Building ‘validated’ mouse models of human cancer

As a model system for the understanding of human cancer, the mouse has proved immensely valuable. Indeed, studies of mouse models have helped to define the nature of cancer as a genetic disease and demonstrated the causal role of genetic events found in tumors. As the scientific and medical community's understanding of human cancer becomes more sophisticated, however, limitations and potential weaknesses of existing models are revealed. How valid are these murine models for the understanding and treatment of human cancer? The answer, it appears, depends on the nature of the research requirement. Certain models are better suited for particular applications. Using novel molecular tools and genetic strategies, improved models have recently been described that accurately mimic many aspects of human cancer.     

实验小鼠在癌症研究中的应用及其进展

小鼠是生物医学研究中使用数量最多的哺乳类实验动物。人类利用小鼠模型进行癌症研究已有100多年的历史,小鼠大量的遗传变异可作为研究人类癌症的借鉴。特别是近年来,培育成功的转基因、基因敲除等遗传工程小鼠模型,使我们对人类癌症发生有了深刻的认识,为评估癌症的诊断方法,革新预防和治疗方案提供了一个很有价值的平台。本文着重介绍了癌症研究中常用的小鼠模型、GEM模型及取得的最新进展等,分析了小鼠肿瘤模型的局限性,并对其发展趋势进行展望。     

The right time,the right place: will targeting human cancer-associated mutations to the mouse provide the perfect preclinical model?

Over the past 10 years the realisation that genetic mouse models of cancer may play a key role in preclinical drug development has gained strong momentum. Moreover sequencing studies of human tumours have provided key insights into the mutational complexity of epithelial cancer, unleashing important clues for researchers to generate accurate genetically engineered mouse (GEM) models of cancer. Thus by targeting multiple cancer associated human mutations to the appropriate murine epithelia, mice develop tumours that more closely recapitulate the human disease. As a number of excellent models now exist, the next 5-10 years will ascertain whether these models will predict response of human cancer to intervention. If so they might become the 'gold standard' where all drugs are required to be tested in mouse models of disease before proceeding into the patient. However, although this principle is very attractive, it is relatively untested and here, using examples of prevalent human cancers, we will review the latest data on preclinical GEM studies and comment on what challenges are left to overcome.     

Mammary gland neoplasia: insights from transgenic mouse models

Current theories of breast cancer progression have been greatly influenced by the development and refinement of mouse transgenic and gene targeting technologies. Early transgenic mouse models confirmed the involvement of oncogenes, previously implicated in human breast cancer, by establishing a causal relationship between overexpression or activation of these genes and mammary tumorigenesis. More recently, the importance of genes located at sites of loss of heterozygosity in human breast cancer have been examined in mice by their targeted disruption via homologous recombination. The union of these two approaches allows the generation of complex animal models that more accurately reflect the multistep nature of human breast cancer. This review will examine how the study of transgenic mice has increased our understanding of the molecular events responsible for oncogenic transformation of the mammary gland. BioEssays 22:554-563, 2000.     

Adult lung stem cells and their contribution to lung tumourigenesis

The isolation and characterization of lung stem and progenitor cells represent an important step towards the understanding of lung repair after injury, lung disease pathogenesis and the identification of the target cells of transformation in lung carcinogenesis. Different approaches using prospective isolation of progenitor cells by flow cytometry or lineage-tracing experiments in mouse models of lung injury have led to the identification of distinct progenitor subpopulations in different morphological regions of the adult lung. Genetically defined mouse models of lung cancer are offering new perspectives on the cells of origin of different subtypes of lung cancer. These mouse models pave the way to further investigate human lung progenitor cells at the origin of lung cancers, as well as to define the nature of the lung cancer stem cells. It will be critical to establish the link between oncogenic driver mutations recently discovered in lung cancers, target cells of transformation and subtypes of lung cancers to enable better stratification of patients for improved therapeutic strategies.     

Tissue-specific apoptotic effects of the p53 codon 72 polymorphism in a mouse model

Currently there are several dozen human polymorphisms that have been loosely associated with cancer risk. Correlating such variants with cancer risk has been challenging, primarily due to factors such as genetic heterogeneity, contributions of diet and environmental factors, and the difficulty in obtaining large sample sizes for analysis. Such difficulties can be circumvented with the establishment of mouse models for human variants. Recently, several groups have modeled human cancer susceptibility polymorphisms in the mouse. Remarkably, in each case these mouse models have accurately reflected human phenotypes, and clarified the contribution of these variants to cancer risk. We recently reported on a mouse model for the codon 72 polymorphism in p53, and found that this polymorphism regulates the ability to cooperate with NF-kB and induce apoptosis. Here-in we present evidence that this polymorphism impacts the apoptotic function of p53 in a tissue-specific manner; such tissue-specific effects of polymorphic variants represent an added challenge to human cancer risk association studies. The data presented here support the premise that modeling human polymorphisms in the mouse represents a powerful tool to assess the impact of these variants on cancer risk, progression and therapy.     

