Flow cytometric detection and quantification of heterotrophic nanoflagellates in enriched seawater and cultures

A flow cytometric protocol to detect and enumerate heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF) in enriched waters is reported. At present, the cytometric protocols that allow accurate quantification of bacterioplankton cannot be used to quantify protozoa for the following reasons: i) the background produced by the bacterial acquisitions does not allow the discrimination of protozoa at low abundance, ii) since the final protozoan fluorescence is much higher than the bacterioplankton fluorescence (more than 35 fold) the protozoa acquisitions lie outside the range. With an increase in the fluorescence threshold and a reduction of the fluorescence detector voltage, low fluorescence particles (bacteria) are beneath the detection limits and only higher fluorescence particles (most of them heterotrophic nanoflagellates) are detected. The main limitation for the application of the cytometric protocol developed is that a ratio of bacteria/HNF below 1000 is needed. At higher ratios, the background of larger cells of bacterioplankton makes it difficult to discriminate protozoa. The proposed protocol has been validated by epifluorescence microscopy analyzing both a mixed community and two single species of HFN: Rhynchomonas nasuta and Jakoba libera. Taking into account the required bacteria/HNF ratio cited above, the results provide evidence that the flow cytometric protocol reported here is valid for counting mixed communities of HNF in enriched seawater and in experimental micro or mesocosms. In the case of single species of HNF previous knowledge of the biological characteristics of the protist and how they can affect the effectiveness of the flow cytometric count is necessary.     

Rapid flow cytometry – Nile red assessment of PHA cellular content and heterogeneity in cultures of Pseudomonas aeruginosa 47T2 (NCIB 40044) grown in waste frying oil

The accumulation of cytoplasmic polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs) and the heterogeneity of bacterial populations were analysed by flow cytometry and SYTO-13 and Nile red staining in rhamnolipid-producing Pseudomonas aeruginosa cultures grown in waste frying oil as carbon source. A combination of SYTO-13 and Nile red fluorescence with cytometric forward and side scatter values may allow increases in the final production of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) by two basic mechanisms: (i) rapid assessment of polyhydroxyalkanoate content and (ii) definition of flow cytometric cell sorting protocols to select high polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA)-producing strains. We report a rapid (less than 30 min) flow cytometric assessment of PHAs in Pseudomonas aeruginosa 47T2 following Nile red staining: (i) to estimate cellular PHAs content; (ii) to study heterogeneity of the batch cultures producing PHAs and (iii) to establish the basis for sorting sub-populations with a high capacity to accumulate PHAs.     

Assessing amino acid uptake by phototrophic nanoflagellates in nonaxenic cultures using flow cytometric sorting

Biologically available concentrations of individual dissolved amino acids in the open ocean are generally <1 nM. Despite this, the microbial turnover of amino acids is usually measured in hours indicating high demand. It is thought that the majority of uptake is due to bacterioplankton, although protists, particularly phototrophic protists, are also expected to take up amino acids. In order to assess the ability of protists to compete with prokaryotes for amino acids at subnanomolar concentrations, we examined the direct uptake of ³H-leucine by phototrophic nanoflagellates (prasinophytes, pelagophytes and trebouxiophytes) and by associated bacteria using flow cytometric cell sorting. In contrast to ³H-leucine-assimilating bacterial copopulations, none of the six studied nanoflagellates showed measurable direct uptake of ³H-leucine, suggesting that the studied phototrophic protists were unable to utilize dissolved ³H-leucine at natural oceanic concentrations. More practically, the flow-sorting technique allowed rapid and unequivocal differentiation of organic nitrogen uptake between prokaryotic cells and eukaryotic cells in mixed microbial populations, reducing the need to establish and maintain axenic algal cultures.     

