Interpretation of the dose and LET dependence of RBE values for lethal lesions in yeast cells

Survival data on yeast cells proficient or deficient in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) and data on the induction of dsb are used to interpret the dose dependence of the RBE value for lethal lesions after irradiation at high dose rate followed by 72-hr liquid holding providing optimum conditions for repair of potentially lethal lesions (RBEDP, DP = delayed plating). The radiations applied are conventional (150 kV), soft (50 kV), and ultrasoft (4 kV) X rays, 30-MeV electrons (or 60Co gamma rays), and 3.5-MeV alpha particles. Analysis shows that the dose dependence of the RBEDP value can be explained by the combination of two dose-independent RBE values, one for the single-particle traversal effect (RBEspt) and the other for the accumulation of dsb (RBEdsb) due to the traversal of more than one particle through the cell nucleus. Furthermore, it is shown that the LET dependence of RBEspt values describing the linear component of the lethal lesions must be considered separately for "electron" and "particle" radiations.     

Recovery from lethal and mutagenic damage during postirradiation holding and low-dose-rate irradiations of cultured hamster cells

Survival and mutation to thioguanine resistance were measured in V79-4 hamster cells grown to plateau phase without refeeding and irradiated with 60Co gamma rays. The effects of low-dose-rate irradiation and of postirradiation holding on recovery from gamma-ray damage leading to these two responses were also studied. The responses of these plateau (extended G1)-phase cells to acute irradiation were similar to those we previously found for exponentially growing cells, including the linear relationship between induced mutant frequency and (log) surviving fraction. Irradiation at low dose rate (0.34 rad/min) considerably reduced both the lethal and mutagenic effects of given doses of gamma rays, but the linear mutation-survival relationship was approximately the same as for acute irradiation. In contrast, cells given a 5-hr holding period after acute irradiation showed the anticipated recovery from potentially lethal damage but no recovery from damage leading to mutation. These results are discussed in terms of previously proposed cellular repair processes (sublethal damage repair and potentially lethal damage repair) and the possibility that the radiation damage leading to lethality is different from mutagenic damage.     

The relative biological effectiveness of 14.5-MeV neutrons for the induction of gene conversion and mutation in yeast

The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) and oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) were determined in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae for the induction of gene conversion (the product of recombinational repair) and mutation (the product of error prone repair) by 14.5-MeV neutrons in comparison with 60Co gamma rays and 150 KVp X rays. Neutron irradiation in oxic or anoxic conditions induced significantly higher yields of convertants and mutants than sparsely ionizing radiations under the same conditions. RBEs for both gene conversion and mutation under anoxia were significantly higher than under oxic conditions. RBEs for mutant induction under anoxia were lower than the RBEs for gene conversion under the same conditions. The data support the hypothesis that the production of lesions leading to the genetic consequences of gene conversion and mutation differ in their dependence upon LET and the presence of oxygen during irradiation, and therefore the two DNA repair processes which produce these end points recognize, at least in part, different classes of damage.     

Liquid holding recovery in stationary and log phase cultures of diploid yeast exposed to gamma and alpha radiations

Summary The kinetics of liquid-holding recovery (LHR) in diploid yeast after gamma and alpha irradiation is studied. In case of stationary phase culture the rate and extent of LHR is found to be greater for gamma-ray-induced damage than for alpha-ray-induced damage. At 10% survival level, the half-time for recovery is 5.2 h for gamma-ray damage and 12 h for alpha-ray damage. Further, while the recovery factor for alpha damage reaches saturation at 5% survival level, that for gamma damage continues to increase as survival level decreases. Oxygen is required for the recovery process during LH after gamma irradiation. The cells can recover to the same extent from both oxygen-dependent and oxygen-independent components of damage. Log phase cells containing a high per cent of budding cells, however, exhibit negative liquid holding effect after gamma irradiation.     

