Fourier-transform infrared study of the photoactivation process of Xenopus (6-4) photolyase

Photolyases (PHRs) are blue light-activated DNA repair enzymes that maintain genetic integrity by reverting UV-induced photoproducts into normal bases. The flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) chromophore of PHRs has four different redox states: oxidized (FAD(ox)), anion radical (FAD(?-)), neutral radical (FADH(?)), and fully reduced (FADH(-)). We combined difference Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy with UV-visible spectroscopy to study the detailed photoactivation process of Xenopus (6-4) PHR. Two photons produce the enzymatically active, fully reduced PHR from oxidized FAD: FAD(ox) is converted to semiquinone via light-induced one-electron and one-proton transfers and then to FADH(-) by light-induced one-electron transfer. We successfully trapped FAD(?-) at 200 K, where electron transfer occurs but proton transfer does not. UV-visible spectroscopy following 450 nm illumination of FAD(ox) at 277 K defined the FADH(?)/FADH(-) mixture and allowed calculation of difference FTIR spectra among the four redox states. The absence of a characteristic C=O stretching vibration indicated that the proton donor is not a protonated carboxylic acid. Structural changes in Trp and Tyr are suggested by UV-visible and FTIR analysis of FAD(?-) at 200 K. Spectral analysis of amide I vibrations revealed structural perturbation of the protein's β-sheet during initial electron transfer (FAD(?-) formation), a transient increase in α-helicity during proton transfer (FADH(?) formation), and reversion to the initial amide I signal following subsequent electron transfer (FADH(-) formation). Consequently, in (6-4) PHR, unlike cryptochrome-DASH, formation of enzymatically active FADH(-) did not perturb α-helicity. Protein structural changes in the photoactivation of (6-4) PHR are discussed on the basis of these FTIR observations.     

Searching for a photocycle of the cryptochrome photoreceptors

The initial photochemistry of plant cryptochromes has been extensively investigated in recent years. It is hypothesized that cryptochrome photoexcitation involves a Trp-triad-dependent photoreduction. According to this hypothesis, cryptochromes in the resting state contain oxidized FAD; light triggers a sequential electron transfer from three tryptophan residues to reduce FAD to a neutral semiquinone (FADH*); FADH* is the presumed signaling state and it is re-oxidized to complete the photocycle. However, this photoreduction hypothesis is currently under debate. An alternative model argues that the initial photochemistry of cryptochromes involves a photolyase-like cyclic electron shuttle without a bona fide redox reaction mediated by the Trp-triad residues, leading to conformational changes, signal propagation, and physiological responses.     

Blue-light-induced changes in Arabidopsis cryptochrome 1 probed by FTIR difference spectroscopy

Cryptochromes are blue-light photoreceptors that regulate a variety of responses in animals and plants, including circadian entrainment in Drosophila and photomorphogenesis in Arabidopsis. They comprise a photolyase homology region (PHR) of about 500 amino acids and a C-terminal extension of varying length. In the PHR domain, flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) is noncovalently bound. The presence of a second chromophore, such as methenyltetrahydrofolate, in animal and plant cryptochromes is still under debate. Arabidopsis cryptochrome 1 (CRY1) has been intensively studied with regard to function and interaction of the protein in vivo and in vitro. However, little is known about the pathway from light absorption to signal transduction on the molecular level. We investigated the full-length CRY1 protein by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and UV/vis difference spectroscopy. Starting from the fully oxidized state of the chromophore FAD, a neutral flavoprotein radical is formed upon illumination in the absence of any exogenous electron donor. A preliminary assignment of the chromophore bands is presented. The FTIR difference spectrum reveals only moderate changes in secondary structure of the apoprotein in response to the photoreduction of the chromophore. Deprotonation of an aspartic or glutamic acid, probably D396, accompanies radical formation, as is deduced from the negative band at 1734 cm(-)(1) in D(2)O. The main positive band at 1524 cm(-)(1) in the FTIR spectrum shows a strong shift to lower frequencies as compared to other flavoproteins. Together with the unusual blue-shift of the absorption in the visible range to 595 nm, this clearly distinguishes the radical form of CRY1 from those of structurally highly homologous DNA photolyases. As a consequence, the direct comparison of cryptochrome to photolyase in terms of photoreactivity and mechanism has to be made with caution.     

