Tradescantia stamen hair mutation bioassay

The Tradescantia stamen hair mutation (Trad-SH) assay (clone 4430) was evaluated for its efficiency and reliability as a screen for mutagens in an IPCS collaborative study on plant systems. Four coded chemicals, i.e. azidoglycerol (AG, 3-azido-1,2-propanediol), N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU), sodium azide (NaN₃) and maleic hydrazide (MH) were distributed by the Radian Corporation to the five laboratories in five different countries for testing mutagenicity. Pink mutations were scored between the 7th and 14th day according to a standard protocol. Test results from the five individual laboratories were analyzed and compared after decoding. One out of the two laboratories that conducted tests on AG demonstrated that AG is a mutagen with genetically effective doses ranging from 50 to 100 μg/ml. MH yielded positive responses in all laboratories but no linear dose-response pattern was observed. The effective dose range for MH was between 1 and 45 μg/ml. The mutagenicity of MNU was reported by five laboratories in the dose range between 10 and 80 μg/ml. NaN₃, which exhibited a relatively high degree of toxicity, elicited a positive mutagenic response in three of the five laboratories in which it was tested. As with MNU the effective dose for NaN₃ ranged between 3 and 80 μg/ml. The results from the current study substantiate the Trad-SH assay as a reliable system for screening chemicals for their potential mutagenic effects. Although the study was carried out exclusively under laboratory conditions, a survey of the current literature would indicate that the Trad-SH assay could be an effective in situ monitor of gaseous, liquid, and radioactive pollutants as well.     

Results and recommendations

In the first phase of a collaborative study by the International Programme on Chemical Safety (PRCS), four coded chemicals, i.e. azidoglycerol (AG, 3-azido-1,2-propanediol), methyl nitrosurea (MNU), sodium azide (NaN₃) and maleic hydrazide (MH), and ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) as a positive control were tested in four plant bioassays, namely the Arabidopsis embryo and chlorophyll mutation assay, the Tradescantia stamen hair assay (Trad-SH assay), the Tradescantia micronucleus assay (Trade-MCN), and the Vicia faba root tip assay. Seventeen laboratories from diverse regions of the world participated with four to six laboratories each using one plant assay. For the Arabidopsis assay, laboratories were in agreement with MNU and AG giving positive responses and NaN₃ giving a negative response. With the exception of one laboratory which reported MH as weakly mutagenic, no mutagenic response was reported for MH by the other laboratories. For the Vicia faba assay, all laboratories reported a positive response for MNU, AG, and MH, whereas two of the six laboratories reported a negative response for NaN₃. For the Trad-SH assay, MH was reported as giving a positive response and a positive response was also observed for MNU with the exception of one laboratory. NaN₃, which exhibited a relatively high degree of toxicity, elicited a positive response in three of the five laboratories. AG was found positive in only one of the two laboratories which tested this chemical. For the Trad-MCN assay, MNU and MH were reported as positive by all laboratories, while four out of five laboratories reported NaN₃ to be positive. Only one of three laboratories reported AG to be positive. The major sources of variability were identified and considered to be in the same range as found in similar studies on other test systems. Recommendations were made for minor changes in methodology and for initiating the second phase of this study.     

Cytotoxic effects of maleic hydrazide.

