Low Mitochondrial Free Radical Production Per Unit O2 Consumption Can Explain the Simultaneous Presence of High Longevity and High Aerobic Metabolic Rate in Birds

Birds are unique since they can combine a high rate of oxygen consumption at rest with a high maximum life span (MLSP). The reasons for this capacity are unknown. A similar situation is present in primates including humans which show MLSPs higher than predicted from their rates of O₂ consumption. In this work rates of oxygen radical production and O₂ consumption by mitochondria were compared between adult male rats (MLSP = 4 years) and adult pigeons (MLSP = 35 years), animals of similar body size. Both the O₂ consumption of the whole animal at rest and the O₂ consumption of brain, lung and liver mitochondria were higher in the pigeon than in the rat. Nevertheless, mitochondrial free radical production was 2-4 times lower in pigeon than in rat tissues. This is possible because pigeon mitochondria show a rate of free radical production per unit O₂ consumed one order of magnitude lower than rat mitochondria: bird mitochondria show a lower free radical leak at the respiratory chain. This result, described here for the first time, can possibly explain the capacity of birds to simultaneously increase maximum longevity and basal metabolic rate. It also suggests that the main factor relating oxidative stress to aging and longevity is not the rate of oxygen consumption but the rate of oxygen radical production. Previous inconsistencies of the rate of living theory of aging can be explained by a free radical theory of aging which focuses on the rate of oxygen radical production and on local damage to targets relevant for aging situated near the places where free radicals are continuously generated.     

The rate of free radical production as a determinant of the rate of aging: evidence from the comparative approach

The relationship of oxidative stress with maximum life span (MLSP) in different vertebrate species is reviewed. In all animal groups the endogenous levels of enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidants in tissues negatively correlate with MLSP and the most longevous animals studied in each group, pigeon or man, show the minimum levels of antioxidants. A possible evolutionary reason for this is that longevous animals produce oxygen radicals at a low rate. This has been analysed at the place where more than 90% of oxygen is consumed in the cell, the mitochondria. All available work agrees that, across species, the longer the life span, the lower the rate of mitochondrial oxygen radical production. This is true even in animal groups that do not conform to the rate of living theory of aging, such as birds. Birds have low rates of mitochondrial oxygen radical production, frequently due to a low free radical leak in their respiratory chain. Possibly the low rate of mitochondrial oxygen radical production of longevous species can decrease oxidative damage at targets important for aging (like mitochondrial DNA) that are situated near the places of free radical generation. A low rate of free radical production can contribute to a low aging rate both in animals that conform to the rate of living (metabolic) theory of aging and in animals with exceptional longevities, like birds and primates. Available research indicates there are at least two main characteristics of longevous species: a high rate of DNA repair together with a low rate of free radical production near DNA. Simultaneous consideration of these two characteristics can explain part of the quantitative differences in longevity between animal species. Accepted: 12 December 1997     

Antioxidant Systems in Tissues of Senescence Accelerated Mice

Significant decrease in the level of lipid antioxidants (measured from the kinetics of the induced chemiluminescence in brain homogenate) and of the hydrophilic antioxidant carnosine as well was observed in the brain of 14-16-month-old mice of SAMP1 line, which is characterized by accelerated accumulation of senile features, in comparison with the control line SAMR1. In the brain of SAMP1 animals the activity of cytosolic Cu/Zn-containing superoxide dismutase (SOD) was reduced, while the activity of membrane-bound Mn-SOD was at an extremely low level. The activity of glutathione-dependent enzymes (glutathione peroxidase, glutathione reductase, and glutathione transferase) did not differ in the brain of SAMP1 and SAMR1 animals, and catalase activity was similarly low in both cases. At the same time, excess concentration of excitotoxic compounds, significantly exceeding that for the control line, was determined in the brain and blood of SAMP1 animals. The activity of glutathione enzymes in liver and heart as well as the activity of cytosolic Cu/Zn-SOD in liver did not differ in the two studied lines, while the activity of erythrocyte glutathione peroxidase was slightly increased, and the activity of liver catalase and erythrocyte Cu/Zn-SOD was significantly decreased for SAMP1 compared with SAMR1. The results demonstrate that the accelerated ageing of SAMP1 animals is connected to a significant extent with the decreased efficiency of the systems utilizing reactive oxygen species (ROS) in tissues.     