Effects of Viruses on Nutrient Turnover and Growth Efficiency of Noninfected Marine Bacterioplankton

The effects of virus infection and lysis of a marine Vibrio sp. on C, N, and P turnover and the growth efficiency of noninfected bacterioplankton were studied in a series of dilution cultures. The cultures were enriched with various sources of organic matter and N and P. The growth of the Vibrio host and the growth of the natural bacterioplankton were measured by immunofluorescence and 4(prm1),6-diamidino-2-phenylindole staining methods, respectively. Lysis products resulting from infection of the Vibrio sp. caused an increase in metabolic activity and cell production by the noninfected bacterioplankton. In P-limited cultures, the addition of viruses increased the uptake of dissolved organic carbon by 72% and the potential alkaline phosphatase activity by 89% compared with control cultures without viruses. Our data suggest that input of available phosphorus through virus-induced Vibrio lysates occurred, which caused an increase in the bacterial nutrient uptake. The growth efficiency of noninfected bacteria was reduced in the presence of viruses compared with the control without viruses (growth efficiencies, 0.08 (plusmn) 0.03 and 0.24 (plusmn) 0.02, respectively). We suggest that the decrease in growth efficiency may be explained by an increase in bacterial energy demand associated with extracellular degradation of polymeric organic nitrogen and phosphorus in cell lysates.     

Factors governing the flow cytometric analysis and sorting of large biological particles

We have investigated the suitability of large flow cell tips for the flow cytometric analysis and sorting of large biological particles, including plant cells (pollen) and protoplasts. Using flow tips ranging in diameter from 79-204 micron, we have optimized conditions for the establishment of a stable hydrodynamic flow leading to accurate droplet production. We describe instrument modifications required for large particle sorting and demonstrate the use of these experimental conditions for the sorting to high purity of pollen and viable plant protoplasts possessing diameters as large as 95 micron. Our experiments have revealed a complex interaction among sorting efficiency, particle diameter, flow cell tip diameter and bimorphic crystal drive frequency. This interaction can be satisfactorily explained in terms of interference effects owing to phase differences between the particle-induced disturbance and the undulation driven by the bimorphic crystal.     

Flow cytometric analysis of a marine LAS-degrading consortia

The specific nucleic acid fluorochrome SYTO-13 was used in flow cytometric analysis to assess changes in the density and heterogeneity of marine bacterial populations which biodegrade linear alkylbenzene sulphonate (LAS). Seawater samples with LAS and incubated in the laboratory (20 degrees C, 100 rpm, 30 days) were used to monitor LAS-degrading consortia. Flow cytometric studies and culture methods were used to characterize the LAS degrading bacterioplankton consortia. Fluorescence and scatter signals enabled us to define three regions (R1, R2 and R3) in the dual parameter cytograms. The distribution of the bacterial counts in these regions allowed us to monitor the formation and evolution of the consortia.     

Comparison of phosphate uptake rates by the smallest plastidic and aplastidic protists in the North Atlantic subtropical gyre

The smallest phototrophic protists (<3 μm) are important primary producers in oligotrophic subtropical gyres - the Earth's largest ecosystems. In order to elucidate how these protists meet their inorganic nutrient requirements, we compared the phosphate uptake rates of plastidic and aplastidic protists in the phosphate-depleted subtropical and tropical North Atlantic (4-29°N) using a combination of radiotracers and flow cytometric sorting on two Atlantic Meridional Transect cruises. Plastidic protists were divided into two groups according to their size (<2 and 2-3 μm). Both groups of plastidic protists showed higher phosphate uptake rates per cell than the aplastidic protists. Although the phosphate uptake rates of protist cells were on average seven times (P<0.001) higher than those of bacterioplankton, the biomass-specific phosphate uptake rates of protists were one fourth to one twentieth of an average bacterioplankton cell. The unsustainably low biomass-specific phosphate uptake by both plastidic and aplastidic protists suggests the existence of a common alternative means of phosphorus acquisition - predation on phosphorus-rich bacterioplankton cells.     