Since 1950, maleic hydrazide (MH) has been introduced into agriculture as a major commercial herbicide and a depressant of plant growth in numerous circumstances such as suppression of sprouting of vegetables and stored food crops, control of sucker growth on tobacco plants, ratardation of flowering and prolongation of dormancy period. Since 1951 MH has been known as an effective chromosome-breaking agent in higher plants, in sharp contrast with its low effect on the chromosomes and general health of tested mammals. The selectivity of action of MH in plants and animals was obviously the main reason of low interest devoted to the chemical by people working the field of environmental mutagenesis. In early works the inhibitory effects of MH on plant growth were mainly considered to result from the suppression of plant metabolism (inhibition of enzymic activity) and interference of the compound with plant hormones and growth regulators. More recently, numerous experiments performed with various plant species have shown that MH acts as an inhibitor of the synthesis of nucleic acids and proteins. Similar results have been obtained with animal tumour cells. The chromosome-breaking effect of MH on plant chromosomes resembles very closely the chromosome-breaking properties of alkylating agents and other mutagenic compounds such as mitomycin C. MH-induced chromosomal aberrations have also been recorded in grasshoppers, fish and mice, although tests with some mammalian cell lines gave negative results. Among higher plants, selective sensitivity to the toxic effects of MH is well proved. This phenomenon seems to be due to the differential ability of various plant species to detoxicate the chemical. Plants can break down MH into several products, one of which, hydrazine, is a well-known mutagen and carcinogen. MH does not seem to be toxic to bacteria and fungi. The compound is degraded by soil microflora and hence can be utilized as a source of nitrogen nutrition. MH proved to be of low toxicity to mammals, but in some instances it decreased the fertility of rats. The reported carcinogenic effects of MH in mice and rats raise the question of its risks to man.     

Comet-FISH for the evaluation of plant DNA damage after mutagenic treatments

The aim of this study was to perform a comparative investigation of the actions of three mutagens that are widely used in plant mutagenesis using the comet-FISH technique. The comet-FISH technique was used for the analysis of DNA damage and the kinetics of repair within specific DNA sequences. FISH with rDNA and telomeric/centromeric DNA probes was applied to comets that were obtained from an alkaline/neutral comet assay. Migration within specific DNA sequences was analysed after treatment with two chemical mutagens-maleic hydrazide (MH) and N-nitroso-N-methylurea (MNU), and γ-rays. Barley was used as a model plant in this study. The possible utility of specific DNA sequences in a comparative assessment of the distribution of DNA damage within a plant genome was evaluated. This study proved that the comet-FISH technique is suitable for a detailed quantification of DNA damage and repair within specific DNA sequences in plant mutagenesis. The analysis of FISH signals demonstrated that the involvement of specific DNA sequences in DNA damage was different and was dependent on the mutagen used. We showed that 5S rDNA and telomeric DNA sequences are more sensitive to mutagenic treatment, which was expressed by a stronger fragmentation and migration in comparison to the other probes used in the study. We found that 5S rDNA and telomeric DNA probes are more suitable for testing the genotoxicity of environmental factors. A comparison of the involvement of specific chromosome domains in direct DNA breakage/repair and in chromosome aberration formation after mutagen treatment indicates the compatibility of the results.     

Tradescantia micronucleus bioassay

Four coded chemicalsm azidoglycerol (AG), N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU), sodium azide (NaN₃), and maleic hydrazide (MH), were tested with the Tradescantia micronucleus (Trad-MCN) bioassay by five independent laboratories from five different countries. The purpose of this international collaborative study was to evaluate four plant bioassays, of which the Trad-MCN assay was one, for their sensitivity, efficiency and reliability. The study was carried out under the sponsorship of the International Programme on Chemical Safety. All laboratories adhered to a standard Trad-MCN protocol which suggested that three replicate tests be conducted with each chemical. The results reported by all laboratories, although not equal, showed good agreement among the laboratories. In fact, all five laboratories obtained positive results with MH and MNU, while four of the five laboratories achieved positive results with NaN₃. AG was tested in only three laboratories. Two reported negative results, while one reported positive results but only at a single high dose. The data from this study suggest that under normal conditions, the Trad-MCN bioassay is an efficient and reliable short-term bioassay for clastogens. It is suitable for the rapid screening of chemicals, and also is specially qualified for in situ monitoring of ambient pollutants.     

