Comparison of the Caco-2, HT-29 and the mucus-secreting HT29-MTX intestinal cell models to investigate Salmonella adhesion and invasion

Human intestinal cell models are widely used to study host-enteric pathogen interactions, with different cell lines exhibiting specific characteristics and functions in the gut epithelium. In particular, the presence of mucus may play an important role in adhesion and invasion of pathogens. The aim of this study was to evaluate the suitability of the mucus-secreting HT29-MTX intestinal epithelial cell model to test adhesion and invasion of Salmonella strains and compare with data obtained with the more commonly used Caco-2 and HT-29 models. Adhesion of Salmonella to HT29-MTX cell model was significantly higher, likely due to high adhesiveness to mucins present in the native human mucus layer covering the whole cell surface, compared to the non- and low-mucus producing Caco-2 and HT-29 cell models, respectively. In addition, invasion percentages of some clinical Salmonella strains to HT29-MTX cultures were remarkably higher than to Caco-2 and HT-29 cells suggesting that these Salmonellae have subverted the mucus to enhance pathogenicity. The transepithelial electrical resistances of the infected HT29-MTX cell model decreased broadly and were highly correlated with invasion ability of the strain. Staining of S. Typhimurium-infected cell epithelium confirmed the higher invasion by Salmonella and subsequent disruption of tight junctions of HT29-MTX cell model compared with the Caco-2 and HT-29 cell models. Data from this study suggest that the HT29-MTX cell model, with more physiologically relevant characteristics with the mucus layer formation, could be better suited for studying cells–pathogens interactions.     

SIgA Binding to Mucosal Surfaces Is Mediated by Mucin-Mucin Interactions

The oral mucosal pellicle is a layer of absorbed salivary proteins, including secretory IgA (SIgA), bound onto the surface of oral epithelial cells and is a useful model for all mucosal surfaces. The mechanism by which SIgA concentrates on mucosal surfaces is examined here using a tissue culture model with real saliva. Salivary mucins may initiate the formation of the mucosal pellicle through interactions with membrane-bound mucins on cells. Further protein interactions with mucins may then trigger binding of other pellicle proteins. HT29 colon cell lines, which when treated with methotrexate (HT29-MTX) produce a gel-forming mucin, were used to determine the importance of these mucin-mucin interactions. Binding of SIgA to cells was then compared using whole mouth saliva, parotid (mucin-free) saliva and a source of purified SIgA. Greatest SIgA binding occurred when WMS was incubated with HT29-MTX expressing mucus. Since salivary MUC5B was only able to bind to cells which produced mucus and purified SIgA showed little binding to the same cells we conclude that most SIgA binding to mucosal cells occurs because SIgA forms complexes with salivary mucins which then bind to cells expressing membrane-bound mucins. This work highlights the importance of mucin interactions in the development of the mucosal pellicle.     

The Interaction of Helicobacter pylori with the Adherent Mucus Gel Layer Secreted by Polarized HT29-MTX-E12 Cells

Helicobacter pylori colonises the gastric mucosa of humans. The majority of organisms live in mucus. These organisms are an important reservoir for infection of the underlying epithelium. Cell culture models for H. pylori infection do not normally possess a mucus layer. The interaction of H. pylori with TFF1, a member of the trefoil factor family found in gastric mucin, is mediated by lipopolysaccharide. To test the hypothesis that the interaction of H. pylori with TFF1 promotes mucus colonization we characterised the interaction of H. pylori with a mucus secreting cell line, HT29-MTX-E12. An isogenic mutant of H. pylori with truncated core oligosaccharides was produced and binding to TFF1 and ability to colonise HT29-MTX-E12 cells determined. The adherent mucus layer of HT29-MTX-E12 cells contained the gastric mucin MUC5AC and trefoil factors, TFF1 and TFF3. H. pylori was found within the mucus layer in discrete clusters and in close association with TFF1. It also interacted with the membrane bound mucin MUC1 and replicated when co-cultured with the cells. An isogenic mutant of H. pylori with a truncated LPS core did not interact with TFF1, and colonization of HT29-MTX-E12 cells was reduced compared to the wild-type strain (p<0.05). Preincubation of cells with wild type LPS but not with truncated LPS resulted in reduced colonization by H. pylori. These results demonstrate that the interaction of TFF1 with H. pylori is important for colonization of gastric mucus and the core oligosaccharide of H. pylori LPS is critical for this interaction to occur. HT29-MTX-E12 cells are a useful system with which to study the interaction of bacteria with mucosal surfaces and the effect of such interactions on mediating colonization.     

