Reply to Macaulay et al. (1999): mitochondrial DNA recombination-reasons to panic

We recently presented evidence of recombination in human mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) using a data set of largely complete human mtDNAs gleaned from GenBank and the literature. It was pointed out that some of the sequences are probably incorrect and that, when those sequences are removed, so too is the evidence of recombination. Nevertheless, we argue that there is still evidence of recombination. First, there are excessive numbers of homoplasies in other mtDNA data sets. Second, an expanded data set of our own, excluding the sequences which are the subject of suspicion, shows a significant excess of homoplasies and, hence, evidence of recombination.     

Effects of poly[d(pGpT).d(pApC)] and poly[d(pCpG).d(pCpG)] repeats on homologous recombination in somatic cells.

Sequencing studies have shown that in somatic cells alternating runs of purines and pyrimidines are frequently associated with recombination crossover points. To test whether such sequences actually promote recombination, we have examined the effects of poly[d(pGpT).d(pApC)] and poly[d(pCpG).d(pCpG)] repeats on a homologous recombination event. The parental molecule used in this study, pSVLD, is capable of generating wild-type simian virus 40 DNA via recombination across two 751-base-pair regions of homology and has been described previously (Miller et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81:7534-7538, 1984). Single inserts of either a poly[d(pGpT).d(pApC)] repeat or a poly[d(pCpG).d(pCpG)] repeat were positioned adjacent to one region of homology in such a way that the recombination product, wild-type simian virus 40 DNA, could be formed only by recombination within the homologies and not by recombination across the alternating purine-pyrimidine repeats. We have found that upon transfection of test DNAs into simian cells, a poly[d(pCpG).d(pCpG)] repeat enhanced homologous recombination 10- to 15-fold, whereas a poly[d(pGpT).d(pApC)] repeat had less effect. These results are discussed in terms of the features of these repeats that might be responsible for promoting homologous recombination.     

Homologous recombination between highly diverged mitochondrial sequences: examples from maternally and paternally transmitted genomes

Homologous recombination is restricted to sequences of low divergence. This is attributed to the mismatch repairing system (MMR), which does not allow recombination between sequences that are highly divergent. This acts as a safeguard against recombination between nonhomologous sequences that could result in genome imbalance. Here, we report recombination between maternal and paternal mitochondrial genomes of the sea mussel, whose sequences differ by >20%. We propose that the strict maternal inheritance of the animal mitochondrial DNA and the ensuing homoplasmy has relieved the MMR system of the animal mitochondrion from the pressure to tolerate recombination only among sequences with a high degree of similarity.     

Analysis of plastid and mitochondrial DNA insertions in the nucleus (NUPTs and NUMTs) of six plant species: size,relative age and chromosomal localization

We analysed the size, relative age and chromosomal localization of nuclear sequences of plastid and mitochondrial origin (NUPTs-nuclear plastid DNA and NUMTs-nuclear mitochondrial DNA) in six completely sequenced plant species. We found that the largest insertions showed lower divergence from organelle DNA than shorter insertions in all species, indicating their recent origin. The largest NUPT and NUMT insertions were localized in the vicinity of the centromeres in the small genomes of Arabidopsis and rice. They were also present in other chromosomal regions in the large genomes of soybean and maize. Localization of NUPTs and NUMTs correlated positively with distribution of transposable elements (TEs) in Arabidopsis and sorghum, negatively in grapevine and soybean, and did not correlate in rice or maize. We propose a model where new plastid and mitochondrial DNA sequences are inserted close to centromeres and are later fragmented by TE insertions and reshuffled away from the centromere or removed by ectopic recombination. The mode and tempo of TE dynamism determines the turnover of NUPTs and NUMTs resulting in their species-specific chromosomal distributions.     

Recombination between poly[d(GT).d(CA)] sequences in simian virus 40-infected cultured cells.

