Turn of Promotor DNA by cAMP Receptor Protein Characterized by Bead Model Simulation of Rotational Diffusion

Abstract

The rotation diffusion of DNA double helices and their complexes with the cAMP receptor protein (CRP) has been simulated by bead models, in order to derive information on their structure in solution by comparison with results obtained from dichroism decay measurements. Straight DNA double helices are simulated by linear, rigid strings of overlapping beads. The radius of the beads and the length of the string are increased simultaneously by the same increments from initial outer dimensions derived from crystallographic data to final values, which are fitted to experimental rotation time constants observed for short DNA fragments (< 100 bp). The final values reflect the solvated structure with the same ‘solvation layer’ added in all three dimensions. The protein is simulated by overlapping beads, which are assembled to a structure very similar to that found by x-ray crystallography. Complexes of the protein with DNA are formed with the centres of palindromic DNA sites at the centre of the two helix- turn-helix-motifs of the protein with some overlap of the two components. Simulation of the experimental data obtained for CRP complexes with specific DNA in the presence of cAMP requires strong bending of the double helices. According to our simulation the DNA is almost completely wrapped around the protein both in the complexes with a 62 bp fragment containing the standard CRP site and with a 80 bp fragment containing the second binding site of the lac operon. Simulations of the data obtained for a 203 bp fragment with both binding sites suggest that the two bound CRP proteins are in contact with each other and that the DNA is wrapped around the two protein dimers. A stereochemical model is suggested with a tetrahedral arrangement of the four protein subunits, which provides the advantage that two binding sites of the protein formed by two subunits each are located favorable for tight contacts to two binding sites on bent DNA provided that the DNA sites are separated by an integer number of helix turns. In summary, the simulations demonstrate strong bending, which can be reflected by an arc radius in the range around 50 Å. According to these data the overall bending angle of our longest DNA fragment is approximately 180°, and thus the protruding ends are sufficiently close to each other such that RNA polymerase, for example, could contact both helical segments.     

Turn of promotor DNA by cAMP receptor protein characterized by bead model simulation of rotational diffusion

The rotation diffusion of DNA double helices and their complexes with the cAMP receptor protein (CRP) has been simulated by bead models, in order to derive information on their structure in solution by comparison with results obtained from dichroism decay measurements. Straight DNA double helices are simulated by linear, rigid strings of overlapping beads. The radius of the beads and the length of the string are increased simultaneously by the same increments from initial outer dimensions derived from crystallographic data to final values, which are fitted to experimental rotation time constants observed for short DNA fragments (less than 100 bp). The final values reflect the solvated structure with the same 'solvation layer' added in all three dimensions. The protein is simulated by overlapping beads, which are assembled to a structure very similar to that found by x-ray crystallography. Complexes of the protein with DNA are formed with the centres of palindromic DNA sites at the centre of the two helix-turn-helix-motifs of the protein with some overlap of the two components. Simulation of the experimental data obtained for CRP complexes with specific DNA in the presence of cAMP requires strong bending of the double helices. According to our simulation the DNA is almost completely wrapped around the protein both in the complexes with a 62 bp fragment containing the standard CRP site and with a 80 bp fragment containing the second binding site of the lac operon. Simulations of the data obtained for a 203 bp fragment with both binding sites suggest that the two bound CRP proteins are in contact with each other and that the DNA is wrapped around the two protein dimers. A stereochemical model is suggested with a tetrahedral arrangement of the four protein subunits, which provides the advantage that two binding sites of the protein formed by two subunits each are located favorable for tight contacts to two binding sites on bent DNA, provided that the DNA sites are separated by an integer number of helix turns. In summary, the simulations demonstrate strong bending, which can be reflected by an arc radius in the range around 50 A. According to these data the overall bending angle of our longest DNA fragment is approximately 180 degrees, and thus the protruding ends are sufficiently close to each other such that RNA polymerase, for example, could contact both helical segments.     

