A fluorescence resonance energy transfer approach for monitoring protein-mediated glycolipid transfer between vesicle membranes

A lipid transfer protein, purified from bovine brain (23.7 kDa, 208 amino acids) and specific for glycolipids, has been used to develop a fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay (anthrylvinyl-labeled lipids; energy donors and perylenoyl-labeled lipids; energy acceptors) for monitoring the transfer of lipids between membranes. Small unilamellar vesicles composed of 1 mol% anthrylvinyl-galactosylceramide, 1.5 mol% perylenoyl-triglyceride, and 97.5% 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine (POPC) served as donor membranes. Acceptor membranes were 100% POPC vesicles. Addition of glycolipid transfer protein to mixtures of donor and acceptor vesicles resulted in increasing emission intensity of anthrylvinyl-galactosylceramide and decreasing emission intensity of the nontransferable perylenoyl-triglyceride as a function of time. The behavior was consistent with anthrylvinyl-galactosylceramide being transferred from donor to acceptor vesicles. The anthrylvinyl and perylenoyl energy transfer pair offers advantages over frequently used energy transfer pairs such as NBD and rhodamine. The anthrylvinyl emission overlaps effectively the perylenoyl excitation spectrum and the fluorescence parameters of the anthrylvinyl fluorophore are nearly independent of the medium polarity. The nonpolar fluorophores are localized in the hydrophobic region of the bilayer thus producing minimal disturbance of the bilayer polar region. Our results indicate that this method is suitable for assay of lipid transfer proteins including mechanistic studies of transfer protein function.     

Resonance energy transfer study using a rhenium metal-ligand lipid conjugate as the donor in a model membrane.

We measured steady state and time-resolved resonance energy transfer between donors and acceptors in model membranes. The donor was a long lifetime rhenium-lipid complex, which displayed a mean lifetime of 1 microsecond and lifetime components as long as 3 microseconds in the labeled DOPC membranes. The transfer efficiencies were found to be substantially larger than those predicted without consideration of lateral diffusion. The larger transfer efficiencies are consistent with a mutual lateral diffusion coefficient in the membrane near 2 x 10(-8) cm2/s. These results demonstrate that lateral diffusion in membranes can be detected with microsecond lipid probes.     

Fluorescent probe study of the spatial structure of membranes and lipoproteins

A review is devoted to principles of studies in spatial structure of the model and biological membranes and lipoproteins on the basis of measuring radiationless energy transfer between fluorescent probes and from proteins to the probes. Recently the theory has been developed for energy transfer in membranes of various geometry and in lipoproteins of different size and structure. Special fluorescent probes are designed and made. The measurement procedure was tested in simulated systems and used to study a series of membranes as well as blood plasma lipoproteins of main classes. Everything above-mentioned resulted in obtaining data on the size of protein molecules in membranes and lipoproteins, proteins location relative to the lipid phase, on the surface area of the membranes (isolated and directly in a cell), association of protein molecules, state of near-protein lipid layer, membrane asymmetry, spreading of proteins on the lipoprotein surface, on the cholesterol effect on the lipid bilayer size etc.     

Antimicrobial activity and membrane selective interactions of a synthetic lipopeptide MSI-843

