Measuring cation dependent DNA polymerase fidelity landscapes by deep sequencing

High-throughput recording of signals embedded within inaccessible micro-environments is a technological challenge. The ideal recording device would be a nanoscale machine capable of quantitatively transducing a wide range of variables into a molecular recording medium suitable for long-term storage and facile readout in the form of digital data. We have recently proposed such a device, in which cation concentrations modulate the misincorporation rate of a DNA polymerase (DNAP) on a known template, allowing DNA sequences to encode information about the local cation concentration. In this work we quantify the cation sensitivity of DNAP misincorporation rates, making possible the indirect readout of cation concentration by DNA sequencing. Using multiplexed deep sequencing, we quantify the misincorporation properties of two DNA polymerases - Dpo4 and Klenow exo(-) - obtaining the probability and base selectivity of misincorporation at all positions within the template. We find that Dpo4 acts as a DNA recording device for Mn(2+) with a misincorporation rate gain of ～2%/mM. This modulation of misincorporation rate is selective to the template base: the probability of misincorporation on template T by Dpo4 increases >50-fold over the range tested, while the other template bases are affected less strongly. Furthermore, cation concentrations act as scaling factors for misincorporation: on a given template base, Mn(2+) and Mg(2+) change the overall misincorporation rate but do not alter the relative frequencies of incoming misincorporated nucleotides. Characterization of the ion dependence of DNAP misincorporation serves as the first step towards repurposing it as a molecular recording device.     

噬菌体RB69 DNA聚合酶以不正确的核苷酸为底物的聚合反应的稳态动力学研究

测定了ＲＢ６９ ＤＮＡ 聚合酶以不正确的核苷酸（ｒＮＴＰ、ｄｄＮＴＰ以及碱基不配对的ｄＮＴＰ）为底物进行聚合反应的稳态动力学常数,并与Ｋｌｅｎｏｗ 酶进行了比较．结果表明,ＲＢ６９ ＤＮＡ 聚合酶在以不正确的核苷酸为底物进行聚合反应时,其Ｋｍ 值与正确底物参入时相比有大幅度提高,而ｋｃａｔ保持不变或下降幅度较小．而Ｋｌｅｎｏｗ 酶在利用不正确的核苷酸为底物时,与正确底物参入时相比,其ｋｃａｔ大幅度下降,而Ｋｍ （或ＫＤ）基本保持不变或上升较小幅度．两种酶不同的动力学特点反映出它们不同的底物选择机制．     

Conformational dynamics during misincorporation and mismatch extension defined using a DNA polymerase with a fluorescent artificial amino acid

High-fidelity DNA polymerases select the correct nucleotide over the structurally similar incorrect nucleotides with extremely high specificity while maintaining fast rates of incorporation. Previous analysis revealed the conformational dynamics and complete kinetic pathway governing correct nucleotide incorporation using a high-fidelity DNA polymerase variant containing a fluorescent unnatural amino acid. Here we extend this analysis to investigate the kinetics of nucleotide misincorporation and mismatch extension. We report the specificity constants for all possible misincorporations and characterize the conformational dynamics of the enzyme during misincorporation and mismatch extension. We present free energy profiles based on the kinetic measurements and discuss the effect of different steps on specificity. During mismatch incorporation and subsequent extension with the correct nucleotide, the rates of the conformational change and chemistry are both greatly reduced. The nucleotide dissociation rate, however, increases to exceed the rate of chemistry. To investigate the structural basis for discrimination against mismatched nucleotides, we performed all atom molecular dynamics simulations on complexes with either the correct or mismatched nucleotide bound at the polymerase active site. The simulations suggest that the closed form of the enzyme with a mismatch bound is greatly destabilized due to weaker interactions with active site residues, nonideal base pairing, and a large increase in the distance from the 3ʹ-OH group of the primer strand to the α-phosphate of the incoming nucleotide, explaining the reduced rates of misincorporation. The observed kinetic and structural mechanisms governing nucleotide misincorporation reveal the general principles likely applicable to other high-fidelity DNA polymerases.     

