Serpins Flex Their Muscle: I. PUTTING THE CLAMPS ON PROTEOLYSIS IN DIVERSE BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS*

Serpins compose the largest superfamily of peptidase inhibitors and are well known as regulators of hemostasis and thrombolysis. Studies using model organisms, from plants to vertebrates, now show that serpins and their unique inhibitory mechanism and conformational flexibility are exploited to control proteolysis in molecular pathways associated with cell survival, development, and host defense. In addition, an increasing number of non-inhibitory serpins are emerging as important elements within a diversity of biological systems by serving as chaperones, hormone transporters, or anti-angiogenic factors.     

Understanding the specificity of serpin–protease complexes through interface analysis

Serpins such as antithrombin, heparin cofactor II, plasminogen activator inhibitor, antitrypsin, antichymotrypsin, and neuroserpin are involved in important biological processes by inhibiting specific serine proteases. Initially, the protease recognizes the mobile reactive loop of the serpin eliciting conformational changes, where the cleaved loop together with the protease inserts into β-sheet A, translocating the protease to the opposite side of inhibitor leading to its inactivation. Serpin interaction with proteases is governed mainly by the reactive center loop residues (RCL). However, in some inhibitory serpins, exosite residues apart from RCL have been shown to confer protease specificity. Further, this forms the basis of multi-specificity of some serpins, but the residues and their dimension at interface in serpin-protease complexes remain elusive. Here, we present a comprehensive structural analysis of the serpin-protease interfaces using bio COmplexes COntact MAPS (COCOMAPS), PRotein Interface Conservation and Energetics (PRICE), and ProFace programs. We have carried out interface, burial, and evolutionary analysis of different serpin-protease complexes. Among the studied complexes, non-inhibitory serpins exhibit larger interface region with greater number of residue involvement as compared to the inhibitory serpins. On comparing the multi-specific serpins (antithrombin and antitrypsin), a difference in the interface area and residue number was observed, suggestive of a differential mechanism of action of these serpins in regulating their different target proteases. Further, detailed study of these multi-specific serpins listed few essential residues (common in all the complexes) and certain specificity (unique to each complex) determining residues at their interfaces. Structural mapping of interface residues suggested that individual patches with evolutionary conserved residues in specific serpins determine their specificity towards a particular protease.     

Serpins 2005 - fun between the beta-sheets. Meeting report based upon presentations made at the 4th International Symposium on Serpin Structure, Function and Biology (Cairns, Australia)

Serpins are the largest family of protease inhibitors and are fundamental for the control of proteolysis in multicellular eukaryotes. Most eukaryote serpins inhibit serine or cysteine proteases, however, noninhibitory members have been identified that perform diverse functions in processes such as hormone delivery and tumour metastasis. More recently inhibitory serpins have been identified in prokaryotes and unicellular eukaryotes, nevertheless, the precise molecular targets of these molecules remains to be identified. The serpin mechanism of protease inhibition is unusual and involves a major conformational rearrangement of the molecule concomitant with a distortion of the target protease. As a result of this requirement, serpins are susceptible to mutations that result in polymerization and conformational diseases such as the human serpinopathies. This review reports on recent major discoveries in the serpin field, based upon presentations made at the 4th International Symposium on Serpin Structure, Function and Biology (Cairns, Australia).     

Structure of native protein C inhibitor provides insight into its multiple functions

Protein C inhibitor (PCI) is a multifunctional serpin with wide ranging protease inhibitory functions, unique cofactor binding activities, and potential non-inhibitory functions akin to the hormone-transporting serpins. To gain insight into the molecular mechanisms utilized by PCI we developed a robust expression system in Escherichia coli and solved the crystal structure of PCI in its native state. The five monomers obtained from our two crystal forms provide an NMR-like ensemble revealing regions of inherent flexibility. The reactive center loop (RCL) of PCI is long and highly flexible with no evidence of hinge region incorporation into beta-sheet A, as seen for other heparin-binding serpins. We adapted an extrinsic fluorescence method for determining dissociation constants for heparin and find that the N-terminal tail of PCI and residues adjacent to helix H are not involved in heparin binding. The minimal heparin length capable of tight binding to PCI was determined to be chains of eight monosaccharide units. A large hydrophobic pocket occupied by hydrophobic crystal contacts was found in an analogous position to the hormone-binding site in thyroxine-binding globulin. In conclusion, the data presented here provide important insights into the mechanisms by which PCI exercises its multiple inhibitory and non-inhibitory functions.     

