Role of glycoprotein PE2 in formation and maturation of the Sindbis virus spike.

Sindbis virus envelope assembly is a multistep process resulting in the maturation of a rigid, highly ordered T=4 icosahedral protein lattice containing 80 spikes composed of trimers of E1-E2 heterodimers. Intramolecular disulfide bonds within E1 stabilize E1-E1 associations required for envelope formation and maintenance of the envelope's structural integrity. The structural integrity of the envelope protein lattice is resistant to reduction by dithiothreitol (DTT), indicating that E1 disulfides which stabilize structural domains become inaccessible to DTT at some point during virus maturation. The development of E1 resistance to DTT occurs prior to the completion of E1 folding and is temporally correlated with spike assembly in the endoplasmic reticulum. From these data we have predicted that in the final stages of spike assembly, E1 intramolecular disulfides, which stabilize the structural integrity of the envelope protein lattice, are buried within the spike and become inaccessible to the reductive activity of DTT. The spike is formed prior to the completion of E1 folding, and we have suggested that PE2 (the precursor to E2) may play a critical role in E1 folding after PE2-E1 oligomer formation has occurred. In this study we have investigated the role of PE2 in E1 folding, oligomer formation, and development of E1 resistance to both protease digestion and reduction by DTT by using a Sindbis virus replicon (SINrep/E1) which allows for the expression of E1 in the presence of truncated PE2. Through pulse-chase analysis of both Sindbis virus- and SINrep/E1-infected cells, we have determined that the folding of E1 into a trypsin-resistant conformation and into its most compact and stable form is not dependent upon association of E1 with PE2. However, E1 association with PE2 is required for oligomer formation, the export of E1 from the endoplasmic reticulum, and E1 acquisition of resistance to DTT.     

Formation and rearrangement of disulfide bonds during maturation of the Sindbis virus E1 glycoprotein.

The rigidly ordered icosahedral lattice of the Sindbis virus envelope is composed of a host-derived membrane bilayer in which the viral glycoproteins E1 and E2 reside. E1-E1 interactions stabilized by intramolecular disulfide bridges play a significant role in maintaining the envelope's structural integrity (R. P. Anthony and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 65:1187-1194, 1991; R. P. Anthony, A. M. Paredes, and D. T. Brown, Virology 190:330-336, 1992). We have examined the acquisition of disulfide bridges within E1 during its maturation. Prior to exit from the endoplasmic reticulum, E1 folds via at least three intermediates, differing in the number and/or arrangement of their disulfides, into a single, compact form. This E1 species remains stable with respect to its disulfides until late in the secretory pathway, when E1 attains a metastable conformation. At this point, when appropriately triggered, intramolecular thiol-disulfide exchange reactions within E1 can occur, resulting in the generation of alternative E1 species. This metastable nature of mature E1 may have important implications for the mechanism of virus disassembly during the initial stages of the infection process (B. Abell and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 67:5496-5501, 1993).     

Protein-protein interactions in an alphavirus membrane.

Using homobifunctional chemical cross-linkers with various span distances, we have determined the near-neighbor associations and planar organization of the E1 and E2 envelope glycoproteins which compose the icosahedral surface of Sindbis virus. We have found that E1-E2 heterodimers, which form the virus protomeric units, exist in two conformationally distinct forms, reflecting their nonequivalent positions in the icosahedron. Three of these heterodimers form the trimeric morphologic units (capsomeres) which are held together by central E1-E1 interactions. In addition, we present data which suggest that E2-E2 interactions organize the capsomeres into pentameric and hexameric geometric units and that E1-E1 interactions between capsomeres maintain the icosahedral lattice in mature virions.     

Sindbis virus glycoprotein E1 is divided into two discrete domains at amino acid 129 by disulfide bridge connections

The E1 membrane glycoprotein of Sindbis virus contains structural and functional domains, which are conformationally dependent on the presence of intramolecular disulfide bridges (B. A. Abell and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 67:5496-5501, 1993; R. P. Anthony, A. M. Paredes, and D. T. Brown, Virology 190:330-336, 1992). We have examined the disulfide bonds in E1 and have determined that the E1 membrane glycoprotein contains two separate sets of interconnecting disulfide linkages, which divide the protein into two domains at amino acid 129. These separate sets of disulfides may stabilize and define the structural and functional regions of the E1 protein.     

