Browsing impact of large herbivores on Acacia xanthophloea Benth in Lake Nakuru National Park, Kenya

Significant differences ( P <0.05) were found in growth of plant height, canopy cover and stem diameter of Acacia xanthophloea trees in fenced plot as compared with unfenced plot both in the wet and in the dry seasons. Finding of this study showed that although heavy browsing reduced the height and canopy of trees, it did not kill any trees and seedling regeneration took place simultaneously. Despite the presence of large herbivores that impact some considerable browsing pressure results indicate that the A. xanthophloea habitat type would continue to remain in balance in the presence of recruitment of seedlings and saplings. The conditions at the time of study indicate that the browsing on A. xanthophloea was not significant and was not serious enough to warrant management intervention at present.     

Influence supplementary feeding on bark browsing by red deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cervus elaphus</Emphasis>) under experimental conditions

The effect of various supplementary feeds on bark browsing was studied in red deer under controlled conditions. Fifteen female red deer were randomly assigned to five dietary treatments (n = 3 animals each): meadow hay as a control (C), combinations of meadow hay with grass silage (GS), maize silage (MS), maize silage with oats (MSO) or a pelleted concentrate (PC). The deer were kept in enclosures where we offered fresh spruce stems daily. The experiment consisted of two periods. In the first period (A), the animals had free access to food during 24 h, while in the second period (B), the access was restricted to night hours only. In both periods, the supplementary feeds were available ad libitum. Mean daily consumption of browsed bark in the control group in period A was 1,053 g while in the remaining groups it ranged from six to 20 g. In period B, simulating the conditions in disturbed hunting areas, bark consumption in all groups increased considerably, the highest increase being found in groups GS (430 vs. 19 g/day) and MS (101 vs. 6 g/day). In period A, the highest dry matter (DM) intake including browse was found in group MS (2,816 g/day) and the lowest one in group GS (2,307 g/day). In period B, the highest (2,763 g/day) and the lowest (2,153 g/day) DM intake was observed in groups PC and MSO, respectively. If red deer is fed supplementary, meadow hay should be combined with maize silage, grass silage or concentrate to reduce bark browsing in forests. The bark browsing rate may increase considerably if red deer are disturbed or their grazing cycle is impaired.     

Vegetation changes during a 36-year period in northern Chobe National Park, Botswana

Changes in vegetation cover in northern Chobe National Park (Botswana) were assessed using aerial photographs from 1962, 1985 and 1998, with subsequent ground proofing. In addition, cumulative browsing by elephants and the occurrence of fire scars were recorded on random vegetation sites within shrubland (n = 20) and mixed woodland (n = 20). Coverage of woodland vegetation decreased from 60% to 30% between 1962 and 1998, while shrubland vegetation increased from 5% to 33% during the same period. During the study period, woodland has gradually retreated away from the river front. While riparian forest covered a continuous area along the riverfront in 1962, only fragments were left in 1998. We found a significant decrease in browse use with increasing distance to the Chobe river for Combretum apiculatum, Combretum elaeagnoides, Combretum mossambicense and other woody plants combined (all P < 0.0001). The occurrence of fire (P < 0.0001) and basal area (P < 0.0001) were positively related to distance to the river. Elephant browsing occurred on >70% of available stems within 2 km from the river, while less than 20% of the trees had fire scars in the same zone. Beyond 7 km from the river, elephant browsing was reduced to >50% of available stems, while more than 50% of the trees had fire scars. The density of any of the shrubs was not related to distance to the river neither within shrubland (all P > 0.05) nor within mixed woodlands (all P > 0.05).     

Impact on plant communities by white-tailed deer in Mississippi,USA

Background: The abundance of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) in the eastern United States has escalated during the twentieth century, potentially impacting plant communities.

Methods: We measured understorey plant cover and biomass five years after excluding deer from mature forests of three ecological regions in Mississippi, USA. We extended the significance of P values to 0.10 to detect developing impacts.

Results: Deer impacts were limited and varied by ecological region. We recorded 151 species in cover transects. Consistent exclosure treatment effects were detected in two regions where there was greater cover of two deer forages and less cover of three non-forages. Species richness was greater in exclosures in one region, but otherwise species richness and diversity indices did not differ. We recorded 127 species in biomass quadrats. Exclosure treatment effects on biomass were inconsistent. Out of five species with significant differences, three had more biomass in controls, including two deer forages. Except for greater total biomass in controls of one region, there were no differences by growth form or total vegetation for canopy coverage or biomass. Ordination of community canopy cover demonstrated similarity of paired exclosure and controls.

