Interactions between core histones and chromatin at physiological ionic strength

Addition of core histones to chromatin or chromatin core particles at physiological ionic strength results in soluble nucleohistone complexes when polyglutamic acid is included in the sample. The interaction between nucleosomes and added core histones is strong enough to inhibit nucleosome formation on a closed circular DNA in the same solution. Complexes consisting of core particles and core histones run as discrete nucleoprotein particles on polyacrylamide gels. Consistent with the electrophoretic properties of these particles, protein cross-linking with dimethyl suberimidate indicates that added core histones are bound as excess octamers. Histones in the excess octamers do not exchange with nucleosomal core histones at an ionic strength of 0.1 M and can be selectively removed from core particles by incubating the complexes in a solution containing sufficient DNA. Under conditions where added histones are confined to the surface of chromatin, the excess histones are mobile and can migrate onto a contiguous extension of naked DNA and form nucleosomes.     

Thermodynamics of condensation of nuclear chromatin. A differential scanning calorimetry study of the salt-dependent structural transitions

We present a detailed thermodynamic investigation of the conformational transitions of chromatin in calf thymus nuclei. Differential scanning calorimetry was used as the leading method, in combination with infrared spectroscopy, electron microscopy, and techniques for the molecular characterization of chromatin components. The conformational transitions were induced by changes in the counterion concentration. In this way, it was possible to discriminate between the interactions responsible for the folding of the higher order structure and for the coiling of nucleosomal DNA. Our experiments confirm that the denaturation of nuclear chromatin at physiological ionic strength occurs at the level of discrete structural domains, the linker and the core particle, and we were able to rule out that the actual denaturation pattern might be determined by dissociation of the nucleohistone complex and successive migration of free histones toward native regions, as recently suggested. The sequence of the denaturation events is (1) the conformational change of the histone complement at 66 degrees C, (2) the unstacking of the linker DNA at 74 degrees C, and (3) the unstacking of the core particle DNA, that can be observed either at 90 or at 107 degrees C, depending on the degree of condensation of chromatin. Nuclear chromatin unfolds in low-salt buffers, and can be refolded by increasing the ionic strength, in accordance with the well-known behavior of short fragments. The process is athermal, therefore showing that the stability of the higher order structure depends on electrostatic interactions. The transition between the folded conformation and the unfolded one proceeds through an intermediate condensation state, revealed by an endotherm at 101 degrees C. The analysis of the thermodynamic parameters of denaturation of the polynucleosomal chain demonstrates that the wrapping of the DNA around the histone octamer involves a large energy change. The most striking observation concerns the linker segment, which melts a few degrees below the peak temperature of naked DNA. This finding is in line with previous thermal denaturation investigations on isolated chromatin at low ionic strength, and suggests that a progressive destabilization of the linker occurs in the course of the salt-induced coiling of DNA in the nucleosome.     

Ionic strength-dependent conformational transitions of chromatin. Circular dichroism and thermal denaturation studies

High-molecular-weight chicken erythrocyte chromatin was prepared by mild digestion of nuclei with micrococcal nuclease. Samples of chromatin containing both core (H3, H4, H2A, H2B) and lysine-rich (H1, H5) histone proteins (whole chromatin) or only core histone proteins (core chromatin) were examined by CD and thermal denaturation as a function of ionic strength between 0.75 and 7.0 × 10^?3M Na⁺. CD studies at 21°C revealed a conformational transition over this range of ionic strengths in core chromatin, which indicated a partial unfolding of a segment of the core particle DNA at the lowest ionic strength studied. This transition is prevented by the presence of the lysine-rich histones in whole chromatin. Thermal-denaturation profiles of both whole and core chromatins, recorded by hyperchromicity at 260 nm, reproducibly and systematically varied with the ionic strength of the medium. Both materials displayed three resolvable thermal transitions, which represented the total DNA hyperchromicity on denaturation. The fractions of the total DNA which melted in each of these transitions were extremely sensitive to ionic strength. These effects are considered to result from intra- and/or internucleosomal electrostatic repulsions in chromatin studied at very low ionic strengths. Comparison of the whole and core chromatin melting profiles indicated substantial stabilization of the core-particle DNA by binding sites between the H1/H5 histones and the 140-base-pair core particle.     

