The significance of differences in the mechanisms of photosynthetic acclimation to light, nitrogen and CO2 for return on investment in leaves

1. We report changes in photosynthetic capacity of leaves developed in varying photon flux density (PFD), nitrogen supply and CO₂ concentration. We determined the relative effect of these environmental factors on photosynthetic capacity per unit leaf volume as well as the volume of tissue per unit leaf area. We calculated resource-use efficiencies from the photosynthetic capacities and measurements of leaf dry mass, carbohydrates and nitrogen content.
2. There were clear differences between the mechanisms of photosynthetic acclimation to PFD, nitrogen supply and CO₂. PFD primarily affected volume of tissue per unit area whereas nitrogen supply primarily affected photosynthetic capacity per unit volume. CO₂ concentration affected both of these parameters and interacted strongly with the PFD and nitrogen treatments.
3. Photosynthetic capacity per unit carbon invested in leaves increased in the low PFD, high nitrogen and low CO₂ treatments. Photosynthetic capacity per unit nitrogen was significantly affected only by nitrogen supply.
4. The responses to low PFD and low nitrogen appear to function to increase the efficiency of utilization of the limiting resource. However, the responses to elevated CO₂ in the high PFD and high nitrogen treatments suggest that high CO₂ can result in a situation where growth is not limited by either carbon or nitrogen supply. Limitation of growth at elevated CO₂ appears to result from internal plant factors that limit utilization of carbohydrates at sinks and/or transport of carbohydrates to sinks.     

Affinity for CO2 in relation to the ability of freshwater macrophytes to use HCO–3

1. The affinity of photosynthesis for CO₂ is calculated here as the initial slope of net-photosynthetic rate against concentration of CO₂. The affinity for CO₂ for pairs of freshwater macrophytes with similar leaf morphology but able or unable to use HCO^–₃ as a carbon source was compared.
2. Species restricted to CO₂ had a higher affinity for CO₂ than species that were also able to use HCO^–₃ when rates were expressed on the basis of area, dry mass and content of chlorophyll a .
3. Published values for the affinity for CO₂ and the concentration of CO₂ which half-saturated rate of photosynthesis were compiled and compared. Despite a large range of values, affinity for CO₂ was greater for species restricted to CO₂ than for those also able to use HCO^–₃ and statistically different when the slope was expressed on the basis of dry mass and chlorophyll a content.
4. The difference in affinity is consistent with predicted benefits of a high permeability to CO₂ for species relying on passive diffusion of CO₂ and a lower permeability for species able to use HCO^–₃ in order to reduce efflux of CO₂ from a high internal concentration generated by active transport.
5. The implications of the different affinities are discussed in terms of species distribution.     

Does photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO2 increase photosynthetic nitrogen-use efficiency? A study of three native UK grassland species in open-top chambers

1. The photosynthetic response to elevated CO₂ and nutrient stress was investigated in Agrostis capillaris, Lolium perenne and Trifolium repens grown in an open-top chamber facility for 2 years under two nutrient regimes. Acclimation was evaluated by measuring the response of light-saturated photosynthesis to changes in the substomatal CO₂ concentration.
2. Growth at elevated CO₂ resulted in reductions in apparent Rubisco activity in vivo in all three species, which were associated with reductions of total leaf nitrogen content on a unit area basis for A. capillaris and L. perenne . Despite this acclimation, photosynthesis was significantly higher at elevated CO₂ for T. repens and A. capillaris , the latter exhibiting the greatest increase of carbon uptake at the lowest nutrient supply.
3. The photosynthetic nitrogen-use efficiency (the rate of carbon assimilation per unit leaf nitrogen) increased at elevated CO₂, not purely owing to higher values of photosynthesis at elevated CO₂, but also as a result of lower leaf nitrogen contents.
4. Contrary to most previous studies, this investigation indicates that elevated CO₂ can stimulate photosynthesis under a severely limited nutrient supply. Changes in photosynthetic nitrogen-use efficiency may be a critical determinant of competition within low nutrient ecosystems and low input agricultural systems.     

