Epidermal cells as accessory cells in the generation of allo-reactive and hapten-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses

The capacity of epidermal cells (EC) to stimulate T cell activation is a Langerhans cell (LC)-dependent phenomenon. In all in vitro assays probed, LC subserve antigen-presenting cell functions in that they display surface-bound foreign or altered-self structures and thereby activate T cell responses. In contrast, attempts to demonstrate accessory cell (ACC) function of LC-containing EC have yielded negative results, i.e., EC lacking foreign cell surface antigens were not able to restore cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses in Ia+ adherent cell-depleted cultures. Reasoning that the ACC function of EC might be critically linked to cluster formation between LC and other cell types involved, we tested the ACC function of EC under experimental conditions that allow a close physical contact between the cell types involved (round-bottomed microtiter plates and brief centrifugation of culture plates). By using these modifications, the failure of highly purified B6 T cells to develop alloreactive CTL activity when stimulated with either highly purified, mitomycin C-treated C3H or B6CF1 T cells was restored by the addition of B6 EC. The CTL thus generated produced significant lysis of Con-A-stimulated C3H or BALB/c, but not B6, spleen cell targets. In a similar fashion, TNP- or FITC-specific CTL were generated when (in a syngeneic system) mitomycin C-treated TNP- or FITC-modified stimulator T cells and responder T cells were co-cultured in the presence, but not in the absence, of unmodified EC. The capacity of EC to restore CTL activity in a culture system depleted of Ia-bearing cells was not dependent upon their H-2 type, but was critically linked to the presence of Ia-bearing LC. We therefore conclude that LC-containing EC can subserve the ACC function in the generation of H-2-restricted CTL, provided that culture conditions are chosen that allow a close physical contact between the cell types involved.     

Induction of alloreactive cytotoxic T cells by acute virus infection of mice

Alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) distinct from virus-specific CTL and activated natural killer (NK) cells were generated during acute lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) infection of C57BL/6J mice. The alloreactive CTL shared similar antigenic markers (Thy-1.2+, Lyt-2.2+, and asialo GM1-) with the virus-specific CTL that appeared at the same time 7 days postinfection, but had different target specificities. These alloreactive CTL lysed allogeneic but not syngeneic or xenogeneic targets. These were distinct from activated NK cells, which lysed all target cell types, peaked 3 days postinfection, and had a phenotype of asialo GM1+, Thy-1 +/-, Lyt-2.2-. Cold target competition studies indicated that there were several subsets of alloreactive T cells with distinct specificities, and that these alloreactive T cells were not subsets of the virus-specific T cells. Similar types of alloreactive CTL were induced at much lower levels in C3H/St mice. This may indicate that the generation of this "aberrant" T cell activity is under genetic control. Hence, the LCMV infection of C57BL/6J mice induces several cytotoxic effector populations including alloreactive CTL, activated NK cells, and virus-specific CTL. Virus infections therefore have the ability not only to polyclonally stimulate B cells, as previously described, but also to stimulate CTL.     

Characterization of the T cell-mediated cellular cytotoxicity during acute infectious mononucleosis

Primary infection with EBV during acute infectious mononucleosis (IM) is associated with a cytotoxic response against allogeneic target cells. C depletion with anti-CD3 (OKT3) and anti-CD8 (OKT8) mAb decreased the allogeneic cytolysis of two EBV-infected lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) by 96% and 89%, respectively. Complement depletion with the NK cell-specific mAb Leu-11b and NKH-1a resulted in only a slight decrease (less than 35%) in the lysis of these LCL. mAb inhibition studies with OKT3 and OKT8 inhibited the allogeneic lysis of two LCL by 87% and 82%, respectively. The alloreactive cytotoxic response was strongly inhibited by mAb specific for MHC class I determinants (W6/32, 65% inhibition and BBM.1, 58% inhibition). Acute IM lymphocytes lysed the allogeneic EBV-negative cell lines HSB2 (45%) and HTLV-1 T cell lines (16%). NK cell-depleted lymphocytes from an acute IM patient demonstrated preferential lysis of K562 transfected with human HLA-A2 (73%) compared with the K562 transfected control (20%). Cold target competition studies with allogeneic and autologous target and competitor LCL demonstrated no significant competitive inhibition between allogeneic and autologous cells. We interpret these results as evidence that 1) the acute IM-alloreactive cytotoxic response is mediated primarily by CTL; 2) these alloreactive CTL lyse allogeneic target cells irrespective of EBV antigenic expression; 3) MHC class I expression is sufficient for allogeneic recognition and lysis of target cells; 4) distinct effector CTL populations mediate lysis of autologous and allogeneic target cells; and 5) during acute IM, EBV infection results in the induction of both virus-specific and alloreactive CTL populations.     