CVI cells were transfected with oversized simian virus 40 (SV40) genomes that could be reduced to packageable size by alternative homologous recombination pathways involving either two polydeoxyguanylic-thymidylic acid X polydeoxycytidylic-adenylic acid (poly[d(GT).d(CA)]; abbreviated hereafter as poly(GT)] tracts or two tracts of homologous SV40 sequence. Plaque-forming viruses rescued by this procedure were found to contain genomes formed by homologous and nonhomologous recombination events. Half of the viable viral DNA molecules recovered were the result of recombination between two tracts of poly(GT). Approximately 20% of the rescued viral genomes were produced by homologous recombination between tracts of SV40 DNA. Nonhomologous recombination involving SV40 sequences was also a major pathway of deletion, producing ca. 30% of the viral plaques. Tracts of poly(GT) generated by recombination were variable in length, suggesting that recombination between poly(GT) tracts was usually unequal. On a per-nucleotide basis, poly(GT) recombination occurred eight times more frequently than did recombination between homologous SV40 DNA. This eightfold difference is the maximum recombinatory enhancement attributable to poly(GT) sequences. Although DNA sequence analysis showed that tracts of poly(GT) generated by recombination retained the alternating G-T repeat motif throughout their length, the contribution of the nonhomologous pathway to poly(GT) recombination cannot be ruled out, and the relative proclivity of a given length of d(GT).d(CA) sequence to undergo homologous recombination is probably less than eight times greater than that of an SV40 sequence of the same length.     

The evolutionarily conserved repetitive sequence d(TG.AC)n promotes reciprocal exchange and generates unusual recombinant tetrads during yeast meiosis.

We have studied the genetic behavior of the alternating copolymer d(TG.AC)n inserted into a defined position in the genome of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. When d(TG.AC)n sequences were present at the HIS3 locus on homologous chromosomes, diploid cells undergoing meiosis generated an excess of tetrads containing reciprocally recombined products with crossover points close to the repetitive DNA insert. Most of these tetrads exhibited gene conversion of a d(TG.AC)n insert. However, the insertion of d(TG.AC)n sequences had no effect on the frequency of gene conversion of closely linked marker genes. Surprisingly, when d(TG.AC)n sequences were present on only one homolog at the HIS3 locus, one-half of the tetrads exhibiting nonparental segregation for marker genes that flanked the repetitive DNA insert were very unusual and appeared to have arisen by multiple recombination events in the vicinity of the d(TG.AC)n insert. Similar multiply recombinant tetrads were seen in crosses in which d(TG.AC)n sequences were present on both homologs. Combined, the data strongly suggest that d(TG.AC)n sequences significantly enhance reciprocal meiotic recombination and may be important in causing multiple recombination events to occur within a relatively small region of the yeast chromosome. Molecular evidence is presented that clearly documents the postmeiotic segregation of an 80-base stretch of d(TG.AC)n.     

Identification of the entire set of transferred chloroplast DNA sequences in the mitochondrial genome of rice

Summary The entire set of transferred chloroplast DNA sequences in the mitochondrial genome of rice (Oryza sativa cv. Nipponbare) was identified using clone banks that cover the chloroplast and mitochondrial genomes. The mitochondrial fragments that were homologous to chloroplast DNA were mapped and sequenced. The nucleotide sequences around the termini of integrated chloroplast sequences in the rice mtDNA revealed no common sequences or structures that might enhance the transfer of DNA. Sixteen chloroplast sequences, ranging from 32 bases to 6.8 kb in length, were found to be dispersed throughout the rice mitochondrial genome. The total length of these sequences is equal to approximately 6% (22 kb) of the rice mitochondrial genome and to 19% of the chloroplast genome. The transfer of segments of chloroplast DNA seems to have occurred at different times, both before and after the divergence of rice and maize. The mitochondrial genome appears to have been rearranged after the transfer of chloroplast sequences as a result of recombination at these sequences. The rice mitochondrial DNA contains nine intact tRNA genes and three tRNA pseudogenes derived from the chloroplast genome.     