Partitioning of dry mass and leaf area within plants of three species grown at elevated CO2

1. We tested the hypothesis that the net partitioning of dry mass and dry mass:area relationships is unaltered when plants are grown at elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations.
2. The total dry mass of Dactylis glomerata, Bellis perennis and Trifolium repens was higher for plants in 700 compared to 350 μmol CO₂ mol^–1 when grown hydroponically in controlled-environment cabinets.
3. Shoot:root ratios were higher and leaf area ratios and specific leaf areas lower in all species grown at elevated CO₂. Leaf mass ratio was higher in plants of B. perennis and D. glomerata grown at elevated CO₂.
4. Whilst these data suggest that CO₂ alters the net partitioning of dry mass and dry mass:leaf area relationships, allometric comparisons of the components of dry mass and leaf area suggest at most a small effect of CO₂. CO₂ changed only two of a total of 12 allometric coefficients we calculated for the three species: ν relating shoot to root dry mass was higher in D. glomerata , whilst ν relating leaf area to total dry mass was lower in T. repens .
5. CO₂ alone has very little effect on partitioning when the size of the plant is taken into account.     

The effect of an elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration on growth, photosynthesis and respiration of Plantago major

The effect of an elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration on growth, photosynthesis and root respiration of Plantago major L. ssp. major L. was investigated. Plants were grown in a nutrient solution in growth chambers at 350 and 700 μl I⁻¹ CO₂ during 7 weeks. The total dry weight of the Co₂-enriched plants at the end of this period was 50% higher than that of control plants. However, the relative growth rate (RGR) was stimulated only during the first half of the growing period. The transient nature of the stimulation of the RGR was not likely to be due to end-product inhibition of photosynthesis. It is suggested that in P. major , a rosette plant, self-shading causes a decline in photosynthesis and results in an increase in the shoot: root ratio and a decrease in RGR. CO₂-enriched plants grow faster and cosequently suffer more from self-shading. Corrected for this ontogenetic drift, high CO₂ concentrations stimulated the RGR of P. major throughout the entire experiment.     

Coppicing shifts CO2 stimulation of poplar productivity to above-ground pools: a synthesis of leaf to stand level results from the POP/EUROFACE experiment

A poplar short rotation coppice (SRC) grown for the production of bioenergy can combine carbon (C) storage with fossil fuel substitution. Here, we summarize the responses of a poplar ( Populus ) plantation to 6 yr of free air CO₂ enrichment (POP/EUROFACE consisting of two rotation cycles). We show that a poplar plantation growing in nonlimiting light, nutrient and water conditions will significantly increase its productivity in elevated CO₂ concentrations ([CO₂]). Increased biomass yield resulted from an early growth enhancement and photosynthesis did not acclimate to elevated [CO₂]. Sufficient nutrient availability, increased nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) and the large sink capacity of poplars contributed to the sustained increase in C uptake over 6 yr. Additional C taken up in high [CO₂] was mainly invested into woody biomass pools. Coppicing increased yield by 66% and partly shifted the extra C uptake in elevated [CO₂] to above-ground pools, as fine root biomass declined and its [CO₂] stimulation disappeared. Mineral soil C increased equally in ambient and elevated [CO₂] during the 6 yr experiment. However, elevated [CO₂] increased the stabilization of C in the mineral soil. Increased productivity of a poplar SRC in elevated [CO₂] may allow shorter rotation cycles, enhancing the viability of SRC for biofuel production.     

Effects of source-sink relations on photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO2

Abstract. While photosynthesis of C₃ plants is stimulated by an increase in the atmospheric CO₂ concentration, photosynthetic capacity is often reduced after long-term exposure to elevated CO₂. This reduction appears to be brought about by end product inhibition, resulting from an imbalance in the supply and demand of carbohydrates. A review of the literature revealed that the reduction of photosynthetic capacity in elevated CO₂ was most pronounced when the increased supply of carbohydrates was combined with small sink size. The volume of pots in which plants were grown affected the sink size by restricting root growth. While plants grown in small pots had a reduced photosynthetic capacity, plants grown in the field showed no reduction or an increase in this capacity. Pot volume also determined the effect of elevated CO₂ on the root/shoot ratio: the root/shoot ratio increased when root growth was not restricted and decreased in plants grown in small pots. The data presented in this paper suggest that plants growing in the field will maintain a high photosynthetic capacity as the atmospheric CO₂ level continues to rise.     