Single base extension (SBE) with proofreading polymerases and phosphorothioate primers: improved fidelity in single-substrate assays

Model single base extension (SBE) genotyping reactions with individual deoxy-, dideoxy- and acyclonucleoside triphosphates are monitored by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry. Three non-proofreading DNA polymerases display remarkably high misincorporation (up to 64% of correct incorporation) when extending primers with single substrates at saturating concentrations. Introduction of one phosphorothioate (PS) linkage into the primer 3′ terminus reduces misincorporation by these enzymes an average 1.4-fold (range 0- to 3.5-fold) versus correct incorporation. Combined use of 3′-PS primers with strongly proofreading DNA polymerases yields order of magnitude improvements in SBE fidelity over those produced by the equivalent non-proofreading enzymes. Errors are reduced to below MALDI-TOF detectable levels in almost all cases. The Sp diastereomer of the 3′-PS primer, which can be prepared in situ by incubation with proofreading polymerase, is stable to 3′-exonuclease activity over periods longer than 16 h. Products of correct extension by T7 DNAP are retained over 30–60 min during idling turnover at a dNTP concentration of 2.5 µM, indicating that the assay can be applied over a broad range of substrate concentrations. These results suggest that the use of PS primers and proofreading polymerases will offer a simple and cost-effective means to improve fidelity in a range of single-substrate SBE assay formats.     

Structure and enzymatic properties of a chimeric bacteriophage RB69 DNA polymerase and single-stranded DNA binding protein with increased processivity

In vivo, replicative DNA polymerases are made more processive by their interactions with accessory proteins at the replication fork. Single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB) is an essential protein that binds tightly and cooperatively to single-stranded DNA during replication to remove adventitious secondary structures and protect the exposed DNA from endogenous nucleases. Using information from high resolution structures and biochemical data, we have engineered a functional chimeric enzyme of the bacteriophage RB69 DNA polymerase and SSB with substantially increased processivity. Fusion of RB69 DNA polymerase with its cognate SSB via a short six amino acid linker increases affinity for primer-template DNA by sixfold and subsequently increases processivity by sevenfold while maintaining fidelity. The crystal structure of this fusion protein was solved by a combination of multiwavelength anomalous diffraction and molecular replacement to 3.2 A resolution and shows that RB69 SSB is positioned proximal to the N-terminal domain of RB69 DNA polymerase near the template strand channel. The structural and biochemical data suggest that SSB interactions with DNA polymerase are transient and flexible, consistent with models of a dynamic replisome during elongation.     

Error induction and correction by mutant and wild type T4 DNA polymerases. Kinetic error discrimination mechanisms.

The fidelity of DNA synthesis as determined by the misincorporation of the base analogue 2-aminopurine in competition with adenine has been measured as a function of deoxynucleoside triphosphate substrate concentrations using purified mutator (L56), antimutator (L141), and wild type (T4D) T4 DNA polymerases. Although the rates of both incorporation and turnover of aminopurine and adenine decrease as substrate concentrations are decreased, the ratio of turnover/polymerase activity is increased. Thus, the nuclease/polymerase ratio of each of these three DNA polymerases can be controlled. The misincorporation of aminopurine decreases with decreasing substrate concentrations such that all three enzymes approach nearly identical misincorporation frequencies at the lowest substrate concentration. The increased accuracy of DNA synthesis corresponds to conditions producing a high nuclease/polymerase ratio. The misinsertion frequency for aminopurine is independent of substrate concentrations and enzyme phenotype; therefore, the increased accuracy of DNA synthesis with decreasing substrate concentrations is shown to be a result of increased nuclease activity and not increased polymerase or nuclease specificity. The data are analyzed in terms of a kinetic model of DNA polymerase accuracy which proposes that discrimination in nucleotide insertion and removal is based on the free energy difference between matched and mismatched base pairs. A value of 1.1 kcal/mol free energy difference, delta G, between adenine: thymine and aminopurine:thymine base pairs is predicted by model analysis of the cocentration dependence of aminopurine misincorporation and removal frequencies. An independent estimate of this free energy difference based on the 6-fold higher apparent Km of T4 DNA polymerase for aminopurine compared to adenine also gives a value of 1.1 kcal/mol. It is shown that the aminopurine misinsertion frequency for an enzyme having either extremely low 3'-exonuclease activity, Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I, or no measurable exonuclease activity, calf thymus DNA polymerase alpha, is 12 to 15%, which is similar to that for the T4 polymerases and consistent with delta G approximately 1.1 kcal/mol.     