The method of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) has been employed to monitor cytochrome c interaction with bilayer phospholipid membranes. Liposomes composed of phosphatidylcholine and varying amounts of anionic lipid cardiolipin (CL) were used as model membranes. Trace amount of fluorescent lipid derivative, anthrylvinyl-phosphatidylcholine was incorporated into the membranes to serve energy donor for heme moiety of cytochrome c. Energy transfer efficiency was measured at different lipid and protein concentrations to obtain extensive set of data, which were further analyzed globally in terms of adequate models of protein adsorption and energy transfer on the membrane surface. It has been found that the cytochrome c association with membranes containing 10 mol% CL can be described in terms of equilibrium binding model (yielding dissociation constant Kd = 0.2-0.4 microM and stoichiometry n = 11-13 lipid molecules per protein binding site) combined with FRET model assuming uniform acceptor distribution with the distance of 3.5-3.6 nm between the bilayer midplane and heme moiety of cytochrome c. However, increasing the CL content to 20 or 40 mol% (at low ionic strength) resulted in a different behavior of FRET profiles, inconsistent with the concepts of equilibrium adsorption of cytochrome c at the membrane surface and/or uniform acceptor distribution. To explain this fact, several possibilities are analyzed, including cytochrome c-induced formation of non-bilayer structures and clusters of charged lipids, or changes in the depth of cytochrome c penetration into the bilayer depending on the protein surface density. Additional control experiments have shown that only the latter process can explain the peculiar concentration dependences of FRET at high CL content.     

A single vesicle-vesicle fusion assay for in vitro studies of SNAREs and accessory proteins

SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor) proteins are a highly regulated class of membrane proteins that drive the efficient merger of two distinct lipid bilayers into one interconnected structure. This protocol describes our fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based single vesicle-vesicle fusion assays for SNAREs and accessory proteins. Both lipid-mixing (with FRET pairs acting as lipophilic dyes in the membranes) and content-mixing assays (with FRET pairs present on a DNA hairpin that becomes linear via hybridization to a complementary DNA) are described. These assays can be used to detect substages such as docking, hemifusion, and pore expansion and full fusion. The details of flow cell preparation, protein-reconstituted vesicle preparation, data acquisition and analysis are described. These assays can be used to study the roles of various SNARE proteins, accessory proteins and effects of different lipid compositions on specific fusion steps. The total time required to finish one round of this protocol is 3–6 d.     

Localization of adriamycin in model and natural membranes. Influence of lipid molecular packing

The interaction of adriamycin with lipids was studied in model (monolayers, small unilamellar vesicles, large multilamellar vesicles) and natural (chinese hamster ovary cell) membranes by measurement of fluorescence energy transfer and fluorescence quenching. 2-APam, 7-ASte, 12-ASte and anthracene-phosphatidylcholine were used as fluorescent probes in which the anthracene group is well located at graded depths in the membrane. Egg-yolk phosphatidylcholine and a 1/1 mixture of it with bovine brain phosphatidylserine were used in model membrane systems. Large fluorescence energy transfer was observed between these molecules as donors and the drug as acceptor. With liposomes, at pH 7.4 and over an adriamycin concentration range of 0-100 microM, the efficiency of energy transfer was 12-ASte greater than 7-ASte greater than 2-APam, with 100% energy transfer for 12-ASte above a drug concentration of 30 microM. At pH 5, where the fatty acids are buried deeper (0.45 nm) in the lipid bilayer due to protonation of the carboxyl group, the order of energy transfer 7-ASTe greater than 12-ASte = 2-APam was observed. Measurements of fluorescence quenching using the non-permeant Cu2+ ion as quencher and spectrophotometric assays indicated that around 40% of the adriamycin molecules were deeply embedded in the lipid bilayer. Adriamycin molecules thus appear to penetrate the lipid bilayer, with the aminoglycosyl group interacting with the lipid phosphate groups and the dihydroanthraquinone residue in contact with the lipid fatty acid chains. In contrast, fluorescence energy transfer and quenching studies on CHO cells showed that adriamycin penetrated the plasma membrane of these cells to a much more limited extent than in the model membrane systems. This can be related to the squeezing out of the drug from a film of phosphatidylcholine which was observed in monolayers by means of surface pressure, potential and fluorescence experiments. These observations indicated that the penetration of adriamycin into lipid bilayers strongly depends on the molecular packing of the lipid.     