On the role of aromatic side chains in the photoactivation of BLUF domains

BLUF (blue-light sensing using FAD) domain proteins are a novel group of blue-light sensing receptors found in many microorganisms. The role of the aromatic side chains Y21 and W104, which are in close vicinity to the FAD cofactor in the AppA BLUF domain from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, is investigated through the introduction of several amino acid substitutions at these positions. NMR spectroscopy indicated that in the W104F mutant, the local structure of the FAD binding pocket was not significantly perturbed as compared to that of the wild type. Time-resolved fluorescence and absorption spectroscopy was applied to explore the role of Y21 and W104 in AppA BLUF photochemistry. In the Y21 mutants, FADH*-W* radical pairs are transiently formed on a ps time scale and recombine to the ground state on a ns time scale. The W104F mutant shows a spectral evolution similar to that of wild type AppA but with an increased yield of signaling state formation. In the Y21F/W104F double mutant, all light-driven electron-transfer processes are abolished, and the FAD singlet excited-state evolves by intersystem crossing to the triplet state. Our results indicate that two competing light-driven electron-transfer pathways are available in BLUF domains: one productive pathway that involves electron transfer from the tyrosine, which leads to signaling state formation, and one nonproductive electron-transfer pathway from the tryptophan, which leads to deactivation and the effective lowering of the quantum yield of the signaling state formation. Our results are consistent with a photoactivation mechanism for BLUF domains where signaling state formation proceeds via light-driven electron and proton transfer from the conserved tyrosine to FAD, followed by a hydrogen-bond rearrangement and radical-pair recombination.     

Variable Electron Transfer Pathways in an Amphibian Cryptochrome: TRYPTOPHAN VERSUS TYROSINE-BASED RADICAL PAIRS*

Electron transfer reactions play vital roles in many biological processes. Very often the transfer of charge(s) proceeds stepwise over large distances involving several amino acid residues. By using time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance and optical spectroscopy, we have studied the mechanism of light-induced reduction of the FAD cofactor of cryptochrome/photolyase family proteins. In this study, we demonstrate that electron abstraction from a nearby amino acid by the excited FAD triggers further electron transfer steps even if the conserved chain of three tryptophans, known to be an effective electron transfer pathway in these proteins, is blocked. Furthermore, we were able to characterize this secondary electron transfer pathway and identify the amino acid partner of the resulting flavin-amino acid radical pair as a tyrosine located at the protein surface. This alternative electron transfer pathway could explain why interrupting the conserved tryptophan triad does not necessarily alter photoreactions of cryptochromes in vivo. Taken together, our results demonstrate that light-induced electron transfer is a robust property of cryptochromes and more intricate than commonly anticipated.     

Blue light induces radical formation and autophosphorylation in the light-sensitive domain of Chlamydomonas cryptochrome

Cryptochromes are sensory blue light receptors mediating various responses in plants and animals. Studies on the mechanism of plant cryptochromes have been focused on the flowering plant Arabidopsis. In the genome of the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, a single plant cryptochrome, Chlamydomonas photolyase homologue 1 (CPH1), has been identified. The N-terminal 500 amino acids comprise the light-sensitive domain of CPH1 linked to a C-terminal extension of similar size. We have expressed the light-sensitive domain heterologously in Escherichia coli in high yield and purity. The 59-kDa protein bears exclusively flavin adenine dinucleotide in its oxidized state. Illumination with blue light induces formation of a neutral flavin radical with absorption maxima at 540 and 580 nm. The reaction proceeds aerobically even in the absence of an exogenous electron donor, which suggests that it reflects a physiological response. The process is completely reversible in the dark and exhibits a decay time constant of 200 s in the presence of oxygen. Binding of ATP strongly stabilizes the radical state after illumination and impedes the dark recovery. Thus, ATP binding has functional significance for plant cryptochromes and does not merely result from structural homology to DNA photolyase. The light-sensitive domain responds to illumination by an increase in phosphorylation. The autophosphorylation takes place although the protein is lacking its native C-terminal extension. This finding indicates that the extension is dispensable for autophosphorylation, despite the role it has been assigned in mediating signal transduction in Arabidopsis.     