Loop-inserted and thermostabilized structure of P1-P1' cleaved ovalbumin mutant R339T.

Ovalbumin is a member of a superfamily of serine proteinase inhibitors, known as the serpins. It is, however, non-inhibitory towards serine proteinases, and lacks the loop insertion mechanism common to the serpins due to unknown structural factors. Mutant ovalbumin, R339T, in which the P14 hinge residue is replaced, was produced and analyzed for its thermostability and three-dimensional structure. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed that the mutant ovalbumin, but not the wild-type protein, undergoes a marked thermostabilization (DeltaT(m)=15.8 degrees C) following the P1-P1' cleavage. Furthermore, the crystal structure, solved at 2.3 A resolution, clearly proved that the P1-P1' cleaved form assumes the fully loop-inserted conformation as seen in serpin that possess inhibitory activity. We therefore conclude that ovalbumin acquires the structural transition mechanism into the loop-inserted, thermostabilized form by the single hinge mutation. The mutant protein does not, however, possess inhibitory activity. The solved structure displays the occurrence of specific interactions that may prevent the smooth motion, relative to sheet A, of helices E and F and of the loop that follows helix F. These observations provide crucial insights into the question why R339T is still non-inhibitory.     

Novel secretory vesicle serpins,endopin 1 and endopin 2: endogenous protease inhibitors with distinct target protease specificities

Secretory vesicles of neuroendocrine cells possess multiple proteases for proteolytic processing of proteins into biologically active peptide components, such as peptide hormones and neurotransmitters. The importance of proteases within secretory vesicles predicts the presence of endogenous protease inhibitors in this subcellular compartment. Notably, serpins represent a diverse class of endogenous protease inhibitors that possess selective target protease specificities, defined by the reactive site loop domains (RSL). In the search for endogenous serpins in model secretory vesicles of neuroendocrine chromaffin cells, the presence of serpins related to alpha1-antichymotrypsin (ACT) was detected by Western blots with anti-ACT. Molecular cloning revealed the primary structures of two unique serpins, endopin 1 and endopin 2, that possess homology to ACT. Of particular interest was the observation that distinct RSL domains of these new serpins predicted that endopin 1 would inhibit trypsin-like serine proteases cleaving at basic residues, and endopin 2 would inhibit both elastase and papain that represent serine and cysteine proteases, respectively. Endopin 1 showed selective inhibition of trypsin, but did not inhibit chymotrypsin, elastase, or subtilisin. Endopin 2 demonstrated cross-class inhibition of the cysteine protease papain and the serine protease elastase. Endopin 2 did not inhibit chymotrypsin, trypsin, plasmin, thrombin, furin, or cathepsin B. Endopin 1 and endopin 2 each formed SDS-stable complexes with target proteases, a characteristic property of serpins. In neuroendocrine chromaffin cells from adrenal medulla, endopin 1 and endopin 2 were both localized to secretory vesicles. Moreover, the inhibitory activity of endopin 2 was optimized under reducing conditions, which required reduced Cys-374; this property is consistent with the presence of endogenous reducing agents in secretory vesicles in vivo. These new findings demonstrate the presence of unique secretory vesicle serpins, endopin 1 and endopin 2, which possess distinct target protease selectivities. Endopin 1 inhibits trypsin-like proteases; endopin 2 possesses cross-class inhibition for inhibition of papain-like cysteine proteases and elastase-like serine proteases. It will be of interest in future studies to define the endogenous protease targets of these two novel secretory vesicle serpins.     