Trends in oxidative aging theories

The early observations on the rate-of-living theory by Max Rubner and the report by Gershman that oxygen free radicals exist in vivo culminated in the seminal proposal in the 1950s by Denham Harman that reactive oxygen species are a cause of aging (free radical theory of aging). The goal of this review is to analyze recent findings relevant in evaluating Harman's theory using experimental results as grouped by model organisms (i.e., invertebrate models and mice). In this regard, we have focused primarily on recent work involving genetic manipulations. Because the free radical theory of aging is not the only theorem proposed to explain the mechanism(s) involved in aging at the molecular level, we also discuss how this theory is related to other areas of research in biogerontology, specifically, telomere/cell senescence, genomic instability, and the mitochondrial hypothesis of aging. We also discuss where we think the free radical theory is headed. It is now possible to give at least a partial answer to the question whether oxidative stress determines life span as Harman posed so long ago. Based on studies to date, we argue that a tentative case for oxidative stress as a life-span determinant can be made in Drosophila melanogaster. Studies in mice argue for a role of oxidative stress in age-related disease, especially cancer; however, with regard to aging per se, the data either do not support or remain inconclusive on whether oxidative stress determines life span.     

Testing the 'free radical theory of aging' hypothesis: physiological differences in long-lived and short-lived colubrid snakes

We test the 'free radical theory of aging' using six species of colubrid snakes (numerous, widely distributed, non-venomous snakes of the family Colubridae) that exhibit long (> 15 years) or short (< 10 years) lifespans. Because the 'rate of living theory' predicts metabolic rates to be correlated with rates of aging and oxidative damage results from normal metabolic processes we sought to answer whether physiological parameters and locomotor performance (which is a good predictor of survival in juvenile snakes) mirrored the evolution of lifespans in these colubrid snakes. We measured whole animal metabolic rate (oxygen consumption Vo2), locomotor performance, cellular metabolic rate (mitochondrial oxygen consumption), and oxidative stress potential (hydrogen peroxide production by mitochondria). Longer-lived colubrid snakes have greater locomotor performance and reduced hydrogen peroxide production than short-lived species, while whole animal metabolic rates and mitochondrial efficiency did not differ with lifespan. We present the first measures testing the 'free radical theory of aging' using reptilian species as model organisms. Using reptiles with different lifespans as model organisms should provide greater insight into mechanisms of aging.     

Tick tock,tick tock: Mouse culture and tissue aging captured by an epigenetic clock

Aging is associated with dramatic changes to DNA methylation (DNAm), although the causes and consequences of such alterations are unknown. Our ability to experimentally uncover mechanisms of epigenetic aging will be greatly enhanced by our ability to study and manipulate these changes using in vitro models. However, it remains unclear whether the changes elicited by cells in culture can serve as a model of what is observed in aging tissues in vivo. To test this, we serially passaged mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) and assessed changes in DNAm at each time point via reduced representation bisulfite sequencing. By developing a measure that tracked cellular aging in vitro, we tested whether it tracked physiological aging in various mouse tissues and whether anti‐aging interventions modulate this measure. Our measure, termed CultureAGE, was shown to strongly increase with age when examined in multiple tissues (liver, lung, kidney, blood, and adipose). As a control, we confirmed that the measure was not a marker of cellular senescence, suggesting that it reflects a distinct yet progressive cellular aging phenomena that can be induced in vitro. Furthermore, we demonstrated slower epigenetic aging in animals undergoing caloric restriction and a resetting of our measure in lung and kidney fibroblasts when re‐programmed to iPSCs. Enrichment and clustering analysis implicated EED and Polycomb group (PcG) factors as potentially important chromatin regulators in translational culture aging phenotypes. Overall, this study supports the concept that physiologically relevant aging changes can be induced in vitro and used to uncover mechanistic insights into epigenetic aging.     

