Binding of triple helix forming oligonucleotides to sites in gene promoters

A class of triplex-forming oligodeoxyribonucleotides (TFOs) is described that can bind to naturally occurring sites in duplex DNA at physiological pH in the presence of magnesium. The data are consistent with a structure in which the TFO binds in the major groove of double-stranded DNA to form a three-stranded complex that is superficially similar to previously described triplexes. The distinguishing features of this class of triplex are that TFO binding apparently involves the formation of hydrogen-bonded G.GC and T.AT triplets and the TFO is bound antiparallel with respect to the more purine-rich strand of the underlying duplex. Triplex formation is described for targets in the promoter regions of three different genes: the human c-myc and epidermal growth factor receptor genes and the mouse insulin receptor gene. All three sites are relatively GC rich and have a high percentage of purine residues on one strand. DNase I footprinting shows that individual TFOs bind selectively to their target sites at pH 7.4-7.8 in the presence of millimolar concentrations of magnesium. Electrophoretic analysis of triplex formation indicates that specific TFOs bind to their target sites with apparent dissociation constants in the 10(-7)-10(-9) M range. Strand orientation of the bound TFOs was confirmed by attaching eosin or an iron-chelating group to one end of the TFO and monitoring the pattern of damage to the bound duplex DNA. Possible hydrogen-bonding patterns and triplex structures are discussed.     

Triplex-induced recombination and repair in the pyrimidine motif

Triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) bind DNA in a sequence-specific manner at polypurine/polypyrimidine sites and mediate targeted genome modification. Triplexes are formed by either pyrimidine TFOs, which bind parallel to the purine strand of the duplex (pyrimidine, parallel motif), or purine TFOs, which bind in an anti-parallel orientation (purine, anti-parallel motif). Both purine and pyrimidine TFOs, when linked to psoralen, have been shown to direct psoralen adduct formation in cells, leading to mutagenesis or recombination. However, only purine TFOs have been shown to mediate genome modification without the need for a targeted DNA-adduct. In this work, we report the ability of a series of pyrimidine TFOs, with selected chemical modifications, to induce repair and recombination in two distinct episomal targets in mammalian cells in the absence of any DNA-reactive conjugate. We find that TFOs containing N3′→P5′ phosphoramidate (amidate), 5-(1-propynyl)-2′-deoxyuridine (pdU), 2′-O-methyl-ribose (2′-O-Me), 2′-O-(2-aminoethyl)-ribose, or 2′-O, 4′-C-methylene bridged or locked nucleic acid (LNA)-modified nucleotides show substantially increased formation of non-covalent triplexes under physiological conditions compared with unmodified DNA TFOs. However, of these modified TFOs, only the amidate and pdU-modified TFOs mediate induced recombination in cells and stimulate repair in cell extracts, at levels comparable to those seen with purine TFOs in similar assays. These results show that amidate and pdU-modified TFOs can be used as reagents to stimulate site-specific gene targeting without the need for conjugation to DNA-reactive molecules. By demonstrating the potential for induced repair and recombination with appropriately modified pyrimidine TFOs, this work expands the options available for triplex-mediated gene targeting.     

Chromosome targeting at short polypurine sites by cationic triplex-forming oligonucleotides

Triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) bind specifically to duplex DNA and provide a strategy for site-directed modification of genomic DNA. Recently we demonstrated TFO-mediated targeted gene knockout following systemic administration in animals. However, a limitation to this approach is the requirement for a polypurine tract (typically 15-30 base pairs (bp)) in the target DNA to afford high affinity third strand binding, thus restricting the number of sites available for effective targeting. To overcome this limitation, we have investigated the ability of chemically modified TFOs to target a short (10 bp) site in a chromosomal locus in mouse cells and induce site-specific mutations. We report that replacement of the phosphodiester backbone with cationic phosphoramidate linkages, either N,N-diethylethylenediamine or N,N-dimethylaminopropylamine, in a 10-nucleotide, psoralen-conjugated TFO confers substantial increases in binding affinity in vitro and is required to achieve targeted modification of a chromosomal reporter gene in mammalian cells. The triplex-directed, site-specific induction of mutagenesis in the chromosomal target was charge- and modification-dependent, with the activity of N,N-diethylethylenediamine > N,N-dimethylaminopropylamine phosphodiester, resulting in 10-, 6-, and <2-fold induction of target gene mutagenesis, respectively. Similarly, N,N-diethylethylenediamine and N,N-dimethylaminopropylamine TFOs were found to enhance targeting at a 16-bp G:C bp-rich target site in a chromatinized episomal target in monkey COS cells, although this longer site was also targetable by a phosphodiester TFO. These results indicate that replacement of phosphodiester bonds with positively charged N,N-diethylethylenediamine linkages enhances intracellular activity and allows targeting of relatively short polypurine sites, thereby substantially expanding the number of potential triplex target sites in the genome.     

