Dynamin at the Neck of Caveolae Mediates Their Budding to Form Transport Vesicles by GTP-driven Fission from the Plasma Membrane of Endothelium

The molecular mechanisms mediating cell surface trafficking of caveolae are unknown. Caveolae bud from plasma membranes to form free carrier vesicles through a “pinching off” or fission process requiring cytosol and driven by GTP hydrolysis (Schnitzer, J.E., P. Oh, and D.P. McIntosh. 1996. Science. 274:239–242). Here, we use several independent techniques and functional assays ranging from cell-free to intact cell systems to establish a function for dynamin in the formation of transport vesicles from the endothelial cell plasma membrane by mediating fission at the neck of caveolae. This caveolar fission requires interaction with cytosolic dynamin as well as its hydrolysis of GTP. Expression of dynamin in cytosol as well as purified recombinant dynamin alone supports GTP-induced caveolar fission in a cell-free assay whereas its removal from cytosol or the addition to the cytosol of specific antibodies for dynamin inhibits this fission. Overexpression of mutant dynamin lacking normal GTPase activity not only inhibits GTP-induced fission and budding of caveolae but also prevents caveolae-mediated internalization of cholera toxin B chain in intact and permeabilized endothelial cells. Analysis of endothelium in vivo by subcellular fractionation and immunomicroscopy shows that dynamin is concentrated on caveolae, primarily at the expected site of action, their necks. Thus, through its ability to oligomerize, dynamin appears to form a structural collar around the neck of caveolae that hydrolyzes GTP to mediate internalization via the fission of caveolae from the plasma membrane to form free transport vesicles.     

Membrane fission by dynamin: what we know and what we need to know

The large GTPase dynamin is the first protein shown to catalyze membrane fission. Dynamin and its related proteins are essential to many cell functions, from endocytosis to organelle division and fusion, and it plays a critical role in many physiological functions such as synaptic transmission and muscle contraction. Research of the past three decades has focused on understanding how dynamin works. In this review, we present the basis for an emerging consensus on how dynamin functions. Three properties of dynamin are strongly supported by experimental data: first, dynamin oligomerizes into a helical polymer; second, dynamin oligomer constricts in the presence of GTP; and third, dynamin catalyzes membrane fission upon GTP hydrolysis. We present the two current models for fission, essentially diverging in how GTP energy is spent. We further discuss how future research might solve the remaining open questions presently under discussion.     

Perturbation of the vesicle cycle in reticulospinal synapses of lamprey after presynaptic microinjections of GTPγS

The synaptic vesicle cycle sustains neurotransmission and keeps exo- and endocytosis in synapses in dynamic equilibrium. GTP-binding proteins function as key regulators of this cycle. The large GTPase dynamin is implicated in the fission of clathrin-coated vesicles from presynaptic membrane during endocytosis. The present study addresses the effect of the nonhydrolysable GTP analog GTPγS on assembly of the dynamin fission complex in situ. Intraaxonal microinjections of GTPγS induced the following distinct ultrastructural changes in the synapses: the number of synaptic vesicles in a cluster decreased while the number of the docked vesicles at the active zone increased; at the same time, the clathrin-coated intermediates also increased in number, indicating the inhibition of synaptic vesicle recycling. Unusual clathrin-coated intermediates were found. At low concentrations of GTPγS, they were presented by long tubules wreathed with a dynamin helix (spiral) and topped with a clathrin-coated vesicle. At high concentrations of GTPγS the tubular structures were much shorter and branched, with each branch topped with a clathrin-coated vesicle. The spiral pitch and the tubule diameter were significantly reduced as the concentration of GTPγS built up (23.1 ± 0.4 and 26.6 ± 0.4 nm, respectively, at low and 19.0 ± 0.5 and 23.3 ± 0.4 nm at high concentration of GTPγS, p < 0.001). We suggest that these ultrastructural changes reflect different steps in dynamin-mediated fission of clathrin-coated vesicles and propose a model for this process. The model implies that at first, GTP hydrolysis leads to a fast elongation of the helix due to a straightening of its dynamin dimmers. This entails an increase both in a pitch and a diameter of the dynamin helix. The shift in diameter disrupts local hydrophobic interactions between the inner and the outer lipid layers of the membrane at the sites of dynamin binding. Concurrent stretching of the helix and the clathrin-coated vesicle’s neck disintegrates the neck membrane and results finally in a release of the clathrincoated vesicle.     

