Schistosoma japonicum: protective immunity induced by schistosomulum-derived cells in a mouse model

We previously reported that immunization with intact live cells from schistosomula of Schistosoma japonicum (S.j) partially protected the Kunming strain of mice from challenge infection. In the present work, 2 immune protective experiments were designed to further validate the protective effect induced by this type of vaccine and to optimize the immunization protocol, including the number of inoculations and parasite stages from which immunogenic cells were derived. Three antigens derived from 18-day-old postinfection live (LLC) and dead (DLC) larval worm cells and from dead 42-day-old postinfection adult worm cells (DAC) were used as immunogens. Our results demonstrate that live cells from 18-day-old worms are capable of inducing significant protection in mice using a murine-Sj challenge model as shown by reduction rates of worm recoveries and egg burdens. The development of adult worms was stunted. A Th1-biased immune response was reflected in the protected groups as evidenced by the ratio of IgG2a/IgG1. A 38-kDa polypeptide was recognized by sera from LLC immunized animals. We demonstrate that live parasite cells are a source of novel protective antigens that can be exploited for vaccine development.     

Studies of stage-specific immunity against Trichostrongylus colubriformis in sheep: immunization by normal and truncated infections.

Sheep immunized with multiple normal infections of 30,000 Trichostrongylus colubriformis larvae (T.c. L3) suppressed the fecundity, establishment and survival of adoptively transferred adult worms, showing that these parasites were susceptible to the effects of host immunity. When sheep were immunized by four 'truncated' larval infections of 4, 7 or 10 days' (d) duration with 10(5) T.c. L3, animals given 4 x 4d infections were susceptible to challenge, whereas sheep given 4 x 7d and 4 x 10d infections were significantly protected. A serial analysis of the rejection of T. colubriformis from nine sheep given 5 x 7d infections revealed that the challenge larval infection given intraduodenally was expelled within 3 days after challenge (DAC). However, another five of these sheep only rejected around 50% of transferred adult worms by 21 DAC when compared with control animals. The results indicate that stage-specific antigens produced by early L3 and L4 stages of T. colubriformis effectively immunize sheep against a larval challenge but appear less reliably protective against adult worms.     

Induction of protective immunity against Schistosoma mansoni by a nonliving vaccine. III. Correlation of resistance with induction of activated larvacidal macrophages

Mice protected against Schistosoma mansoni infection by intradermal (i.d.) immunization with nonliving larval or adult worm antigens plus bacterial adjuvant developed 24-hr skin test responsiveness to schistosome antigens with the histologic features of delayed hypersensitivity. Intraperitoneal antigen injection elicited a mononuclear cell-enriched exudative population containing macrophages activated for direct cytotoxicity against schistosomula and tumor cell targets. This was likely to be due to in vivo exposure to macrophage-activating lymphokines, since these cells were unresponsive to further lymphokine stimulation in vitro and splenocytes from immunized mice reacted to specific in vitro antigen challenge by production of lymphokines capable of conferring larvacidal activity upon control macrophages. In contrast, mice treated with schistosome antigens by i.v. injection, which were not protected against challenge infection, failed to develop delayed hypersensitivity or activated macrophages in response to specific antigen challenge in vivo, and the titers of macrophage-activating lymphokine produced by in vitro antigen-stimulated splenocytes from these mice were threefold to fourfold lower than those produced by cells from animals immunized by the i.d. route. Thus, sensitization for cell-mediated immune responses including lymphokine production and macrophage activation correlated with induction of resistance to S. mansoni in this model of vaccination.     

The influence of adjuvant on induction of protective immunity by a non-living vaccine against schistosomiasis

Mice were protected against subsequent infection with Schistosoma mansoni by intradermal or s.c. vaccination with killed schistosomula or soluble parasite extracts and bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG). Treatment with i.p. immunization was somewhat less effective, whereas i.m. vaccination failed to elicit protective immunity. The level of resistance induced by intradermal immunization was influenced by the strain of BCG used, and isolated BCG cell walls did not reliably substitute for whole BCG organisms as adjuvant. Bordetella pertussis vaccine and saponin were also able to function as adjuvants for protective immunity in this model, whereas other immunopotentiators including Corynebacterium parvum and aluminum hydroxide were ineffective. No correlation between resistance to challenge infection and antibody levels was detected. Animals immunized intradermally using either protective or non-protective adjuvants all showed minimal humoral reactivity against schistosomulum surface Ag but strong IgG response to soluble parasite components including paramyosin, which is the major serologically recognized Ag in mice vaccinated intradermally with schistosome Ag plus BCG and is protective in this model. In contrast, a strong correlation was observed between resistance and Ag-specific cell-mediated reactivity, including IFN production by T lymphocytes in vitro and macrophage activation in vivo. These results further substantiate the hypothesis that protection in this model is based on cell-mediated immune effector mechanisms. Moreover, they may be of general relevance in the design of vaccination protocols using other Ag or against other infectious agents.     