Effects of histone acetylation on nucleosome properties as evaluated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and hydroxylapatite dissociation chromatography

The release of acetylated histones from chick oviduct chromatin was analyzed by hydroxylapatite column chromatography. By raising of the NaCl concentration, acetylated histones were eluted from hydroxylapatite-bound chromatin depending on their release from nucleosomal DNA. Electrophoresis on acid-urea gel showed that hyperacetylated forms of histone H4 were eluted at a lower NaCl concentration than non-acetylated or hypoacetylated H4, suggesting that hyperacetylated H4 has decreased stability in nucleosomes. However, under milder ionic conditions which do not induce dissociation between histones and DNA, polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of purified nucleosome cores showed no evidence for their unfolding or for increased accessibility by high mobility group protein-17.     

Proximity and accessibility studies of histones in nuclei and free nucleosomes.

Histone proximity in chromatin was studied with the cleavable crosslinking reagent, dithiobissuccinimidyl propionate. Crosslinks between H4 and H2a, H4 and H2b, H4 and H3, H2a and H2b, H2b and H3 were found. H1 is also crosslinked to the nucleosomal histones. In nuclei, unsheared chromatin, and H1 depleted chromatin, the four nucleosomal histones are crosslinked at similar relative rates both in 5 mM salt and 100 mM salt. After micrococcal nuclease treatment to generate nucleosomes, H2a and H2b are crosslinked faster than H4 and H3. C14-NEM titration of thiopropionate residues bound to each histone shows that H2a and H2b are more accessible to this reagent after nuclease treatment but that the increased binding was not sufficient by itself to explain the increase in crosslinking. Bolton Hunter reagent was used to further study the accessibility of the four nucleosomal histones in whole chromatin and nuclease digested chromatin. These studies showed that salt increases the accessibility of all four histones while nuclease treatment decreases H4 accessibility.     

The comparative analysis of interaction between acridine orange and DNA-containing systems]

The interaction between acridine orange (AO) and diluted and concentrated solutions of DNA, DNP systems and chromatin suspension at the physiologic ionic strength was investigated. The effect of AO on DNP systems was also investigated. It was shown that highest possible number of AO molecules bound to DNA made up 70% of the total number of nucleotides. The model of AO binding to DNA is proposed and used for calculation of constants of stronger and weaker AO-binding capacities equal to 6-10(6) M-1 and 1,7-10(5) M-1, respectively. The AO-DNA binding constants in DNP-complex are five as low. The primary number of binding sites in chromatin suspension made up 10% of the corresponding sites in DNA and increased as AO was adsorbed. AO induced the supercontraction of oriented DNP systems at the physiologic ionic strength and the appearance of the low-temperature melting hump.     

Unfolding of nucleosome cores induced by chemical acetylation of histones

Relative accessibility of nucleosomal histones to acetic anhydride during acetylation has been studied as a function of concentration, pH and ionic strength of the solution using high-resolution gel-electrophoresis. It was shown that about 80% of lysine residues in nucleosomal histones and 100% of the same residues in histone complexes without DNA in 2 M NaCl are accessible to the modification, which is proved by the localization of the majority of lysine residues in nucleosomes near the surface of the histone octamer, by their participation in ionic interactions with DNA and, probably, in histone-histone contacts. Gel-electrophoretic experiments with nucleosomes and studies of the histone resistance to mild trypsinolysis indicated that neither nucleosomes themselves nor histone octamers are affected even though 50% of lysine residues in histones have been acetylated. The process of acetylation is accompanied by the growing tendency of histones to participate in mild trypsinolysis and by a gradual decline in electrophoretic mobility and in the value of the sedimentation constant. The circular dichroism spectra and the microscopic appearance of nucleosomes are also markedly changed. These results suggest that a gradual unfolding of nucleosomes occurs when 5 or more lysine residues in the nucleosomal histones have been acetylated.     

Binding of ethidium bromide and quinacrine hydrochloride to nucleic acids and reconstituted nucleohistones

Studies of binding of ethidium bromide and quinacrine hydrochloride to native DNA at low ionic strength indicate that for both compounds the binding is selective, with about one binding site for about four nucleotides. Annealing of unfractionated histones to DNA by a salt-gradient dialysis method slightly decreases the binding of the dyes to DNA. Similar observations made with reconstituted preparations by using individual histone fractions reveal that the arginine-rich histones (histones H3 and H4) are most effective in decreasing the binding. The binding studies with ethidium bromide at high ionic strength and with denatured DNA show that strong dye binding to DNA is strongly dependent on the ionic strength and on the secondary structure of DNA. The histones are not effective in decreasing the dye binding under conditions of high ionic strength. The results are consistent with the observations [Oliver & Chalkley (1974) Biochemistry13, 5093-5098; Axel, Melchoir, Sollner-Web & Felsenfield (1974) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.71, 4101-4105] that histones form some kind of surface structures on DNA through non-specific interactions and [Kornberg & Thomas (1974) Science184, 865-868; Kornberg (1974) Science184, 868-871; D'Anna & Isenberg (1974) Biochemistry13, 4992-4997; Vandegrift, Serra, Marve & Wagner (1974) Biochemistry13, 5087-5092] that the tendency of arginine-rich histones to aggregate may be an important factor in determining the structure of chromatin.     

