Further Characterization of Ferredoxin Nitrite Reductase and the Relationship between the Enzyme and Methyl Viologen-dependent Nitrite Reductase

Ferredoxin-dependent nitrite reductase of spinach has been further characterized and the relationship between this enzyme and methyl viologen-dependent nitrite reductase studied.

Purified ferredoxin nitrite reductase, having a molecular weight of 86,000, showed 2.5 times higher ferredoxin-dependent activity than methyl viologen-linked activity. Besides 4 mol of labile sulfide the enzyme contained about 2 mol of siroheme per mol. When dithionite, methyl viologen and nitrite were added, ESR signals of a heme nitrosyl complex at g = 2.14, 2.07 and 2.02 were observed. Moreover, hyperfine splitting of the signal due to ¹⁴N nuclear spin was also observed at 2.033, 2.023 and 2.013. The sole addition of hydroxylamine to the ferric enzyme also caused the same but much less intense signals with the hyperfine splitting.

On treatment of the ferredoxin nitrite reductase (native enzyme) with DEAE-Sephadex A-50 chromatography, a modified nitrite reductase having a molecular weight of 61,000 and a protein fraction having an apparent molecular weight of 24,000 were separated. The modified enzyme contained about one mol of siroheme and 4 mol of labile sulfide per mol and showed essentially the same heme ESR signals as the native enzyme. Contrary to the native enzyme, this modified enzyme accepted electrons more efficiently from methyl viologen than ferredoxin and the reduction of nitrite to ammonia catalyzed by the modified enzyme was not stoichiometric. The observed nitrite to ammonia ratio was 1 to less than 0.6. Cyanide at concentrations between 0.02 to 0.2 mm inhibited the activity of the native enzyme almost completely but the modified enzyme was inhibited only partially.

From the results obtained, it is suggested that the native ferredoxin-linked nitrite reductase consists of two components (or subunits) and removal of the light component results in formation of a modified enzyme with increased relative affinity to methyl viologen.     

Antigenic similarities between ferredoxin-dependent nitrite reductase and glutamate synthase fromChlamydomonas reinhardtii

Polyclonal antisera were prepared against ferredoxin-nitrite reductase (EC 1.7.7.1) and ferredoxin-glutamate synthase (glutamate synthase (ferredoxin); EC 1.4.7.1) from the green algaChlamydomonas reinhardtii. The anti-glutamate synthase antibodies recognized both glutamate synthase and nitrite reductase, but inhibited only the ferredoxin-linked activity of the latter enzyme and not the activity dependent on methyl viologen. Analogously, the anti-nitrite reductase antibodies recognized glutamate synthase and nitrite reductase but the first enzyme was only poorly inhibited. Free ferredoxin protected the nitrite reductase against its inactivation by anti-glutamate synthase antibodies. These results indicate that the ferredoxin-dependent glutamate synthase and nitrite reductase from this alga share common antigenic determinants, and that these are located at the ferrodoxin-binding domains.     

The role of tryptophan in the ferredoxin-dependent nitrite reductase of spinach

A system has been developed for expressing a His-tagged form of the ferredoxin-dependent nitrite reductase of spinach in Escherichia coli. The catalytic and spectral properties of the His-tagged, recombinant enzyme are similar, but not identical, to those previously observed for nitrite reductase isolated directly from spinach leaf. A detailed comparison of the spectral, catalytic and fluorescence properties of nitrite reductase variants, in which each of the enzyme’s eight tryptophan residues has been replaced using site-directed mutagenesis by either aromatic or non-aromatic amino acids, has been used to examine possible roles for tryptophan residues in the reduction of nitrite to ammonia catalyzed by the enzyme.     

Purification and Properties of Nitrite Reductase from Spinach Leaves

Nitrite reductase (EC 1.6.6.4) has been purified 730-fold from spinach leaves. The enzyme catalyzes the reduction of nitrite to ammonia, with the use of reduced form of methyl viologen and ferredoxin. A stoichiometry of one molecule of nitrite reduced per molecule of ammonia formed has been found. KCN at 2.5×10^-4 m inhibited nitrite reductase activity almost completely. Purified enzyme was almost homogeneous by disk electrophoresis with polyacrylamide gel. The molecular weight of the enzyme was estimated to be 61,000 from gel filtration. Nitrite reductase, in the oxidized form, has absorption maxima at 276, 388 and 573 mμ. Both methyl viologen and ferredoxin linked nitrite reductase activities of the enzyme were inactivated on exposure to low ionic strength.     