Studies of stage-specific immunity against Trichostrongylus colubriformis in sheep: immunization with adult parasites.

Merino sheep immunized by the adoptive transfer of adult T. colubriformis for 8 weeks were significantly protected against a challenge infection of 20,000 larvae. Two additional groups of sheep received a primary infection of 9000 adult worms which were allowed to persist for 14 weeks before one group was drenched. When both groups were challenged 10 days later with 30,000 larvae, serial necropsies of these and naive sheep revealed that worm rejection did not occur until 7-10 days after challenge. By comparison with the rapid rejection of larval challenges from sheep immunized with normal primary infections, the results suggest that the antigens which elicited rejection in these experiments are stage-specific and were only present or synthesized in sufficient quantities when parasites had developed for 1 week.     

Acquired immunity in rats against Angiostrongylus cantonensis infection

Acquired immunity against Angiostrongylus cantonensis was induced by immunizing rats with somatic antigens from fifth-stage larvae and adult worms and live third-stage larvae. Rats immunized twice had significantly fewer worms than rats immunized three times. Fewer worms were recovered from rats immunized with 200 live third-stage larvae than from any other groups. Rats immunized with somatic antigens had higher enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) antibody levels than rats immunized with live larvae. Rats immunized with live third-stage larvae of Angiostrongylus cantonensis were more strongly protected against challenge infections (62-92%) than rats immunized with antigens extracted from fifth-stage larvae (0-30%) and adult worms (11-24%).     

Trichinella spiralis: immunization of pigs with newborn larval antigens

The potential of crude Trichinella spiralis newborn larval antigens for pig immunization was investigated. A preparation of whole newborn larvae killed by freezing and thawing, and combined with Freund's complete adjuvant, induced a high level of protection against challenge (78%), compared to a 40% resistance level in pigs immunized with excretory secretory antigens of muscle larvae. Sera from pigs immunized with newborn larvae contained antibodies which bound to the surface of the newborn larvae, as determined by immunofluorescence. In a second trial, the freeze thawed newborn larvae preparation was compared with a soluble and insoluble fraction prepared by sonication of whole newborn larvae. Pigs receiving whole newborn larvae or the insoluble fraction developed strong immunity to challenge (88.2 and 85.5%, respectively); the soluble fraction was ineffective. Immunization with all preparations induced antibody to newborn larval antigens, but not to adult or muscle larvae excretory secretory antigens. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of the soluble and insoluble fractions indicated that sonication was ineffective in solubilizing the larger molecular weight components. These results demonstrate that newborn larval antigens are highly protective in pigs, but that their further development as a vaccine will require more efficient procedures for antigen solubilization and large-scale production.     

Rodent malaria: BCG-induced protection and immunosuppression.

One dose of 10(7) viable units of Mycobacterium bovis, strain BCG, protected a significant number of Swiss mice from a primary challenge with 10(4) thoracic sporozoites of Plasmodium berghei. Immunization with irradiated sporozoites induced greater protection than that observed in BCG-treated with BCG and surviving a primary sporozoite challenge were not protected from rechallenge, whereas mice immunized with irradiated sporozoites and surviving initial challenge of sporozoites were solidly immune to further challenge. Immunizing mice with BCG and irradiated sporozoites simultaneously resulted in a synergistic effect of increased protection against a primary challenge of sporozoites only if the two immunogens were administered on the same day and if the mice were challenged 1 to 3 days later. Mice given BCG and irradiated sporozoites and surviving a primary challenge of sporozoites were unable to survive rechallenge. BCG given to mice previously immunized with irradiated sporozoites suppressed their protective immunity against sporozoite challenge.     