Distance and affinity dependence of triplex-induced recombination

Triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) have the potential to serve as gene therapeutic agents on the basis of their ability to mediate site-specific genome modification via induced recombination. However, high-affinity triplex formation is limited to polypurine/polypyrimidine sites in duplex DNA. Because of this sequence restriction, careful analysis is needed to identify suitable TFO target sites within or near genes of interest. We report here an examination of two key parameters which influence the efficiency of TFO-induced recombination: (1) binding affinity of the TFO for the target site and (2) the distance between the target site and the mutation to be corrected. To test the influence of binding affinity, we compared induced recombination in human cell-free extracts by a series of G-rich oligonucleotides with an identical base composition and an increasing number of mismatches in the third strand binding code. As the number of mismatches increased and, therefore, binding affinity decreased, induced recombination frequency also dropped. There was an apparent threshold at an equilibrium dissociation constant (K(d)) of 1 x 10(-)(7) M. In addition, TFO chemical modification with N,N-diethylethylenediamine (DEED) internucleoside linkages to confer improved binding was found to yield increased levels of induced recombination. To test the ability of triplex formation to induce recombination at a distance, episomal targets with informative reporter genes were constructed to contain polypurine TFO target sites at varying distances from the mutations to be corrected. TFO-induced recombination in mammalian cells between a plasmid vector and a donor oligonucleotide was detected at distances ranging from 24 to 750 bp. Together, these results indicate that TFO-induced recombination requires high-affinity binding but can affect sites hundreds of base pairs away from the position of triplex formation.     

Triple helix formation: binding avidity of acridine-conjugated AG motif third strands containing natural, modified and surrogate bases opposed to pyrimidine interruptions in a polypurine target.

A critical issue for the general application of triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) as modulators of gene expression is the dramatically reduced binding of short TFOs to targets that contain one or two pyrimidines within an otherwise homopurine sequence. Such targets are often found in gene regulatory regions, which represent desirable sites for triple helix formation. Using intercalator-conjugated AG motif TFOs, we compared the efficacy and base selectivity of 13 different bases or base surrogates in opposition to pyrimidines and purines substituted into selected positions within a paradigm 15-base polypurine target sequence. We found that substitutions closer to the intercalator end of the TFO (positions 4-6) had a more deleterious effect on the dissociation constant (K d) than those farther away (position 11). Opposite T residues at position 11, 3-nitropyrrole or cytosine in the TFO provided adequate binding avidity for useful triplex formation (K ds of 55 and 110 nM, respectively). However, 3-nitropyrrole was more base selective than cytosine, binding to T >/=4 times better than to A, G or C. None of the TFOs tested showed avid binding when C residues were in position 11, although the 3-nitropyrrole-containing TFO bound with a K d of 200 nM, significantly better than the other designs. Molecular modeling showed that the 3-nitropyrrole.T:A triad is isomorphous with the A.A:T triad, and suggests novel parameters for evaluating new base triad designs.     

Improved synthesis of daunomycin conjugates with triplex-forming oligonucleotides. The polypurine tract of HIV-1 as a target

Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) are promising agents for the control of gene expression, as they can selectively bind to a chosen oligopyrimidine.oligopurine region of a gene of interest thus interfering with its expression. The stability of the triplex formed by the TFO and the duplex is often too poor for successful applications of TFOs in vivo and the conjugation of a DNA intercalating moiety to the TFO is a common way to enhance the TFO affinity for its target. In a previous work, we investigated the properties of daunomycin conjugated TFO (dauno-TFO) and found that this class of compounds showed a higher degree of affinity than native oligonucleotides for an oligopyrimidine.oligopurine duplex target and that the presence of the amino sugar increases such stability. Here, we report a significantly improved synthetic procedure for the preparation of the conjugates, based on the protection of the daunosamine moiety by N-trifluoroacetylation. This protecting group is removed as a final step from the conjugation product by mild basic hydrolysis to give the desired dauno-TFO. Compared to the previous synthetic procedure, the improvement is important. The synthesis is now more reproducible and no side products are formed. Moreover, the thus protected daunomycin derivative is very stable, up to at least one year. Two dauno-TFOs, differing by the length of the oligonucleotide moiety, were prepared to target the polypurine tract (PPT) of HIV-1. Triplex formation by these compounds with model duplexes was studied by UV spectroscopy, thermal gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) and gel electrophoretic mobility shift. The experimental results demonstrate that dauno-TFOs bind to the PPT of HIV-1 more strongly than the unconjugated TFOs.     