Specific DNA binding of the cAMP receptor protein within the lac operon stabilizes double-stranded DNA in the presence of cAMP

The effects of varying amounts of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) in the presence and absence of cAMP on the melting and differential melting curves of a 301-bp fragment containing the lac control region in 5 mM Na+ have been investigated. The native 301-bp fragment consists of three cooperatively melting thermalites. At 5 mM Na+, thermalite I (155 bp) has a Tm of 66.4 degrees C and the melting transitions of thermalites II (81 bp) and III (65 bp) are superimposed with a Tm of 61.9 degrees C. The specific DNA target site for CRP and the lac promotor are located within thermalite II. CRP alone exerts no specific effects on the melting of the 301-bp fragment, non-specific DNA binding of CRP resulting in a progressive stabilization of the double-stranded DNA by increasing the number of base pairs melting at a higher Tm in a non-cooperative transition. The cAMP-CRP complex, however, exerts a specific effect with a region of approximately 36 bp, comprising the specific CRP binding site and a neighbouring region of DNA, being stabilized. The appearance of this new cooperatively melting region, known as thermalite IV, is associated with a corresponding decrease in the area of thermalites II/III. The Tm of thermalite IV is 64.4 degrees C, 2.5 degrees C higher than that of thermalites II/III. With two or more cAMP-CRP complexes bound per 301-bp fragment, the stabilization also affects the remaining 110 bp now making up thermalites II/III whose Tm is increased by 1 degrees C to 62.9 degrees C. The implications of these findings for various models of the mode of action of the cAMP-CRP complex are discussed.     

Sensitization of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein to trypsin cleavage by polydeoxyribonucleotides and polyribonucleotides

In the absence of cAMP the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) is relatively resistant to trypsin whereas the cAMP X CRP complex is attacked yielding N-terminal core fragments of 14,300 and 18,500 Da which still bind cAMP. The DNA X CRP complex formed at low ionic strength in the absence of cAMP is cleaved by trypsin with the formation of 9,700- and 6,000-Da fragments and the concomitant loss of cAMP binding activity. DNA X CRP remains as resistant to attack by subtilisin, clostripain, and the Staphylococcus aureus V8 protease as unliganded CRP but is slowly digested by chymotrypsin. All of the double-stranded polydeoxyribonucleotides and several of the single-stranded polydeoxyribonucleotides and polyribonucleotides tested render CRP sensitive to cleavage by trypsin. CRP is less rapidly cleaved by trypsin in the presence of d(A)n, d(I)n, and r(C)n indicative of a weaker affinity of CRP for these polynucleotides. The 9,700-Da fragment is N-terminal in CRP and probably terminates at Lys-89. The loss of cAMP binding activity following trypsin cleavage of DNA X CRP indicates that regions beyond this residue are important in the function of the cAMP-binding domain of CRP. The 6,000-Da fragment extends from Val-131 to Arg-185 or Lys-188 and contains part of the F helix involved in DNA binding by CRP.     

Structures during binding of cAMP receptor to promoter DNA: promoter search slowed by non-specific sites

The kinetics of cAMP receptor (CAP) binding to promoter DNA has been studied by stopped-flow electric-dichroism at a reduced salt concentration, where the coupling of non-specific and specific binding can be observed directly. Amplitudes, rise and decay times of dichroism transients provide detailed information about the reaction and the structure of intermediates over more than six orders of magnitude on the time scale. CAP binding during the first milliseconds after mixing is indicated by an increase of both rise- and decay-time constants. A particularly large increase of rise times reflects initial formation of non-symmetric complexes by protein binding to non-specific sites at DNA ends. The increase of the hydrodynamic dimensions continues up to ~1 s, before a decrease of time constants reflects transition to compact states with bent DNA up to the time range of ~10³ s. The slow approach to CAP-induced DNA bending is due to non-specific complexes, which are formed initially and are converted slowly to the specific complex. At the salt concentration of 13.5 mM, conversion to specific complexes with bent DNA is completed after ~40 s at pH 8 compared to >10³ s at pH 7, resulting from a higher affinity of CAP to non-specific sites at pH 7 than 8 by a factor of ~100. Thus, under the given conditions non-specific sites delay rather than facilitate formation of the specific complex with bent DNA. Experimental data obtained for a non-specific DNA clearly indicate the impact of pseudo-sites. The different electro-optical parameters have been combined in global fits.     