Immunological aspects of murine infection with the rat nematode Strongyloides ratti Sandground, 1925

In a study of the immune response of the rat to infection with the nematode Strongyloidis ratti, the antigens of the infective larval stage (L3) and of the parasitic, parthenogenetic female (Fp) were investigated. From both the larvae and the adult females, one metabolic (exoantigen) and two somatic antigens were extracted. Of the two somatic antigens, one was soluble and obtainable by physical means while the other was separated by chemical means from the tegument of the parasite. Humoral responses to the various antigens were evaluated by immunodiffusion and ELISA techniques, while the overall immune response was assayed by the worm burden in the immunized and subsequently infected rats. Agar-gel double diffusion yielded precipitin bands only with larval somatic antigens. ELISA proved positive at a titer of 20,000 with larval metabolic antigen and sera of rats immunized against either larval metabolic or somatic antigens. By 20 days post challenge infection, however, this titer diminished to 4000. In vivo studies of worm burden in rats immunized with the various antigens and then exposed to the live L3 of the nematode showed that there were significantly fewer adult worms in the rats immunized with larval somatic antigen and adult metabolic antigen than in those immunized with adult somatic antigen or larval metabolic antigen.     

Immunoaffinity-isolated antigens induce protective immunity against larval Strongyloides stercoralis in mice

The objective of this study was to identify soluble protein antigens that would induce protective immunity against infective-stage larvae (L-3) of Strongyloides stercoralis in mice. Deoxycholate (DOC)-soluble proteins derived from L-3, adsorbed to aluminum hydroxide, induced protective immunity in BALB/c mice. The immunized mice generated parasite-specific IgG that could transfer passive immunity to na?ve animals. The protective antibodies bound to parasite antigens found in the muscles and nerve cords of the L-3. An IgG affinity chromatography column generated with IgG from the sera of DOC-immunized mice was used to purify specific larval antigens. Proteins were eluted from the affinity column with sizes of 80, 75, 61, 57, 43, and 32 kDa. This antigen pool stimulated both proliferation and IL-5 production by splenocytes recovered from mice immunized with live L-3. Vaccination of mice with the immunoaffinity-isolated antigens led to significant protective immunity, with 83% of challenge larvae killed. This study demonstrates that IgG-isolated proteins are candidate antigens for a vaccine against larval S. stercoralis.     

Genetic control of murine immune responses to larval Dirofilaria immitis

Previous studies have demonstrated that BALB/c mice, immunized against infection with Dirofilaria immitis, were capable of killing a significant percentage of challenge larvae found within diffusion chambers. The percentage of larvae killed by immunized mice was, however, less than in immunized dogs and unlike immunized dogs, mice were unable to retard the development of the surviving larvae. The objective of the present study was to test 3 inbred strains of mice to determine whether a higher level of protective immunity would develop in these hosts and if larval growth retardation would occur. DBA/2J and C57BL/6J mice and their F1 hybrids B6D2F1/J were used in these studies; it was determined that there were differences in susceptibility among the 3 strains but no difference in ability to eliminate larvae from challenge infections. Growth retardation was seen in larvae recovered from immunized DBA/2J and C57BL/6J mice but not in B6D2F1/J. No difference was noted between immune and control mice in the cell types found in the diffusion chambers. The predominant cell types seen were mononuclear macrophages, multinucleate syncytial cells, and neutrophils. Antibody responses to soluble third- and fourth-stage larval antigens and larval excretory/secretory antigens were measured. Although antibodies to all 3 antigen groups were found in higher concentrations in immunized mice than in their respective controls, only antibody responses to soluble L-3 antigens provided a clear correlation with protective immunity.     

Active and passive immunization of mice against larval Dirofilaria immitis

The objective of this study was to determine if Dirofilaria immitis larvae would survive in diffusion chambers implanted in dogs and mice and secondly to determine if mice could be immunized against infection with D. immitis. Dirofilaria immitis third-stage larvae (L3) survived and grew in diffusion chambers implanted in dogs and mice for at least 3 wk. BALB/c mice, which were repeatedly infected with live L3, showed resistance to challenge infections. Dead L3, with or without adjuvants elicited no protective immunity. A correlation was found between the degree of immune protection seen in mice and antibody levels to soluble larval antigen but not to antibody levels to surface antigens. A monoclonal antibody was prepared that reacted with the surface of D. immitis and Onchocerca lienalis L3, but not to the surfaces of other stages and species of various filarial worms. When this antibody was administered to mice prior to challenge no significant reduction in larval survival was observed.     