Some properties of nitrite and hydroxylamine reductases from Derxia gummosa

NADH-nitrite and -hydroxylamine reductases were co-purified from Derxia gummosa. The stoichiometries for the reduction of nitrite and hydroxylamine to ammonia were 3 NADH:1 NO⁻₂:1 NH₃ and 1 NADH:1 NO⁻₂:1 NH₃. The K_m values for nitrite and hydroxylamine were 4.8 μM and 5.3 mM, respectively, and for NADH they were 6.3 μM for nitrite reductase and 150 μM for hydroxylamine reductase. The optimal pH value for both enzyme activities was 8.5. Both activities were inhibited by NADH in the absence of the appropriate substrate, namely nitrite or hydroxylamine. Studies with amino acid modifiers indicate that histidine, glutamate/aspartate, sulphydryl and tyrosine are essential components of the enzyme protein. Kinetic studies show that nitrite and hydroxylamine were competitive for the same binding site on the enzyme. The results indicate that although nitrite and hydroxylamine reductases are associated with the same enzyme, its main function is the reduction of nitrite to ammonia. Azaserine inhibited the induction of the enzyme.     

Mechanism of spinach chloroplast ferredoxin-dependent nitrite reductase: spectroscopic evidence for intermediate states

Nitrite reductases found in plants, algae, and cyanobacteria catalyze the six-electron reduction of nitrite to ammonia with reduced ferredoxin serving as the electron donor. They contain one siroheme and one [4Fe-4S] cluster, acting as separate one-electron carriers. Nitrite is thought to bind to the siroheme and to remain bound until its complete reduction to ammonia. In the present work the enzyme catalytic cycle, with ferredoxin reduced by photosystem 1 as an electron donor, has been studied by EPR and laser flash absorption spectroscopy. Substrate depletion during enzyme turnover, driven by a series of laser flashes, has been demonstrated. A complex of ferrous siroheme with NO, formed by two-electron reduction of the enzyme complex with nitrite, has been shown to be an intermediate in the enzyme catalytic cycle. The same complex can be formed by incubation of free oxidized nitrite reductase with an excess of nitrite and ascorbate. Hydroxylamine, another putative intermediate in the reduction of nitrite catalyzed by nitrite reductase, was found to react with oxidized nitrite reductase to produce the same ferrous siroheme-NO complex, with a characteristic formation time of about 13 min. The rate-limiting step for this reaction is probably hydroxylamine binding to the enzyme, with the conversion of hydroxylamine to NO at the enzyme active site likely being much faster.     

The effect of low osmotic potential on nitrite reduction in intact spinach chloroplasts

The effect of water stress (reduced osmotic potential) on photosynthetic nitrite reduction was investigated using intact, isolated spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts. Nitrite-dependent O₂ evolution was inhibited 39% at −29.5 bars osmotic potential, relative to a control at −11 bars. In the presence of an uncoupler of photophosphorylation this inhibition was not seen. Reduced osmotic potential did not inhibit either methyl viologen reduction or photosynthetic O₂ reduction. These results indicate that an inhibition of electron transport to ferredoxin cannot account for the observed inhibition of nitrite-dependent O₂ evolution. In vitro assay of nitrite reductase activity showed that the interaction of the enzyme with nitrite was not affected by changes in the concentrations of ions or molecules that might be caused by water stress conditions. These results indicate that the most likely site for the effect of water stress on chloroplastic nitrite reduction is the interaction of ferredoxin with nitrite reductase.     