Radiosensitization in multifraction schedules. I. Evidence for an extremely low oxygen enhancement ratio

Stable monolayers of contact-inhibited C3H 10T1/2 cells were used in multifraction radiation experiments to measure the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) at low doses/fraction under conditions where cell cycle effects (repopulation, redistribution) were minimal. Consistent with there being a dose-dependent reduction in the OER at low doses, an extremely low OER of 1.34 was measured after 20 fractions of 1.7 Gy every 12 h. The sparing effects of fractionating radiation doses were not apparent for cells irradiated under hypoxic conditions (i.e., multifraction survivals were lower than acute single-dose values) until doses exceeding 15 Gy were reached. This result suggested a deficiency in the recovery from sublethal and/or potentially lethal damage might exist after hypoxic irradiations, thereby reducing the OER. The capacity to repair potentially lethal damage was found to be nearly the same after hypoxic as compared to aerobic irradiations. However, there was an apparent absence of sublethal damage repair by 10T1/2 cells between two hypoxic irradiations which could be a major contributing factor to the extremely low OER value measured in this multifraction schedule.     

Effect of hypoxia on recovery from damage induced by heat and radiation in plateau-phase CHO cells

The effect of hypoxia on the induction of and recovery from damage by radiation alone and in combination with heat has been investigated using plateau-phase Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Postirradiation hypoxia reduced the potentially lethal damage recovery (PLDR) in cells irradiated under an euoxic state and completely eliminated PLDR in cells irradiated under hypoxia. Cells which were maintained under hypoxia during both irradiation and a 4-hr recovery period and then incubated for a further period of 4 hr under euoxic conditions showed PLDR, suggesting that the inhibition of PLDR by hypoxia is reversible. Oligomycin, an inhibitor of energy metabolism, completely eliminated PLDR when present at a concentration of 1 microM during the postirradiation period. Pre- or postirradiation heat treatment at 42.5 degrees C for 30 min appreciably sensitized the cells to the induction of lethality. Thermal enhancement ratio (TER) was 1.7 for cells irradiated and heat treated under hypoxic conditions. The same heat treatment reduced the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) associated with gamma radiation from 3.1 to 2.5. Cells subjected to this postirradiation heat treatment showed a small extent of PLDR, whereas the pre-heat-treated cells showed as much recovery as non-heat-treated cells. When hypoxic conditions prevailed during the post-treatment incubation period, PLDR was reduced in preheated cells and completely eliminated in postheated cells. The kinetics of interaction between heat and radiation damage were studied by introducing a time gap of 4 hr between the treatments. Cells maintained under euoxic conditions between the treatments showed an appreciable decrease in interaction, suggesting recovery from damage induced by the first treatment. Hypoxic conditions intervening the two treatments largely inhibited the loss of sensitization. Analysis of the results suggests that cells fail to recover from sublethal heat damage when held for 4 hr under hypoxic conditions. Cells held under hypoxic conditions partly recover from the radiation damage which subsequently interacts with sublethal heat damage, resulting in cell lethality.     

Genetic control of repair of radiation damage produced under euoxic and anoxic conditions in diploid yeastSaccharomyces cerevisiae

Summary Diploid wild type yeast strains 211, X2180 and the radiation sensitive mutantsrad2, 6, 9, 18, 50–55, and57 were exposed to cobalt-60 gamma radiation, in the presence and absence of oxygen, in order to identify the RAD loci involved in the repair of sublethal damage (SLD), recovery from potentially lethal damage (PLD) and oxygen enhancement ratio (OER). Response of wild type and mutants were compared in terms of survival curve parameters D_q, D₁₀, D₁, and D₀. As compared to wild type the mutants showed increased sensitivity to radiation lethality, both under euoxic and hypoxic conditions, as judged by the reduction in D_q and D₀ values. OER was reduced in therad2, 9, 18, 50, 51, and57 mutants indicating that these genes could be associated with the repair of gamma radiation damage produced under hypoxic condition.Shoulder (D_q) a measure of the ability of the cells to repair SLD, was reduced in therad6, 9, 18, 50, 53, and57 strains and was almost absent in therad51, 52, 54, and55 mutants. The ability to recover from PLD was equal to that of wild type strain in therad2, 6, 9, and18 strains, reduced in therad53, 55, and57 strains and was absent in therad50–52 and54 strains. In the mutants with liquid holding recovery ability, the extent of recovery from PLD produced under euoxic and hypoxic conditions was the same. These observations suggest that different groups of loci are involved in the control of different repair processes and that the expression of therad50–57 loci play a very important role in the repair of ionising radiation damage.On the basis of the liquid holding recovery data presented here and the observations made by others it is suggested that the unrepaired DSB constitute the PLD and that the repair of DSB involves recombination between homologous chromosomes.     

