Molecular modeling of the three-dimensional structure of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P), an enzyme involved in tRNA maturation, consists of a catalytic RNA subunit and a protein cofactor. Comparative phylogenetic analysis and molecular modeling have been employed to derive secondary and tertiary structure models of the RNA subunits from Escherichia coli (type A) and Bacillus subtilis (type B) RNase P. The tertiary structure of the protein subunit of B.subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus RNase P has recently been determined. However, an understanding of the structure of the RNase P holoenzyme (i.e. the ribonucleoprotein complex) is lacking. We have now used an EDTA-Fe-based footprinting approach to generate information about RNA-protein contact sites in E.coli RNase P. The footprinting data, together with results from other biochemical and biophysical studies, have furnished distance constraints, which in turn have enabled us to build three-dimensional models of both type A and B versions of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme in the absence and presence of its precursor tRNA substrate. These models are consistent with results from previous studies and provide both structural and mechanistic insights into the functioning of this unique catalytic RNP complex.     

Function of heterologous and truncated RNase P proteins in Bacillus subtilis

Bacterial RNase P is composed of an RNA subunit and a single protein (encoded by the rnpB and rnpA genes respectively). The Bacillus subtilis rnpA knockdown strain d7 was used to screen for functional conservation among bacterial RNase P proteins from a representative spectrum of bacterial subphyla. We demonstrate conserved function of bacterial RNase P (RnpA) proteins despite low sequence conservation. Even rnpA genes from psychrophilic and thermophilic bacteria rescued growth of B. subtilis d7 bacteria; likewise, terminal extensions and insertions between beta strands 2 and 3, in the so-called metal binding loop, were compatible with RnpA function in B. subtilis. A deletion analysis of B. subtilis RnpA defined the structural elements essential for bacterial RNase P function in vivo. We further extended our complementation analysis in B. subtilis strain d7 to the four individual RNase P protein subunits from three different Archaea, as well as to human Rpp21 and Rpp29 as representatives of eukaryal RNase P. None of these non-bacterial RNase P proteins showed any evidence of being able to replace the B. subtilis RNase P protein in vivo, supporting the notion that archaeal/eukaryal RNase P proteins are evolutionary unrelated to the bacterial RnpA protein.     

Probing the architecture of the B. subtilis RNase P holoenzyme active site by cross-linking and affinity cleavage

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein complex composed of one catalytic RNA (PRNA) and one protein subunit (P protein) that together catalyze the 5' maturation of precursor tRNA. High-resolution X-ray crystal structures of the individual P protein and PRNA components from several species have been determined, and structural models of the RNase P holoenzyme have been proposed. However, holoenzyme models have been limited by a lack of distance constraints between P protein and PRNA in the holoenzyme-substrate complex. Here, we report the results of extensive cross-linking and affinity cleavage experiments using single-cysteine P protein variants derivatized with either azidophenacyl bromide or 5-iodoacetamido-1,10-o-phenanthroline to determine distance constraints and to model the Bacillus subtilis holoenzyme-substrate complex. These data indicate that the evolutionarily conserved RNR motif of P protein is located near (<15 Angstroms) the pre-tRNA cleavage site, the base of the pre-tRNA acceptor stem and helix P4 of PRNA, the putative active site of the enzyme. In addition, the metal binding loop and N-terminal region of the P protein are proximal to the P3 stem-loop of PRNA. Studies using heterologous holoenzymes composed of covalently modified B. subtilis P protein and Escherichia coli M1 RNA indicate that P protein binds similarly to both RNAs. Together, these data indicate that P protein is positioned close to the RNase P active site and may play a role in organizing the RNase P active site.     

Bacterial RNase P: a new view of an ancient enzyme

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ubiquitous endonuclease that catalyses the maturation of the 5' end of transfer RNA (tRNA). Although it carries out a biochemically simple reaction, RNase P is a complex ribonucleoprotein particle composed of a single large RNA and at least one protein component. In bacteria and some archaea, the RNA component of RNase P can catalyse tRNA maturation in vitro in the absence of proteins. The discovery of the catalytic activity of the bacterial RNase P RNA triggered numerous mechanistic and biochemical studies of the reactions catalysed by the RNA alone and by the holoenzyme and, in recent years, structures of individual components of the RNase P holoenzyme have been determined. The goal of the present review is to summarize what is known about the bacterial RNase P, and to bring together the recent structural results with extensive earlier biochemical and phylogenetic findings.     

