Subunit Secondary Structure in Filamentous Viruses: Predictions and Observations

Abstract

The algorithm of Gamier, Osguthorpe and Robson (J. Mol. Biol. 120, 97–120, 1978) for prediction of protein secondary structure has been applied to the coat protein sequences of six filamentous bacteriophages: fd, Ifl, IKe, Pfl, Xf and Pf3. For subunits of Class I virions (fd, Ifl, IKe), the algorithm predicts a very high percentage of helix in comparison to other structure types, which is in accord with the results of laser Raman and circular dichroism measurements. For subunits of the Class II virions (Pfl, Xf, Pf3), the algorithm consistently predicts a predominance of β structure, which is compatible with the demonstrated facility for conversion of Class II subunits from α-helix to β-strand under appropriate experimental conditions (Thomas, Prescott and Day, J. Mol. Biol. 165, 321–356, 1983). Even when the algorithm is biased to favor helix, the Class II virion subunits are predicted to contain considerably more strand than helix. Qualitatively similar results are obtained using the algorithm of Chou and Fasman {Adv. Enzym. 47, 45–148,45-148). Therefore, both predictive and experimental methods indicate a distinction between Gass I and II subunits, which is reflected in a greater tendency of the latter to adopt other than uniform β-helical conformation. The results suggest a possible model for the disassembly of filamentous viruses which may involve the unraveling of coat protein helices at the N terminus.     

Structure similarity, difference and variability in the filamentous viruses fd, If1, IKe, Pf1 and Xf. Investigation by laser Raman spectroscopy

The filamentous bacteriophages fd, If1, IKe, Pf1, Xf and Pf3 in aqueous solutions of low, moderate and high ionic strength have been investigated as a function of temperature by laser Raman difference spectroscopy. By analogy with Raman spectra of model compounds and viruses of known structure, the data reveal the following structural features: the predominant secondary structure of the coat protein subunit in each virus is the alpha-helix, but the amount of alpha-helix differs from one virus to another, ranging from an estimated high of 100% in Pf1 to a low of approximately 50% in Xf. The molecular environment and intermolecular interactions of tyrosine, tryptophan and phenylalanine residues differ among the different viruses, as do the conformations of aliphatic amino acid side-chains. The foregoing features of coat protein structure are highly sensitive to changes in Na+ concentration, temperature or both. The backbones of A-DNA and B-DNA structures do not occur in any of the viruses, and unusual DNA structures are indicated for all six viruses. The alpha-helical protein subunits of Pf1, like those of Pf3 and Xf, can undergo reversible transitions to beta-sheet structures while retaining their association with DNA; yet fd, IKe and If1 do not undergo such transitions. Raman intensity changes with ionic strength or temperature suggest that transgauche rotations of aliphatic amino acid side-chains and stacking of aromatic side-chains are important structural variables in each virus.     

Filamentous bacterial viruses. XI. Molecular architecture of the class II (Pf1, Xf) virion

The diffraction patterns of the Pf 1 and Xf strains of filamentous bacterial viruses (class II) can be interpreted in terms of a simple helix of protein subunits with 15Åpitch, having 22 units in five turns. The protein subunits are each elongated in an axial direction, and also slope radially, so as to overlap each other, giving an arrangement of subunits reminiscent of scales on a fish. The protein helix forms a tube with inner diameter about 20Åand outer diameter about 60Å. The single-stranded circular DNA is contained within this tube, with two DNA strands running the length of the tube.The diffraction patterns of fd, If 1 and IKe (class I) can be interpreted in terms of a perturbed version of the class II simple helix.     