Local Conformations and Competitive Binding Affinities of Single- and Double-stranded Primer-Template DNA at the Polymerization and Editing Active Sites of DNA Polymerases

In addition to their capacity for template-directed 5′ → 3′ DNA synthesis at the polymerase (pol) site, DNA polymerases have a separate 3′ → 5′ exonuclease (exo) editing activity that is involved in assuring the fidelity of DNA replication. Upon misincorporation of an incorrect nucleotide residue, the 3′ terminus of the primer strand at the primer-template (P/T) junction is preferentially transferred to the exo site, where the faulty residue is excised, allowing the shortened primer to rebind to the template strand at the pol site and incorporate the correct dNTP. Here we describe the conformational changes that occur in the primer strand as it shuttles between the pol and exo sites of replication-competent Klenow and Klentaq DNA polymerase complexes in solution and use these conformational changes to measure the equilibrium distribution of the primer between these sites for P/T DNA constructs carrying both matched and mismatched primer termini. To this end, we have measured the fluorescence and circular dichroism spectra at wavelengths of >300 nm for conformational probes comprising pairs of 2-aminopurine bases site-specifically replacing adenine bases at various positions in the primer strand of P/T DNA constructs bound to DNA polymerases. Control experiments that compare primer conformations with available x-ray structures confirm the validity of this approach. These distributions and the conformational changes in the P/T DNA that occur during template-directed DNA synthesis in solution illuminate some of the mechanisms used by DNA polymerases to assure the fidelity of DNA synthesis.Escherichia coli DNA polymerase (DNAP)² I is a single subunit polymerase that is organized into three functional domains: an N-terminal domain that is associated with 5′ → 3′ exonuclease activity, an intermediate domain that carries the 3′ → 5′ proofreading activity, and a C-terminal domain that is associated with the 5′ → 3′ template-directed polymerization activity. An important role of DNAP I is to remove the RNA primers of the Okazaki fragments formed during lagging strand DNA synthesis in E. coli replication and to fill in the resulting gaps by template-directed DNA synthesis (1). An N-terminal deletion mutant of DNAP I, known as the “large fragment” or Klenow form of the enzyme, contains only the polymerase (pol) and the 3′ → 5′ exonuclease (exo) domains. The Klenow polymerase has served and continues to serve as an excellent model system for isolating and defining general structure-function relationships in polymerases and in the supporting machinery of DNA replication.The main function of the 3′ → 5′ exonuclease activity of DNAP I is to remove misincorporated nucleotide residues from the 3′-end of the primer (2), thus contributing significantly to the overall fidelity of DNA replication (3). Contrary to initial expectations, crystallographic studies showed that the pol and exo active sites are quite far apart in replication polymerases, about 30 Å in Klenow (4). As a consequence, the ability of polymerases to “shuttle” the 3′-end of the primer strand efficiently between the pol and the exo sites in order to rectify misincorporation events during polymerization is critical to maintaining the overall accuracy of template-directed replication. Elucidation of the mechanisms of this shuttling and determination of the factors that control the rates (and equilibria) of the active site switching reaction will certainly increase our understanding of fidelity control by DNA polymerases.An early crystallographic study of the Klenow polymerase complexed with fully paired primer-template (P/T) DNA revealed that 3–4 nt of the 3′-primer terminus had been unwound from the template stand and partitioned into the exo site and that an extended single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) binding pocket of the exo site appeared to make position-specific hydrophobic contacts with the unstacked bases at the 3′-end of the primer (4). A separate crystallographic study of an editing complex confirmed that an ssDNA fragment 4 nt in length was bound at the exo site in the same conformation as seen for the single-stranded 3′-primer sequence unwound from P/T DNA (5). A structure of Klenow polymerase with the DNA bound at the pol site has not yet been reported, although such structures have been obtained for other homologous polymerases, including Klentaq (the “large fragment” of Thermus aquaticus (Taq) DNAP), Bacillus stearothermophilus (Bst) “large fragment” polymerase, and the T7 DNAP (6–8), all of which are members of the polymerase family that includes Klenow.The amino acid residues involved in the binding of DNA at the pol site in these polymerases (determined from co-crystal structures) and those