HMG-D and histone H1 alter the local accessibility of nucleosomal DNA

There is evidence that HMGB proteins facilitate, while linker histones inhibit chromatin remodelling, respectively. We have examined the effects of HMG-D and histone H1/H5 on accessibility of nucleosomal DNA. Using the 601.2 nucleosome positioning sequence designed by Widom and colleagues we assembled nucleosomes in vitro and probed DNA accessibility with restriction enzymes in the presence or absence of HMG-D and histone H1/H5. For HMG-D our results show increased digestion at two spatially adjacent sites, the dyad and one terminus of nucleosomal DNA. Elsewhere varying degrees of protection from digestion were observed. The C-terminal acidic tail of HMG-D is essential for this pattern of accessibility. Neither the HMG domain by itself nor in combination with the adjacent basic region is sufficient. Histone H1/H5 binding produces two sites of increased digestion on opposite faces of the nucleosome and decreased digestion at all other sites. Our results provide the first evidence of local changes in the accessibility of nucleosomal DNA upon separate interaction with two linker binding proteins.     

pH-induced conformational changes in chromatin subunits measured by circular dichroism and immunochemical reactivity

Changes in the conformational state of chromatin core particles from chicken erythrocytes were studied by both immunochemical and biophysical methods as a function of pH and ionic strength. When the pH of core particles in a solution of ionic strength 3, 60 or 220 mM was lowered from pH 7.5, a sharp transition in the circular dichroism spectrum of DNA monitored between 320 and 260 nm was observed at pH 6.65. This change in DNA ellipticity was totally reversible. Binding to core particles of antibodies specific for histones H2B, H2A, H3 and for the IRGERA (synthetic C-terminal) peptide of H3 was used to follow changes in histone antigenicity. Binding was studied in the pH range 7.5-5.35, and at ionic strength of 60 and 220 mM. A change in reactivity of some histone epitopes was observed around pH 6.2–6.5. However, the changes observed by circular dichroism and antibody binding pertain to different components of chromatin subunits and they probably reflect independent phenomena. The alteration in accessibility of these determinants at the surface of core particles was completely reversible and was dependent on ionic strength. The conformation changes in core particles occurring near physiological ionic strength and pH may reflect dynamic changes in chromatin structure that possess functional significance.     

Fluorescence spectra of Hoechst 33258 bound to chromatin

Fluorescence spectra of Hoechst 33258 bound to rat thymocytes were measured by flow cytometry. At low dye concentrations (less than or equal to 2 micrograms/ml) the fluorescence maximum was situated at 460 nm irrespective of solvent composition. With higher dye concentrations the fluorescence maximum was shifted upwards, the intensity decreased and the width of the fluorescence peak increased. Linear combinations of a spectrum obtained at a low dye concentration (0.5 microgram/ml, type 1 binding) and one obtained at a high dye concentration (42.4 micrograms/ml, type 2 binding) failed to reproduce spectra measured at intermediate dye concentrations (0.15 M NaCl). Hence, Hoechst 33258 forms at least three different fluorescing complexes with DNA in chromatin. The shift in the fluorescence maximum of the Hoechst 33258/chromatin complex towards higher wavelengths decreased with ionic strength. 25% ethanol in the 0.15 M NaCl staining buffer reduced the wavelength shift at high dye concentrations, indicating that the strength of type 2 binding depends on DNA conformation in addition to ionic strength. The fluorescence spectrum was independent of whether DNA in chromatin was complexed with histones or not. However, histone-depleted thymocytes fluoresced more intensely than cells in which DNA was complexed with histones, the difference being greater at low concentrations of Hoechst 33258. Hence, type 2 binding to DNA in chromatin appears to be less restricted by histones than type 1 binding.     

Characteristics of chromatin fibers immobilized on a polycationic surface]

The possibility of chromatin fiber immobilization on a polycationic surface formed by lysine-rich histones was investigated. The amount of lysine-rich histones preimmobilized on a hydrophobic surface was estimated. It was shown that depending on the initial solution concentration the number of immobilized fibers can reach a level characteristic of a bilayer package. Immobilized fibers preserve a nucleosomal structure and shown an ability in compactization at physiological values of the ionic strength. Possible applications of the described approach as a model system for the study of the chromatin domain organization is discussed.     

