Prediction of estrogen receptor β ligands potency and selectivity by docking and MM-GBSA scoring methods using three different scaffolds

This study aimed to identify the docking and molecular mechanics-generalized born surface area (MM-GBSA) re-scoring parameters which can correlate the binding affinity and selectivity of the ligands towards oestrogen receptor β (ERβ). Three different series of ERβ ligands were used as dataset and the compounds were docked against ERβ (protein data bank (PDB) ID: 1QKM) using Glide and ArgusLab. Glide docking showed superior results when compared with ArgusLab. Docked poses were then rescored using Prime-MM-GBSA to calculate free energy binding. Correlations were made between observed activities of ERβ ligands with computationally predicted values from docking, binding energy parameters. ERβ ligands experimental binding affinity/selectivity did not correlate well with Glide and ArgusLab score. Whereas calculated Glide energy (coulomb-van der Waal interaction energy) correlated significantly with binding affinity of ERβ ligands (r²?=?0.66). MM-GBSA re-scoring showed correlation of r²?=?0.74 with selectivity of ERβ ligands. These results will aid the discovery of novel ERβ ligands with isoform selectivity.     

7-Substituted 2-phenyl-benzofurans as ER beta selective ligands

A series of 2-(4-hydroxy-phenyl)-benzofuran-5-ols with relatively lipophilic groups in the 7-position of the benzofuran was prepared and the affinity and selectivity for ER beta was measured. Many of the analogues were found to be potent and selective ER beta ligands. Additional modifications at the benzofuran 4-position as well as at the 3'-position of the 2-phenyl group were found to further increase selectivity. Such modifications led to compounds with <10 nM potency and >100-fold selectivity for ER beta.     

Benzothiophenes containing a piperazine side chain as selective ligands for the estrogen receptor alpha and their bioactivities in vivo

The synthesis of benzothiophenes containing a piperazine side chain and their binding affinities for estrogen receptors are described. These compounds bearing piperazine side chains were identified to be high-affinity ligands with high selectivity for ER alpha subtype. They were also potent agonists in bone tissue.     

Identification of ligands with bicyclic scaffolds provides insights into mechanisms of estrogen receptor subtype selectivity

Estrogen receptors alpha (ERalpha) and beta (ERbeta) have distinct functions and differential expression in certain tissues. These differences have stimulated the search for subtype-selective ligands. Therapeutically, such ligands offer the potential to target specific tissues or pathways regulated by one receptor subtype without affecting the other. As reagents, they can be utilized to probe the physiological functions of the ER subtypes to provide information complementary to that obtained from knock-out animals. A fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based assay was used to screen a 10,000-compound chemical library for ER agonists. From the screen, we identified a family of ERbeta-selective agonists whose members contain bulky oxabicyclic scaffolds in place of the planar scaffolds common to most ER ligands. These agonists are 10-50-fold selective for ERbeta in competitive binding assays and up to 60-fold selective in transactivation assays. The weak uterotrophic activity of these ligands in immature rats and their ability to stimulate expression of an ERbeta regulated gene in human U2OS osteosarcoma cells provides more physiological evidence of their ERbeta-selective nature. To provide insight into the molecular mechanisms of their activity and selectivity, we determined the crystal structures of the ERalpha ligand-binding domain (LBD) and a peptide from the glucocorticoid receptor-interacting protein 1 (GRIP1) coactivator complexed with the ligands OBCP-3M, OBCP-2M, and OBCP-1M. These structures illustrate how the bicyclic scaffolds of these ligands are accommodated in the flexible ligand-binding pocket of ER. A comparison of these structures with existing ER structures suggests that the ERbeta selectivity of OBCP ligands can be attributed to a combination of their interactions with Met-336 in ERbeta and Met-421 in ERalpha. These bicyclic ligands show promise as lead compounds that can target ERbeta. In addition, our understanding of the molecular determinants of their subtype selectivity provides a useful starting point for developing other ER modulators belonging to this relatively new structural class.     

