Saccharomyces cerevisiae Msh2-Msh3 acts in repair of base-base mispairs

DNA mismatch repair is thought to act through two subpathways involving the recognition of base-base and insertion/deletion mispairs by the Msh2-Msh6 heterodimer and the recognition of insertion/deletion mispairs by the Msh2-Msh3 heterodimer. Here, through genetic and biochemical approaches, we describe a previously unidentified role of the Msh2-Msh3 heterodimer in the recognition of base-base mispairs and the suppression of homology-mediated duplication and deletion mutations. Saccharomyces cerevisiae msh3 mutants did not show an increase in the rate of base substitution mutations by the CAN1 forward mutation assay compared to the rate for the wild type but did show an altered spectrum of base substitution mutations, including an increased accumulation of base pair changes from GC to CG and from AT to TA; msh3 mutants also accumulated homology-mediated duplication and deletion mutations. The mutation spectrum of mlh3 mutants paralleled that of msh3 mutants, suggesting that the Mlh1-Mlh3 heterodimer may also play a role in the repair of base-base mispairs and in the suppression of homology-mediated duplication and deletion mutations. Mispair binding analysis with purified Msh2-Msh3 and DNA substrates derived from CAN1 sequences found to be mutated in vivo demonstrated that Msh2-Msh3 exhibited robust binding to specific base-base mispairs that was consistent with functional mispair binding.     

基于功率谱分析的基因编码序列单碱基突变研究

针对DNA序列单碱基的不同类型突变,利用数字信号处理方法,研究了单碱基替换突变、删除突变、插入突变对DNA序列三周期功率谱的影响。研究结果表明:对于不同长度的编码序列,替换突变对序列功率谱的影响较小,删除突变和插入突变对序列功率谱的影响较大;随着序列编码区长度的减小,替换、删除、插入突变对序列编码区的功率谱影响会越来越大。对于中等长度外显子,插入突变对序列三周期功率谱影响最大,对于短外显子,删除突变对序列三周期功率谱的影响最大。研究结果可为含突变基因编码区的识别与检测提供参考。     

In vivo site-directed mutagenesis using oligonucleotides

Functional characterization of the genes of higher eukaryotes has been aided by their expression in model organisms and by analyzing site-specific changes in homologous genes in model systems such as the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Modifying sequences in yeast or other organisms such that no heterologous material is retained requires in vitro mutagenesis together with subcloning. PCR-based procedures that do not involve cloning are inefficient or require multistep reactions that increase the risk of additional mutations. An alternative approach, demonstrated in yeast, relies on transformation with an oligonucleotide, but the method is restricted to the generation of mutants with a selectable phenotype. Oligonucleotides, when combined with gap repair, have also been used to modify plasmids in yeast; however, this approach is limited by restriction-site availability. We have developed a mutagenesis approach in yeast based on transformation by unpurified oligonucleotides that allows the rapid creation of site-specific DNA mutations in vivo. A two-step, cloning-free process, referred to as delitto perfetto, generates products having only the desired mutation, such as a single or multiple base change, an insertion, a small or a large deletion, or even random mutations. The system provides for multiple rounds of mutation in a window up to 200 base pairs. The process is RAD52 dependent, is not constrained by the distribution of naturally occurring restriction sites, and requires minimal DNA sequencing. Because yeast is commonly used for random and selective cloning of genomic DNA from higher eukaryotes such as yeast artificial chromosomes, the delitto perfetto strategy also provides an efficient way to create precise changes in mammalian or other DNA sequences.     

Specificities mediated by neighboring nucleotides appear to underlie mutation induced by antifolates in E. coli