Quantitative analysis of nucleic acids, proteins, and viruses by Raman band deconvolution

A constrained, iterative Fourier deconvolution method is employed to enhance the resolution of Raman spectra of biological molecules for quantitative assessment of macromolecular secondary structures and hydrogen isotope exchange kinetics. In an application to the Pf1 filamentous bacterial virus, it is shown that the Raman amide I band contains no component other than that due to alpha-helix, indicating the virtual 100% helicity of coat proteins in the native virion. Comparative analysis of the amide I band of six filamentous phages (fd, If1, IKe, Pf1, Xf, and Pf3), all at the same experimental conditions, indicates that the subunit helix-percentage ranges from a high of 100% in Pf1 to a low of 71% in Xf. Deconvolution of amide I of Pf3 at elevated temperatures, for which an alpha-to-beta transition was previously reported (Thomas, G. J., Jr., and L. A. Day, 1981, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA., 78:2962-2966), allows quantitative evaluation of the contributions of both alpha-helix and beta-strand conformations to the structure of the thermally perturbed viral coat protein. Weak Raman lines of viral DNA bases and coat protein side chains, which are poorly resolved instrumentally, are also distinguished for all viruses by the deconvolution procedure. Application to the carbon-8 hydrogen isotope exchange reaction of a purine constituent of transfer RNA permits accurate determination of the exchange rate constant, which is in agreement with calculations based upon curve-fitting methods.     

Sugar pucker and phosphodiester conformations in viral genomes of filamentous bacteriophages: fd, If1, IKe, Pf1, Xf, and Pf3

The laser Raman spectra of filamentous viruses contain discrete bands which are assignable to molecular vibrations of the encapsidated, single-stranded DNA genomes and which are informative of their molecular conformations. Discrimination between Raman bands of the DNA and those of the coat proteins is facilitated by analysis of viruses containing deuterium-labeled amino acids. Specific DNA vibrational assignments are based upon previous studies of A-, B-, and Z-DNA oligonucleotide crystals of known structure [Thomas, G.J., Jr., & Wang, A.H.-J. (1988) in Nucleic Acids and Molecular Biology (Eckstein, F., & Lilley, D.M.J., Eds.) Vol. 2, Springer-Verlag, Berlin]. The present results show that canonical DNA structures are absent from six filamentous viruses: fd, If1, IKe, Pfl, Xf, and Pf3. The DNAs in three viruses of symmetry class I (fd, If1, IKe) contain very similar nucleoside sugar puckers and glycosyl torsions, deduced to be C3'-endo/anti. However, nucleoside conformations are not the same among the three class II viruses examined: Pf1 and Xf DNAs contain similar conformers, deduced to be C2'-endo/anti, whereas Pf3 DNA exhibits bands usually associated with C3'-endo/anti conformers. Conformation-sensitive Raman bands of the DNA 3'-C-O-P-O-C-5' groups show that in all class I viruses and in Pf1 the ssDNA backbones do not contain regularly ordered phosphodiester group geometries, like those found in ordered single- and double-stranded nucleic acids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Silver and mercury probing of deoxyribonucleic acid structures in the filamentous viruses fd, If1, IKe, Xf, Pf1, and Pf3

Ag+ binding and Hg2+ binding to both double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) have been examined in some detail, and the results have been applied to study the structures of circular ssDNA in several filamentous viruses. It has been known for some time that Ag+ and Hg2+ bind to the bases of DNA producing characteristic large changes in absorbance and circular dichroism (CD) spectra, as well as changes in sedimentation rates. In the case of Ag+, it is known that there are three modes of binding to isolated dsDNA, referred to as types I, II, and III. Type III binding, by definition, occurs when Ag+ binds to Ag-dsDNA complexes having sites for binding types I and II extensively occupied, if not saturated. It produces CD spectra, assigned in this study, and absorbance spectra that are isosbestic with those of the Ag-dsDNA complexes present prior to its onset. In phosphate buffers binding is restricted to types I and II, whereas in borate buffers weaker type III binding can occur. Characteristics of types I, II, and III were observed for the DNAs in fd, If1, IKe, and Xf, but not for those in Pf1 and Pf3. Similarly, many of the spectral changes seen when Hg2+ binds to isolated double-stranded DNA are mimicked by Hg2+ binding to the DNAs within fd, IKe, If1, and Xf, but not for those in Pf1 and Pf3. The Ag+ and Hg2+ results indicate the presence of right-handed DNA helices in fd, If1, IKe, and Xf, with the two antiparallel strands of the covalently closed single-stranded DNAs having the bases directed toward the virion axes. For Pf1 and Pf3, Ag+ and Hg2+ binding cause large absorbance changes but only small CD changes. The very different results for Pf1 and Pf3 are consistent with the presence of inverted DNA structures (I-DNA) with the bases directed away from the structure axes, but the two structures differ from one another. Sedimentation velocity changes with Ag+ and Hg2+ binding strongly suggest structural linkages between the DNA and the surrounding protein sheath in each of the viruses.     