On the nature of damage involved in liquid-holding recovery in diploid yeast after gamma- and alpha-irradiation.

Cells surviving after liquid-holding recovery following gamma- and alpha-irradiations are found to be slightly more sensitive to a second series of radiation doses. Further, the shoulder on the gamma survival curve of the pre-irradiated and liquid-held cells disappears. The shoulder and sensitivity are restored only when these cells are grown in broth before the second series of doses. In addition to this, liquid-holding recovery reduces progressively if the cells after irradiation are incubated in broth for different periods of time before holding. These observations suggest that: (1) the so-called potentially lethal damage may consitute that part of the sub-lethal damage which interact with one another to form lethal damage; (2) during liquid-holding, the interaction among sub-lethal damage transforming them to the status of lethal damage is inhibited; (3) the 'recovered' cells are saturated with sub-lethal damage, the repair of which will be completed only when the cells are placed in a nutrient medium. The inhibitory process is not a passive one, but requires energy metabolism.     

Human epithelial teratocarcinoma cells (P3): radiobiological characterization, DNA damage, and comparison with other rodent and human cell lines

Survival parameters and immediate DNA damage induced by 60Co gamma rays, 50-kVp X rays, and Janus fission-spectrum neutrons in human epithelial P3 cells (derived from an embryonic teratocarcinoma) are compared with those for Chinese hamster lung V79 cells. DNA damage caused by X and gamma irradiation, measured by alkaline elution methods, is the same in both cell types, whereas the P3 cells are about two times more sensitive (as measured by Do ratios of the final survival curve slope) to the lethal effects of these radiations than are the V79 cells. Human P3 cells are also more sensitive to the lethal effects of fission-spectrum neutrons than V79 cells. Survival experiments with split radiation doses and hypertonic salt treatment indicate that both P3 cells and V79 cells can recover from radiation-induced damage efficiently.     

Contribution of a photoreactivable component to the oxygen effect observed in certain rad mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae after exposure to high energy electrons

It is shown that a fraction of damage induced by high energy electrons (25 MeV) in certain rad mutants of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae can be photoreactivated. The photoreactivable damage contributes to the lethal effect of this type of irradiation and modifies the oxygen effect. Using photoreactivating light or nigrosin, the amount of photoreactivable damage is reduced and the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) for yeast mutants increases approximately to the OER found in wild-type cells.     

The effect of 238Pu alpha-particles on the mouse fibroblast cell line C3H 10T1/2: characterization of source and RBE for cell survival

Considerable interest has been aroused in recent years by reports that the transforming and carcinogenic effectiveness of low doses of high LET radiations can be increased by reducing the dose rate, especially for transformation of 10T1/2 cells in vitro by fission-spectrum neutrons. We report on conditions which have been established for irradiation of 10T1/2 cells with high LET monoenergetic alpha-particles (energy of 3.2 MeV, LET of 124 keV microns-1) from 238Pu. The alpha-particle irradiator allows convenient irradiation of multiple dishes of cells at selectable high or low dose rates and temperatures. The survival curves of irradiated cells showed that the mean lethal dose of alpha-particles was 0.6 Gy and corresponded to an RBE, at high dose rates, of 7.9 at 80 per cent survival and 4.6 at 5 per cent survival, relative to 60Co gamma-rays. The mean areas of the 10T1/2 nuclei, perpendicular to the incident alpha-particles, was measured as 201 microns2, from which it follows that, on average, only one in six of the alpha-particle traversals through a cell nucleus is lethal. Under the well-characterized conditions of these experiments the event frequency of alpha-particle traversals through cell nuclei is 9.8 Gy-1.     