Electrochemical and NMR spectroscopic investigations of the influence of the probe molecule Eu(fod)3 on the permeability of lipid membranes to ions

Investigating the action of the fluorinated europium complex Eu(fod)3 on lipid membranes we found that the complex facilitates the ion transfer through the membrane. Electric measurements on planar lipid membranes showed that the membrane conductivity increases considerably by insertion of the complex into the membrane. The increase in the conductivity was only obtained if both layers of the membrane were modified with the complex. 1H NMR spectroscopic studies using DOPC liposomes gave information about the location of the modifier complex in the lipid membrane. From chemical shift effects we concluded that the complex resides in the choline head group region of the membrane and also in the membrane interior near the -C =C- lipid double bond, but not in the center of the bilayer. For understanding of the mentioned conductivity effect we assume that the europium complex induces defects of yet unknown structure in the lipid matrix which provide paths for the ion transfer through the membrane. As appropriate measurements revealed, these paths seem to conduct cations predominantly. Investigating the current voltage behavior of the modified lipid membranes in dependence on the ion concentration we obtained different shaped current-voltage curves. Calculation showed that a model with only one energy barrier inside the membrane is unable to describe these curves kinetically. However, by assuming two energy barriers--one barrier in each membrane lipid layer--the observed curve can be described satisfactorily.     

Effect of chronic ionizing irradiation on the structural properties of the apical and mitochondrial membranes of small intestine enterocytes

The different ways of the radiation-induced effect were revealed in the investigations of chronic ionizing radiation influence in total doses of 0.3, 0.6 and 1.0 Gy (0.0072 Gy/day) on the structural properties of the apical and of the mitochondrial membranes of small intestine enterocytes. The modification of the physical properties of the membrane surface area, the decrease of the structural order of the lipid component and conformational changes of the proteins were shown to be specific for the apical membrane. The disturbance of the dynamic properties and topography of the internal mitochondria membrane was revealed in the investigation of the inductive-resonance energy transfer between the pairs of the fluorophores: tryptophan-pyrene, tryptophan-ANS, pyrene-ANS.     

Transfer of phosphatidylcholine between different membranes in Tetrahymena as studied by spin labeling

Transfer of phosphatidylcholine molecules between different membrane fractions of Tetrahymena pyriformis cells grown at 15, 27 and 39.5°C was studied by electron spin resonance (ESR). Microsomes were labeled densely with a phosphatidylcholine spin label and the spin-labeled microsomes were incubated with non-labeled cilia, pellicles or microsomes. The transfer of the phosphatidylcholine spin labels was measured by decrease in the exchange broadening of the electron spin resonance spectrum. In one experiment, the lipid transfer was measured between ³²P-labeled microsomes and non-labeled pellicles by use of their radioactivity. The result was in good agreement with that by ESR. The fluidity of the membrane was estimated using a fatty-acid spin label incorporated into the membranes. Transfer between lipid vesicles was also studied. The results obtained were as follows: (1) The transfer between sonicated vesicles of egg- or dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine occurred rapidly in the liquid crystalline phase, with an activation energy of 20 kcal/mol, whereas it hardly occurred in the solid crystalline phase. (2) The transfer rate between microsomal membranes increased with temperature, and an activation energy of the reaction was 17.8 kcal/mol. (3) The transfer from the spin-labeled microsomes to subcellular membranes of the cells grown at 15°C was larger than that to the membranes of the cells grown at 39.5°C. The membrane fluidity was larger for the cells grown at lower temperature. (4) Similar tendency was observed for the transfer between microsomal lipid vesicles prepared from the cells grown at 15°C and at 39.5°C. (5) The transfer from microsomes to various membrane fractions increased in the order, cilia < pellicles < microsomes. The order of increase in the membrane fluidity was cilia < microsomes < pellicles, although the difference between microsomes and pellicles was slight. These results indicate a crucial role of the membrane fluidity in the transfer reaction. (6) Some evidence supported the idea that the lipid transfer between these organelles occurred through the lipid exchange rather than through the fusion.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer study of the associative state of membrane-bound complexes of complement proteins C5b-8

