A genetic screen in C. elegans reveals roles for KIN17 and PRCC in maintaining 5’ splice site identity

Pre-mRNA splicing is an essential step of eukaryotic gene expression carried out by a series of dynamic macromolecular protein/RNA complexes, known collectively and individually as the spliceosome. This series of spliceosomal complexes define, assemble on, and catalyze the removal of introns. Molecular model snapshots of intermediates in the process have been created from cryo-EM data, however, many aspects of the dynamic changes that occur in the spliceosome are not fully understood. Caenorhabditis elegans follow the GU-AG rule of splicing, with almost all introns beginning with 5’ GU and ending with 3’ AG. These splice sites are identified early in the splicing cycle, but as the cycle progresses and “custody” of the pre-mRNA splice sites is passed from factor to factor as the catalytic site is built, the mechanism by which splice site identity is maintained or re-established through these dynamic changes is unclear. We performed a genetic screen in C. elegans for factors that are capable of changing 5’ splice site choice. We report that KIN17 and PRCC are involved in splice site choice, the first functional splicing role proposed for either of these proteins. Previously identified suppressors of cryptic 5’ splicing promote distal cryptic GU splice sites, however, mutations in KIN17 and PRCC instead promote usage of an unusual proximal 5’ splice site which defines an intron beginning with UU, separated by 1nt from a GU donor. We performed high-throughput mRNA sequencing analysis and found that mutations in PRCC, and to a lesser extent KIN17, changed alternative 5’ splice site usage at native sites genome-wide, often promoting usage of nearby non-consensus sites. Our work has uncovered both fine and coarse mechanisms by which the spliceosome maintains splice site identity during the complex assembly process.     

Complex splicing control of the human Thrombopoietin gene by intronic G runs

The human thrombopoietin (THPO) gene displays a series of alternative splicing events that provide valuable models for studying splicing mechanisms. The THPO region spanning exon 1–4 presents both alternative splicing of exon 2 and partial intron 2 (IVS2) retention following the activation of a cryptic 3′ splice site 85 nt upstream of the authentic acceptor site. IVS2 is particularly rich in stretches of 3–5 guanosines (namely, G1–G10) and we have characterized the role of these elements in the processing of this intron. In vivo studies show that runs G7–G10 work in a combinatorial way to control the selection of the proper 3′ splice site. In particular, the G7 element behaves as the splicing hub of intron 2 and its interaction with hnRNP H1 is critical for the splicing process. Removal of hnRNP H1 by RNA interference promoted the usage of the cryptic 3′ splice site so providing functional evidence that this factor is involved in the selection of the authentic 3′ splice site of THPO IVS2.     

Functional characterization of two novel splicing mutations of glucokinase gene associated with maturity-onset diabetes of the young type 2 (MODY2)

Two novel mutations in the glucokinase gene (GCK) have been identified in patients with maturity-onset diabetes of the young type-2 (MODY2), i.e., a C-for-G substitution at position ?1 of the acceptor splice site of intron 7 (c. 864-1G>C) and a synonymous c.666C>G substitution (GTC>GTG, p.V222V) at exon 6. An analysis of the splicing products obtained upon the transfection of human embryonic HEK293 cells with GCK minigene constructs carrying these mutations showed that both substitutions impaired normal splicing. As a result of c.864-1G>C, the usage of the normal acceptor site was blocked, which activated cryptic acceptor splice sites within intron 7 and generated several aberrant RNAs containing fragments of intron 7. The synonymous substitution c.666C>G created a novel donor splice site in exon 6, which results in the formation of an abnormal GCK mRNA with a 16-nucleotide deletion in exon 6. In vitro experiments on minigene splicing confirmed the inactivating effect of these mutations on glucokinase gene expression.     