Investigation of the effectiveness of disinfectants against planktonic and biofilm forms of P. aeruginosa and E. faecalis cells using a compilation of cultivation,microscopic and flow cytometric techniques

This study evaluated the effectiveness of selected disinfectants against bacterial cells within a biofilm using flow cytometry, the conventional total viable count test and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). A flow cytometric procedure based on measurement of the cellular redox potential (CRP) was demonstrated to have potential for the rapid evaluation of activity against biofilm and planktonic forms of microbes. Quaternary ammonium compound-based disinfectant (QACB) demonstrated a higher level of anti-microbial activity than a performic acid preparation (PAP), with mean CRP values against P. aeruginosa cells of 2 and 1.33 relative fluorescence units (RFU) vs 63.33 and 61.33 RFU for 8 and 24 h cultures respectively. Flow cytometric evaluation of the anti-biofilm activity demonstrated a higher efficacy of QACB compared to PAP for P. aeruginosa cells of 1 and 0.66 RFU vs 18.33 and 22.66 RFU for 8 and 24 h cultures respectively. SEM images of treated P. aeruginosa cells demonstrated disinfectant-specific effects on cell morphology.     

Assimilation efficiency of Vibrio bacterial protein biomass by the flagellate Pteridomonas : assessment using flow cytometric sorting

A flow cytometric sorting technique for direct determination of bacterial biomass assimilation by phagotrophic flagellates was developed and tested in laboratory culture experiments. Living Vibrio bacteria were quantitatively pulse-chase labelled with [(35)S]methionine tracer and fed to Pteridomonas flagellates. Flow sorting revealed that the isotopically labelled material is in either bacterial prey or flagellate predators and the egested bacterial debris contained negligible amounts of tracer. These experimental results confirm an earlier hypothesis that flagellates release metabolised bacterial proteins primarily in a dissolved form. The assimilation efficiency of the Vibrio protein biomass by Pteridomonas was low, only about 20%, independently of the amount of consumed bacterial biomass, confirming our earlier indirect estimates. Additionally, against expectations that cells decrease their metabolic activity whilst preparing for and engaged in division, we found that the precursor uptake rates by flow sorted bacterial cells at the S+G(2) cell cycle stages were constantly 1.5 times higher than those of cells at the G(1) stage.     

Statistical analysis and biological interpretation of the flow cytometric heterogeneity observed in bacterial axenic cultures

Histogram comparison and meaningful statistics in flow cytometry is probably the most widely encountered mathematical problem in flow cytometry. Ideally, a test for determining the statistical equality or difference of flow cytometric distributions will identify the significant differences or similarities of the obtained histograms. This situation is of particular interest when flow cytometry is used to study the heterogeneity of axenic bacterial populations. We have statistically measured the heterogeneity of successive cytometric measures, the modifications produced after 20 transfers from the same culture, and the differences between 20 subcultures of identical origin. The heterogeneity of the bacterial populations and the similarity of the obtained 360 histograms were analysed by standard statistical methods. We have studied bacterial axenic cultures in order to detect, quantify and interpret their cytometric heterogeneity, and to assess intrinsic differences and differences produced by laboratory manipulations. We concluded that the standard axenic cultures have a considerable intrinsic cellular and molecular heterogeneity. We suggest that the heterogeneity we have detected basically has two origins: cell size diversity and cell cycle variations.     

Effect of natural sunlight on bacterial activity and differential sensitivity of natural bacterioplankton groups in northwestern Mediterranean coastal waters

We studied the effects of natural sunlight on heterotrophic marine bacterioplankton in short-term experiments. We used a single-cell level approach involving flow cytometry combined with physiological probes and microautoradiography to determine sunlight effects on the activity and integrity of the cells. After 4 h of sunlight exposure, most bacterial cells maintained membrane integrity and viability as assessed by the simultaneous staining with propidium iodide and SYBR green I. In contrast, a significant inhibition of heterotrophic bacterial activity was detected, measured by 5-cyano-2,3 ditolyl tetrazolium chloride reduction and leucine incorporation. We applied microautoradiography combined with catalyzed reporter deposition-fluorescence in situ hybridization to test the sensitivity of the different bacterial groups naturally occurring in the Northwestern Mediterranean to sunlight. Members of the Gammaproteobacteria and Bacteroidetes groups appeared to be highly resistant to solar radiation, with small changes in activity after exposure. On the contrary, Alphaproteobacteria bacteria were more sensitive to radiation as measured by the cell-specific incorporation of labeled amino acids, leucine, and ATP. Within Alphaproteobacteria, bacteria belonging to the Roseobacter group showed higher resistance than members of the SAR11 cluster. The activity of Roseobacter was stimulated by exposure to photosynthetic available radiation compared to the dark treatment. Our results suggest that UV radiation can significantly affect the in situ single-cell activity of bacterioplankton and that naturally dominating phylogenetic bacterial groups have different sensitivity to natural levels of incident solar radiation.     