Structural Localization of the E3 Glycoprotein in Attenuated Sindbis Virus Mutants

We have determined the three-dimensional structures of the wild-type Sindbis virus and two of its mutants that retain the E3 sequence within PE2. Using difference imaging between these mutants and the wild-type virus, we have assigned a location for the 64-amino-acid sequence corresponding to E3 in the mutant spike complex. In the wild-type virus, the spike is composed of an E1-E2 heterotrimer. The E3 protein was found to protrude midway between the center of the spike complex and the tips. Based on these results and the work of others, we propose a distribution for the functional domains of the spike proteins within the structure of wild-type Sindbis virus. Within the structure of the virus, the E1 domains form the central portion of the spike complex, while the tips are formed by the E2 domains that flare out from the center of the complex. The structural similarity between these Sindbis virus mutants and Ross River virus suggests that E3 may also be present in the latter, which is also a member of the Alphavirus genus.     

Sindbis virus membrane fusion is mediated by reduction of glycoprotein disulfide bridges at the cell surface.

We have examined the role of thiol-disulfide exchange reactions during the penetration of cells by Sindbis virus. The protein-protein association that form the rigid icosahedral lattice of the Sindbis virus envelope have been shown to be stabilized by disulfide bridges, and reduction of these critical disulfide bridges during cell penetration may be the mechanism by which the rigid protein lattice is disrupted prior to fusion (R. Anthony and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 65:1187-1194, 1991; R. Anthony, A. Paredes, and D. T. Brown, Virology 190:330-336, 1992). Reduction of disulfide bridges occurs at near neutral pHs via thiol-disulfide exchange reactions, and these reactions can be blocked by covalent modification of the thiol involved. In this study, the effects of the reducing agent 2-mercaptoethanol on Sindbis virus-mediated cell-cell fusion from without and the effects of the membrane-impermeable thiol-alkylating reagent 5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) on Sindbis virus penetration were determined. The presence of exogenous reducing agent was found to induce fusion from without under conditions unfavorable to both typical Sindbis virus-mediated fusion from without and cysteine-mediated thiol-disulfide exchange reactions. In addition, the thiol-alkylating reagent was found to inhibit Sindbis virus entry when present during infection. These results are consistent with a model for Sindbis virus entry in which reduction of critical disulfide bridges at the cell surface disrupts the rigid protein-protein associations of the envelope, allowing membrane fusion and release of the viral genome into the cell.     

Interaction of Sindbis virus glycoproteins during morphogenesis.

In cells infected with the Sindbis temperature-sensitive mutants ts-23 and ts-10 (complementation group D), which contain a defect in the envelope glycoprotein E1, the precursor polypeptide PE2 is not cleaved to the envelope glycoprotein E2 at the nonpermissive temperature. This defect is phenotypically identical to the defect observed in the complementation group E mutant, ts-20. The lesion in ts-23 is reversible upon shift to permissive temperature, whereas that of ts-10 is not. Antiserum against whole virus, E1, or E2 also prevents the cleavage of PE2 in cells infected with wild-type Sindbis virus. Because the cleavage of PE2 is inhibited by the lesion in mutants that are genotypically distinct and by anti-E1 or -E2 serum, it appears that PE2 and E1 exist as a complex in the membrane of the infected cell.     

The formation of intramolecular disulfide bridges is required for induction of the Sindbis virus mutant ts23 phenotype.

The Sindbis virus envelope protein spike is a hetero-oligomeric complex composed of a trimer of glycoprotein E1-E2 heterodimers. Spike assembly is a multistep process which occurs in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and is required for the export of E1 from the ER. PE2 (precursor to E2), however, can transit through the secretory pathway and be expressed at the cell surface in the absence of E1. Although oligomer formation does not appear to be required for the export of PE2, there is evidence that defects in E1 folding can affect PE2 transit from the ER. Temperature-sensitive mutant ts23 of Sindbis virus contains two amino acid substitutions in E1, while PE2 and capsid protein have the wild-type sequence; however, at the nonpermissive temperature, both E1 and PE2 are retained within the ER and can be isolated in protein aggregates with the molecular chaperone GRP78-BiP. We previously demonstrated that the temperature sensitivity for ts23 was lost as oligomer formation took place at the permissive temperature, suggesting that temperature sensitivity is initiated early in the process of viral spike assembly (M. Carleton and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 70:952-959, 1996). Experiments described herein investigated the defects in envelope protein maturation that occur in ts23-infected cells and which result in retention of both envelope proteins in the ER. The data demonstrate that in ts23-infected cells incubated at the nonpermissive temperature, E1 folding is disrupted early after synthesis, resulting in the rapid incorporation of both E1 and PE2 into disulfide-stabilized aggregates. Furthermore, the aberrant E1 conformation which is responsible for induction of the ts phenotype requires the formation of intramolecular disulfide bridges formed prior to E1 association with PE2 and the completion of E1 folding.     