The StcE metalloprotease of enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli reduces the inner mucus layer and promotes adherence to human colonic epithelium ex vivo

Enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli (EHEC) is a major foodborne pathogen and tightly adheres to human colonic epithelium by forming attaching/effacing lesions. To reach the epithelial surface, EHEC must penetrate the thick mucus layer protecting the colonic epithelium. In this study, we investigated how EHEC interacts with the intestinal mucus layer using mucin‐producing LS174T colon carcinoma cells and human colonic mucosal biopsies. The level of EHEC binding and attaching/effacing lesion formation in LS174T cells was higher compared to mucin‐deficient colon carcinoma cell lines, and initial adherence was independent of the presence of flagellin, Escherichia coli common pilus, or long polar fimbriae. Although EHEC infection did not affect gene expression of secreted mucins, it resulted in reduced MUC2 glycoprotein levels. This effect was dependent on the catalytic activity of the secreted metalloprotease StcE, which reduced the inner mucus layer and thereby promoted EHEC access and binding to the epithelium in vitro and ex vivo. Given the lack of efficient therapies against EHEC infection, StcE may represent a suitable target for future treatment and prevention strategies.     

TFF3-peptide increases transepithelial resistance in epithelial cells by modulating claudin-1 and -2 expression

TFF3 plays an important role in the protection and repair of the gastrointestinal mucosa. The molecular mechanisms of TFF function, however, are still largely unknown. Increasing evidence indicates that apart from stabilizing mucosal mucins TFF3 induces cellular signals that modulate cell–cell junctions of epithelia. In transfected HT29/B6 and MDCK cells stably expressing FLAG-tagged human TFF3 we have recently shown that TFF3 down-regulates E-cadherin, impairs the function of adherens junctions and thus facilitates cell migration in wounded epithelial cell layers. Here we investigate TFF3-induced effects on the composition and function of tight junctions in these cells. TFF3 increased the cellular level of tightening claudin-1 and decreased the amount of claudin-2 known to form cation-selective channels. Expression of ZO-1, ZO-2 and occludin was not altered. The change in claudin-1 and -2 expression in TFF3-expressing HT29/B6 cells was accompanied by an increase in the transepithelial resistance in confluent monolayers of these cells. These data suggest that TFF3 plays a role in the regulation of intestinal barrier function by altering the claudin composition within tight junctions thus decreasing paracellular permeability of the intestinal mucosa.     

Improved in vitro model systems for gastrointestinal infection by choice of cell line, pH, microaerobic conditions, and optimization of culture conditions

BACKGROUND: Commonly used in vitro infection cultures do not mimic the human gastrointestinal tract with regard to pH and microaerobic conditions. Furthermore, despite the importance of mucin-Helicobacter interactions, the cell lines used have not been selected for appropriate mucin expression. To make in vitro studies more applicable to human disease, we have developed coculture methods taking these factors into account. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Nine human gastrointestinal epithelial cell lines (MKN1, MKN7, MKN28, MKN45, KATO3, HFE145, PCAA/C11 Caco-2, and LS513) were investigated. Expression and glycosylation of mucins (MUC1, 2, 3, 4, 5AC, 5B, 6, 12, 13, and 16) were determined by immunohistochemistry. We analyzed the effect of microaerobic conditions and acidic pH on cell proliferation, viability, and apoptosis. RESULTS: Microaerobic culture, which is more physiological for the bacteria, did not adversely affect mammalian cell viability, proliferation, or induce apoptosis The cell lines varied in mucin expression, with MKN7 and MKN45 being most similar to gastric mucosa and Caco-2 and LS513 to intestinal mucosa, although none exactly matched normal mucosa. However, changes in culture conditions did not cause major changes in the mucin expression within cell lines. CONCLUSIONS: Culture conditions mimicking the natural environment and allowing the bacterial cells to thrive had no effect on cell viability or apoptosis, and very little influence on mucin expression of human gastrointestinal cells. Thus, it is feasible, using the simple methods we present here, to substantially improve bacterial-mammalian cell in vitro coculture studies to make them more reflective of human infection.     