A Flavin Binding Cryptochrome Photoreceptor Responds to Both Blue and Red Light in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Cryptochromes are flavoproteins that act as sensory blue light receptors in insects, plants, fungi, and bacteria. We have investigated a cryptochrome from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii with sequence homology to animal cryptochromes and (6-4) photolyases. In response to blue and red light exposure, this animal-like cryptochrome (aCRY) alters the light-dependent expression of various genes encoding proteins involved in chlorophyll and carotenoid biosynthesis, light-harvesting complexes, nitrogen metabolism, cell cycle control, and the circadian clock. Additionally, exposure to yellow but not far-red light leads to comparable increases in the expression of specific genes; this expression is significantly reduced in an acry insertional mutant. These in vivo effects are congruent with in vitro data showing that blue, yellow, and red light, but not far-red light, are absorbed by the neutral radical state of flavin in aCRY. The aCRY neutral radical is formed following blue light absorption of the oxidized flavin. Red illumination leads to conversion to the fully reduced state. Our data suggest that aCRY is a functionally important blue and red light-activated flavoprotein. The broad spectral response implies that the neutral radical state functions as a dark form in aCRY and expands the paradigm of flavoproteins and cryptochromes as blue light sensors to include other light qualities.     

Conformational change induced by ATP binding correlates with enhanced biological function of Arabidopsis cryptochrome

Cryptochromes are widely distributed blue light photoreceptors involved in numerous signaling functions in plants and animals. Both plant and animal-type cryptochromes are found to bind ATP and display intrinsic autokinase activity; however the functional significance of this activity remains a matter of speculation. Here we show in purified preparations of Arabidopsis cry1 that ATP binding induces conformational change independently of light and increases the amount and stability of light-induced flavin radical formation. Nucleotide binding may thereby provide a mechanism whereby light responsivity in organisms can be regulated through modulation of cryptochrome photoreceptor conformation.     

Role of structural plasticity in signal transduction by the cryptochrome blue-light photoreceptor

Cryptochromes are blue-light photoreceptors that regulate a variety of responses such as growth and circadian rhythms in organisms ranging from bacteria to humans. Cryptochromes share a high level of sequence identity with the light-activated DNA repair enzyme photolyase. Photolyase uses energy from blue light to repair UV-induced photoproducts in DNA through cyclic electron transfer between the catalytic flavin adenine dinucleotide cofactor and the damaged DNA. Cryptochromes lack DNA repair activity, and their mechanism of signal transduction is not known. It is hypothesized that a light-dependent signaling state in cryptochromes is created as a result of an intramolecular redox reaction, resulting in conformational rearrangement and effector binding. Plant and animal cryptochromes possess 30-250 amino acid carboxy-terminal extensions beyond the photolyase-homology region that have been shown to mediate phototransduction. We analyzed the structures of C-terminal domains from an animal and a plant cryptochrome by computational, biophysical, and biochemical methods and found these domains to be intrinsically unstructured. We show that the photolyase-homology region interacts with the C-terminal domain, inducing stable tertiary structure in the C-terminal domain. Importantly, we demonstrate a light-dependent conformational change in the C-terminal domain of Arabidopsis Cry1. Collectively, these findings provide the first biochemical evidence for the proposed conformational rearrangement of cryptochromes upon light exposure.     

A novel photoreaction mechanism for the circadian blue light photoreceptor Drosophila cryptochrome

Cryptochromes are flavoproteins that are evolutionary related to the DNA photolyases but lack DNA repair activity. Drosophila cryptochrome (dCRY) is a blue light photoreceptor that is involved in the synchronization of the circadian clock with the environmental light-dark cycle. Until now, spectroscopic and structural studies on this and other animal cryptochromes have largely been hampered by difficulties in their recombinant expression. We have therefore established an expression and purification scheme that enables us to purify mg amounts of monomeric dCRY from Sf21 insect cell cultures. Using UV-visible spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and reversed phase high pressure liquid chromatography, we show that insect cell-purified dCRY contains flavin adenine dinucleotide in its oxidized state (FAD(ox)) and residual amounts of methenyltetrahydrofolate. Upon blue light irradiation, dCRY undergoes a reversible absorption change, which is assigned to the conversion of FAD(ox) to the red anionic FAD(.) radical. Our findings lead us to propose a novel photoreaction mechanism for dCRY, in which FAD(ox) corresponds to the ground state, whereas the FAD(.) radical represents the light-activated state that mediates resetting of the Drosophila circadian clock.     

