Latex bread technique for detection of the plaque-forming cell response to teratocarcinoma tumor antigens

Summary A latex bead technique modified for measuring the plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to teratocarcinoma tumor antigens in syngeneic animals is described.With this method one can detect both the primary (IgM) and the secondary (IgG) immune response to tumor antigens. Optimal detection of the PFC response depends on the proper ratio of sheep red blood cells to latex beads and the dose of tumor cell antigen used for immunization. The presence of fetal calf serum interfered with immunization of animals and the coating of the latex beads with the tumor cell antigens. The plaques obtained in response to immunization with teratocarcinoma cell antigens varied in size, probably reflecting the complex immune response to more than one class of antigens on tumor cells.     

Computational modeling of the immune response to tumor antigens

Vaccination protocols designed to elicit anti-cancer immune responses have, many times, failed in producing tumor eradication and in prolonging patient survival. Usually in cancer vaccination, epitopes from one organism are included in the genome or linked with some protein of another in the hope that the immunogenic properties of the latter will boost an immune response to the former. However, recent results have demonstrated that injections of two different vectors encoding the same recombinant antigen generate high levels of specific immunity. Systematic comparison of the efficacy of different vaccination protocols has been hampered by technical limitations, and clear evidence that the use of multiple vectors has advantages over single carrier injections is lacking. We used a computational model to investigate the dynamics of the immune response to different anti-cancer vaccines based on randomly generated antigen/carrier compounds. The computer model was adapted for simulations to this new area in immunology research and carefully validated to the purpose. As a matter of fact, it reproduces a relevant number of experimental observations. The model shows that when priming and boosting with the same construct, competition rather than cooperation develops amongst T cell clones of different specificities. Moreover, from the simulations, it appears that the sequential use of multiple carriers may generate more robust anti-tumor immune responses and may lead to effective tumor eradication in a higher percentage of cases. Our results provide a rational background for the design of novel strategies for the achievement of immune control of cancer.     

Phenotype and surface antigens of mouse teratocarcinoma x fibroblast cell hybrids

Numerous colonies of hybrids between PCC4-aza 1 teratocarcinoma cells and fibroblasts of the heteroploid Cl.1D cell line were examined. All of the hybrids were fibroblasts showing extinction of the multiple developmental potentialities of the teratocarcinoma cell parent, irrespective of whether the teratocarcinoma parent was diploid or tetraploid. The hybrids did not show loss of any specific chromosome contributed by the PCC4-aza 1 cell parent. In contrast with the PCC4 parental cells which carry F9 antigens and do not express H-2b, the hybrids do not express F9 antigens and carry H-2 alloantigens of both parental specificities. These results suggest that in hybrids whose phenotype is that of the Cl.1D parent, a change may occur in the genetic program of the teratocarcinoma cells.     

Antigen-specific suppression of the plaque-forming cell response induced polyclonally by lipopolysaccharides

Horse erythrocytes (HRBC) were added with LPS in mouse spleen cell cultures, and the effects of HRBC on the LPS-induced polyclonal PFC response were investigated by enumerating total IgM-secreting PFC, anti-HRBC PFC, and PFC against sheep erythrocytes (SRBC). The addition of HRBC influenced the frequencies of anti-HRBC PFC in the total IgM-secreting PFC, but did not influence those of anti-SRBC PFC. The augmentation of the frequencies of anti-HRBC PFC occurred only when an appropriate dose of HRBC was added in the cultures containing T cells. Higher doses of HRBC decreased the frequencies of anti-HRBC PFC whether T cells were present or absent. The degree of reduction of the frequencies of anti-HRBC PFC was dependent on the dose of HRBC, but independent of the dose of LPS. The addition of HRBC at 1 day after LPS stimulation also decreased the frequency of anti-HRBC PFC, though the addition of 2 or 3 days hardly suppressed it. These results suggest that the antigen-specific augmentation occurs via helper T cells, and the suppression is ascribed to the direct action of antigen on the antigen-specific B cells.     

H-2-linked genetic control of the plaque-forming cell response to sheep red blood cells

The role of genes linked to the H-2 locus in effecting an immune response to SRBC was examined using strains of mice which differ in the classes of antibodies produced following multiple injections with SRBC. While H-2-linked gene action appeared to be at the level of regulating the number of plaque-forming cells (PFC) present in the spleens of different strains following two injections with SRBC, non-H-2-linked immune response genes seemed to determine whether an IgM-IgG switch occurred as well as how much of each antibody class was produced by the number of PFC available as a result of H-2-linked gene intervention. Mapping studies showed that the H-2-linked genetic effects were due to either the requirement for two genes or the presence of genes located between I-B and H-2D.     