The antifolate, trimethoprim (TRMP, 5 microM) caused a 10-fold increase in mutation frequency and primarily induced base substitution and deletion mutations in wild-type E. coli. Base-substitutions induced by antifolates were equally divided between transition and transversion mutations. When mutations consistent with expected antifolate-induced deoxynucleotide pool imbalances were considered, 29 out of 32 base-substitution mutations in the i-d region of the lacI gene were followed 3' by the same nucleotide substituted at the base mismatch site and all but one mutation occurred at sites consistent with next nucleotide effects resulting from antifolate-induced deoxynucleotide pool alterations. 66% of the TRMP-induced base-substitutions were also found at sites of frequent mutation identified in the spontaneous spectrum of a mutator D5 strain of E. coli which is deficient in the 3'-exonucleolytic proofreading function of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. These results suggest that the pool imbalances induced by the antifolate trimethoprim compromise the proofreading activity of polymerase III holoenzyme and lead to mutation at specific sites. The results also imply that not all DNA sequence environments encountered by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme and its accompanying exonuclease are handled with equal facility at the level of nucleotide insertion and exonucleolytic proofreading when the enzyme is faced with an intracellular nucleotide pool imbalance. A number of small deletion and duplication mutations were also induced by the antifolate trimethoprim. In most cases these mutations were flanked by at least two A:T base pairs which could facilitate DNA-strand breakage at deoxyuridine misincorporation sites.     

Characterization of carbadox-induced mutagenesis using a shuttle vector pSP189 in mammalian cells

Carbadox, a quinoxaline 1,4-dioxide derivative, is a known mutagen with its functional mechanism yet to be well defined. In the present study we used a shuttle vector assay in vitro to uncover the functional details of carbadox-induced mutagenesis in mammalian cells. The plasmid DNA of a shuttle vector pSP189 was treated with different doses of carbadox at 37 degrees C for 1 or 2h with or without the presence of S9. The target gene SupF in the plasmid was sequenced after replication in Vero cells followed by amplification in Escherichia coli MBM7070 to evaluate mutation frequency. DNA sequencing analysis of recovered carbadox-induced mutations revealed 76.3% single base substitution, 7.9% single base insertion, 10.5% single base deletion and 5.3% large fragments deletion. All single base substitutions occurred at G:C base pairs, among which transversion and transition occurred at a 2:1 ratio. The mutations did not occur randomly in the supF gene, but had sequence specificity and hotspots instead: most substitutions were detected at the nucleotide N in a 5'-NNTTNN-3' sequence; 75% of base insertions were seen in the 5'-TCC-3' sequence; whereas all large fragments deletions occurred in the 5'-ANGGCCNAAA-3' sequence. Nucleotide 129, 141 and 155 in the supF gene of plasmid pSP189 were identified as the hotspots for carbadox-induced mutations that accounted for 65% of all single base substitutions. We conclude that carbadox and its metabolites induce sequence-specific DNA mutations at high frequencies, therefore its safe usage in animal husbandry should be seriously considered.     

Mechanisms of spontaneous mutagenesis: an analysis of the spectrum of spontaneous mutation in the Escherichia coli lacI gene

We have obtained via DNA sequence analysis a spectrum of 174 spontaneous mutations occurring in the lac I gene of Escherichia coli. The spectrum comprised base substitution, frameshift, deletion, duplication and insertion mutations, of which the relative contributions to spontaneous mutation could be estimated. Two thirds of all lacI mutations occurred in the frameshift hotspot site. An analysis of the local DNA sequence suggested that the intensity of this hotspot may depend on structural features of the DNA that extend beyond those permitted by the repeated tetramer at this site. Deletions comprised the largest non-hotspot class (37%). They could be divided into two subclasses, depending on whether they included the lac operator sequence; the latter was found to be a preferred site for deletion endpoints. Most of the deletions internal to the lacI gene were associated with the presence of directly or invertedly repeated sequences capable of accounting for their endpoints. Base substitutions comprised 34% of the non-hotspot events. Unlike the base substitution spectrum obtained via nonsense mutations, G . C----A . T transitions do not predominate. A new base substitution hotspot was discovered at position +6 in the lac operator; its intensity may reflect specific features of the operator DNA. IS1 insertion mutations contributed 12% of the non-hotspot mutations and occurred dispersed throughout the gene in both orientations. Since the lacI gene is not A + T-rich, the contribution of IS1 insertion to spontaneous mutation in general might be underestimated. Single-base frameshift mutations were found only infrequently. In general, they did not occur in runs of a common base. Instead, their occurrence seemed based on the "perfection" of direct or inverted repeats in the local DNA sequence. Three (tandem) duplication events were recovered. No repeated sequences were found that might have determined their endpoints.     

Nested genetic bit analysis (N-GBA) for mutation detection in the p53 tumor suppressor gene.

