Synapse elimination by fiber type and maturational state in rabbit soleus muscle

We have compared the development of fast and slow motor innervation in the neonatal rabbit soleus, a muscle which contains two distinct motor unit types during the early period of polyneuronal innervation. The innervation state of individual muscle fibers was ascertained using an intracellular electrode; a fluorescent dye was then injected into particular fibers to permit subsequent identification of histochemical type. We found no significant difference in the time course of synapse elimination for fast and slow motor units as judged by the percentage of fibers remaining polyneuronally innervated at two ages: 7-8 days, when most fibers are multiply innervated, and 10-11 days, when the level of polyinnervation is low. In a second experiment, we examined a phenomenon in which compound end-plate potentials were occasionally seen in muscle fibers at an age (17-23 days) well past the major episode of synapse elimination. We present evidence that this apparent polyinnervation in fact derives from an electrode-induced electrical coupling artifact and that genuinely polyinnervated fibers are very rare at this stage, if present at all.     

Postmetamorphic development of neuromuscular junctions and muscle fibers in the frog cutaneous pectoris

Synaptic size, synaptic remodelling, polyneuronal innervation, and synaptic efficacy of neuromuscular junctions were studied as a function of growth in cutaneous pectoris muscles of postmetamorphic Rana pipiens. Recently metamorphosed frogs grew rapidly, and this growth was accompanied by hypertrophy of muscle fibers, myogenesis, and increases in the size and complexity of neuromuscular junctions. There were pronounced gradients in pre- and postsynaptic size across the width of the muscle, with neuromuscular junctions and muscle fibers near the medial edge being smaller than in more lateral regions. The incidence of polyneuronal innervation, measured physiologically and histologically, was also higher near the medial edge. Growth-associated declines in all measures of polyneuronal innervation indicated that synapse elimination occurs throughout life. Electrophysiology also demonstrated regional differences in synaptic efficacy and showed that doubly innervated junctions have lower synaptic efficacy than singly innervated junctions. Repeated, in vivo observations revealed extensive growth and remodelling of motor nerve terminals and confirmed that synapse elimination is a slow process. It was concluded that some processes normally associated with embryonic development persist long into adulthood in frog muscles.     

Activity and synapse elimination at the neuromuscular junction

The neuromuscular junction undergoes a loss of synaptic connections during early development. This loss converts the innervation of each muscle fiber from polyneuronal to single. During this change the number of motor neurons remains constant but the number of muscle fibers innervated by each motor neuron is reduced. Evidence indicates that a local competition among the inputs on each muscle fiber determines which inputs are eliminated. The role of synapse elimination in the development of neuromuscular circuits, other than ensuring a single innervation of each fiber, is unclear. Most evidence suggests that the elimination plays little or no role in correcting for errant connections. Rather, it seems that connections are initially highly specific, in terms of both which motor neurons connect to which muscles and which neurons connect to which particular fibers within these muscles. A number of attempts have been made to determine the importance of neuromuscular activity during early development for this rearrangement of synaptic connections. Experiments reducing neuromuscular activity by muscle tenotomy, deafferentation and spinal cord section, block of nerve impulse conduction with tetrodotoxin, and the use of postsynaptic and presynaptic blocking agents have all shown that normal activity is required for normal synapse elimination. Most experiments in which complete muscle paralysis has been achieved show that activity may be essential for the occurrence of synapse elimination. Furthermore, experiments in which neuromuscular activity has been augmented by external stimulation show that synapse elimination is accelerated. A plausible hypothesis to explain the activity dependence of neuromuscular synapse elimination is that a neuromuscular trophic agent is produced by the muscle fibers and that this production is controlled by muscle-fiber activity. The terminals on each fiber compete for the substance produced by that fiber. Inactive fibers produce large quantities of this substance; on the other hand, muscle activity suppresses the level of synthesis of this agent to the point where only a single synaptic terminal can be maintained. Inactive muscle fibers would be expected to be able to maintain more nerve terminals. The attractiveness of this scheme is that it provides a simple feedback mechanism to ensure that each fiber retains a single effective input.     