of Klenow (determined by site-directed mutagenesis studies (9, 10)) are highly conserved, suggesting that a similar DNA binding mode at the pol site may apply to all of the DNAP I polymerases. The crystal structure of Klenow revealed that the polymerization domain has a shape reminiscent of a right hand in which the palm, fingers, and thumb domains form the DNA-binding crevice. Structural studies with various DNAP I polymerases in the presence of P/T DNA constructs yielded an “open” binary complex, whereas the addition of the next correct dNTP (as a chain-terminating dideoxy-NTP) resulted in the formation of a catalytically competent “closed” ternary complex (6–8). In the latter complex, the 3′-primer terminus was base-paired with the template DNA, and the templating base was poised for incorporation of the next correct nucleotide. These structures showed that the conformation of the DNA primer terminus bound at the pol site is markedly different from that of the “frayed open” primer observed at the exo site in Klenow (4, 5).Although crystallographic studies have provided a wealth of information about the conformations of the DNA substrates bound at the active sites of DNAP, replication itself is a dynamic process (reviewed in Ref. 11), and it is critical to be able to distinguish between various forms of DNA-polymerase complexes in solution in order to fully understand the mechanistic details of the replication process. A solution approach used by Millar and co-workers (reviewed in Ref. 12) for studying the conformation of DNA in these complexes involved measuring the time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy properties of a dansyl fluorophore attached to a DNA base located 8 bp upstream of the P/T DNA junction. The changes in the lifetime of the fluorophore, which appeared to depend mostly on the local environment occupied by the probe within the protein (i.e. buried versus partially exposed), were correlated with specific binding conformations of the primer to provide an estimate of the fractional occupancy of the pol and the exo sites. Reha-Krantz and co-workers (13) more recently used a related approach, here involving the monitoring of changes in the fluorescent lifetimes of a single 2-aminopurine (2-AP) base (a fluorescent analogue of adenine) site-specifically substituted in the template strand at the P/T junction, to make similar fractional occupancy measurements. However, we note that structural interpretations of these fluorescence experiments relied heavily on the available crystal structures, and it remained to be shown directly that the 3′-end of the primer in P/T DNA constructs assumes the same distribution of conformations when bound to the protein in solution.To get around this problem, as well as to directly investigate the conformations of the primer DNA in both active sites of the Klenow and Klentaq polymerases, we have used a novel CD spectroscopic approach to characterize the solution conformations of primer DNA bound to Klenow and Klentaq DNAPs. Previously, we had shown that CD spectroscopy, in conjunction with fluorescence measurements, can be used to examine changes in local DNA and RNA conformations at 2-AP dimer probes inserted at specified positions within the nucleic acid frameworks of a variety of macromolecular machines functioning in solution (14–16). 2-AP is a structural isomer of adenine that forms base pairs with thymine in DNA (and uridine in RNA), and the substitution of 2-AP for adenine in such bp does not significantly perturb the structure or stability of the resultant double helix. Furthermore, when these probes are used as dimer pairs, the CD spectrum primarily reflects the interaction of the transition dipoles of the two probes themselves and thus the local conformation of the DNA at those positions within the P/T DNA. The characteristic CD and fluorescence signals for 2-AP probes in nucleic acids occur at wavelengths of >300 nm, a spectral region in which the protein and the canonical nucleic acid components of the “macromolecular machines of gene expression” are otherwise transparent. In this study, we have examined the binding of Klenow and Klentaq polymerases to P/T DNA constructs that were designed to be comparable with the nucleic acid components of functioning replication complexes. By examining the low energy CD spectra of site-specifically placed 2-AP probes, we have been able to characterize base conformations at defined positions within the DNA to reveal conformational features of specific DNA bases bound at and near both the pol and the exo active sites of these polymerases. These measurements, in that they directly reflect the actual conformations of the DNA chains bound within the active sites of the functioning polymerase, have also provided a direct means to estimate the equilibrium distributions of primer ends between the two active sites for various P/T DNA constructs.     