Suppression of Repeat-Mediated Gross Mitochondrial Genome Rearrangements by RecA in the Moss Physcomitrella patens

RecA and its ubiquitous homologs are crucial components in homologous recombination. Besides their eukaryotic nuclear counterparts, plants characteristically possess several bacterial-type RecA proteins localized to chloroplasts and/or mitochondria, but their roles are poorly understood. Here, we analyzed the role of the only mitochondrial RecA in the moss Physcomitrella patens. Disruption of the P. patens mitochondrial recA gene RECA1 caused serious defects in plant growth and development and abnormal mitochondrial morphology. Analyses of mitochondrial DNA in disruptants revealed that frequent DNA rearrangements occurred at multiple loci. Structural analysis suggests that the rearrangements, which in some cases were associated with partial deletions and amplifications of mitochondrial DNA, were due to aberrant recombination between short (<100 bp) direct and inverted repeats in which the sequences were not always identical. Such repeats are abundant in the mitochondrial genome, and interestingly many are located in group II introns. These results suggest that RECA1 does not promote but rather suppresses recombination among short repeats scattered throughout the mitochondrial genome, thereby maintaining mitochondrial genome stability. We propose that RecA-mediated homologous recombination plays a crucial role in suppression of short repeat-mediated genome rearrangements in plant mitochondria.     

Recombination sequences in plant mitochondrial genomes: diversity and homologies to known mitochondrial genes.

Several plant mitochondrial genomes contain repeated sequences that are postulated to be sites of homologous intragenomic recombination (1-3). In this report, we have used filter hybridizations to investigate sequence relationships between the cloned mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) recombination repeats from turnip, spinach and maize and total mtDNA isolated from thirteen species of angiosperms. We find that strong sequence homologies exist between the spinach and turnip recombination repeats and essentially all other mitochondrial genomes tested, whereas a major maize recombination repeat does not hybridize to any other mtDNA. The sequences homologous to the turnip repeat do not appear to function in recombination in any other genome, whereas the spinach repeat hybridizes to reiterated sequences within the mitochondrial genomes of wheat and two species of pokeweed that do appear to be sites of recombination. Thus, although intragenomic recombination is a widespread phenomenon in plant mitochondria, it appears that different sequences either serve as substrates for this function in different species, or else surround a relatively short common recombination site which does not cross-hybridize under our experimental conditions. Identified gene sequences from maize mtDNA were used in heterologous hybridizations to show that the repeated sequences implicated in recombination in turnip and spinach/pokeweed/wheat mitochondria include, or are closely linked to genes for subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase and 26S rRNA, respectively. Together with previous studies indicating that the 18S rRNA gene in wheat mtDNA is contained within a recombination repeat (3), these results imply an unexpectedly frequent association between recombination repeats and plant mitochondrial genes.     

Transfection of plant mitochondria and in organello gene integration

Investigation and manipulation of mitochondrial genetics in animal and plant cells remains restricted by the lack of an efficient in vivo transformation methodology. Mitochondrial transfection in whole cells and maintenance of the transfected DNA are main issues on this track. We showed earlier that isolated mitochondria from different organisms can import DNA. Exploiting this mechanism, we assessed the possibility to maintain exogenous DNA in plant organelles. Whereas homologous recombination is scarce in the higher plant nuclear compartment, recombination between large repeats generates the multipartite structure of the plant mitochondrial genome. These processes are under strict surveillance to avoid extensive genomic rearrangements. Nevertheless, following transfection of isolated organelles with constructs composed of a partial gfp gene flanked by fragments of mitochondrial DNA, we demonstrated in organello homologous recombination of the imported DNA with the resident DNA and integration of the reporter gene. Recombination yielded insertion of a continuous exogenous DNA fragment including the gfp sequence and at least 0.5 kb of flanking sequence on each side. According to our observations, transfection constructs carrying multiple sequences homologous to the mitochondrial DNA should be suitable and targeting of most regions in the organelle genome should be feasible, making the approach of general interest.     

