Energetics of outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) dimerization

Outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is a widely conserved transmembrane enzyme found in Gram-negative bacteria, and it is implicated in the virulence of a number of pathogenic organisms. The regulation of the protein's phospholipase activity is not well understood despite the existence of a number of high resolution structures. Previous biochemical studies have demonstrated that dimerization of OMPLA is a prerequisite for its phospholipase activity, and it has been shown in vitro that this dimerization is dependent on calcium and substrate binding. Therefore, to fully understand the regulation of OMPLA, it is necessary to understand the stability of the protein dimer and the extent to which it is influenced by its effector molecules. We have used sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation to dissect the energetics of Escherichia coli OMPLA dimerization in detergent micelles. We find that calcium contributes relatively little stability to the dimer, while interactions with the substrate acyl chain are the predominant force in stabilizing the dimeric conformation of the enzyme. The resulting thermodynamic cycle suggests that interactions between effector molecules are additive. These energetic measurements not only provide insight into the activation of OMPLA, but they also represent the first quantitative investigation of the association energetics of a transmembrane beta-barrel. This thermodynamic study allows us to begin to address the differences between protein-protein interfaces in transmembrane proteins with a helical fold to those of a beta-barrel fold and to more fully understand the forces involved in membrane protein interactions.     

Activation of a covalent outer membrane phospholipase A dimer.

The activity of outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is regulated by reversible dimerization. However, native OMPLA reconstituted in phospholipid vesicles was found to be present as a dimer but nevertheless inactive. To investigate the importance of dimerization for control of OMPLA activity, a covalent OMPLA dimer was constructed and its properties were compared to native OMPLA both in a micellar detergent and after reconstitution in a phospholipid bilayer. Unlike native OMPLA, activity of the covalent OMPLA dimer was independent of type and concentration of detergent in micellar systems. In such systems, the covalent OMPLA dimer invariantly displayed high calcium affinity. In contrast, high calcium concentrations were required to activate a covalent OMPLA dimer when present in intact vesicles. Solubilization of the vesicles increased the affinity for calcium, suggesting that in an intact bilayer the dimer interface is not properly formed. This was supported by the observation that OMPLA variants having an impaired dimeric interface also lacked high affinity calcium binding. A covalent linkage was not able to restore high affinity calcium binding in these variants, demonstrating that a proper dimer interface is essential for optimal catalysis.     

Influence of proline residues in transmembrane helix packing

Integral membrane proteins often contain proline residues in their alpha-helical transmembrane (TM) fragments, which may strongly influence their folding and association. Pro-scanning mutagenesis of the helical domain of glycophorin A (GpA) showed that replacement of the residues located at the center abrogates helix packing while substitution of the residues forming the ending helical turns allows dimer formation. Synthetic TM peptides revealed that a point mutation of one of the residues of the dimerization motif (L75P) located at the N-terminal helical turn of the GpA TM fragment, adopts a secondary structure and oligomeric state similar to the wild-type sequence in detergents. In addition, both glycosylation mapping in biological membranes and molecular dynamics showed that the presence of a proline residue at the lipid/water interface has as an effect the extension of the helical end. Thus, helix packing can be an important factor that determines appearance of proline in TM helices. Membrane proteins might accumulate proline residues at the two ends of their TM segments in order to modulate the exposition of key amino acid residues at the interface for molecular recognition events while allowing stable association and native folding.     

The role of a hydrogen bonding network in the transmembrane beta-barrel OMPLA

The hydrogen bonding of polar side-chains has emerged as an important theme for membrane protein interactions. The crystal structure of the dimeric state of the transmembrane beta-barrel protein outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) revealed an intermolecular hydrogen bond mediated by a highly conserved glutamine side-chain (Q94). It has been shown that the introduction of a polar residue can drive the association of model helices, and by extension it was presumed that the glutamine hydrogen bond played a key role in stabilizing the OMPLA dimer. However, a thermodynamic investigation using sedimentation equilibrium ultracentrifugation in detergent micelles reveals that the hydrogen bond plays only a very modest role in stabilizing the dimer. The Q94 side-chain is hydrogen bonded intramolecularly to residues Y92 and S96, but amino acid substitutions at these positions suggest these intramolecular interactions are not responsible for attenuating the strength of the intermolecular Q94 hydrogen bond. Other substitutions suggested that hydration of the local environment around Q94 may be responsible for the modest strength of the hydrogen bond. Heat inactivation experiments with the variants suggest that the Y92-Q94-S96 network may instead be important for thermal stability of the monomer. These results highlight the context dependence and broad range of interactions that can be mediated by polar residues in membrane proteins.     