Dysfunction of astrocytes in senescence-accelerated mice SAMP8 reduces their neuroprotective capacity

Early onset increases in oxidative stress and tau pathology are present in the brain of senescence-accelerated mice prone (SAMP8). Astrocytes play an essential role, both in determining the brain's susceptibility to oxidative damage and in protecting neurons. In this study, we examine changes in tau phosphorylation, oxidative stress and glutamate uptake in primary cultures of cortical astrocytes from neonatal SAMP8 mice and senescence-accelerated-resistant mice (SAMR1). We demonstrated an enhancement of abnormally phosphorylated tau in Ser(199) and Ser(396) in SAMP8 astrocytes compared with that of SAMR1 control mice. Gsk3beta and Cdk5 kinase activity, which regulate tau phosphorylation, was also increased in SAMP8 astrocytes. Inhibition of Gsk3beta by lithium or Cdk5 by roscovitine reduced tau phosphorylation at Ser(396). Moreover, we detected an increase in radical superoxide generation, which may be responsible for the corresponding increase in lipoperoxidation and protein oxidation. We also observed a reduced mitochondrial membrane potential in SAMP8 mouse astrocytes. Glutamate uptake in astrocytes is a critical neuroprotective mechanism. SAMP8 astrocytes showed a decreased glutamate uptake compared with those of SAMR1 controls. Interestingly, survival of SAMP8 or SAMR1 neurons cocultured with SAMP8 astrocytes was significantly reduced. Our results indicate that alterations in astrocyte cultures from SAMP8 mice are similar to those detected in whole brains of SAMP8 mice at 1-5 months. Moreover, our findings suggest that this in vitro preparation is suitable for studying the molecular and cellular processes underlying early aging in this murine model. In addition, our study supports the contention that astrocytes play a key role in neurodegeneration during the aging process.     

Age-specific variation of resistance to oxidative stress in the greater flamingo (Phoenicopterus ruber roseus)

Birds exhibit exceptional longevity and are thus regarded as a convenient model to study the intrinsic mechanisms of aging. The oxidative stress theory of aging suggests that individuals age because molecules, cells, tissues, organs, and, ultimately, animals accumulate oxidative damage over time. Accumulation of damage progressively reduces the level of antioxidant defences that are expected to decline with age. To test this theory, we measured the resistance of red blood cells to free radical attack in a captive population of greater flamingo (Phoenicopterus ruber roseus) of known age ranging from 0.3 to 45 years. We observed a convex relationship with young adults (12–20 years old) having greater resistance to oxidative stress than immature flamingos (5 months old) and old flamingos (30–45 years old). Our results suggest that the antioxidant detoxifying system must go through a maturation process before being completely functional. It then declines in older adults, supporting the oxidative theory of aging. Oxidative stress could hence play a significant role in shaping the pattern of senescence in a very long-lived bird species.     

Oxidative damage to mitochondrial DNA is inversely related to maximum life span in the heart and brain of mammals.

DNA damage is considered of paramount importance in aging. Among causes of this damage, free radical attack, particularly from mitochondrial origin, is receiving special attention. If oxidative damage to DNA is involved in aging, long-lived animals (which age slowly) should show lower levels of markers of this kind of damage than short-lived ones. However, this possibility has not heretofore been investigated. In this study, steady-state levels of 8-oxo-7, 8-dihydro-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxodG) referred to deoxyguanosine (dG) were measured by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) in the mitochondrial (mtDNA) and nuclear (nDNA) DNA from the heart of eight and the brain of six mammalian species ranging in maximum life span (MLSP) from 3.5 to 46 years. Exactly the same digestion of DNA to deoxynucleosides and HPLC protocols was used for mtDNA and nDNA. Significantly higher (three- to ninefold) 8-oxodG/dG values were found in mtDNA than in nDNA in all the species studied in both tissues. 8-oxodG/dG in nDNA did not correlate with MLSP across species either in the heart (r=-0.68; P<0.06) or brain (r = 0.53; P<0.27). However, 8-oxodG/dG in mtDNA was inversely correlated with MLSP both in heart (r=-0.92; P<0.001) and brain (r=-0.88; P<0.016) tissues following the power function y = a(.)x(b), where y is 8-oxodG/dG and x is the MLSP. This agrees with the consistent observation that mitochondrial free radical generation is also lower in long-lived than in short-lived species. The results obtained agree with the notion that oxygen radicals of mitochondrial origin oxidatively damage mtDNA in a way related to the aging rate of each species.-Barja, G., Herrero, A. Oxidative damage to mitochondrial DNA is inversely related to maximum life span in the heart and brain of mammals.     

Maintenance of proteins and aging: the role of oxidized protein repair

According to the free radical theory of aging proposed by Denham Harman (Journal of Gerontology 1956, 11, pp. 298-300), the continuous oxidative damage to cellular components over an organism's life span is a causal factor of the aging process. The age-related build-up of oxidized protein is therefore resulting from increased protein oxidative damage and/or decreased elimination of oxidized proteins. In this mini-review, we will address the fate, during aging, of the protein maintenance systems that are involved in the degradation of irreversibly oxidized proteins and in the repair of reversible protein oxidative damage with a special focus on the methionine sulfoxide reductases system. Since these protein degradation and repair systems have been found to be impaired with age, it is proposed that not only failure of redox homeostasis but, as importantly, failure of protein maintenance are critical factors in the aging process.     

