Muscle development in the grasshopper embryo. III. Sequential origin of the flexor tibiae muscle pioneers

The flexor (FlTi) and extensor (ETi) tibiae are antagonist muscles located in the femur of the metathoracic leg of the grasshopper. Both are complex, consisting of an array of bundles of muscle fibers connecting the ectoderm of the wall of the femur with their respective apodemes. In the previous paper (E. E. Ball and C. S. Goodman, 1985, Dev. Biol. 111, 399-416) we described the embryonic development of the ETi muscle, focusing in particular on its syncytial origin from a giant supramuscle pioneer which later divides into an array of individual muscle pioneers. Here we describe the embryonic development of the FlTi muscle. In contrast to the development of the ETi muscle, the array of individual muscle pioneers for the FlTi does not have a syncytial origin but rather arises by sequential recruitment from the mass of smaller, undifferentiated mesoderm cells. The FlTi MPs first appear as two cells symmetrically placed on the corners of the FlTi apodeme at around 37%. A third MP is then added between these two; this third MP later dies. Subsequent growth occurs by symmetrical addition of MPs distally along the sides of the developing apodeme and by enlargement of the individual MPs. Initially each MP contains only a single nucleus; by about 50% there are at least two to three nuclei per MP and each is surrounded by a cluster of smaller, undifferentiated mesoderm cells. Each MP develops into a bundle of muscle fibers by a cycle of fusion and division. The individual mesoderm cells surrounding each MP fuse with it starting at about 60%. At the same time, the large MP begins to divide into smaller muscle fibers.     

Muscle development in the grasshopper embryo. I. Muscles, nerves, and apodemes in the metathoracic leg

Much is known about the development of nerve pathways in the metathoracic limb bud of the grasshopper embryo. In this series of three papers, we report on the development of muscles in the same embryonic appendage. In a fourth paper (E. E. Ball, R. K. Ho, and C. S. Goodman, 1985, J. Neurosci, in press) we examine the development of specific neuromuscular connections for one of these muscles (coxal muscle 133a). In this first paper, we present an overview of the development of muscles, nerves, and apodemes (tendons). We previously reported on a class of large mesodermal cells, called muscle pioneers (MPs), that arises early in development and appears to act as a scaffold for developing muscles and guidance cue for motoneuron growth cones (R. K. Ho, E. E. Ball, and C. S. Goodman, 1983, Nature (London) 301, 66-69). We have used the I-5 monoclonal antibody (which specifically labels the MPs as well as the nerve pathways), HRP immunocytochemistry, and Normarski optics to visualize muscle, nerve, and apodeme development in the embryonic metathoracic limb bud from 27.5% (before the appearance of the MPs) to 55% (after the muscles have attained their basic adult pattern). Cell fusions, cell migration, and cell death all appear to play important roles in the development of MPs. The patterns of muscle development vary greatly, ranging from (i) single MPs for simple muscles (which in the adult have only one bundle of muscle fibers, e.g., coxal muscle 133a), to (ii) arrays of MPs for complex muscles [which in the adult have many bundles of muscle fibers each with separate sites of insertion, e.g., the extensor tibiae (ETi) and flexor tibiae (FlTi) muscles in the femur].     

The occurrence of intercellular bridges in groups of cells exhibiting synchronous differentiation

A previous electron microscopic study of the cat testis revealed that spermatids derived from the same spermatogonium are joined together by intercellular bridges. The present paper records the observation of similar connections between spermatocytes and between spermatids in Hydra, fruit-fly, opossum, pigeon, rat, hamster, guinea pig, rabbit, monkey, and man. In view of these findings, it is considered likely that a syncytial relationship within groups of developing male germ cells is of general occurrence and is probably responsible for their synchronous differentiation. When clusters of spermatids, freshly isolated from the germinal epithelium are observed by phase contrast microscopy, the constrictions between the cellular units of the syncytium disappear and the whole group coalesces into a spherical multinucleate mass. The significance of this observation in relation to the occurrence of abnormal spermatozoa in semen and the prevalence of multinucleate giant cells in pathological testes is discussed. In the ectoderm of Hydra, the clusters of cnidoblasts that arise from proliferation of interstitial cells are also connected by intercellular bridges. The development of nematocysts within these groups of conjoined cells is precisely synchronized. Both in the testis of vertebrates and the ectoderm of Hydra, a syncytium results from incomplete cytokinesis in the proliferation of relatively undifferentiated cells. The intercellular bridges between daughter cells are formed when the cleavage furrow encounters the spindle remnant and is arrested by it. The subsequent dissolution of the spindle filaments establishes free communication between the cells. The discovery of intercellular bridges in the two unrelated tissues discussed here suggests that a similar syncytial relationship may be found elsewhere in nature where groups of cells of common origin differentiate synchronously.     