The utility of Apc-mutant rats in modeling human colon cancer

Prior to the advent of genetic engineering in the mouse, the rat was the model of choice for investigating the etiology of cancer. Now, recent advances in the manipulation of the rat genome, combined with a growing recognition of the physiological differences between mice and rats, have reignited interest in the rat as a model of human cancer. Two recently developed rat models, the polyposis in the rat colon (Pirc) and Kyoto Apc Delta (KAD) strains, each carry mutations in the intestinal-cancer-associated adenomatous polyposis coli (Apc) gene. In contrast to mouse models carrying Apc mutations, in which cancers develop mainly in the small intestine rather than in the colon and there is no gender bias, these rat models exhibit colonic predisposition and gender-specific susceptibility, as seen in human colon cancer. The rat also provides other experimental resources as a model organism that are not provided by the mouse: the structure of its chromosomes facilitates the analysis of genomic events, the size of its colon permits longitudinal analysis of tumor growth, and the size of biological samples from the animal facilitates multiplexed molecular analyses of the tumor and its host. Thus, the underlying biology and experimental resources of these rat models provide important avenues for investigation. We anticipate that advances in disease modeling in the rat will synergize with resources that are being developed in the mouse to provide a deeper understanding of human colon cancer.KEY WORDS: APC, Allelic series, Animal models, Colorectal cancer     

Modeling disease in the mouse: lessons from DNA damage response and cell cycle control genes

The advent of gene targeting has allowed the dissection of many essential cellular pathways, including those involved in cell cycle regulation, signal transduction, and development. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that the simple gene deletion strategy may not be sufficient for the modeling of many cancer syndromes. In this Prospect article, we will discuss the strengths and weaknesses of mouse models, how they have advanced from gene deletions to truncations, point mutations, and conditional mouse models in which expression or loss of the gene of interest is controlled either temporally or spatially. We will also consider future directions for the use of mouse models in cancer. The vastness of the field necessitates focusing on a few specific examples with the unfortunate exclusion of many excellent studies from our discussion. As such, we focus on a few specific models of human cancer syndromes, however many of the themes discussed here are applicable to other systems of genetic manipulation and may be applied across fields.     

Phosphorylation of the mRNA cap-binding protein eIF4E and cancer

Dysregulated protein synthesis is frequently involved in oncogenesis and cancer progression. Translation initiation is thought to be the rate-limiting step in protein synthesis, and the mRNA 5′ cap-binding protein eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E (eIF4E) is a pivotal factor that initiates translation. The activities of eIF4E are regulated at multiple levels, one of which is through its phosphorylation at Serine 209 by the mitogen-activated protein kinase-interacting kinases (MNKs, including MNK1 and MNK2). Benefiting from novel mouse genetic tools and pharmacological MNK inhibitors, our understanding of a role for eIF4E phosphorylation in tumor biology and cancer therapy has greatly evolved in recent years. Importantly, recent studies have found that the level of eIF4E phosphorylation is frequently upregulated in a wide variety of human cancer types, and phosphorylation of eIF4E drives a number of important processes in cancer biology, including cell transformation, proliferation, apoptosis, metastasis and angiogenesis. The MNK-eIF4E axis is being assessed as a therapeutic target either alone or in combination with other therapies in different cancer models. As novel MNK inhibitors are being developed, experimental studies bring new hope to cure human cancers that are not responsive to traditional therapies. Herein we review recent progress on our understanding of a mechanistic role for phosphorylation of eIF4E in cancer biology and therapy.     

Mouse cancer models as a platform for performing preclinical therapeutic trials

Engineering cancer-associated mutations into the mouse germline is an important tool for biological studies of growth control and tumorigenesis. Tractable models of many human cancers now exist in which the initiating genetic lesions have been elucidated and, in some instances, where the cooperating lesions are also known. The urgent need for more effective strategies for treating human cancer has stimulated interest in harnessing these models to test therapeutic agents. Although the ultimate value of genetically engineered mouse models for cancer drug discovery is unknown, several encouraging experiments provide proof of principle.     