Human mesenchymal stem cells suppress induction of cytotoxic response to alloantigens

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) fail to induce allogeneic responses in mixed lymphocyte reaction assays. Because MSC express HLA class I molecules, here we investigated whether they could be recognized as allogeneic targets by cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL). With this aim, CTL precursor (CTLp) frequencies were measured following stimulation of T cells with either allogeneic mononuclear cells (MNC) or MSC originated from the same human bone marrow donor. Lysis of MSC was measured at day 10 of culture in standard chromium release assays. In addition, allogeneic PHA blast T cells or B-EBV lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) generated from the same donor were used as positive controls of lysis. Our results showed that when allogeneic MNC were used to stimulate T cells, a high CTLp frequency was detected towards MSC targets. However, when MSC were used as stimulators, CTLp frequencies were markedly altered whatever the targets used, i.e.: MSC, PHA blast T cells or EBV-B LCLs. Moreover, when graded concentrations of MSC were added together with MNC upon stimulation of alloreactive T cells, we observed a dose-dependent decrease in CTLp frequencies towards MSC targets. This inhibition of MSC lysis was partially overcome by adding exogenous rh-IL-2 from the beginning of cultures. In addition, this suppressive effect was totally reproduced when, instead of MSC, supernatant harvested from MSC cultures was added to allogeneic MNC, upon stimulation of alloreactive T cells. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that MSC which can be recognized as targets by pre-activated alloreactive CTLs, may be able to suppress differentiation of CTL precursors into CTL effectors through secretion of suppressive factors.     

Human vascular endothelial cells stimulate memory but not naive CD8+ T cells to differentiate into CTL retaining an early activation phenotype

Endothelial cell (EC)-selective alloreactive CTL may mediate alloimmune vascular injury. In the present study, EC-selective CTL were generated in cocultures of purified human CD8+ T cells with allogeneic EC and were compared with conventional CTL against corresponding B lymphoblastoid cells (BLC). EC caused activation and expansion of memory but not naive CD8+ T cells, which differentiated into EC-selective CTL that retained high surface expression of CD69, CD25, and CD62L and displayed low intracellular perforin content. In contrast, BLC-stimulated CTL could be generated from naive or memory CD8+ T cells and showed a more mature phenotype (low CD69, CD25, and CD62L with higher levels of perforin). The expansion of alloreactive T cells by EC stimulation was 5- to 20-fold less effective than in corresponding BLC-stimulated cultures, accounting for a reduction in the assayable cytotoxicity of individual microcultures. In these IL-2-supplemented cocultures, no effect on CTL generation or phenotype was observed by mAb blocking of costimulation provided by LFA-3, ICAM-1, or CD40, by addition of comitogenic anti-CD28 mAb, or by preactivation of EC with CD40 ligand. Cyclosporine inhibited CTL expansion and cytotoxicity similarly in both EC- and BLC-stimulated cultures but did not affect the phenotype of those CTL that did emerge. This study extends the characterization of endothelium as an immunoregulatory cell type distinct from conventional APC and may explain why graft rejection within the arterial intima, an anatomic compartment in which EC may be the primary type of APC, is separable from rejection in the graft parenchyma.     

Depletion of human NK cells with monoclonal antibodies allows the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes without NK-like cells in mixed cultures