Correlation of serpin-protease expression by comparative analysis of real-time PCR profiling data

Imbalanced protease activity has long been recognized in the progression of disease states such as cancer and inflammation. Serpins, the largest family of endogenous protease inhibitors, target a wide variety of serine and cysteine proteases and play a role in a number of physiological and pathological states. The expression profiles of 20 serpins and 105 serine and cysteine proteases were determined across a panel of normal and diseased human tissues. In general, expression of serpins was highly restricted in both normal and diseased tissues, suggesting defined physiological roles for these protease inhibitors. A high correlation in expression for a particular serpin-protease pair in healthy tissues was often predictive of a biological interaction. The most striking finding was the dramatic change observed in the regulation of expression between proteases and their cognate inhibitors in diseased tissues. The loss of regulated serpin-protease matched expression may underlie the imbalanced protease activity observed in pathological states.     

Tip of another iceberg: Drosophila serpins

Serpins are serine protease inhibitors with a conserved structure that have been identified in nearly all species and act as suicide substrates by binding covalently to their target proteases. Serpins regulate various physiological processes and defence mechanisms. In humans, several serpin mutations are linked to diseases. The genome of Drosophila melanogaster encodes 29 serpins and even more serine proteases. To date, three serpins have been investigated in detail. Spn27A controls the Toll pathway during early development and is involved in defence reactions in adult flies. SPN42DaA is an inhibitor of furin, a subtilisin-like convertase that is required for pro-protein maturation. Spn43Ac controls the Toll pathway during the immune response. In each case, Drosophila genetics has shed new light on the function of these serine protease inhibitors.     

Analysis of the plasma elimination kinetics and conformational stabilities of native, proteinase-complexed, and reactive site cleaved serpins: comparison of alpha 1-proteinase inhibitor, alpha 1-antichymotrypsin, antithrombin III, alpha 2-antiplasmin, angiotensinogen, and ovalbumin.

Proteinase inhibitors of the serpin superfamily may exist in one of three distinct conformations: the native form, a fully active protein with the reactive site loop intact; the proteolytically modified form in which inhibitory capacity is abolished; and the proteinase-complexed form, a stable equimolar complex between the inhibitor and a target proteinase. Here, the specificity and kinetics of the plasma elimination of different serpin conformations are compared. Proteinase-complexed serpins were rapidly cleared from the circulation. However, the native and modified forms were not cleared rapidly, indicating that the receptor-mediated pathways which recognize the complexes fail to recognize the native and modified forms. This result suggests that significant structural differences exist between modified and proteinase-complexed serpins. The structural differences were probed by using transverse urea gradient gel electrophoresis, a technique that allows comparisons of the conformational stabilities of proteins. With the exception of the noninhibitory serpins ovalbumin and angiotensinogen, the modified and proteinase-complexed serpins were both stabilized thermodynamically compared to the native forms. In addition, the proteinase component of the serpin-proteinase complex was usually thermodynamically stabilized. These data are used to compare the conformations of serpin-proteinase complexes with those of native and modified serpins; they are discussed in terms of a model whereby serpins inhibit proteinases in a manner similar to that described for other types of protein inhibitors of serine proteinases.     

The role of conformational change in serpin structure and function

Serpins are members of a family of structurally related protein inhibitors of serine proteinases, with molecular masses between 40 and 100kDa. In contrast to other, simpler, proteinase inhibitors, they may interact with proteinases as inhibitors, as substrates, or as both. They undergo conformational interconversions upon complex formation with proteinase, upon binding of some members to heparin, upon proteolytic cleavage at the reactive center, and under mild denaturing conditions. These conformational changes appear to be critical in determining the properties of the serpin. The structures and stabilities of these various forms may differ significantly. Although the detailed structural changes required for inhibition of proteinase have yet to be worked out, it is clear that the serpin does undergo a major conformational change. This is in contrast to other, simpler, families of protein inhibitors of serine proteinases, which bind in a substrate-like or product-like manner. Proteolytic cleavage of the serpin can result in a much more stable protein with new biological properties such as chemo-attractant behaviour. These structural transformations in serpins provide opportunities for regulation of the activity and properties of the inhibitor and are likely be important in vivo, where serpins are involved in blood coagulation, fibrinolysis, complement activation and inflammation.     