Subclass restriction of murine antibodies: V. The IgG plaque-forming cell response to thymus-independent and thymus-dependent antigens in athymic and euthymic mice

Antigens differ in their abilities to stimulate antibodies of various isotypes. Many thymus-independent (TI) polysaccharide antigens stimulate largely IgG3 and IgM antibodies while thymus-dependent (TD) protein antigens stimulate predominantly IgG1 and smaller amounts of other isotypes. Here we determine whether thymus dependence or independence is a property of antigens which is expressed equally by all isotypes. To do this nu/+ and nu/nu mice were immunized with several TI and TD antigens and antibody responses of IgM and the four IgG subclasses measured. We found that, within the conditions of these experiments, all IgG isotypes were influenced equally by the presence or absence of T lymphocytes. Second, in agreement with J. L. Press (J. Immunol.126, 1234, 1981), we propose a division of TD antigens into two types based upon the ability to stimulate responses in the CBA/N mouse.     

Coupled gel electrophoresis-agar diffusion method for the detection of tumor antigens

A gel electrophoretic method coupled with agar diffusion has been devised for detecting tumor antigens in human colon tissue. Separation of the antigens is achieved on duplicate electrophoretic gels. One gel is used for the location of the antigens by protein staining and the other gel is used for assaying of the antigenicity by agar diffusion against homologous antiserum. Analysis of perchloric acid extracts of colon tumors by this coupled method revealed the presence of carcinoembryonic antigen and two additional glycoprotein antigens. Analysis of KClHCl tumor extracts revealed two new tumor antigens.     

A replica plating technique for the study of plaque-forming centers

Mouse spleen cells were cultured on Millipore filters supported on the surface of Eagle's agarose medium. The secretory products of individual plaque-forming centers (PFC) revealed after diffusion into the agarose, were studied over an extended period of time by transferring the Millipore filters to fresh agarose surfaces repeatedly in a manner analogous to the replica plating technique employed with bacteria.     

Regulation of the autoimmune plaque-forming cell response to single-strand DNA (sDNA) in vitro.

We have shown that young autoimmune and normal strain mice possess autoantigen-sensitive cells potentially capable of producing anti-sDNA autoantibody in the absence of normal regulatory mechanisms in vitro. In certain strains such as B/W mice, these regulatory mechanisms presumably break down with increasing age, and autoimmunity develops. These regulatory mechanisms might consist of sDNA, T cells, or some combination of these since both of these agents suppressed the anti-sDNA PFC response in vitro. The sDNA may have inhibited PFC development by a receptor blockade mechanism since i) spleen cells pulsed with sDNA for short periods and then washed were suppressed after 5 days of culture; ii) treatment of these blocked cells with trypsin and DNase I restored the anti-sDNA response; iii) the PFC remaining in partially blocked cultures were of lower avidity than PFC in unblocked cultures; and iv) the target of sDNA may be a B cell. Thymocytes and splenic T cells suppressed the anti-sDNA response but not the anti-SRBC response in vitro in a dose-dependent manner. The suppressive capacity of thymus cells did not decline with age in B/W mice. In addition, thymus cells activated by competing foreign antigens could also suppress the anti-sDNA response. The relationship between these modes of regulating autoreactivity remains to be investigated.     

Antibody response to Candida albicans cell wall antigens

The cell wall of Candida albicans is not only the structure where many essential biological functions reside but is also a significant source of candidal antigens. The major cell wall components that elicit a response from the host immune system are proteins and glycoproteins, the latter being predominantly mannoproteins. Both carbohydrate and protein moieties are able to trigger immune responses. Proteins and glycoproteins exposed at the most external layers of the wall structure are involved in several types of interactions of fungal cells with the exocellular environment. Thus, coating of fungal cells with host antibodies has the potential to profoundly influence the host-parasite interaction by affecting antibody-mediated functions such as opsonin-enhanced phagocytosis and blocking the binding activity of fungal adhesins to host ligands. In this review we examine various members of the protein and glycoprotein fraction of the C. albicans cell wall that elicit an antibody response in vivo. Some of the studies demonstrate that certain cell wall antigens and anti-cell wall antibodies may be the basis for developing specific and sensitive serologic tests for the diagnosis of candidiasis, particularly the disseminated form. In addition, recent studies have focused on the potential of antibodies against the cell wall protein determinants in protecting the host against infection. Hence, a better understanding of the humoral response triggered by the cell wall antigens of C. albicans may provide the basis for the development of (i) effective procedures for the serodiagnosis of disseminated candidiasis, and (ii) novel prophylactic (vaccination) and therapeutic strategies to control this type of infections.     