Increased photosynthetic capacity of Scirpus olneyi after 4 years of exposure to elevated CO2

Abstract. While a short-term exposure to elevated atmospheric CO₂ induces a large increase in photosynthesis in many plants, long-term growth in elevated CO₂ often results in a smaller increase due to reduced photosynthetic capacity. In this study, it was shown that, for a wild C₃ species growing in its natural environment and exposed to elevated CO₂ for four growing seasons, the photosynthetic capacity has actually increased by 31%. An increase in photosynthetic capacity has been observed in other species growing in the field, which suggests that photosynthesis of certain field grown plants will continue to respond to elevated levels of atmospheric CO₂     

Biomass Production and Carbohydrate Content of Arabidopsis thaliana at Atmospheric CO2 Concentrations from 390 to 1680 μl l-1

Abstract: The concentration dependency of the impact of elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations on Arabidopsis thaliana L. was studied. Plants were exposed to nearly ambient (390), 560, 810, 1240 and 1680 μl I^-1 CO₂ during the vegetative growth phase for 8 days. Shoot biomass production and dry matter content were increased upon exposure to elevated CO₂. Maximal increase in shoot fresh and dry weight was obtained at 560 μl I^-1 CU₂, which was due to a transient stimulation of the relative growth rate for up to 3 days. The shoot starch content increased with increasing CO₂ concentrations up to two-fold at 1680 μl I^-1 CO₂, whereas the contents of soluble sugars and phenolic compounds were hardly affected by elevated CO₂. The chlorophyll and carotenoid contents were not substantially affected at elevated CO₂ and the chlorophyll a/b ratio remained unaltered. There was no acclimation of photosynthesis at elevated CO₂; the photosynthetic capacity of leaves, which had completely developed at elevated CO₂ was similar to that of leaves developed in ambient air. The possible consequences of an elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration to Arabidopsis thaliana in its natural habitat is discussed.     

Carbon and water fluxes in a calcareous grassland under elevated CO2

1. As part of a long-term study of the effects of elevated CO₂ on biodiversity and ecosystem function in a calcareous grassland, we measured ecosystem carbon dioxide and water-vapour fluxes over 24-h periods during the 1994 and 1995 growing seasons. Data were used to derive CO₂ and H₂O gas-exchange response functions to quantum flux density (QFD).
2. The relative increase in net ecosystem CO₂ flux (NEC) owing to CO₂ enrichment increased as QFD rose. Daytime NEC at high QFD under elevated CO₂ increased by 25% to 60%, with the greatest increases in the spring and after mowing in June when above-ground biomass was lowest. There was much less stimulation of NEC in early June and again in October when the canopy was fully developed. Night-time NEC was not significantly altered under elevated CO₂.
3. Short-term reversal of CO₂ concentrations between treatments after two seasons of CO₂ exposure provided evidence for a 50% downward adjustment of NEC expressed per unit above-ground plant dry weight. However, when expressed on a land area basis, this difference disappeared because of a c. 20% increase in above-ground biomass under elevated CO₂.
4. Ecosystem evapotranspiration (ET) was not significantly altered by elevated CO₂ when averaged over all measurement dates and positions. However, ET was reduced 3–18% at high QFD in plots at the top of the slope at our study site. In summary, CO₂ enrichment resulted in a large stimulation of ecosystem CO₂ capture, especially during periods of a large demand of carbon in relationship to its supply, and resulted in a relatively small and variable effect on ecosystem water consumption.     

Adaptation to high CO2 concentration in an optimal environment: radiation capture, canopy quantum yield and carbon use efficiency