There is a growing and significant demand for reliable, simple and sensitive methods for repeated scanning of a given gene or gene fragment for detection and characterization of mutations. Solid-phase sequencing by single base primer extension of nested GBATM primers on miniaturized DNA arrays can be used to effectively scan targeted sequences for missense, insertion and deletion mutations. This paper describes the use of N-GBA arrays designed to scan the sequence of a 33 base region of exon 8 of the p53 gene (codons 272-282) encompassing a hot spot for mutations associated with the development of cancer. Synthetic DNA templates containing various missense, insertion and deletion mutations, as well as DNA prepared from pancreatic and biliary tumor cells, were genotyped using the exon 8 arrays.     

EXO1 and MSH6 are high-copy suppressors of conditional mutations in the MSH2 mismatch repair gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Msh2p, a central component in mismatch repair, forms a heterodimer with Msh3p to repair small insertion/deletion mismatches and with Msh6p to repair base pair mismatches and single-nucleotide insertion/deletion mismatches. In haploids, a msh2Delta mutation is synthetically lethal with pol3-01, a mutation in the Poldelta proofreading exonuclease. Six conditional alleles of msh2 were identified as those that conferred viability in pol3-01 strains at 26 degrees but not at 35 degrees. DNA sequencing revealed that mutations in several of the msh2(ts) alleles are located in regions with previously unidentified functions. The conditional inviability of two mutants, msh2-L560S pol3-01 and msh2-L910P pol3-01, was suppressed by overexpression of EXO1 and MSH6, respectively. Partial suppression was also observed for the temperature-sensitive mutator phenotype exhibited by msh2-L560S and msh2-L910P strains in the lys2-Bgl reversion assay. High-copy plasmids bearing mutations in the conserved EXO1 nuclease domain were unable to suppress msh2-L560S pol3-01 conditional lethality. These results, in combination with a genetic analysis of msh6Delta pol3-01 and msh3Delta pol3-01 strains, suggest that the activity of the Msh2p-Msh6p heterodimer is important for viability in the presence of the pol3-01 mutation and that Exo1p plays a catalytic role in Msh2p-mediated mismatch repair.     

Mutation detection using immobilized mismatch binding protein (MutS).

An accurate and highly sensitive mutation detection assay has been developed. The assay is based on the detection of mispaired and unpaired bases by immobilized mismatch binding protein (Escherichia coli MutS). The assay can detect most mismatches and all single base substitution mutations, as well as small addition or deletion mutations. The assay is simple to use and does not require the use of either radioactivity or gel electrophoresis.     

Specificity of the mutator effect caused by disruption of the RAD1 excision repair gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Disruption of RAD1, a gene controlling excision repair in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, increased the frequency of spontaneous forward mutation in a plasmid-borne copy of the SUP4-o gene. To characterize this effect in detail, a collection of 249 SUP4-o mutations arising spontaneously in the rad1 strain was analyzed by DNA sequencing. The resulting mutational spectrum was compared with that derived from an examination of 322 spontaneous SUP4-o mutations selected in an isogenic wild-type (RAD1) strain. This comparison revealed that the rad1 mutator phenotype was associated with increases in the frequencies of single-base-pair substitution, single-base-pair deletion, and insertion of the yeast retrotransposon Ty. In the rad1 strain, the relative fractions of these events and their distributions within SUP4-o exhibited features similar to those for spontaneous mutagenesis in the isogenic RAD1 background. The increase in the frequency of Ty insertion argues that Ty transposition can be activated by unrepaired spontaneous DNA damage, which normally would be removed by excision repair. We discuss the possibilities that either translesion synthesis, a reduced fidelity of DNA replication, or a deficiency in mismatch correction might be responsible for the majority of single-base-pair events in the rad1 strain.     

Removal of Frameshift Intermediates by Mismatch Repair Proteins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Frameshift mutations occur when the coding region of a gene is altered by addition or deletion of a number of base pairs that is not a multiple of three. The occurrence of a deletion versus an insertion type of frameshift depends on the nature of the transient intermediate structure formed during DNA synthesis. Extrahelical bases on the template strand give rise to deletions, whereas extrahelical bases on the strand being synthesized produce insertions. We previously used reversion of a +1 frameshift mutation to analyze the role of the mismatch repair (MMR) machinery in correcting -1 frameshift intermediates within a defined region of the yeast LYS2 gene. In this study, we have used reversion of a -1 frameshift mutation within the same region of LYS2 to analyze the role of the MMR machinery in the correction of frameshift intermediates that give rise to insertion events. We found that insertion and deletion events occur at similar rates but that the reversion spectra are very different in both the wild-type and MMR-defective backgrounds. In addition, analysis of the +1 spectra revealed novel roles for Msh3p and Msh6p in removing specific types of frameshift intermediates.     