Nucleotide-dependent conformational changes in dynamin: evidence for a mechanochemical molecular spring

The GTPase dynamin plays an essential part in endocytosis by catalysing the fission of nascent clathrin-coated vesicles from the plasma membrane. Using preformed phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate-containing lipid nanotubes as a membrane template for dynamin self-assembly, we investigate the conformational changes that arise during GTP hydrolysis by dynamin. Electron microscopy reveals that, in the GTP-bound state, dynamin rings appear to be tightly packed together. After GTP hydrolysis, the spacing between rings increases nearly twofold. When bound to the nanotubes, dynamin's GTPase activity is cooperative and is increased by three orders of magnitude compared with the activity of unbound dynamin. An increase in the Kcat (but not the K(m) of GTP hydrolysis accounts for the pronounced cooperativity. These data indicate that a novel, lengthwise ('spring-like') conformational change in a dynamin helix may participate in vesicle fission.     

Domain structure and intramolecular regulation of dynamin GTPase.

Dynamin is a 100 kDa GTPase required for receptor-mediated endocytosis, functioning as the key regulator of the late stages of clathrin-coated vesicle budding. It is specifically targeted to clathrin-coated pits where it self-assembles into 'collars' required for detachment of coated vesicles from the plasma membrane. Self-assembly stimulates dynamin GTPase activity. Thus, dynamin-dynamin interactions are critical in regulating its cellular function. We show by crosslinking and analytical ultracentrifugation that dynamin is a tetramer. Using limited proteolysis, we have defined structural domains of dynamin and evaluated the domain interactions and requirements for self-assembly and GTP binding and hydrolysis. We show that dynamin's C-terminal proline- and arginine-rich domain (PRD) and dynamin's pleckstrin homology (PH) domain are, respectively, positive and negative regulators of self-assembly and GTP hydrolysis. Importantly, we have discovered that the alpha-helical domain interposed between the PH domain and the PRD interacts with the N-terminal GTPase domain to stimulate GTP hydrolysis. We term this region the GTPase effector domain (GED) of dynamin.     

Deformation of dynamin helices damped by membrane friction

Dynamin and other proteins of the dynamin superfamily are widely used by cells to sever lipid bilayers. During this process, a short helical dynamin polymer (one to three helical turns) assembles around a membrane tubule and reduces its radius and pitch upon guanosine triphosphate hydrolysis. This deformation is thought to be crucial for dynamin's severing action and results in an observable twisting of the helix. Here, we quantitatively characterize the dynamics of this deformation by studying long dynamin helices (many helical turns). We perform in vitro experiments where we attach small beads to the dynamin helix and track their rotation in real time, thus collecting information about the space and time dependence of the deformation. We develop a theoretical formalism to predict the dynamics of a mechanically continuous helix deforming on long timescales. Longer helices deform more slowly, as predicted by theory. This could account for the previously reported observation that they are less fission-competent. Comparison between experiments and our model indicates that the deformation dynamics is dominated by the draining of the membrane out of the helix, allowing quantification of helix-membrane interactions.     

Regulation of dynamin family proteins by post-translational modifications

Dynamin superfamily proteins comprising classical dynamins and related proteins are membrane remodelling agents involved in several biological processes such as endocytosis, maintenance of organelle morphology and viral resistance. These large GTPases couple GTP hydrolysis with membrane alterations such as fission, fusion or tubulation by undergoing repeated cycles of self-assembly/disassembly. The functions of these proteins are regulated by various post-translational modifications that affect their GTPase activity, multimerization or membrane association. Recently, several reports have demonstrated variety of such modifications providing a better understanding of the mechanisms by which dynamin proteins influence cellular responses to physiological and environmental cues. In this review, we discuss major post-translational modifications along with their roles in the mechanism of dynamin functions and implications in various cellular processes.     