A proton delivery pathway in the soluble fumarate reductase from Shewanella frigidimarina

The mechanism for fumarate reduction by the soluble fumarate reductase from Shewanella frigidimarina involves hydride transfer from FAD and proton transfer from the active-site acid, Arg-402. It has been proposed that Arg-402 forms part of a proton transfer pathway that also involves Glu-378 and Arg-381 but, unusually, does not involve any bound water molecules. To gain further insight into the importance of this proton pathway we have perturbed it by substituting Arg-381 by lysine and methionine and Glu-378 by aspartate. Although all the mutant enzymes retain measurable activities, there are orders-of-magnitude decreases in their k(cat) values compared with the wild-type enzyme. Solvent kinetic isotope effects show that proton transfer is rate-limiting in the wild-type and mutant enzymes. Proton inventories indicate that the proton pathway involves multiple exchangeable groups. Fast scan protein-film voltammetric studies on wild-type and R381K enzymes show that the proton transfer pathway delivers one proton per catalytic cycle and is not required for transporting the other proton, which transfers as a hydride from the reduced, protonated FAD. The crystal structures of E378D and R381M mutant enzymes have been determined to 1.7 and 2.1 A resolution, respectively. They allow an examination of the structural changes that disturb proton transport. Taken together, the results indicate that Arg-381, Glu-378, and Arg-402 form a proton pathway that is completely conserved throughout the fumarate reductase/succinate dehydrogenase family of enzymes.     

Impact of the N5-proximal Asn on the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of the semiquinone radical in photolyase

Flavoproteins can dramatically adjust the thermodynamics and kinetics of electron transfer at their flavin cofactor. A versatile regulatory tool is proton transfer. Here, we demonstrate the significance of proton-coupled electron transfer to redox tuning and semiquinone (sq) stability in photolyases (PLs) and cryptochromes (CRYs). These light-responsive proteins share homologous overall architectures and FAD-binding pockets, yet they have evolved divergent functions that include DNA repair, photomorphogenesis, regulation of circadian rhythm, and magnetoreception. We report the first measurement of both FAD redox potentials for cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer PL (CPD-PL, Anacystis nidulans). These values, E(1)(hq/sq) = -140 mV and E(2)(sq/ox) = -219 mV, where hq is FAD hydroquinone and ox is oxidized FAD, establish that the sq is not thermodynamically stabilized (ΔE = E(2) - E(1) = -79 mV). Results with N386D CPD-PL support our earlier hypothesis of a kinetic barrier to sq oxidation associated with proton transfer. Both E(1) and E(2) are upshifted by ～ 100 mV in this mutant; replacing the N5-proximal Asn with Asp decreases the driving force for sq oxidation. However, this Asp alleviates the kinetic barrier, presumably by acting as a proton shuttle, because the sq in N386D CPD-PL oxidizes orders of magnitude more rapidly than wild type. These data clearly reveal, as suggested for plant CRYs, that an N5-proximal Asp can switch on proton transfer and modulate sq reactivity. However, the effect is context-dependent. More generally, we propose that PLs and CRYs tune the properties of their N5-proximal residue to adjust the extent of proton transfer, H-bonding patterns, and changes in protein conformation associated with electron transfer at the flavin.     

Light-induced electron transfer in Arabidopsis cryptochrome-1 correlates with in vivo function

Cryptochromes are blue light-activated photoreceptors found in multiple organisms with significant similarity to photolyases, a class of light-dependent DNA repair enzymes. Unlike photolyases, cryptochromes do not repair DNA and instead mediate blue light-dependent developmental, growth, and/or circadian responses by an as yet unknown mechanism of action. It has recently been shown that Arabidopsis cryptochrome-1 retains photolyase-like photoreduction of its flavin cofactor FAD by intraprotein electron transfer from tryptophan and tyrosine residues. Here we demonstrate that substitution of two conserved tryptophans that are constituents of the flavin-reducing electron transfer chain in Escherichia coli photolyase impairs light-induced electron transfer in the Arabidopsis cryptochrome-1 photoreceptor in vitro. Furthermore, we show that these substitutions result in marked reduction of light-activated autophosphorylation of cryptochrome-1 in vitro and of its photoreceptor function in vivo, consistent with biological relevance of the electron transfer reaction. These data support the possibility that light-induced flavin reduction via the tryptophan chain is the primary step in the signaling pathway of plant cryptochrome.     

