Ribonucleotide reductases: divergent evolution of an ancient enzyme

Ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs) are uniquely responsible for converting nucleotides to deoxynucleotides in all dividing cells. The three known classes of RNRs operate through a free radical mechanism but differ in the way in which the protein radical is generated. Class I enzymes depend on oxygen for radical generation, class II uses adenosylcobalamin, and the anaerobic class III requires S-adenosylmethionine and an iron–sulfur cluster. Despite their metabolic prominence, the evolutionary origin and relationships between these enzymes remain elusive. This gap in RNR knowledge can, to a major extent, be attributed to the fact that different RNR classes exhibit greatly diverged polypeptide chains, rendering homology assessments inconclusive. Evolutionary studies of RNRs conducted until now have focused on comparison of the amino acid sequence of the proteins, without considering how they fold into space. The present study is an attempt to understand the evolutionary history of RNRs taking into account their three-dimensional structure. We first infer the structural alignment by superposing the equivalent stretches of the three-dimensional structures of representatives of each family. We then use the structural alignment to guide the alignment of all publicly available RNR sequences. Our results support the hypothesis that the three RNR classes diverged from a common ancestor currently represented by the anaerobic class III. Also, lateral transfer appears to have played a significant role in the evolution of this protein family.     

The periodic table of ribonucleotide reductases

In most organisms, transition metal ions are necessary cofactors of ribonucleotide reductase (RNR), the enzyme responsible for biosynthesis of the 2′-deoxynucleotide building blocks of DNA. The metal ion generates an oxidant for an active site cysteine (Cys), yielding a thiyl radical that is necessary for initiation of catalysis in all RNRs. Class I enzymes, widespread in eukaryotes and aerobic microbes, share a common requirement for dioxygen in assembly of the active Cys oxidant and a unique quaternary structure, in which the metallo- or radical-cofactor is found in a separate subunit, β, from the catalytic α subunit. The first class I RNRs, the class Ia enzymes, discovered and characterized more than 30 years ago, were found to use a diiron(III)-tyrosyl-radical Cys oxidant. Although class Ia RNRs have historically served as the model for understanding enzyme mechanism and function, more recently, remarkably diverse bioinorganic and radical cofactors have been discovered in class I RNRs from pathogenic microbes. These enzymes use alternative transition metal ions, such as manganese, or posttranslationally installed tyrosyl radicals for initiation of ribonucleotide reduction. Here we summarize the recent progress in discovery and characterization of novel class I RNR radical-initiating cofactors, their mechanisms of assembly, and how they might function in the context of the active class I holoenzyme complex.     

Spectroscopic and theoretical approaches for studying radical reactions in class I ribonucleotide reductase

Ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs) catalyze the production of deoxyribonucleotides, which are essential for DNA synthesis and repair in all organisms. The three currently known classes of RNRs are postulated to utilize a similar mechanism for ribonucleotide reduction via a transient thiyl radical, but they differ in the way this radical is generated. Class I RNR, found in all eukaryotic organisms and in some eubacteria and viruses, employs a diferric iron center and a stable tyrosyl radical in a second protein subunit, R2, to drive thiyl radical generation near the substrate binding site in subunit R1. From extensive experimental and theoretical research during the last decades, a general mechanistic model for class I RNR has emerged, showing three major mechanistic steps: generation of the tyrosyl radical by the diiron center in subunit R2, radical transfer to generate the proposed thiyl radical near the substrate bound in subunit R1, and finally catalytic reduction of the bound ribonucleotide. Amino acid- or substrate-derived radicals are involved in all three major reactions. This article summarizes the present mechanistic picture of class I RNR and highlights experimental and theoretical approaches that have contributed to our current understanding of this important class of radical enzymes.     