The Occurrence of Intercellular Bridges in Groups of Cells Exhibiting Synchronous Differentiation

A previous electron microscopic study of the cat testis revealed that spermatids derived from the same spermatogonium are joined together by intercellular bridges. The present paper records the observation of similar connections between spermatocytes and between spermatids in Hydra, fruit-fly, opossum, pigeon, rat, hamster, guinea pig, rabbit, monkey, and man. In view of these findings, it is considered likely that a syncytial relationship within groups of developing male germ cells is of general occurrence and is probably responsible for their synchronous differentiation. When clusters of spermatids, freshly isolated from the germinal epithelium are observed by phase contrast microscopy, the constrictions between the cellular units of the syncytium disappear and the whole group coalesces into a spherical multinucleate mass. The significance of this observation in relation to the occurrence of abnormal spermatozoa in semen and the prevalence of multinucleate giant cells in pathological testes is discussed. In the ectoderm of Hydra, the clusters of cnidoblasts that arise from proliferation of interstitial cells are also connected by intercellular bridges. The development of nematocysts within these groups of conjoined cells is precisely synchronized. Both in the testis of vertebrates and the ectoderm of Hydra, a syncytium results from incomplete cytokinesis in the proliferation of relatively undifferentiated cells. The intercellular bridges between daughter cells are formed when the cleavage furrow encounters the spindle remnant and is arrested by it. The subsequent dissolution of the spindle filaments establishes free communication between the cells. The discovery of intercellular bridges in the two unrelated tissues discussed here suggests that a similar syncytial relationship may be found elsewhere in nature where groups of cells of common origin differentiate synchronously.     

Morphogenesis of the chick embryo limb. Competence of the embryonic and extra-embryonic ectoderm

Ecto-mesodermal interactions were investigated during the initiation of limb development in avian embryos. Experiments were performed on 2-day chick embryos. They consisted in implanting prospective leg mesoderm at different medio-lateral levels of the trunk and also into the extra-embryonic area. The implanted mesoderm was thus brought into contact with embryonic or extra-embryonic cicatricial or healing ectoderm, the ability of which to participate in the formation of an ectopic leg was tested. Whatever the level of embryonic ectoderm tested in hosts ranging from stage 14 to 27 pairs of somites (axial, paraxial, flank, ventrum), the experiments resulted in the formation of supernumerary limbs. Their frequency was level-dependent and decreased for each level, with increasing age of the host. The weakest competence was observed in the ectoderm of the prospective ventrum, the strongest in that of the prospective flank, axial and paraxial ectoderm showing an intermediary competence. Extra-embryonic ectoderm of blastoderms of the same age was unable to respond to the inducing action of the implanted prospective leg mesoderm. It was found to be incompetent, even at younger stages (5 to 13 pairs of somites).     

Cystid Structure and Protrusion of the Polypide in Crisia (Bryozoa, Cyclostomata)

The ultrastructure of the cystid of Crisia eburnea has been studied. The cystid wall comprises an outer periostracum, a calcified layer and one inner cell layer, the ectoderm. The membranous sac, which consists of an outer basement membrane, a series of very thin annular muscle cells and an inner layer of epithelial cells, is interpreted as the detached mesoderm of the cystid wall. Accordingly, the atrial sphincter and the generally eight branched, longitudinal muscle cells connecting the terminal membrane and the membranous sac are interpreted as ectoderm. The membranous sac is attached to the cystid wall with two lateral ligaments and at four abfrontal areas: 1) a wide distal area, 2) an area at the origin of the retractor muscles, 3) a small area between 1 and 2, and 4) a small basal area at the origin of a pair of small muscle cells attached to the lowermost part of the caecum.
We infer that the protrusion of the polypide is caused by a sequential contraction of the annular muscle cells of the membranous sac, starting basally and aided by the contraction of the longitudinal ectodermal muscle cells.     