Contribution of redox status to hepatitis C virus E2 envelope protein function and antigenicity

Disulfide bonding contributes to the function and antigenicity of many viral envelope glycoproteins. We assessed here its significance for the hepatitis C virus E2 envelope protein and a counterpart deleted for hypervariable region-1 (HVR1). All 18 cysteine residues of the antigens were involved in disulfides. Chemical reduction of up to half of these disulfides was compatible with anti-E2 monoclonal antibody reaction, CD81 receptor binding, and viral entry, whereas complete reduction abrogated these properties. The addition of 5,5'-dithiobis-2-nitrobenzoic acid had no effect on viral entry. Thus, E2 function is only weakly dependent on its redox status, and cell entry does not require redox catalysts, in contrast to a number of enveloped viruses. Because E2 is a major neutralizing antibody target, we examined the effect of disulfide bonding on E2 antigenicity. We show that reduction of three disulfides, as well as deletion of HVR1, improved antibody binding for half of the patient sera tested, whereas it had no effect on the remainder. Small scale immunization of mice with reduced E2 antigens greatly improved serum reactivity with reduced forms of E2 when compared with immunization using native E2, whereas deletion of HVR1 only marginally affected the ability of the serum to bind the redox intermediates. Immunization with reduced E2 also showed an improved neutralizing antibody response, suggesting that potential epitopes are masked on the disulfide-bonded antigen and that mild reduction may increase the breadth of the antibody response. Although E2 function is surprisingly independent of its redox status, its disulfide bonds mask antigenic domains. E2 redox manipulation may contribute to improved vaccine design.     

The surface conformation of Sindbis virus glycoproteins E1 and E2 at neutral and low pH, as determined by mass spectrometry-based mapping

Sindbis virus contains two membrane glycoproteins, E1 and E2, which are organized into 80 trimers of heterodimers (spikes). These trimers form a precise T=4 icosahedral protein lattice on the surface of the virus. Very little is known about the organization of the E1 and E2 glycoproteins within the spike trimer. To gain a better understanding of how the proteins E1 and E2 are arranged in the virus membrane, we have used the techniques of limited proteolysis and amino acid chemical modification in combination with mass spectrometry. We have determined that at neutral pH the E1 protein regions that are accessible to proteases include domains 1-21 (region encompassing amino acids 1 to 21), 161-176, and 212-220, while the E2 regions that are accessible include domains 31-84, 134-148, 158-186, 231-260, 299-314, and 324-337. When Sindbis virus is exposed to low pH, E2 amino acid domains 99-102 and 262-309 became exposed while other domains became inaccessible. Many new E1 regions became accessible after exposure to low pH, including region 86-91, which is in the putative fusion domain of E1 of Semliki Forest virus (SFV) (M. C. Kielian et al., J. Cell Biol. 134:863-872, 1996). E1 273-287 and region 145-158 were also exposed at low pH. These data support a model for the structure of the alphavirus spike in which the E1 glycoproteins are centrally located as trimers which are surrounded and protected by the E2 glycoprotein. These data improve our understanding of the structure of the virus membrane and have implications for understanding the protein conformational changes which accompany the process of virus-cell membrane fusion.     