Characteristics of mammalian class III alcohol dehydrogenases, an enzyme less variable than the traditional liver enzyme of class I

Class III alcohol dehydrogenase, whose activity toward ethanol is negligible, has defined, specific properties and is not just a "variant" of the class I protein, the traditional liver enzyme. The primary structure of the horse class III protein has now been determined, and this allows the comparison of alcohol dehydrogenases from human, horse, and rat for both classes III and I, providing identical triads for both these enzyme types. Many consistent differences between the classes separate the two forms as distinct enzymes with characteristic properties. The mammalian class III enzymes are much less variable in structure than the corresponding typical liver enzymes of class I: there are 35 versus 84 positional differences in these identical three-species sets. The class III and class I subunits contain four versus two tryptophan residues, respectively. This makes the differences in absorbance at 280 nm a characteristic property. There are also 4-6 fewer positive charges in the class III enzymes accounting for their electrophoretic differences. The substrate binding site of class III differs from that of class I by replacements at positions that form the hydrophobic barrel typical for this site. In class III, two to four of these positions contain residues with polar or even charged side chains (positions 57 and 93 in all species, plus positions 116 in the horse and 140 in the human and the horse), while corresponding intraclass variation is small. All these structural features correlate with functional characteristics and suggest that the enzyme classes serve different roles. In addition, the replacements between these triad sets illustrate further general properties of the two mammalian alcohol dehydrogenase classes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The Evolution of Acetyl-CoA Synthase

Acetyl-coenzyme A synthases (ACS) are Ni-Fe-S containing enzymes found in archaea and bacteria. They are divisible into 4 classes. Class I ACS's catalyze the synthesis of acetyl-CoA from CO2 + 2e-, CoA, and a methyl group, and contain 5 types of subunits (alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon). Class II enzymes catalyze essentially the reverse reaction and have similar subunit composition. Class III ACS's catalyze the same reaction as Class I enzymes, but use pyruvate as a source of CO2 and 2e-, and are composed of 2 autonomous proteins, an alpha 2 beta 2 tetramer and a gamma delta heterodimer. Class IV enzymes catabolize CO to CO2 and are alpha-subunit monomers. Phylogenetic analyses were performed on all five subunits. ACS alpha sequences divided into 2 major groups, including Class I/II sequences and Class III/IV-like sequences. Conserved residues that may function as ligands to the B- and C-clusters were identified. Other residues exclusively conserved in Class I/II sequences may be ligands to additional metal centers in Class I and II enzymes. ACS beta sequences also separated into two groups, but they were less divergent than the alpha's, and the separation was not as distinct. Class III-like beta sequences contained approximately 300 residues at their N-termini absent in Class I/II sequences. Conserved residues identified in beta sequences may function as ligands to active site residues used for acetyl-CoA synthesis. ACS gamma-sequences separated into 3 groups (Classes I, II, and III), while delta-sequences separated into 2 groups (Class I/II and III). These groups are less divergent than those of alpha sequences. ACS epsilon-sequence topology showed greater divergence and less consistency vis-à-vis the other subunits, possibly reflecting reduced evolutionary constraints due to the absence of metal centers. The alpha subunit phylogeny may best reflect the functional diversity of ACS enzymes. Scenarios of how ACS and ACS-containing organisms may have evolved are discussed.     

Ribonucleotide reduction - horizontal transfer of a required function spans all three domains

Background  

Ribonucleotide reduction is the only de novo pathway for synthesis of deoxyribonucleotides, the building blocks of DNA. The reaction is catalysed by ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs), an ancient enzyme family comprised of three classes. Each class has distinct operational constraints, and are broadly distributed across organisms from all three domains, though few class I RNRs have been identified in archaeal genomes, and classes II and III likewise appear rare across eukaryotes. In this study, we examine whether this distribution is best explained by presence of all three classes in the Last Universal Common Ancestor (LUCA), or by horizontal gene transfer (HGT) of RNR genes. We also examine to what extent environmental factors may have impacted the distribution of RNR classes.     

Cysteines involved in radical generation and catalysis of class III anaerobic ribonucleotide reductase. A protein engineering study of bacteriophage T4 NrdD

Class III ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) is an anaerobic glycyl radical enzyme that catalyzes the reduction of ribonucleotides to deoxyribonucleotides. We have investigated the importance in the reaction mechanism of nine conserved cysteine residues in class III RNR from bacteriophage T4. By using site-directed mutagenesis, we show that two of the cysteines, Cys-79 and Cys-290, are directly involved in the reaction mechanism. Based on the positioning of these two residues in the active site region of the known three-dimensional structure of the phage T4 enzyme, and their structural equivalence to two cysteine residues in the active site region of the aerobic class I RNR, we suggest that Cys-290 participates in the reaction mechanism by forming a transient thiyl radical and that Cys-79 participates in the actual reduction of the substrate. Our results provide strong experimental evidence for a similar radical-based reaction mechanism in all classes of RNR but also identify important differences between class III RNR and the other classes of RNR as regards the reduction per se. We also identify a cluster of four cysteines (Cys-543, Cys-546, Cys-561, and Cys-564) in the C-terminal part of the class III enzyme, which are essential for formation of the glycyl radical. These cysteines make up a CX(2)C-CX(2)C motif in the vicinity of the stable radical at Gly-580. We propose that the four cysteines are involved in radical transfer between Gly-580 and the cofactor S-adenosylmethionine of the activating NrdG enzyme needed for glycyl radical generation.     