Probing p53 biological functions through the use of genetically engineered mouse models

The p53 tumor suppressor gene is rendered dysfunctional in the majority of human cancers. To model the effects of p53 dysfunction in an experimentally manipulable organismal context, genetically engineered inbred mice have been the models of choice. Transgenic and knock-out technologies have been utilized to generate an array of different p53 germ line alterations. As expected, many (though not all) of the mutant p53 mouse models are susceptible to enhanced spontaneous and carcinogen-induced tumors of a variety of types. A number of different variables affect the incidence and spectrum of tumors in p53 mutant mice. These include strain background, the nature of the p53 mutation, the presence of wild-type p53 (in addition to mutant p53), exposure to physical and chemical mutagens, or introduction of other cancer-associated genes into the mutant p53 background. In addition to their role in furthering our understanding of the mechanisms of cancer initiation and progression, these models have led to unexpected insights into p53 function in embryogenesis and aging. With the development of ever more sophisticated methods for manipulating the mouse genome, new p53 models are on the horizon, which should deliver advances that will provide not only important mechanistic insights but also discoveries of great clinical relevance.     

Tissue-specific apoptotic effects of the p53 codon 72 polymorphism in a mouse model

Currently there are several dozen human polymorphisms that have been loosely associated with cancer risk. Correlating such variants with cancer risk has been challenging, primarily due to factors such as genetic heterogeneity, contributions of diet and environmental factors, and the difficulty in obtaining large sample sizes for analysis. Such difficulties can be circumvented with the establishment of mouse models for human variants. Recently, several groups have modeled human cancer susceptibility polymorphisms in the mouse. Remarkably, in each case these mouse models have accurately reflected human phenotypes, and clarified the contribution of these variants to cancer risk. We recently reported on a mouse model for the codon 72 polymorphism in p53, and found that this polymorphism regulates the ability to cooperate with NFκB and induce apoptosis. Here-in we present evidence that this polymorphism impacts the apoptotic function of p53 in a tissue-specific manner; such tissue-specific effects of polymorphic variants represent an added challenge to human cancer risk association studies. The data presented here support the premise that modeling human polymorphisms in the mouse represents a powerful tool to assess the impact of these variants on cancer risk, progression and therapy.Key words: p53, polymorphism, apoptosis, codon 72, NFκB     

Genomically humanized mice: technologies and promises

Mouse models have become an invaluable tool for understanding human health and disease owing to our ability to manipulate the mouse genome exquisitely. Recent progress in genomic analysis has led to an increase in the number and type of disease-causing mutations detected and has also highlighted the importance of non-coding regions. As a result, there is increasing interest in creating 'genomically' humanized mouse models, in which entire human genomic loci are transferred into the mouse genome. The technical challenges towards achieving this aim are large but are starting to be tackled with success.     

A mouse model repository for cancer biomarker discovery

Early detection of cancer using biomarkers obtained from blood or other easily accessible tissues would have a significant impact on reducing cancer mortality. However, identifying new blood-based biomarkers has been hindered by the dynamic complexity of the human plasma proteome, confounded by genetic and environmental variability, and the scarcity of high quality controlled samples. In this report, we discuss a new paradigm for biomarker discovery through the use of mouse models. Inbred mouse models of cancer recapitulate many critical features of human cancer, while eliminating sources of environmental and genetic variability. The ability to collect samples from highly matched cases and controls under identical conditions further reduces variability which is critical for successful biomarker discovery. We describe the establishment of a repository containing tumor, plasma, urine, and other tissues from 10 different mouse models of human cancer, including two breast, two lung, two prostate, two gastrointestinal, one ovarian, and one skin tumor model. We present the overall design of this resource and its potential use by the research community for biomarker discovery.     

Comet assay as a tool to screen for mouse models with inherited radiation sensitivity

Recent in vivo and in vitro data of patients analyzed for genetic susceptibility to radiation during cancer therapy have shown structural changes in the chromosomes to be prevalent both in the patients being treated and in their immediate family members. As structural changes in chromosomes frequently lead to activation of proto-oncogenes and elimination of tumor-suppressor genes, they represent important mechanisms for the initiation of DNA repair processes and tumorigenesis. With the exception of rare genetic syndromes such as AT (Ataxia telangiectasia) or NBS (Nijmegen Breakage Syndrome), the background for the inheritance of genetic susceptibility to radiation is unknown. Recently, a large-scale genetic screen of mouse mutants has been established within the German Human Genome Project (Hrabè de Angelis and Balling 1998). The goal of this ENU (ENU: ethylnitrosourea) mutagenesis screen is the generation of mutant mice that will serve as animal models for human diseases and genetic susceptibility. In order to fully utilize the potential of a genetic screen of this magnitude, in which exploration for genes responsible for genomic instability and radiation sensitivity is to occur, it is necessary to establish a simple assay system that is amenable to automation. Hence, we are using the single-cell gel electrophoresis (comet assay) to detect mouse mutants that display a genetic susceptibility to ionizing radiation. We have established the analysis parameters in the comet assay which are currently used to detect radiation-sensitive mouse mutants and to control the variance within the mouse population in the ENU screen. The assay can be used to isolate genes that are responsible for DNA repair and radiation sensitivity in mouse and human. Received: 16 December 1999 / Accepted: 17 December 1999     