Complex formation between ferredoxin and Synechococcus ferredoxin: nitrate oxidoreductase

The ferredoxin-dependent nitrate reductase from the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942 has been shown to form a high-affinity complex with ferredoxin at low ionic strength. This complex, detected by changes in both the absorbance and circular dichroism (CD) spectra, did not form at high ionic strength. When reduced ferredoxin served as the electron donor for the reduction of nitrate to nitrite, the activity of the enzyme declined markedly as the ionic strength increased. In contrast, the activity of the enzyme with reduced methyl viologen (a non-physiological electron donor) was independent of ionic strength. These results suggest that an electrostatically stabilized complex between Synechococcus nitrate reductase and ferredoxin plays an important role in the mechanism of nitrate reduction catalyzed by this enzyme. Treatment of Synechococcus nitrate reductase with either an arginine-modifying reagent or a lysine-modifying reagent inhibited the ferredoxin-dependent activity of the enzyme but did not affect the methyl viologen-dependent activity. Treatment with these reagents also resulted in a large decrease in the affinity of the enzyme for ferredoxin. Formation of a nitrate reductase complex with ferredoxin prior to treatment with either reagent protected the enzyme against loss of ferredoxin-dependent activity. These results suggest that lysine and arginine residues are present at the ferredoxin-binding site of Synechococcus nitrate reductase. Results of experiments using site-specific, charge reversal variants of the ferredoxin from the cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7119 as an electron donor to nitrate reductase were consistent with a role for negatively charged residues on ferredoxin in the interaction with Synechococcus nitrate reductase.     

Nitrite and hydroxylamine reduction in higher plants. Fractionation, electron donor and substrate specificity of leaf enzymes, principally from vegetable marrow (Cucurbita pepo L.)

Nitrite reductase was purified between 760- and 1300-fold from vegetable marrow (Cucurbita pepo L.) and residual hydroxylamine reductase activity was low or negligible by comparison. With ferredoxin as electron donor, nitrite loss and ammonia formation at pH7.5 were stoicheiometrically equivalent. Crude nitrite reductase preparations showed negligible activity with NADPH as electron donor maintained in the reduced state by glucose 6-phosphate, whereas by comparison, activity was high when either ferredoxin or benzyl viologen were also present and reduced by the NADPH-glucose 6-phosphate system, whereas FMNH(2) produced variable and relatively low activity under the same conditions. At pH values below 7, non-enzymic reactions occurred between reduced benzyl viologen and nitrite, and intermediate reduction products were inferred to be produced instead of ammonia. Activity with ferredoxin (0.1mm), reduced by chloroplast grana in the light, was 25 times that produced with ferredoxin (40mum) reduced with NADPH and glucose 6-phosphate. For an approximate molecular weight 61000-63000 derived by chromatography on Sephadex G-100 and G-200, and a specific activity of 46mumol of nitrite reduced/min per mg of protein with light and chloroplast grana, a minimum turnover number of 3x10(3)mol of nitrite reduced/min per mol of enzyme was found. Two hydroxylamine reductases were separated on Sephadex gels. One (HR1) was initially associated with nitrite reductase during gel filtration but disappeared during later fractionation. This HR1 fraction showed nearly comparable activity with reduced benzyl viologen, ferredoxin or FMNH(2). The other (HR2), of molecular weight approx. 35000, reacted with reduced benzyl viologen but showed negligible activity with ferredoxin or NADPH. Activity with FMNH(2) was associated with an irregular trailing boundary during gel filtration, with much diminished activity in the HR2 region. Activity with NADPH was about 30% of that with FMNH(2), reduced benzyl viologen or ferredoxin and was considered to reside in fraction HR1. Hydroxylamine yielded ammonia under all assay conditions. No activity with hyponitrite or sulphite was observed with reduced benzyl viologen as electron donor in either the nitrite reductase or the hydroxylamine reductase systems, but pyruvic oxime produced about 4% of the activity of hydroxylamine.     

The interaction of ferredoxin and glutamate synthase: cross-linking and immunological studies

The water-soluble carbodiimide, N-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide (EDC) serves as an effective reagent for cross-linking spinach leaf ferredoxin and the ferredoxin-dependent spinach leaf enzyme, glutamate synthase. The cross-linked complex was functional in the absence of added ferredoxin, suggesting that ferredoxin is cross-linked to glutamate synthase at the physiological binding site on the enzyme for this iron-sulfur protein electron donor. The ferredoxin:glutamate synthase stoichiometry of the cross-linked complex was estimated to be 2:1. The absorbance spectrum of the oxidized, cross-linked complex was very similar to that of an electrostatically stabilized, noncovalent, 2:1 complex of the two proteins. An antibody raised against spinach NADP+ reductase, which recognizes a ferredoxin-binding site on glutamate synthase, does not recognize the cross-linked ferredoxin-glutamate synthase complex. This implies that the ferredoxin-binding sites on the two enzymes are structurally similar enough so that an antibody raised against one of these ferredoxin-dependent enzymes recognizes an epitope at the ferredoxin-binding site of the second enzyme. Cross-linking of ferredoxin to its binding site on glutamate synthase renders this epitope inaccessible to the antibody.     