Mechanism of nucleotide incorporation in DNA polymerase beta

DNA polymerases play a central role in the mechanisms of DNA replication and repair. Here, we report mechanisms of the beta-polymerase catalyzed phosphoryl transfer reactions corresponding to correct and incorrect nucleotide incorporations in the DNA. Based on energy minimizations, molecular dynamics simulations, and free energy calculations of solvated ternary complexes of pol beta and by employing a mixed quantum mechanics molecular mechanics Hamiltonian, we have uncovered the identities of transient intermediates in the phosphoryl transfer pathways. Our study has revealed that an intriguing Grotthuss hopping mechanism of proton transfer involving water and three conserved aspartate residues in pol beta's active site mediates the phosphoryl transfer in the correct as well as misincorporation of nucleotides. The significance of this catalytic step in serving as a kinetic check point of polymerase fidelity may be unique to DNA polymerase beta, and is discussed in relation to other known mechanisms of DNA polymerases.     

Variants of DNA polymerase Beta extend mispaired DNA due to increased affinity for nucleotide substrate

DNA polymerase beta offers an attractive system to study the biochemical mechanism of polymerase-dependent mutagenesis. Variants of DNA polymerase beta, Y265F and Y265W, were analyzed for misincorporation efficiency and mispair extension ability, relative to wild-type DNA polymerase beta. Our data show that the fidelity of the mutant polymerases is similar to wild-type enzyme on a one-nucleotide gapped DNA substrate. In contrast, with a six-nucleotide gapped DNA, the mutant proteins are slightly more accurate than the wild-type enzyme. The mutagenic potential of Y265F and Y265W is more pronounced when encountering a mispaired DNA substrate. Here, both variants can extend a G:G mispair quite efficiently, and Y265F can also extend a T:G mispair. The kinetic basis of the increased mispair extension efficiency is due to an improved ability to bind to the incoming nucleotide. Y265W extends the G:G mispair even with an incorrect nucleotide substrate. Overall, our results demonstrate that the Y265 hinge residue is important for stabilizing the architecture of the nucleotide binding pocket of DNA polymerase beta, and that alterations of this residue can have significant impacts upon the fidelity of DNA synthesis.     

Steric and Electrostatic Effects at the C2 Atom Substituent Influence Replication and Miscoding of the DNA Deamination Product Deoxyxanthosine and Analogs by DNA Polymerases

Deoxyinosine (dI) and deoxyxanthosine (dX) are both formed in DNA at appreciable levels in vivo by deamination of deoxyadenosine (dA) and deoxyguanosine (dG), respectively, and can miscode. Structure-activity relationships for dA pairing have been examined extensively using analogs but relatively few studies have probed the roles of the individual hydrogen-bonding atoms of dG in DNA replication. The replicative bacteriophage T7 DNA polymerase/exonuclease and the translesion DNA polymerase Sulfolobus solfataricus pol IV were used as models to discern the mechanisms of miscoding by DNA polymerases. Removal of the 2-amino group from the template dG (i.e., dI) had little impact on the catalytic efficiency of either polymerase, as judged by either steady-state or pre-steady-state kinetic analysis, although the misincorporation frequency was increased by an order of magnitude. dX was highly miscoding with both polymerases, and incorporation of several bases was observed. The addition of an electronegative fluorine atom at the 2-position of dI lowered the oligonucleotide T_m and strongly inhibited incorporation of dCTP. The addition of bromine or oxygen (dX) at C2 lowered the T_m further, strongly inhibited both polymerases, and increased the frequency of misincorporation. Linear activity models show the effects of oxygen (dX) and the halogens at C2 on both DNA polymerases as mainly due to a combination of both steric and electrostatic factors, producing a clash with the paired cytosine O2 atom, as opposed to either bulk or perturbation of purine ring electron density alone.     