In vitro characterization of the splicing efficiency and fidelity of the RmInt1 group II intron as a means of controlling the dispersion of its host mobile element

Group II introns are catalytic RNAs that are excised from their precursors in a protein-dependent manner in vivo. Certain group II introns can also react in a protein-independent manner under nonphysiological conditions in vitro. The efficiency and fidelity of the splicing reaction is crucial, to guarantee the correct formation and expression of the protein-coding mRNA. RmInt1 is an efficient mobile intron found within the ISRm2011-2 insertion sequence in the symbiotic bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti. The RmInt1 intron self-splices in vitro, but this reaction generates side products due to a predicted cryptic IBS1* sequence within the 3′ exon. We engineered an RmInt1 intron lacking the cryptic IBS1* sequence, which improved the fidelity of the splicing reaction. However, atypical circular forms of similar electrophoretic mobility to the lariat intron were nevertheless observed. We analyzed a run of four cytidine residues at the 3′ splice site potentially responsible for a lack of fidelity at this site leading to the formation of circular intron forms. We showed that mutations of residues base-pairing in the tertiary EBS3–IBS3 interaction increased the efficiency and fidelity of the splicing reaction. Our results indicate that RmInt1 has developed strategies for decreasing its splicing efficiency and fidelity. RmInt1 makes use of unproductive splicing reactions to limit the transposition of the insertion sequence into which it inserts itself in its natural context, thereby preventing potentially harmful dispersion of ISRm2011-2 throughout the genome of its host.     

A Genetic Screen for Suppressors of a Mutated 5′ Splice Site Identifies Factors Associated With Later Steps of Spliceosome Assembly