Lipid solvation effects contribute to the affinity of Gly-xxx-Gly motif-mediated helix-helix interactions

Interactions between transmembrane helices are mediated by the concave Gly-xxx-Gly motif surface. Whether Gly residues per se are sufficient for selection of this motif has not been established. Here, we used the in vivo TOXCAT assay to measure the relative affinities of all 18 combinations of Gly, Ala, and Ser "small-xxx-small" mutations in glycophorin A (GpA) and bacteriophage M13 major coat protein (MCP) homodimers. Affinity values were compared with the accessibility to a methylene-sized probe of the total surface area of each helix monomer as a measure of solvation by membrane components. A strong inverse correlation was found between nonpolar-group lipid accessibility and dimer affinity (R = 0.75 for GpA, p = 0.013, and R = 0.81 for MCP, p = 0.004), suggesting that lipid as a poor membrane protein solvent, conceptually analogous to water in soluble protein folding, can contribute to dimer stability and help to define helix-helix interfaces.     

Detergent organisation in crystals of monomeric outer membrane phospholipase A

The structure of the detergent in crystals of outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) has been determined using neutron diffraction contrast variation. Large crystals were soaked in stabilising solutions, each containing a different H(2)O/D(2)O contrast. From the neutron diffraction at five contrasts, the 12 A resolution structure of the detergent micelle around the protein molecule was determined. The hydrophobic beta-barrel surfaces of the protein molecules are covered by rings of detergent. These detergent belts are fused to neighbouring detergent rings forming a continuous three-dimensional network throughout the crystal. The thickness of the detergent layer around the protein varies from 7-20 A. The enzyme's active site is positioned just outside the hydrophobic detergent zone and is thus in a proper location to catalyse the hydrolysis of phospholipids in a natural membrane. Although the dimerisation face of OMPLA is covered with detergent, the detergent density is weak near the exposed polar patch, suggesting that burying this patch in the enzyme's dimer interface may be energetically favourable. Furthermore, these results indicate a crucial role for detergent coalescence during crystal formation and contribute to the understanding of membrane protein crystallisation.     

Unusual catalytic triad of Escherichia coli outer membrane phospholipase A

Escherichia coli outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is an integral membrane enzyme. OMPLA is active as a homodimer and requires calcium as a cofactor. The crystal structures of the monomeric and the inhibited dimeric enzymes were recently determined [Snijder, H. J., et al. (1999) Nature 401, 717-721] and revealed that OMPLA monomers are folded into a 12-stranded antiparallel beta-barrel. The active site consists of previously identified essential residues Ser144 and His142 in an arrangement resembling the corresponding residues of a serine hydrolase catalytic triad. However, instead of an Asp or Glu that normally is present in the triad of serine hydrolases, a neutral asparagine (Asn156) was found in OMPLA. In this paper, the importance of the catalytic Asn156 is addressed by site-directed mutagenesis studies. All variants were purified at a 30 mg scale, and were shown to be properly folded using SDS-PAGE and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Using chemical cross-linking, it was shown that all variants were not affected in their calcium-dependent dimerization properties. The Asn156Asp variant exhibited a 2-fold lower activity than wild-type OMPLA at neutral pH. Interestingly, the activity of the variant is 1 order of magnitude higher than that of the wild type at pH >10. Modest residual activities (5 and 2.5%, respectively) were obtained for the Asn156Ala and Asn156Gln mutants, showing that the active site of OMPLA is more tolerant toward replacements of this third residue of the catalytic triad than other serine hydrolases, and that the serine and histidine residues are minimally required for catalysis. In the X-ray structure of dimeric OMPLA, the cofactor calcium is coordinating the putative oxyanion via two water molecules. We propose that this may lessen the importance for the asparagine in the catalytic triad of OMPLA.     

The position of the Gly-xxx-Gly motif in transmembrane segments modulates dimer affinity.