Analysis of class II (hydrolytic) and class I (beta-lyase) apurinic/apyrimidinic endonucleases with a synthetic DNA substrate.

We have developed simple and sensitive assays that distinguish the main classes of apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonucleases: Class I enzymes that cleave on the 3' side of AP sites by beta-elimination, and Class II enzymes that cleave by hydrolysis on the 5' side. The distinction of the two types depends on the use of a synthetic DNA polymer that contains AP sites with 5'-[32P]phosphate residues. Using this approach, we now show directly that Escherichia coli endonuclease IV and human AP endonuclease are Class II enzymes, as inferred previously on the basis of indirect assays. The assay method does not exhibit significant interference by nonspecific nucleases or primary amines, which allows the ready determination of different AP endonuclease activities in crude cell extracts. In this way, we show that virtually all of the Class II AP endonuclease activity in E. coli can be accounted for by two enzymes: exonuclease III and endonuclease IV. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the Class II AP endonuclease activity is totally dependent on a single enzyme, the Apn1 protein, but there are probably multiple Class I enzymes. The versatility and ease of our approach should be useful for characterizing this important class of DNA repair enzymes in diverse systems.     

Control of metallation and active cofactor assembly in the class Ia and Ib ribonucleotide reductases: diiron or dimanganese?

Ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs) convert nucleotides to deoxynucleotides in all organisms. Activity of the class Ia and Ib RNRs requires a stable tyrosyl radical (Y?), which can be generated by the reaction of O2 with a diferrous cluster on the β subunit to form active diferric-Y? cofactor. Recent experiments have demonstrated, however, that in vivo the class Ib RNR contains an active dimanganese(III)-Y? cofactor. The similar metal binding sites of the class Ia and Ib RNRs, their ability to bind both MnII and FeII, and the activity of the class Ib RNR with both diferric-Y? and dimanganese(III)-Y cofactors raise the intriguing question of how the cell prevents mismetallation of these essential enzymes. The presence of the class Ib RNR in numerous pathogenic bacteria also highlights the importance of manganese for these organisms' growth and virulence.     

Two active site asparagines are essential for the reaction mechanism of the class III anaerobic ribonucleotide reductase from bacteriophage T4

Class III ribonucleotide reductase is an anaerobic enzyme that uses a glycyl radical to catalyze the reduction of ribonucleotides to deoxyribonucleotides and formate as ultimate reductant. The reaction mechanism of class III ribonucleotide reductases requires two cysteines within the active site, Cys-79 and Cys-290 in bacteriophage T4 NrdD numbering. Cys-290 is believed to form a transient thiyl radical that initiates the reaction with substrate and Cys-79 to take part as a transient thiyl radical in later steps of the reductive reaction. The recently solved three-dimensional structure of class III ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) from bacteriophage T4 shows that two highly conserved asparagines, Asn-78 and Asn-311, are positioned close to the essential Cys-79. We have investigated the function of Asn-78 and Asn-311 by site-directed mutagenesis and measured enzyme activity and glycyl radical formation in five single (N78(A/C/D) and N311(A/C)) and one double (N78A/N311A) mutant proteins. Our results suggest that both asparagines are important for the catalytic mechanism of class III RNR and that one asparagine can partially compensate for the lack of the other functional group in the single Asn --> Ala mutant proteins. A plausible role for these two asparagines could be in positioning formate in the active site to orient it toward the proposed thiyl radical of Cys-79. This would also control the highly reactive carbon dioxide radical anion form of formate within the active site before it is released as carbon dioxide. A detailed reaction scheme including the function of the two asparagines and two formate molecules is proposed for class III RNRs.     