Human and Drosophila cryptochromes are light activated by flavin photoreduction in living cells

Cryptochromes are a class of flavoprotein blue-light signaling receptors found in plants, animals, and humans that control plant development and the entrainment of circadian rhythms. In plant cryptochromes, light activation is proposed to result from photoreduction of a protein-bound flavin chromophore through intramolecular electron transfer. However, although similar in structure to plant cryptochromes, the light-response mechanism of animal cryptochromes remains entirely unknown. To complicate matters further, there is currently a debate on whether mammalian cryptochromes respond to light at all or are instead activated by non-light-dependent mechanisms. To resolve these questions, we have expressed both human and Drosophila cryptochrome proteins to high levels in living Sf21 insect cells using a baculovirus-derived expression system. Intact cells are irradiated with blue light, and the resulting cryptochrome photoconversion is monitored by fluorescence and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic techniques. We demonstrate that light induces a change in the redox state of flavin bound to the receptor in both human and Drosophila cryptochromes. Photoreduction from oxidized flavin and subsequent accumulation of a semiquinone intermediate signaling state occurs by a conserved mechanism that has been previously identified for plant cryptochromes. These results provide the first evidence of how animal-type cryptochromes are activated by light in living cells. Furthermore, human cryptochrome is also shown to undergo this light response. Therefore, human cryptochromes in exposed peripheral and/or visual tissues may have novel light-sensing roles that remain to be elucidated.     

Formation and function of flavin anion radical in cryptochrome 1 blue-light photoreceptor of monarch butterfly

The monarch butterfly (Danaus plexippus) cryptochrome 1 (DpCry1) belongs in the class of photosensitive insect cryptochromes. Here we purified DpCry1 expressed in a bacterial host and obtained the protein with a stoichiometric amount of the flavin cofactor in the two-electron oxidized, FAD(ox), form. Exposure of the purified protein to light converts the FAD(ox) to the FAD*(-) flavin anion radical by intraprotein electron transfer from a Trp residue in the apoenzyme. To test whether this novel photoreduction reaction is part of the DpCry1 physiological photocycle, we mutated the Trp residue that acts as the ultimate electron donor in flavin photoreduction. The mutation, W328F, blocked the photoreduction entirely but had no measurable effect on the light-induced degradation of DpCry1 in vivo. In light of this finding and the recently published action spectrum of this class of Crys, we conclude that DpCry1 and similar insect cryptochromes do not contain flavin in the FAD(ox) form in vivo and that, most likely, the [see text] photoreduction reaction is not part of the insect cryptochrome photoreaction that results in proteolytic degradation of the photopigment.     

Lifetimes of Arabidopsis cryptochrome signaling states in vivo

One crucial component in light signaling is the quantity of photoreceptor present in the active signaling state. The lifetime of the signaling state of a photoreceptor is limited because of thermal or otherwise back reversion of the chromophore to the ground state, and/or degradation of the photoreceptor in the light‐activated state. It was previously shown that the lit state of plant cryptochromes contains flavin‐neutral semiquinone, and that the half‐lives of the lit state were in the range of 3–4 min in vitro. However, it was unknown how long‐lived the signaling states of plant cryptochromes are in situ. Based on the loss of degradation of cry2 after prolonged dark incubation and loss of reversibility of photoactivated cry1 by a pulse of green light, we estimate the in vivo half‐lives of the signaling states of cry1 and cry2 to be in the range of 5 and 16 min, respectively. Based on electron paramagnetic resonance measurements, the lifetime of the Arabidopsis cry1 lit state in insect cells was found to be ~6 min, and thus very similar to the lifetime of the signaling state in planta. Thus, the signaling state lifetimes of plant cryptochromes are not, or are only moderately, stabilized in planta.     

A cluster of carboxylic groups in PsbO protein is involved in proton transfer from the water oxidizing complex of Photosystem II

The hypothesis presented here for proton transfer away from the water oxidation complex of Photosystem II (PSII) is supported by biochemical experiments on the isolated PsbO protein in solution, theoretical analyses of better understood proton transfer systems like bacteriorhodopsin and cytochrome oxidase, and the recently published 3D structure of PS II (Pdb entry 1S5L). We propose that a cluster of conserved glutamic and aspartic acid residues in the PsbO protein acts as a buffering network providing efficient acceptors of protons derived from substrate water molecules. The charge delocalization of the cluster ensures readiness to promptly accept the protons liberated from substrate water. Therefore protons generated at the catalytic centre of PSII need not be released into the thylakoid lumen as generally thought. The cluster is the beginning of a localized, fast proton transfer conduit on the lumenal side of the thylakoid membrane. Proton-dependent conformational changes of PsbO may play a role in the regulation of both supply of substrate water to the water oxidizing complex and the resultant proton transfer.     