Demonstration by ultraviolet resonance Raman spectroscopy of differences in DNA organization and interactions in filamentous viruses Pf1 and fd

Pf1, a class II filamentous virus, has been investigated by ultraviolet resonance Raman (UVRR) spectroscopy with excitation wavelengths of 257, 244, 238, and 229 nm. The 257-nm UVRR spectrum is rich in Raman bands of the packaged single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) genome, despite the low DNA mass (6%) of the virion. Conversely, the 229-nm UVRR spectrum is dominated by tyrosines (Tyr 25 and Tyr 40) of the 46-residue alpha-helical coat subunit. UVRR spectra excited at 244 and 238 nm exhibit Raman bands diagnostic of both viral DNA and coat protein tyrosines. Raman markers of packaged Pf1 DNA contrast sharply with those of the DNA packaged in the class I filamentous virus fd [Wen, Z. Q., Overman, S. A., and Thomas, G. J., Jr. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 7810-7820]. Interestingly, deoxynucleotides of Pf1 DNA exhibit sugars in the C2'-endo/anti conformation and bases that are largely unstacked, compared with C3'-endo/anti conformers and very strong base stacking in fd DNA; hydrogen-bonding interactions of thymine carbonyls are also different in Pf1 and fd. On the other hand, coat protein tyrosines of Pf1 exhibit Raman markers of ring environment identical to those of fd, including an anomalous singlet at 853 cm-1 in lieu of the canonical Fermi doublet (850/830 cm-1) found in globular proteins. The results indicate markedly different modes of organization of ssDNA in Pf1 and fd virions, despite similar environments for coat protein tyrosines, and suggest strong hydrogen-bonding interactions between DNA bases and coat subunits of Pf1 but not between those of fd. We propose that structural relationships between the protein coat and encapsidated ssDNA genome are also fundamentally different in the two assemblies.     

Structural details of the thermophilic filamentous bacteriophage PH75 determined by polarized Raman microspectroscopy

The filamentous virus PH75, which infects the thermophile Thermus thermophilus, consists of a closed DNA strand of 6500 nucleotides encapsidated by 2700 copies of a 46-residue coat subunit (pVIII). The PH75 virion is similar in composition to filamentous viruses infecting mesophilic bacteria but is distinguished by in vivo assembly at 70 degrees C and thermostability to at least 90 degrees C. Structural details of the PH75 assembly are not known, although a fiber X-ray diffraction based model suggests that capsid subunits are highly alpha-helical and organized with the same symmetry (class II) as in the mesophilic filamentous phages Pf1 and Pf3 [Pederson et al. (2001) J. Mol. Biol. 309, 401-421]. This is distinct from the symmetry (class I) of phages fd and M13. We have employed polarized Raman microspectroscopy to obtain further details of PH75 architecture. The spectra are interpreted in combination with known Raman tensors for modes of the pVIII main chain (amide I) and Trp and Tyr side chains to reveal the following structural features of PH75: (i) The average pVIII peptide group is oriented with greater displacement from the virion axis than peptide groups of fd, Pf1, or Pf3. The data correspond to an average helix tilt angle of 25 degrees in PH75 vs 16 degrees in fd, Pf1, and Pf3. (ii) The indolyl ring of Trp 37 in PH75 projects nearly equatorially from the subunit alpha-helix axis, in contrast to the more axial orientations for Trp 26 of fd and Trp 38 of Pf3. (iii) The phenolic rings of Tyr 15 and Tyr 39 project along the subunit helix axis, and one phenoxyl engages in hydrogen-bonding interaction that has no counterpart in either fd or Pf1 tyrosines. Also, in contrast to fd, Pf1, and Pf3, the packaged DNA genome of PH75 exhibits no Raman anisotropy, suggesting that DNA bases are not oriented unidirectionally within the nucleocapsid assembly. The structural findings are discussed in relation to intrasubunit and intersubunit interactions that may confer hyperthermostability to the PH75 virion. A refined molecular model is proposed for the PH75 capsid subunit.     