Oxygen activation by isolated chloroplasts from Euglena gracilis. Ferredoxin-dependent function of a fluorescent compound and photosynthetic electron transport close to photosystem.

Oxygen reduction by isolated chloroplast lamellae from spinach, yielding the superoxide free radical in the light, is stimulated by a fluorescent factor (“compound No. 4”, isolated from Euglena gracilis strain Z) in a ferredoxin-dependent reaction. This reaction is not observed with Euglena chloroplasts, although there is a stimulation by compound No. 4 of ferredoxin-dependent oxygen reduction at the expense of NADPH + H⁺ as electron donor in the dark. Evidence is provided that in Euglena chloroplasts in the absence of NADP as electron acceptor a cyclic electron transport is predominating, including photosystem I, ferredoxin, NADP-ferredoxin reductase, and cytochrome₅₅₂. Isolated spinach chloroplast lamellae show a similar “cyclic” electron transport after treatment with digitonin, depending on the addition of the above cofactors. This result might indicate that Euglena chloroplast lamellae show this cyclic electron transport only as an artifact due to the isolation procedure. The results furthermore indicate that the pteridine-like, fluorescent compound No. 4 is not active as the primary electron acceptor of photosystem I; it may however be involved in oxygen activation by Euglena gracilis chloroplasts.     

Immunological studies of ferredoxin-nitrite reductases and ferredoxin-glutamate synthases from photosynthetic organisms

Polyclonal antiserum specific for ferredoxin-nitrite reductase (EC 1.7.7.1) from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardii recognized the nitrite reductase from other green algae, but did not cross-react with the corresponding enzyme from different cyanobacteria or higher plant leaves. An analogous situation was also found for ferredoxin-glutamate synthase (EC 1.4.7.1), using its specific antiserum. Besides, the antibodies raised against C. reinhardii ferredoxin-glutamate synthase were able to inactivate the ferredoxin-dependent activity of nitrite reductase from green algae.These results suggest that there exist similar domains in ferredoxin-nitrite reductases and ferredoxin-glutamate synthases from green algae. In addition, both types of enzymes share common antigenic determinants, probably located at the ferredoxin-binding domain. In spite of their physicochemical resemblances, no apparent antigenic correlation exists between the corresponding enzymes from green algae and those from higher plant leaves or cyanobacteria.Abbreviations Fd ferredoxin - GOGAT glutamate synthase - MV⁺ reduced methyl viologen (radical cation) - NiR nitrite reductase - PMSF phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate     

Hydroxylamine reductase enzymes from maize scutellum and their relationship to nitrite reductase

Three enzymes contribute to the total hydroxylamine reductase activity of corn (Zea mays L.) scutellum extracts. Two of these resemble enzymes previously prepared from leaves, while the third, which accounts for a major part of the activity, appears to have no counterpart in leaf tissue. One of the hydroxylamine reductases found only in small amounts is associated with nitrite reductase and is induced, together with nitrite reductase, by nitrite. The other two enzymes are noninducible by nitrite and can be totally separated from nitrite reductase, which subsequently remains capable of catalyzing the reduction of nitrite to ammonia. Possible causes of the decline of hydroxylamine reductase activity during the induction of nitrite reductase are discussed.     