In vitro stimulation of human mononuclear cells with x-irradiated autologous lymphoblastoid cell line (LCL) or allogeneic normal cells in mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) was previously shown to result in the generation of OKT3+ OKT8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) lytic for allogeneic and autologous LCLs and also of natural killer- (NK) like cells that are OKT3- and primarily OKT8- and are lytic for HLA- NK-sensitive K562 cells. The origin of the NK-like cells was not previously known because, although the majority of fresh human NK cells react with monoclonal antibodies OKM1 and B73.1, lymphocytes bearing these markers are not detected several days after the onset of MLC, when NK-like cells are present. In this study, experiments were undertaken to determine whether NK-like cells generated after stimulation with x-irradiated pooled allogeneic normal cells (poolx) or with autologous LCL are derived from cells expressing antigens reactive with monoclonal antibodies OKM1 or B73.1, which react with fresh NK cells. Mononuclear cells, depleted of monocytes, were stained with OKM1 or B73.1 and fluorescein-labeled goat anti-mouse IgG. Lymphocytes depleted of OKM1+ or B73.1+ cells, by fluorescence-activated cell sorting, and lymphocytes that were stained but not sorted were stimulated for 7 days with either poolx or autologous LCL. The generation of NK-like activity was decreased at least 90% after depletion of cells reactive with OKM1 or B73.1, whereas the generation of CTL against autologous and allogeneic LCL was minimally affected. These findings show that NK-like cells generated in MLC are derived from cells that express the phenotype of fresh NK cells (OKM1+ or B73.1+) and that CTL can be generated in cultures in which relatively little NK-like activity is concomitantly detected, by depleting NK cells with monoclonal antibodies before stimulation.     

Further studies on the use of mouse epidermal cells for the in vitro induction and detection of cell-mediated cytotoxicity

Mouse epidermal cells (EC) and lymphoid cells (LC) were compared as targets of cellmediated cytotoxicity (CMC) in short-term chromium release assays where attacker cells were generated in primary mixed cultures using irradiated allogeneic EC or LC as stimulators. Three patterns of relative susceptibility to lysis of the two types of target cells were observed: (i) significantly greater lysis of LC than of EC targets; (ii) significantly greater lysis of EC than LC targets; and (iii) approximately equal susceptibility to lysis of the two targets. The first pattern was primarily associated with LC stimulators, whereas the second and third patterns were almost invariably associated with EC stimulators. Factors possibly contributing to the differences in in vitro immunogenicity and susceptibility to CMC of EC and LC were investigated, including the alteration of EC surface antigens during the trypsinization required to prepare EC suspensions, the differential expression of shared alloantigens, or the restricted expression of tissue-specific alloantigens on the two types of cells. Tests with intact and trypsinized LC on the one hand and fresh and short-term cultured EC on the other indicated that trypsinization is not responsible for the basic differences between EC and LC detected in the in vitro assays. Antibody absorption tests demonstrated that although EC and LC express approximately equal quantities of the cell surface antigens determined by the H-2D region of the H-2 complex, LC express significantly greater quantities of the antigens determined by the H-2K and I regions. In addition, the results of cold target inhibition tests suggest that tissue-specific antigens on both EC and LC also influence their relative immunogenicity and susceptibility to lysis.     

Modulation of in vitro immune responses by monoclonal antibody to T200 antigen

The effects of monoclonal antibody to the T200 antigen on murine mixed-lymphocyte cultures (MLC) and on the generation of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are investigated. Addition of monoclonal anti-T200 without complement to MLC results in a late suppression of the proliferative response preceded in some cases by an early enhancement. These modulations require the presence of allogeneic stimulator cells; no effects are seen when antibody is added to responders alone. A similar effect is seen on the generation of CTL. Compared to controls without antibody, cultures carried out in the presence of anti-T200 show reduced levels of cytotoxicity measured against allogeneic targets by Day 5. The kinetics of the suppressive effects differ from those seen with anti-Lyt-2, and no suppressive effects are seen with monoclonal antibodies to other cell surface molecules.     

Detection of distinct subpopulations of Langerhans cells by flow cytometry and sorting

Flow cytometry was found to be a very appropriate tool for the study of Langerhans cells (LC), which represent a minor cell population (2-3%) of human epidermis, and allowed us to obtain new phenotypic, functional, and cell cycle data on these rare cells. The phenotypic analysis of cell surface antigens demonstrates the existence of two subpopulations of LC: the former is HLA-DR+ and OKT 6+ (about 90% of total HLA-DR+ cells) and the latter is HLA-DR+ and OKT 6- (about 10% of total HLA-DR+ cells). These subpopulations of LC are both able to stimulate the proliferation of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in the presence of keratinocytes i.e., in mixed skin lymphocyte reaction (MSLR). Analysis of the cell cycle could be performed on OKT 6+ LC. Results show that they can be found in the various phases of the cell cycle, suggesting that the large majority of Langerhans cells are able to proliferate in situ in normal human epidermis.     