Communication between the ATPase and cleavage/religation domains of human topoisomerase IIalpha

The DNA strand passage activity of eukaryotic topoisomerase II relies on a cascade of conformational changes triggered by ATP binding to the N-terminal domain of the enzyme. To investigate the interdomain communication between the ATPase and cleavage/religation domains of human topoisomerase IIalpha, we characterized a mutant enzyme that contains a deletion at the interface between the two domains, covering amino acids 350-407. The ATPase domain retained full activity with a rate of ATP hydrolysis that was severalfold higher than normal, but the ATPase activity was unaffected by DNA. The cleavage and religation activities of the enzyme were comparable with those of the wild-type enzyme both in the absence and presence of cancer chemotherapeutic agents. However, neither ATP nor a nonhydrolyzable ATP analog stimulated cleavage complex formation. Although both conserved domains retained full activity, the mutant enzyme was unable to coordinate these activities into strand passage. Our findings suggest that the normal conformational transitions occurring in the enzyme upon ATP binding are hampered or lacking in the mutant enzyme. Consistent with this hypothesis, the enzyme displayed an abnormal clamp closing activity. In summary, the region covering amino acids 350-407 in human topoisomerase IIalpha seems to be essential for correct interdomain communication and probably is involved in signaling ATP binding to the rest of the enzyme.     

Synergistic interactions of multiple mutations on catalysis during the hydroxylation reaction of p-hydroxybenzoate hydroxylase: studies of the Lys297Met, Asn300Asp, and Tyr385Phe mutants reconstituted with 8-Cl-flavin

The oxygen transfer to p-hydroxybenzoate catalyzed by p-hydroxybenzoate hydroxylase (PHBH) has been shown to occur via a C4a-hydroperoxide of the flavin. Two factors are likely to be important in facilitating the transfer of oxygen from the C4a-hydroperoxide to the substrate. (a) The positive electrostatic potential of the active site partially stabilizes the negative charge centered on the oxygen of the flavin-C4a-alkoxide leaving group during the transition state [Ortiz-Maldonado, M., Ballou, D. P., and Massey, V. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 8124-8137]. (b) The hydrogen-bonding network ionizes the substrate to promote its nucleophilic attack on the electrophilic C4a-hydroperoxide intermediate [Entsch, B., Palfey, B. A., Ballou, D. P., and Massey, V. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 17341-17349]. This ionization is also aided by the positive electrostatic potential of the active site [Moran, G. R., Entsch, B., Palfey, B. A., and Ballou, D. P. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 7548-7556]. Substituents on the flavin can specifically affect the stability of the alkoxide leaving-group, whereas changes to specific enzyme residues can affect the charge in the active site and the hydrogen-bonding network. We have used wild-type (WT) PHBH and several mutant forms, all with normal FAD and with 8-Cl-FAD substituted for FAD, to assess the relative contributions of the two effects. Lys297Met and Asn300Asp have decreased positive charge in the active site, and these variants engender approximately 35-fold slower hydroxylation rates than the WT enzyme. Substitution of 8-Cl-FAD in these mutant forms gives approximately 1.8-fold increases in hydroxylation rates, compared with a > or =4.8-fold increase for WT with this flavin. The hydroxylation catalyzed by Tyr385Phe, a mutant enzyme form with a disrupted hydrogen-bonding network that compromises the ionization of the substrate without changing the positive charge of the active site, is stimulated 1.5-fold by substituting the enzyme with 8-Cl-FAD. The substrate, tetrafluoro-p-hydroxybenzoate, is fully ionized in WT PHBH, but this phenolate is a poor nucleophile because of the electron-withdrawing effects of the fluorine substituents. With tetrafluoro-p-hydroxybenzoate as the substrate, substitution of FAD with 8-Cl-FAD in the WT enzyme stabilizes the leaving alkoxide and leads to a 2.3-fold increase in the hydroxylation rate compared to that with FAD. Either the use of substrates that do not communicate with the proton network or the mutation of amino acid residues that perturb this interaction may prevent a necessary conformational change that allows proper orientation between reactants during the hydroxylation reaction or permits the essential protonation of the initially formed nascent flavin-C4a-peroxide anion. Thus, both activation of substrate by the proton network and stabilization of the leaving alkoxide appear to be important for oxygen transfer catalyzed by PHBH. The full effect of the substituents on the flavin (4.8-fold) can only be realized when the optimal transition state can be achieved, and this optimal state is not fully realized with the mutant forms.