Biosynthesis of phycobilins. Ferredoxin-mediated reduction of biliverdin catalyzed by extracts of Cyanidium caldarium

Cell-free extract of the unicellular rhodophyte, Cyanidium caldarium catalyzes enzymatic reduction of biliverdin IX alpha to phycocyanobilin, the chromophore of the light-harvesting phycobiliprotein, phycocyanin. The enzyme activity is soluble, and the required reductant is NADPH. The extract has been separated into three protein fractions, all of which are required to reconstitute biliverdin reduction. One fraction contains ferredoxin, which was identified by its absorption spectrum. This fraction could be replaced with commercial ferredoxin derived from spinach or the red alga, Porphyra umbilicalis. The second protein fraction contains ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase, which was identified by the ability to catalyze ferredoxin-dependent reduction of cytochrome c in the presence of NADPH. This fraction could be replaced with commercial spinach ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase. These two components appear to be identical to previously described components of the algal heme oxygenase system that catalyzes biliverdin IX alpha formation from protoheme in C. caldarium extracts. The third protein fraction, in the presence of the first two (or their commercial counterparts) plus NADPH, catalyzes the reduction of biliverdin IX alpha to phycocyanobilin. The results indicate that the transformation of biliverdin to phycocyanobilin catalyzed by C. caldarium extracts is a ferredoxin-linked reduction process. The results also suggest the possibility that heme oxygenation and biliverdin reduction may occur in C. caldarium on associated enzyme systems.     

Prosthetic group content and ligand-binding properties of spinach nitrite reductase

Chemical analysis of the ferredoxin-dependent native form (Mr = 85,000) of spinach nitrite reductase has demonstrated a siroheme content that approaches 2 mol of siroheme/mol of enzyme. A widely studied modified (Mr = 61,000) form of nitrite reductase, that has lost much of the native enzyme's ability to use ferredoxin as an electron donor, contains approximately 1 mol of siroheme/mol of enzyme. Quantitation of the high spin ferri-siroheme EPR signals and of nitrite-binding sites of the two preparations confirmed that the native enzyme's siroheme content is approximately twice that of the modified enzyme. Plots of nitrite and cyanide binding to the native enzyme versus ligand concentration are sigmoidal, with Hill coefficients of 1.6-1.8 and 2.3-2.8, respectively. Plots of enzyme activity versus nitrite concentration for the native enzyme are sigmoidal with a Hill coefficient of 2.4. Cyanide inhibition of enzymatic activity was shown to be not competitive. Addition of cyanide to the native enzyme resulted in a diminution of the high spin ferri-siroheme EPR signal and produced EPR signals with g values of 2.71, 2.33, and 1.49 due to low spin ferri-siroheme.     

Localization of Nitrogen-Assimilating Enzymes in the Chloroplast of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The specific activities of nitrate reductase, nitrite reductase, glutamine synthetase, glutamate synthase, and glutamate dehydrogenase were determined in intact protoplasts and intact chloroplasts from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. After correction for contamination, the data were used to calculate the portion of each enzyme in the algal chloroplast. The chloroplast of C. reinhardtii contained all enzyme activities for nitrogen assimilation, except nitrate reductase, which could not be detected in this organelle. Glutamate synthase (NADH- and ferredoxin-dependent) and glutamate dehydrogenase were located exclusively in the chloroplast, while for nitrite reductase and glutamine synthetase an extraplastidic activity of about 20 and 60%, respectively, was measured. Cells grown on ammonium, instead of nitrate as nitrogen source, had a higher total cellular activity of the NADH-dependent glutamate synthase (+95%) and glutamate dehydrogenase (+33%) but less activity of glutamine synthetase (−10%). No activity of nitrate reductase could be detected in ammonium-grown cells. The distribution of nitrogen-assimilating enzymes among the chloroplast and the rest of the cell did not differ significantly between nitrate-grown and ammonium-grown cells. Only the plastidic portion of the glutamine synthetase increased to about 80% in cells grown on ammonium (compared to about 40% in cells grown on nitrate).     

The mechanism of photosynthetic sulfate reduction by isolated chloroplasts

The reduction of sulfate by isolated spinach chloroplasts was studied. A reconstituted system of broken chloroplasts and of chloroplast extract reduced sulfate to sulfite in the light when ADP, NADP⁺, ferredoxin and glutathione were added. The chloroplast extract reduced sulfate to sulfite in the dark if supplemented with ATP and with reduced glutathione. Neither ferredoxin nor NADPH were needed for this reduction in the dark.

A sulfite reductase was purified from spinach leaves. Broken chloroplasts and sulfite reductase reduced sulfite to sulfide in the light when ferredoxin was added. NADP⁺ was not required for this reduction.