The D246V mutant of DNA polymerase beta misincorporates nucleotides: evidence for a role for the flexible loop in DNA positioning within the active site

DNA polymerase beta, a member of the X family of DNA polymerases, is known to be involved in base excision repair. A key to determining the biochemical properties of this DNA polymerase is structure-function studies of site-specific mutants that result in substitution of particular amino acids at critical sites. In a previous genetic screen, we identified three 3'-azido-2',3'-dideoxythymidine 5'-triphosphate-resistant mutants, namely E249K, D246V, and R253M, of polymerase beta in the flexible loop of the palm domain. In this work, we perform an extensive kinetic analysis to investigate the role of the D246V mutant on polymerase fidelity. We find that D246V misincorporates T opposite template bases G and C. The mechanistic basis of misincorporation appears to be altered DNA positioning within the active site. We provide evidence that the fidelity of D246V is greatly affected by the base that is 5' of the templating base. We propose that the Asp residue at position 246 helps to maintain the proper positioning of the DNA within the polymerase active site and maintains the fidelity of polymerase beta. Altogether, the results suggest that the flexible loop domain of polymerase beta plays a major role in its fidelity.     

Effect of molecular crowding on DNA polymerase activity

Live cells contain high concentrations of macromolecules, but almost all experimental biochemical data have been generated from dilute solutions that do not reflect conditions in vivo. To understand biomolecular behavior in vivo, properties studied in vitro are extrapolated to conditions in vivo; however, the molecular conditions within live cells are inherently crowded. The present study investigates the effect of molecular crowding on DNA polymerase activity using polyethylene glycol PEG of various molecular weights as a crowding agent. Polymerase activity assays under various conditions demonstrated that the activities of T7 and Taq DNA polymerases depend on the molecular weight and concentration of the crowding agent. Furthermore, equilibrium and kinetic analyses demonstrated that the binding affinity and catalytic activity of the polymerase increase and decrease, respectively, with increasing PEG concentrations. Based on quantitative parameters of the polymerase reactions, we improved the efficiency of PCR amplification under conditions of molecular crowding. These results suggest that quantitative measurements of biomolecular structure and function are useful for understanding the behavior of biomolecules in vivo and for biotechnology applications in vitro.     

Kinetic analysis of the unique error signature of human DNA polymerase ν

The fidelity of DNA synthesis by A-family DNA polymerases ranges from very accurate for bacterial, bacteriophage, and mitochondrial family members to very low for certain eukaryotic homologues. The latter include DNA polymerase ν (Pol ν) which, among all A-family polymerases, is uniquely prone to misincorporating dTTP opposite template G in a highly sequence-dependent manner. Here we present a kinetic analysis of this unusual error specificity, in four different sequence contexts and in comparison to Pol ν's more accurate A-family homologue, the Klenow fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I. The kinetic data strongly correlate with rates of stable misincorporation during gap-filling DNA synthesis. The lower fidelity of Pol ν compared to that of Klenow fragment can be attributed primarily to a much lower catalytic efficiency for correct dNTP incorporation, whereas both enzymes have similar kinetic parameters for G-dTTP misinsertion. The major contributor to sequence-dependent differences in Pol ν error rates is the reaction rate, k(pol). In the sequence context where fidelity is highest, k(pol) for correct G-dCTP incorporation by Pol ν is ~15-fold faster than k(pol) for G-dTTP misinsertion. However, in sequence contexts where the error rate is higher, k(pol) is the same for both correct and mismatched dNTPs, implying that the transition state does not provide additional discrimination against misinsertion. The results suggest that Pol ν may be fine-tuned to function when high enzyme activity is not a priority and may even be disadvantageous and that the relaxed active-site specificity toward the G-dTTP mispair may be associated with its cellular function(s).     

Unlocking the sugar "steric gate" of DNA polymerases

To maintain genomic stability, ribonucleotide incorporation during DNA synthesis is controlled predominantly at the DNA polymerase level. A steric clash between the 2'-hydroxyl of an incoming ribonucleotide and a bulky active site residue, known as the "steric gate", establishes an effective mechanism for most DNA polymerases to selectively insert deoxyribonucleotides. Recent kinetic, structural, and in vivo studies have illuminated novel features about ribonucleotide exclusion and the mechanistic consequences of ribonucleotide misincorporation on downstream events, such as the bypass of a ribonucleotide in a DNA template and the subsequent extension of the DNA lesion bypass product. These important findings are summarized in this review.