Thymidine incorporation into lake water bacterioplankton and pure cultures of chemolithotrophic (CO, H2) and methanotrophic bacteria

Abstract Incorporation of [³H]methyl thymidine into bacterial DNA was measured using samples of bacterioplankton from Lake Constance and pure cultures of CO, H₂ and CH₄-oxidizing bacteria. Thymidine was incorporated by Pseudomonas carboxydovorans, Paracoccus denitrificans, Methylosinus trichosporium, Methylomonas agile , and by various chemolithotropic or methylotrophic isolates from Lake Constance. Thymidine incorporation by bacterial cultures was stimulated by increasing concentrations of CO or H₂. Increased CH₄ concentrations stimulated thymidine incorporation by Ms. trichosporium only if the cells had been starved. In contrast to bacterial cultures, thymidine incorporation by bacterioplankton samples was not stimulated by increasing     

Consequences of protist-stimulated bacterial production for estimating protist growth efficiencies

The trophic link between bacteria and bacterivorous protists is a complex interaction that involves feedback of inorganic nutrients and growth substrates that are immeadiately available for prey growth. These interactions were examined in the laboratory and in incubations of concentrated natural assemblages of bacterioplankton. Growth dynamics of estuarine and marine bacterivorous protists were determined in laboratory culture using Vibrio natriegens as prey and were compared to growth of protists on bacterioplankton assemblages concentrated by tangential flow filtration from four northwest Florida Estuaries. Biomass transfers from bacteria to protists were monitored by tracing elemental carbon and nitrogen in particulate fractions of protist added and grazer free controls. Gross growth efficiencies of the protists on naturally occurring bacteria were within the range determined in lab estimates of growth efficiency on cultured bacteria (50%). However, bacterial response to protist excretion products was different in the lab and field incubations, and bacterial growth contributed to the biomass available to protists in the field incubations. As determined by radioisotope-labeled substrate incorporation, a time lag in bacterial reponse to protist excretion products was observed for laboratory batch cultures, allowing accurate estimation of growth efficiency. In incubations with concentrated natural bacterial assemblages, bacterial growth response coincided with protist growth and excretion. The additional bacterial production on protist excretion products reached a maximum of 2–3-fold higher than protist-free controls. In addition, ammonium concentrations increased with protist grazing and growth in lab cultures, but ammonium excreted by protists in concentrates did not accumulate. The C:N values for the bacterial concentrates suggests that these bacteria were nitrogen limited. It is speculated that dissolved organic carbon, concentrated by tangential flow filtration (> 100,000 MW membrane) with the bacterioplankton, was utilized by bacteria when nitrogen was supplied as ammonium and amino acids from protist excretion. Thus, estimates of protist growth efficiency on naturally occurring bacterioplankton, corrected for protist-stimulated bacterial production, were in the range of 13–21%.     

Changes in community composition during dilution cultures of marine bacterioplankton as assessed by flow cytometric and molecular biological techniques

