Governing stem cell research in California and the USA: towards a social infrastructure

Owing to the restrictive human embryonic stem cell (hESC) policies of the US government, the question of whether to pursue human embryonic stem cell experiments has dominated the ethical and political discourse concerning such research. Explicit attention must now turn to problems of implementing the research on a large scale: in the 2004 US elections, California voters approved a state initiative for stem cell research, earmarking $3 billion in direct spending over 10 years. This article explores three ethical and political problem areas emerging out of the California program, the resolution of which will help set the trajectory of hESC research in the US and abroad, and then proposes an institutional approach to help address them: a network of public stem cell banks in the US that feature transparent and shared governance.     

Role of the embryology laboratory in the human embryonic stem cell line derivation process

With the introduction of regenerative medicine and cell therapy programmes by means of human embryonic stem cells (hESC), several research centres have begun projects of derivation of hESC lines. In some stem cell banks, such as the Andalusian Stem Cell Bank, the law also permits the creation of these cell lines. Therefore, the recovery of cryopreserved embryos, their culture and the subsequent derivation to hESC lines requires a suitable embryology laboratory and specialized and highly qualified staff. Moreover, new techniques, from therapeutic nuclear transfer, need this type of laboratory and staff, too. Several International Associations have drawn up some guidelines for laboratories where embryos are manipulated and they reflect the physical space, the staff and the equipment needed in these kinds of laboratories. Nevertheless, we can see that these guidelines do not distinguish between IVF laboratories and other laboratories that obtain hESC lines, so it would be convenient to make a distinction. Following these guidelines, we have tried to draw up concurrent aspects applicable to areas of embryology within stem cell banks. So, the design and the specific implementation programmes for these areas and other research centres with this area but which do not use IVF techniques is vital to develop embryonic cell lines in optimum conditions for future therapeutic applications, although maybe it is rather premature to standardize this type of research.     

A high-resolution molecular-based panel of assays for identification and characterization of human embryonic stem cell lines

Meticulous characterization of human embryonic stem cells (hESC) is critical to their eventual use in cell-based therapies, particularly in view of the diverse methods for derivation and maintenance of these cell lines. However, characterization methods are generally not standardized and many currently used assays are subjective, making dependable and direct comparison of cell lines difficult. In order to address this problem, we selected 10 molecular-based high-resolution assays as components of a panel for characterization of hESC. The selection of the assays was primarily based on their quantitative or objective (rather than subjective) nature. We demonstrate the efficacy of this panel by characterizing 4 hESC lines, derived in two different laboratories using different derivation techniques, as pathogen free, genetically stable, and able to differentiate into derivatives of all three germ layers. Our panel expands and refines a characterization panel previously proposed by the International Stem Cell Initiative and is another step toward standardized hESC characterization and quality control, a crucial element of successful hESC research and clinical translation.     

Governing stem cell banks and registries: Emerging Issues

The expansion of national and international research efforts in stem cell research is increasingly paired with the trend of establishing stem cell banks and registries. In jurisdictions crossing the spectrum of restrictive to liberal stem cell policies, banks and registries are emerging as an essential resource for transnational access to quality-controlled and ethically sourced stem cell lines. In this study, we report the preliminary findings of a survey of stem cell banks participating in the International Stem Cell Forum's International Stem Cell Banking Initiative (ISCBI). The questionnaire circulated to all ISCBI members addressed both general issues surrounding research policies (e.g., national policies regulating the permissibility of conducting embryonic stem cell research (hESCR)) and, more specifically, issues relating to the governance of stem cell banking projects. The results of the questionnaire were complemented by scholarly research conducted by the authors. This article provides an overview of the current international hESC banking landscape (I). For this purpose, the policy and governance approaches adopted in the surveyed stem cell banks at the national level will be analyzed and areas of convergence and variance will be identified (II). It is beyond the scope of this paper to provide a comprehensive analysis of the wide range of possible governance approaches, policy responses, and their implications. However, we want to provide a starting point for discussion surrounding key questions and challenges as concerns provenance, access, and deposit of hESC lines (III). Finally, while our analysis is focused on research grade hESCs, the lessons to be gleaned from this examination will encourage further thought, analysis, and research into the issues raised in the banking and governance of other sources of stem cell lines (e.g., SCNT, parthenogenesis, iPs) (IV).     