Natural and synthetic inhibitors of kallikrein-related peptidases (KLKs)

Including the true tissue kallikrein KLK1, kallikrein-related peptidases (KLKs) represent a family of fifteen mammalian serine proteases. While the physiological roles of several KLKs have been at least partially elucidated, their activation and regulation remain largely unclear. This obscurity may be related to the fact that a given KLK fulfills many different tasks in diverse fetal and adult tissues, and consequently, the timescale of some of their physiological actions varies significantly. To date, a variety of endogenous inhibitors that target distinct KLKs have been identified. Among them are the attenuating Zn²⁺ ions, active site-directed proteinaceous inhibitors, such as serpins and the Kazal-type inhibitors, or the huge, unspecific compartment forming α₂-macroglobulin. Failure of these inhibitory systems can lead to certain pathophysiological conditions. One of the most prominent examples is the Netherton syndrome, which is caused by dysfunctional domains of the Kazal-type inhibitor LEKTI-1 which fail to appropriately regulate KLKs in the skin. Small synthetic inhibitory compounds and natural polypeptidic exogenous inhibitors have been widely employed to characterize the activity and substrate specificity of KLKs and to further investigate their structures and biophysical properties. Overall, this knowledge leads not only to a better understanding of the physiological tasks of KLKs, but is also a strong fundament for the synthesis of small compound drugs and engineered biomolecules for pharmaceutical approaches. In several types of cancer, KLKs have been found to be overexpressed, which makes them clinically relevant biomarkers for prognosis and monitoring. Thus, down regulation of excessive KLK activity in cancer and in skin diseases by small inhibitor compounds may represent attractive therapeutical approaches.     

Serpins: finely balanced conformational traps

Serine protease inhibitors (serpins) play very important roles in the maintenance of various physiologically important systems. As knowledge of the workings of proteins of this family grows, new understanding is gained of the mechanisms by which they inhibit target proteases, using conformational changes for which the structure of serpins is uniquely adapted. This finely balanced system is utilized to healthy benefit in the control of serpin function by modulators, arguably the most striking examples of which occur in the control of proteolytic cascades, such as the coagulation system. Serpins also play very important intracellular roles: one example is the protection of immune cells from their own cytotoxic proteases. The finely balanced serpin mechanism also means that it is prone to disastrous consequences if mutations should occur in vital positions in the serpin structure. Many examples of disease-associated mutations have been shown, which has the dual effect of highlighting how important these molecules are in the maintenance of health and the fine balance that must be maintained in order to preserve their active, inhibitory conformation.     

Maspin inhibits cell migration in the absence of protease inhibitory activity

Maspin is a member of the serpin family of protease inhibitors and is a tumor suppressor gene acting at the level of tumor invasion and metastasis. This in vivo activity correlates with the ability of maspin to inhibit cell migration in vitro. This behavior suggests that maspin inhibits matrix-degrading proteases, such as those of the plasminogen activation system, in a similar manner to the serpin PAI-1. However, there is controversy concerning the protease inhibitory activity of maspin. It is devoid of activity against a wide range of proteases, in common with other non-inhibitory serpins, but has recently been reported to inhibit plasminogen activators associated with cells and other biological surfaces (Sheng, S. J., Truong, B., Fredrickson, D., Wu, R. L., Pardee, A. B., and Sager, R. (1998) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 95, 499-504; McGowen, R., Biliran, H., Jr., Sager, R., and Sheng, S. (2000) Cancer Res. 60, 4771-4778). We have compared the effects of maspin with those of PAI-1 in a range of situations in which plasminogen activation is potentiated, reflecting the biological context of this proteolytic system: urokinase-type plasminogen activator bound to its receptor on the surface of tumor cells, tissue-type plasminogen activator specifically bound to vascular smooth muscle cells, fibrin, and the prion protein. Maspin was found to have no inhibitory effect in any of these situations, in contrast to the efficient inhibition observed with PAI-1, but nevertheless maspin inhibited the migration of both tumor and vascular smooth muscle cells. We conclude that maspin is a non-inhibitory serpin and that protease inhibition does not account for its activity as a tumor suppressor.     