Differentiation of a clone isolated from the HT29 cell line: polarized distribution of histocompatibility antigens (HLA) and of transferrin receptors

The HT29 cell line, derived from a human colon adenocarcinoma, is able to differentiate if galactose replaces glucose in the culture medium. We have isolated a clone (HT29-18) from this cell line which displays differentiated properties of the parent cell line. HT29-18 cells grown in glucose-containing medium form multiple layers of round cells without specific cell-cell adhesion. In contrast, when grown in galactose-containing medium, they form a monolayer with tight junctions and exhibit a well differentiated brush border at their apical membrane, which faces the culture medium. The polarized properties of HT29-18 cells grown in galactose-containing medium were demonstrated by immunofluorescent techniques with antibodies against 2 plasma membrane proteins. Class I histocompatibility antigens (HLA) and transferrin receptors, 2 well characterized integral membrane proteins, are uniformly distributed on the cell surface of undifferentiated HT29-18 cells, but acquire a polarized distribution during differentiation, localized on the basolateral membranes and absent from the apical surface. Binding of 125I-labeled transferrin was used to determine transferrin receptor distribution on apical and basolateral membranes. Functional tight junctions in the differentiated cultures were demonstrated, as the monolayer was impermeable to a permeation dye (ruthenium red) as well as to antibodies. The sealing of these tight junctions is, as in vivo, Ca++-dependent as they could be opened by a short incubation in Ca++-free medium.     

Production of MUC1 and MUC2 mucins by human tumor cell lines.

A mucus secreting, clonal derivative (HT29-SB) of the human colonic adenocarcinoma cell line HT29, and the LS174T colon cancer cell line, secrete mucin into the culture medium as a viscoelastic gel. Mab BC2, which defines a peptide epitope present in the variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) of the MUC1 core protein, reacted with this material after deglycosylation. Two high molecular weight bands were detected in TFMSA treated gel-formed mucin from HT29-SB and LS174T by western blotting (Mr 580 kDa and 420 kDa). A similar pattern of reactivity was seen with the culture supernatants from HT29-SB, the ovarian tumor cell line COLO-316, and the breast cancer cell line MCF-7. Mab CCP58 (anti-MUC2 VNTR) reacted with a 580 kDa band in gel-formed mucin produced by LS174T, but was not reactive with mucin produced by the other cell lines. The findings indicate that human colonic cell lines, in addition to breast and ovarian cell lines, may both express and secrete the MUC1 protein core, and that the LS174T cell line expresses and secretes both the MUC1 and MUC2 core proteins.     

Butyrate enemas upregulate Muc genes expression but decrease adherent mucus thickness in mice colon

Colonic mucosal protection is provided by the mucus gel, mainly composed of mucins. Several factors can modulate the formation and the secretion of mucins, and among them butyrate, an end-product of carbohydrate fermentation. However, the specific effect of butyrate on the various colonic mucins, and the consequences in terms of the mucus layer thickness are not known. Our aim was to determine whether butyrate modulates colonic MUC genes expression in vivo and whether this results in changes in mucus synthesis and mucus layer thickness. Mice received daily for 7 days rectal enemas of butyrate (100 mM) versus saline. We demonstrated that butyrate stimulated the gene expression of both secreted (Muc2) and membrane-linked (Muc1, Muc3, Muc4) mucins. Butyrate especially induced a 6-fold increase in Muc2 gene expression in proximal colon. However, butyrate enemas did not modify the number of epithelial cells containing the protein Muc2, and caused a 2-fold decrease in the thickness of adherent mucus layer. Further studies should help understanding whether this last phenomenon, i.e. the decrease in adherent mucus gel thickness, results in a diminished protective function or not.     