Fc gamma RII/CD32-negative human Langerhans cells may be responsible for the immunostimulatory activity of freshly isolated epidermal cells.

Cultured murine and human epidermal Langerhans cells (LC) undergo a phenotypical and functional maturation process. In fact, they loose Fc gamma RII and Birbeck granules, increase HLA-DR expression, and become potent accessory cells for allogeneic MLR. However, resident/freshly isolated human epidermal LC represent a phenotypically heterogeneous cell population. Indeed, a subset of CD1a+ LC lacks Birbeck granules, is Fc gamma RII/CD32-, and strongly expresses HLA-DR and the RFD1 antigen that is considered to be specific for interdigitating cells. In the present study the functional capacity of this Fc gamma RII/CD32- CD1a+ LC subset was investigated in MLR assays by comparing the stimulatory activity of freshly isolated crude epidermal cells (EC) with that of freshly isolated EC depleted in CD1a+ or in Fc gamma RII+ cells. Thereby, we observed that crude EC stimulated allogeneic PBMC while the removal of CD1a+ cells abrogated this stimulation. However, crude EC depleted in Fc gamma RII/CD32+ cells still exhibited a stimulatory capacity that was at least equal to that of crude EC. Taken together, these data suggest that among resident human epidermal LC there exists a subset of phenotypically and functionally more differentiated cells that may be solely responsible for the stimulatory capacity of freshly isolated crude EC.     

Human cytotoxic lymphocytes. V. Frequency and specificity of gamma delta+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors activated by allogeneic or autologous stimulator cells

We have investigated the frequency and specificity of gamma delta+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) under limiting dilution culture conditions. E rosette separated total T cells and CD3+CD4-CD8-TCR alpha beta- double-negative (DN) T cells were cocultured with allogeneic or autologous PBMC stimulator cells, and frequencies of alloreactive and autoreactive CLP were determined after 12 to 14 days against Con A blast target cells. Freshly isolated DN cells consisting of 82.3 +/- 8.2% gamma delta+ T cells did not exert cytolytic activity against K562 or anti-TCR gamma delta mAb-producing hybridoma cells. In striking contrast to E+ cells, the vast majority of alloantigen-stimulated clonally developing DN CLP did not show specificity for stimulator-derived target cells. Thus, frequencies of alloreactive and autoreactive CLP after alloantigenic stimulation were in the range of 1/100 to 1/4800 and 1/450 to 1/5000, respectively. After coculture with autologous stimulator cells, frequencies of autoreactive and alloreactive DN CLP were 1/700 to 1/2700 and 1/1360 to 1/4500, respectively. Split culture analysis revealed that most proliferating DN colonies selected for high probability of clonality simultaneously killed both autologous and HLA-mismatched allogeneic targets. The majority of the DN cells expressed the CD3+/TCR gamma delta+ phenotype after culture, and thus were not CD2+CD3- NK cells. Taken together, our results show that 1) freshly isolated peripheral blood gamma delta+ T cells lack cytotoxic activity, and 2) most cytotoxic gamma delta+ T cells activated by autologous or allogeneic stimulator cells under limiting dilution conditions do not discriminate between autologous and allogeneic targets.     

The human antimurine xenogeneic cytotoxic response. I. Dependence on responder antigen-presenting cells

We have examined the role of the human responder APC in the generation of CTL responses to xenogeneic antigens. Of six xenogeneic responses evaluated, only the human antimurine response was dependent on human APC for CTL generation. APC requirements for the other five xenogeneic responses more closely resembled those observed in the generation of human or murine alloreactive CTL. Depletion studies identified a defective human CD4+ Th cell-murine stimulator cell interaction that could be bypassed by the addition of exogenous IL-2. The function of the responder APC involved in the human antimurine CTL response was inhibited by chloroquine, suggesting a requirement for Ag processing. Effective presentation of murine stimulator Ag by human APC was completely blocked by anti-human Ia mAb, indicating that the Ag is presented to Th cells via the human class II molecule. These results are consistent with an Ia-dependent recognition of processed murine Ag by human T cells and represents a model for investigating human T cell activation requirements, Th cell function, and MHC restriction.     