Dilution cultures are a common technique for measuring the growth of bacterioplankton communities. In this study, the taxonomic composition of marine bacterioplankton dilution cultures was followed in water samples from Plymouth Sound and the English Channel (UK). Bacterial abundances as well as protein and DNA content were closely monitored by flow cytometry. Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) of polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-amplified 16S rDNA fragments and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) were applied directly to the water samples and to cells sorted from the dilution cultures based on their protein and DNA content. As expected, a rapid activation of bacteria occurred. However, molecular techniques showed that the community developed in the dilution culture within 1 day was significantly different from that in the original water samples. Whereas in the original samples, cells detectable by FISH were dominated by members of the C ytophaga / Flavobacterium (CF) cluster, in dilution cultures, gamma-proteobacteria accounted for the majority of cells detected, followed by alpha-proteobacteria. An actively growing and an apparently non-growing population with average cellular protein contents of 24 and 4.5 fg respectively, were sorted by flow cytometry. FISH indicated mostly gamma- (64%) and alpha-proteobacteria (33%) in the first active fraction and 78% members of the CF cluster in the second fraction. Sequencing of DGGE bands confirmed the FISH assignments of the latter two groups. The data presented clearly show that even relatively short-term dilution experiments do not measure in situ growth, but rather growth patterns of an enrichment. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that the combination of flow cytometric analysis and sorting combined with FISH and DGGE analysis presented a fairly rapid method of analysing the taxonomic composition of marine bacterioplankton.     

Different Marine Heterotrophic Nanoflagellates Affect Differentially the Composition of Enriched Bacterial Communities

We studied the effects of predation on the cytometric and phylogenetic features of two enriched bacterial communities obtained from two cultures of marine heterotrophic nanoflagellates: Jakoba libera and a mixed culture of Cafeteria sp. and Monosiga sp. Protists were harvested by flow cytometric cell sorting and eight different treatments were prepared. Each bacterial community was incubated with and without protists, and we added two treatments with protists and the bacteria present after the sorting procedure (cosorted bacteria). The bacterial community derived from the culture of Jakoba libera had higher green fluorescence per cell (FL1) than that derived from the mixed culture of Cafeteria sp. and Monosiga sp. When the experiment began all treatments presented bacterial communities that increase in fluorescence per bacterium (FL1); after that the FL1 decreased when bacteria attained maximal concentrations; and, finally, there was a new increase in FL1 toward the end of the experiment. Cosorted bacteria of Jakoba libera had the same fluorescence as the bacterial community derived from this protist, while the bacteria derived from the mixed culture of Cafeteria sp. and Monosiga sp. was nearly twice as fluorescent than that of the parental community. All treatments presented a general decline of SSC along the incubation. Therefore, there was a small influence of protists on the cytometric signature of each bacterial community. However, each bacterial community preyed by Jakoba libera or the mixed culture of Cafeteria sp. and Monosiga sp. led to four different phylogenetic fingerprint. Besides, the final Communities were different from the fingerprint of controls without protists, and most of them diverge from the fingerprint of cosorted bacteria. Our results confirm that changes in the phylogenetic composition of marine bacterial communities may depend on the initial communities of both bacteria and protists.     

Effects of Nutrients on Specific Growth Rate of Bacterioplankton in Oligotrophic Lake Water Cultures

The effects of organic and inorganic nutrient additions on the specific growth rates of bacterioplankton in oligotrophic lake water cultures were investigated. Lake water was first passed through 0.8-μm-pore-size filters (prescreening) to remove bacterivores and to minimize confounding effects of algae. Specific growth rates were calculated from changes in both bacterial cell numbers and biovolumes over 36 h. Gross specific growth rates in unmanipulated control samples were estimated through separate measurements of grazing losses by use of penicillin. The addition of mixed organic substrates alone to prescreened water did not significantly increase bacterioplankton specific growth rates. The addition of inorganic phosphorus alone significantly increased one or both specific growth rates in three of four experiments, and one experiment showed a secondary stimulation by organic substrates. The stimulatory effects of phosphorus addition were greatest concurrently with the highest alkaline phosphatase activity in the lake water. Because bacteria have been shown to dominate inorganic phosphorus uptake in other P-deficient systems, the demonstration that phosphorus, rather than organic carbon, can limit bacterioplankton growth suggests direct competition between phytoplankton and bacterioplankton for inorganic phosphorus.     