Equilibrium studies of the cyclic AMP receptor protein-DNA interaction

The binding of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) to restriction fragments containing the lac promoter-operator region has been investigated as a function of cAMP concentration, using a sensitive gel electrophoresis assay. Under standard conditions (13 mM ionic strength), the equilibrium constant for CAP binding to its primary site on a 203 base-pair lac promoter fragment is 6.3 X 10(8) M-1 at 0.2 microM-cAMP, and increases to 8.4 X 10(10) M-1 at 5.0 microM-cAMP. The latter is about 10(5) times larger than the equilibrium constant for binding to an isolated, non-specific site. The L8 mutation, which renders the lac promoter unresponsive to CAP in vivo, lowers this binding affinity by five- to tenfold. Analysis of the cAMP dependency of binding over the concentration range of 0.2 microM to 10 microM reveals that uptake of a single equivalent of cAMP is required for site-specific binding. Similarly, the transfer of CAP from a non-specific DNA site to a specific site requires the net uptake of a single molecule of cAMP. In contrast, co-operative non-specific binding to DNA was found to be independent of cAMP concentration with an equilibrium binding constant of 6 X 10(6) M-1. We conclude that the cAMP affinity of the two CAP subunits in the specific promoter complex is not equal, and that the complex structure therefore deviates significantly from twofold symmetry. A model for the regulation of the lac promoter by the intracellular cAMP concentration is proposed on the basis of the equilibrium binding results.     

Isolation and characterization of the amino and carboxyl proximal fragments of the adenosine cyclic 3' ,5'-phosphate receptor protein of Escherichia coli

The cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) is a positive and negative regulatory protein for gene expression in Escherichia coli. The protein has been cleaved proteolytically to determine the relation between CRP structure and function. In the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (NaDodSO4), chymotrypsin dissects CRP into two stable fragments of molecular weight 9500 (9.5K) and 13 000 (13K). After removal of NaDodSO4, the two fragments are resolved by Bio-Rex 70 chromatography in 6 M urea. Analyses of the terminal amino acids released from each fragment and cyanogen bromide cleavage products indicate that the 9.5K fragment is amino proximal in CRP while the 13K fragment is carboxyl proximal. Notable features of amino acid composition are the relatively high amount of arginine and methionine in the 13K fragment and the retention in the 9.5K fragment of the two tryptophans present in the CRP subunit. Following isoelectric focusing in 8 M urea, the 9.5K fragment, 22.5K CRP, and 13K fragment migrate to pH 5.5, 8.3, and 10.3, respectively. While CRP is a cAMP-stimulated DNA binding protein, the 13K fragment binds to DNA in the presence and absence of cAMP. The 9.5K fragment associates to form dimers and decamers. These data are consonant with a model in which the DNA binding domain is present in the carboxyl proximal region of CRP while the amino proximal region contains the subunit-subunit interaction sites and much of the cAMP binding domain.     

On the origin of selectivity in recognition by cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate receptor protein of its specific binding site of the lactose promoter region

From fluorescence measurements we could analyse the binding of cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli to its specific site on a 301 base-pair long DNA fragment containing the control region of the lactose operon. At physiological ionic strength selection of the specific site is strictly dependent on the allosteric effector cAMP, and binding of the cAMP . CRP complex to its specific site is favoured over the non-specific binding by 5 kcal/mol with Kass (specific) = 10(8) M-1 at 37 degrees C.     

Modulation of HU–DNA interactions by salt concentration and applied force

HU is one of the most abundant proteins in bacterial chromosomes and participates in nucleoid compaction and gene regulation. We report experiments using DNA stretching that study the dependence of DNA condensation by HU on force, salt and HU concentration. Previous experiments at sub-physiological salt levels revealed that low concentrations of HU could compact DNA, whereas larger HU concentrations formed a DNA-stiffening complex. Here we report that this bimodal binding behavior depends sensitively on salt concentration. Only the compaction mode was observed for 150 mM and higher NaCl levels, i.e. for physiological salt concentrations. Similar results were obtained for the more physiological salt K-glutamate. Real-time studies of dissociation kinetics revealed that HU unbound slowly (minutes to hours under the conditions studied) but completely for salt concentrations at or above 100 mM NaCl; the lifetime of HU complexes was observed to increase with the HU concentration at which the complexes were formed, and to decrease with salt concentration. Higher salt levels of 300 mM NaCl completely eliminated observable HU binding to DNA. Finally, we observed that the dissociation kinetics depend on force applied to the DNA: increased applied force in the sub-piconewton range accelerates dissociation, suggesting a mechanism for DNA tension to regulate chromosome structure and gene expression.     