Human vascular endothelial cells stimulate a lower frequency of alloreactive CD8+ pre-CTL and induce less clonal expansion than matching B lymphoblastoid cells: development of a novel limiting dilution analysis method based on CFSE labeling of lymphocytes

We have previously shown that human endothelial cells (EC) are less efficient than professional APC, e.g., B lymphoblastoid cells (BLC), at stimulating allogeneic CD8(+) T cells to develop into CTL. In this study we describe FACS-based limiting dilution analyses using the dilution of the intracellular dye CFSE as an indicator of CD8(+) T cell alloactivation and expansion with significantly increased sensitivity compared with conventional, cytotoxicity-based assays. In addition, this assay permits the relative size of clonal CTL populations that are generated in individual CD8(+) T cell cultures to be determined (clonal burst size). We have applied this method to quantitatively compare the generation of CTL at the clonal level following stimulation of allogeneic CD8(+) T cells by either BLC or HUVEC derived from the same donor. CD8(+) T cells expanded by allostimulation were identified as CD8(+), CFSE(low) cells and were categorized as CTL by the expression of intracellular perforin and IFN-gamma. Precursor frequencies for EC-stimulated CTL were 5- to 40-fold (mean, 7.5-fold) lower compared with BLC-stimulated CTL (p < 0.01). Concomitantly, the average clonal burst sizes in EC-stimulated CTL cultures were significantly smaller than those in conventional CTL cultures, primarily due to the occurrence of some very large clone sizes exclusively with BLC stimulation. Although EC-stimulated CTL were generated only from the memory subset of CD8(+) T cells, BLC-stimulated very large burst sizes of CTL were observed from both naive and memory CD8(+) T cell precursors. These data establish that both a lower frequency of reactive precursors and more limited clonal expansion, but not regulatory T cells, contribute to the reduced capacity of EC to promote alloreactive CTL differentiation compared with that of professional APC.     

In vitro binding and internalization of HIV envelope glycoproteins by human epidermal langerhans cells does not require the CD4-GP120-binding site

Langerhans cells (LC) are epidermal dendritic cells which express several surface antigens, among them the CD4 antigens. Recent data demonstrated that LC constitute target and storage cells for HIV. To better understand the interactions between HIV and LC, we investigated, in the present work, the fate of HIV envelope glycoproteins (gp120 and gp160) incubated with healthy human trypsinized LC in suspensions.After trypsin treatment, only the epitope for OKT4 appeared to be resistant on LC. In the absence of antigenic sites identified by OKT4A, Leu3a or BL4 (epitopes implicated in HIV binding), LC bound and internalized recombinant HIV gp120 or gp160.This finding supports the hypothesis that there exists at the surface of LC a second molecule which may act as an HIV receptor.     

Antigen presentation by Langerhans cells in vivo: donor-derived Ia+ Langerhans cells are required for induction of delayed-type hypersensitivity but not for cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses to alloantigens

T cell activation in response to allogeneic stimulation and hapten-specific delayed-contact hypersensitivity responses in vivo can be initiated by Ia-bearing epidermal Langerhans cells (LC). By using a murine heterotopic corneal allograft model, we have investigated the requirement for allogeneic LC as antigen-presenting cells (APC) in the in vivo induction of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses to alloantigens in fully allogeneic and H-2 I region-disparate strain combinations. LC-deficient, avascular central corneal allografts from BALB/c donors failed to induce DTH responsiveness when grafted to a subdermal bed on C57BL/6 recipients (p greater than 0.05), yet antigen-specific primary CTL reactivity developed within 7 days after grafting. LC-containing corneal-limbus allografts or central corneal allografts containing a latex bead-induced infiltrate of LC resulted in intense DTH as well as CTL responsiveness when grafted in this same strain combination. Similarly, LC-containing but not LC-deficient corneal allografts from A.TL donors induced DTH responsiveness in I region-disparate A.TH hosts despite the fact that these grafts survived for prolonged duration (less than 28 days). By contrast, CTL induction in I region-disparate hosts was independent of the presence of allogeneic LC. Corneal epithelial cells of grafts removed from I region-disparate hosts 7 days posttransplantation were shown by immunohistology to express the Iak antigens of donor origin. The possibility that bone marrow-derived allogeneic LC were a sufficient requirement for DTH induction was confirmed in experiments performed with CB6F1----B6 bone marrow chimeras used as corneal allograft donors. Corneal-limbus grafts obtained from mice 90 days after chimerization were shown by immunohistology to contain Iad-bearing CB6F1 LC as a sole source of class II alloantigens. When grafted to C57BL/6 recipients, LC-containing chimeric corneas induced DTH responsiveness that was similar in magnitude to that observed in C57BL/6 mice grafted with chimeric skin, yet no DTH response to LC-deficient chimeric central corneal grafts was observed. Moreover, in all cases, the chimeric corneal and skin allografts survived for prolonged duration (greater than 28 days). These results demonstrate that donor-derived LC act as APC in the induction of DTH responsiveness to allogeneic tissue; however, there was no apparent requirement for allogeneic LC in the induction of CTL responses to class I or class II MHC alloantigens.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Porcine endothelial cells,unlike human endothelial cells,can be killed by human CTL via Fas ligand and cannot be protected by Bcl-2