A RAD52‐like single‐stranded DNA binding protein affects mitochondrial DNA repair by recombination

The plant mitochondrial DNA‐binding protein ODB1 was identified from a mitochondrial extract after DNA‐affinity purification. ODB1 (organellar DNA‐binding protein 1) co‐purified with WHY2, a mitochondrial member of the WHIRLY family of plant‐specific proteins involved in the repair of organellar DNA. The Arabidopsis thaliana ODB1 gene is identical to RAD52‐1, which encodes a protein functioning in homologous recombination in the nucleus but additionally localizing to mitochondria. We confirmed the mitochondrial localization of ODB1 by in vitro and in vivo import assays, as well as by immunodetection on Arabidopsis subcellular fractions. In mitochondria, WHY2 and ODB1 were found in large nucleo‐protein complexes. Both proteins co‐immunoprecipitated in a DNA‐dependent manner. In vitro assays confirmed DNA binding by ODB1 and showed that the protein has higher affinity for single‐stranded than for double‐stranded DNA. ODB1 showed no sequence specificity in vitro. In vivo, DNA co‐immunoprecipitation indicated that ODB1 binds sequences throughout the mitochondrial genome. ODB1 promoted annealing of complementary DNA sequences, suggesting a RAD52‐like function as a recombination mediator. Arabidopsis odb1 mutants were morphologically indistinguishable from the wild‐type, but following DNA damage by genotoxic stress, they showed reduced mitochondrial homologous recombination activity. Under the same conditions, the odb1 mutants showed an increase in illegitimate repair bypasses generated by microhomology‐mediated recombination. These observations identify ODB1 as a further component of homologous recombination‐dependent DNA repair in plant mitochondria.     

Maize and wheat mitochondrial tRNAPro coding regions have similar sequences but different organizations.

The nucleotide sequences of two maize mitochondrial DNA regions containing a tRNAPro gene and an incomplete tRNAPro gene have been compared with the corresponding regions of wheat mitochondrial DNA. These regions have similar sequences but their organization is modified due to different recombination events involving the tRNAPro immediate environment.     

Dual multiple change-point model leads to more accurate recombination detection

MOTIVATION: We introduce a dual multiple change-point (MCP) model for recombination detection among aligned nucleotide sequences. The dual MCP model is an extension of the model introduced previously by Suchard and co-workers. In the original single MCP model, one change-point process is used to model spatial phylogenetic variation. Here, we show that using two change-point processes, one for spatial variation of tree topologies and the other for spatial variation of substitution process parameters, increases recombination detection accuracy. Statistical analysis is done in a Bayesian framework using reversible jump Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling to approximate the joint posterior distribution of all model parameters. RESULTS: We use primate mitochondrial DNA data with simulated recombination break-points at specific locations to compare the two models. We also analyze two real HIV sequences to identify recombination break-points using the dual MCP model.     

Small, repetitive DNAs contribute significantly to the expanded mitochondrial genome of cucumber

Closely related cucurbit species possess eightfold differences in the sizes of their mitochondrial genomes. We cloned mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) fragments showing strong hybridization signals to cucumber mtDNA and little or no signal to watermelon mtDNA. The cucumber mtDNA clones carried short (30-53 bp), repetitive DNA motifs that were often degenerate, overlapping, and showed no homology to any sequences currently in the databases. On the basis of dot-blot hybridizations, seven repetitive DNA motifs accounted for >13% (194 kb) of the cucumber mitochondrial genome, equaling >50% of the size of the Arabidopsis mitochondrial genome. Sequence analysis of 136 kb of cucumber mtDNA revealed only 11.2% with significant homology to previously characterized mitochondrial sequences, 2.4% to chloroplast DNA, and 15% to the seven repetitive DNA motifs. The remaining 71.4% of the sequence was unique to the cucumber mitochondrial genome. There was <4% sequence colinearity surrounding the watermelon and cucumber atp9 coding regions, and the much smaller watermelon mitochondrial genome possessed no significant amounts of cucumber repetitive DNAs. Our results demonstrate that the expanded cucumber mitochondrial genome is in part due to extensive duplication of short repetitive sequences, possibly by recombination and/or replication slippage.     