Identification of Schistosoma mansoni glycoproteins recognized by protective antibodies from mice immunized with irradiated cercariae

The humoral immune responses of mice patently infected with Schistosoma mansoni and of mice vaccinated with radiation-attenuated cercariae were compared by radioimmunoassays and one- and two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel analyses of radioimmunoprecipitates. The binding observed with antibodies of mice vaccinated twice with radiation-attenuated cercariae over a period of 7 to 11 wk was less than 50% of the binding observed with antibodies of mice patently infected for 20 wk, but three to four times greater than that obtained with antibodies of mice infected for 6 wk, irrespective of whether the test antigen extracts were derived from schistosomula or adult worms. Sera of vaccinated mice precipitated a restricted number of predominantly high m.w. glycoproteins of both schistosomula and adult worms metabolically labeled with [35S] methionine. Each of the glycoproteins of 36 hr in vitro-cultured schistosomula that was precipitated by the sera of vaccinated mice was also precipitated by sera of infected mice. In contrast, sera of vaccinated mice uniquely precipitated a 38,000 m.w. glycoprotein of schistosomula cultured for 5 days and a 94,000 m.w. glycoprotein of adult male worms. Although radiation-attenuated larvae do not reach the adult stage, mice vaccinated with these still elicit a strong immune response against egg glycoproteins. In particular, an egg glycoprotein of 85,000 to 70,000 and isoelectric point of 4.8 showed an enhanced reactivity with sera of vaccinated mice in comparison with infected mice. These results show that the antibody response in mice vaccinated with radiation-attenuated larvae differs qualitatively and quantitatively from that of infected mice.     

Induction of protective immunity against Schistosoma mansoni by a nonliving vaccine is dependent on the method of antigen presentation

A preparation of nonliving parasite antigens containing both soluble and particulate components of frozen-and-thawed invasive larvae was used to immunize C57BL/6J mice against challenge Schistosoma mansoni infection. The method of antigen presentation was observed to be critical to the ability of this preparation to induce protective immunity, because intradermal administration in conjunction with a bacterial adjuvant (BCG) resulted in strong protection against challenge parasites (51% reduction in worm burden in six experiments), whereas i.v. injection of the same antigenic preparation was completely ineffective. Induction of resistance was accompanied by specific immune responsiveness toward schistosome antigens. Protection correlated more closely with sensitization for specific delayed hypersensitivity than with elicitation of circulating antibodies to larval surface antigens or immediate hypersensitivity in these models. These results suggest that it will be possible to design a defined vaccine against S. mansoni infection, but that identification of the route of antigen presentation that most effectively elicits relevant immune effector mechanisms will be crucial to the success of any vaccination protocol involving nonliving antigens.     

Onchocerca volvulus: immunization of chimpanzees with X-irradiated third-stage (L3) larvae.

To provide a theoretical basis for the potential development of vaccines against Onchocerca volvulus (Ov) a trial has been conducted to assess the protective efficacy of immunization of chimpanzees with X-irradiated L3 larvae. Approximately 1000 larvae were injected at 0, 1, and 7 months. The immunized animals, and unimmunized controls, were then challenged with 250 live L3. In order to provide possibly protective exposure to the immunologically distinct L4 epicuticle, a radiation dose (45 krad) was chosen which preserved about 50% of the molting ability of unirradiated larvae. Despite the presence of a strong immune response to crude adult worm extracts, and to cloned Ov antigens, at the time of challenge little or no significant protection against patent infection was observed: three of four immunized animals developed patent infection as compared to four of four controls. One immunized animal failed to become patent or to manifest the late antibody response to adult worm antigens seen in both subpatent and patent infections in this model, and may have been protected from infection. The implications of these studies for future attempts to immunize against O. volvulus are discussed.     

Tyvelose and protective responses to the intestinal stages of Trichinella spiralis

The unusual sugar tyvelose is the immunodominant portion of the major larval glycoprotein antigens of Trichinella spiralis, which play an important role in generating immunity against the intestinal stages of infection. The possibility that the tyvelose component itself may have a host- or parasite-protective role in the intestine was tested by following the outcome of challenge infections in mice primed and boosted with tyvelose-BSA, or in mice primed with tyvelose-BSA before boosting with larval antigen. Although antibody responses were raised against tyvelose there was no evidence of protective immunity against the intestinal stages, as assessed by total adult worm recovery or by size and fecundity of female worms in immunized mice. Equally, priming with tyvelose-BSA before boosting with larval antigen had no effect on the expression of immunity against a challenge infection. The predominant antibody isotype recorded in all immunized mice was IgG1, suggesting the induction of type 2 T cell responses, and this was confirmed by cytokine analysis, mesenteric node lymphocytes of all mice showing production of IL-5 but not IFN-gamma. Clearly immunization with tyvelose had no significant effect on T cell polarization. The data show that, with the experimental design employed, there was no evidence for a functional role of tyvelose in either host- or parasite-protection during the intestinal phase of infection.     