Conclusions: Exclosure treatment effects on canopy cover and species richness in two regions indicated limited negative impacts from deer foraging. A time frame of more than five years may be required for exclusion to allow recovery of vegetation, even with relatively open canopies and a long growing season.     

Seasonal change in browsing by sika deer on hinoki cypress trees on Mount Takahara,central Japan

Browsing by sika deer (Cervus nippon Temminck) on hinoki cypress (Chamaecyparis obtusa (Sieb. et Zucc.) Endl.) was monitored for approximately 3years on 300 trees at three sites on Mount Takahara, central Japan. We investigated the seasonal change in browsing on hinoki cypress in relation to the availability of other food plants (dominated by Sasa nipponica Makino et Shibata) and preferred food plants (deciduous broad leaves). Browsing occurred mostly from November to April, while no browsing damage occurred from June to October. Browsing was observed in November, even when the amount of other food plants did not decrease. Therefore, the cause of browsing cannot be fully explained by a decreased availability of other food plants. Comparison of fecal composition and food availability showed that deer had a preference for deciduous broad leaves. The availability of these preferred plants decreased in November and increased in May. Chemical analysis of the hinoki cypress and deciduous broad leaves (crude protein and neutral detergent fiber) showed that the quality of deciduous broad leaves decreased in November, and as a result the quality of hinoki became higher than that of the deciduous broad leaves. Browsing on hinoki cypress occurred when the availability of deciduous broad leaves decreased, and vice versa. These results suggest that the availability of preferred food plants influences browsing on hinoki cypress by sika deer.     

Feedback effects of chronic browsing on life-history traits of a large herbivore

1. Increasing ungulate populations are affecting vegetation negatively in many areas, but few studies have assessed the long-term effects of overbrowsing on individual life-history traits of ungulates. 2. Using an insular population of white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus Zimmermann; Anticosti, Québec, Canada) introduced in 1896, and whose density has remained high since the first evidence of severe browsing in the 1930s, we investigated potential feedbacks of long-term and heavy browsing on deer life-history traits. 3. We assessed whether chronic browsing contributed to a decline of the quality of deer diet in early autumn during the last 25 years, and evaluated the impacts of reduced diet quality on deer body condition and reproduction. 4. Rumen nitrogen content declined 22% between two time periods, 1977-79 and 2002-04, indicating a reduction in diet quality. 5. After accounting for the effects of year within the time period, age and date of harvest in autumn, peak body mass of both sexes declined between the two time periods. At the end of November, males were on average 12% heavier and adult does 6% heavier in 1977-79 than in 2002-04. Hind foot length did not vary between time periods. 6. The probability of conception increased 15% between the two time periods, but litter size at ovulation declined 7%, resulting in a similar total number of ovulations in 2002-04 and in 1977-79. 7. Our results suggest that following a decline in diet quality, white-tailed deer females modified their life-history strategies to maintain reproduction at the expense of growth. 8. Deer appear to tolerate drastic reductions in diet quality by modifying their life history traits, such as body mass and reproduction, before a reduction in density is observed. Such modifications may contribute to maintain high population density of large herbivores following population irruption.     

Impact of the black rhinoceros (Diceros bicornis minor) on a local population of Euphorbia bothae in the Great Fish River Reserve,South Africa

In the Great Fish River Reserve, South Africa, black rhinoceros (Diceros bicornis minor) feed extensively on a local population of Euphorbia bothae. Maintaining the endangered black rhinoceros and the protected E. bothae population are both conservation priorities of the reserve. Therefore, the sustainability of this plant–animal interaction was investigated by comparing population characteristics, browsing incidence and intensity within the reserve and in an adjacent exclosure without access to rhino. Fixed‐point photographs showed that over a 2‐month period 36.6% of 213 monitored plants were browsed, with an average biomass loss of 13%, and 1% were destroyed. Of 26 plants re‐photographed after approximately 3 years, 70% showed a decrease in biomass, averaging 37.8% over this period. In this time span, 19% of the monitored plants died. Small plants (<45 cm) were over‐represented in the rhino‐browsed area, whereas the fraction of reproductively active plants and overall plant density were found to be lower than in the adjacent exclosure. No evidence of short‐term compensatory growth in response to browsing was found for E. bothae. This study indicates that, with the current population size, rhinos are overexploiting the E. bothae population and special measures should be taken to prevent local extinction.     