Crustacean Neuromuscular Mechanisms

Properties of crustacean muscle fibers and neuromuscular synapsesare discussed, with particular reference to the problems offast and slow contraction, synaptic diversity, and peripheralinhibition. Electrical and mechanical responses of crustacean muscle fibersare variable, and govern to a large extent the muscle's performance.Fast and slow contractions are often mediated by distinct "phasic"and "tonic" muscle fibers, as in abdominal muscles, in whichsuch fibers are segregated into two parallel sets of muscles.In leg muscles the fibers are often heterogeneous in propertiesand innervation. In doubly-motor-innervated muscles of crabsthe axons producing fast and slow contractions preferentiallyinnervate rapidly and slowly contracting fibers, respectively. Crustacean neuromuscular synapses vary greatly in electricalbehavior and in ultrastructural characteristics. Some motoraxons possess both facilitating and nonfacilitating synapses.The proportion of the different types of synapse associatedwith a motor axon probably determines in large measure the propertiesof the postsynaptic potentials evoked by that axon. Pre-synaptic and post-synaptic inhibition both occur, sometimesin the same muscle. The latter type is more common. Pre-synapticinhibition is thought to be mediated by the action of an inhibitorytransmitter-substance on receptors of the motor nerve terminals.     

Activity-dependent switch from synapse formation to synapse elimination during development of neuromuscular junctions

The embryonic development of neuromuscular junctions consists of two successive epochs, an early period marked by exuberant synapse formation and a later period marked by synapse elimination. In the frog muscles we have studied, myogenesis is protracted and overlaps the periods of synapse formation and elimination. Thus, the formative and regressive events of synaptic development do not occur in synchrony across different fibers in the muscle. We propose that local activity orchestrates a shift from synaptogenesis to synapse elimination at the level of single muscle fibers. We also present evidence that perisynaptic Schwann cells and the expression of ion channels in the sarcolemma play important roles in the development of neuromuscular junctions. Questions for future study are outlined.     

Muscle reinnervation in rats treated with vitamin E]

During muscle reinnervation, a transitory phase of polyinnervation occurs. In reinnervated muscles of vitamin E deficient rats, sprouting and polyinnervation are increased with respect to reinnervated controls. In this work, polyinnervation was observed in reinnervated extensor digitorum longus (edl) muscle of rats treated with pharmacological doses of vitamin E. Sciatic nerve was crushed and edl muscle was examined electrophysiologically at 30, 40 and 60 days after denervation. The percentage of polyinnervated cells in controls peaked at 30 days and thus it decreased. In muscles of vitamin E treated rats, the time course of percentage of polyinnervated muscle cells was qualitatively the same, but it was decreased at all times.     

Extraocular muscles in the lamprey, Lampetra fluviatils L. II. Motor end plates

Motor innervation and particularly the structure of motor end plates (MEPs) was studied in the extraocular muscles of the lamprey, Lampetra fluviatilis L., by light and electron microscopy. Each muscle is supplied with numerous thin motor nerve fibres. Motor end plates are located at their ends or along their course. Two motor end plate types were distinguished: en grappe-like plates with a low acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity were observed on thin muscle fibres, whilst en plaque-like plates with a high AChE activity were found on thick mitochondria-rich and thick multifibrillar muscle fibres. The postsynaptic membrane of the former MEP type does not show the presence of infoldings, MEPs located on thick mitochondria-rich fibres show occasional infoldings, whereas the postsynaptic membrane of MEPs present on thick multifibrillar fibres reveals numerous infoldings. Motor end plates present in the extraocular muscles in the lamprey possess features typical for higher vertebrates and elasmobranch fishes, as well as for Tunicata.     