Mutation induction in Escherichia coli WP2 uvrA by Cerenkov emission associated with 137Cs gamma irradiation

Evidence is presented for the mutation of the tryptophan-requiring bacterial strain Escherichia coli WP2 uvrA from auxotrophy to prototrophy, and from streptomycin sensitivity to resistance, by Cerenkov emission associated with 137Cs gamma irradiation. Furthermore, the data strongly suggest a more than additive interaction between the gamma-induced damage and that induced by Cerenkov emission for both mutations scored. An additional observation is that mutant yields (expressed as mutants/10(7) survivors) show a dependence on the number of viable cells plated for both uv (254 nm) and Cerenkov-induced mutations, but not for those induced by gamma irradiation. This demonstrates another similarity between uv- and Cerenkov-induced damage.     

Reduced repair of potentially lethal radiation damage in glutathione synthetase-deficient human fibroblasts after X-irradiation

Using a human fibroblast strain deficient in glutathione synthetase and a related proficient control strain, the role of glutathione (GSH) in repair of potentially lethal damage (PLD) has been investigated in determining survival by plating cells immediately or 24 h after irradiation. After oxic or hypoxic irradiation, both cell strains repair radiation-induced damage. However, under hypoxic conditions, the proficient cells repair PLD as well as under oxic conditions while the deficient cells repair less PLD after irradiation under hypoxic than under oxic conditions. Therefore, the oxygen enhancement ratio (o.e.r.) for proficient cells is similar whether the cells are plated immediately or 24 h later (2.0 and 2.13, respectively). In contrast, the o.e.r. for deficient cells is lower when the cells are plated 24 h after irradiation than when they are plated immediately thereafter (1.16 as compared to 1.55). The results indicate that GSH is involved in PLD repair and, in particular, in the repair of damage induced by radiation delivered under hypoxic conditions.     

Effect of Oxygen Radicals and Peroxide on Survival After Ultraviolet Irradiation and Liquid Holding Recovery of Bacteroides fragilis

The survival of Bacteroides fragilis cells after far-ultraviolet irradiation under anaerobic and aerobic conditions and the liquid holding recovery under aerobic conditions were not affected by peroxide or quenchers of toxic oxygen derivatives.     

Repair of potentially lethal damage in yeast induced by fast neutrons

Survival curves of 3 diploid (D7) yeast strains: one wild-type, one deficient in excision of pyrimidine dimers (UV-sensitive) and one blocked in DNA double-strand-break repair (X-ray-sensitive), were compared after irradiation with cyclotron-produced fast neutrons. It was observed that both the UV-sensitive (rad3/rad3) and the X-ray-sensitive (rad52/rad52) mutants were more sensitive to neutrons than the wild-type. The role of DNA double-strand-breaks in neutron-induced cell death was further studied by comparing the relative sensitivity of the rad52/rad52 mutant to gamma-rays and fast neutrons. A comparison of the dose modification factors revealed that the deficiency in DNA double-strand-break repair did not make the yeast cells more sensitive to neutrons than to photons, which suggests that lesions of a different type may also be produced by neutrons. Survival curves obtained upon immediate plating and after delayed plating of neutron-irradiated cells showed that all 3 yeast strains were efficient in liquid holding recovery. The role of different repair pathways in cellular recovery from neutron-induced lethal damage is discussed.     

Reparable and irreparable damage in yeast cells induced by sparsely ionizing radiation.