Human complement protein C8 was labeled with the fluorescent chromophores fluorescein-5-isothiocyanate (FITC), 3-(4-isothiocyanatophenyl)-7-diethylamine-4-methyl coumarin (IPM), eosin-5-isothiocyanate (EOS), or Texas Red (sulforhodamine-101-sulfonyl chloride; TR) with only minor reduction in the specific hemolytic activity of the protein. The distribution of C5b-8 complexes bound to sheep erythrocyte membranes was investigated by monitoring fluorescence resonance energy transfer (RET) between the following RET donor/acceptor pairs of labeled C8: FITC-C8/EOS-C8, IPM-C8/EOS-C8, and FITC-C8/TR-C8. On binding to membranes containing pre-formed C5b67 complexes, specific RET was detected for each of the donor/acceptor pairs of labeled C8 investigated. In contrast, no energy transfer was observed for these RET donor/acceptor pairs of labeled C8 incubated in the presence of control membranes or in membrane-free solution. On the basis of a consideration of the transfer efficiency that would be expected for donor/acceptor pairs of labeled C8 that were uniformly dispersed on the membrane surface, these results suggest that C5b-8 complexes are aggregated into polymeric clusters when membrane-bound. The efficiency of donor-C8 to acceptor-C8 RET--and the hemolytic activity of membrane-bound C5b-8 (in the absence of C9)--are both related to the surface density of membrane-bound C5b67, suggesting that the physical clustering of the membrane-inserted C5b-8 complex may be related to the expression of its cytolytic activity.     

Influence of membrane phospholipid composition and structural organization on spontaneous lipid transfer between membranes

Investigations were carried out on the influence of phospholipid composition of model membranes on the processes of spontaneous lipid transfer between membranes. Acceptor vesicles were prepared from phospholipids extracted from plasma membranes of control and ras-transformed fibroblasts. Acceptor model membranes with manipulated levels of phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), sphingomyelin and phosphatidic acid were also used in the studies. Donor vesicles were prepared of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and contained two fluorescent lipid analogues, NBD-PC and N-Rh-PE, at a self-quenching concentration. Lipid transfer rate was assessed by measuring the increase of fluorescence in acceptor membranes due to transfer of fluorescent lipid analogues from quenched donor to unquenched acceptor vesicles. The results showed that spontaneous NBD-PC transfer increased upon fluidization of acceptor vesicles. In addition, elevation of PE concentration in model membranes was also accompanied by an increase of lipid transfer to all series of acceptor vesicles. The results are discussed with respect to the role of lipid composition and structural order of cellular plasma membranes in the processes of spontaneous lipid exchange between membrane bilayers.     

Characteristics of the heterogeneity of the physical properties of the lipid phase of synaptic membranes from the rat brain using the fluorescent probe pyrene

A theoretical analysis of the dependence of pyrene excimerization on its concentration in biological membranes was carried out. It was shown that in synaptic membranes the concentration dependencies of pyrene excimerization parameter upon direct stimulation appear as nonlinear, thus being reflective of the heterogeneity of physical properties of the lipid phase. Upon pyrene excitation at the expense of the energy transfer from tryptophanyl residues the dependence is linear, which points to the homogeneity of the anular lipid pool. It was assumed that a comparison of microviscosity of the anular and bilayer lipids requires independent measurements of the coefficient of the probe distribution between the lipids or of the anular lipid content in the membrane.     

Structure of apolipophorin-III in discoidal lipoproteins. Interhelical distances in the lipid-bound state and conformational change upon binding to lipid