Caco-2 and LS174T cell lines provide different models for studying mucin expression in colon cancer

To compare the differences in MUC2 and MUC5AC mRNA among four colon cancer cell lines and to identify the best in vitro models for studying mucin expression, quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction was used to measure the expression of MUC2 and MUC5AC mRNA in Caco-2, HT29, LoVo, and LS174T cell lines. The levels of MUC2 mRNA expression in the four colon cancer cell lines ranked in order of mRNA abundance were: LS174T > LoVo > HT-29 > Caco-2. In contrast to MUC2, the abundances of MUC5AC mRNA were in the order: Caco-2 > HT-29 > LS174T > LoVo. Caco-2 (highest level of MUC5AC mRNA) and LS174T (highest level of MUC2 mRNA) were used to investigate the phenotypes. Morphologically, Caco-2 cells were larger with low electron density mucus-storing vacuoles, many cell surface microvilli, and no obvious intercellular spaces between cells, compared to LS174T cells. The proliferative and invasive capacities of LS174T cells were significantly higher than those of Caco-2 cells. Caco-2 and LS174T cells provide excellent in vitro models for studying mucin expression in colon cancer.     

Barrier characteristics of epithelial cultures modelling the airway and intestinal mucosa: a comparison

The barrier characteristics of polarized layers of Calu-3 and Caco-2 cell lines, as commonly used in vitro models of intestinal and airway mucosa, respectively, were investigated by assessing the translocation of model macromolecules and nanoparticles. The barrier capacity of the cell layers towards the movement of macromolecules and nanoparticulates differed considerably between the cell lines. Permeability studies revealed the existence of a notably larger solute molecular weight limit for paracellular diffusion in Caco-2 monolayers compared to Calu-3 cells. Removal of mucus in Calu-3 cells resulted in cell layers exhibiting a larger macromolecular permeability, in addition to improved nanoparticle translocation. Microscopic examination of the tight junctions, as cellular features that play a major role in preventing transepithelial movement of macromolecules, revealed that the appearance of cell–cell boundaries was notably different in the two cell lines, which could explain the differences in macromolecular permeability. The data overall showed that epithelial layers of airway Calu-3 and intestinal Caco-2 cell cultures in vitro exhibit a different level of restrictiveness and this is due to the cell morphology and the presence of mucus.     

Generation of Mouse Small Intestinal Epithelial Cell Lines That Allow the Analysis of Specific Innate Immune Functions

Cell lines derived from the small intestine that reflect authentic properties of the originating intestinal epithelium are of high value for studies on mucosal immunology and host microbial homeostasis. A novel immortalization procedure was applied to generate continuously proliferating cell lines from murine E19 embryonic small intestinal tissue. The obtained cell lines form a tight and polarized epithelial cell layer, display characteristic tight junction, microvilli and surface protein expression and generate increasing transepithelial electrical resistance during in vitro culture. Significant up-regulation of Cxcl2 and Cxcl5 chemokine expression upon exposure to defined microbial innate immune stimuli and endogenous cytokines is observed. Cell lines were also generated from a transgenic interferon reporter (Mx2-Luciferase) mouse, allowing reporter technology-based quantification of the cellular response to type I and III interferon. Thus, the newly created cell lines mimic properties of the natural epithelium and can be used for diverse studies including testing of the absorption of drug candidates. The reproducibility of the method to create such cell lines from wild type and transgenic mice provides a new tool to study molecular and cellular processes of the epithelial barrier.     

Differential mucin expression in colon carcinoma HT-29 clones with variable resistance to 5-fluorouracil and methotrexate