Mesoderm induction by the mesoderm of Xenopus neurulae

Combinations were made between explants of mesoderm from the archenteron roof of early Xenopus neurulae and explants of ectoderm from mid-blastulae. In each combination one component was labeled with the fluorescent lineage label RDA (rhodamine-dextran-amine). Frequent and large mesoderm inductions, consisting mainly of muscle, were found where the presomite plate was used as the inducer. Less frequent and smaller mesoderm inductions were found when notochord was used as the inducer. We conclude that induced mesoderm can itself be active as a mesoderm inducing tissue. If this capability is acquired in the blastula then it follows that mesoderm induction must propagate from cell to cell and its spread be antagonized by some other factor.     

NERVOUS ORGANIZATION AND THE PROBLEM OF THE SYNAPSE IN ACTINIA EQUINA

The nervous system of Actinia equina was studied by routinehistological methods and by metallic impregnation techniques.Some preliminary results from electron microscopy are included. The organization of the nervous system of this species is morecomplex than that of other anthozoans; it consists of two interconnectednerve plexuses which are developed to differing degrees in variousparts of the body. These are: (1) a superficial (outer) plexuslying in the ectoderm, and (2) a deeper (inner) plexus constitutingthe main nerve net, lying in the mesoderm. The former is composedof bipolar and multipolar nerve cells, and the latter of multipolarcells. Receptor cells in the ectoderm make contact with fibersof the ectodermal plexus. Processes from the mesodermal plexusrun out to the muscle fibers. Connections between the receptor cells and the nerve processesof the superficial plexus and between the processes of the cteeperplexus and the muscle fibers appear to be of the discontinuous(synaptic) type. In the nerve nets themselves, although someconnections resembling synapses have been seen, most of thenerve elements stand in direct connection with one another,so that the system must be regarded as at least partly syncytial.Evidence is given for the growth of the nerve net, in step withthe general growth of the animal, by division of nuclei followedby their movement apart within the syncytium. The distribution of the nerve elements in various parts of thebody, the interconnections between these regions, and the cytologicalcharacteristics of the cells are described. Ways in which excitationcould pass from one part to another are discussed.     

Potential and current distributions in a cylindrical bundle of cardiac tissue.

The intracellular and interstitial potentials associated with each cell or fiber in multicellular preparations carrying a uniformly propagating wave are important for characterizing the electrophysiological behavior of the preparation and in particular, for evaluating the source contributed by each fiber. The aforementioned potentials depend on a number of factors including the conductivities characterizing the intracellular, interstitial, and extracellular domains, the thickness of the tissue, and the distance (depth) of the field point from the surface of the tissue. A model study is presented describing the extracellular and interstitial potential distribution and current flow in a cylindrical bundle of cardiac muscle arising from a planar wavefront. For simplicity, the bundle is considered as a bidomain. Using typical values of conductivity, the results show that the intracellular and interstitial potential of fibers near the center of a very large bundle (greater than 10 mm) may be approximated by the potentials of a single fiber surrounded by a limited extracellular space (a fiber in oil), hence justifying a core-conductor model. For smaller bundles, the peak interstitial potential is less than that predicted by the core-conductor model but still large enough to affect the overall source strength. The magnitude of the source strength is greatest for fibers lying near the center of the bundle and diminishes sharply for fibers within 50 microns of the surface.     

Embryonic development of the innervation of the locust extensor tibiae muscle by identified neurons: formation and elimination of inappropriate axon branches

Intracellular dye fills have been used to reveal the pattern of embryonic growth of each of the four neurons which innervate the extensor tibiae muscle (ETi) of the hind leg of the locust. The growth cone of the slow extensor tibiae motoneuron (SETi), the first of the four neurons to leave the central nervous system, pioneers nerve 3 (N3). The fast extensor motoneuron (FETi), the next neuron to grow out, follows earlier outgrowing motoneurons into the periphery in nerve 5 (N5) and then rejoins SETi in N3. As it transfers from N5 to N3, it is transiently dye-coupled to the Tr1 pioneer neuron which spans the gap between the two nerves. It then follows SETi onto the ETi muscle in the femur. The common inhibitory neuron and the dorsal unpaired median neuron (DUMETi) follow SETi and FETi in nerves 3B2 and 5B1, respectively. SETi's growth cone requires almost twice as long to reach ETi as those of the three later motoneurons, all of which follow preexisting neural pathways. At least three of the four developing motoneurons form one or more axon branches not found in the adult. These branches may occur (1) at segmental boundaries; (2) where the nerve, which the growth cone is following, itself branches or the growth cone encounters another nerve; or (3) when the axon continues to grow beyond its target muscle. These findings contrast with the apparent absence of inappropriate axon branches in another developing locust neuromuscular system and during the innervation of zebrafish myotomes, but resemble in some ways the transient production of inappropriate axonal branches reported for embryonic leech motoneurons.     