Selective cloning of hybridoma cells for enhanced immunoglobulin production using flow cytometric cell sorting and automated laser nephelometry

Techniques for selective cloning of murine hybridoma cells by flow cytometric cell sorting and use of automated laser nephelometry to determine the resultant clones' immunoglobulin secretion levels are described. Using a commercially available attachment to a fluorescence-activated cell sorter, individual hybridoma cells were successfully distributed into microtiter wells in an automated manner based on their forward angle light scatter properties and their reaction to fluorescein-conjugated anti-mouse-IgG. The techniques were used to estimate successfully the frequency of immunoglobulin-secreting cells in established cultures. In addition, heterogeneity of cell surface immunoglobulin expression was observed and utilized as a criterion for flow sorting of new hybridoma variants. In these studies, clones derived from high (anti-IgG) intensity sorting regions yielded cultures with enhanced immunoglobulin secretion levels, as determined by automated laser nephelometry. Furthermore, the surface immunoglobulin phenotype of the derived clones was conserved in subsequent progeny. Finally, it was established that inclusion of propidium iodide in the hybridoma cell sorting mixtures improved cloning efficiency by facilitating enhanced discrimination and elimination of nonviable cells. Our results indicate that flow cytometric-assisted single cell deposition provides positive attributes of several traditional hybridoma cloning techniques and, in addition, furnishes a tool for steering the cloning process toward selection of enhanced immunoglobulin producing cultures.     

Comparable light stimulation of organic nutrient uptake by SAR11 and Prochlorococcus in the North Atlantic subtropical gyre

Subtropical oceanic gyres are the most extensive biomes on Earth where SAR11 and Prochlorococcus bacterioplankton numerically dominate the surface waters depleted in inorganic macronutrients as well as in dissolved organic matter. In such nutrient poor conditions bacterioplankton could become photoheterotrophic, that is, potentially enhance uptake of scarce organic molecules using the available solar radiation to energise appropriate transport systems. Here, we assessed the photoheterotrophy of the key microbial taxa in the North Atlantic oligotrophic gyre and adjacent regions using ³³P-ATP, ³H-ATP and ³⁵S-methionine tracers. Light-stimulated uptake of these substrates was assessed in two dominant bacterioplankton groups discriminated by flow cytometric sorting of tracer-labelled cells and identified using catalysed reporter deposition fluorescence in situ hybridisation. One group of cells, encompassing 48% of all bacterioplankton, were identified as members of the SAR11 clade, whereas the other group (24% of all bacterioplankton) was Prochlorococcus. When exposed to light, SAR11 cells took 31% more ATP and 32% more methionine, whereas the Prochlorococcus cells took 33% more ATP and 34% more methionine. Other bacterioplankton did not demonstrate light stimulation. Thus, the SAR11 and Prochlorococcus groups, with distinctly different light-harvesting mechanisms, used light equally to enhance, by approximately one-third, the uptake of different types of organic molecules. Our findings indicate the significance of light-driven uptake of essential organic nutrients by the dominant bacterioplankton groups in the surface waters of one of the less productive, vast regions of the world''s oceans—the oligotrophic North Atlantic subtropical gyre.     

Seasonality and spatial variation in abundance, biomass and activity of heterotrophic bacterioplankton in relation to some biotic and abiotic variables in an Ethiopian rift-valley lake (Awassa)

SUMMARY. I. Seasonality and spatial variation in abundance, biomass and activity of heterotrophic bacterioplankton was studied in a tropical freshwater lake. Variation in phytoplankton biomass and production, and several other limnological parameters, were also quantified.
2. Bacterial number and biomass fluctuated between 3.88–8.33×10⁶ ml⁻¹ and 68–125 mg C m⁻³, respectively. No spatial variation was observed in these bacterial variables, although other limnological parameters showed vertical variation.
3. Seasonal and vertical variation of heterotrophic bacterial activity were estimated from oxygen consumption, ¹⁴CO₂dark uptake and plate counts of colony forming units. All three methods showed vertical heterogeneity, with higher activity in the hypolimnion during the long stratification period (February May). Oxygen consumption rate and plate counts showed seasonality.
4. In spite of the low seasonality of climate in the tropics, several biological, chemical and physical variables were correlated with changes in bacterial variables. Wind and rainfall, and their effects on stratification and mixing, vertical distribution of nutrients and rate of primary production appeared to be the important parameters affecting heterotrophic bacterioplankton.