In clinical transplantation host CTL are major effectors of acute rejection, and graft endothelial cells (EC) are major targets of the CTL response. It is unclear what roles CTL will play in pig-into-human xenotransplantation. We compared the mechanisms of killing used by human CTL (huCTL) vs allogeneic and pig xenogeneic EC targets. Both responses show MHC class I restriction of target cell recognition. A granzyme B inhibitor peptide completely blocks anti-human and partially blocks anti-pig responses, while inhibitory Fas ligand Ab only blocks killing of porcine cells despite similar levels of Fas expression in both target cell types. Transduction of Bcl-2 completely protects human EC from huCTL, but has no effect on huCTL-mediated killing of porcine EC despite its efficacy vs drug-induced apoptosis. Bcl-2 effectively protects human EC rendered sensitive to Fas ligand by overexpressing Fas from huCTL, yet fails to protect porcine aortic endothelial cells from huCTL in the presence of anti-Fas ligand Ab. These data reveal differences in the susceptibility of human and porcine targets to huCTL.     

Role of endogenous peptides in murine allogenic cytotoxic T cell responses assessed using transfectants of the antigen-processing mutant 174xCEM.T2.

One model to explain the high frequency of alloreactive T cells proposes that allogeneic MHC molecules are recognized together with host cell-derived peptides. A model system was developed to investigate the relevance of this mechanism by expression of H-2Dd or H-2Ld in 174xCEM.T2 (T2) cells. This human cell line contains a mutation in its Ag-processing pathway that should restrict the association of endogenous peptides with cell surface class I molecules. CTL generated by stimulating C57BL/6 (H-2b) responder cells with H-2Dd or H-2Ld transfectants of the human B cell line C1R or the murine T cell lymphoma EL4 were assayed for their ability to recognize alloantigenic determinants on these transfectants. The major fraction of the H-2Dd-specific allogeneic CTL response, generated in a MLC or under clonal limiting dilution conditions, was composed of T cells that recognized H-2Dd expressed on C1R or EL4 cells, but failed to recognize this molecule on T2 cells. Clonal analysis indicated that approximately one-third of these CTL recognized determinants that were unique to H-2Dd expressed on C1R stimulator cells whereas the remainder recognized determinants that were also found on EL4 transfectants. Less than 10% of H-2Dd-reactive CTL recognized the T2 transfectant, and these clones also killed C1R-Dd and EL4-Dd. This result suggests that the great majority of H-2Dd-specific alloreactive CTL recognize determinants that are formed by a complex of H-2Dd with endogenous peptides that are absent or significantly reduced in T2 cells. Based on recognition of human or murine transfectants, these CTL exhibit some level of specificity for the structure or composition of the bound peptides. Examination of allogeneic CTL specific for H-2Ld revealed populations similar to those described for H-2Dd. In addition, a major new population was present that recognized determinants shared between C1R-Ld and T2-Ld but not present on EL4-Ld. These results are consistent with the idea that the alloreactive response to H-2Ld is also largely dependent on the presence of bound peptide. However, they also may indicate that the H-2Ld molecule expressed on T2 cells is occupied by one or more peptides that are shared with other human, but not murine, cells. The significance of these results to current models of alloreactivity is discussed.     