Cell surface antigens of totipotent mouse teratocarcinoma cells grown in vivo: their relation to embryo, adult, and tumor antigens.

Cell surface antigens on mouse embryonal carcinoma (or teratocarcinoma) cells were investigated by means of a syngeneic antiserum prepared against small-size embryoid bodies from the ascites form of the OTT 6050 transplantable teratoma. These embryoid bodies consist of embryonal carcinoma cells which are usually covered by a yolk-sac-like epithelium. The choice of immunogen was based on the previous demonstration [Mintz, B., and Illmensee, K. (1975) Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA72, 3585–3589] that embryonal carcinoma cells from this specific source are euploid, developmentally totipotent, and completely reversible to normalcy. In indirect immunofluorescence tests, anti-embryoid-body serum reacted with both cell types of the immunogen and with two in vitro lines of embryonal carcinoma cells. Absorption of antiserum with a pure yolk sac carcinoma derived from the epithelial component of the embryoid bodies enabled assessment of reactivity with the embryonal carcinoma component of the immunogen: The absorption revealed that some antigens recognized on the embryonal carcinoma cells were shared by the yolk sac epithelial cells but that some antigens were present only on the embryonal carcinoma cells. The antigens were not shared by sperm, which failed to fluoresce with unabsorbed antiserum and were ineffective when tested as absorbents of antiserum reactivity against embryoid body target cells. Unfertilized eggs also failed to fluoresce. Preimplantation embryos gave immunofluorescence evidence of some antigens shared with embryonal carcinoma cells (and some with yolk sac cells) during cleavage, and in the blastocyst on both inner cell mass and trophoblast. Postimplantation embryos were also antigen-positive (at least through Day 6) in immunofluorescence tests on endoderm as well as ectoderm cells. Absorption of the antiserum with various normal adult tissues showed substantial cross-reactivity, especially with ovary and testis. Other tumors were tested, but only hepatoma cells grown in vitro were reactive, thereby indicating lack of any general tumor recognition in the antiserum. The above results with syngeneic immunizations demonstrate that known totipotent teratocarcinoma cells possess surface molecules which, while not universal on normal cells or tumors, are shared with many other tissues, including developmentally plastic cells of early embryos, developmentally restricted cells of later embryos, and various adult tissues. Immunofluorescence tests of cleavage-stage (Day 2) embryos from matings of $\text{+}\text{t}{}^{12}\text{×}\text{+}\text{t}{}^{12}$ heterozygotes, yielding 40% mutant $\text{t}{}^{12}\text{t}{}^{12}$ homozygotes lethal on Day 3, were uniformly positive on all the embryos, including mutants and normals. Therefore, under these conditions, no evidence was adduced to support the hypothesis that surface components required for normal early development might be coded by the wild-type allele of t¹².     

High chemotactic response to platelet-derived growth factor of a teratocarcinoma differentiated mesodermal cell line

Summary Evidence is presented that a differentiated mesodermal line (MES-1) from P19 EC cells express a high chemotactic response to platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) as assayed in a blind-well modified Boyden chamber. Compared to the NIH 3T3 fibroblasts the chemotactic response of MES-1 is increased by 10-fold at 0.3 ng/ml of PDGF, 4-fold at 1.25 ng/ml of PDGF, 2-fold at 2.5 ng/ml of PDGF. In contrast, PDGF induces the same increase in [³H]thymidine incorporation in both cell lines, made quiescent under reduced serum concentration. This high chemotactic response to PDGF seems specific for these mesodermal cells. Among the different teratocarcinoma cells tested, including stem cells (F9, PC 13, PCC4) and endodermal derivatives (PYS, F9 with retinoic acid, PSA 5E), only the visceral endodermlike cells (PSA5E) are slightly attracted by PDGF. This chemotactic response to PDGF is not related to the presence or characteristics of the type B PDGF receptors, which are less numerous in MES-1 cells (10⁵ receptors/cell, KDa 1,2 mM) compared to NIH 3T3 cells (64×10⁴ receptors per cell, KDa 1,8 nM). The MES-1 cell line might be of interest for studying the chemotactic effect of PDGF. These results also suggest a role for this soluble factor in cell migration during early embryogenesis. This investigation was supported by a grant of La Fondation pour la Recherche Médicale.     