DNA damage induced by mutagens in plant and human cell nuclei in acellular comet assay

Higher plant cells have a long tradition of use in the studies on environmental mutagenesis in situ, especially in relation to human health risk determination. The studies on the response of plant and human cells to physical and chemical mutagens showed differences in their sensitivity. The differences in the presence of cell components in plants and humans could influence such response. Additionally, the level of the organization of the employed material could influence DNA-damaging effect: leukocytes are isolated cells and plant--an intact organism. To preclude these obstacles, the effects of direct treatment of isolated nuclei with genotoxic agents were determined to compare the sensitivity of plant and human cells. In the present study, we have determined the DNA-damaging effects of two chemical mutagens: maleic acid hydrazide (MH) and N-methyl-N-nitroso-urea (MNU) applied to isolated nuclei of both plant and human cells. In order to compare the sensitivity of the nuclei of Nicotiana tabacum var. xanthi and the nuclei of leukocytes, the acellular Comet assay was carried out. The results showed higher sensitivity of the nuclei of leukocytes as compared to the nuclei of plant cells to mutagenic treatment with the applied doses of MH and MNU.     

Vicia faba chromosomal aberration assay

A collaborative study involving laboratories in six countries was initiated under the sponsorship of the International Programme on Chemical Safety (IPCS) to determine the sensitivity, efficiency and reliability of the Vicia faba root tip meristem chromosomal aberration assay using a standardized protocol. The six Laboratories that participated in this study were located in the Slovak Republic, India, Japan, Poland, Sweden and the USA. All laboratories adhered to a standardized protocol for the Vicia faba chromosomal aberartion assay. Four coded chemicals, azidoglycerol (AG), N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU), sodium azide (NaN₃) and maleic hydrazide (MH) were tested with the Vicia faba chromosomal aberration assay. Of the four chemicals, three (MH, AG and MNU) were found to be clastogenic and gave a concentration related response. However, the results of NaN₃ were equivocal which might be explained by the stability of NaN₃. The conclusions from this study suggest that the Vicia faba chromosomal aberration bioassay is an efficient and reliable short-term bioassay for the rapid screening of chemicals for clastogenicity.     

Structure-activity relationships of the azide metabolite, azidoalanine, in S. typhimurium

Azide is metabolized to the proximate mutagen, L-azidoalanine in bacterial systems. While this novel mutagenic metabolite plays a key role in azide mutagenesis, the biochemistry of this role is unknown. The chemical synthesis of authentic racemic azidoalanine and several derivatives thereof allowed the exploration of structure-activity relationships with this unique mutagen. We found that whereas azide, azidoalanine and azidoalanine tert.-butyl ester were of comparable mutagenic potency, derivatives which lack the free amino group, such as azidopropionic acid and amino-blocked azidoalanine, were orders of magnitude less active. These findings demonstrate that the free amino group is essential for significant activity, while the carboxyl group may be less important. This conclusion together with the finding that DL-azidoalanine is a less potent mutagen than azide itself, suggests that the metabolite, while necessary for azide mutagenicity, may not be the ultimate mutagenic species. Instead, the data are consistent with the hypothesis that azidoalanine requires further bioactivation.     

Influence of the Presence of B Chromosomes on DNA Damage in Crepis capillaris

The sensitivity of different plant species to mutagenic agents is related to the DNA content and organization of the chromatin, which have been described in ABCW and bodyguard hypotheses, respectively. Plant species that have B chromosomes are good models for the study of these hypotheses. This study presents an analysis of the correlation between the occurrence of B chromosomes and the DNA damage that is induced by the chemical mutagen, maleic hydrazide (MH), in Crepis capillaris plants using comet assay. The presence of B chromosomes has a detectable impact on the level of DNA damage. The level of DNA damage after MH treatment was correlated with the number of B chromosomes and it was observed that it increased significantly in plants with 3B chromosomes. We did not find evidence of the protective role from chemical mutagens of the constitutive heterochromatin for euchromatin in relation to DNA damage. The DNA damage involving the 25S rDNA sequences was analyzed using the comet-FISH technique. Fragmentation within or near the 25S rDNA involved the loci on the A and B chromosomes. The presence of B chromosomes in C. capillaris cells had an influence on the level of DNA damage that involves the 25S rDNA region.     