The effect of elevated [CO₂] on wheat (Triticum aestivum L. Veery 10) productivity was examined by analysing radiation capture, canopy quantum yield, canopy carbon use efficiency, harvest index and daily C gain. Canopies were grown at either 330 or 1200 μ mol mol^–1[CO₂] in controlled environments, where root and shoot C fluxes were monitored continuously from emergence to harvest. A rapidly circulating hydroponic solution supplied nutrients, water and root zone oxygen. At harvest, dry mass predicted from gas exchange data was 102·8 ± 4·7% of the observed dry mass in six trials. Neither radiation capture efficiency nor carbon use efficiency were affected by elevated [CO₂], but yield increased by 13% due to a sustained increase in canopy quantum yield. CO₂ enrichment increased root mass, tiller number and seed mass. Harvest index and chlorophyll concentration were unchanged, but CO₂ enrichment increased average life cycle net photosynthesis (13%, P < 0·05) and root respiration (24%, P < 0·05). These data indicate that plant communities adapt to CO₂ enrichment through changes in C allocation. Elevated [CO₂] increases sink strength in optimal environments, resulting in sustained increases in photosynthetic capacity, canopy quantum yield and daily C gain throughout the life cycle.     

Interaction of elevated CO2 and O3 on growth, photosynthesis and respiration of three perennial species grown in low and high nitrogen

Seedlings of three species native to central North America, a C₃ tree, Populus tremuloides Michx., a C₃ grass, Agropyron smithii Rybd., and a C₄ grass, Bouteloua curtipendula Michx., were grown in all eight combinations of two levels each of CO₂, O₃ and nitrogen (N) for 58 days in a controlled environment. Treatment levels consisted of 360 or 674 μmol mol^-1 CO₂, 3 or 92 nmol mol^-1 O₃, and 0.5 or 6.0 m M N. In situ photosynthesis and relative growth rate (RGR) and its determinants were obtained at each of three sequential harvests, and leaf dark respiration was measured at the second and third harvests. In all three species, plants grown in high N had significantly greater whole-plant mass, RGR and photosynthesis than plants grown in low N. Within a N treatment, elevated CO₂ did not significantly enhance any of these parameters nor did it affect leaf respiration. However, plants of all three species grown in elevated CO₂ had lower stomatal conductance compared to ambient CO₂-exposed plants. Seedlings of P. tremuloides (in both N treatments) and B. curtipendula (in high N) had significant ozone-induced reductions in whole-plant mass and RGR in ambient but not under elevated CO_2. This negative O₃ impact on RGR in ambient CO₂ was related to increased leaf dark respiration, decreased photosynthesis and/or decreased leaf area ratio, none of which were noted in high O₃ treatments in the elevated CO₂ environment. In contrast, A. smithii was marginally negatively affected by high O_3.     

Interactive effects of elevated [CO2] and drought on cherry (Prunus avium) seedlings I. Growth, whole-plant water use efficiency and water loss

Seeds of cherry ( Prunus avium ) were germinated and grown for two growing seasons in ambient (∼350 μmol mol⁻¹) or elevated (ambient+∼350 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ mole fractions in six open-top chambers. The seedlings were fertilized once a week, following Ingestad principles in order to supply mineral nutrients at free-access rates. In the first growing season gradual drought was imposed on rapidly growing cherry seedlings by withholding water for a 6-wk drying cycle. In the second growing season, the rapid onset of drought was imposed at the height of the growing season on the seedlings which had already experienced drought in the first growing season. Elevated [CO₂] significantly increased total dry-mass production in both water regimes, but did not ameliorate the growth response to drought of the cherry seedlings subjected to two sequential drying cycles. Water loss did not differ in either well watered or droughted seedlings between elevated and ambient [CO₂]; consequently whole-plant water- use efficiency (the ratio of total dry mass produced to total water consumption) was significantly increased. Similar patterns of carbon allocation between shoot and root were found in elevated and ambient [CO₂] when the seedlings were the same size. Thus, elevated [CO₂] did not improve drought tolerance, but it accelerated ontogenetic development irrespective of water status.     

Exposure to preindustrial, current and future atmospheric CO2 and temperature differentially affects growth and photosynthesis in Eucalyptus

To investigate if Eucalyptus species have responded to industrial-age climate change, and how they may respond to a future climate, we measured growth and physiology of fast- ( E. saligna ) and slow-growing ( E. sideroxylon ) seedlings exposed to preindustrial (290), current (400) or projected (650 μL L⁻¹) CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) and to current or projected (current +4 °C) temperature. To evaluate maximum potential treatment responses, plants were grown with nonlimiting soil moisture. We found that: (1) E. sideroxylon responded more strongly to elevated [CO₂] than to elevated temperature, while E. saligna responded similarly to elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature; (2) the transition from preindustrial to current [CO₂] did not enhance eucalypt plant growth under ambient temperature, despite enhancing photosynthesis; (3) the transition from current to future [CO₂] stimulated both photosynthesis and growth of eucalypts, independent of temperature; and (4) warming enhanced eucalypt growth, independent of future [CO₂], despite not affecting photosynthesis. These results suggest large potential carbon sequestration by eucalypts in a future world, and highlight the need to evaluate how future water availability may affect such responses.     