Targeted gene knockout by 2'-O-aminoethyl modified triplex forming oligonucleotides

Triplex forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) are of interest because of their potential for facile gene targeting. However, the failure of TFOs to bind target sequences at physiological pH and Mg(2+) concentration has limited their biological applications. Recently, pyrimidine TFOs with 2'-O-aminoethyl (AE) substitutions were shown to have enhanced kinetics and stability of triplex formation (Cuenoud, B., Casset, F., Husken, D., Natt, F., Wolf, R. M., Altmann, K. H., Martin, P., and Moser H. E. (1998) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 37, 1288--1291). We have prepared psoralen-linked TFOs with varying amounts of the AE-modified residues, and have characterized them in biochemical assays in vitro, and in stability and HPRT gene knockout assays in vivo. The AE TFOs showed higher affinity for the target in vitro than a TFO with uniform 2'-OMe substitution, with relatively little loss of affinity when the assay was performed in reduced Mg(2+). Once formed they were also more stable in "physiological" buffer, with the greatest affinity and stability displayed by the TFO with all but one residue in the AE format. However, TFOs with lesser amounts of the AE modification formed the most stable triplexes in vivo, and showed the highest HPRT gene knockout activity. We conclude that the AE modification can enhance the biological activity of pyrimidine TFOs, but that extensive substitution is deleterious.     

Synthesis and evaluation of a triplex-forming oligonucleotide-pyrrolobenzodiazepine conjugate

In most cases, unmodified oligonucleotides designed as antigene molecules are incapable of binding to DNA with sufficient stability to prevent gene expression. To stabilize binding to a polypurine tract in the HER-2/neu promoter, a triplex forming oligonucleotide (TFO) was conjugated to a pyrrolo[1,4]benzodiazepine (PBD), desmethyltomaymycin, and site-specific DNA binding was evaluated. An activated ester of the PBD moiety was conjugated by an acylation reaction to a free primary amine on a 50-atom aliphatic linker at the 5' end of the TFO. This long aliphatic linker was designed to provide a bridge from the major groove binding site of the TFO to the minor groove binding site of the PBD. Triplex formation by the resulting TFO-PBD conjugate occurred more slowly and with a nearly 30-fold lower affinity compared to an unconjugated TFO. PBD binding to the triplex target was demonstrated by protection from restriction enzyme digestion, and covalent binding to the exocyclic amino group of guanine was inferred by substituting specific guanines with inosines. Although the binding of the TFO was less efficient, this report demonstrates that in principle, TFOs can be used to direct the binding of a PBD to specific location. Further optimization of TFO-PBD conjugate design, likely involving optimization of the linker and perhaps placing a PBD at both ends of the TFO, will be needed to make gene modification robust.     

Extensive sugar modification improves triple helix forming oligonucleotide activity in vitro but reduces activity in vivo

We are developing triple helix forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) for gene targeting. Previously, we synthesized bioactive TFOs containing 2'-O-methylribose (2'-OMe) and 2'-O-aminoethylribose (2'-AE) residues. Active TFOs contained four contiguous 2'-AE residues and formed triplexes with high thermal stability and rapid association kinetics. In an effort to further improve bioactivity, we synthesized three series of TFOs containing the 2'-AE patch and additional ribose modifications distributed throughout the remainder of the oligonucleotide. These were either additional 2'-AE residues, the conformationally locked BNA/LNA ribose with a 2'-O,4'-C-methylene bridge, or the 2'-O,4'-C-ethylene analogue (ENA). The additionally modified TFOs formed triplexes with greater thermal stability than the reference TFO, and some had improved association kinetics. However, the most active TFOs in the biochemical and biophysical assays were the least active in the bioassay. We measured the thermal stability of triplexes formed by the TFOs in each series on duplex targets containing a change in sequence at a single position. The Tm value of the variant sequence triplexes increased as the number of all additional modifications increased. A simple explanation for the failure of the improved TFOs in the bioassay was that the increased affinity for nonspecific targets lowered the effective nuclear concentration. Enhancement of TFO bioactivity will require chemical modifications that improve interaction with the specific targets while retaining selectivity against mismatched sequences.