Although the intrinsic low solubility of membrane proteins presents challenges to their high-resolution structure determination, insight into the amino acid sequence features and forces that stabilize their folds has been provided through study of sequence-dependent helix-helix interactions between single transmembrane (TM) helices. While the stability of helix-helix partnerships mediated by the Gly-xxx-Gly (GG4) motif is known to be generally modulated by distal interfacial residues, it has not been established whether the position of this motif, with respect to the ends of a given TM segment, affects dimer affinity. Here we examine the relationship between motif position and affinity in the homodimers of 2 single-spanning membrane protein TM sequences: glycophorin A (GpA) and bacteriophage M13 coat protein (MCP). Using the TOXCAT assay for dimer affinity on a series of GpA and MCP TM segments that have been modified with either 4 Leu residues at each end or with 8 Leu residues at the N-terminal end, we show that in each protein, centrally located GG4 motifs are capable of stronger helix-helix interactions than those proximal to TM helix ends, even when surrounding interfacial residues are maintained. The relative importance of GG4 motifs in stabilizing helix-helix interactions therefore must be considered not only in its specific residue context but also in terms of the location of the interactive surface relative to the N and C termini of alpha-helical TM segments.     

Functional importance of calcium binding sites in outer membrane phospholipase A

Outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is an integral membrane enzyme that hydrolyses phospholipids requiring Ca(2+) as cofactor. In vitro studies have shown that OMPLA is only active as a dimer. The structures of monomeric and dimeric OMPLA provided possible clues to the activation process. In the inhibited dimeric species calcium ions are located at the dimer interface ideally suited to stabilise the oxyanion intermediates formed during catalysis. The side chain hydroxyl function of Ser152 is one of the ligands of this interfacial calcium. In the crystal structure of monomeric OMPLA the interfacial calcium site is lacking, but calcium was found to bind at a site involving the carboxylates of Asp149 and Asp184. In the current study the relevance of the identified calcium sites has been studied by site-directed mutagenesis. The Ser152Asn variant confirmed the importance of the interfacial calcium site for catalysis, and also demonstrated that this site is essentially involved in the dimerisation process. Replacements of the ligands in monomeric OMPLA, i.e. Asp149Asn, Asp149Ala and Asp184Asn, only showed minor effects on catalytic activity and dimerisation. A stronger effect observed for the variant Asp184Ala was explained by the proximity of Asp184 to the catalytically important Ser152 residue. We propose that Asp149 and Asp184 provide an electronegative funnel that may facilitate Ca(2+) transfer to the interfacial calcium site.     

Functional importance of calcium binding sites in outer membrane phospholipase A

Outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is an integral membrane enzyme that hydrolyses phospholipids requiring Ca²⁺ as cofactor. In vitro studies have shown that OMPLA is only active as a dimer. The structures of monomeric and dimeric OMPLA provided possible clues to the activation process. In the inhibited dimeric species calcium ions are located at the dimer interface ideally suited to stabilise the oxyanion intermediates formed during catalysis. The side chain hydroxyl function of Ser152 is one of the ligands of this interfacial calcium. In the crystal structure of monomeric OMPLA the interfacial calcium site is lacking, but calcium was found to bind at a site involving the carboxylates of Asp149 and Asp184. In the current study the relevance of the identified calcium sites has been studied by site-directed mutagenesis. The Ser152Asn variant confirmed the importance of the interfacial calcium site for catalysis, and also demonstrated that this site is essentially involved in the dimerisation process. Replacements of the ligands in monomeric OMPLA, i.e. Asp149Asn, Asp149Ala and Asp184Asn, only showed minor effects on catalytic activity and dimerisation. A stronger effect observed for the variant Asp184Ala was explained by the proximity of Asp184 to the catalytically important Ser152 residue. We propose that Asp149 and Asp184 provide an electronegative funnel that may facilitate Ca²⁺ transfer to the interfacial calcium site.     

Amphipathic polymers: tools to fold integral membrane proteins to their active form

Among the major obstacles to pharmacological and structural studies of integral membrane proteins (MPs) are their natural scarcity and the difficulty in overproducing them in their native form. MPs can be overexpressed in the non-native state as inclusion bodies, but inducing them to achieve their functional three-dimensional structure has proven to be a major challenge. We describe here the use of an amphipathic polymer, amphipol A8-35, as a novel environment that allows both beta-barrel and alpha-helical MPs to fold to their native state, in the absence of detergents or lipids. Amphipols, which are extremely mild surfactants, appear to favor the formation of native intramolecular protein-protein interactions over intermolecular or protein-surfactant ones. The feasibility of the approach is demonstrated using as models OmpA and FomA, two outer membrane proteins from the eubacteria Escherichia coli and Fusobacterium nucleatum, respectively, and bacteriorhodopsin, a light-driven proton pump from the plasma membrane of the archaebacterium Halobacterium salinarium.     