Ultrastructure of the pre-implantation shark yolk sac placenta

During ontogeny, the yolk sac of viviparous sharks differentiates into a yolk sac placenta which functions in gas exchange and hematrophic nutrient transport. The pre-implantation yolk sac functions in respiration and yolk absorption. In a 10.0 cm embryo, the yolk sac consists of six layers, viz. (1) somatic ectoderm; (2) somatic mesoderm; (3) extraembryonic coelom; (4) capillaries; (5) endoderm; and (6) yolk syncytium. The epithelial ectoderm is a simple cuboidal epithelium possessing the normal complement of cytoplasmic organelles. The endoplasmic cisternae are dilated and vesicular. The epithelium rests upon a basal lamina below which is a collagenous stroma that contains dense bodies of varying diameter. They have a dense marginal zone, a less dense core, and a dense center. The squamous mesoderm has many pinocytotic caveolae. The capillary endothelium is adjacent to the mesoderm and is delimited by a basal lamina. The endoderm contains yolk degradation vesicles whose contents range from pale to dense. The yolk syncytium contains many morphologically diverse yolk granules in all phases of degradation. Concentric membrane lamellae form around yolk bodies as the main yolk granules begin to be degraded. During degradation, yolk platelets exhibit a vesicular configuration.     

Polarization predicts the pattern of cellularization in cereal endosperm

Summary The endosperm of cereal grains develops as a multinucleate mass of wall-less cytoplasm (syncytium) that lines the periphery of the central cell before becoming cellular. The pattern of initial wall formation is precisely oriented and is followed by a round of precisely oriented formative cell division that gives rise to initials for the two tissues of endosperm. The initial anticlinal walls form at boundaries of nuclear-cytoplasmic domains (NCDs) defined by radial microtubules emanating from nuclei in the syncytium. Polarized growth of the NCDs in axes perpendicular to the embryo sac wall and centripetal elongation of the anticlinal walls results in a single layer of open ended alveoli overtopped by the remaining syncytial cytoplasm. This arboreal stage, so named because the elongate nucleate columns of cytoplasm resemble an orchard of trees, predicts the division polarity of the imminent formative division. Mitosis occurs as a wave which, like polarization, moves in both directions from ventral to dorsal. Spindles are oriented parallel to the long axis of the alveoli and cell plates give rise to periclinal walls. The outer daughter nuclei (aleurone initials) are thus completely enclosed by walls and the inner nuclei (starchy endosperm initials) are in alveoli adjacent to the central vacuole.     

Expression of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors in aneural Xenopus embryos

During gastrulation in vertebrate embryos, the mesoderm moves inward and under the ectoderm and these two cell layers subsequently differentiate in close proximity to each other, providing an opportunity for the exchange of inductive signals. This study examines whether the activation of muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) genes and the subsequent expression of receptors in Xenopus myotomal muscle are dependent on interaction between the ectoderm and the mesoderm, or their derivatives, after the onset of gastrulation. We eliminated such interaction by inducing total exogastrulation of Xenopus embryos. During exogastrulation, the mesoderm moves away from the ectoderm, and the nervous system fails to develop. Single channel recordings from the myotomal muscle of exogastrulated embryos revealed the presence of two major classes of AChRs, which could be distinguished on the basis of channel conductance. The current amplitudes, conductances, reversal potentials, and open times of these channels closely resembled those reported for the two major classes of AChR channels normally expressed in vivo. We conclude that interaction between ectoderm and mesoderm following the onset of gastrulation is not required for the future expression of the major classes of AChRs in myotomal muscle.     