Arabidopsis assay for mutagenicity

Four laboratories, two in the Czech Republic (Brno and Prague) and two in the CIS (Moscow and Duschanbe), participated in the International Programme on Chemical Safety's (IPCS) collaborative study to evaluate the utility of the most commonly used plant test systems, including the Arabidopsis thaliana assay, for assessign the mutagenic potential of environmental agents. Out of the five compounds evaluated in the Arabidopsis assay, three compounds, i.e., ethyl methanesulfonate, N-methyl-N-nitrosourea, and azidoglycerol, were reported to be mutagenic by all four participating laboratories. Sodium azide (NaN₃) demonstrated a negative response in all four laboratories, whereas maleic hydrazide was reported to be weakly mutagenic by one laboratory and nonmutagenic by the other three laboratories.     

Ellagic acid protects rat embryos in culture from the embryotoxic effects of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea.

Ellagic acid is a naturally occurring plant phenol that has demonstrated anticarcinogenic and antimutagenic activity in several test systems. Given the common proposed etiopathogenic processes of mutagenesis, carcinogenesis, and teratogenesis induced by genotoxic chemicals, the present study was initiated to determine whether ellagic acid would protect rat embryos in culture from the teratogenic effects of N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU). Ellagic acid alone (as used in these experiments; 50 microM in DMSO) was not embryotoxic. Ellagic acid (50 microM) significantly (P less than 0.01) prevented MNU (75 microM)-induced effects including mortality (absence of heart beat), abnormal formation of the cephalic neural tube derivatives, and delayed differentiation as assessed by a morphological scoring system. These embryoprotective effects were dose responsive. Sequential treatment of embryos with ellagic acid followed by MNU in fresh media also was embryoprotective with no diminution of effect. The site at which ellagic acid interrupts the critical teratogenic events induced by MNU is apparently within the embryo and/or placenta. This model of chemical embryoprotection may be useful in determining the role of cell death and/or mutation in the teratogenic mechanism of action of methylating agents.     

Mutagenicity of N-nitrosopyrrolidine derivatives in Salmonella (Ames) and Escherichia coli K-12 (343/113) assays

The mutagenicity of nitrosopyrrolidine (NPYR) and its derivatives was determined by use of the Ames Salmonella assay. A clear specificity to revert the missense stain of TA1535 and a requirement for the phenobarbital-induced rat-liver activation system (S9 mix) were noted. 3,4-Dichloronitrosopyrrolidine was more mutagenic than NPYR, whereas 3-hydroxynitrosopyrrolidine was weakly mutagenic. The carcinogenic nitroso-3-pyrrolidine was not mutagenic under the test conditions. The noncarcinogenic derivatives (2,5-dimethylnitrosopyrrolidine, nitrosoproline and 4-hydroxynitrosoproline) were not mutagenic. Liquid preincubation assays were not any more effective than the pour-plate assays. Selected derivatives of NPYR were tested in the Escherichia coli K-12 (343/113) assay A specificity to revert the missense mutation at the arg locus and a dependence on phenobarbital-induced rat-liver S9 mix were noted with NPYR and its derivatives. 3,4-Dibromonitrosopyrrolidine, which was not mutagenic in Salmonella, was effective in E. coli, and the weakly carcinogenic NPRL was a weak mutagen resulting in a 2-fold enhancement in the E. coli arginine reversion assay.     

Transformed roots of Crepis capillaris--a [corrected] sensitive system for the evaluation of the clastogenicity of abiotic agents

The presence of a large number of pollutants, including mutagenic agents in the environment is a problem of a major concern. Rapid progress in plant biotechnology, especially in the development of cell transformation methods, including the production of transformed roots -- 'hairy roots' -- has opened new possibilities to use transformed root cultures in plant bioassays for the evaluation mutagenic effects of different agents. We have used Crepis capillaris hairy roots for evaluation of cytogenetic effects of mutagenic treatment. Effects of maleic acid hydrazide (MH) and X-ray treatment were analysed in chromosomal aberration, sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and TUNEL tests. Comparison of cytogenetic effects in hairy roots and roots of seedlings showed a much higher sensitivity of hairy roots, which makes them convenient material for monitoring DNA damage after mutagenic treatment.     