Structural investigations of calcium binding and its role in activity and activation of outer membrane phospholipase A from Escherichia coli

Outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is an integral membrane enzyme that catalyses the hydrolysis of phospholipids. Enzymatic activity is regulated by reversible dimerisation and calcium-binding. We have investigated the role of calcium by X-ray crystallography. In monomeric OMPLA, one calcium ion binds between two external loops (L3L4 site) at 10 A from the active site. After dimerisation, a new calcium-binding site (catalytic site) is formed at the dimer interface in the active site of each molecule at 6 A from the L3L4 calcium site. The close spacing and the difference in calcium affinity of both sites suggests that the L3L4 site may function as a storage site for a calcium ion, which relocates to the catalytic site upon dimerisation. A sequence alignment demonstrates conservation of the catalytic calcium site but evolutionary variation of the L3L4 site. The residues in the dimer interface are conserved as well, suggesting that all outer membrane phospholipases require dimerisation and calcium in the catalytic site for activity. For this family of phospholipases, we have characterised a consensus sequence motif (YTQ-X(n)-G-X(2)-H-X-SNG) that contains conserved residues involved in dimerisation and catalysis.     

A method for determining transmembrane helix association and orientation in detergent micelles using small angle x-ray scattering.

Solution small angle x-ray scattering can be used to study the association of transmembrane proteins solubilized in detergent micelles. We have used the alpha-helical transmembrane domain of the human erythrocyte glycophorin A (GpA) fused to the carboxyl terminus of monomeric staphylococcal nuclease (SN/GpA) as a model system for study. By matching the average electron density of the detergent micelles to that of the buffer solution, the micelle contribution to the small angle scattering vanishes, and the molecular weight and the radius of gyration of the proteins can be determined. SN/GpA has been found to dimerize in a zwitterionic detergent micelle, N-dodecyl-N,N-(dimethylammonio)butyrate (DDMAB), whose average electron density naturally matches the electron density of an aqueous buffer. The dimerization occurs through the transmembrane domains of GpA. With the aid of the nuclease domain scattering, the orientation of the helices within a dimer can be determined to be parallel by radius of gyration analysis. The association constant of a mutant (G83I) that weakens the GpA dimerization has been determined to be 24 microM in the DDMAB environment. The experimental methods established here could be used to apply solution small angle x-ray scattering to studying the association and interactions of other membrane proteins.     

A molecular dynamics investigation of mono and dimeric states of the outer membrane enzyme OMPLA

OMPLA is a phospholipase found in the outer membranes of many Gram-negative bacteria. Enzyme activation requires calcium-induced dimerisation plus bilayer perturbation. As the conformation of OMPLA in the different crystal forms (monomer versus dimer; with/without bound Ca(2+)) is remarkably similar we have used multi-nanosecond molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to probe possible differences in conformational dynamics that may be related to enzyme activation. Simulations of calcium-free monomeric OMPLA, of the Ca(2+)-bound dimer, and of the Ca(2+)-bound dimer with a substrate analogue covalently linked to the active site serine have been performed, all with the protein embedded in a phospholipid (POPC) bilayer. All simulations were stable, but differences in the dynamic behaviour of the protein between the various states were observed. In particular, the stability of the active site and the hydrophobic substrate-binding cleft varied. Dimeric OMPLA is less flexible than monomeric OMPLA, especially around the active site. In the absence of bound substrate analogue, the hydrophobic substrate-binding cleft of dimeric OMPLA collapses. A model is proposed whereby the increased stability of the active site in dimeric OMPLA is a consequence of the local ordering of water around the nearby calcium ion. The observed collapse of the substrate-binding cleft may explain the experimentally observed occurrence of multiple dimer conformations of OMPLA, one of which is fully active while the other shows significantly reduced activity.     

Substrate interferes with dimerisation of outer membrane phospholipase A

Outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) activity is regulated by reversible dimerisation with the dimer being the active species. Observed lag phases in activity indicated that dimerisation may be slow relative to turnover. A covalent OMPLA dimer indeed did not display lag phase behaviour. A model for OMPLA kinetics was proposed accounting for a slow dimerisation step. Preincubation conditions determined the initial amount of monomer and influenced both lag times and final activities. Under the conditions used, substrate concentrations higher than 50 mol% inhibited OMPLA activity and increased lag times. Our results may shed more light on mechanisms controlling OMPLA activity in vivo.     