Derivation and characterization of three new human embryonic stem cell lines in Finland

Human embryonic stem cell (hESC) lines can be established from the preimplantation embryos. Due to their ability to differentiate into all three embryonic layers, hESC are of significant interest as a renewable source of cell material for different applications, especially for cell replacement therapy. Since the establishment of the first hESC lines in 1998, several studies have described the derivation and culture of new hESC lines using various derivation methods and culture conditions. Our group has currently established eight new hESC lines of which three of the latest ones are described in a more detailed way in this report. The described lines have been established using mechanical derivation methods for surplus bad quality embryos and culture conditions containing human foreskin fibroblast feeder cells and serum-free culture medium. All the new lines have a normal karyotype and typical hESC characteristics analyzed in vitro. The described hESC lines are available for research purposes upon request (www.regea.fi).     

Derivation of human embryonic stem cell lines

Human embryonic stem cells (hESC) are undifferentiated cells derived from an early embryo that can grow in vitro indefinitely, while retaining their capability to differentiate into specialized somatic cell types. Over the last decade there has been great interest in derivation and culture of these cells, as they can potentially provide a supply of readily available differentiated cells and tissues of all types to be used for therapeutic purposes in cell transplantation in humans, as well as for other medical uses such as drug discovery. The source of hESC lines is usually excess human embryos from in vitro fertilization treatments, although novel ways of producing hESCs have been suggested recently. The actual methods of hESC derivation have not changed greatly since the first report by Thomson et al. in 1998 . However, the main emphasis over the last several years has been in finding defined conditions for derivation and culture of hESCs, because to enable the clinical use of hESC for cell transplantation, the use of animal derived biological components is no longer acceptable. For basic research, the aim is to replace even human derived materials with completely defined systems. In this paper we describe methods utilized in our laboratory for hESC derivation and describe two studies conducted in an attempt to improve derivation efficiency and to enable research outcomes to be achieved using fewer embryos.     

Human embryonic stem cell registries: value, challenges and opportunities

The accelerating pace of human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research has created an urgent need for the development of hESC registries, information repositories intended to gather, organize and disseminate hESC information. Although of enormous value to this evolving field, registries face significant challenges to their development. These challenges include addressing the legal and ethical issues surrounding hESC derivation as well as complex intellectual property concerns. In addition to these issues, registries must develop tools to efficiently gather, validate and present many different types of hESC information from a variety of sources. Given the pace and regulatory complexities of this field, it is important that registries develop cooperative mechanisms to avoid duplication and more efficiently support hESC research.     

Gene expression profiles of human inner cell mass cells and embryonic stem cells

Human embryonic stem cell (hESC) lines are derived from the inner cell mass (ICM) of preimplantation human blastocysts obtained on days 5–6 following fertilization. Based on their derivation, they were once thought to be the equivalent of the ICM. Recently, however, studies in mice reported the derivation of mouse embryonic stem cell lines from the epiblast; these epiblast lines bear significant resemblance to human embryonic stem cell lines in terms of culture, differentiation potential and gene expression. In this study, we compared gene expression in human ICM cells isolated from the blastocyst and embryonic stem cells. We demonstrate that expression profiles of ICM clusters from single embryos and hESC populations were highly reproducible. Moreover, comparison of global gene expression between individual ICM clusters and human embryonic stem cells indicated that these two cell types are significantly different in regards to gene expression, with fewer than one half of all genes expressed in both cell types. Genes of the isolated human inner cell mass that are upregulated and downregulated are involved in numerous cellular pathways and processes; a subset of these genes may impart unique characteristics to hESCs such as proliferative and self-renewal properties.     

No relationship between embryo morphology and successful derivation of human embryonic stem cell lines

Background

The large number (30) of permanent human embryonic stem cell (hESC) lines and additional 29 which did not continue growing, in our laboratory at Karolinska Institutet have given us a possibility to analyse the relationship between embryo morphology and the success of derivation of hESC lines. The derivation method has been improved during the period 2002–2009, towards fewer xeno-components. Embryo quality is important as regards the likelihood of pregnancy, but there is little information regarding likelihood of stem cell derivation.

Methods

We evaluated the relationship of pronuclear zygote stage, the score based on embryo morphology and developmental rate at cleavage state, and the morphology of the blastocyst at the time of donation to stem cell research, to see how they correlated to successful establishment of new hESC lines.