Screening of murine monoclonal antibodies against living schistosomula of Schistosoma mansoni by radioimmunoassay

A radioimmunoassay was developed to screen supernatants of murine monoclonal antibodies against surface antigens of living schistosomula of Schistosoma mansoni. Of 196 clones screened, 10% bound schistosomula. Of these, 74% bound only schistosomula. The remaining molecules also reacted with soluble adult worm antigens and soluble egg antigens as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Immunoblot analysis demonstrated that monoclonal antibody 204-3E4 reacted with a 68 kDa protein, a glycoprotein that induces substantial resistance against S. mansoni infection. Recognition of an 18 kDa antigen by 204-3F1 antibody was stage-specific with the antigen being expressed in cercariae, 3- and 24-h-old parasites but not 4-day, lung stage or adult worms. Monoclonal antibody 204-4E3 reacted with purified S. mansoni paramyosin. These data indicate that radioimmunoassay using living schistosomula is a rapid alternative method to identify murine hybridomas that secrete antibodies which react with surface antigens of S. mansoni.     

In vitro killing of schistosomula of Schistosoma mansoni by BCG and C. parvum-activated macrophages.

Resistance to Schistosoma mansoni infection in the mouse has been induced either specifically by a primary infection with this parasite or nonspecifically by a variety of immunostimulants such as BCG. In the present study we developed an in vitro system to examine the effector mechanism of nonspecifically induced resistance. Activated macrophage monolayers obtained from BCG- or Corynebacterium parvum treated mice killed a respective mean 32 +/- 6% and 48 +/- 5% of schistosomula after 24 hr incubation. The killing of the parasites was verified by their inability to mature to adult worms upon injection into normal mice. The activated macrophage-mediated killing was related to cell:parasite ratio, and was partially lost if the macrophage monolayers were kept in cultures for 24 hr before incubation with the organism. Supernatants of macrophages cultured in the presence of schistosomula killed a mean of 51 +/- 3% of the organisms whereas those from cells cultured alone resulted in a mean killing of 25 +/- 3%. Furthermore, toxic supernatants could be generated equally well on incubation with S. mansoni schistosomula or Trichinella spiralis larvae. Our data show that activated macrophage monolayers through soluble mediators destroy a significant proportion of the multicellular parasite S. mansoni schistosomula in vitro.     

Immunity to adult Heligmosomoides polygyrus (Nematospiroides dubius): survival or rejection of adult worms following transplantation to mice refractory to larval challenge

Experiments were carried out to explore the survival of 14-day adult H. polygyrus following transplantation to mice of four strains, immunized by various protocols. Adult worm establishment and survival was unimpaired in CFLP mice which were totally refractory to larval challenge. Transplanted adult worms were also successful in NIH mice immunized by the 9-day abbreviated infection regime. However, NIH mice exposed to irradiated larvae or subjected to the divided primary infection, expelled transplanted adults. The 9-day abbreviated infection was further examined in SJL and (C57 Bl10 X NIH) F1 mice which expel adult worms during a primary infection and although this regime was unsuccessful in causing NIH mice to reject adult worms, expulsion of adult worms was accelerated in SJL and F1 mice. The survival of adult H. polygyrus was discussed in the context of stage-specific immunity and the delicate balance between the immunogenic stimuli from developing larvae, the immunomodulatory activities of adult stages and the host's genetically determined capacity to respond to these opposing signals.     

Ultrastructure, antigenicity, and histochemistry of stichocyte granules of adult Trichinella spiralis.

The stichosome of adult Trichinella spiralis was studied to determine its ultrastructural, antigenic, and histochemical characteristics. Stichocytes of adult worms had 2 types of granules, type I and type II, the ultrastructure of which was different from those of muscle larvae. Both types of granules consisted of a membrane surrounding a homogeneous matrix, and type I granules were rounder than type II granules. Sera from C3H mice immunized against excretory-secretory products of muscle larvae produced positive immunostaining of type I but not type II granules. Differences in antigenicity were observed between larval and adult stichocyte granules; monoclonal antibodies against alpha-granules of muscle larvae failed to label the adult granules. Azan staining revealed a histochemical difference between larval and adult stichocytes; adult stichocytes stained yellow, whereas larval stichocytes are known to stain red or blue. Thus, the present contribution revealed the existence of 2 distinct types of stichocyte granules in adult T. spiralis and showed them to differ profoundly from those characterized previously in muscle larvae.