The mutational specificity of DNA polymerase-beta during in vitro DNA synthesis. Production of frameshift, base substitution, and deletion mutations

The frequency and specificity of mutations produced in vitro by eucaryotic DNA polymerase-beta have been determined in a forward mutation assay using a 250-base target sequence in M13mp2 DNA. Homogeneous DNA polymerase-beta, isolated from four different sources, produces mutations at a frequency of 4-6%/single round of gap-filling DNA synthesis. DNA sequence analyses of 460 independent mutants resulting from this error-prone DNA synthesis demonstrate a wide variety of mutational events. Frameshift and base substitutions are made at approximately equal frequency and together comprise about 90% of all mutations. Two mutational "hot spots" for frameshift and base substitution mutations were observed. The characteristics of the mutations at these sites suggest that certain base substitution errors result from dislocation of template bases rather than from direct mispair formation by DNA polymerase-beta. When considering the entire target sequence, single-base frameshift mutations occur primarily in runs of identical bases, usually pyrimidines. The loss of a single base occurs 20-80 times more frequently than single-base additions and much more frequently than the loss of two or more bases. Base substitutions occur at many sites throughout the target, representing a wide spectrum of mispair formations. Averaged over a large number of phenotypically detectable sites, the base substitution error frequency is greater than one mistake for every 5000 bases polymerized. Large deletion mutations are also observed, at a frequency more than 10-fold over background, indicating that purified DNA polymerases alone are capable of producing such deletions. These data are discussed in relation to the physical and kinetic properties of the purified enzymes and with respect to the proposed role for this DNA polymerase in vivo.     

The viral thymidine kinase gene as a tool for the study of mutagenesis in Trypanosoma brucei.

We have tested the use of thymidine kinase as a negative selection system for Trypanosoma brucei. To this end we have targeted a construct containing a Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (TK) gene into the ribosomal DNA array of procyclic T. brucei. This resulted in TK activity 30-50-fold above background and in susceptibility to the nucleoside analogues ganciclovir, ethyl-deoxyuridine and 1-[2-deoxy,2-fluoro-8-D-arabinofuranosyl]-5-iodouracil, all of which have no effect on wild-type trypanosomes. TK+ trypanosomes, however, reverted to a ganciclovir resistant phenotype at a rate of 10(-6) per cell-generation. A similar reversion rate was observed using the Varicella-zoster virus TK gene. Loss of TK activity was not due to detectable DNA rearrangements or a decrease in TK mRNA. Sequence analysis of the revertant genes demonstrated, however, the occurrence of point mutations and frameshifts. One revertant line had a mutation in the thymidine binding site leading to the substitution of a conserved arginine by a glycine. Other mutations included single base insertion, single base deletion and the introduction of a premature termination codon by point mutation.     

DNA base changes and RNA levels in N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene-induced dihydrofolate reductase mutants of Chinese hamster ovary cells

Formerly, we isolated a series of dihydrofolate reductase-deficient Chinese hamster ovary cell mutants that were induced by N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene. Deletions and complex gene rearrangements were detected in 28% of these mutants; 72% contained putative point mutations. In the present study, we have localized the putative point mutations in the 25,000 base dhfr gene by RNase heteroduplex mapping. Assignment of a position for each mutation was successful in 16 of 19 mutants studied. We cloned DNA fragments containing the mapped mutations from nine mutants into a bacteriophage lambda vector. In the case of 11 other mutants, DNA was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction procedure. Sequence analysis of cloned and amplified DNA confirmed the presence of point mutations. Most mutants (90%) carried base substitutions; the rest contained frameshift mutations. Of the point mutations, 75% were G.C to T.A transversions in either the dhfr coding sequence or at splice sites; transition G.C to A.T mutations were found in two mutants (10%). In one of these transition mutants, the base substitution occurred at the fifth base of the third intron. Of the frameshift mutations, one was a deletion of G.C pair and the other was an insertion of an A.T pair. Of the mapped mutants, 38% exhibited greatly reduced (approximately 10-fold) steady-state levels of dhfr mRNA. All eight sequenced mutants displaying this phenotype contained premature chain termination codons. Normal levels of dhfr mRNA were observed in five missense mutants and in five mutants carrying nonsense codons in the translated portion of exon VI. Taken together with the results of other mutagens at this locus, we conclude that the low dhfr mRNA phenotype is correlated with the presence of nonsense codons in exons II to V but not in the last exon of the dhfr gene.     