Effects of deer browsing on the early stage of pyrogenic succession on Miyajima Island,southwestern Japan

The early stage of forest regeneration on Miyajima Island, southewstern Japan, was studied for three years after a fire in 1984, with respect to the effects of deer browsing. The regeneration patterns of woody species, in terms of the biomass increment and browsing damage to plants, were classified into the following three groups: non- or rarely browsed species with little increment of biomass, heavily browsed with little increment, and heavily browsed with large increment. The aboveground biomass increased from 0.4 kg to 2.7 kg per 100 m² during three years, and was less than half of the biomass obtained in other burnt pine forests on the adjacent deer-free islands. About 28% of the plant biomass was consumed by deer. The effects of browsing on forest regeneration were heavier at lower than that at the higher altitudes. On this island, deer browsing seems to have an important effect on vegetational succession in the burnt areas.     

Status of the Mara Woodlands in Kenya

The woodlands of the Masai Mara National Reserve in Kenya have suffered dramatic declines over four decades as a result of elephant and fire pressure. This study examined the current status of woody resources in the Reserve and browse pressure thereon, using both classification (TWINSPAN) and ordination (DCA) techniques. From 333 widespread regular plots used to survey the vegetation, a total of 62 woody species were identified. Thirteen woody habitats were identified on the basis of species composition, varying from species‐rich closed thickets and forest to less diverse open grasslands. A NW/SE stratification of the more open habitats was observed, possibly as a result of differences in soils, rainfall and drainage. Both plant density and diversity were lower than in communal and privately managed areas outside the Reserve. Moreover, browser pressure was substantially higher than that observed previously in the ecosystem, and suggests increased competition for scarcer woody resources within the Reserve. This has implications for the management of the ecosystem as a whole. As woodland and thickets continue to decline, long‐term monitoring should expand to encompass the wider habitat diversity of the open grasslands and unprotected areas where much of the regeneration potential resides.     

Impact of Cotyledon and Leaf Removal on Seedling Survival in Three Tree Species with Contrasting Cotyledon Functions1

The relative importance of cotyledons and leaves for seedling survival was evaluated using a factorial field experiment on three neotropical tree species with contrasting cotyledon functional morphologies (photosynthetic, epigeal reserve vs. hypogeal reserve). In all species, cotyledon and leaf removal shortly after leaf expansion had additive negative effects on seedling survival over 7 weeks. Carbon supplies from cotyledons and other carbohydrate reserves apparently enhanced ability of seedlings to cope with herbivory and disease.     

Effects of moisture,nitrogen, grass competition and simulated browsing on the survival and growth of Acacia karroo seedlings

The effects of irrigation, nitrogen fertilization, grass competition and clipping were investigated for one growing season at the research farm of the University of Fort Hare in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa. The aim of the experiment was to assess the short‐term performance of Acacia karroo seedlings under different environmental conditions and the implications of such factors on the long‐term recruitment of plant species in savanna rangelands. There were no significant treatment effects on the survival of A. karroo seedlings. Using stem length and basal diameter as growth parameters, it was observed that irrigation enhanced both variables, while nitrogen fertilization did not have any significant effects. Clipping, grass competition and their interaction greatly suppressed the growth of the seedlings. Clipping increased the mean stem length when they were irrigated and fertilized. Control and fertilized plants had the highest stem length in the absence of grass competition, while grass competition combined with clipping resulted in the lowest stem length in both irrigated and nonirrigated plants. It was concluded that in the presence of grass competition, controlled browsing could be a viable solution to the problem of bush encroachment in savanna rangelands.     

The effects of deer exclusion on the development of a Mediterranean plant community affected by a wildfire

Despite the resilience of Mediterranean ecosystems to fire, the ecological restoration of burned plant communities can be hindered by ungulate herbivores, particularly in areas with high population densities. This study compares the postfire development of a shrub community with and without deer, after a wildfire occurred in 2003 in a protected area in Central Portugal. We monitored 12 fenced and 12 unfenced plots 2, 3, 4, and 8 years after fire. Within each plot, we established a linear transect and measured the monospecific canopy projections (plant patches). Five plant community indicators (patch number, average patch length, average patch height, patch cover, and patch phytovolume per square meter) were obtained. The diameter and height of individuals of the most abundant shrub species (Cistus salvifolius, Erica scoparia, Myrtus communis, Pistacia lentiscus, Rubus ulmifolius, and Ulex jussiaei) were also measured. These measurements were used as response variables in generalized linear mixed models in order to assess the effects of time‐after‐fire and fencing, on the development of the plant community. Patch height and phytovolume had a significantly higher growth in fenced plots. At the species level, C. salvifolius, M. communis, R. ulmifolius, and U. jussiaei showed a higher growth across time both in height and in diameter, in the absence of herbivory. This work shows that deer exclusion needs to be considered when aiming at the postfire restoration of Mediterranean shrub communities.     