Ribonucleotide reduction in Pseudomonas species: simultaneous presence of active enzymes from different classes.

Three separate classes of ribonucleotide reductases exist in nature. They differ widely in protein structure. Class I enzymes are found in aerobic bacteria and eukaryotes; class II enzymes are found in aerobic and anaerobic bacteria; class III enzymes are found in strict and facultative anaerobic bacteria. Usually, but not always, one organism contains only one or two (in facultative anaerobes) classes. Surprisingly, the genomic sequence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa contains sequences for each of the three classes. Here, we show by DNA hybridization that other species of Pseudomonas also contain the genes for three classes. Extracts from P. aeruginosa and P. stutzeri grown aerobically or microaerobically contain active class I and II enzymes, whereas we could not demonstrate class III activity. Unexpectedly, class I activity increased greatly during microaerobic conditions. The enzymes were separated, and the large proteins of the class I enzymes were obtained in close to homogeneous form. The catalytic properties of all enzymes are similar to those of other bacterial reductases. However, the Pseudomonas class I reductases required the continuous presence of oxygen during catalysis, unlike the corresponding Escherichia coli enzyme but similar to the mouse enzyme. In similarity searches, the amino acid sequence of the class I enzyme of P. aeruginosa was more related to that of eukaryotes than to that of E. coli or other proteobacteria, with the large protein showing 42% identity to that of the mouse, suggesting the possibility of a horizontal transfer of the gene. The results raise many questions concerning the physiological function and evolution of the three classes in Pseudomonas species.     

Structure of the high-valent FeIIIFeIV state in ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) of Chlamydia trachomatis--combined EPR, 57Fe-, 1H-ENDOR and X-ray studies

A recently discovered subgroup of class I ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) found in the infectious bacterium Chlamydia trachomatis (C. trachomatis) was shown to exhibit a high-valent Fe(III)Fe(IV) center instead of the tyrosyl radical observed normally in all class I RNRs. The X-ray structure showed that C. trachomatis WT RNR has a phenylalanine at the position of the active tyrosine in Escherichia coli RNR. In this paper the X-ray structure of variant F127Y is presented, where the tyrosine is restored. Using (1)H- and (57)Fe-ENDOR spectroscopy it is shown, that in WT and variants F127Y and Y129F of C. trachomatis RNR, the Fe(III)Fe(IV) center is virtually identical with the short-lived intermediate X observed during the iron oxygen reconstitution reaction in class I RNR from E. coli. The experimental data are consistent with a recent theoretical model for X, proposing two bridging oxo ligands and one terminal water ligand. A surprising extension of the lifetime of the Fe(III)Fe(IV) state in C. trachomatis from a few seconds to several hours at room temperature was observed under catalytic conditions in the presence of substrate. These findings suggest a possible new role for the Fe(III)Fe(IV) state also in other class I RNR, during the catalytic radical transfer reaction, by which the substrate turnover is started.     

Structural determinants and distribution of phosphate specificity in ribonucleotide reductases

Ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs) catalyze the reduction of ribonucleotides to the corresponding deoxyribonucleotides, the building blocks of DNA. RNRs are specific for either ribonucleoside diphosphates or triphosphates as substrates. As far as is known, oxygen-dependent class I RNRs (NrdAB) all reduce ribonucleoside diphosphates, and oxygen-sensitive class III RNRs (NrdD) are all ribonucleoside triphosphate reducers, whereas the adenosylcobalamin-dependent class II (NrdJ) contains both ribonucleoside diphosphate and triphosphate reducers. However, it is unknown how this specificity is conveyed by the active site of the enzymes and how this feature developed in RNR evolution. By structural comparison of the active sites in different RNRs, we identified the apical loop of the phosphate-binding site as a potential structural determinant of substrate specificity. Grafting two residues from this loop from a diphosphate- to a triphosphate-specific RNR caused a change in preference from ribonucleoside triphosphate to diphosphate substrates in a class II model enzyme, confirming them as the structural determinants of phosphate specificity. The investigation of the phylogenetic distribution of this motif in class II RNRs yielded a likely monophyletic clade with the diphosphate-defining motif. This indicates a single evolutionary-split event early in NrdJ evolution in which diphosphate specificity developed from the earlier triphosphate specificity. For those interesting cases where organisms contain more than one nrdJ gene, we observed a preference for encoding enzymes with diverse phosphate specificities, suggesting that this varying phosphate specificity confers a selective advantage.     