The results suggest that in chloroplasts a sulfate activated by ATP (phosphoadenosine phosphosulfate) is reduced to sulfite by a sulfhydryl compound and that sulfite is reduced to sulfide by a ferredoxin-dependent sulfite reductase.     

Methyl Viologen-linked Nitrite Reductase from Bean Roots

Methyl viologen-linked nitrite reductase (EC 1.7.7.1), an enzyme which catalyzes the 6-electron reduction of nitrite to ammonia, was isolated from bean roots. The isolated enzyme was homogeneous by disc electrophoresis with polyacrylamide gel. The molecular weight of the enzyme was estimated to be 62,000 by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. In the oxidized form, the enzyme had absorption maxima at 280, 397 (Soret band), 535, and 573 nm (α band), indicating that siroheme is directly involved in the catalysis of nitrite reduction. The absorbance ratios, A₃₉₇ : A₂₈₀ and A₅₇₃ : A₃₉₇, were 0.3 and 0.39, respectively. Antiserum to spinach leaf nitrite reductase failed to give a positive Ouchterlony result with bean root nitrite reductase, but this antiserum did inhibit the activity of the latter enzyme.     

Chemical modification studies of tryptophan,arginine and lysine residues in maize chloroplast ferredoxin:sulfite oxidoreductase

The ferredoxin-dependent sulfite reductase from maize was treated, in separate experiments, with three different covalent modifiers of specific amino acid side chains. Treatment with the tryptophan-modifying reagent, N-bromosuccinimide (NBS), resulted in a loss of enzymatic activity with both the physiological donor for the enzyme, reduced ferredoxin, and with reduced methyl viologen, a non-physiological electron donor. Formation of the 1:1 ferredoxin/sulfite reductase complex prior to treating the enzyme with NBS completely protected the enzyme against the loss of both activities. Neither the secondary structure, nor the oxidation-reduction midpoint potential (E _m) values of the siroheme and [4Fe–4S] cluster prosthetic groups of sulfite reductase, nor the binding affinity of the enzyme for ferredoxin were affected by NBS treatment. Treatment of sulfite reductase with the lysine-modifying reagent, N-acetylsuccinimide, inhibited the ferredoxin-linked activity of the enzyme without inhibiting the methyl viologen-linked activity. Complex formation with ferredoxin protects the enzyme against the inhibition of ferredoxin-linked activity produced by treatment with N-acetylsuccinimide. Treatment of sulfite reductase with N-acetylsuccinimide also decreased the binding affinity of the enzyme for ferredoxin. Treatment of sulfite reductase with the arginine-modifying reagent, phenylglyoxal, inhibited both the ferredoxin-linked and methyl viologen-linked activities of the enzyme but had a significantly greater effect on the ferredoxin-dependent activity than on the reduced methyl viologen-linked activity. The effects of these three inhibitory treatments are consistent with a possible role for a tryptophan residue the catalytic mechanism of sulfite reductase and for lysine and arginine residues at the ferredoxin-binding site of the enzyme.     

Spinach ferredoxin-nitrite reductase: characterization of catalytic activity and interaction of the enzyme with substrates

The steady-state kinetic parameters of the enzymatic reduction of nitrite by spinach ferredoxin-nitrite reductase [EC 1.7.7.1] were measured under anaerobic conditions. The maximum velocity of ferredoxin-linked activity was essentially the same as for the methyl viologen-linked activity of the enzyme. The initial velocity patterns of the oxidation of reduced ferredoxin suggested a sequential reaction scheme by which nitrite and reduced ferredoxin bind to the free enzyme. The binding of nitrite and ferredoxin to the enzyme was also investigated by different spectra produced by the complex formed by the enzyme with the substrates. Nitrite and ferredoxin each gave a 1: 1 complex with the enzyme. The dissociation constant (Kd) of the enzyme-nitrite complex agreed well with the Km value for the ferredoxin-linked activity, whereas the Kd of the enzyme-ferredoxin complex differed from the Km value for the enzyme activity. It was concluded that our preparation of spinach ferredoxin-nitrite reductase differs from both the complex (Mr = 85,000) and the modified (Mr = 61,000) forms of the enzyme reported by Hirasawa et al. [J. Biol. Chem. 262, 12428-12433 (1987)].