Specific phosphorothioate substitutions probe the active site of Bacillus subtilis ribonuclease P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein that requires magnesium ions to catalyze the 5' maturation of transfer RNA. To identify interactions essential for catalysis, the properties of RNase P containing single sulfur substitutions for nonbridging phosphodiester oxygens in helix P4 of Bacillus subtilis RNase P were analyzed using transient kinetic experiments. Sulfur substitution at the nonbridging oxygens of the phosphodiester bond of nucleotide U51 only modestly affects catalysis. However, phosphorothioate substitutions at A49 and G50 decrease the cleavage rate constant enormously (300-4,000-fold for P RNA and 500-15,000-fold for RNase P holoenzyme) in magnesium without affecting the affinity of pre-tRNA(Asp), highlighting the importance of this region for catalysis. Furthermore, addition of manganese enhances pre-tRNA cleavage catalyzed by B. subtilis RNase P RNA containing an Sp phosphorothioate modification at A49, as observed for Escherichia coli P RNA [Christian et al., RNA, 2000, 6:511-519], suggesting that an essential metal ion may be coordinated at this site. In contrast, no manganese rescue is observed for the A49 Sp phosphorothioate modification in RNase P holoenzyme. These differential manganese rescue effects, along with affinity cleavage, suggest that the protein component may interact with a metal ion bound near A49 in helix P4 of P RNA.     

Characterization in vitro of the defect in a temperature-sensitive mutant of the protein subunit of RNase P from Escherichia coli.

We have studied the assembly of Escherichia coli RNase P from its catalytic RNA subunit (M1 RNA) and its protein subunit (C5 protein). A mutant form of the protein subunit, C5A49, has been purified to apparent homogeneity from a strain of E. coli carrying a thermosensitive mutation in the rnpA gene. The heat inactivation kinetics of both wild-type and mutant holoenzymes are similar, an indication of equivalent thermal stability. However, when the catalytic efficiencies of the holoenzymes were compared, we found that the holoenzyme containing the mutant protein had a lower efficiency of cleavage than the wild-type holoenzyme at 33, 37, and 44 degrees C. We then explored the interaction of M1 RNA and C5 protein during the assembly of the holoenzyme. The yield of active holoenzyme obtained by reconstitution with wild-type M1 RNA and C5A49 protein in vitro can be considerably enhanced by the addition of excess M1 RNA, just as it can be in vivo. We concluded that the Arg-46----His-46 mutation in the C5A49 protein affects the ability of the protein to participate with M1 RNA in the normal assembly process of RNase P.     

RNase P of the Cyanophora paradoxa cyanelle: a plastid ribozyme

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein enzyme that generates the mature 5' ends of tRNAs. Ubiquitous across all three kingdoms of life, the composition and functional contributions of the RNA and protein components of RNase P differ between the kingdoms. RNA-alone catalytic activity has been reported throughout bacteria, but only for some archaea, and only as trace activity for eukarya. Available information for RNase P from photosynthetic organelles points to large differences to bacterial as well as to eukaryotic RNase P: for spinach chloroplasts, protein-alone activity has been discussed; for RNase P from the cyanelle of the glaucophyte Cyanophora paradoxa, a type of organelle sharing properties of both cyanobacteria and chloroplasts, the proportion of protein was found to be around 80% rather than the usual 10% in bacteria. Furthermore, the latter RNase P was previously found catalytically inactive in the absence of protein under a variety of conditions; however, the RNA could be activated by a cyanobacterial protein, but not by the bacterial RNase P protein from Escherichia coli. Here we demonstrate that, under very high enzyme concentrations, the RNase P RNA from the cyanelle of C. paradoxa displays RNA-alone activity well above the detection level. Moreover, the RNA can be complemented to a functional holoenzyme by the E. coli RNase P protein, further supporting its overall bacterial-like architecture. Mutational analysis and domain swaps revealed that this A,U-rich cyanelle RNase P RNA is globally optimized but conformationally unstable, since changes as little as a single point mutation or a base pair identity switch at positions that are not part of the universally conserved catalytic core led to a complete loss of RNA-alone activity. Likely related to this low robustness, extensive structural changes towards an E. coli-type P5-7/P15-17 subdomain as a canonical interaction site for tRNA 3'-CCA termini could not be coaxed into increased ribozyme activity.     