Requirements for the insertion of the Sindbis envelope glycoproteins into the endoplasmic reticulum membrane

Previous work has shown that the Sindbis structural proteins, core, the internal protein, and PE2 and E1, the integral membrane glycoproteins are synthesized as a polyprotein from a 26S mRNA; core PE2 and E1 are derived by proteolytic cleavage of a nascent chain. Newly synthesized core protein remains on the cytoplasmic side of the endoplasmic reticulum while newly synthesized PE2 and E1 are inserted into the lipid bilayer, presumably via their amino-termini. PE2 and E1 are glycosylated as nascent chains. Here, we examine a temperature-sensitive mutant of Sindbis virus which fails to cleave the structural proteins, resulting in the production of a polyprotein of 130,000 mol wt in which the amino-termini of PE2 and E1 are internal to the protein. Although the envelope sequences are present in this protein, it is not inserted into the endoplasmic reticulum bilayer, but remains on the cytoplasmic side as does the core protein in cells infected with wild-type Sindbis virus. We have also examined the fate of PE2 and E1 in cells treated with tunicamycin, an inhibitor of glycosylation. Unglycosylated PE2 and E1 are inserted normally into the lipid bilayer as are the glycosylated proteins. These results are consistent with the notion that a specific amino-terminal sequence is required for the proper insertion of membrane proteins into the endoplasmic reticulum bilayer, but that glycosylation is not required for this insertion.     

Substitution of specific cysteine residues in the E1 glycoprotein of classical swine fever virus strain Brescia affects formation of E1-E2 heterodimers and alters virulence in swine

E1, along with E(rns) and E2, is one of the three envelope glycoproteins of classical swine fever virus (CSFV). E1 and E2 are anchored to the virus envelope at their carboxyl termini, and E(rns) loosely associates with the viral envelope. In infected cells, E2 forms homodimers and heterodimers with E1 mediated by disulfide bridges between cysteine residues. The E1 protein of CSFV strain Brescia contains six cysteine residues at positions 5, 20, 24, 94, 123, and 171. The role of these residues in the formation of E1-E2 heterodimers and their effect on CSFV viability in vitro and in vivo remain unclear. Here we observed that recombinant viruses harboring individual cysteine-to-serine substitutions within the E1 envelope protein still have formation of E1-E2 heterodimers which are functional in terms of allowing efficient virus progeny yields in infected primary swine cells. Additionally, these single cysteine mutant viruses were virulent in infected swine. However, a double mutant harboring Cys24Ser and Cys94Ser substitutions within the E1 protein altered formation of E1-E2 heterodimers in infected cells. This recombinant virus, E1ΔCys24/94v, showed delayed growth kinetics in primary swine macrophage cultures and was attenuated in swine. Furthermore, despite the observed diminished growth in vitro, infection with E1ΔCys24/94v protected swine from challenge with virulent CSFV strain Brescia at 3 and 28 days postinfection.     

Formation of Sindbis Virus Proteins: Identification of a Precursor for One of the Envelope Proteins

Exposure of Sindbis virus-infected chicken embryo cells to a short pulse of radioactive amino acids revealed the formation of primarily three proteins: the nucleocapsid (C) of the virus, one of the viral envelope proteins (E1), and a glycoprotein that did not appear in the virion. This third protein (PE2) has now been identified as a precursor of the other viral envelope protein (E2) on the basis of two observations: (i) the simultaneous disappearance of radioactive PE2 and appearance of labeled E2 in pulse-chase experiments, and (ii) the identity of (14)C-arginine tryptic peptides in fingerprints of the two proteins. The nucleocapsid was the most heavily labeled protein in the cell and appeared in the virus during the short pulse. The two (14)C-labeled envelope proteins, although having different kinetics of labeling in the cell, appeared simultaneously in the virus only after the chase. Addition of pactamycin, a drug inhibiting initiation of protein synthesis, preferentially inhibited the formation of capsid protein Assuming that Sindbis virus proteins are formed initially as a single polypeptide, our studies locate the nucleocapsid at the amino-terminal end of the polypeptide chain.     

Location and role of free cysteinyl residues in the Sindbis virus E1 and E2 glycoproteins