Comparison of protein and deoxyribonucleic acid backbone structures in fd and Pf1 bacteriophages

The conformations of the protein and nucleic acid backbones in the filamentous viruses fd and Pf1 are characterized by one- and two-dimensional solid-state NMR experiments on oriented virus solutions. Striking differences are observed between fd and Pf1 in both their protein and DNA structures. The coat proteins of fd and Pf1 are almost entirely alpha helical and in both viruses most of the helix is oriented parallel to the filament axis. fd coat protein is one stretch of alpha helix that is slightly slued about the filament axis. In Pf1 coat protein two distinct sections of alpha helix are present, the smaller of which is tilted with respect to the filament axis by about 20 degrees. The DNA backbone structure of fd is completely disordered. By contrast, the DNA backbone of Pf1 is uniformly oriented such that all of the phosphodiester groups have the O-P-O plane of the nonesterified oxygens approximately perpendicular to the filament axis.     

A theory of the symmetries of filamentous bacteriophages.

A mathematical model is presented which explains the symmetries observed for the protein coats of filamentous bacterial viruses. Three viruses (Ff, IKe, and If1) all have five-start helices with rotation angles of 36 degrees and axial translations of 16 A (Type I symmetry), and three other viruses (Pf1, Xf, and Pf3) all have one-start helices with rotation angles of approximately equal to 67 degrees and translations of approximately 3 A (Type II symmetry). The coat protein subunits in each group diverge from each other in amino acid sequence, and Type II viruses differ dramatically in DNA structure. Regardless of the differences, both Type I and Type II symmetry can be understood as direct, natural consequences of the close-packing of alpha-helical protein subunits. In our treatment, an alpha-helical subunit is modeled as consisting of two interconnected, flexible tubular segments that follow helical paths around the DNA, one in an inner layer and the other in an outer layer. The mathematical model is a set of algebraic equations describing the disposition of the flexible segments. Solutions are described by newly introduced symmetry indices and other parameters. An exhaustive survey over the range of indices has produced a library of all structures that are geometrically feasible within our modeling scheme. Solutions which correspond in their rotation angles to Type I and Type II viruses occur over large ranges of the parameter space. A few solutions with other symmetries are also allowed, and viruses with these symmetries may exist in nature. One solution to the set of equations, obtained without any recourse to the x-ray data, yields a calculated x-ray diffraction pattern for Pf1 which compares reasonably with experimental patterns. The close-packing geometry we have used helps explain the near constant linear mass density of known filamentous phages. Helicoid, rigid cylinder, and maximum entropy structure models proposed by others for Pf1 are reconciled with the flexible tube models and with one another.     

Different packaging of DNA in the filamentous viruses Pf1 and Xf

Xf Virus DNA, like Pf1 DNA, is a single-stranded circular molecule and contains, within experimental error, the same number of nucleotides, 7400. This was unexpected since Pf1 virus is 2 μm long while Xf virus is only 1 μm long. The ratio of nucleotides to major coat protein subunits has been found to be nearly unity in Pf1 and nearly two in Xf, but it is not certain that the ratios have exactly integer values. Calculations give the average axial internucleotide separation in Pf1virus as 5.3 Å whereas in Xf virus, the calculated separation is only 2.6 Å. The protein subunits in both Pf1 and Xf have calculated axial separations close to 2.6 Å. The results provide a solution to a problem encountered in the interpretation of X-ray diffraction patterns of these viruses concerning the number of protein subunits per helical turn.     