Many alleles of human disease genes have mutations within splicing consensus sequences that activate cryptic splice sites. In Caenorhabditis elegans, the unc-73(e936) allele has a G-to-U mutation at the first base of the intron downstream of exon 15, which results in an uncoordinated phenotype. This mutation triggers cryptic splicing at the −1 and +23 positions and retains some residual splicing at the mutated wild-type (wt) position. We previously demonstrated that a mutation in sup-39, a U1 snRNA gene, suppresses e936 by increasing splicing at the wt splice site. We report here the results of a suppressor screen in which we identify three proteins that function in cryptic splice site choice. Loss-of-function mutations in the nonessential splicing factor smu-2 suppress e936 uncoordination through changes in splicing. SMU-2 binds SMU-1, and smu-1(RNAi) also leads to suppression of e936. A dominant mutation in the conserved C-terminal domain of the C. elegans homolog of the human tri-snRNP 27K protein, which we have named SNRP-27, suppresses e936 uncoordination through changes in splicing. We propose that SMU-2, SMU-1, and SNRP-27 contribute to the fidelity of splice site choice after the initial identification of 5′ splice sites by U1 snRNP.PRE-mRNA splicing takes place in a large ribonucleoprotein complex called the spliceosome (Burge et al. 1999). Components of this splicing machinery assemble at conserved signal sequences within the pre-mRNA. The 5′ splice site consensus sequence M₋₃A₋₂G₋₁ | G₊₁U₊₂R₊₃A₊₄G₊₅U₊₆ and the 3′ splice site consensus sequence Y₋₃A₋₂G₋₁ | R₊₁ (M is either A or C; R is a purine, and Y is a pyrimidine) define the limits of the intron. Base-pairing interactions between the 5′ end of the U1 snRNA and the 5′ splice site consensus sequence occur early in spliceosome assembly. It is the nearly invariable GU dinucleotide at the first two positions of the 5′ end of the intron that defines the beginning of the intron. The 5′ consensus sequence is essential but insufficient for splice site selection, as 5′ splice sites with weaker consensus matches may require additional determinants for proper activation (Sanford et al. 2005).Mutations that disrupt the 5′ consensus splice signal can lead to genetic disease in humans (Nelson and Green 1990; Cohen et al. 1994). Approximately 15% of point mutations that cause genetic diseases affect pre-mRNA splicing consensus sequences (Krawczak et al. 1992). For some specific disease genes, as many as 50% of the known heritable alleles alter splicing (Teraoka et al. 1999; Ars et al. 2000; Roca et al. 2003; Pagenstecher et al. 2006). Among all the positions of the 5′ splice site consensus sequence, the highest proportion of human disease mutations occur at the +1G position (Buratti et al. 2007). The fidelity of pre-mRNA splice site choice is largely disrupted by this defect, since this mutation causes splicing at this site to be either abolished or outcompeted by the activation of nearby cryptic 5′ splice sites (Nelson and Green 1990; Cohen et al. 1994). Cryptic splice sites are used only when the wild-type splice donor is disrupted by mutation, as they tend to have very weak splice donor consensus sequences outside of a 5′-GU dinucleotide that defines the beginning of the intron (Roca et al. 2003). Suppression of mutations to the 5′ splice site consensus sequence in vivo has been achieved through the expression of U1 snRNAs containing compensatory base substitutions (Zhuang and Weiner 1986); however, suppression of mutations to the +1 position of the intron using reverse genetic approaches has not been successful (Newman et al. 1985; Nelson and Green 1990; Cohen et al. 1994).We have used a specific allele of the Caenorhabditis elegans unc-73 gene, e936, which contains a G-to-U mutation at the first nucleotide of intron 16 (Steven et al. 1998), as a model for studying cryptic splice site choice (Roller et al. 2000; Zahler et al. 2004). unc-73 encodes a RAC guanine nucleotide exchange factor that is expressed in neurons and is important for axon guidance (Steven et al. 1998). The e936 allele induces the use of three different cryptic 5′ splice sites (Figure 1A). Two of these 5′ splice sites, located at the −1 and +23 positions, define introns beginning with GU. The third 5′ splice site used is at the mutated wild-type (wt) position and is referred to as “wt” since splicing at this site still produces wild-type unc-73 mRNA and protein, even though the intron begins with UU (Roller et al. 2000). Use of either the −1 or the +23 cryptic site causes a shift in the reading frame and loss of gene function. In e936 animals, 90% of the stable messages of unc-73 are out-of-frame, yet the phenotype is not as severe as for other alleles in this gene. This indicates that the 10% of steady-state messages that are in frame have some functional role.Open in a separate windowFigure 1.—(A) Diagram of the unc-73 gene between exons 15 and 16. The positions of the −1 and +23 cryptic 5′ splice sites are indicated by arrows. The intronic e936 (+1G → U) point mutation is highlighted. (B) γ-³²P-labeled RT–PCR results across the cryptic splicing region of unc-73(e936) for different strains. Lanes 1, 2, and 3 are loaded with RT–PCR reactions from wild type (N2), unc-73(e936);sup-39(je5), and unc-73(e936) RNA, respectively. The lines carrying the suppressor alleles and e936 follow in lanes 4–10 as indicated. (C) The unc-73 genomic sequence from exon 15 (uppercase letters) and intron 15 (lowercase letters). The locations of the az23 and e936 mutational substitutions are indicated below. The position of the −9 cryptic splice donor activated in e936az23 is indicated by an arrow above.In a previous genetic screen for extragenic suppressors of e936 movement defects, Way and colleagues identified sup-39 (Run et al. 1996). It was subsequently shown that mutations in sup-39 alter cryptic splice site choice of e936 (Roller et al. 2000). sup-39 encodes a U1 snRNA gene with a compensatory mutation at the position that normally base pairs with the +1G. This allows sup-39 to base pair with an intron with a +1U (Zahler et al. 2004). This dominant suppressor increases usage of the mutated splice site and improves the fraction of in-frame messages from e936 from 10 to 33%, with a dramatic improvement in coordination. A similar mutant U1 snRNA suppressor with a different compensatory substitution, sup-6(st19), was found to suppress the intronic +1G to A transition of unc-13(e309) to allow for splicing at the mutated wild-type site, even though the intron begins with AU instead of GU (Zahler et al. 2004).We are interested in identifying additional factors that play a role in cryptic 5′ splice site choice. To do this, we took advantage of unc-73(e936), in which modest increases in the use of the wt splice site lead to dramatic increases in coordination, as a sensitive screen for changes in cryptic splice site choice. In this article we report that the proteins SMU-1 and SMU-2, which are nonessential factors previously shown to have a role in alternative splicing (Spartz et al. 2004), have a role in selection of cryptic 5′ splice sites. We also report the identification of a new dominant suppressor of cryptic splicing, snrp-27, which encodes a C. elegans homolog of the human tri-snRNP 27K protein.     

Evidence that RNA editing modulates splice site selection in the 5-HT2C receptor gene

Adenosine to inosine editing of mRNA from the human 5-HT2C receptor gene (HTR2C) occurs at five exonic positions (A–E) in a stable stem–loop that includes the normal 5′ splice site of intron 5 and is flanked by two alternative splice sites. Using in vitro editing, we identified a novel editing site (F) located in the intronic part of the stem–loop and demonstrated editing at this site in human brain. We have shown that in cell culture, base substitutions to mimic editing at different combinations of the six sites profoundly affect relative splicing at the normal and the upstream alternative splice site, but splicing at the downstream alternative splice site was consistently rare. Editing combinations in different splice variants from human brain were determined and are consistent with the effects of editing on splicing observed in cell culture. As RNA editing usually occurs close to exon/intron boundaries, this is likely to be a general phenomenon and suggests an important novel role for RNA editing.     