The Ras G Domain Lacks the Intrinsic Propensity to Form Dimers

Ras GTPase is a molecular switch controlling a number of cellular pathways including growth, proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis. Recent reports indicated that Ras undergoes dimerization at the membrane surface through protein-protein interactions. If firmly established this property of Ras would require profound reassessment of a large amount of published data and modification of the Ras signaling paradigm. One proposed mechanism of dimerization involves formation of salt bridges between the two GTPase domains (G domains) leading to formation of a compact dimer as observed in Ras crystal structures. In this work, we interrogated the intrinsic ability of Ras to self-associate in solution by creating conditions of high local concentration through irreversibly tethering the two G domains together at their unstructured C-terminal tails. We evaluated possible self-association in this inverted tandem conjugate via analysis of the time-domain fluorescence anisotropy and NMR chemical shift perturbations. We did not observe the increased rotational correlation time expected for the G domain dimer. Variation of the ionic strength (to modulate stability of the salt bridges) did not affect the rotational correlation time in the tandem further supporting independent rotational diffusion of two G domains. In a parallel line of experiments to detect and map weak self-association of the G domains, we analyzed NMR chemical shifts perturbations at a number of sites near the crystallographic dimer interface. The nearly complete lack of chemical shift perturbations in the tandem construct supported a simple model with the independent G domains repelled from each other by their overall negative charge. These results lead us to the conclusion that self-association of the G domains cannot be responsible for homodimerization of Ras reported in the literature.     

Folding and assembly of beta-barrel membrane proteins

Beta-barrel membrane proteins occur in the outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria, mitochondria and chloroplasts. The membrane-spanning sequences of beta-barrel membrane proteins are less hydrophobic than those of alpha-helical membrane proteins, which is probably the main reason why completely different folding and membrane assembly pathways have evolved for these two classes of membrane proteins. Some beta-barrel membrane proteins can be spontaneously refolded into lipid bilayer model membranes in vitro. They may also have this ability in vivo although lipid and protein chaperones likely assist with their assembly in appropriate target membranes. This review summarizes recent work on the thermodynamic stability and the mechanism of membrane insertion of beta-barrel membrane proteins in lipid model and biological membranes. How lipid compositions affect folding and assembly of beta-barrel membrane proteins is also reviewed. The stability of these proteins in membranes is not as large as previously thought (<10 kcal/mol) and is modulated by elastic forces of the lipid bilayer. Detailed kinetic studies indicate that beta-barrel membrane proteins fold in distinct steps with several intermediates that can be characterized in vitro. Formation of the barrel is synchronized with membrane insertion and all beta-hairpins insert simultaneously in a concerted pathway.     

Structural biology of membrane-intrinsic beta-barrel enzymes: sentinels of the bacterial outer membrane

The outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria are replete with integral membrane proteins that exhibit antiparallel beta-barrel structures, but very few of these proteins function as enzymes. In Escherichia coli, only three beta-barrel enzymes are known to exist in the outer membrane; these are the phospholipase OMPLA, the protease OmpT, and the phospholipidColon, two colonslipid A palmitoyltransferase PagP, all of which have been characterized at the structural level. Structural details have also emerged for the outer membrane beta-barrel enzyme PagL, a lipid A 3-O-deacylase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Lipid A can be further modified in the outer membrane by two beta-barrel enzymes of unknown structure; namely, the Salmonella enterica 3'-acyloxyacyl hydrolase LpxR, and the Rhizobium leguminosarum oxidase LpxQ, which employs O(2) to convert the proximal glucosamine unit of lipid A into 2-aminogluconate. Structural biology now indicates how beta-barrel enzymes can function as sentinels that remain dormant when the outer membrane permeability barrier is intact. Host immune defenses and antibiotics that perturb this barrier can directly trigger beta-barrel enzymes in the outer membrane. The ensuing adaptive responses occur instantaneously and rapidly outpace other signal transduction mechanisms that similarly function to restore the outer membrane permeability barrier.     

Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Micelle Formation around Dimeric Glycophorin A Transmembrane Helices

Insertion and formation of membrane proteins involves the interaction of protein helices with one another in lipid environments. Researchers have studied glycophorin A (GpA) transmembrane helices embedded in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles to identify contacts significant for helix dimerization. However, a detailed picture of the conformation and dynamics of the GpA-SDS system cannot be obtained solely through experiment. Molecular dynamics simulations of SDS and a GpA dimer can provide an atomic-level picture of SDS aggregation and helix association. We report 2.5-ns simulations of GpA wild-type and mutants in a preformed micelle as well as a 32-ns simulation showing the formation of a complete micelle around wild-type GpA from an initially random placement of SDS molecules in an aqueous environment. In the latter case, an initial instability of GpA helices in water is reversed after the helices become surrounded by SDS. The properties of the spontaneously formed micelle surrounding the GpA are indistinguishable from those of the preformed micelle surrounding the GpA dimer.