Functional heterogeneity in allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones. II. Development of syngeneic cytotoxicity in the absence of specific antigenic stimulation

Two out of four long-term murine allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones tested could develop high levels of cytotoxicity against syngeneic target cells when cultured under appropriate conditions. All CTL clones maintained strict allospecificity so long as they were cultured with both appropriate allogeneic stimulator cells and growth factor (supernatant from secondary mixed lymphocyte cultures). In two of the clones, syngeneic reactivity rapidly developed when the allogeneic stimulator cells were replaced with syngeneic or third party stimulator cells, and when the supernatant from EL4 thymoma cells stimulated with phorbol ester was used as growth factor. In addition to killing the appropriate allogeneic target, clones with syngeneic reactivity could kill both syngeneic C57BL/6 targets and H-2-congenic BALB.B targets but not third party unrelated targets, suggesting that the self structure recognized was coded for within the major histocompatibility complex. Such clones did not kill the natural killer (NK) target YAC. The results obtained from cold target inhibition and from subcloning at limiting dilution of clones with syngeneic reactivity suggested that both allogeneic and syngeneic reactivity could be expressed by the same individual cell in the CTL clone. The specificity for syngeneic H-2 as opposed to third party H-2 and NK-sensitive target cells, and the observation that both allospecific and syngeneic killing could be partially blocked by anti-Lyt-2 antibody treatment of the CTL, strongly suggested that different recognition structures are involved in CTL-mediated syngeneic cytotoxicity and NK cytotoxicity.     

Individual differences in the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response in man to public HLA determinants

The allospecific anti-HLA response of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from 22 unrelated individuals and 7 monozygous twin pairs was examined. From each responder, CTL were generated in several responder-stimulator combinations, each mismatched for one HLA-A or -B antigen. The CTL were assayed in the cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) on panels of third-party target cells, comprising cells that express the stimulating antigen (specific target cells), cells that express an antigen cross-reactive with the stimulating antigen (CREG target cells), and cells that do not express either the stimulating or a cross-reactive antigen (nonsharing target cells). Individual variations in the allo-CTL response were observed. We identified individuals (responders) who showed a consistently narrow CTL response and those who showed a broad reaction pattern to various stimulator cells. The narrow response was restricted almost entirely to specific target cells; the broad response comprised lysis of specific, CREG, and nonsharing target cells. These differences were evidently not dependent on the HLA-A, -B, -C phenotype of the responder, because HLA-A, -B, (-C)-identical individuals responded differently to the same stimulator. The identical response of monozygous twins indicates that the allogeneic CTL response is genetically controlled. The CTL response is not regulated by the HLA-DR antigens of the responder, nor is it influenced by the DR mismatch between responder and stimulator. The observed differences were not dependent on sex or age and could not be explained by differences in the T-lymphocyte subsets (OKT3+, OKT4+, OKT8+) or by differences in proliferative reactivity to mitogens (phytohemagglutinin, concanavalin A, phorbol-myristate acetate, pokeweed mitogen, anti-T3 monoclonal antibodies). The IL-2 activity in the supernatants of mixed lymphocyte cultures of broad and narrow responder-stimulator combinations did not differ.     

Cell-mediated lympholysis of trinitrophenyl-derivatized autologous human cells: in vitro triggering by nonspecific signals.

This report describes the primary in vitro generation of human CTL that lyse TNP-derivatized autologous cells. Although in the majority of these studies, a direct cytotoxic response to the TNP-modified autologous stimulators was not achieved, in all experiments the addition of either allogeneic cells or soluble antigen triggered the generation of killer cells which destroy TNP-modified, but not unaltered, autologous targets. Fractionation of responder lymphocyte populations demonstrated that the cytotoxic activity was mediated by T cells. Killer cell specificity was tested by assaying for cytotoxicity to a variety of targets, and by blocking the cytolysis of TNP-altered autologous targets with various populations of nonradiolabeled cells. Results indicated that these CTL were cytotoxic for TNP-modified autologous cells but not unaltered autologous or TNP-modified allogeneic targets. The capacity of soluble antigen and alloantigens to facilitate the in vitro generation of altered-self reactive human CTL is not an isolated phenomenon. This "helper" effect has now been observed for the cytotoxic response to chemically modified autologous cells and MHC identical human leukemic blasts. It is possible that in vivo, similar responses to nonspecific antigenic stimuli may play a role in the maintenance of immune surveillance.