Three novel types of splicing aberrations in the tuberous sclerosis TSC2 gene caused by mutations apart from splice consensus sequences

Disease causing aberrations in both tuberous sclerosis predisposing genes, TSC1 and TSC2, comprise nearly every type of alteration with a predominance of small truncating mutations distributed over both genes. We performed an RNA based screening of the entire coding regions of both TSC genes applying the protein truncation test (PTT) and identified a high proportion of unusual splicing abnormalities affecting the TSC2 gene. Two cases exhibited different splice acceptor mutations in intron 9 (IVS9-15G-->A and IVS9-3C-->G) both accompanied by exon 10 skipping and simultaneous usage of a cryptic splice acceptor in exon 10. Another splice acceptor mutation (IVS38-18A-->G) destroyed the putative polypyrimidine structure in intron 38 and resulted in simultaneous intron retention and usage of a downstream cryptic splice acceptor in exon 39. Another patient bore a C-->T transition in intron 8 (IVS8+281C-->T) activating a splice donor site and resulting in the inclusion of a newly recognised exon in the mRNA followed by a premature stop. These splice variants deduced from experimental results are additionally supported by RNA secondary structure analysis based on free energy minimisation. Three of the reported splicing anomalies are due to sequence changes remote from exon/intron boundaries, described for the first time in TSC. These findings highlight the significance of investigating intronic changes and their consequences on the mRNA level as disease causing mutations in TSC.     

Aberrant 3' splice sites in human disease genes: mutation pattern, nucleotide structure and comparison of computational tools that predict their utilization

The frequency distribution of mutation-induced aberrant 3′ splice sites (3′ss) in exons and introns is more complex than for 5′ splice sites, largely owing to sequence constraints upstream of intron/exon boundaries. As a result, prediction of their localization remains a challenging task. Here, nucleotide sequences of previously reported 218 aberrant 3′ss activated by disease-causing mutations in 131 human genes were compared with their authentic counterparts using currently available splice site prediction tools. Each tested algorithm distinguished authentic 3′ss from cryptic sites more effectively than from de novo sites. The best discrimination between aberrant and authentic 3′ss was achieved by the maximum entropy model. Almost one half of aberrant 3′ss was activated by AG-creating mutations and ~95% of the newly created AGs were selected in vivo. The overall nucleotide structure upstream of aberrant 3′ss was characterized by higher purine content than for authentic sites, particularly in position −3, that may be compensated by more stringent requirements for positive and negative nucleotide signatures centred around position −11. A newly developed online database of aberrant 3′ss will facilitate identification of splicing mutations in a gene or phenotype of interest and future optimization of splice site prediction tools.     

Functionally antagonistic sequences are required for normal autoregulation of Drosophila tra-2 pre-mRNA splicing

Expression of functional TRA-2 protein in the male germline of Drosophila is regulated through a negative feedback mechanism in which a specific TRA-2 isoform represses splicing of the M1 intron in the TRA-2 pre-mRNA. We have previously shown that the mechanism of M1 splicing repression is conserved between distantly related Drosophila species. Using transgenic fly strains, we have examined the effects on regulation of mutations in two conserved features of the M1 intron. Our results show that TRA-2-dependent repression of M1 splicing depends on the presence of a suboptimal non-consensus 3′ splice site. Substitution of this 3′ splice site with a strong splice site resulted in TRA-2 independent splicing, while substitution with an unrelated weak 3′ splice site was compatible with repression, implying that reduced basal splicing efficiency is important for regulation. A second conserved element internal to the intron was found to be essential for efficient M1 splicing in the soma where the intron is not normally retained. We show that the role of this element is to enhance splicing and overcome the reduction in efficiency caused by the intron’s suboptimal 3′ splice site. Our results indicate that antagonistic elements in the M1 intron act together to establish a context that is permissive for repression of splicing by TRA-2 while allowing efficient splicing in the absence of a repressor.     