Rabbit liver alcohol dehydrogenase: isolation and characterization of class I isozymes

Livers of rabbits contain three classes of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) isozymes which are highly analogous to the human classes. Class I ADHs migrate toward cathode on starch gel and are very sensitive to 4-methylpyrazole (4-MePz) inhibition. Class II ADH migrates slowly toward anode and is less sensitive to 4-MePz. Class III ADH migrates rapidly toward anode and is insensitive to 4-MePz. There are one class II, one class III and at least three class I ADH isozymes present in the rabbit liver. The three class I isozymes purified to homogeneity are all dimers with subunit molecular weight of 41700. Two are heterodimers composed of A-, C-chains and B-, C-chains, respectively. The third one is a homodimer, contains only the C-chain. These results indicate that among all the mammals examined, rabbit ADH bears the greatest resemblance to the human enzyme.     

Allosteric control of three B12-dependent (class II) ribonucleotide reductases. Implications for the evolution of ribonucleotide reduction

Three separate classes of ribonucleotide reductases are known, each with a distinct protein structure. One common feature of all enzymes is that a single protein generates each of the four deoxyribonucleotides. Class I and III enzymes contain an allosteric substrate specificity site capable of binding effectors (ATP or various deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates) that direct enzyme specificity. Some (but not all) enzymes contain a second allosteric site that binds only ATP or dATP. Binding of dATP to this site inhibits the activity of these enzymes. X-ray crystallography has localized the two sites within the structure of the Escherichia coli class I enzyme and identified effector-binding amino acids. Here, we have studied the regulation of three class II enzymes, one from the archaebacterium Thermoplasma acidophilum and two from eubacteria (Lactobacillus leichmannii and Thermotoga maritima). Each enzyme has an allosteric site that binds ATP or various deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates and that regulates its substrate specificity according to the same rules as for class I and III enzymes. dATP does not inhibit enzyme activity, suggesting the absence of a second active allosteric site. For the L. leichmannii and T. maritima enzymes, binding experiments also indicate the presence of only one allosteric site. Their primary sequences suggest that these enzymes lack the structural requirements for a second site. In contrast, the T. acidophilum enzyme binds dATP at two separate sites, and its sequence contains putative effector-binding amino acids for a second site. The presence of a second site without apparent physiological function leads to the hypothesis that a functional site was present early during the evolution of ribonucleotide reductases, but that its function was lost from the T. acidophilum enzyme. The other two B12 enzymes lost not only the function, but also the structural basis for the site. Also a large subgroup (Ib) of class I enzymes, but none of the investigated class III enzymes, has lost this site. This is further indirect evidence that class II and I enzymes may have arisen by divergent evolution from class III enzymes.     

Class III human liver alcohol dehydrogenase: a novel structural type equidistantly related to the class I and class II enzymes

The primary structure of class III alcohol dehydrogenase (dimeric with chi subunits) from human liver has been determined by peptide analyses. The protein chain is a clearly distinct type of subunit distantly related to those of both human class I and class II alcohol dehydrogenases (with alpha, beta, gamma, and pi subunits, respectively). Disregarding a few gaps, residue differences in the chi protein chain with respect to beta 1 and pi occur at 139 and 140 positions, respectively. Compared to class I, the 373-residue chi structure has an extra residue, Cys after position 60, and two missing ones, the first two residues relative to class I, although the N-terminus is acetylated like that for those enzymes. The chi subunit contains two more tryptophan residues than the class I subunits, accounting for the increased absorbance at 280 nm. There are also four additional acidic and two fewer basic side chains than in the class I beta structure, compatible with the markedly different electrophoretic mobility of the class III enzyme. Residue differences between class III and the other classes occur with nearly equal frequency in the coenzyme-binding and catalytic domains. The similarity in the number of exchanges relative to that of the enzymes of the other two classes supports conclusions that the three classes of alcohol dehydrogenase reflect stages in the development of separate enzymes with distinct functional roles. In spite of the many exchanges, the residues critical to basic functional properties are either completely unchanged--all zinc ligands and space-restricted Gly residues--or partly unchanged--residues at the coenzyme-binding pocket.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)