Experimental manipulation leading to induction of dorsal ectodermal ridges on normal limb buds results in a phenocopy of the eudiplopodia chick mutant

Elongation of chick limb buds depends on the presence of the apical ectodermal ridge which is induced by subjacent limb bud mesoderm. Recombination experiments have shown that the limb bud mesoderm loses the capacity to induce ridges by late stage 17. Moreover, in normal limb development only one ridge forms. However, in the eudiplopodia chick mutant accessory ectodermal ridges form on the dorsal surface of limb buds as late as stage 22. Tissue recombinant experiments show that the mutation affects the ectoderm, extending the time it responds to ridge induction (Fraser and Abbott, 1971a, Fraser and Abbott, 1971b while the mesoderm is normal. The result is polydactyly, with extra digits dorsal to the normal digits. Because eudiplopodia limb bud dorsal mesoderm can induce ridges at stage 22 but is unaffected by the gene, genetically normal dorsal limb bud mesoderm may also be able to induce ridges after stage 17. To test this possibility we grafted stages 14–18 flank ectoderm to normal limb bud dorsal mesoderm and found that mesoderm from stages 17 through 20 was able to induce a ridge and subsequently dorsal digits developed. Limbs with duplicate digits were similar to eudiplopodia limbs. In other experiments, stage 18, 19, and 20 leg bud dorsal ectoderm did not form ridges when grafted to leg bud dorsal mesoderm of the same stage, indicating a lack of response to the mesoderm. Finally, the inductive capacity of limb bud mesoderm appeared to be reduced compared to mesoderm at pre-limb bud stages. These experiments demonstrate a spatially generalized potential in limb bud dorsal mesoderm to induce ridges during the stages when the apical ridge is induced. The determination of where the ridge will form and the acquired inability of limb bud dorsal ectoderm to respond to induction by underlying mesoderm are necessary early pattern forming events which assure that a single proximodistal limb axis will form.     

The ectodermal control of mesodermal patterns of differentiation in the developing chick wing

The influence of limb ectoderm on the dorso-ventral muscle and skeletal patterns in the chick wing was studied by recombining stage 14-21 limb mesoderm with the same stage ectoderm in dorso-ventrally reversed orientation. Recombinants grafted to the flank of host embryos were allowed to develop for 10 days. Fully developed wings obtained from stage 15-21 donor embryos have at their distal half d-v polarity conforming to the reversed ectoderm and proximally polarity conforming with the mesoderm. The ectodermal effect is generally observed as a bidorsal feather pattern at the autopod and an almost complete d-v reversal of muscle and skeletal patterns. In experimental wings from donor embryos younger than stage 15, the dorso-ventral pattern conforms with the polarity of the limb mesoderm. The results suggest that control of dorso-ventral polarity resides in the mesoderm until the onset of limb development at stage 15. At this stage, the ectoderm acquires dorso-ventral information which it can impose on the mesoderm.     

The functional relationship between ectodermal and mesodermal segmentation in the crustacean, Parhyale hawaiensis

In arthropods, annelids and chordates, segmentation of the body axis encompasses both ectodermal and mesodermal derivatives. In vertebrates, trunk mesoderm segments autonomously and induces segmental arrangement of the ectoderm-derived nervous system. In contrast, in the arthropod Drosophila melanogaster, the ectoderm segments autonomously and mesoderm segmentation is at least partially dependent on the ectoderm. While segmentation has been proposed to be a feature of the common ancestor of vertebrates and arthropods, considering vertebrates and Drosophila alone, it is impossible to conclude whether the ancestral primary segmented tissue was the ectoderm or the mesoderm. Furthermore, much of Drosophila segmentation occurs before gastrulation and thus may not accurately represent the mechanisms of segmentation in all arthropods. To better understand the relationship between segmented germ layers in arthropods, we asked whether segmentation is an intrinsic property of the ectoderm and/or the mesoderm in the crustacean Parhyale hawaiensis by ablating either the ectoderm or the mesoderm and then assaying for segmentation in the remaining tissue layer. We found that the ectoderm segments autonomously. However, mesoderm segmentation requires at least a permissive signal from the ectoderm. Although mesodermal stem cells undergo normal rounds of division in the absence of ectoderm, they do not migrate properly in respect to migration direction and distance. In addition, their progeny neither divide nor express the mesoderm segmentation markers Ph-twist and Ph-Even-skipped. As segmentation is ectoderm-dependent in both Parhyale and holometabola insects, we hypothesize that segmentation is primarily a property of the ectoderm in pancrustacea.     

Mandible movements in ants.