Functional studies on the ATM intronic splicing processing element

In disease-associated genes, the understanding of the functional significance of deep intronic nucleotide variants may represent a difficult challenge. We have previously reported a new disease-causing mechanism that involves an intronic splicing processing element (ISPE) in ATM, composed of adjacent consensus 5′ and 3′ splice sites. A GTAA deletion within ISPE maintains potential adjacent splice sites, disrupts a non-canonical U1 snRNP interaction and activates an aberrant exon. In this paper, we demonstrate that binding of U1 snRNA through complementarity within a ~40 nt window downstream of the ISPE prevents aberrant splicing. By selective mutagenesis at the adjacent consensus ISPE splice sites, we show that this effect is not due to a resplicing process occurring at the ISPE. Functional comparison of the ATM mouse counterpart and evaluation of the pre-mRNA splicing intermediates derived from affected cell lines and hybrid minigene assays indicate that U1 snRNP binding at the ISPE interferes with the cryptic acceptor site. Activation of this site results in a stringent 5′–3′ order of intron sequence removal around the cryptic exon. Artificial U1 snRNA loading by complementarity to heterologous exonic sequences represents a potential therapeutic method to prevent the usage of an aberrant CFTR cryptic exon. Our results suggest that ISPE-like intronic elements binding U1 snRNPs may regulate correct intron processing.     

Oriented Scanning Is the Leading Mechanism Underlying 5′ Splice Site Selection in Mammals

Splice site selection is a key element of pre-mRNA splicing. Although it is known to involve specific recognition of short consensus sequences by the splicing machinery, the mechanisms by which 5′ splice sites are accurately identified remain controversial and incompletely resolved. The human F7 gene contains in its seventh intron (IVS7) a 37-bp VNTR minisatellite whose first element spans the exon7–IVS7 boundary. As a consequence, the IVS7 authentic donor splice site is followed by several cryptic splice sites identical in sequence, referred to as 5′ pseudo-sites, which normally remain silent. This region, therefore, provides a remarkable model to decipher the mechanism underlying 5′ splice site selection in mammals. We previously suggested a model for splice site selection that, in the presence of consecutive splice consensus sequences, would stimulate exclusively the selection of the most upstream 5′ splice site, rather than repressing the 3′ following pseudo-sites. In the present study, we provide experimental support to this hypothesis by using a mutational approach involving a panel of 50 mutant and wild-type F7 constructs expressed in various cell types. We demonstrate that the F7 IVS7 5′ pseudo-sites are functional, but do not compete with the authentic donor splice site. Moreover, we show that the selection of the 5′ splice site follows a scanning-type mechanism, precluding competition with other functional 5′ pseudo-sites available on immediate sequence context downstream of the activated one. In addition, 5′ pseudo-sites with an increased complementarity to U1snRNA up to 91% do not compete with the identified scanning mechanism. Altogether, these findings, which unveil a cell type–independent 5′−3′-oriented scanning process for accurate recognition of the authentic 5′ splice site, reconciliate apparently contradictory observations by establishing a hierarchy of competitiveness among the determinants involved in 5′ splice site selection.     

Mutational analysis of the U12-dependent branch site consensus sequence

Highly conserved sequences at the 5′ splice site and branch site of U12-dependent introns are important determinants for splicing by U12-dependent spliceosomes. This study investigates the in vivo splicing phenotypes of mutations in the branch site consensus sequence of the U12-dependent intron F from a human NOL1 (P120) minigene. Intron F contains a fully consensus branch site sequence (UUCCUUAAC). Mutations at each position were analyzed for their effects on U12-dependent splicing in vivo. Mutations at most positions resulted in a significant reduction of correct U12-dependent splicing. Defects observed included increased unspliced RNA levels, the activation of cryptic U2-dependent 5′ and 3′ splice sites, and the activation of cryptic U12-dependent branch/3′ splice sites. A strong correlation was observed between the predicted thermodynamic stability of the branch site: U12 snRNA interaction and correct U12-dependent splicing. The lack of a polypyrimidine tract between the branch site and 3′ splice site of U12-dependent introns and the observed reliance on base-pairing interactions for correct U12-dependent splicing emphasize the importance of RNA/RNA interactions during U12-dependent intron recognition and proper splice site selection.