Identification of five rare mutations including a novel frameshift mutation causing beta zero-thalassemia in Thai patients with beta zero-thalassemia/hemoglobin E disease.

6 out of 14 uncharacterized beta-thalassemia alleles from 187 Thai beta-thalassemia/HbE patients were identified by direct sequencing of DNA amplified by polymerase chain reaction. A novel mutation occurring from an insertion of adenosine in codon 95, which results in a shift of the reading frame with terminator at the new codon 101, was detected in one patient. In addition, two frameshift mutations not previously reported among the Thai population were also detected in 3 patients: one with a deletion of thymidine in codon 15 and two with an insertion of cytidine in codons 27/28. A frameshift mutation that occurred from a cytidine deletion in codon 41 was also found in one patient in this study. The remaining case was an amber mutation, GAG-TAG, in codon 43 in exon 2 of the beta-globin gene. These mutations bring the number of mutations known to be present in the Thai population to a total of 20, 15 of which were detected in beta-thalassemia/HbE patients.     

In vivo study of fidelity of DNA double-strand break repair in bacteriophage T4

A method for in vivo studying the fidelity of DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair in bacteriophage T4 has been developed. The frequency of reversion of rII mutations to the wild phenotype was measured in i segC+ x i ets 1 segCDelta crosses, where ets 1 is an insertion in the initial part of the rII gene carrying a sequence recognized by SegC endonuclease; i designates a rIIB or rIIA mutation located at some distance from ets 1, and segCDelta is a deletion in the segC gene. In such cross, a DSB occurs in the site of ets 1. Their repair involves genetic recombination and DNA replication in the neighborhood of ets 1. In parallel, the frequency of reversion of the same i mutant in the absence of DSBs is measured in i x i self-crosses. Reversions of different types (base substitutions, deletions, insertions) can be studied with the use of structurally different i mutations located at varying distances from ets 1. The reversion frequencies were determined for three rIIB mutations and one rIIA mutation. The results obtained suggest that DSB repair in bacteriophage T4 is a process of high fidelity with the rate of errors that does not essentially exceed that in the case of usual phage multiplication.     

Mutational specificities of 1′-acetoxysafrole,N-benzoyloxy-N-methyl-4-aminoazobenzene,and ethyl methanesulfonate in human cells

We have used an oriP-tk shuttle vector t determine the types of mutations induced in human cells by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), 1'-acetoxysafrole (AcOS), and N-benzoyloxy-N-methyl-4-aminoazobenzene (BzOMAB). Plasmid DNA was treated in vitro with mutagen and electroporated into human lymphoblastoid cells. After replication of the vector in human cells, plasmids were analyzed for mutations in the herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase gene. Ethyl methanesulfonate induced predominantly GC → AT transition mutations. Treatment of the shuttle vector with AcOS induced 5 of the 6 possible base substitution mutations, including GC → AT (32%) and AT → GC (14%) transition mutations, GC → TA (%), GC → CG (18%), and AT → TA (14%) transversion mutations, as well as a low frequency (9%) of −1 frameshift mutations at GC base pairs. Replication in human cells of DNA modified with BzOMAB yielded a significant increase (17-fold) in the frequency of deletion mutations relative to solvent-treated DNA. A majority (94%) of the point mutations induced by BzOMAB occurred at GC base pairs and were predomianntly GC → AT transitions (33%) and −1 frameshift (22%) mutations, with the remainder consisting mainly of transversions at GC base pairs (28%). The broad spectrum of base substitution mutations observed for AcOS and BzOMAB may indicate the frequent insertion of a variety of bases during replicative bypass of aralkylated bases in human cells.     