It is shown that in diploid yeast there are significant differences in the extent of irreparable damage after irradiation with X-rays, 60Co-gamma-rays and 30 MeV electrons. At extremely low dose rates, 60Co-gamma-rays were found to produce almost no irreparable damage at least up to 1200 Gy. X-rays, however, at the same low dose rate caused irreparable damage in the same dose range yielding a surviving fraction of 0.25 at 1200 Gy. For irradiations at high dose rate followed by liquid holding recovery the relative biological effectiveness of X-rays amounted to at least 4 for absorbed doses of up to 1000 Gy. With 30 MeV electrons at high dose rates an accumulation of sublethal and potentially lethal damage resulting in irreparable damage occurred above 1000 Gy. It is suggested that irreparable damage in yeast is due to a cooperative effect of neighbouring track ends.     

Radiosensitization in multifraction schedules. II. Greater sensitization by 2-nitroimidazoles than by oxygen

The objective of this study was to characterize the extent of and mechanisms involved in radiosensitization by 2-nitroimidazoles in multifraction schedules using low doses per fraction. For this purpose, contact-inhibited monolayers of C3H 10T1/2 cells were given 1.7 Gy every 12 h and plated 12 h after the last dose received to allow full repair of potentially lethal damage (PLD). Severe hypoxia was obtained by a 1-h gassing procedure at room temperature immediately before each irradiation. No toxicity occurred as a consequence of multiple exposures to 5 mM misonidazole (MISO) or SR 2508 (2508) during the deoxygenation procedure. Experimental conditions during the pregassing and irradiation (presence of drug and gas mixture) were appropriately manipulated to test for the different mechanisms of radiosensitization demonstrated by nitroimidazoles. A very low oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) results under these conditions (1.34). Exposure to 5 mM MISO or 2508 during the deoxygenation and irradiation of hypoxic cells resulted in greater radiosensitization than could be accounted for by oxygen-mimetic sensitization alone (MISO and 2508 enhancement ratios were greater than the OER). Pregassing cells with N2 in the presence of 5 mM drug sensitized cells which were subsequently irradiated under aerobic conditions (drug free), indicating the occurrence of the "preincubation effect" (which does not require hypoxia or the drug's presence during the irradiation). Thus, for the hypoxic irradiations, the preincubation effect could account for the greater sensitization by nitroimidazoles than by oxygen. The presence of 5 mM drug only during the irradiation of aerobic cells produced radiosensitization in both multifraction and single-dose experiments with delayed plating. This sensitization has been previously shown to involve reduced PLD repair. Finally, maximum radiosensitization occurred in the multifraction schedule when a transient period of hypoxia with drug preceded an aerobic irradiation with drug present, thus combining the benefits of both the preincubation effect and PLD repair inhibition. This work demonstrates the possibility that effects other than oxygen-mimetic radiosensitization could be largely responsible for the sensitization seen in multifraction schedules, particularly when the OER is already low and only transient periods of hypoxia occur.     

DNA repair-deficient Chinese hamster ovary cells exhibiting differential sensitivity to gamma rays under aerobic and hypoxic conditions

The survival of the wild-type parent and two mutant lines of Chinese hamster cells, known to be defective in DNA repair, has been determined as a function of exposure to gamma rays under aerobic and hypoxic conditions. When compared to the wild-type line, one of the mutants selected for sensitivity to ethyl methyl sulfonate (EMS), and known to be defective in the repair of DNA strand breaks, exhibits a markedly enhanced sensitivity to aerobic irradiation but a reduced enhancement to hypoxic irradiation and thus an enhanced oxygen enhancement ratio (OER). In contrast, the other line, known to be defective in the incision step of excision repair, exhibits the reverse pattern of sensitivity and hence a reduced OER. The results are compared to findings in bacterial mutants and cells obtained from ataxia telangiectasia (AT) patients and heterozygotes.     