Detection of free radical formation in various tissues after acute carbon tetrachloride administration in gerbil

alpha-phenyl N-tert-butyl nitrone (PBN) was used as a spin-trapping agent to search for free radical formation in various tissues of gerbils. A significantly large amount of free radicals was detected in liver, kidney, heart, lung and testis after a single intraperitoneal dose of CCl4. We have also detected free radical formation in the brain and blood, although the number of spins was considerably smaller than those found in the other tissues. Free radicals formed in brain tissue after an oxidative insult may give strong supporting evidence for the free radical theory of aging.     

Ginkgo biloba extract EGb 761 protects against mitochondrial aging in the brain and in the liver.

According to the free radical theory of aging, oxygen-derived free radicals causes the age-associated impairment at the cellular and tissue levels. The mitochondrial theory of aging points to mitochondria, and specially mitochondrial DNA, as the major targets of free radical attack upon aging. Thus, oxidative damage to mtDNA accumulate with age in human and rodent tissues and also is inversely related to maximum life span of mammals. Mitochondrial deficits, such as a decrease in mitochondrial membrane potential, occur upon aging due to oxidative damage. The age-related mitochondrial oxidative stress may be prevented by late onset administration of certain antioxidants, such as Ginkgo biloba extract EGb 761. These antioxidants may also delay the physiological impairment associated with aging.     

Deleterious mitochondrial DNA mutations accumulate in aging human tissues.

This paper reviews the current state of knowledge of the contribution of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations to the phenotype of aging. Its major focus is on the discovery of deletions of mtDNA which previously were thought to occur only in individuals with neuromuscular disease. One particular deletion (mtDNA4977) accumulates with age primarily in non-dividing cells such as muscle and brain of normal individuals. The level of the deletion rises with age by more than 1000 fold in heart and brain and to a lesser extent in other tissues. In the brain, different regions have substantially different levels of the deletion. High levels of accumulation of the deletion in tissues are correlated with high oxygen consumption. We speculate that oxidative damage to mtDNA may be 'catastrophic'; mutations affecting mitochondrially encoded polypeptides involved in electron transport could increase free radical generation leading to more mtDNA damage.     

Effects of chronic irradiation on age-related biochemical changes in mice

Some of the biochemical indices relevant to the "free radical theory" of aging have been assessed in mice subjected to chronic low-dose whole-body irradiation. Radiation exposure results in enhanced accumulation of the lipofuscins in brain, heart, and intestine. In these animals, the degree of lipoperoxidation in liver was greatly increased, as were the free activities of acid phosphatase and cathespin, indicating damage to lysosomal membranes. The activity of SOD in brain and liver 20,000g post-mitochondrial supernatants was lower in the irradiated mice. All these changes arising from chronic whole-body irradiation are similar to those observed during aging and are effectively prevented by dietary supplementation with BHT. These observations lend considerable support to the "free radical theory" of aging.     

Plasma Antioxidants and Human Aging: A Study on Healthy Elderly Tunisian Population

The aging has been described by several theories. It was proposed that free radicals are the major factor involved in this process. This gave birth to the free radical theory of aging. This current theory provides the most popular explanation for how aging occurs at the biochemical/molecular level. Ever since 1956, this theory has received widespread attention and a large body of evidence has been accumulated in support of its hypotheses which were subsequently refined. The free radical theory of aging postulates that age-associated reductions in physiological functions are caused by an irreversible accumulation of oxidative alterations to macromolecules. This accumulation increases with age and is associated with the life expectancy of organisms. Moreover, this theory suggests the existence of an imbalance between reactive oxygen species (ROS)-producing pathways and (ROS)-scavenging pathways, which is responsible for the generation of oxidative stress syndrome. In this article, we evaluate the antioxidant status in a population of healthy elderly Tunisians in comparison with a group of healthy young Tunisian subjects. This study sets out to investigate the age-related changes in glutathione peroxidase (GPx), superoxide dismutase (SOD) activities, and in total antioxidant status (TAS) of human plasma. We have concluded that healthy aging is accompanied with a disturbed antioxidant status.     