Sindbis virus is a single-stranded positive-sense RNA virus. It is composed of 240 copies of three structural proteins: E1, E2, and capsid. These proteins form a mature virus particle composed of two nested T=4 icosahedral shells. A complex network of disulfide bonds in the E1 and E2 glycoproteins is developed through a series of structural intermediates as virus maturation occurs (M. Mulvey and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 68:805-812, 1994; M. Carleton et al., J. Virol. 71:1558-1566, 1997). To better understand the nature of this disulfide network, E1 and E2 cysteinyl residues were labeled with iodoacetamide in the native virus particle and analyzed by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. This analysis identified cysteinyl residues of E1 and E2, which were found to be label accessible in the native virus particle, as well as those that were either label inaccessible or blocked by their involvement in disulfide bonds. Native virus particles alkylated with iodoacetamide demonstrated a 4-log decrease in viral infectivity. This suggests that the modification of free cysteinyl residues results in the loss of infectivity by destabilizing the virus particle or that a rearrangement of disulfide bonds, which is required for infectivity, is blocked by the modification. Although modification of these residues prevented infectivity, it did not alter the ability of virus to fuse cells after exposure to acidic pH; thus, modification of free cysteinyl residues biochemically separated the process of infection from the process of membrane fusion.     

Identification of bull protamine disulfides

We have identified the disulfide cross-links in bull protamine by titrating intact bull sperm with dithiothreitol (DTT) and following the modification of each cysteine residue with tritiated iodoacetate. The derivatization of each cysteine was monitored by a combination of HPLC, peptide mapping, and protein sequencing. Analyses of total free sulfhydryls show that all seven of the bull protamine cysteines are cross-linked as disulfides in mature sperm. The first disulfide is reduced at a DTT:protamine cysteine (DTT:Cys) ratio of 0.3 and the last at a ratio of 2.0. Intra- and intermolecular disulfides were identified by correlating the reduction of specific disulfides with the dissociation of protamine from DNA in partially reduced sperm and sperm treated with N,N'-ethylenedimaleimide, a bifunctional disulfide cross-linking agent. Three intermolecular and two intramolecular disulfides were identified. The results of these experiments demonstrate that the amino- and carboxy-terminal ends of the bull protamine molecule are folded inward toward the center of the molecule and are locked in place, each by a single intramolecular disulfide bridge. Three intermolecular disulfides cross-link neighboring protamine molecules around the DNA helix in such a manner that the protamines cannot be dissociated from DNA without first reducing the interprotamine disulfides.     

Proteolytic processing of the Sindbis virus membrane protein precursor PE2 is nonessential for growth in vertebrate cells but is required for efficient growth in invertebrate cells.

We have shown previously that processing of the Sindbis virus envelope protein precursor PE2 to envelope protein E2 is not required for virus maturation in cultured vertebrate fibroblast cells and that unprocessed PE2 can be incorporated into infectious virus in place of E2 (J. F. Presley and D. T. Brown, J. Virol. 63:1975-1980, 1989; D. L. Russell, J. M. Dalrymple, and R. E. Johnston, J. Virol. 63:1619-1629, 1989). To better understand the role of this processing event in the invertebrate vector portion of the alphavirus life cycle, we have examined the maturation of Sindbis virus mutants defective in PE2 processing in cultured mosquito cells. We found that although substantial amounts of structural proteins PE2, E1, and C were produced in infected mosquito (aedine) cell lines, very little infectious virus was released. When the period of infection was extended, plaque size variants appeared, some of which exhibited a restored ability to grow in mosquito cells. The nucleotide sequences of two such variants were determined. These variants contained point mutations that restored PE2 cleavage, indicating a genetic linkage between failure to cleave PE2 and failure to grow in mosquito cells.     

Involvement of the molecular chaperone BiP in maturation of Sindbis virus envelope glycoproteins.

Sindbis virus codes for two membrane glycoproteins, E1 and PE2, which assemble into heterodimers within the endoplasmic reticulum. We have examined the role of the molecular chaperone BiP (grp78) in the maturation of these two proteins. E1, which folds into its mature conformation via at least three intermediates differing in the configurations of their disulfide bonds, was found to interact strongly and transiently with BiP after synthesis. ATP depletion mediated by carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone treatment results in the stabilization of complexes between BiP and E1. The depletion of intracellular ATP levels also greatly inhibits conversions between the E1 folding intermediates and results in the slow incorporation of E1 into disulfide-stabilized aggregates. These results suggest that the ATP-regulated binding and release of BiP have a role in modulating disulfide bond formation during E1 folding. In comparison with E1, very little PE2 is normally recovered in association with BiP. However, under conditions in which E1 folding is aberrant, increased amounts of PE2 become directly associated with BiP. The formation of these BiP-PE2 interactions occurs after E1 begins to misfold or fails to fold efficiently. We propose that nascent PE2 is stable prior to pairing with E1 for only a limited period of time, after which unpaired PE2 becomes recognized by BiP. This implies that the productive association of PE2 and E1 must occur within a restricted time frame and only after E1 has accomplished certain folding steps mediated by BiP binding and release. Kinetic studies which show that the pairing of E1 with PE2 is delayed after translocation support this conclusion.     