Rapid constriction of lipid bilayers by the mechanochemical enzyme dynamin

Dynamin, a large GTPase, is located at the necks of clathrin-coated pits where it facilitates the release of coated vesicles from the plasma membrane upon GTP binding, and hydrolysis. Previously, we have shown by negative stain electron microscopy that wild-type dynamin and a dynamin mutant lacking the C-terminal proline-rich domain, DeltaPRD, form protein-lipid tubes that constrict and vesiculate upon addition of GTP. Here, we show by time-resolved cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) that DeltaPRD dynamin in the presence of GTP rapidly constricts the underlying lipid bilayer, and then gradually disassembles from the lipid. In agreement with the negative stain results, the dynamin tubes constrict from 50 to 40 nm, and their helical pitch decreases from approximately 13 to 9.4 nm. However, in contrast to the previous results, examination by cryo-EM shows that the lipid bilayer remains intact and small vesicles or fragments do not form upon GTP binding and hydrolysis. Therefore, the vesicle formation seen by negative stain may be due to the lack of mobility of the dynamin tubes on the grid during the GTP-induced conformational changes. Our results confirm that dynamin is a mechanochemical enzyme and suggest that during endocytosis dynamin is directly responsible for membrane constriction. In the cell, other proteins may enhance the activity of dynamin or the constraints induced by the surrounding coated pit and plasma membrane during constriction may cause the final membrane fission event.     

Dynamin and the actin cytoskeleton cooperatively regulate plasma membrane invagination by BAR and F-BAR proteins

Cell membranes undergo continuous curvature changes as a result of membrane trafficking and cell motility. Deformations are achieved both by forces extrinsic to the membrane as well as by structural modifications in the bilayer or at the bilayer surface that favor the acquisition of curvature. We report here that a family of proteins previously implicated in the regulation of the actin cytoskeleton also have powerful lipid bilayer-deforming properties via an N-terminal module (F-BAR) similar to the BAR domain. Several such proteins, like a subset of BAR domain proteins, bind to dynamin, a GTPase implicated in endocytosis and actin dynamics, via SH3 domains. The ability of BAR and F-BAR domain proteins to induce tubular invaginations of the plasma membrane is enhanced by disruption of the actin cytoskeleton and is antagonized by dynamin. These results suggest a close interplay between the mechanisms that control actin dynamics and those that mediate plasma membrane invagination and fission.     

Dynamin-Catalyzed Membrane Fission Requires Coordinated GTP Hydrolysis

Dynamin is the most-studied membrane fission machinery and has served as a paradigm for studies of other fission GTPases; however, several critical questions regarding its function remain unresolved. In particular, because most dynamin GTPase domain mutants studied to date equally impair both basal and assembly-stimulated GTPase activities, it has been difficult to distinguish their respective roles in clathrin-mediated endocytosis (CME) or in dynamin catalyzed membrane fission. Here we compared a new dynamin mutant, Q40E, which is selectively impaired in assembly-stimulated GTPase activity with S45N, a GTP-binding mutant equally defective in both basal and assembly-stimulated GTPase activities. Both mutants potently inhibit CME and effectively recruit other endocytic accessory proteins to stalled coated pits. However, the Q40E mutant blocks at a later step than S45N, providing additional evidence that GTP binding and/or basal GTPase activities of dynamin are required throughout clathrin coated pit maturation. Importantly, using in vitro assays for assembly-stimulated GTPase activity and membrane fission, we find that the latter is much more potently inhibited by both dominant-negative mutants than the former. These studies establish that efficient fission from supported bilayers with excess membrane reservoir (SUPER) templates requires coordinated GTP hydrolysis across two rungs of an assembled dynamin collar.     