A current challenge is to define the biological characteristics of colon tumor cells resistant to chemotherapy. Distinct sub-populations of mucus-secreting cells were previously obtained from the colon cancer cell line HT-29 after long-term treatment with the anti-cancer drugs, 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and methotrexate (MTX). Since mucins are increasingly implicated as playing a role in carcinogenesis, we studied the pattern of mucin expression in two HT-29 clones of mucus-secreting and two clones of enterocyte-like phenotype which differ in their capacity to resist to 5-FU and/or MTX. The expression of both transmembrane (MUC1, MUC3, MUC4) and secreted gel-forming (MUC2, MUC5AC, MUC5B, MUC6) mucins in clones was studied by northern and/or western blotting. The four HT-29 clones showed three cellular phenotypes: (1) The mucus-secreting clone HT29-5F12 consists of unpolarized cells with mucus secretions that have anti-colonic mucin immunoreactivity, and mainly expresses MUC2 and is resistant to 5-FU and sensitive to MTX; (2) The mucus-secreting clone HT29-5M21 forms a monolayer of polarized cells with strong anti-gastric mucin immunoreactivity and mainly expresses MUC5AC and MUC5B and is resistant to MTX and sensitive to 5-FU; (3) The two enterocyte-like clones, HT29-5F7 and HT29-5M12 are resistant to both MTX and 5-FU and express mainly MUC1 and MUC5B, respectively. These clones which originate from a same colorectal tumour and display different patterns of mucin expression as well as differing resistance to MTX and 5-FU will make useful in vitro models for studying the potential role of mucins or other biological markers in drug resistance pathways.     

Functional Heterogeneity of Colonic Adenocarcinoma Mucins for Inhibition of Entamoeba histolytica Adherence to Target Cells1

Mucins secreted from the gastrointestinal epithelium form the basis of the adherent mucus layer which is the host's first line of defense against invasion by Entamoeba histolytica. Galactose and N-acetyl-D-galactosamine residues of mucins specifically inhibit binding of the amebic 170 kDa heavy subunit Gal-lectin to target cells, an absolute prerequisite for pathogenesis. Herein we characterized the secretory mucins isolated from the human colon and from three human colonic adenocarcinoma cell lines: two with goblet cell-like (LS174T and T84) and one with absorptive cell-like morphology (Caco-2). By Northern blot analysis the intestinal mucin genes MUC2 and MUC3 were constitutively expressed by confluent LS174T and Caco-2 cells, whereas T84 cells only transcribed MUC2 and not MUC3 mRNA. ³H-glucosamine and ³H-threonine metabolically labeled proteins separated as high M_r mucins in the void (V_o > 10⁶ Da) of Sepharose-4B column chromatography and remained in the stacking gel of SDS-PAGE as depicted by fluorography. All mucin preparations contained high amounts of N-acetyl-glucosamine, galactose, N-acetyl-galactosamine, fucose and sialic acid, saccharides typical of the O-linked carbohydrate side chains. Mucin samples from the human colon and from LS174T and Caco-2 cells inhibited E. histolytica adherence to Chinese hamster ovary cells, whereas mucins from T84 cells did not. These results suggest that genetic heterogeneity and/or posttranslational modification in glycosylation of colonic mucins can affect specific epithelial barrier function against intestinal pathogens.     

Mucins: A biologically relevant glycan barrier in mucosal protection

Background

The mucins found as components of mucus gel layers at mucosal surfaces throughout the body play roles in protection as part of the defensive barrier on an organ and tissue specific basis.

Scope of the review

The human MUC gene family codes up to 20 known proteins, which can be divided into secreted and membrane-associated forms each with a typical protein domain structure. The secreted mucins are adapted to cross link in order to allow formation of the extended mucin networks found in the secreted mucus gels. The membrane-associated mucins possess membrane specific domains which enable their various biological functions as part of the glycocalyx. All mucins are highly O-glycosylated and this is tissue specific and linked with specific biological functions at these locations. Mucin biology is dynamic and the processes of degradation and turnover are well integrated with biosynthesis to maintain a continuous mucosal protection against all external aggressive forces. Interaction of mucins with microflora plays an important role in normal function. Mucins are modified in a variety of diseases and this may be due to abberant mucin peptide or glycosylation.

Major conclusions

Mucins represent a family of glycoprotein having fundamental roles in mucosal protection and communication with external environment.

General significance

The review emphasises the nature of mucins as glycoproteins and their role in presenting an array of glycan structures at the mucosal cell surface.     