Specificity and development of innervation pattern of Xenopus pectoralis muscle

Multielectrode recordings were used to identify and measure the axonal inputs to each end plate on contiguous surface fibers covering about 25% of the Xenopus pectoralis muscle in mature and developing animals. The mature innervation pattern was remarkably precise. Individual axons tended to innervate fibers of similar input resistance (R_in) in compact motor units restricted to only a portion of the region studied. Motor units comprising fibers of similar R_in overlapped mainly near their borders. Most fibers had two end plates. In more than 80% of these fibers, both end plates received input from the same axon. In 57%, this was the only input to both end plates. This implies a powerful mechanism for excluding or eliminating inputs from other axons. About 16% of the mature junctions showed focal polyneuronal innervation, with the weaker end plate potential component often less than 1 mV in noncurarized preparations. However, we have no evidence that the weaker inputs were being eliminated. During development, motor units became more compact, which was associated with synapse elimination; but from the earliest times studied, soon after metamorphosis when many fibers were adding second end plates, a majority of those that had two end plates were innervated at both sites by the same axon. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Synapse elimination,the size principle,and Hebbian synapses

Synapse elimination at the vertebrate neuromuscular junction reduces a polyinnervated population of muscle fibers to a monoinnervated state. The function of this developmental phenomenon (if any) is unproven. A theoretical analysis of Hebbian (correlation) rules connecting presynaptic and postsynaptic activity and synaptic strength at the neuromuscular junction is presented. The following points are demonstrated: (1) Correlational competition leads to the reduction of polyinnervation to a stable monoinnervated state; (2) the competition gives rise to the size principle over a wide range of the plausible parameter space; (3) over a significant subrange, the competition selectively eliminates topographically incorrect synapses; and (4) in cases in which topographic projection errors overwhelm the system, both error correction and the development of the size principle are disrupted. Correlational competition may explain contradictory experimental results concerning the effects of stimulating or silencing subpopulations of motor neurons. It may also explain an otherwise puzzling instance of a breakdown in the size principle seen in humans undergoing neural regeneration. Taken together, these findings suggest a novel hypothesis for the function of synapse elimination at the neuromuscular junction: the establishment of the size principle. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Synapse elimination occurs late in the hormone-sensitive levator ani muscle of the rat

Using tetranitroblue tetrazolium (TNBT) to stain neuromuscular synapses, we compared the development of the adult pattern of innervation in two fast-twitch muscles in the rat: the androgen-sensitive levator ani (LA) and the extensor digitorum longus (EDL), which is not thought to be androgen sensitive. We found that about 18% of adult LA muscle fibers, but only about 2% of adult EDL fibers, are multiply innervated. Moreover, synapse elimination occurs substantially later in the LA compared with the EDL. At 2 weeks after birth, the EDL is already predominantly singly innervated, whereas the LA is still predominantly multiply innervated. The apparent delay in the normal time course of synapse elimination in the LA corresponds to a similar delay in other aspects of neuromuscular development (the time course of appearance of axonal retraction bulbs, the growth of fibers, and the development of adult motor terminal morphology). Finally, motor terminals change during synapse elimination from morphologies resembling growth cones to the adult form of neuromuscular synapses. Because the period of synapse elimination is significantly different for muscles that differ in their androgen sensitivity, hormonal sensitivity may represent an important property of motoneurons or muscle fibers influencing the normal time course of neuromuscular synapse elimination in rats. Thus, androgen might regulate the normal ontogenetic process of synapse elimination.     