The crystal structure of plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 at 2.0 A resolution: implications for serpin function.

BACKGROUND: Plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 (PAI-2) is a member of the serpin family of protease inhibitors that function via a dramatic structural change from a native, stressed state to a relaxed form. This transition is mediated by a segment of the serpin termed the reactive centre loop (RCL); the RCL is cleaved on interaction with the protease and becomes inserted into betasheet A of the serpin. Major questions remain as to what factors facilitate this transition and how they relate to protease inhibition. RESULTS: The crystal structure of a mutant form of human PAI-2 in the stressed state has been determined at 2.0 A resolution. The RCL is completely disordered in the structure. An examination of polar residues that are highly conserved across all serpins identifies functionally important regions. A buried polar cluster beneath betasheet A (the so-called 'shutter' region) is found to stabilise both the stressed and relaxed forms via a rearrangement of hydrogen bonds. CONCLUSIONS: A statistical analysis of interstrand interactions indicated that the shutter region can be used to discriminate between inhibitory and non-inhibitory serpins. This analysis implied that insertion of the RCL into betasheet A up to residue P8 is important for protease inhibition and hence the structure of the complex formed between the serpin and the target protease.     

Distribution of the native strain in human alpha 1-antitrypsin and its association with protease inhibitor function

Serine protease inhibitors (serpins) are metastable in their native state. This strain, which is released upon binding to target proteases, is essential for the inhibitory activity of serpins. To understand the structural basis of the native strain, we previously characterized stabilizing mutations of alpha(1)-antitrypsin, a prototypical inhibitory serpin, in regions such as the hydrophobic core. The present study evaluates the effects of single point mutations throughout the molecule on stability and protease inhibitory activity. We identified stabilizing mutations in most secondary structures, suggesting that the native strain is distributed throughout the molecule. Examination of the substitution patterns and the structures of the mutation sites revealed surface hydrophobic pockets as a component of the native strain in alpha(1)-antitrypsin, in addition to the previously identified unusual interactions such as side chain overpacking and cavities. Interestingly, many of the stabilizing substitutions did not affect the inhibitory activity significantly. Those that affected the activity were confined in the regions that are mobilized during the complex formation with a target enzyme. The results of our study should be useful for designing proteins with strain and for regulating the stability and functions of serpins.     

Serpins in prokaryotes

Members of the serpin (serine proteinase inhibitor) superfamily have been identified in higher multicellular eukaryotes (plants and animals) and viruses but not in bacteria, archaea, or fungi. Thus, the ancestral serpin and the origin of the serpin inhibitory mechanism remain obscure. In this study we characterize 12 serpin-like sequences in the genomes of prokaryotic organisms, extending this protein family to all major branches of life. Notably, these organisms live in dramatically different environments and some are evolutionarily distantly related. A sequence-based analysis suggests that all 12 serpins are inhibitory. Despite considerable sequence divergence between the proteins, in four of the 12 sequences the region of the serpin that determines proteinase specificity is highly conserved, indicating that these inhibitors are likely to share a common target. Inhibitory serpins are typically prone to polymerization upon heating; thus, the existence of serpins in the moderate thermophilic bacterium Thermobifida fusca, the thermophilic bacterium Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis, and the hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrobaculum aerophilum is of particular interest. Using molecular modeling, we predict the means by which heat stability in the latter protein may be achieved without compromising inhibitory activity.     