An Intramolecular Signaling Element that Modulates Dynamin Function In Vitro and In Vivo

Dynamin exhibits a high basal rate of GTP hydrolysis that is enhanced by self-assembly on a lipid template. Dynamin''s GTPase effector domain (GED) is required for this stimulation, though its mechanism of action is poorly understood. Recent structural work has suggested that GED may physically dock with the GTPase domain to exert its stimulatory effects. To examine how these interactions activate dynamin, we engineered a minimal GTPase-GED fusion protein (GG) that reconstitutes dynamin''s basal GTPase activity and utilized it to define the structural framework that mediates GED''s association with the GTPase domain. Chemical cross-linking of GG and mutagenesis of full-length dynamin establishes that the GTPase-GED interface is comprised of the N- and C-terminal helices of the GTPase domain and the C-terminus of GED. We further show that this interface is essential for structural stability in full-length dynamin. Finally, we identify mutations in this interface that disrupt assembly-stimulated GTP hydrolysis and dynamin-catalyzed membrane fission in vitro and impair the late stages of clathrin-mediated endocytosis in vivo. These data suggest that the components of the GTPase-GED interface act as an intramolecular signaling module, which we term the bundle signaling element, that can modulate dynamin function in vitro and in vivo.     

Dynamin GTPase regulation is altered by PH domain mutations found in centronuclear myopathy patients

The large GTPase dynamin has an important membrane scission function in receptor‐mediated endocytosis and other cellular processes. Self‐assembly on phosphoinositide‐containing membranes stimulates dynamin GTPase activity, which is crucial for its function. Although the pleckstrin‐homology (PH) domain is known to mediate phosphoinositide binding by dynamin, it remains unclear how this promotes activation. Here, we describe studies of dynamin PH domain mutations found in centronuclear myopathy (CNM) that increase dynamin's GTPase activity without altering phosphoinositide binding. CNM mutations in the PH domain C‐terminal α‐helix appear to cause conformational changes in dynamin that alter control of the GTP hydrolysis cycle. These mutations either ‘sensitize’ dynamin to lipid stimulation or elevate basal GTPase rates by promoting self‐assembly and thus rendering dynamin no longer lipid responsive. We also describe a low‐resolution structure of dimeric dynamin from small‐angle X‐ray scattering that reveals conformational changes induced by CNM mutations, and defines requirements for domain rearrangement upon dynamin self‐assembly at membrane surfaces. Our data suggest that changes in the PH domain may couple lipid binding to dynamin GTPase activation at sites of vesicle invagination.     

“Gearing” up for dynamin-catalyzed membrane fission

Endocytic dynamins self-assemble into helical scaffolds and utilize energy from GTP hydrolysis to constrict and sever tubular membranous necks of budded endocytic intermediates. They bind the membrane using a pleckstrin-homology domain (PHD). The PHD is characterized by four unstructured loops, two of which partially insert into the membrane. Recent studies reveal that loop insertion lowers the bending rigidity of the membrane and that mutations in these two loops produce separable and opposite effects on the efficiency of dynamin-catalyzed membrane fission. Here, we review the current understanding of dynamin-catalyzed membrane fission and attempt to reconcile contrasting notions that have emerged from biochemical and cellular studies evaluating the role of the PHD in this process. We propose that two membrane-inserting loops act as “gears” that define the catalytic efficiency of the dynamin helical scaffold in membrane fission.     

Induction of mutant dynamin specifically blocks endocytic coated vesicle formation