An essential protein-binding domain of nuclear RNase P RNA

Eukaryotic RNase P and RNase MRP are endoribonucleases composed of RNA and protein subunits. The RNA subunits of each enzyme share substantial secondary structural features, and most of the protein subunits are shared between the two. One of the conserved RNA subdomains, designated P3, has previously been shown to be required for nucleolar localization. Phylogenetic sequence analysis suggests that the P3 domain interacts with one of the proteins common to RNase P and RNase MRP, a conclusion strengthened by an earlier observation that the essential domain can be interchanged between the two enzymes. To examine possible functions of the P3 domain, four conserved nucleotides in the P3 domain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNase P RNA (RPR1) were randomized to create a library of all possible sequence combinations at those positions. Selection of functional genes in vivo identified permissible variations, and viable clones that caused yeast to exhibit conditional growth phenotypes were tested for defects in RNase P RNA and tRNA biosynthesis. Under nonpermissive conditions, the mutants had reduced maturation of the RPR1 RNA precursor, an expected phenotype in cases where RNase P holoenzyme assembly is defective. This loss of RPR1 RNA maturation coincided, as expected, with a loss of pre-tRNA maturation characteristic of RNase P defects. To test whether mutations at the conserved positions inhibited interactions with a particular protein, specific binding of the individual protein subunits to the RNA subunit was tested in yeast using the three-hybrid system. Pop1p, the largest subunit shared by RNases P and MRP, bound specifically to RPR1 RNA and the isolated P3 domain, and this binding was eliminated by mutations at the conserved P3 residues. These results indicate that Pop1p interacts with the P3 domain common to RNases P and MRP, and that this interaction is critical in the maturation of RNase P holoenzyme.     

Mapping RNA-protein interactions in ribonuclease P from Escherichia coli using disulfide-linked EDTA-Fe

The protein subunit of Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (which has a cysteine residue at position 113) and its single cysteine-substituted mutant derivatives (S16C/C113S, K54C/C113S and K66C/C113S) have been modified using a sulfhydryl-specific iron complex of EDTA-2- aminoethyl 2-pyridyl disulfide (EPD-Fe). This reaction converts C5 protein, or its single cysteine-substituted mutant derivatives, into chemical nucleases which are capable of cleaving the cognate RNA ligand, M1 RNA, the catalytic RNA subunit of E. coli RNase P, in the presence of ascorbate and hydrogen peroxide. Cleavages in M1 RNA are expected to occur at positions proximal to the site of contact between the modified residue (in C5 protein) and the ribose units in M1 RNA. When EPD-Fe was used to modify residue Cys16 in C5 protein, hydroxyl radical-mediated cleavages occurred predominantly in the P3 helix of M1 RNA present in the reconstituted holoenzyme. C5 Cys54-EDTA-Fe produced cleavages on the 5' strand of the P4 pseudoknot of M1 RNA, while the cleavages promoted by C5 Cys66-EDTA-Fe were in the loop connecting helices P18 and P2 (J18/2) and the loop (J2/4) preceding the 3' strand of the P4 pseudoknot. However, hydroxyl radical-mediated cleavages in M1 RNA were not evident with Cys113-EDTA-Fe, perhaps indicative of Cys113 being distal from the RNA-protein interface in the RNase P holoenzyme. Our directed hydroxyl radical-mediated footprinting experiments indicate that conserved residues in the RNA and protein subunit of the RNase-P holoenzyme are adjacent to each other and provide structural information essential for understanding the assembly of RNase P.     

The Ribonuclease P database.

The Ribonuclease P Sequence database is a compilation of RNase P sequences, sequence alignments, secondary structures, three-dimensional models, and accessory information. In its initial form, the database contains information on RNase P RNA in bacteria and archaea, and RNase P protein in bacteria. The sequences themselves are presented phylogenetically ordered and aligned. The database also contains secondary structures of bacterial and archaeal RNAs, including specially annotated 'reference' secondary structures of Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis RNase P RNAs, a minimum phylogenetic consensus structure, and coordinates for models of three-dimensional structure.     