Predicting the habitat usage of African black rhinoceros (Diceros bicornis) using random forest models

Species distribution models are often used in ecology to ascertain relationships between environmental variables and species presence. Modelling to understand this relationship can be used to aid conservation management strategies. In this paper, we applied the random forest classification method to predict habitat used by black rhino for browsing. The random forest model was created using detailed habitat data collected from Ol Pejeta Conservancy in Kenya. Variables from plots where rhino had been present were compared to those not used by rhino. Independent data were used to test the predictive accuracy of the rules generated. The model performed well with the independent test data, correctly classifying 69% of the sampling plots where black rhino were present. Important habitat features that affected rhino presence were browse availability and density of vegetation, with Vachellia drepanolobium (formerly Acacia) and Euclea divinorum being important components. The analysis also highlighted areas of potential high browse pressure, which should be the focus of continued monitoring and management.     

Effects of water dependence on the utilization pattern of woody vegetation by elephants in the Tembe Elephant Park, Maputaland, South Africa

The utilization of vegetation and particularly trees in enclosed small reserves where elephant populations are confined is a contentious conservation issue. In Tembe Elephant Park in Maputaland, the diverse Sand Forest is considered the most valuable feature to conserve; yet it is considered at risk from increasing elephant utilization of the park's vegetation in general. The mean canopy removal by elephants across the park was studied over two periods: a recent period including the twelve months before the study and an older period >12 months earlier. Age of utilization was determined from the degree of decay observed on woody fibres. The relationships between intensity of utilization, vegetation unit selection and distance to water were evaluated. Results show that utilization patterns have shifted in the recent drier period, during which elephants used vegetation communities closer to permanent water. Concurringly, a significant decrease in utilization intensity was correlated to an increasing distance from water points in the park during that period, while this effect was not observed during the wetter old period. We debate that active water availability management may be a way to limit elephant utilization in small fenced reserves.     

Disentangling Competition, Herbivory, and Seasonal Effects on Young Plants in Newly Restored Communities

Optimizing techniques of impact and consequence assessment are critical when faced with the challenges of reclamation within a damaged or altered ecosystem. Much debate has arisen over an appropriate index to evaluate herbivore and competition effects on restored communities. We assessed concurrent environmental pressures by means of repeated measurements using three common indices of plant performance (biomass, shoot extension, and survival) in conjunction with monitoring for number and timing of plants eaten. Our design incorporated 24 species, representing a range of taxonomic groups and growth forms, planted at low and high densities, inside and outside large‐scale mammal exclosures. We demonstrate that biomass and height measurements are correlated (at both the individual and the combined species levels), whereas the survival index often showed independent information. Using the most conservative measure (survival), we delineate between plant deaths attributed to seasonal effects, competition (some facilitation was apparent), and herbivory (both compensation and loss of fitness were demonstrated). Plant spacing effects depended on the index (response variable) and whether we measured individual or combined species. The survival index rarely showed competition effects. Due to counter facilitation effects, competition was not demonstrated for any index at the combined species level. The comparison of the relative order and magnitude of plants being eaten against impact identified vulnerable and compensating species. Once identified, compensating species may be used sacrificially to buffer damage in new reclamation systems, whereas deterrents may be used around known vulnerable species.     

The Seedling Ratio Method for determining ungulate impacts on forest understoreys: Utility in an Australian ecosystem

The Seedling Ratio Method was devised to assess the impacts of introduced ungulates on plant species richness in forest understoreys. The method has successfully assessed ungulate impacts on species richness in forests in New Zealand and Hawaii, which do not have native herbivores. We tested the three critical assumptions that underlie this method to investigate its potential for use in an Australian ecosystem. This study was conducted in the Yarra Ranges National Park (YRNP), Victoria, which had a high‐density population of an introduced deer species, Sambar (Cervus unicolor), in addition to several native herbivore species. One of the three key assumptions of the Seedling Ratio Method was not supported, whereas conventional differential exclosures showed clear and separate impacts by Sambar and native herbivores. We conclude that the Seedling Ratio Method could not provide a clear indication of browsing impact on forest understoreys in YRNP.