Evidence for differences among the sectors of potentially lethal damage expressed by hypertonic treatment in plateau-phase V79 cells after exposure to neutrons or gamma rays: the importance of distinction between alpha and beta-PLD forms

Expotentially growing and plateau-phase V79 cells were exposed to various doses of neutrons and plated either immediately or after treatment in hypertonic medium (250-500 mM NaCl) to express radiation-induced potentially lethal damage (PLD). Postirradiation treatment of exponentially growing cells in hypertonic medium (500 mM) resulted in a decrease in both Dq and D0, whereas postirradiation treatment of plateau-phase cells in hypertonic medium (in the range between 200 to 1,500 mM) resulted mainly in a reduction of Dq. This difference in response between exponentially growing and plateau-phase cells may reflect differences in the chromatin structure in cells at various stages of the cell cycle, affecting fixation of radiation-induced damage. Exposure of plateau-phase cells to gamma rays, on the other hand, resulted in a treatment time and salt concentration-dependent decrease in Dq along with a decrease in D0. Repair of neutron-induced, hypertonic treatment-sensitive PLD, measured by delaying treatment for various periods after irradiation, was found to proceed with a t1/2 of about 1 h. This is similar to the repair kinetics obtained by delaying treatment of plateau-phase cells with 150 microM beta-D-arabinofuranosyladenine (araA) after exposure to gamma rays or neutrons and contrasts the repair kinetics observed after exposure of cells to gamma rays. In this case, hypertonic treatment was found to affect a form of PLD repaired with a t1/2 of 10-15 min (beta-PLD) and araA, a different form of PLD, repaired with a t1/2 of about 1 h (alpha-PLD). Based on these results it is hypothesized that the sector of lesions affected by hypertonic treatment and araA coincides after exposure to neutrons (effect on alpha-PLD) but only partly overlaps after exposure to gamma rays (due to the effect on beta-PLD of hypertonic treatment). The results presented, together with previously published observations, suggest a differential induction and/or fixation by hypertonic medium of the alpha- and beta-PLD forms as the LET of the radiation increases. Furthermore, they indicate that direct comparison of the effects of a postirradiation treatment, as well as of the repair kinetics obtained by its delayed application after exposure to radiations of various LET, should be made with caution.     

Combined use of Monte Carlo DNA damage simulations and deterministic repair models to examine putative mechanisms of cell killing

A kinetic repair-misrepair-fixation (RMF) model is developed to better link double-strand break (DSB) induction to reproductive cell death. Formulas linking linear-quadratic (LQ) model radiosensitivity parameters to DSB induction and repair explicitly account for the contribution to cell killing of unrejoinable DSBs, misrepaired and fixed DSBs, and exchanges formed through intra- and intertrack DSB interactions. Information from Monte Carlo simulations is used to determine the initial yields and complexity of DSBs formed by low- and high-LET radiations. Our analysis of published survival data for human kidney cells suggests that intratrack DSB interactions are negligible for low-LET radiations but increase rapidly with increasing LET. The analysis suggests that no class of DSB is intrinsically unrejoinable or that DSB reparability is not strictly determined by the number of lesions forming the DSB. For radiations with LET >110 keV/mum, the model predicts that the relative cell killing efficiency, per unit absorbed dose, should continue to increase, whereas data from published experiments indicate a reduced cell killing efficiency. This observation suggests that the Monte Carlo simulation overestimates the DSB yield beyond 110 keV/microm or that other biological phenomena not included in the model, such as proximity effects, are important. For 200-250 kVp X rays ( approximately 1.9 keV/microm), only about 1% of the one-track killing is attributed to intratrack binary misrepair interactions. The analysis indicates that the remaining 99% of the lethal damage is due to other types of one-track damage, including possible unrepairable, misrepaired and fixed damage. Compared to the analysis of the X-ray results, 48% of the one-track lethal damage caused by 5.1 MeV alpha particles (approximately 88 keV/microm) is due to intratrack DSB interactions while the remainder is due to other forms of one-track damage.