Organismal Aging and Oxidants beyond Macromolecules Damage

The relationship between oxidants and organismal aging was first articulated through the free radical theory of aging. One of the major predictions of the free radical theory of aging is that oxidative stress shortens organisms’ lifespan because of an increased level of oxidants, which are damaging to macromolecules. However, challenging the role of oxidants in age‐related diseases, there is now sufficient evidence that antioxidant supplements do not provide significant health benefits. Interestingly, in addition to an increase in oxidant‐mediated macromolecules damage, there is convincing experimental data to support the role of senescent cells in the process of aging. Here, the current knowledge regarding the role of oxidants and cellular senescence in organismal aging is reviewed and it is proposed that, in addition to the role of oxidants as inducers of macromolecular damage, oxidants may also function as regulators of signaling pathways involved in the establishment of cellular senescence. If this role for oxidants is established, it may be necessary to modify the free radical theory of aging from “Organisms age because cells accumulate reactive oxygen species‐dependent damage over time” to: “Organisms age because cells accumulate oxidants’‐dependent damage and oxidants’‐dependent senescent characteristics over time.”     

Maintenance of cellular ATP level by caloric restriction correlates chronological survival of budding yeast

The free radical theory of aging emphasizes cumulative oxidative damage in the genome and intracellular proteins due to reactive oxygen species (ROS), which is a major cause for aging. Caloric restriction (CR) has been known as a representative treatment that prevents aging; however, its mechanism of action remains elusive. Here, we show that CR extends the chronological lifespan (CLS) of budding yeast by maintaining cellular energy levels. CR reduced the generation of total ROS and mitochondrial superoxide; however, CR did not reduce the oxidative damage in proteins and DNA. Subsequently, calorie-restricted yeast had higher mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP), and it sustained consistent ATP levels during the process of chronological aging. Our results suggest that CR extends the survival of the chronologically aged cells by improving the efficiency of energy metabolism for the maintenance of the ATP level rather than reducing the global oxidative damage of proteins and DNA.     

Rate of generation of oxidative stress-related damage and animal longevity

Comparative studies about the relationship between endogenous antioxidant and pro-oxidant factors and maximum longevity of different animal species are reviewed. The majority of studies on antioxidant supplementation indicate that it can increase mean survival without changing maximum longevity. On the other hand, endogenous antioxidants are negatively correlated with maximum longevity. The same is true for the rates of mitochondrial oxygen radical generation, oxidative damage to mitochondrial DNA, and the degree of fatty acid unsaturation of cellular membranes in postmitotic tissues. The lower rate of mitochondrial oxygen radical generation of long-lived animals in relation to that of short-lived ones can be a primary cause of their slow aging rate. This is secondarily complemented in long-lived animals with low rates of lipid peroxidation due to their low degrees of fatty acid unsaturation. These two traits suggest that the rate of generation of endogenous oxidative damage determines, at least in part, the rate of aging in animals.     

Aging in vertebrates,and the effect of caloric restriction: a mitochondrial free radical production–DNA damage mechanism?

Oxygen is toxic to aerobic animals because it is univalently reduced inside cells to oxygen free radicals. Studies dealing with the relationship between oxidative stress and aging in different vertebrate species and in caloric-restricted rodents are discussed in this review. Healthy tissues mainly produce reactive oxygen species (ROS) at mitochondria. These ROS can damage cellular lipids, proteins and, most importantly, DNA. Although antioxidants help to control this oxidative stress in cells in general, they do not decrease the rate of aging, because their concentrations are lower in long- than in short-lived animals and because increasing antioxidant levels does not increase vertebrate maximum longevity. However, long-lived homeothermic vertebrates consistently have lower rates of mitochondrial ROS production and lower levels of steady-state oxidative damage in their mitochondrial DNA than short-lived ones. Caloric-restricted rodents also show lower levels of these two key parameters than controls fed ad libitum. The decrease in mitochondrial ROS generation of the restricted animals has been recently localized at complex I and the mechanism involved is related to the degree of electronic reduction of the complex I ROS generator. Strikingly, the same site and mechanism have been found when comparing a long- with a short-lived animal species. It is suggested that a low rate of mitochondrial ROS generation extends lifespan both in long-lived and in caloric-restricted animals by determining the rate of oxidative attack and accumulation of somatic mutations in mitochondrial DNA.