Synthesis and receptor binding in trans-CD ring-fused A-CD estrogens: Comparison with the cis-fused isomers

Ligands which selectively activate only one of the estrogen receptors, ERα or ERβ, are current pharmaceutical targets. Previously, we have reported on substituted cis A-CD ligands in which the B-ring of the steroidal structure has been removed and cis refers the stereochemistry of the CD ring junction as compared to trans in estradiol. These compounds often showed good potency and selectivity for ERβ. Here we report the synthesis and binding affinities for a similar series of trans A-CD ligands, and compare them to the cis-series. Counterintuitively, trans A-CD ligands, which are structurally more closely related to the natural ligand estradiol, show weaker binding and less β-selectivity than their cis-counterparts.     

In vitro evaluation of the anti-estrogenic activity of hydroxyl substituted diphenylnaphthyl alkene ligands for the estrogen receptor

There is still a need for additional scaffolds to further explore tissue selectivity and improving efficacy of selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs). A series of hydroxyl substituted diphenylnaphthyl alkene ligands for the two estrogen receptors are described that arose from an initial de novo designed diphenylnaphthyl propylene ligand 1. All compounds gave K(i)s under 10 nM when assayed in the presence of ERalpha. Generally these compounds had very high affinity for both ER isotypes. Moving the hydroxyl group on naphthalene from the 6- to the 5-position of the alpha-naphthalene attached compounds (6b and 6e vs 6c and 6f) had little affect on ER binding nor did altering the position of the naphthalene attachment (alpha or beta) to the alkene moiety. In transfection assays none of the compounds displayed agonistic activity in the absence of E(2). In MCF-7 proliferation assays 6a-d, 6f and 12a-c successfully abrogated E(2) stimulation and resulted in greater than 50% inhibition at 1 microM, a level of efficacy similar to that obtained when the cells were treated with raloxifene. Our results show that this new class of SERMs are good candidates for further study as therapeutic agents for the treatment of breast cancer and osteoporosis.     

Fluorine-substituted corticosteroids: Synthesis and evaluation as potential receptor-based imaging agents for positron emission tomography of the brain

We have prepared eight fluorine-substituted corticosteroids representing ligands selective for Type I and Type II corticosteroid receptor subtypes as potential imaging agents for corticosteroid receptor-containing regions of the brain. Receptor binding affinity assays show that fluorine substitution for hydroxyl or hydrogen in these steroids generally results in some reduction in affinity, with the result that the absolute affinity of these fluorine-substituted ligands for receptor is less than that typical for steroid hormones that show receptor-based, target selective uptake in vivo. Five of these compounds were prepared in fluorine-18 labeled form by a simple sulfonate ester displacement reaction, and their tissue distribution was studied in the adrenalectomized rat. There is no selective accumulation nor selective retention of the Type I selective corticosteroids (¹⁸F-RU 26752, 21-[¹⁸F]fluoroprogesterone, 21-[¹⁸F]fluoro-11β-hydroxyprogesterone) in either the brain, or other target tissues (pituitary, kidney, liver). The Type II selective corticosteroids (¹⁸F-RU 28362, ¹⁸F-triamcinolone acetonide) show uptake into the hippocampus which can be partially blocked by a competing ligand; in target tissues outside the brain, the blocking is more complete. All of the ¹⁸F-labeled compounds show considerable defluorination, evident as high bone activity levels. These results, coupled with earlier findings in the literature, suggest that radiolabeled corticosteroid receptor ligands with both greater metabolic stability and higher receptor binding affinity and selectivity are needed for imaging corticosteroid receptors in the hippocampus.     