Critical period for the androgenic block of neuromuscular synapse elimination

Juvenile androgen treatment during developmental synapse elimination changes the pattern of innervation in the adult levator ani (LA), an androgen-sensitive muscle (Jordan, Letinsky, and Arnold, 1989b). Most notably, such adult muscles contain an unusually high number of muscle fibers that are innervated by two or more axons indicating that these fibers are multiply innervated. Juvenile androgen treatment also increases the adult level of preterminal branching, the number of junctional sites per adult fiber, and the size of adult LA muscle fibers and motoneurons in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB). The present study was designed to determine when in development androgen treatment is most effective in maintaining multiple innervation in adulthood and whether there are different critical periods for the different effects of juvenile androgen treatment. Male rats were castrated on 7, 21, or 34 days after birth (roughly corresponding to the beginning, middle, and end of synapse elimination in the LA muscle) and treated daily with testosterone propionate for the next 2 weeks. All rats were sacrificed at 9 weeks and their spinal cords and LA muscles were stained and analyzed. Only during the first treatment period (7-20) did androgen treatment result in increased levels of multiple innervation at 9 weeks. During this period, androgen also increased the number of junctional sites per fiber and the size of SNB somata but did not influence the adult level of preterminal branching or the diameter of adult LA muscle fibers. Androgen treatment during the two later periods increased the level of preterminal branching and the size of LA muscle fibers without influencing the level of multiple innervation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Morphological effects of ciliary neurotrophic factor treatment during neuromuscular synapse elimination

In adult skeletal muscles, exogenous ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) induces axons and their nerve terminals to sprout. CNTF also regulates the amount of multiple innervation in developing skeletal muscles during synapse elimination, maintaining multiple innervation of muscle fibers. While CNTF may maintain multiple innervation by regulating developmental synapse elimination, it is also possible that CNTF induces the formation of new multiple innervation through a sprouting response. In this study I examined morphologically the effects of CNTF during synapse elimination in the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscle. Rat pups received injections of CNTF in one leg and vehicle in the other either early [postnatal day 7 (P7)-P13] or late (P14–P20) in development. The early treatment period corresponds to that time when the pattern of innervation in the EDL is converted from predominantly multiple to single innervation. The late treatment period is at the end of synapse elimination for the EDL but corresponds to the major period of synapse elimination in the levator ani (LA), allowing a comparison of effects on these two muscles from the same animals. On the day after the final injection, EDL muscles were dissected and stained with tetranitroblue tetrazolium and the resulting pattern of innervation was assessed. The present findings indicate that only the early CNTF treatment regulates the level of multiple innervation in the EDL. Moreover, the effect of early CNTF treatment was local, affecting multiple innervation only in the EDL from the CNTF-treated leg. CNTF injected during the late treatment period had no apparent effects on the EDL but had a potent effect on the pattern of innervation in the LA, significantly increasing the level of multiple innervation in this muscle. Thus, CNTF affected multiple innervation in these two muscles only if provided during the period when single innervation normally develops. There was no evidence to indicate that CNTF induced axons or their terminals to sprout during either treatment period. In conclusion, CNTF increases the level of multiple innervation, probably by regulating synapse elimination, and skeletal muscles themselves may be an important target site for CNTF action. Presumably, the sprouting response to CNTF found in adult muscle develops sometime after P21. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Transient and permanent effects of androgen during synapse elimination in the levator ani muscle of the rat.

Young male rats were castrated at 7 days of age, and treated with testosterone propionate daily from 7 to 34 days of age. At 13 months of age, motor axons and terminals innervating the levator ani (LA) muscle were stained with tetranitroblue tetrazolium (TNBT). The number of separate axons innervating individual muscle fibers was counted, and muscle fiber diameter was measured. Previous studies have shown that this androgen treatment increases muscle fiber diameter and delays synapse elimination, measured as (1) a greater percentage of muscle fibers innervated by multiple axons and (2) larger motor units. The present results indicate that the androgenic effect on synapse elimination is permanent, in that high levels of multiple innervation persisted for 12 months after the end of androgen treatment. In contrast, the effect on muscle fiber diameter was not maintained for this period. This dissociation of androgenic effects on the pattern of innervation from androgenic effects on muscle fiber diameter offers further evidence that the androgenic maintenance of multiple innervation is not dependent on muscle fiber size. In addition, circulating testosterone levels were measured at 50 and 60 days of age in animals similarly treated with androgen or oil from 7 to 34 days of age. By 60 days of age, testosterone levels in hormone-treated animals had dropped below detectability, comparable to levels in oil-treated controls. This provides additional evidence that androgen treatment during juvenile development can have permanent effects on the adult pattern of innervation in the LA muscle.     