Allosteric control of cAMP receptor binding dynamics

The intrinsic fluorescence of the cyclic AMP receptor is a sensitive indicator of the reaction with DNA, but signals are perturbed by a photoreaction. A ratio procedure is shown to be useful for correction. The reaction of the protein with DNA indicated by corrected transients extends over a broad time range not only at low salt concentrations but also at physiological salt concentrations. The initial binding step can be recorded preferentially at low salt pH 7 and is shown to be very similar for specific and nonspecific DNA. The rate constant for initial binding at 13.5 mM salt pH 7 is 2 × 10(8) M(-1) s(-1). Slow reaction steps up to times of several hundred seconds are observed both at low and high salt; the magnitude and sign of fluorescence amplitudes are strongly dependent on salt and pH. At 100 mM salt pH 8, the slow reaction step observed for the binding of the cyclic AMP receptor protein to promoter DNA is strongly shifted to longer times upon reduction of the cAMP concentration. The observed cAMP dependence is described quantitatively by a model implying that binding of the receptor to promoter DNA requires two cAMP molecules per protein dimer and is not consistent with a model assuming that a single cAMP is sufficient for activation. The rate constant for binding of the protein·dimer·(cAMP)(2) complex to the promoter is 1.3 × 10(8) M(-1) s(-1), close to the limit of diffusion control. Equilibration of specific complexes takes ~100 s at physiological concentrations of the reaction components.     

The gene encoding the periplasmic cyclophilin homologue, PPlase A, in Escherichia coli, is expressed from four promoters, three of which are activated by the cAMP–CRP complex and negatively regulated by the CytR repressor

The rot gene in Escherichia coli encodes PPlase A, a periplasmic peptldyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase with homology to the cyclophilin family of proteins. Here it is demonstrated that rot is expressed in a complex manner from four overlapping promoters and that the rot regulatory region is unusually compact, containing a close array of sites for DNA-binding proteins. The three most upstream rot promoters are activated by the global gene regulatory cAMP–CRP complex and negatively regulated by the CytR repressor protein. Activation of these three promoters occurs by binding of cAMP–CRP to two sites separated by 53 bp. Moreover, one of the cAMP–CRP complexes is involved in the activation of both a Class I and a Class II promoter. Repression takes place by the formation of a CytR/cAMP–CRP/DNA nucleoprotein complex consisting of the two cAMP–CRP molecules and CytR bound in between. The two regulators bind co-operatively to the DNA overlapping the three upstream promoters, simultaneously quenching the cAMP–CRP activator function. These results expand the CytR regulon to include a gene whose product has no known function in ribo- and deoxyribonucleoside catabolism or transport.     

Specific binding of cyclic-AMP receptor protein to DNA. Effect of the sequence and of the introduction of a nick in the binding site.

The binding of Escherichia coli Cyclic AMP Receptor Protein (CRP) to several DNA fragments of about 45 base pairs, bearing the natural lactose or galactose sites, as well as several synthetic related sites, was investigated using fluorescence spectroscopy and gel retardation experiments. The salt dependence of the equilibrium binding constant indicates that CRP makes an identical number of ion pairs with the lac, lacL8 and gal sites although the binding constants are drastically different. However increasing the symmetry of the gal site leads to an increase of the number of ion pairs between the protein and the DNA. A single strand nick was introduced at the centre of a symmetrized gal site and this reduces the binding energy of CRP by about 0.6 Kcal. These results are discussed with respect to the bending constraints imposed on the DNA by the binding of CRP. The results are in agreement with the recently published crystal structure of the CRP complexed with DNA [Schutz, S.C., Shields, G.C. and Steitz, T.A., Science 253, 1001-1007 (1991)] showing that the 90 degrees bending of the DNA in the complex results from two kinks.