Results

Derivation of hESC lines succeeded from poor quality and good quality embryos in the same extent. In several blastocysts, no real inner cell mass (ICM) was seen, but permanent well growing hESC lines could be established. One tripronuclear (3PN) zygote, which developed to blastocyst stage, gave origin to a karyotypically normal hESC line.

Conclusion

Even very poor quality embryos with few cells in the ICM can give origin to hESC lines.     

The prospect of pluripotent stem cell-based therapy

Human embryonic stem cells (hESC) are able to maintain pluripotency in culture, to proliferate indefinitely and to differentiate into all somatic cell types. Due to these unique properties, hESC may become an exceptional source of tissues for transplantation and have a great potential for the therapy of incurable diseases. Here, we review new developments in the area of embryonic stem cells and discuss major challenges — standardization of protocols for cell derivation and cultivation, identification of specific molecular markers, development of new approaches for directed differentiation, etc. — which remain to be settled, prior to safe and successful clinical application of stem cells. We appraise several potential approaches in hESC-based therapy including derivation of autologous cells via therapeutic cloning (1), generation of immune tolerance to allogenic donor cells via hematopoetic chimerism (2), and development of the banks of hESC lines compatible with the main antigens and exhibiting equivalent pluripotency (3). In addition, we discuss briefly induced pluripotent cells, which are derived via genetic modification of autologous somatic cells and are analogous to ESC. Our analysis demonstrates that uncontrollable differentiation in vivo and teratogenic potential of hESC are critical limitations of their application in clinical practice. Therefore, the major approach in hESC therapy is derivation of a specific differentiated progeny, which has lower proliferative potential and immune privilege, yet poses fewer risks for organism. The review demonstrates that cell therapy is far more complex and resource-consuming process as compared with drug-based medicine and consequently pluripotent stem cell biology and technology still requires further investigation and development before these cells can be used in clinical practice.     

Derivation of human embryonic stem cells at the Center of Regenerative Medicine in Barcelona

We report here the legislative issues related to embryo research and human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research in Spain and the derivation of nine hESC lines at the Center of Regenerative Medicine in Barcelona. You can find the information for obtaining our lines for research purposes at blc@cmrb.eu.     

Xeno-free derivation and culture of human embryonic stem cells： current status, problems and challenges

Human embryonic stem cells （hESC） not only hold great promise for the treatment of degenerative diseases but also provide a valuable tool for developmental studies. However, the clinical applications of hESC are at present limited by xeno-contamination during the in vitro derivation and propagation of these cells. In this review, we summarize the current methodologies for the derivation and the propagation of hESC in conditions that will eventually enable the generation of clinical-grade cells for future therapeutic applications.     

High-efficiency derivation of human embryonic stem cell lines following pre-implantation genetic diagnosis

Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis allows the characterisation of embryos that carry a gene responsible for a severe monogenic disease and to transfer to the mother’s uterus only the unaffected one(s). The genetically affected embryos can be used to establish human embryonic stem cell (hESC) lines. We are currently establishing a cell bank of ESC lines carrying specific disease-causing mutant genes. These cell lines are available to the scientific community. For this purpose, we have designed a technique that requires only minimal manipulation of the embryos. At the blastocyst stage, we just removed the zona pellucida before seeding the embryo as a whole on a layer of feeder cells. This approach gave a good success rate (>20%), whatever the quality of the embryos, and allowed us to derive 11 new hESC lines, representing seven different pathologies. Full phenotypic validation of the cell lines according to ISCI guidelines confirmed their pluripotent nature, as they were positive for hESC markers and able to differentiate in vitro in all three germ layers derivatives. Nine out of 11 stem cell lines had normal karyotypes. Our results indicate that inner cell mass isolation is not mandatory for hESC derivation and that minimal manipulation of embryos can lead to high success rate.     

Generation of new human embryonic stem cell lines with diploid and triploid karyotypes

Human pluripotent embryonic stem cells (hESC) have great promise for research into human developmental biology and the development of cell therapies for the treatment of diseases. To meet the increased demand for characterized hESC lines, we present the derivation and characterization of five hESC lines on mouse embryonic fibroblast cells. Our stem cell lines are characterized by morphology, long-term expansion, and expression profiles of a number of specific markers, including TRA-1-60, TRA-1-81, alkaline phosphatase, connexin 43, OCT-4, NANOG, CXCR4, NODAL, LEFTY2, THY-1, TDGF1, PAX6, FOXD3, SOX2, EPHA2, FGF4, TAL1, AC133 and REX-1. The pluripotency of the cell line was confirmed by spontaneous differentiation under in vitro conditions. Whereas all of the cell lines expressed all the characteristics of undifferentiated pluripotent hESC, two of the cell lines carried a triploid karyotype.     