Understanding the Roles of FAK in Cancer: Inhibitors,Genetic Models,and New Insights

Focal adhesion kinase (FAK) is a protein tyrosine kinase that regulates cellular adhesion, motility, proliferation and survival in various types of cells. Interestingly, FAK is activated and/or overexpressed in advanced cancers, and promotes cancer progression and metastasis. For this reason, FAK became a potential therapeutic target in cancer, and small molecule FAK inhibitors have been developed and are being tested in clinical phase trials. These inhibitors have demonstrated to be effective by inducing tumor cell apoptosis in addition to reducing metastasis and angiogenesis. Furthermore, several genetic FAK mouse models have made advancements in understanding the specific role of FAK both in tumors and in the tumor environment. In this review, we discuss FAK inhibitors as well as genetic mouse models to provide mechanistic insights into FAK signaling and its potential in cancer therapy.     

Novel molecular and computational methods improve the accuracy of insertion site analysis in Sleeping Beauty-induced tumors

The recent development of the Sleeping Beauty (SB) system has led to the development of novel mouse models of cancer. Unlike spontaneous models, SB causes cancer through the action of mutagenic transposons that are mobilized in the genomes of somatic cells to induce mutations in cancer genes. While previous methods have successfully identified many transposon-tagged mutations in SB-induced tumors, limitations in DNA sequencing technology have prevented a comprehensive analysis of large tumor cohorts. Here we describe a novel method for producing genetic profiles of SB-induced tumors using Illumina sequencing. This method has dramatically increased the number of transposon-induced mutations identified in each tumor sample to reveal a level of genetic complexity much greater than previously appreciated. In addition, Illumina sequencing has allowed us to more precisely determine the depth of sequencing required to obtain a reproducible signature of transposon-induced mutations within tumor samples. The use of Illumina sequencing to characterize SB-induced tumors should significantly reduce sampling error that undoubtedly occurs using previous sequencing methods. As a consequence, the improved accuracy and precision provided by this method will allow candidate cancer genes to be identified with greater confidence. Overall, this method will facilitate ongoing efforts to decipher the genetic complexity of the human cancer genome by providing more accurate comparative information from Sleeping Beauty models of cancer.     

Genetic analysis of Down syndrome facilitated by mouse chromosome engineering

Human trisomy 21 is the most frequent live-born human aneuploidy and causes a constellation of disease phenotypes classified as Down syndrome, which include heart defects, myeloproliferative disorder, cognitive disabilities and Alzheimer-type neurodegeneration. Because these phenotypes are associated with an extra copy of a human chromosome, the genetic analysis of Down syndrome has been a major challenge. To complement human genetic approaches, mouse models have been generated and analyzed based on evolutionary conservation between the human and mouse genomes. These efforts have been greatly facilitated by Cre/loxP-mediated mouse chromosome engineering, which may result in the establishment of minimal critical genomic regions and eventually new dosage-sensitive genes associated with Down syndrome phenotypes. The success in genetic analysis of Down syndrome will further enhance our understanding of this disorder and lead to better strategies in developing effective therapeutic interventions.     

The use of genetically engineered mouse models of prostate cancer for nutrition and cancer chemoprevention research

The ability to modify the expression of specific genes in the mouse through genetic engineering technologies allows for the generation of previously unavailable models for prostate cancer prevention research. Although animal models have existed for some time for the study of prostate cancer prevention (primarily in the rat), it is uncertain if the mechanisms that drive prostate carcinogenesis in these models are relevant to those in human prostate cancer. Cell culture studies are of limited usefulness because the conditions are inherently artificial. Factors such as relevant physiologic concentrations and metabolism of putative chemoprevention compounds are difficult to model in an in vitro system. These studies also preclude the types of interactions known to occur between multiple cell types in vivo. In addition, all prostate cancer cell lines are already highly progressed and are not representative of the type of cells to which most preventive strategies would be targeted. Due to the advent of genetically engineered mouse (GEM) models, we now have models of prostate cancer that are dependent on molecular mechanisms already implicated in human prostate carcinogenesis. With these models we can perform a variety of experiments that could previously only be done in cell culture or in prostate cancer cell line xenografts. The currently available GEM models of prostate cancer have been extensively reviewed therefore, this review will focus on the types of models available and their usefulness for various types of preclinical studies relevant to prostate cancer prevention.