Comparison of a forward and a reverse mutation assay in Salmonella typhimurium measuring L-arabinose resistance and histidine prototrophy

A forward and a reverse mutation assay designed to detect environmental mutagens have been compared in Salmonella typhimurium. The forward mutation assay scored resistance to L-arabinose and the reverse assay, reversion of histidine auxotrophy. Eighteen chemicals of different structural groups, all known to be mutagenic in the histidine reverse assay, were applied to strains carrying the genetic markers needed to perform both mutation assays. The mutagenicity of each chemical was determined by both plate and liquid tests. The plate test counted absolute numbers of surviving mutants and the liquid test separately measured survival and frequency of mutants among the survivors. All the chemicals used were found to be mutagenic in both mutation assays. The response of the L-arabinose assay was equal to or larger than the response of the histidine assay in the case of 16 chemicals. The two other compounds, 2-nitrofluorene and sodium azide, were detected more efficiently by the histidine assay. Sodium azide, a non-carcinogenic compound, is a potent mutagen in the histidine assay, but very weak in the L-arabinose assay.     

Somatic crossing-over in Glycine max (L.) merrill: activation of dimethyl nitrosoamine by plant seed and comparison with methyl nitrosourea in inducing somatic mosaicism

The soybean system used for detecting environmental mutagens is analyzed for various types of spots on the leaves of heterozygous y11y11 plants and homozygous y11y11's induced by a nitrosoamine (dimethyl nitrosoamine, DMN) and a nitrosoamide (methyl nitrosourea, MNU). It is shown that the nitrosoamine can be "activated" by the seed (is converted to a true mutagen) without the addition of NADPH or S-9 fraction of the liver homogenate as is necessary in animal tissue culture or bacterial studies. Whereas somatic mosaicism in soybean can be induced with a dose as low as 1.25 ppm of DMN, the upper limit in spot production is reached at around 60 ppm concentration, applied for 0--24 h. Such saturation effect may be due to a limited amount of DMN being converted to true mutagen. MNU, on the other hand, does not show such limitations, perhaps because of its property of being a direct mutagen not necessitating an intermediate step required for converting the promutagen DMN. The frequency of twin spots on Y11y11 leaves increases only slightly by either DMN or MNU, suggesting only a small increase in somatic crossing-over induced by the two chemicals. The yellow spots increase the most, perhaps due to segmental losses carrying Y11 or non-complementary segregation of exchanges involving non-homologous chromosomes. Neither chemical is found capable of mutating y11 to Y11 as seen by the general lack of light green sectors on y11Y11 plants. Usefulness of the soybean system in studying mutagenesis is briefly discussed.     

Sodium azide mutagenesis in mammals: inability of mammalian cells to convert azide to a mutagenic intermediate

Sodium azide is unique among mutagens. It is highly mutagenic in many plant and bacterial species but marginally mutagenic in mammalian cells. A possible explanation for this difference in mutagenic efficiency may lie in the inability of mammalian cells to convert azide to the putative ultimate mutagen. Normal human fibroblasts and Chinese hamster cells or cell-free extracts from these cell lines were treated with azide and the sonicates tested for mutagenicity in Salmonella strain TA1530. The data suggest that neither cell line was capable of converting azide to a mutagenic intermediate. In addition, both cell lines expressed the enzyme O-acetylserine(thio)-lyase which is responsible for the conversion of azide to azidoalanine, the putative mutagenic intermediate. Although mammalian cells possess the enzyme responsible for the conversion of azide to azidoalanine, they appear incapable of converting azide into a mutagenic intermediate in appreciable quantities. Further, the data support the conclusion that azide may be further modified in mammalian cells to an intermediate that is not genotoxic.     