Transient and permanent effects of androgen during synapse elimination in the levator ani muscle of the rat

Young male rats were castrated at 7 days of age, and treated with testosterone propionate daily from 7 to 34 days of age. At 13 months of age, motor axons and terminals innervating the levator ani (LA) muscle were stained with tetranitroblue tetrazolium (TNBT). The number of separate axons innervating individual muscle fibers was counted, and muscle fiber diameter was measured. Previous studies have shown that this androgen treatment increases muscle fiber diameter and delays synapse elimination, measured as (1) a greater percentage of muscle fibers innervated by multiple axons and (2) larger motor units. The present results indicate that the androgenic effect on synapse elimination is permanent, in that high levels of multiple innervation persisted for 12 months after the end of androgen treatment. In contrast, the effect on muscle fiber diameter was not maintained for this period. This dissociation of androgenic effects on the pattern of innervation from androgenic effects on muscle fiber diameter offers further evidence that the androgenic maintenance of multiple innervation is not dependent on muscle fiber size. In addition, circulating testosterone levels were measured at 50 and 60 days of age in animals similarly treated with androgen or oil from 7 to 34 days of age. By 60 days of age, testosterone levels in hormone-treated animals had dropped below detectability, comparable to levels in oil-treated controls. This provides additional evidence that androgen treatment during juvenile development can have permanent effects on the adult pattern of innervation in the LA muscle.     

Axotomy of developing rat spinal motoneurons: Cell survival,soma size,muscle recovery,and the influence of testosterone

During the period of synapse elimination, motoneurons are impaired in their ability to generate or regenerate axonal branches: following partial denervation of their target muscle, young motoneurons do not sprout to nearby denervated fibers and after axonal injury, they fail to reinnervate the muscle. In the rat levator ani (LA) muscle, which is innervated by motoneurons in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB), synapse elemination ends relatively late in development and can be regulated by testosterone. We took advantage of this system to determine if the end of synapse elimination and the development of regenerative capabilities by motoneurons share a common mechanism, or, alternatively, if these two events can be dissociated in time. Axotomy on or before postnatal day 14 (P14) caused the death of SNB motoneurons. By P21, toward the end of synapse elimination in the LA muscle, SNB motoneurons had developed the ability to survive axonal injury. Altering testosterone levels by castration on P7 followed by 4 weeks of either testosterone propionate or control injections did not change the ability of SNB motoneurons to survive axonal injury during development, although these same treatments alter the time course of synapse elimination in the LA muscle. Thus, we dissociated the inability of SNB motoneurons to recover from axonal injury from their developmental elimination of synaptic terminals. We also measured the effect of early axotomy on motoneuronal soma size and on target muscle weight. Axotomy on P14 caused a long-lasting decrease in the soma size of surviving SNB motoneurons, whereas motoneurons axotomized on P28 recovered their normal soma size. Axotomy on or before P7 caused severe atrophy of the target muscles, matching the extensive loss of motoneurons. However, target muscle recovery after axotomy on P14 was as good as recovery after axotomy at later ages, despite greater motoneuronal death after axotomy on P14. This result may reflect an increase in motor unit size, a decrease in polyneuronal innervation by SNB motoneurons that survive axotomy on P14, or a combination of the two. © 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Effects of evoked and spontaneous motoneuronal firing on synapse competition and elimination in skeletal muscle