Intensity of the polarized Raman band at 1340-1345 cm-1 as an indicator of protein alpha-helix orientation: application to Pf1 filamentous virus

Raman spectra of oriented alpha-helical protein molecules exhibit a prominent band near 1340-1345 cm(-)(1), the intensity of which is highly sensitive to molecular orientation. Polarization of the 1340-1345 cm(-)(1) marker is evident in Raman spectra of alpha-helical poly-L-alanine (alphaPLA) and alpha-helical poly-gamma-benzyl-L-glutamate (alphaPBLG). Corresponding polarization is also observed in Raman spectra of the filamentous virus Pf1, which is an assembly of alpha-helical coat protein molecules. In alphaPLA and alphaPBLG, we assign the band to a normal mode of symmetry type E(2) and specifically to a vibration localized in the (O=C)-C(alpha)-H linkages of the main chain peptide group. Although strict helical symmetry does not apply to coat subunits of filamentous viruses, an approximate E(2)-type mode may be presumed to account for a corresponding Raman band of Pf1 and fd filamentous viruses. Spectroscopic studies of N-methylacetamide and isotopically-edited fd viruses support the present assignment of the 1340-1345 cm(-)(1) band. Polarization anisotropy indicates that this band may be exploited as a novel indicator of protein alpha-helix orientation. Application of this approach to the polarized Raman spectrum of Pf1 suggests that, on average, the axis of the alpha-helical coat protein subunit in the native virion structure forms an angle of 20 +/- 10 degrees with respect to the virion axis.     

Structural polymorphism correlated to surface charge in filamentous bacteriophages.

Fiber diffraction studies are used to demonstrate that changes in the helical symmetry of the protein coat of filamentous bacterial viruses fd and M13 are correlated with changes in the surface charge. Comparison of the structure of M13 and fd at pH 2 and 8 indicate that surface charge affects both the helical symmetry and flexibility of the virions. The changes in helical symmetry are similar in magnitude to that observed in the Pseudomanas phage Pf1 and probably reflect an inocuous side effect of the particle flexibility required for protection of the virus particles from damage due to shear. The magnitude of the observed changes in helical symmetry appears to be limited to that which can occur without repacking of the interfaces between the alpha-helices making up the viral protein coat.     

The protein capsid of filamentous bacteriophage PH75 from Thermus thermophilus

The PH75 strain of filamentous bacteriophage (Inovirus) grows in the thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus at 70 degrees C. We have characterized the viral DNA and determined the amino acid sequence of the major coat protein, p8. The p8 protein is synthesized without a leader sequence, like that of bacteriophage Pf3 but unlike that of bacteriophage Pf1, both of which grow in the mesophile Pseudomonas aeruginosa. X-ray diffraction patterns from ordered fibres of the PH75 virion are similar to those from bacteriophages Pf1 and Pf3, indicating that the protein capsid of the PH75 virion has the same helix symmetry and subunit shape, even though the primary structures of the major coat proteins are quite different and the virions assemble at very different temperatures. We have used this information to build a molecular model of the PH75 protein capsid based on that of Pf1, and refined the model by simulated annealing, using fibre diffraction data extending to 2.4 A resolution in the meridional direction and to 3.1 A resolution in the equatorial direction. The common design may reflect a fundamental motif of alpha-helix packing, although differences exist in the DNA packaging and in the means of insertion of the major coat protein of these filamentous bacteriophages into the membrane of the host bacterial cell. These may reflect differences in the assembly mechanisms of the virions.     