Growth in elevated CO2 enhances temperature response of photosynthesis in wheat

The temperature dependence of C₃ photosynthesis may be altered by the growth environment. The effects of long-term growth in elevated CO₂ on photosynthesis temperature response have been investigated in wheat ( Triticum aestivum L.) grown in controlled chambers with 370 or 700 μmol mol⁻¹ CO₂ from sowing through to anthesis. Gas exchange was measured in flag leaves at ear emergence, and the parameters of a biochemical photosynthesis model were determined along with their temperature responses. Elevated CO₂ slightly decreased the CO₂ compensation point and increased the rate of respiration in the light and ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) V_cmax, although the latter effect was reversed at 15°C. With elevated CO₂, J_max decreased in the 15–25°C temperature range and increased at 30 and 35°C. The temperature response (activation energy) of V_cmax and J_max increased with growth in elevated CO₂. CO₂ enrichment decreased the ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP)-limited photosynthesis rates at lower temperatures and increased Rubisco- and RuBP-limited rates at higher temperatures. The results show that the photosynthesis temperature response is enhanced by growth in elevated CO₂. We conclude that if temperature acclimation and factors such as nutrients or water availability do not modify or negate this enhancement, the effects of future increases in air CO₂ on photosynthetic electron transport and Rubisco kinetics may improve the photosynthetic response of wheat to global warming.     

Ecophysiological responses to simulated canopy gaps of two tree species of contrasting shade tolerance in elevated CO2

1. One-year-old seedlings of shade tolerant Acer rubrum and intolerant Betula papyrifera were grown in ambient and twice ambient (elevated) CO₂, and in full sun and 80% shade for 90 days. The shaded seedlings received 30-min sun patches twice during the course of the day. Gas exchange and tissue–water relations were measured at midday in the sun plants and following 20 min of exposure to full sun in the shade plants to determine the effect of elevated CO₂ on constraints to sun-patch utilization in these species.
2. Elevated CO₂ had the largest stimulation of photosynthesis in B. papyrifera sun plants and A. rubrum shade plants.
3. Higher photosynthesis per unit leaf area in sun plants than in shade plants of B. papyrifera was largely owing to differences in leaf morphology. Acer rubrum exhibited sun/shade differences in photosynthesis per unit leaf mass consistent with biochemical acclimation to shade.
4. Betula papyrifera exhibited CO₂ responses that would facilitate tolerance to leaf water deficits in large sun patches, including osmotic adjustment and higher transpiration and stomatal conductance at a given leaf-water potential, whereas A. rubrum exhibited large increases in photosynthetic nitrogen-use efficiency.
5. Results suggest that species of contrasting successional ranks respond differently to elevated CO₂, in ways that are consistent with the habitats in which they typically occur.     

Elevated atmospheric CO2 influences the interaction between the parasitic angiosperm Orobanche minor and its host Trifolium repens

The influence of the root holoparasitic angiosperm Orobanche minor Sm. on the biomass, photosynthesis, carbohydrate and nitrogen content of Trifolium repens L. was determined for plants grown at two CO₂ concentrations (350 and 550 μmol mol⁻¹). Infected plants accumulated less biomass than their uninfected counterparts, although early in the association there was a transient stimulation of growth. Infection also influenced biomass allocation both between tissues (infected plants had lower root:shoot ratios) and within tissues:infected roots were considerably thicker before the point of parasite attachment and thinner below. Higher concentrations of starch were also found in roots above the point of attachment, particularly for plants grown in elevated CO₂. Elevated CO₂ stimulated the growth of T. repens only during the early stages of development. There was a significant interaction between infection and CO₂ on growth, with infected plants showing a greater response, such that elevated CO₂ partly alleviated the effects of the parasite on host growth. Elevated CO₂ did not affect total O. minor biomass per host, the number of individual parasites supported by each host, or their time of attachment to the host root system. Photosynthesis was stimulated by elevated CO₂ but was unaffected by O. minor . There was no evidence of down-regulation of photosynthesis in T. repens grown at elevated CO₂ in either infected or uninfected plants. The data are discussed with regard to the influence of elevated CO₂ on other parasitic angiosperm-host associations and factors which control plant responses to elevated CO₂.     