Ants use their mandibles for almost any task, including prey-catching, fighting, leaf-cutting, brood care and communication. The key to the versatility of mandible functions is the mandible closer muscle. In ants, this muscle is generally composed of distinct muscle fiber types that differ in morphology and contractile properties. Fast contracting fibers have short sarcomeres (2-3 microm) and attach directly to the closer apodeme, that conveys the muscle power to the mandible joint. Slow but forceful contracting fibers have long sarcomeres (5-6 microm) and attach to the apodeme either directly or via thin thread-like filaments. Volume proportions of the fiber types are species-specific and correlate with feeding habits. Two biomechanical models explain why species that rely on fast mandible strikes, such as predatory ants, have elongated head capsules that accommodate long muscle fibers directly attached to the apodeme at small angles, whereas species that depend on forceful movements, like leaf-cutting ants, have broader heads and many filament-attached fibers. Trap-jaw ants feature highly specialized catapult mechanisms. Their mandible closing is known as one of the fastest movements in the animal kingdom. The relatively large number of motor neurons that control the mandible closer reflects the importance of this muscle for the behavior of ants as well as other insects.     

Xwnt-8 modifies the character of mesoderm induced by bFGF in isolated Xenopus ectoderm.

In Xenopus, growth factors of the TGF-beta, FGF and Wnt oncogene families have been proposed to play a role in generating embryonic pattern. In this paper we examine potential interactions between the bFGF and Xwnt-8 signaling pathways in the induction and dorsal-ventral patterning of mesoderm. Injection of Xwnt-8 mRNA into 2-cell Xenopus embryos does not induce mesoderm formation in animal cap ectoderm isolated from these embryos at the blastula stage, but alters the response of this tissue to mesoderm induction by bFGF. While animal cap explants isolated from non-injected embryos differentiate to form ventral types of mesoderm and muscle in response to bFGF, explants from Xwnt-8 injected embryos form dorsal mesodermal and neural tissues in response to the same concentration of bFGF, even if the ectoderm is isolated from the prospective ventral sides of embryos or from UV-ventralized animals. Our results support a model whereby dorso-ventral mesodermal patterning can be attained by a single mesoderm inducing agent, possibly bFGF, which is uniformly distributed across the prospective dorsal-ventral axis, and which acts in concert with a dorsally localized signal, possibly a Wnt protein, which either alters the response of ectoderm to induction or modifies the character of mesoderm after its induction.     

Ultrastructure of macrocyst formation in the cellular slime mold, Dictyostelium mucoroides: extensive phagocytosis of amoebae by a specialized cell

Macrocyst differentiation in Dictyostelium mucoroides was carried out in shaking flasks. Observations of the development of macrocysts were made by light and electron microscopy. Macrocyst development begins with the clumping of stationary phase amoebae. Subsequently, the clumps become subdivided into smaller masses, each surrounded by a fibrillar sheath. At the center of each mass there arises a cytophagic cell which proceeds to engulf in turn all the cells in the mass. The engulfed cells (endocytes) undergo drastic changes in their fine structure and eventually are transformed into granules. During the early stages of engulfment the cytophagic cell has a single large nucleus, but by the time all the cells have been converted to endocytes the cytophagic cell has become multinucleate. The multinucleate condition persists in the granular stage. The thick cellulose wall surrounding each macrocyst is produced by the cytophagic cell soon after it has engulfed all the cells in the mass and before the granular stage.     

Inhibitory effect on limb morphogenesis by cells of the polarizing zone coaggregated with pre- or postaxial wing bud mesoderm.

The influence of cells of the polarizing zone mesoderm on the morphogenesis of recombinant chick limbs was studied. The recombinant buds were composed of leg bud ectoderm and different regions of the wing bud mesoderm, which had been dissociated and reaggregated. In any case where the polarizing zone mesoderm was coaggregated with the wing mesoderm the morphogenetic capabilities of the recombinant were reduced. This was the case with postaxial mesoderm, preaxial mesoderm plus polarizing tissue, and postaxial mesoderm from which a piece of the nonpolarizing mesoderm (comparable in size to the polarizing zone) had been removed. All of these gave outgrowths with digits in only a very low percentage of cases. In contrast, those recombinants without polarizing mesoderm developed outgrowths with digits in a high percentage of cases, indicating good morphogenesis. Finally, if the polarizing zone were removed prior to dissociation, the recombinant limb, composed of the total remaining wing bud mesoderm plus leg bud ectoderm, exhibited a higher percentage of complete morphogenesis than if the polarizing zone had been part of the recombinant.It is clear that cells of the polarizing zone, when dissociated, and coaggregated with wing mesoderm, are inhibitory to the morphogenetic performance of that mesoderm in the recombinant limb situation.