Synapse elimination is a general feature of the development of neural connections, including the connections of motoneurons to skeletal muscle fibers. Our work addressed two questions: (1) how the action potentials generated in the set of motoneurons innervating an individual muscle (i.e., in a motor pool) are correlated in time during development in vivo; (2) what influence different firing patterns exert on the processes of polyneuronal innervation and synapse elimination which characterize the establishment of muscle innervation. We recorded the spontaneous electromyographic activity of the tibialis anterior and soleus muscles of late embryonic and neonatal rats, identifying the firing of at least two single motor unit signals in each record. We found that a striking switch occurs a few days after birth from a highly synchronous type of firing to an asynchronous one, the first thus characterizing embryonic while the second one adult motoneurons. We also investigated the effects of an evoked synchronous type of discharge on neuromuscular synapse formation, measuring polyneuronal innervation and synapse elimination. This was done in an adult in vivo model of de novo synapse formation, while a chronic TTX nerve conduction block, placed centrally with respect to the stimulating electrodes, eliminated the natural activity of motoneurons. We found that the imposed synchronous activity greatly inhibits synapse elimination, causing polyneuronal innervation to persist. We conclude that the early synchronous firing, favors the establishment of polyneuronal innervation while the subsequent switch to an asynchronous one promotes synapse elimination.     

An anatomical and electrophysiological study of synapse elimination at the developing frog neuromuscular junction

Synapse elimination was examined in the developing frog cutaneous pectoris muscle using histological and electrophysiological techniques. Morphological synapse elimination occurred in two phases. The first phase, which began at the time of metamorphosis and continued until the second to third postmetamorphic week, was characterized by a rapid decline in the number of endplates receiving greater than or equal to 3 synaptic inputs. However, 50% of the muscle fibers still remained dually innervated. This dual innervation decreased with a much slower time course; approximately 20% of the muscle fibers were dually innervated in 1- to 2-year-old frogs. During the first phase of synapse elimination no difference was noted between the distribution of acetylcholine receptors or acetylcholinesterase activity associated with the terminal arborizations formed by separate axons at one synaptic site. However, terminal arborizations formed by small diameter axons and consisting of varicosities separated by thin interconnectives became apparent during this period. Such varicose arborizations responded to nerve stimulation and released acetylcholine in proportion to their terminal length as did the nonvaricose arborizations. In addition, the number of morphological and physiological inputs at one endplate site was well correlated throughout the first phase of synapse elimination.     

Progression of multiple innervation of reinnervated rat muscle treated with bilobalide]

During motor nerve regeneration a transitory polyinnervation of muscle cells occurs, which represents a phase of rearrangement of the recovered innervation. Bilobalide, a terpene extrated from Ginkgo biloba leaves, was proposed to affect some aspects of nervous system development and regeneration. In this work, influence of bilobalide on polyinnervation in reinnervated extensor digitorum longus muscle was studied, through electrophysiological and histological techniques. The muscle was denervated crushing the sciatic nerve and it was examined at 1 or 2 months after denervation. The polyinnervated muscle cells in controls reached 24% at 1 month and thus the percentage decreased. In muscles of bilobalide treated rats the number of polyinnervated cells was decreased at both times.     

Nitric oxide synthase expression and effects of nitric oxide modulation on contractility of rat extraocular muscle.

Extraocular muscles (EOMs) are specialized skeletal muscles that are constantly active, generate low levels of force for cross sectional area, have rapid contractile speeds, and are highly fatigue resistant. The neuronal isoform of nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) is concentrated at the sarcolemma of fast-twitch muscles fibers, and nitric oxide (NO) modulates contractility. This study evaluated nNOS expression in EOM and the effect of NO modulation on lateral rectus muscle's contractility. nNOS activity was highest in EOM compared with diaphragm, extensor digitorum longus, and soleus. Neuronal NOS was concentrated to the sarcolemma of orbital and global singly innervated fibers, but not evident in the multi-innervated fibers. The NG-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME, a NOS inhibitor), increased submaximal tetanic and peak twitch forces. The NO donors S-nitroso-N-acetylcysteine (SNAC) and spermineNONOate reduced submaximal tetanic and peak twitch forces. The effect of NO on the contractile force of lateral rectus muscle is greater than previously observed on other skeletal muscle. NO appears more important in modulating contraction of EOM compared with other skeletal muscles, which could be important for the EOM's specialized role in generation of eye movements.