Mucopolysaccharidosis VI (Maroteaux-Lamy syndrome): six unique arylsulfatase B gene alleles causing variable disease phenotypes.

Mucopolysaccharidosis type VI, or Maroteaux-Lamy syndrome, is a lysosomal storage disorder caused by a deficiency of the enzyme arylsulfatase B (ASB), also known as N-acetylgalactosamine-4-sulfatase. Multiple clinical phenotypes of this autosomal recessively inherited disease have been described. Recent isolation and characterization of the human ASB gene facilitated the analysis of molecular defects underlying the different phenotypes. Conditions for PCR amplification of the entire open reading frame from genomic DNA and for subsequent direct automated DNA sequencing of the resulting DNA fragments were established. Besides two polymorphisms described elsewhere that cause methionine-for-valine substitutions in the arylsulfatase B gene, six new mutations in six patients were detected: four point mutations resulting in amino acid substitutions, a 1-bp deletion, and a 1-bp insertion. The point mutations were two G-to-A and two T-to-C transitions. The G-to-A transitions cause an arginine-for-glycine substitution at residue 144 in a homoallelic patient with a severe disease phenotype and a tyrosine-for-cysteine substitution at residue 521 in a potentially heteroallelic patient with the severe form of the disease. The T-to-C transitions cause an arginine-for-cysteine substitution at amino acid residue 192 in a homoallelic patient with mild symptoms and a proline-for-leucine substitution at amino acid 321 in a homoallelic patient with the intermediate form. The insertion between nucleotides T1284 and G1285 resulted in a loss of the 100 C-terminal amino acids of the wild-type protein and in the deletion of nucleotide C1577 in a 39-amino-acid C-terminal extension of the ASB polypeptide. Both mutations were detected in homoallelic patients with the severe form of the disease. Expression of mutant cDNAs encoding the four amino acid substitutions and the deletion resulted in severe reduction of both ASB protein levels and arylsulfatase enzyme activity in comparison with a wild-type control. The six mutations described in the present study were unique among 25 unrelated mucopolysaccharidosis VI patients, suggesting a broad molecular heterogeneity of the Maroteaux-Lamy syndrome.     

A novel method of identifying genetic mutations using an electrochemical DNA array

We describe the development of a new type of DNA array chip that utilizes electrochemical reactions and a novel method of simultaneously identifying multiple genetic mutations on an array chip. The electrochemical array (ECA) uses a threading intercalator specific to double-stranded nucleotides, ferrocenylnaphthalene diimide (FND), as the indicator. ECA does not require target labeling, and the equipment is simple, durable and less expensive. The simultaneous multiple mutation detection (SMMD) system using an ECA chip and FND utilizes an enzyme to simultaneously distinguish several genetic mutations such as single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP), insertion, deletion, translocation and short tandem repeat. We examined this SMMD system using an ECA chip, by detecting seven different mutations on the lipoprotein lipase (LPL) gene for 50 patients in a blind test. It turned out that all the results obtained were concordant with the sequencing results, demonstrating that this system is a powerful tool for clinical applications.     

Is the rate of insertion and deletion mutation male biased?: Molecular evolutionary analysis of avian and primate sex chromosome sequences.

The rate of mutation for nucleotide substitution is generally higher among males than among females, likely owing to the larger number of DNA replications in spermatogenesis than in oogenesis. For insertion and deletion (indel) mutations, data from a few human genetic disease loci indicate that the two sexes may mutate at similar rates, possibly because such mutations arise in connection with meiotic crossing over. To address origin- and sex-specific rates of indel mutation we have conducted the first large-scale molecular evolutionary analysis of indels in noncoding DNA sequences from sex chromosomes. The rates are similar on the X and Y chromosomes of primates but about twice as high on the avian Z chromosome as on the W chromosome. The fact that indels are not uncommon on the nonrecombining Y and W chromosomes excludes meiotic crossing over as the main cause of indel mutation. On the other hand, the similar rates on X and Y indicate that the number of DNA replications (higher for Y than for X) is also not the main factor. Our observations are therefore consistent with a role of both DNA replication and recombination in the generation of short insertion and deletion mutations. A significant excess of deletion compared to insertion events is observed on the avian W chromosome, consistent with gradual DNA loss on a nonrecombining chromosome.