Dynamin is the mammalian homologue to the Drosophila shibire gene product. Mutations in this 100-kD GTPase cause a pleiotropic defect in endocytosis. To further investigate its role, we generated stable HeLa cell lines expressing either wild-type dynamin or a mutant defective in GTP binding and hydrolysis driven by a tightly controlled, tetracycline- inducible promoter. Overexpression of wild-type dynamin had no effect. In contrast, coated pits failed to become constricted and coated vesicles failed to bud in cells overexpressing mutant dynamin so that endocytosis via both transferrin (Tfn) and EGF receptors was potently inhibited. Coated pit assembly, invagination, and the recruitment of receptors into coated pits were unaffected. Other vesicular transport pathways, including Tfn receptor recycling, Tfn receptor biosynthesis, and cathepsin D transport to lysosomes via Golgi-derived coated vesicles, were unaffected. Bulk fluid-phase uptake also continued at the same initial rates as wild type. EM immunolocalization showed that membrane-bound dynamin was specifically associated with clathrin-coated pits on the plasma membrane. Dynamin was also associated with isolated coated vesicles, suggesting that it plays a role in vesicle budding. Like the Drosophila shibire mutant, HeLa cells overexpressing mutant dynamin accumulated long tubules, many of which remained connected to the plasma membrane. We conclude that dynamin is specifically required for endocytic coated vesicle formation, and that its GTP binding and hydrolysis activities are required to form constricted coated pits and, subsequently, for coated vesicle budding.     

A bacterial dynamin-like protein mediating nucleotide-independent membrane fusion

Dynamins are a family of large GTPases that are involved in key cellular processes, where they mediate events of membrane fission and fusion. The dynamin superfamily is not restricted to eukaryotes but might have a bacterial origin, with many species containing an operon of two genes related to mitofusins. However, it is not clear whether bacterial dynamins promote membrane fission or fusion. The dynamin-like protein DynA of Bacillus subtilis is remarkable in that it arose from a gene fusion of two dynamins and contains two separate dynamin-like subunits and GTPase domains. We found that DynA exhibits strictly auto-regulated GTP hydrolysis, and that progress through the GTPase cycle is concerted within DynA oligomers. Furthermore, we show that DynA can tether membranes and mediates nucleotide-independent membrane fusion in vitro. This process merely requires magnesium as a cofactor. Our results provide a set of minimal requirements for membrane fusion by dynamin-like proteins and have mechanistic implications in particular for the fusion of mitochondria.     

Identification and function of conformational dynamics in the multidomain GTPase dynamin

Vesicle release upon endocytosis requires membrane fission, catalyzed by the large GTPase dynamin. Dynamin contains five domains that together orchestrate its mechanochemical activity. Hydrogen–deuterium exchange coupled with mass spectrometry revealed global nucleotide‐ and membrane‐binding‐dependent conformational changes, as well as the existence of an allosteric relay element in the α2^S helix of the dynamin stalk domain. As predicted from structural studies, FRET analyses detect large movements of the pleckstrin homology domain (PHD) from a ‘closed’ conformation docked near the stalk to an ‘open’ conformation able to interact with membranes. We engineered dynamin constructs locked in either the closed or open state by chemical cross‐linking or deletion mutagenesis and showed that PHD movements function as a conformational switch to regulate dynamin self‐assembly, membrane binding, and fission. This PHD conformational switch is impaired by a centronuclear myopathy‐causing disease mutation, S619L, highlighting the physiological significance of its role in regulating dynamin function. Together, these data provide new insight into coordinated conformational changes that regulate dynamin function and couple membrane binding, oligomerization, and GTPase activity during dynamin‐catalyzed membrane fission.     

Real-time detection reveals that effectors couple dynamin's GTP-dependent conformational changes to the membrane

The GTPase dynamin is a mechanochemical enzyme involved in membrane fission, but the molecular nature of its membrane interactions and their regulation by guanine nucleotides and protein effectors remain poorly characterized. Using site-directed fluorescence labeling and several independent fluorescence spectroscopic techniques, we have developed robust assays for the detection and real-time monitoring of dynamin-membrane and dynamin-dynamin interactions. We show that dynamin interacts preferentially with highly curved, PIP2-dense membranes and inserts partially into the lipid bilayer. Our kinetic measurements further reveal that cycles of GTP binding and hydrolysis elicit major conformational rearrangements in self-assembled dynamin that favor dynamin-membrane association and dissociation, respectively. Sorting nexin 9, an abundant dynamin partner, transiently stabilizes dynamin on the membrane at the onset of stimulated GTP hydrolysis and may function to couple dynamin's mechanochemical conformational changes to membrane destabilization. Amphiphysin I has the opposite effect. Thus, dynamin's mechanochemical properties on a membrane surface are dynamically regulated by its GTPase cycle and major binding partners.     