Evidence for recombination in scorpion mitochondrial DNA (Scorpiones: Buthidae)

There has been very little undisputed evidence for recombination in animal mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) provided so far. Previous unpublished results suggestive of mtDNA recombination in the scorpion family Buthidae, together with cytological evidence for a unique mechanism of mitochondrial fusion in that family, prompted us to investigate this group in more details. First, we sequenced the complete mtDNA genome of Mesobuthus gibbosus, and chose two genes opposing each other (16S and coxI). We then sequenced 150 individuals from the natural populations of four species of Buthidae (Old World genera Buthus and Mesobuthus). We observed strong evidence for widespread recombination through highly significant negative correlations between linkage disequilibrium and physical distance in three out of four species. The evidence is further confirmed when using five other tests for recombination and by the presence of a high amount of homoplasy in phylogenetic trees.     

Selection for thermodynamically stable DNA tetraloops using temperature gradient gel electrophoresis reveals four motifs: d(cGNNAg), d(cGNABg),d(cCNNGg), and d(gCNNGc)

Hairpins play important roles in the function of DNA, forming cruciforms and affecting processes such as replication and recombination. Temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) and in vitro selection have been used to isolate thermodynamically stable DNA hairpins from a six-nucleotide random library. The TGGE-selection process was optimized such that known stable DNA tetraloops were recovered, and the selection appears to be exhaustive. In the selection, four families of exceptionally stable DNA loops were identified: d(cGNNAg), d(cGNABg), d(cCNNGg), and d(gCNNGc). (Lowercase denotes the closing base pair; N = A, C, G, or T; and B = C, G, or T.) It appears that the known stable d(cGNAg) triloop motif can be embedded into a tetraloop, with the extra nucleotide inserted into either the middle of the loop, d(cGNNAg), or at the 3'-end of the loop, d(cGNABg). For d(cGNNAg) and d(cGNABg), a CG closing base pair was strongly preferred over a GC, with DeltaDeltaG degrees (37) approximately 2 kcal/mol. Members of the two families, d(cCNNGg) and d(gCNNGc), are similar in stability. The loop sequences and closing base pairs identified for exceptionally stable DNA tetraloops show many similarities to those known for exceptionally stable RNA tetraloops. These data provide an expanded set of thermodynamic rules for the formation of tetraloops in DNA.     

Evidence for mitochondrial DNA recombination in a human population of island Melanesia: correction

We recently presented evidence of mitochondrial DNA recombination in humans based on the observation of a rare mutation in several unrelated human lineages in Nguna, a small island in Vanuatu, island Melanesia. Since then, the mutation has been shown to be an artefact caused by misalignment of the DNA sequences. Our previous conclusion, that the presence of a rare mutation on different haplotypic backgrounds was a consequence of genetic recombination, is no longer tenable for these data.     

Construction of hybrid bacterial deacetoxycephalosporin C synthases (expandases) by in vivo homeologous recombination

Homeologous recombination (recombination between partially homeologous DNA sequences) was used to produce novel functional deacetoxycephalosporin C synthase (expandase) enzymes in vivo which are hybrids of the Streptomyces clavuligerus and Nocardia lactamdurans enzymes. DNA sequencing of hybrids obtained in E. coli showed that recombination had occurred at several locations within conserved sequences as short as 2 bp. Recombination events obtained in a Streptomyces background resulted in expandases with altered activity on penicillin G as determined by bioassay and HPLC.