Partial characterization of an RNA component that copurifies with Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNase P.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae cellular RNase P is composed of both protein and RNA components that are essential for activity. The isolated holoenzyme contains a highly structured RNA of 369 nucleotides that has extensive sequence similarities to the 286-nucleotide RNA associated with Schizosaccharomyces pombe RNase P but bears little resemblance to the analogous RNA sequences in procaryotes or S. cerevisiae mitochondria. Even so, the predicted secondary structure of S. cerevisiae RNA is strikingly similar to the bacterial phylogenetic consensus rather than to previously predicted structures of other eucaryotic RNase P RNAs.     

The 5' leader of precursor tRNAAsp bound to the Bacillus subtilis RNase P holoenzyme has an extended conformation

RNase P catalyzes the 5' maturation of transfer RNA (tRNA). RNase P from Bacillus subtilis comprises a large RNA component (130 kDa, P RNA) and a small protein subunit (14 kDa, P protein). Although P RNA alone can efficiently catalyze the maturation reaction in vitro, P protein is strictly required under physiological conditions. We have used time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer on a series of donor-labeled substrates and two acceptor-labeled P proteins to determine the conformation of the pre-tRNA 5' leader relative to the protein in the holoenzyme-pre-tRNA complex. The resulting distance distribution measurements indicate that the leader binds to the holoenzyme in an extended conformation between nucleotides 3 and 7. The conformational mobility of nucleotides 5-8 in the leader is reduced, providing further evidence that these nucleotides interact with the holoenzyme. The increased fluorescence intensity and lifetime of the 5'-fluorescein label of these leaders indicate a more hydrophobic environment, consistent with the notion that such interactions occur with the central cleft of the P protein. Taken together, our data support a model where the P protein binds to the 5' leader between the fourth and seventh nucleotides upstream of the cleavage site, extending the leader and decreasing its structural dynamics. Thus, P protein acts as a wedge to separate the 5' from the 3' terminus of the pre-tRNA and to position the cleavage site in the catalytic core. These results reveal a structural basis for the P protein dependent discrimination between precursor and mature tRNAs.     

Eukaryotic ribonuclease P: increased complexity to cope with the nuclear pre-tRNA pathway

Ribonuclease P is an ancient enzyme that cleaves pre-tRNAs to generate mature 5' ends. It contains an essential RNA subunit in Bacteria, Archaea, and Eukarya, but the degree to which the RNA subunit relies on proteins to supplement catalysis is highly variable. The eukaryotic nuclear holoenzyme has recently been found to contain almost twenty times the protein content of the bacterial enzymes, in addition to having split into at least two related enzymes with distinct substrate specificity. In this review, recent progress in understanding the molecular architecture and functions of nuclear forms of RNase P will be considered.     

Activation of bacterial ribonuclease P by macrolides

The effect of macrolide antibiotic spiramycin on RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA from Escherichia coli was investigated. Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribozyme that is responsible for the maturation of 5' termini of tRNA molecules. Spiramycin revealed a dose-dependent activation on pre-tRNA cleavage by E. coli RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA. The K s and V max, as well as the K s(app) and V max(app) values of RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA in the presence or absence of spiramycin, were calculated from primary and secondary kinetic plots. It was found that the activity status of RNase P holoenzyme and M1 RNA is improved by the presence of spiramycin 18- and 12-fold, respectively. Primer extension analysis revealed that spiramycin induces a conformational change of the P10/11 structural element of M1 RNA, which is involved in substrate recognition.     

Expression, purification and characterization of the recombinant ribonuclease P protein component from Bacillus subtilis.

Ribonuclease P is a ribonucleoprotein complex that catalyzes the essential 5' maturation of all precursor tRNA molecules. The protein component both alters the conformation of the RNA component and enhances the substrate affinity and specificity. To facilitate biochemical and biophysical studies, the protein component of Bacillus subtilis ribonuclease P (RNase P) was overproduced in Escherichia coli using the native amino acid sequence with the initial 20 codons optimized for expression in E.coli . A simple purification procedure using consecutive cation exchange chromatography steps in the presence and absence of urea was developed to purify large quantities of P protein without contaminating nucleic acids. The identity of the recombinant protein as a cofactor of RNase P was established by its ability to stimulate the activity of the RNA component in low ionic strength buffer in a 1:1 stoichiometry. Circular dichroism studies indicate that P protein is a combination of alpha-helix and beta-sheet secondary structures and is quite stable, with a T m of 67 degrees C. The described methods facilitated the large scale purification of homogeneous, RNA-free P protein required for high resolution crystallographic analyses and may be useful for the preparation of other RNA binding proteins.