Flow linear dichroism spectra of four filamentous bacteriophages: DNA and coat protein contributions

In this study, we have separated the contributions of DNA and protein to the absorption and linear dichroism (LD) of each of four phages: fd, IKe, Pf1, and Pf3. We have found that the DNA packaged in each of the phages is hypochromic relative to the purified single stranded DNA, suggesting that bases are stacked in all of the phages. We have oriented the phages by flow and for the first time report the intrinsic LD from 320 to 190 nm for each of these phages. From the intrinsic LD of the phages and the isotropic absorption of the individual components, we have determined the reduced dichroism of the DNA within the phages and, subsequently, the maximum angle of inclination of the DNA bases (from the helix axis) for the packaged DNA. The maximum angles were 63° and 64° for the DNAs of class I phages fd and IKe, respectively. The angles were significantly less, 51° and 49°, for the DNAs of the class II phages Pf1 and Pf3, respectively. Thus, the two classes of phage differ in the structures of their packaged DNA, the DNA bases of the class II phages being more parallel to the long axis of the phage than are the DNA bases of the class I phages.     

DNA packing in the filamentous viruses fd, Xf, Pf1 and Pf3.

Spectral data for filamentous viruses in the presence and absence of Ag+, together with other parameters, indicate that the DNA structures in two of the viruses, fd and Xf, are similar to each other but that these differ from two quite unusual and different DNA structures in Pf1 and Pf3.     

Structure of the coat protein in Pf1 bacteriophage determined by solid-state NMR spectroscopy

The atomic resolution structure of Pf1 coat protein determined by solid-state NMR spectroscopy of magnetically aligned filamentous bacteriophage particles in solution is compared to the structures previously determined by X-ray fiber and neutron diffraction, the structure of its membrane-bound form, and the structure of fd coat protein. These structural comparisons provide insights into several biological properties, differences between class I and class II filamentous bacteriophages, and the assembly process. The six N-terminal amino acid residues adopt an unusual "double hook" conformation on the outside of the bacteriophage particle. The solid-state NMR results indicate that at 30 degrees C, some of the coat protein subunits assume a single, fully structured conformation, and some have a few mobile residues that provide a break between two helical segments, in agreement with structural models from X-ray fiber and neutron diffraction, respectively. The atomic resolution structure determined by solid-state NMR for residues 7-14 and 18-46, which excludes the N-terminal double hook and the break between the helical segments, but encompasses more than 80% of the backbone including the distinct kink at residue 29, agrees with that determined by X-ray fiber diffraction with an RMSD value of 2.0 A. The symmetry and distance constraints determined by X-ray fiber and neutron diffraction enable the construction of an accurate model of the bacteriophage particle from the coordinates of the coat protein monomers.     

Three-dimensional structure of complexes of single-stranded DNA-binding proteins with DNA. IKe and fd gene 5 proteins form left-handed helices with single-stranded DNA

Specimen-tilting in an electron microscope was used to determine the three-dimensional architecture of the helical complexes formed with DNA by the closely related single-stranded DNA binding proteins of fd and IKe filamentous viruses. The fd gene 5 protein is the only member of the DNA-helix-destabilizing class of proteins whose structure has been determined crystallographically, and yet a parameter essential to molecular modeling of the co-operative interaction of this protein with DNA, the helix handedness, has not been available prior to this work. We find that complexes formed by titrating fd viral DNA with either the fd or IKe gene 5 protein have a left-handed helical sense. Complexes isolated from Escherichia coli infected by fd virus are also found to be left-handed helical; hence, the left-handed fd helices are not an artefact of reconstitution in vitro. Because the proteins and nucleic acid of the complexes are composed of asymmetric units which cannot be fitted equivalently to right-handed and left-handed helices, these results rule out a previous computer graphics atomic model for the helical fd complexes: a right-handed helix had been assumed for the model. Our work provides a defined three-dimensional structural framework within which to model the protein-DNA and protein-protein interactions of two structurally related proteins that bind contiguously and co-operatively on single-stranded DNAs.