Transformed roots of Crepis capillaries — a sensitive system for the evaluation of the clastogenicity of abiotic agents

The presence of a large number of pollutants, including mutagenic agents in the environment is a problem of a major concern. Rapid progress in plant biotechnology, especially in the development of cell transformation methods, including the production of transformed roots – ‘hairy roots’ – has opened new possibilities to use transformed root cultures in plant bioassays for the evaluation mutagenic effects of different agents. We have used Crepis capillaris hairy roots for evaluation of cytogenetic effects of mutagenic treatment. Effects of maleic acid hydrazide (MH) and X-ray treatment were analysed in chromosomal aberration, sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and TUNEL tests. Comparison of cytogenetic effects in hairy roots and roots of seedlings showed a much higher sensitivity of hairy roots, which makes them convenient material for monitoring DNA damage after mutagenic treatment.     

Carcinogenic potency in rodents versus genotoxic potency in E. coli: a correlation analysis for bifunctional alkylating agents

The mutagenic (M), recombinagenic (R) and SOS inducing (I) potencies of 6 bifunctional directly acting alkylating agents (mitomycin C, thiotepa, chlorambucil, nitrogen mustard, bis(2-chloroethyl)ether and bis(2-chloroethyl)nitrosourea) were measured in an E. coli test system (E. coli multitest) as the integral under the yield-dose curve obtained for each event. This potency crresponds to the cumulative yield of the affected cell population over the entire effective dose range of the chemical treatment.

A weak mutagenic activity was detected only for mitomycin C and thiotepa. Except for bis(2-chloroethyl)ether, all agents were recombinagenic and SOS inducing.

When the 3 genotoxic potencies (M, R and I) of these bifunctional alkylating agents were correlated, separately or in combination, with the respective carcinogenic potencies in rodents, a highly significant correlation was obtained with both the recombinagenic and SOS inducing potencies.     

A comparison of the CHO/HGPRT+ and the L5178Y/TK+/− mutation assays using suspension treatment and soft agar cloning: Results for 10 chemicals

The mouse lymphoma assay (MLA) and Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell assay are sensitive indicators of mutagenicity. The CHO assay has been modified technically to permit treatment in suspension and soft agar cloning comparable to the MLA. This methodology eliminates the risk of metabolic cooperation and the trauma of trypsinization. In addition, a larger population of cells can be treated and cloned for mutant selection. In order to compare the effectiveness of the test systems, 10 chemicals were evaluated for the induction of forward mutations in the CHO and MLA. Several of these chemicals have been reported as clastogenic; therefore, abbreviated colony sizing was performed to gauge the extent of genetic damage to the MLA cells. Both test systems detected benzo[a]pyrene, mitomycin C, acridine orange, and proflavin, and, with the exception of proflavin, more large colonies were present than small colonies. The suspect clastogen, phenytoin, was not mutagenic in the MLA and produced inconclusive results in the CHO. Ethidium bromide, a clastogen and a bacterial mutagen, was not mutagenic in either the MLA or CHO. Four compounds (p-aminophenol, benzoin, methoxychlor, and pyrene) were positive in the MLA, generally inducing a large number of small colonies, while demonstrating no mutagenic activity in the CHO assay. They have also been shown to be generally nongenotoxic in other test systems. Overall, the modified CHO assay did not appear to be better than the MLA for the detection of mutagenic agents. However, the MLA does appear to have lower specificity.Abbreviations AO acridine orange - BAP benzo[a]pyrene - BZN benzoin - CHO Chinese hamster ovary cell assay - DPH diphenylhydantoin - EB ethidium bromide - EMS ethylmethanesulfonate - 3MC 3-methylcholanthrene - MLA mouse lymphoma asay - MMC mitomycin C - MXC methoxychlor - PAP p-aminophenol - PRO proflavin - PYR pyrene