Dynamin2 and cortactin regulate actin assembly and filament organization

The GTPase dynamin is required for endocytic vesicle formation. Dynamin has also been implicated in regulating the actin cytoskeleton, but the mechanism by which it does so is unclear. Through interactions via its proline-rich domain (PRD), dynamin binds several proteins, including cortactin, profilin, syndapin, and murine Abp1, that regulate the actin cytoskeleton. We investigated the interaction of dynamin2 and cortactin in regulating actin assembly in vivo and in vitro. When expressed in cultured cells, a dynamin2 mutant with decreased affinity for GTP decreased actin dynamics within the cortical actin network. Expressed mutants of cortactin that have decreased binding of Arp2/3 complex or dynamin2 also decreased actin dynamics. Dynamin2 influenced actin nucleation by purified Arp2/3 complex and cortactin in vitro in a biphasic manner. Low concentrations of dynamin2 enhanced actin nucleation by Arp2/3 complex and cortactin, and high concentrations were inhibitory. Dynamin2 promoted the association of actin filaments nucleated by Arp2/3 complex and cortactin with phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PIP2)-containing lipid vesicles. GTP hydrolysis altered the organization of the filaments and the lipid vesicles. We conclude that dynamin2, through an interaction with cortactin, regulates actin assembly and actin filament organization at membranes.     

SH3 Domains Differentially Stimulate Distinct Dynamin I Assembly Modes and G Domain Activity

Dynamin I is a highly regulated GTPase enzyme enriched in nerve terminals which mediates vesicle fission during synaptic vesicle endocytosis. One regulatory mechanism involves its interactions with proteins containing Src homology 3 (SH3) domains. At least 30 SH3 domain-containing proteins bind dynamin at its proline-rich domain (PRD). Those that stimulate dynamin activity act by promoting its oligomerisation. We undertook a systematic parallel screening of 13 glutathione-S-transferase (GST)-tagged endocytosis-related SH3 domains on dynamin binding, GTPase activity and oligomerisation. No correlation was found between dynamin binding and their potency to stimulate GTPase activity. There was limited correlation between the extent of their ability to stimulate dynamin activity and the level of oligomerisation, indicating an as yet uncharacterised allosteric coupling of the PRD and G domain. We examined the two variants, dynamin Iab and Ibb, which differ in the alternately splice middle domain α2 helix. They responded differently to the panel of SH3s, with the extent of stimulation between the splice variants varying greatly between the SH3s. This study reveals that SH3 binding can act as a heterotropic allosteric regulator of the G domain via the middle domain α2 helix, suggesting an involvement of this helix in communicating the PRD-mediated allostery. This indicates that SH3 binding both stabilises multiple conformations of the tetrameric building block of dynamin, and promotes assembly of dynamin-SH3 complexes with distinct rates of GTP hydrolysis.     

Cooperative Recruitment of Dynamin and BIN/Amphiphysin/Rvs (BAR) Domain-containing Proteins Leads to GTP-dependent Membrane Scission

Dynamin mediates various membrane fission events, including the scission of clathrin-coated vesicles. Here, we provide direct evidence for cooperative membrane recruitment of dynamin with the BIN/amphiphysin/Rvs (BAR) proteins, endophilin and amphiphysin. Surprisingly, endophilin and amphiphysin recruitment to membranes was also dependent on binding to dynamin due to auto-inhibition of BAR-membrane interactions. Consistent with reciprocal recruitment in vitro, dynamin recruitment to the plasma membrane in cells was strongly reduced by concomitant depletion of endophilin and amphiphysin, and conversely, depletion of dynamin dramatically reduced the recruitment of endophilin. In addition, amphiphysin depletion was observed to severely inhibit clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Furthermore, GTP-dependent membrane scission by dynamin was dramatically elevated by BAR domain proteins. Thus, BAR domain proteins and dynamin act in synergy in membrane recruitment and GTP-dependent vesicle scission.