雌激素受体亚型及其配体调节基因转录机制的研究

本文综述雌激素受体亚型（ERα和ERβ）的结构,功能,组织分布,生理作用及雌激素受体配体调节基因转录的机制,目的是深入系统地了解植物雌激素和选择性雌激素受体调节剂的作用路径及其组织特异性的发生机制,最终为提高雌激素类药物的选择性,优化以临床为基础的药物设计提供一条较为系统的思路。结果表明,ERα和ERβ对不同雌激素类化合物产生不同应答,配体的结构不同,调节基因转录的路径不同和募集的辅调节蛋白的不同是雌激素受体两种亚型组织特异性激活或抑制的主要原因。     

Receptor-based virtual screening evaluation for the identification of estrogen receptor β ligands

Abstract

In this paper, a receptor-based virtual screening study for the identification of estrogen receptor β (ERβ) ligands was developed. Starting from a commercial database of 400?000 molecules, only six compounds resulted to be potential active ligands of ERβ. Interestingly, all the six molecules possess scaffolds that had already been reported in known ERβ ligands. Therefore, the results obtained herein confirm the reliability of our virtual screening procedure, thus encouraging the application of this protocol to larger commercial databases in order to identify new ERβ ligands.     

Synthesis, pharmacological evaluation, and structure-activity relationships of benzopyran derivatives with potent SERM activity

The synthesis, binding affinity for estrogen receptor subtypes (ER alpha and ER beta) and pharmacological activity on rat uterus of a new class of potent ligands, characterized by a 3-phenylbenzopyran scaffold with a basic side chain in position 4, are reported. Some of these compounds, endowed with very high receptor affinity, showed potent inhibition of agonist-stimulated uterine growth, with no or limited proliferative effect. Binding affinity mostly depended on the nature and position of substituents at the 3-phenyl ring, while the uterine activity seems to be affected by basic chain length. Compound 9c (CHF4227) showed excellent binding affinity and antagonist activity on the uterus. The docking of benzopyran derivatives explained the structure-affinity relationships observed for 3-phenyl substitution: a small, hydrophobic 4'-substituent could interact with a small accessory binding cavity, while di-substitution at 4' and 3' led to some ER alpha selectivity. This selectivity can be ascribed to differences in amino acid composition and side chain conformation in the region accommodating the 3-phenyl ring at human ER alpha and ER beta ligand-binding domain.     

Enhanced estrogen receptor beta (ERβ) selectivity of fluorinated carborane-containing ER modulators

We previously showed that fluorination of the carborane-containing selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM) BE360 altered the agonist/antagonist activity balance and the estrogen receptor (ER) α/β subtype selectivity. Here, we designed and synthesized a series of fluorinated carboranyl phenols as candidate ERβ-selective ligands. Introduction of a fluorine atom onto the carborane cage commonly reduced the binding affinity for ERα, to an extent that depended on the other substituents present. The B-fluorinated m-carboranyl phenol 4a showed fourfold more potent ERβ-binding affinity than the parent non-fluorinated compound 7. 1-Iodo-9-fluoro-m-carboranyl phenol 4f showed high ERβ-binding affinity with an ERβ/ERα selectivity ratio of 8.2. Among the compounds tested, 6 showed the highest ERβ selectivity (10.1-fold) and the highest ER-agonistic activity (EC₅₀: 5.1 × 10^?10 M) in MCF-7 cell proliferation assay.     

Design and synthesis of iodocarborane-containing ligands with high affinity and selectivity toward ERβ

The selectivity and the binding affinity of previously reported carborane-containing ligands 2 and 3 toward ERβ remains to be optimized. To improve their biological profiles, a series of iodinated carboranyl phenol derivatives (4–6) were designed and synthesized as prospective ERβ-selective ligands with high affinity. Several iodinated carboranyl phenols showed high relative binding affinity (RBA) values for both ERs, and especially for ERβ, due to suitable hydrophobic interactions of the iodine atoms with the hydrophobic amino acid residues of the ERβ ligand-binding domains. Among these derivatives, 9,10-diiodo-m-carborane 5f exhibited a more than 100% increase of the RBA values toward ERβ, a 14-fold increased selectivity for ERβ over ERα, and ER-agonistic activity in MCF-7 cell proliferation assays.     