Derivation and characterization of human embryonic stem cell lines from the Chinese population

Human embryonic stem cells(hESCs) can self-renew indefinitely and differentiate into all cell types in the human body.Therefore,they are valuable in regenerative medicine,human developmental biology and drug discovery.A number of hESC lines have been derived from the Chinese population, but limited of them are available for research purposes.Here we report the derivation and characterization of two hESC lines derived from human blastocysts of Chinese origin.These hESCs express alkaline phosphatase and hE...     

Derivation of new human embryonic stem cell lines from preimplantation genetic screening and diagnosis-analyzed embryos

In this study, we focused on the derivation of human embryonic stem cell (hESC) from preimplantation genetic screening (PGS)-analyzed and preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD)-analyzed embryos. Out of 62 fresh PGD/PGS-analyzed embryos, 22 embryos reached the blastocyst stage. From 12 outgrowth blastocysts, we derived four hESC lines onto a feeder layer. Surprisingly, karyotype analysis showed that hESC lines derived from aneuploid embryos had diploid female karyotype. One hESC line was found to carry a balanced Robertsonian translocation. All the cell lines showed hESC markers and had the pluripotent ability to differentiate into derivatives of the three embryonic germ layers. The established lines had clonal propagation with 22–31% efficiency in the presence of ROCK inhibitor. These results further indicate that hESC lines can be derived from PGD/PGS-analyzed embryos that are destined to be discarded and can serve as an alternative source for normal euploid lines.     

Variations in humanized and defined culture conditions supporting derivation of new human embryonic stem cell lines

The evolution of "humanized" (i.e., free of animal sourced reagents) and ultimately chemically defined culture systems for human embryo stem cell (hESC) isolation and culture is of importance to improving their efficacy and safety in research and therapeutic applications. This can be achieved by integration of a multitude of individual approaches to replace or eliminate specific animal sourced reagents into a single comprehensive protocol. In the present study our objective was to integrate strategies obviating reliance on some of the most poorly defined and path-critical factors associated with hESC derivation, namely the use of animal immune compliment to isolate embryo inner cell mass, and animal sourced serum products and feeder cells to sustain hESC growth and attachment. As a result we report the derivation of six new hESC lines isolated by outgrowth from whole blastocysts on an extracellular matrix substrate of purified human laminin (Ln) with transitional reliance on mitotically inactivated human fibroblast (HDF) feeder cells. With this integrated system hESC lines were isolated using either HDF conditioned medium supplemented with a bovine-sourced serum replacement (bSRM), or a defined serum-free medium (SFM) containing only human sourced and recombinant protein. Further, outgrowth of embryonic cells from whole blastocysts in both media could be achieved for up to 1 week without reliance on feeder cells. All variant conditions sustained undifferentiated cell status, a stable karyotype and the potential to form cells representative of all three germinal lineages in vitro and in vivo, when transitioned off of feeders onto Laminin or Matrigel. Our study thus demonstrates the capacity to integrate derivation strategies eliminating a requirement for animal immune compliment and serum products, with a transitional requirement for human feeder cells. This represents another sequential step in the generation of therapeutic grade stem cells with reduced risk of zoonotic pathogen transmission.     

Human embryonic stem cells: A journey beyond cell replacement therapies

Success in the derivation of human embryonic stem cell (hESC) lines has opened up a new area of research in biomedicine. Human ESC not only raise hope for cell replacement therapies but also provide a potential novel system to better understand early human normal development, model human abnormal development and disease, and perform drug-screening and toxicity studies. The realization of these potentials, however, depends on expanding our knowledge about the cellular and molecular mechanisms that regulate self-renewal and lineage specification. Here, we briefly highlight the potential applications of hESC and review how flow cytometry has contributed to the initial characterization of both undifferentiated hESC cultures and hematopoietic development arising from hESC. We envision that a combination of state-of-the-art technologies, including cytomics, proteomics and genomics, will be instrumental in moving the field forward, ultimately lending invaluable knowledge to research areas such as human embryology, oncology and immunology.