Distinct Effects of Protein Kinase C on the Barrier Function at Different Developmental Stages

We show here, that activation of protein kinase C by the phorbol ester PMA improves barrier function in colon carcinoma (HT 29) cells. By contrast, in canine kidney (MDCK I) cells it caused increased permeability and opening of tight junctions; the latter has also been noticed in other studies. Thus, with PMA confluent HT 29 cells responded with a reduced passage of 330 kDa sodium fluorescein, increased transepithelial electrical resistance, and a change in the cell shape of the HT 29 cells from an irregular to a regular, hexagonal form. Confocal imaging revealed parallel distinct changes in the staining of occludin and caludin-1, viz. a translocation from cytoplasmic clusters to apical cell–cell contacts. Interestingly, in both cell lines protein kinase A activation caused a decreased in the threonine phosphorylation of occludin that correlated with tight junction assembly in HT 29 cells and tight junction disassembly in MDCK I cells. We conclude that protein kinase C regulation of the epithelial barrier involves specific molecular mechanisms and achieves distinct effects at different developmental stages.     

Characterization of Caco-2 and HT29-MTX cocultures in an in vitro digestion/cell culture model used to predict iron bioavailability

Cocultures of two human cell lines, Caco-2 and HT29-MTX mucus-producing cells, have been incorporated into an in vitro digestion/cell culture model used to predict iron bioavailability. A range of different foods were subjected to in vitro digestion, and iron bioavailability from digests was assessed with Caco-2, Caco-2 overlaid with porcine mucin, HT29-MTX or cocultures of Caco-2 and HT29-MTX at varying ratios. It was found that increasing the ratio of HT29-MTX cells decreased the amount of ferritin formed and resulted in an overall decline in the ability of the model to detect differences in iron bioavailability. At the physiologically relevant ratios of 90% Caco-2/10% HT29-MTX and 75% Caco-2/25% HT29-MTX, however, a mucus layer completely covered the cell monolayer and the in vitro digestion model was nearly as responsive to changes in sample iron bioavailability as pure Caco-2 cultures. The in vitro digestion/Caco-2 cell culture model correlates well with human iron bioavailability studies, but, as mucus appears to play a role in iron absorption, the addition of a physiologically realistic mucus layer and goblet-type cells to this model may give more accurate iron bioavailability predictions.     

CD4 molecules are restricted to the basolateral membrane domain of in vitro differentiated human colon cancer cells (HT29-D4)

The CD4 glycoprotein serves as a receptor for the human immunodeficiency virus HIV, the etiologic agent of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). We have examined the expression of CD4 molecules in a clone (HT29-D4) derived from a human colon adenocarcinoma cell line. HT29-D4 cells synthesized a 60 kDa polypeptide immunoprecipitated with two anti-CD4 monoclonal antibodies after metabolic or cell surface labeling. This 60 kDa polypeptide was also immunodetected using the same antibodies in human acute lymphoblastic leukemia cells CEM which are known to express CD4. HT29-D4 cells can be induced to differentiate into enterocyte-like cells by removing glucose from the culture medium. Under these conditions, HT29-D4 cells form a polarized epithelial monolayer in which tight junctions separate the plasma membrane in an apical and a basolateral domain. The localization of CD4 molecules in differentiated HT29-D4 cells was exclusively restricted to the basolateral membrane domain as demonstrated by radioimmunoassay and indirect immunofluorescence studies. Therefore the HT29-D4 clonal cell line represents a unique model for polarized HIV infection of colonic epithelial cells and may be useful to understand some of the gastrointestinal disorders occurring in AIDS patients.     

Coarse-grained modeling of mucus barrier properties

We designed a simple coarse-grained model of the glycocalyx layer, or adhesive mucus layer (AML), covered by mucus gel (luminal mucus layer) using a polymer lattice model and stochastic sampling (replica exchange Monte Carlo) for canonical ensemble simulations. We assumed that mucin MUC16 is responsible for the structural properties of the AML. Other mucins that are much smaller in size and less relevant for layer structure formation were not included. We further assumed that the system was in quasi-equilibrium. For systems with surface coverage and concentrations of model mucins mimicking physiological conditions, we determined the equilibrium distribution of inert nanoparticles within the mucus layers using an efficient replica exchange Monte Carlo sampling procedure. The results show that the two mucus layers penetrate each other only marginally, and the bilayer imposes a strong barrier for nanoparticles, with the AML layer playing a crucial role in the mucus barrier.