Psoralen-crosslinking of soluble and of H1-depleted soluble rat liver chromatin

We purified soluble rat liver chromatin and H1-depleted chromatin and photocrosslinked its DNA with psoralen at pH 7. Digestion of this chromatin with micrococcal nuclease produced a normal nucleosomal repeat. Chromatin was photoreacted in the presence of 0 to 700 mM-NaCl and was fractionated in sucrose gradients containing the same NaCl concentrations. The dissociation of H1 occurred as in the non-crosslinked controls and no preferential dissociation of core histones was observed. The samples between 100 and 500 mM-NaCl showed precipitation. In the electron microscope, the fibers appeared indistinguishable from the controls at low ionic strength. In the presence of 40 mM-NaCl, the fibers of the photoreacted chromatin were slightly more compact than the controls, and at 500 mM-NaCl, despite the complete dissociation of H1, there were still apparently intact fibers at this ionic strength. The disruption of the psoralen-treated chromatin fibers occurred only in 600 mM-NaCl, as opposed to 500 mM-NaCl in controls. The DNA of all the photoreacted samples was spread for electron microscopy under denaturing conditions. They revealed, for all the samples, single-stranded bubbles corresponding to 200 to 400 base-pairs in size. H1-depleted chromatin containing stoichiometric amounts of core histones was photoreacted at pH 10 and very low ionic strength. Under these conditions many of the nucleosomes appeared to be unraveled, although to a variable extent. In the electron microscope, the purified DNA from these samples showed extensive crosslinking when spread under denaturing conditions. These observations show that histone-DNA interactions different from those in intact nucleosomes may be created, which allow extensive access of psoralen to the DNA.     

Spontaneous access to DNA target sites in folded chromatin fibers

DNA wrapped in nucleosomes is sterically occluded from many protein complexes that must act on it; how such complexes gain access to nucleosomal DNA is not known. In vitro studies on isolated nucleosomes show that they undergo spontaneous partial unwrapping conformational transitions, which make the wrapped nucleosomal DNA transiently accessible. Thus, site exposure might provide a general mechanism allowing access of protein complexes to nucleosomal DNA. However, existing quantitative analyses of site exposure focused on single nucleosomes, while the presence of neighbor nucleosomes and concomitant chromatin folding might significantly influence site exposure. In this work, we carried out quantitative studies on the accessibility of nucleosomal DNA in homogeneous nucleosome arrays. Two striking findings emerged. Organization into chromatin fibers changes the accessibility of nucleosomal DNA only modestly, from ∼ 3-fold decreases to ∼ 8-fold increases in accessibility. This means that nucleosome arrays are intrinsically dynamic and accessible even when they are visibly condensed. In contrast, chromatin folding decreases the accessibility of linker DNA by as much as ∼ 50-fold. Thus, nucleosome positioning dramatically influences the accessibility of target sites located inside nucleosomes, while chromatin folding dramatically regulates access to target sites in linker DNA.     

The use of DNA-cellulose for analyzing histone-DNA interactions. Discovery of nucleosome-like histone binding to single-stranded DNA.

In this report, we introduce the use of DNA-cellulose chromatography for evaluating the strength of binding of histones to DNA under a variety of conditions. We have found that histones added directly to DNA-cellulose at physiological salt concentrations bind relatively weakly, with all histones eluting together at about 0.5 M NaCl when a salt gradient is applied. However, much tighter binding of the four nucleosomal histones to DNA-cellulose is obtained if gradual histone-DNA reconstitution conditions are used. In this case, the binding of histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4 to DNA-cellulose closely resembles their binding to native chromatin. The nativeness of the binding is indicated both by the distinctive sodium chloride elution profile of these histones from DNA-cellulose and by their relative resistance to trypsin digestion when DNA-bound. The binding to DNA-cellulose of histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4, which have had the first 20 to 30 amino acid residues removed from their NH2 termini, is indistinguishable from the binding to DNA-cellulose of the same intact histones, as judged by their salt elution profile. Thus, even though the NH2 termini contain 40 to 50% of the positively charged amino acid residues (thought to interact with the DNA backbone), a major contribution to the DNA binding comes from the remainder of the histone molecule. Finally, we have discovered that histones can form a "nucleosome-like" complex on single-stranded DNA. The same complex does not appear to form on RNA. Histones H3 and H4 play a predominant role in organizing this histone complex on single-stranded DNA, as they do on double-stranded DNA in normal nucleosomes. We suggest that, in the cell nucleus, nucleosomal structures may form transiently on single strands of DNA, as DNA and RNA polymerases traverse DNA packaged by histones.