Int and Xis are provided by induction of the heat-inducible defective prophage, λc1857 ΔH1. After a brief induction (5 min) of these cells, excisive recombination is blocked in the presence of the DNA gyrase inhibitor, coumermycin. However, after a longer induction (greater than 30 min) excisive recombination occurs efficiently under conditions where λ integrative recombination is inhibited by coumermycin. In such extensively induced coumermycin-treated cells, infecting λatt²(L × R) DNA is not supercoiled, and recombinants are found among the relaxed covalently closed circular DNA.In vitro, starting with a hydrogen-bonded λatt² DNA substrate, excision is insensitive to high concentrations of coumermycin and novobiocin. To study the DNA substrate requirements for excisive recombination in more detail, we have developed a restriction fragment assay for excisive recombination. With this assay, we demonstrate that supercoiled, hydrogen-bonded, and linear λatt² DNA molecules are all efficient substrates in the in vitro excision reaction. Spermidine is required but ATP and Mg²⁺ are not. We conclude that supercoiling is not an absolute requirement for site-specific recombination of λ.     

DNA topoisomerase I mutants. Increased heterogeneity in linking number and other replicon-dependent changes in DNA supercoiling

Plasmid pBR322 DNA isolated from Salmonella typhimurium supX (topoisomerase I) mutants exhibits a novel supercoiling distribution characterized by extreme heterogeneity in linking number and the presence of highly negatively supercoiled topoisomers. The most negatively supercoiled topoisomers isolated from one supX mutant have more than twice the wild-type level of supercoiling; the distribution as a whole has a median superhelix density about 1.3 times that of wild type. Surprisingly, the supercoiling distribution of plasmid pUC9 DNA isolated from supX mutants differs from that of pBR322. Escherichia coli topoisomerase I mutants have been shown to acquire compensatory mutations that reduce bacterial chromosome supercoiling to below the wild-type level even in the absence of topoisomerase I. We find that such a compensatory mutation in an E. coli topoisomerase I deletion mutant does not reduce pBR322 DNA supercoiling to a level below that of wild type. Thus, the effects of topoisomerase mutations on supercoiling depend on the replicon.     

Counterintuitive DNA Sequence Dependence in Supercoiling-Induced DNA Melting

The metabolism of DNA in cells relies on the balance between hybridized double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and local de-hybridized regions of ssDNA that provide access to binding proteins. Traditional melting experiments, in which short pieces of dsDNA are heated up until the point of melting into ssDNA, have determined that AT-rich sequences have a lower binding energy than GC-rich sequences. In cells, however, the double-stranded backbone of DNA is destabilized by negative supercoiling, and not by temperature. To investigate what the effect of GC content is on DNA melting induced by negative supercoiling, we studied DNA molecules with a GC content ranging from 38% to 77%, using single-molecule magnetic tweezer measurements in which the length of a single DNA molecule is measured as a function of applied stretching force and supercoiling density. At low force (<0.5pN), supercoiling results into twisting of the dsDNA backbone and loop formation (plectonemes), without inducing any DNA melting. This process was not influenced by the DNA sequence. When negative supercoiling is introduced at increasing force, local melting of DNA is introduced. We measured for the different DNA molecules a characteristic force F _char, at which negative supercoiling induces local melting of the dsDNA. Surprisingly, GC-rich sequences melt at lower forces than AT-rich sequences: F _char = 0.56pN for 77% GC but 0.73pN for 38% GC. An explanation for this counterintuitive effect is provided by the realization that supercoiling densities of a few percent only induce melting of a few percent of the base pairs. As a consequence, denaturation bubbles occur in local AT-rich regions and the sequence-dependent effect arises from an increased DNA bending/torsional energy associated with the plectonemes. This new insight indicates that an increased GC-content adjacent to AT-rich DNA regions will enhance local opening of the double-stranded DNA helix.     

Interactions stabilizing DNA tertiary structure in the Escherichia coli chromosome investigated with ionizing radiation

The structure of the bacterial chromosome was investigated after introducing breaks in the DNA with gamma irradiation. It is demonstrated that irradiation of the chromosome in the cell prior to isolation results in partial unfolding of the isolated condensed DNA, while irradiation of the chromosome after it is released from the cell has no demonstrable effect on DNA folding. The results indicate that RNA/DNA interactions which stabilize DNA folds are unstable when breaks are introduced in the DNA prior to isolation of the chromosome. It is suggested that the supercoiled state of the DNA is required for the initial stabilization of some of the critical RNA/DNA interaction in the isolated nucleoid. However, some of these interactions are not affected by irradiation of the cells. Remnant supercoiling in partially relaxed chromosomes containing a limited number of DNA breaks has the same superhelical density as the unirradiated chromosome. This suggests that restraints on rotation of the packaged DNA are formed prior to the physical unwinding which occurs at the sites of the radiation induced DNA breaks. — Analysis of the in vitro irradiated chromosomes shows that there are 100+-30 domains of supercoiling per genome equivalent of DNA. The introduction of up to 50 double-strand breaks per nucleoid does not influence rotor speed effects of the sedimentation coefficient of the chromosome.     