Serpin protease inhibitors in plant biology

Protease inhibitors of the serpin family are ubiquitous in the plant kingdom but relatively little is known about their biological functions in comparison with their counterparts in animals. X-ray crystal structures have provided crucial insights into animal serpin functions. The recently solved structure of AtSerpin1 from Arabidopsis thaliana, which has the highly conserved reactive center P2-P1' Leu-Arg-Xaa (Xaa = small residue), displays both conserved and plant-specific serpin features. Sequence homology suggests that AtSerpin1 belongs to serpin Clade B, composed of intracellular mammalian serpins, which is consistent with the lack of strong evidence for secretion of serpins from plant cells. The major in vivo target protease for AtSerpin1 is the papain-like cysteine RD21 protease, a match reminiscent of the inhibition of cathepsins K, L and S by the Clade-B mammalian serpin, SCCA-1 (SERPINB3). The function of AtSerpin1 and other serpins that contain P2-P1' Leu-Arg-Xaa (the 'LR' serpins) in plants remains unknown. However, based on its homology and interactive partners, AtSerpin1 and perhaps other serpins are likely to be involved in regulating programmed cell death or associated processes such as senescence. Abundant accumulation of serpins in seeds and their presence in phloem sap suggest additional functions in plant defense by irreversible inhibition of digestive proteases from pests or pathogens. Here we review the most recent findings in plant serpin biology, focusing on advances in describing the structure and inhibitory specificity of the LR serpins.     

A novel Drosophila serpin that inhibits serine proteases

Serpins define a large protein family in which most members function as serine protease inhibitors. Here we report the results of a search for serpins in Drosophila melanogaster that are potentially required for oogenesis or embryogenesis. We cloned and sequenced ovarian cDNAs that encode six distinct proteins having extensive sequence similarity to mammalian serpins, including residues important in the serpin inhibition mechanism. One of these new serpins in recombinant form inactivates, and complexes with, trypsin-like proteases in vitro. To our knowledge, these results represent the first evidence for a serpin in Drosophila that functions as a serine protease inhibitor.     

The putative role of Rhipicephalus microplus salivary serpins in the tick-host relationship

Inflammation and hemostasis are part of the host's first line of defense to tick feeding. These systems are in part serine protease mediated and are tightly controlled by their endogenous inhibitors, in the serpin superfamily (serine protease inhibitors). From this perspective ticks are thought to use serpins to evade host defenses during feeding. The cattle tick Rhipicephalus microplus encodes at least 24 serpins, of which RmS-3, RmS-6, and RmS-17 were previously identified in saliva of this tick. In this study, we screened inhibitor functions of these three saliva serpins against a panel of 16 proteases across the mammalian defense pathway. Our data confirm that Pichia pastoris-expressed rRmS-3, rRmS-6, and rRmS-17 are likely inhibitors of pro-inflammatory and pro-coagulant proteases. We show that rRmS-3 inhibited chymotrypsin and cathepsin G with stoichiometry of inhibition (SI) indices of 1.8 and 2.0, and pancreatic elastase with SI higher than 10. Likewise, rRmS-6 inhibited trypsin with SI of 2.6, chymotrypsin, factor Xa, factor XIa, and plasmin with SI higher than 10, while rRmS-17 inhibited trypsin, cathepsin G, chymotrypsin, plasmin, and factor XIa with SI of 1.6, 2.6, 2.7, 3.4, and 9.0, respectively. Additionally, we observed the formation of irreversible complexes between rRmS-3 and chymotrypsin, rRmS-6/rRmS-17 and trypsin, and rRmS-3/rRmS-17 and cathepsin G, which is consistent with typical mechanism of inhibitory serpins. In blood clotting assays, rRmS-17 delayed plasma clotting by 60 s in recalcification time assay, while rRmS-3 and rRmS-6 did not have any effect. Consistent with inhibitor function profiling data, 2.0 μM rRmS-3 and rRmS-17 inhibited cathepsin G-activated platelet aggregation in a dose-responsive manner by up to 96% and 95% respectively. Of significant interest, polyclonal antibodies blocked inhibitory functions of the three serpins. Also notable, antibodies to Amblyomma americanum, Ixodes scapularis, and Rhipicephalus sanguineus tick saliva proteins cross-reacted with the three R. microplus saliva serpins, suggesting the potential of these proteins as candidates for universal anti-tick vaccines.