Synthesis and evaluation of aryl-substituted diarylpropionitriles,selective ligands for estrogen receptor β, as positron-emission tomographic imaging agents

We have investigated halogen-substituted non-steroidal estrogens with selective binding affinity for the estrogen receptor β (ERβ that might be used for imaging the levels of this ER-subtype in breast tumors by positron emission tomography (PET). Based on diarylpropionitrile (DPN, 1a), a compound previously reported that has a 72-fold binding selectivity for ERβ, we developed a series of DPN analogs having methyl-, hydroxyl-, and halogen substituents, including fluoroethyl and fluoropropyl groups. In competitive radiometric binding assays with [³H]estradiol, all of these DPN analogs showed high ERβ/ERα selectivity; while the selectivity varied, in some cases it reached nearly 300-fold (RBA: ERα, 0.023%; ERβ, 6.25%). The absolute ERβ binding affinities, however, were not sufficient to merit further consideration for developing these ligands as PET imaging agents.     

ER subtype selectivity of m-carborane-containing phenols: C-alkyl groups on the m-carborane cage enhance ERα selectivity

Estrogen receptor (ER) exhibits two subtypes, ERα and ERβ, whose biological functions are quite different despite expression in the same tissues. We developed diiodo-m-carborane derivative 3a, which showed 14-fold selectivity for ERβ with high binding affinity toward ERβ. Interestingly, introduction of an alkyl group into the carbon atom of the m-carborane cage of 3a markedly enhanced the binding affinity toward ERα and decreased affinity toward ERβ. C-n-propyl derivative 3d showed 28-fold selectivity for ERα in an ER binding assay and promoted proliferation of MCF-7 breast cancer cells. Docking simulation studies suggest that the directions of the n-propyl group and the diiodo substituent introduced on the m-carborane cage play important roles for the control of ER subtype selectivity. As 3a and 3d showed ERβ and ERα selectivity with high binding affinity, respectively, these ligands may be useful as biological tools to aid in understanding the different roles of ER subtypes.     

Molecular basis for the subtype discrimination of the estrogen receptor-beta-selective ligand,diarylpropionitrile

Although the two subtypes of the human estrogen receptor (ER), ERalpha and ERbeta, share only 56% amino acid sequence identity in their ligand binding domain (LBD), the residues that surround the ligand are nearly identical; nevertheless, subtype-selective ligands are known. To understand the molecular basis by which diarylpropionitrile (DPN), an ERbeta-selective ligand, is able to discriminate between the two ERs, we examined its activity on ER mutants and chimeric constructs generated by DNA shuffling. The N-terminal region of the ERbeta LBD (through helix 6) appears to be fully responsible for the ERbeta selectivity of DPN. In fact, a single ERalpha point mutation (L384M) was largely sufficient to switch the DPN response of this ER to that of the ERbeta type, but residues in helix 3 are also important in achieving the full ERbeta selectivity of DPN. Using molecular modeling, we found an energetically favorable fit for the S-DPN enantiomer in ERbeta, in which the proximal phenol mimics the A ring of estradiol, and the nitrile engages in stabilizing interactions with residues in the ligand-binding pocket of ERbeta. Our findings highlight that a limited number of critical interactions of DPN with the ERbeta ligand-binding pocket underlie its ER subtype-selective character.     

Synthesis and evaluation of 4-(substituted styryl/alkenyl)-3,5-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)-isoxazoles as ligands for the estrogen receptor

A series of 3,5-bis (4-hydroxyphenyl) isoxazoles bearing a styryl/alkyl vinyl group at the 4-position were prepared and evaluated as ligands for the estrogen receptor-alpha (ERα). The target compounds were prepared using the Suzuki reaction to couple an iodo-isoxazole intermediate with a series of styryl/alkenyl boronic acids, followed by O-demethylation. The products were evaluated for their estrogen receptor-α ligand binding domain (ERα-LBD) binding affinity using a competitive binding assay. The 4-(4-hydroxystyryl) derivative 4h displays binding properties similar to those of the previously described pyrazole class of ER ligands, indicating that the ERα-LBD tolerates the presence of the added vinyl group at the 4-position of the isoxazole ring.