Single-molecule studies on the mechanical interplay between DNA supercoiling and H-NS DNA architectural properties

The Escherichia coli H-NS protein is a major nucleoid-associated protein that is involved in chromosomal DNA packaging and gene regulatory functions. These biological processes are intimately related to the DNA supercoiling state and thus suggest a direct relationship between H-NS binding and DNA supercoiling. Here, we show that H-NS, which has two distinct DNA-binding modes, is able to differentially regulate DNA supercoiling. H-NS DNA-stiffening mode caused by nucleoprotein filament formation is able to suppress DNA plectoneme formation during DNA supercoiling. In contrast, when H-NS is in its DNA-bridging mode, it is able to promote DNA plectoneme formation during DNA supercoiling. In addition, the DNA-bridging mode is able to block twists diffusion thus trapping DNA in supercoiled domains. Overall, this work reveals the mechanical interplay between H-NS and DNA supercoiling which provides insights to H-NS organization of chromosomal DNA based on its two distinct DNA architectural properties.     

Histone H1 preferentially binds to superhelical DNA molecules of higher compaction.

In chromatin, the physiological amount of H1 is one molecule per nucleosome or, roughly, one molecule per 200 bp of DNA. We observed that at such a stoichiometry, H1 selectively binds to supercoiled DNA with magnitude of sigma > or = 0.012 (both negative and positive), leaving relaxed, linear, or nicked DNA molecules unbound. When negative and positive DNA topoisomers of varying superhelicity are simultaneously present in the binding mixture, H1 selectively binds to the molecules with highest superhelicity; less supercoiled forms are gradually involved in binding upon increasing the amount of input protein. We explain this topological preference of H1 as the consequence of an increased probability for more than one H1-DNA contact provided by the supercoiling. The existence of simultaneous contacts of H1 with both intertwined DNA strands in the supercoiled DNA molecules is also inferred by topoisomerase relaxation of H1-DNA complexes that had been prefixed with glutaraldehyde.     

Real-time detection of DNA topological changes with a fluorescently labeled cruciform

Topoisomerases are essential cellular enzymes that maintain the appropriate topological status of DNA and are the targets of several antibiotic and chemotherapeutic agents. High-throughput (HT) analysis is desirable to identify new topoisomerase inhibitors, but standard in vitro assays for DNA topology, such as gel electrophoresis, are time-consuming and are not amenable to HT analysis. We have exploited the observation that closed-circular DNA containing an inverted repeat can release the free energy stored in negatively supercoiled DNA by extruding the repeat as a cruciform. We inserted an inverted repeat containing a fluorophore-quencher pair into a plasmid to enable real-time monitoring of plasmid supercoiling by a bacterial topoisomerase, Escherichia coli gyrase. This substrate produces a fluorescent signal caused by the extrusion of the cruciform and separation of the labels as gyrase progressively underwinds the DNA. Subsequent relaxation by a eukaryotic topoisomerase, human topo IIα, causes reintegration of the cruciform and quenching of fluorescence. We used this approach to develop a HT screen for inhibitors of gyrase supercoiling. This work demonstrates that fluorescently labeled cruciforms are useful as general real-time indicators of changes in DNA topology that can be used to monitor the activity of DNA-dependent motor proteins.     

Conformational and thermodynamic properties of supercoiled DNA.

We used Monte Carlo simulations to investigate the conformational and thermodynamic properties of DNA molecules with physiological levels of supercoiling. Three parameters determine the properties of DNA in this model: Kuhn statistical length, torsional rigidity and effective double-helix diameter. The chains in the simulation resemble strongly those observed by electron microscopy and have the conformation of an interwound superhelix whose axis is often branched. We compared the geometry of simulated chains with that determined experimentally by electron microscopy and by topological methods. We found a very close agreement between the Monte Carlo and experimental values for writhe, superhelix axis length and the number of superhelical turns. The computed number of superhelix branches was found to be dependent on superhelix density, DNA chain length and double-helix diameter. We investigated the thermodynamics of supercoiling and found that at low superhelix density the entropic contribution to superhelix free energy is negligible, whereas at high superhelix density, the entropic and enthalpic contributions are nearly equal. We calculated the effect of supercoiling on the spatial distribution of DNA segments. The probability that a pair of DNA sites separated along the chain contour by at least 50 nm are juxtaposed is about two orders of magnitude greater in supercoiled DNA than in relaxed DNA. This increase in the effective local concentration of DNA is not strongly dependent on the contour separation between the sites. We discuss the implications of this enhancement of site juxtaposition by supercoiling in the context of protein-DNA interactions involving multiple DNA-binding sites.