Effects of intermittent exposure to high atmospheric CO2 on vegetative growth in soybean

Short-term exposure to high CO₂ increases rates of photosynthesis and growth in soybeans, but with prolonged high CO₂ exposure, these high rates are sometimes not maintained. Growth of soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merrill cv. Fiskeby V) seedlings kept for 25 days at atmospheres of 350 or 1000 μ/l CO₂ was compared with growth of plants given 2, 4 or 6 day alternating exposure to high and low CO₂ levels (13 days of total exposure to each level). Final dry weight of plants increased with number of days in high CO₂ but leaf areas were not greatly affected. Thus dry weight gains per unit leaf area (net assimilation rates) were higher in high CO₂ than in low CO₂ throughout the entire period of the experiment and the pattern of exposure to high CO₂ did not affect the rate of dry weight gain in high CO₂.     

Effects of elevated CO2 concentration on photosynthesis, respiration and carbohydrate status of coppice Populus hybrids

To determine how increased atmospheric CO₂ will affect the physiology of coppiced plants, sprouts originating from two hybrid poplar clones ( Populus trichocarpa × P. deltoides - Beaupre and P. deltoides × P. nigra - Robusta) were grown in open-top chambers containing ambient or elevated (ambient + 360 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ concentration. The effects of elevated CO₂ concentration on leaf photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, dark respiration, carbohydrate concentration and nitrogen concentration were measured. Furthermore, dark respiration of leaves was partitioned into growth and maintenance components by regressing specific respiration rate vs specific growth rate. Sprouts of both clones exposed to CO₂ enrichment showed no indication of photosynthetic down-regulation. During reciprocal gas exchange measurements, CO₂ enrichment significantly increased photosynthesis of all sprouts by approximately 60% ( P < 0.01) on both an early and late season sampling date, decreased stomatal conductance of all sprouts by 10% ( P < 0.04) on the early sampling date and nonsignificantly decreased dark respiration by an average of 11%. Growth under elevated CO₂ had no consistent effect on foliar sugar concentration but significantly increased foliar starch by 80%. Respiration rate was highly correlated with both specific growth rate and percent nitrogen. Long-term CO₂ enrichment did not significantly affect the maintenance respiration coefficient or the growth respiration coefficient. Carbon dioxide enrichment affected the physiology of the sprouts the same way it affected these plants before they were coppiced.     

In situ responses to elevated CO2 in tropical forest understorey plants

1. Plants growing in deep shade and high temperature, such as in the understorey of humid tropical forests, have been predicted to be particularly sensitive to rising atmospheric CO₂. We tested this hypothesis in five species whose microhabitat quantum flux density (QFD) was documented as a covariable. After 7 (tree seedlings of Tachigalia versicolor and Beilschmiedia pendula ) and 18 months (shrubs Piper cordulatum and Psychotria limonensis, and grass Pharus latifolius ) of elevated CO₂ treatment ( c. 700 μl litre^–1) under mean QFD of less than 11 μmol m^–2 s^–1, all species produced more biomass (25–76%) under elevated CO₂.
2. Total plant biomass tended to increase with microhabitat QFD (daytime means varying from 5 to 11μmol m^–2 s^–1) but the relative stimulation by elevated CO₂ was higher at low QFD except in Pharus .
3. Non-structural carbohydrate concentrations in leaves increased significantly in Pharus (+ 27%) and Tachigalia (+ 40%).
4. The data support the hypothesis that tropical plants growing near the photosynthetic light compensation point are responsive to elevated CO₂. An improved plant carbon balance in deep shade is likely to influence understorey plant recruitment and competition as atmospheric CO₂ continues to rise.