The structure of apolipophorin III in the lipid-bound state and the extent of the conformational change that takes place when the five-helix bundle apolipoprotein binds to a lipoprotein lipid surface were investigated by fluorescence resonance energy transfer in discoidal lipoproteins. Four intramolecular interhelical distances between helix pairs 1-4, 2-4, 3-4, and 5-4 were estimated by fluorescence resonance energy transfer in both the lipid-free and the lipid-bound states. Depending on the helices pairs, the intramolecular interhelical distances increased between 15 and > or = 20 A upon binding of the apolipoprotein to lipid, demonstrating for the first time that binding to lipid is accompanied by a major change in interhelical distances. Using discoidal lipoproteins made with a combination of apolipophorin III molecules containing donor and acceptor groups and apolipophorin III molecules containing neither donor nor acceptor groups, it was possible to obtain information about intermolecular interhelical distances between the helix 4 of one apolipoprotein and the helices 1, 2, 3, and 5 of a second apolipoprotein residing in the same discoidal lipoprotein. Altogether, the estimated intermolecular and intramolecular interhelical distances suggest a model in which the apolipoprotein arranges in pairs of antiparallel and fully extended polypeptide chains surrounding the periphery of the bilayer disc.     

Aggregation state of melittin in lipid vesicle membranes

We have performed time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer measurements using melittin as donor and a modified melittin as acceptor. The melittin molecules were bound to fluid vesicle membranes of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine. Analysis of the temporal decay of the energy transfer and of its variation with the donor and acceptor concentrations led to the conclusion that melittin in fluid membranes is usually monomeric. Only at the high melittin/lipid molar ratio of 1/200 and high ionic strength evidence for aggregation was obtained, the percentage of aggregated melittin molecules being of the order of 10%. The shortcomings of previous steady-state measurements of fluorescence energy transfer between melittin molecules are discussed.     

Direct visualization of saposin remodelling of lipid bilayers

Saposins A, B, C and D are soluble, non-enzymatic proteins that interact with lysosomal membranes to activate the breakdown and transfer of glycosphingolipids. The mechanisms of hydrolase activation and lipid transfer by saposins remain unknown. We have used in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) with simultaneous confocal fluorescence microscopy to investigate the interactions of saposins with lipid membranes. AFM images of the effect of saposins A, B and C on supported lipid bilayers showed a time and concentration-dependent nucleated spread of membrane transformation. Saposin B produced deep gaps that ultimately filled with granular material, while saposins A and C lead to localized areas of membrane that were reduced in height by approximately 1.5 nm. Fluorescence-labeled saposin C co-localized with the transformed areas of the bilayer, indicating stable binding to the membrane. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer confirmed a direct interaction between saposin C and lipid. Under certain conditions of membrane lipid composition and saposin concentration, extensive bilayer lipid removal was observed. We propose a multi-step mechanism that integrates the structural features and amphipathic properties of the saposin proteins.     

Ceramide-domain formation and collapse in lipid rafts: membrane reorganization by an apoptotic lipid

The effect of physiologically relevant ceramide concentrations (< or = 4 mol %) in raft model membranes with a lipid composition resembling that of cell membranes, i.e., composed of different molar ratios of an unsaturated glycerophospholipid, sphingomyelin, and cholesterol (Chol) along a liquid-disordered-liquid-ordered tie line was explored. The application of a fluorescence multiprobe and multiparameter approach, together with multiple fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) pairs, in the well-characterized palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphocholine (POPC)/palmitoyl-sphingomyelin (PSM)/Chol ternary mixture, revealed that low palmitoyl-ceramide (PCer) concentrations strongly changed both the biophysical properties and lipid lateral organization of the ternary mixtures in the low-to-intermediate Chol/PSM-, small raft size range (<25 mol % Chol). For these mixtures, PCer recruited up to three PSM molecules for the formation of very small ( approximately 4 nm) and highly ordered gel domains, which became surrounded by rafts (liquid-ordered phase) when Chol/PSM content increased. However, the size of these rafts did not change, showing that PCer did not induce the formation of large platforms or the coalescence of small rafts. In the high Chol/PSM-, large raft domains range (>33 mol % Chol), Chol completely abolished the effect of PCer by competing for PSM association. Lipid rafts govern the biophysical properties and lateral organization in these last mixtures.     