Deacylation of the transmembrane domains of Sindbis virus envelope glycoproteins E1 and E2 does not affect low-pH-induced viral membrane fusion activity

The envelope glycoproteins E1 and E2 of Sindbis virus are palmitoylated at cysteine residues within their transmembrane domains (E1 at position 430, and E2 at positions 388 and 390). Here, we investigated the in vitro membrane fusion activity of Sindbis virus variants (derived from the Toto 1101 infectious clone), in which the E1 C430 and/or E2 C388/390 residues had been substituted for alanines. Both the E1 and E2 mutant viruses, as well as a triple mutant virus, fused with liposomes in a strictly low-pH-dependent manner, the fusion characteristics being indistinguishable from those of the parent Toto 1101 virus. These results demonstrate that acylation of the transmembrane domain of Sindbis virus E1 and E2 is not required for expression of viral membrane fusion activity.     

Release of fatty acids from virus glycoproteins by hydroxylamine

The fatty acids bound to the glycoproteins of Sindbis and vesicular stomatitis viruses can be released by treating the protein with 1 M hydroxylamine at pH 8.0, but the rates of release vary greatly among the three proteins. The most labile fatty acyl bonds were in the Sindbis virus PE2/E2 proteins and the most stable were in the E1 protein. Some of the fatty acids in Sindbis virus glycoproteins were reduced to the alcohol after treatment with sodium borohydride, indicating that protein-bound fatty acids could be in thiolester linkage. Sindbis virus PE2/E2 has several cysteine residues near the carboxy terminus, a region of the protein postulated to be localized on the inside (cytoplasmic face) of the bilayer, and protease digestion of microsomal membranes containing E2 protein removed a small portion of this cytoplasmic tail as well as significant amounts of the fatty acid. For the vesicular stomatitis virus G protein, the sensitivity of fatty acid hydrolysis appeared to depend on the conformation of the protein and a significant fraction of G protein was converted to a disulfide-linked dimer by hydroxylamine. These data implicate cysteinyl groups on these proteins as sites involved in fatty acid acylation.     

New water-soluble phosphines as reductants of peptide and protein disulfide bonds: reactivity and membrane permeability

Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) is a widely used substitute for dithiothreitol (DTT) in the reduction of disulfide bonds in biochemical systems. Although TCEP has been recently shown to be a substrate of the flavin-dependent sulfhydryl oxidases, there is little quantitative information concerning the rate by which TCEP reduces other peptidic disulfide bonds. In this study, mono-, di-, and trimethyl ester analogues of TCEP were synthesized to evaluate the role of carboxylate anions in the reduction mechanism, and to expand the range of phosphine reductants. The effectiveness of all four phosphines relative to DTT has been determined using model disulfides, including a fluorescent disulfide-containing peptide (H(3)N(+)-VTWCGACKM-NH(2)), and with protein disulfide bonds in thioredoxin and sulfhydryl oxidase. Mono-, di-, and trimethyl esters exhibit phosphorus pK values of 6.8, 5.8, and 4.7, respectively, extending their reactivity with the model peptide to correspondingly lower pH values relative to that of TCEP (pK = 7.6). At pH 5.0, the order of reactivity is as follows: trimethyl- > dimethyl- > monomethyl- > TCEP > DTT; tmTCEP is 35-fold more reactive than TCEP, and DTT is essentially unreactive. Esterification also increases lipophilicity, allowing tmTCEP to penetrate phospholipid bilayers rapidly (>30-fold faster than DTT), whereas the parent TCEP is impermeant. Although more reactive than DTT toward small-molecule disulfides at pH 7.5, all phosphines are markedly less reactive toward protein disulfides at this pH. Molecular modeling suggests that the nucleophilic phosphorus of TCEP is more sterically crowded than the thiolate of DTT, contributing to the lower reactivity of the phosphine with protein disulfides. In sum, these data suggest that there is considerable scope for the synthesis of phosphine analogues tailored for specific applications in biological systems.