Induction of the immune response to cell surface antigens in vitro

Summary Two tissue culture incubation systems are described in which immune responses to cell surface antigens have been demonstrated In the one-way “mixed lymphocyte interaction” system, a specific stimulation of thymidine uptake was induced by a particulate membrane antigen fraction, the microsomal lipoproteins (MLP)when low levels (0.01 to 0.001 μg per ml) were incubated with spleen or lymph node cells from nonsensitized mice. No stimulation was seen when allogeneic MLP was used at high levels, 10 μg per ml, nor at any level with syngeneic MLP. Specific effectors were demonstrated after 72-hr incubation with stimulatory levels of allogeneic MLP in three separate in vitro assays, a plaque-forming cell reduction assay, a tumor target assay, and an antigen-binding cell assay. In the latter assay, [¹²⁵I]MLP was used as the source of antigen. This system has limited potential inasmuch as mouse spleen cells do not survive in it beyond the 4th day of culture. The second tissue culture system, the Marbrook system, has much greater possibilities because at least 25% of the inoculum is recovered 7days later. In this culture system a cell-free sheep erythrocyte membrane preparation can induce, plaque-forming cells in the absence of macrophages. Using a sensitive radioimmunoassay, frees specific antibody was detected in culture supernatant fluids. With the same culture system, allogeneic lymphocytotoxic cells (killer) have been induced with spleen cells from unprimed mice in strains differing at the major histocompatibility locus (H-2). Allogeneic MLP induced very significant “killer” cell activity with spleen cells from primed mice. In a syngeneic tumor systems, significant amounts of killer cell activity were induced with unprimed spleen cell inocula, and much larger amounts induced with spleen cells from immunized mice. Presented in the formal symposium on Carcinogenesis in Vitro, at the 25th Annual Meeting of the Tissue Culture Association, Miami Beach, Florida, June 3–6, 1974. This work was supported by Public Health Service Rescarch grants CA 07973 and CA 10815 from the National Cancer Institute.     

The plaque-forming cell response of human blood lymphocytes. I. PFC response of lymphocytes to formalin-treated staphylocci.

The plaque-forming cell and proliferative responses of human peripheral blood lymphocytes induced by formalin-treated Staphylococcus aureus of the Cowan strain were studied in vitro. Human blood mononuclear cells were incubated for 6 days with staphylococci in culture medium RPMI 1640 supplemented with 10% human AB serum. The number of anti-sheep erythrocyte plaque-forming cells was determined by the Jerne technique. Lymphocyte proliferation was measured by [³H]thymidine incorporation. Individual lymphocyte donors could be classified as high or low responders to staphylococci. Lymphocyte proliferation appeared necessary for the generation of plaque-forming cells. The plaque-forming cell response was greatly influenced by the source of the human AB serum used in the culture medium. The addition of hydrocortisone to the culture medium augmented the plaque-forming cell response. Human B lymphocytes prepared by passage through a column containing Sepharose 4B conjugated to anti-human F(ab)₂ generated plaque-forming cells when incubated with staphylococci. However, the addition of T lymphocytes to these B-lymphocyte preparations augmented the plaque-forming cell response to staphylococci.     

Reversal of murine alveolar macrophage-mediated suppression of plaque-forming cell response by sodium periodate

Murine alveolar macrophages (AM) have been shown to suppress the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of spleen cells previously primed with sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) in a dose-dependent manner. Mild oxidation of cell membranes on viable AM with sodium periodate resulted in total abrogation of AM-mediated suppression of the PFC response, while periodate treatment of spleen cells resulted only in partial reduction of the suppression. Pretreatment of AM with sodium periodate followed by addition of the aldehyde blocking agent, hydroxylamine, resulted in restoration of the PFC-suppressing activity of AM. Periodate treatment of AM also resulted in significantly increased macrophage-T-cell binding and cluster formation. These observations suggest that the generation of aldehyde moieties on AM membrane sialoglycoconjugates promotes positive macrophage-lymphocyte interactions, resulting in abrogation of AM-mediated suppression of the PFC response.