Lipid radicals--possible mediators of charge transfer and energy transformation (a hypothesis)

A number of enzymatic reactions with the participation of lipid radicals is discussed in the article. It is supposed that NADPH- and NADH-dependent formation of the lipid radicals has a functional importance. The uptake of oxygen by free radicals is considered as one of the reactions of radicals utilization. It is proposed that other reactions with participation of lipid radicals can take place in the membranes of microsomes and mitochondria: the reaction of electron transfer from flavoprotein to cytochrome P448 and the reaction of energy transfer which provide the coupling of oxidation and phosphorylation.     

Resonance energy transfer study of lysozyme-lipid interactions

Resonance energy transfer (RET) between the tryptophan residues of lysozyme as donors and anthrylvinyl-labeled phosphatidylcholine (AV-PC) or phosphatidylglycerol (AV-PG) as acceptors has been examined to gain insight into molecular level details of the interactions of lysozyme with the lipid bilayers composed of PC with 10, 20, or 40 mol% PG. Energy transfer efficiency determined from the enhanced acceptor fluorescence was found to increase with content of the acidic lipid and surface coverage. The results of RET experiments performed with lipid vesicles containing 40 mol% PG were quantitatively analyzed in terms of the model of energy transfer in two-dimensional systems taking into account the distance dependence of orientation factor. Evidence for an interfacial location of the two predominant lysozyme fluorophores, Trp62 and Trp108, was obtained. The RET enhancement observed while employing AV-PG instead of AV-PC as an energy acceptor was interpreted as arising from the ability of lysozyme to bring about local demixing of the neutral and charged lipids in PC/PG model membranes.     

Determination of fluorescent probes localization in membranes by nonradiative energy transfer

One of the new methods of studying the structure and dimensions of biological membranes is based on the F?rster's nonradiative energy transfer between special molecules, the so-called 'membrane fluorescent probes'. Further development of the approach is presented in this article. It consists of the combined use of the time-resolved and steady-state fluorescence data with subsequent computer simulation of the energy transfer in membranes. Anthracene as an energy donor, and 4-p-(dimethylamino)styryl-N-dodecylpyridinium (DSP-12) or 4-dimethylaminochalcone (DMC) as energy acceptors were bound with artificial phospholipid membrane vesicles ('liposomes'). The synchrotron radiation was used as an impulse source for the excitation light. The steady-state fluorescence data permit the area of possible probe localization in membranes to be distinguished, while the kinetic data allow them to be narrowed significantly. There is a good agreement between the obtained localization and our present-day knowledge of lipid bilayer structure. The accuracy of the method is ca. several Angstr?ms.     

Kinetics of fluorescent-labeled phosphatidylcholine transfer between nonspecific lipid transfer protein and phospholipid vesicles

Recently, rat liver nonspecific lipid transfer protein (nsLTP) was shown to form a fluorescent complex when allowed to equilibrate with self-quenching vesicles prepared from the fluorescent phospholipid 1-palmitoyl-2-[12-[(7-nitro-2,1,3-benzoxadiazol-4- yl)amino]dodecanoyl]phosphatidylcholine (P-C12-NBD-PC) [Nichols, J. W. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 14172-14177]. Investigation of the mechanism of complex formation was continued by studying the kinetics of transfer of P-C12-NBD-PC between nsLTP and phospholipid vesicles using a transfer assay based on resonance energy transfer between P-C12-NBD-PC and N-(lissamine rhodamine B sulfonyl)dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine. The principles of mass action kinetics (which predict initial lipid transfer rates as a function of protein and vesicle concentration) were used to derive equations for two distinct mechanisms: lipid transfer by the diffusion of monomers through the aqueous phase and lipid transfer during nsLTP-membrane collisions. The results of these kinetics studies indicated that the model for neither mechanism alone adequately predicted the initial rates of formation and dissolution of the P-C12-NBD-PC-nsLTP complex. The initial rate kinetics for both processes were predicted best by a model in which monomer diffusion and collision-dependent transfer occur simultaneously. These data support the hypothesis that the phospholipid-nsLTP complex functions as an intermediate in the transfer of phospholipids between membranes.